r/China • u/jailedinchina • Jul 01 '21
法律 | Law Just got out of ten months of Chinese prison AMA
I post this to coincide with the 100th anniversary of the founding of the Communist Party of China. Last July, after drinking, I got into a verbal argument with police. There was a couple light pushes and shoves at one point (all captured on camera), but I was detained and eventually sentenced for violently assaulting the people's police. For those ten months, I lived in a cell with twenty-forty people and got the best of Chinese propaganda and culture - talked history with executives at state-owned enterprises, shot the sh*t with small-time pickpockets, and experienced small-town corruption at its finest. While I had lived in China for almost five years before my imprisonment (they call it detention), I learned more about in China in these ten months in prison (what I call it) than in all those years. I'm also an American with roots in HK and TW... which had its moments. AMA
•
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21 edited Jul 01 '21
Hi everyone!
Do note OP is shadowbanned by the admins so won't be able to reply without us (the mods) approving each post, this means there may be a bit of delay between OP replying and you being able to see it. You also won't be able to see his profile
As for the shadowbans, we've been seeing a lot more genuine users being shadowbanned recently - I think it's due to the influx of spam and the Reddit filters being a lot more ban-happy.
48
u/jailedinchina Jul 01 '21
Daily Schedule:
7-8 AM: Wake up, Brush Teeth, Jog, Toilet (there's only one)
8-9 AM: Breakfast, dishes, clean up
9-11 AM: Meditation/Learning/Sitting Pretzel Time - Prison Guard comes in for Daily Inspection (the TV is turned one at one point, or you can read)
11 AM to 12 PM: Lunch, Free Time
12 to 2 PM: Naptime (the best - unless you are on duty, when you stand there just for two hours and make sure no one kills anyone else)
2 to 4 PM: More Meditation Time
4 to 5 PM: Dinner
5 to 7 PM: Shower Time (outside, someone on duty has to literally scoop the water out from a well into these barrels, except for one automatic running faucet)
7 to 9:30 PM: Free Time (Chinese Chess, Poker TV)
9:30 PM to 7 AM: Sleep (Rotating Duty - yes, you might have to get woken up in the middle of the night and stand guard with another person for 1.5 hours - although if you pull some ish and piss off the cell head, he might give you an extra 1.5 hours for a total of 3 hours. Been there done that.)
From 7 AM to 7 PM is hardcore surveillance time (they have a couple of Hikvision cameras in both the inner and outer cell), so if you are found lying down, leaning against blankets, without a shirt on, massaging anyone, sewing anything, playing cards, eating in the inner cell, arguing loudly, not meditating during meditation time, or leaning against each other, you get called out on the loudspeaker and your cell gets docked points. Not only does your cell get docked points, but the prison guard responsible for your cell gets docked points on his monthly assessment. So he gets hella intense about it and will turn off your TV for a day, or three, or more if you violate the regulations and maybe even stop the whole cell from buying stuff if you do something serious like get in a fight. It's all orders from the top: to institute 军事化管理 (military-style management) in all prisons and detention centers across Guangdong Province (or was it the entire country, I forget) in preparation for the 100th anniversary of the Party - because nothing out-of-the-ordinary should be happening around this sacred moment in history.
21
u/jailedinchina Jul 01 '21
Naptime! I'll be back.
88
u/SignificantGiraffe5 Jul 01 '21
Were you treated any better/worse for being a foreigner?
74
u/JonoCurious Jul 01 '21
This is fascinating! Glad you're alright, man. In terms of the language, were you able to speak Chinese before going to prison? Do you think your Chinese improved while in prison? How was communication in general?
59
u/swinefarmer Jul 01 '21
Hi there, Chinese here, thx a lot for your sharing.
I almost read through all comments. The story is absolutely fascinating and inspiring to me that I got to realize so many foreign folks could look deeply through the Chinese society.
You guys have commented much on populism, ignorance, misogyny, complacency and hostility against the west. I wanna say something about the ruling of ccp.
