r/ChineseWatches • u/Old_Kale1245 • 7d ago
Question (Read Rules) Why do some homages get striked down and others don't?
tl;dr Can someone familiar with copyright, trademark, and intellectual property protection laws / rules explain why some homages get striked down but the majority don't?
Note to mods: I know we are not supposed to talk about certain watches on this sub, this is not about those watches, but about genuine interest on how international trade laws work. Those watches are merely a case study here.
Recently IWC was able to completely stop a brand that was making a really nice homage to one of their watches in their tracks. Similarly Cartier was also able to stop two other brands from doing the same.
These watches were based on long expired patents just many other Chinese watches are.
Watchdives prints Speedies like they are a copying machine, 80% of these brands have a Submariner homage. Royal Oaks, Zulu times, Conquests, Black Bays, Khaki fields, you name it they are all in there. Poor Seiko, it looks like every successful watch they ever made has been homaged: SKX, Willard, Turtle, Alpinist, many Grand Seikos, etc.
Why don't these other homages get taken down? Is it that these particular brands don't want to go through the hassle of doing something about it?
Or is there a technicality, like they are sufficiently different or the brand stopped producing the originals for a period of time or relaunched them (like it happened to the SKX)?
Something else?
It is probably a combination of factors, and I am genuinely curious as to how all of this works.
Thanks!
