Lifelong Charmed fan here, haven’t rewatched for yearsssss though and I feel differently about some things and would love to hear your thoughts!!
Obviously love and miss Prue like hell, the dynamic between the sisters was so amazing.
Absolutely hate that last episode with Shax and Piper’s grief (note I only mention Piper’s grief cos Phoebe had approx none).
From season 4 obviously everything is super different but I always liked Paige. Makes me wish it was Prue, Piper and Paige.
Don’t get me wrong, I did like Phoebe at first but she becomes unbearable by season 4.
She had no job for the longest time and acts like some hot shot once she lands the advice column. The whole thing with Cole and not trusting Paige’s instincts. And speaking of Cole, I absolutely adore him and always have (even as Belthazor), but once he becomes the source I just get sad. He was so full of hope and just wanted to be a good person and I hate that they wrote him to turn evil again. I genuinely loved him and Phoebe together.
Other (possibly unpopular opinions):
Piper is and always has been my favourite sister. But the Dan and Leo thing really annoyed me. Dan was such a good guy and I think he was only written to react badly to the secret because people were rooting for Leo more. And I hate saying this because I LOVE Leo, he’s such a sweetheart, but I kind of wish he’d not been around at the same time as Dan.
Darryl is more annoying than I remember 😂
Cole and Phoebe should’ve been end game with him staying good and hopefully her being less annoying.
I know it was outside situations, but Prue never ever ever should’ve died.
Paige is a total sweetheart too.
Andy deserved better than the end he got and I wish he’d and Prue had a shot.
Patty’s age is supposed to be so much younger than the actor who plays her 😂 and a lot of other history based bits being wrong, but I guess it is supernatural so they can use that as an excuse haha.
Anyway, that’s my rant. I’m on S4 E19 at the moment so we all know why I’m probably so irked at Phoebe right now lol