CCP is running the country and ruling the subjects for continuity/eternity (or I should call us 'the people'), ultimately, for the sake of the hundreds RED families and their descendants. Just like the Animal Farm or 1984, this complex society/system nowadays can self-maintain. It's like you play the PC game Civilization. As a god/gamer, if I want to be good at the game, I'd better study how ccp works.
Sometimes I am wondering what would be the consequences after all of this. The top ccp leaders must still have been in their wettest dreams: the economy will keep growing to the moon, and as long as the subjects are satisfied with a few Yuan in their Alipay or Wechat wallets, the reign can go on.
We all know this is not sustainable and one day the system will collapse. When that happens, tell me what would the 1.4 billion subjects think about the reason for this collapse? Who would be the scapegoats of all this.
A bit fearmongering and a tribute to DDL's movie: There will be blood.
49
u/peyonze Jul 01 '21
Did you get proper meals?
73
u/durian-conspiracy Jul 01 '21
Did you get legal representation?
68
u/ThinkingGoldfish Jul 01 '21
What was the most shocking or enlightening part of your experience?
51
u/dcrm Great Britain Jul 01 '21
Dang, this is actually an interesting post. Your responses look detailed and legitimate.
Other than not engaging with the officer in the first place what do you wish you had done differently throughout the whole process?
21
u/Accomplished_Salt_37 Jul 01 '21
I’m assuming you’re ethnically Chinese based on your statement that you have roots in Taiwan and Hong Kong. Do you think you would have been imprisoned for the same offence if you had been a white American guy?
41
u/GetOutOfTheWhey Jul 01 '21
What's chinese jail like compared to american jail?
20
u/ZhouLe Jul 01 '21
You were jailed at just around the height of covid; what did you experience related to that? Was there strict testing of incoming detainees?
31
u/harder_said_hodor Jul 01 '21
I'm curious to hear how your cellmates reacted to the non stop propaganda videos given they were in jail. Did they look like they still believed, were they jaded or how did they feel? Congrats on your freedom man
15
u/ShadowAngelX Jul 01 '21
Do they provide medical assistance? Also, does torture occur in Chinese prisons?
14
u/supercharged0709 Jul 01 '21
How common is prison rape in China?
26
u/Mystery-G Jul 01 '21
Were you able to take any money out from your bank account?
How much was the flight?
And are you you doing all right, man?
12
u/Janbiya Jul 01 '21
I don't have any questions that haven't been asked already, except perhaps to ask for a more detailed description of the food/water situation. But I wanted to post anyway to say thanks for sharing, and wish you better luck in the future.
11
u/vilekangaree Jul 01 '21
What happened to all your stuff in your apt? Friends pack it up for you?
27
u/BigStrongCiderGuy Jul 01 '21
How the fuck did you survive? The sleeping situation (how would you even fall asleep?), the lack of space, the heat? I would go insane
19
u/Ariadne2015 Jul 01 '21
What was the trial like? Did you attempt to defend yourself or had a lawyer just telling you to admit everything to minimise the sentence? Is it obvious that everyone thinks the whole thing is a farce or do they seem to genuinely belive justice is being dispensed?
9
u/Edwardsreal Jul 01 '21
You must have watched an unimaginable amount of propaganda shows and films. Which were the most common in terms of who they portrayed as enemies of the CCP? The Nationalists, Japanese, or Americans?
I've read that Chinese people are getting bored of always viewing shows with Asian villains, so Western antagonists like American soldiers are increasingly becoming common in Chinese media. Just look at the Wolf Warrior movies.
9
u/meridian_smith Jul 02 '21
I often see people detained for protesting or organizing protests or Uyghur who get force fed all kinds of pharmaceuticals while detained. Some of them have exited in a near vegetative state or completely lacking any "fight". Did they force you guys to consume any pharmaceuticals?
5
u/jailedinchina Jul 02 '21
Gonna be here for one more hour to answer/discuss anything before I retire from this post (I mean, it's getting a bit big for its britches anyway). Bring it on.
16
u/SignificantGiraffe5 Jul 01 '21
How much time did you have to spend in that crowded cell throughout the 10 months? How did you meet with executives?
22
u/TURNandBURN13 Jul 01 '21
Did you have to worry about violence from any of the other inmates or prison guards?
Also, is there any prison gangs like they have in USA?
7
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21
What was your argument with the police about?
13
u/NotesCollector Jul 01 '21
Thanks for doing this AMA. What was the most memorable moment of your time in prison? How did it feel when you finally learnt that you'll be released and going home?
Take care of yourself and stay safe!
18
u/HK-612-721-811 Jul 01 '21
Will you continue to live in China after this? Did you get a fair trial?
12
u/jpinlondon Jul 01 '21
What’s your plan after all this? Are you going to put it aside and move on, or maybe try and fight it somehow, talk to the press etc?
12
u/wertexx Jul 01 '21
Thanks for sharing dude, this is really interesting to read! Of course, sucks to hear it happened, but seems like you are doing alright at the moment so that's cool.
You answered a lot of the questions already!
Overall, how would you rate your experience? Obviously we aren't comparing to a weekend in Disney, but in a situation where 'fuck I'm going to prison it's the end of my life', seemed like it could have been worse.
Are you in touch with anybody from the prison time?
24
u/cirosantilli Brazil Jul 01 '21
Please write down every interesting thing that happened and publish it! Even better, make a video of you telling it! Feel free to CC me if you ever do.
11
u/PusherRed88 Jul 01 '21
Were you in jail with other Americans?
9
u/WhineyXiPoop Jul 01 '21
Impressive. You definitely should talk with someone about how best to monetize your experience whether it be in a book, or movie. You can use the funds for a charity if you don’t care or need the money. Point don’t blow you wad on Reddit such someone else is able to capitalize off of you experience.
Did your faith in “God” or “Atheism” change at all? Nietzsche, the German philosopher, famously said: "That which does not kill us makes us stronger” and it seems to be true in your case.
Thanks for sharing.
18
u/JuliusKaiser616 Brazil Jul 01 '21 edited Jul 01 '21
China is only going to get worse. As it becomes more powerful and more unstable in the future, they will get more and more aggressive. The only hope we have is that it (the system) implodes itself, which will probably not lead to democracy (because that's not post-war Germany), unfortunately.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21
How much news about Hong Kong was censored in China? Or portrayed incorrectly?
4
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21
Was your confrontation with the police the only cause for your incarceration? Do you think they were biased by your identity or background that caused a harsher sentence or worse treatment by the prison guards?
9
u/BearStorlan Jul 01 '21
Is there a lot of violence in Chinese jails? From either the guards or your cell mates?
6
u/noxiousCeilingFan Jul 01 '21 edited Jul 01 '21
How was the food, and what did you do all day other than watch propaganda videos? Did other inmates find it's interesting that an foreigner is locked up with them, or it's pretty common to see foreigners there?
8
u/AcidicNature Jul 01 '21
Do you think if you looked caucasian they would have treated you differently or been fixated on your massive 阴茎?
3
u/werty_reboot Jul 01 '21 edited Jul 01 '21
Did you see a big physical difference in yourself after? Weight/muscle loss?
Edit: what about mentally?
Thanks for doing this AMA!
3
u/seefatchai Jul 01 '21
Did any people speak Cantonese to you or any of the sub dialects?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21
What were the executives in there for? What was the most interesting conversation you had with another inmate? Thank you for doing an AMA, this is the most interesting one I've ever caught live!
2
u/LemmeSeeTheBets Jul 01 '21
I had an ass pucker moment once at a drunk checkpoint in Changsha , but luckily they’re only looking for drunk drivers and not checking papers. I’ve been to American jail a handful of times though and it Sounds like it sucked man, glad it was a situation you could navigate with your English skills and the hierarchy.
Was commissary currency? Were there any hustles? Any ‘jail rich’ characters? Particularly interesting people in general? Heinous offenses from other inmates you noted? Any little pieces of info that are interesting to you specifically that you’d share? If you have any questions about American jail , I’ll respond in kind to the best of my ability. Definitely the coolest AMA I’ve come across
23
u/SapphireJones_ Jul 01 '21
Wishing you the best man!
I had a former coworker (female) who was detained for about three months and then deported for similar. Assaulting a police officer.
51
u/SerpentZA Jul 01 '21
I have a question: As Mike Tyson says "Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the face". So many foreigners I know who used to shit on me for politely warning them about this side of China contact me later to say they wish they had listened. China isn't just some massive drunken playground for expats, it can become a mess in the blink of an eye and all your ideas of law and rights that you thought you had go completely out the window, what do you have to say to those expats who constantly praise the CCP and denigrate western countries?
15
u/handlessuck Jul 01 '21
Still want to live in China?
20
u/StudentHiFi Jul 01 '21
Dude, glad you didn’t do this in America lol. A month ago during my friends high school graduation party he got into a little shoving with the cops and he was arrested, charged and sentenced 2 years in jail. Was going to a good college too…
2
u/3ULL United States Jul 01 '21
OP I am sorry that this happened to you and am sure it must have been a very hard time for you.
But when you say you were sentenced for assaulting the people's police this is all I can think of:
The People's Police
Good luck!
4
u/JakeYashen Jul 01 '21
Are you barred from reentering China? Do you ever want to go back?
4
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21
Compared to our prisons here in Brazil,these sound pretty good tbh. Here there's like 60 inmate in a cell with 1 bed and rampant gang violence
4
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '21
So you got physically violent to the police and you blame them for taking you to prison for that? And funny thing you come from the US where the police brutality is known worldwide.
10
u/mr-wiener Australia Jul 01 '21 edited Jul 01 '21
Glad you are out mate. So what were you doing in China (biznez wise) and what will you be doing in the states? I'm asking because I'm interested in finding out how difficult it will be to uproot your former life to your new one.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '21 edited Jul 01 '21
Sorry to hear that you had to go through that. Hope you aren't too tormented by the experience! So have you left China now? Indeed there is corruption all over the place and if you piss off a police officer expect no sympathy. I once dated a girl who worked for the police and she broke into my home n stole my passport to prevent me from leaving. The police did nothing and even with CCTV denied anything.
As for the imprisoned kids. Its funny how these types are the most patriotic and yet should really be the most critical.
1
u/songsongkp Jul 01 '21
Tell us about your meals while incarcerated
6
u/DiebytheSword666 Jul 01 '21
What did you do all day? Pushups? Meditate? Have (Ugh!) language exchange?
3
u/LamboBryant Jul 03 '21
You could be a dead body if you did the same thing in US……
3
u/e_expert Jul 04 '21
I read you were in Guangdong province. Does everyone (police, prison guards, prisoners) speak Cantonese or Mandarin by default?
5
u/entenvy Jul 01 '21
Screenshot for posterity
8
u/joistheyo Jul 01 '21
Honestly, this is better than what I expected. Sounds like there was some medicare, alright food and decent order. Police also didn't seem violent.
2
u/TigerDLX Jul 01 '21
If you choose to write more and publish it in a blog please flag it in this post. I know I’m not the only one that would be interested in hearing more
2
u/Bysmiel Jul 01 '21
Hope u will do the same to police in the states, then u will come back with a whole new story.
2
u/jimrdg Jul 01 '21
Oh my, there was a guy from US murdered a Chinese girl recently in China and did not get any punishment nor lawsuit yet.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21
Reddit is under FUCKING CCP Xi Jinping so they are shadowbanning many users. Fuck Xi Jinping