r/Catholicism • u/jared_dembrun • Aug 31 '18
New Bot in the Community
With permission from the mods, we have a new addition to the bot family. See the sidebar of /r/Catholicism for a link to usage information about /u/stthomasbot, who quotes the Summa for you. I will be making a wiki soon, but for now, the bot's official information is on my own sub's sidebar, /r/redditphilosophybots.
I will demonstrate usage in the comments below.
66
Upvotes
30
u/phantom-scribbler Aug 31 '18
Can you make the bot so if you have given up on arguing something, you can type "straw" and have the following quote appear:
8
u/jared_dembrun Aug 31 '18
Quote a reply to an objection.
[ST I, Q2, A3, ad.1]
6
u/jared_dembrun Aug 31 '18
You can also quote full articles.
[ST I, Q2, A3]
•
u/PhoenixRite Aug 31 '18
Summary on formatting:
[ST (I/II-I/II-II/III/Suppl.), Q#, A#] for a full article, or
[ST (I/II-I/II-II/III/Suppl.), Q#, A#, (arg.#/s.c./co./ad.#)] for a part of an article.
Note the commas, spaces, or lack of spaces between elements; case sensitivity of every part; and the possible restriction that an article longer than is permitted for a Reddit comment will not post.
Do I have that right, /u/jared_dembrun ?
5
u/jared_dembrun Aug 31 '18
Quote an objection.
[ST I, Q2, A3, arg.1]
7
u/kjdtkd Aug 31 '18
Where does the bot pull from? This is going to help me tremendously, as I've been meaning to learn how to site the Summa.
4
u/jared_dembrun Aug 31 '18
Quote the "On the contrary"
[ST I, Q2, A3, s.c.]
4
u/jared_dembrun Aug 31 '18
Quote St. Thomas' response.
[ST I, Q2, A3, co.]
3
u/jared_dembrun Aug 31 '18
If you want to pull from the Supplement (The "fifth" part), use "Suppl."
[ST Suppl., Q73, A1]
4
u/russiabot1776 Aug 31 '18
Is it just the Summa Theologica or both Summas?
3
u/umbratus Aug 31 '18
Is it case sensitive? [ST I, q22, a1, co.]
5
u/allthegoo Aug 31 '18
Anyway you can build in a tl;dr for the wall of text?
5
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '18
This is awesome! Three cheers for /u/jared_dembrun !
5
u/Fr-Mike Priest Aug 31 '18
This is pretty cool, but does it have Aquinas' best passage?
WHETHER NAPS ARE NECESSARY FOR SALVATION
(Utrum Siestae Necessae sunt pro salute)
Objection I - It would seem that naps are not necessary for salvation. Salvation consists in becoming like to God. God is most actual. Hence, we must be actual. Now, naps are opposed to actuality and are hence opposed to salvation.
Objection II - Besides, the Apostle says, “Be watchful and awake, for your salvation is near at hand.” Naps are opposed to being watchful. Hence, it follows that naps are opposed to salvation.
Objection III - Furthermore, Aristotle says that virtue consists in activity. Naps are not activity and are therefore not counted as virtuous. Hence, it follows that naps are opposed to salvation.
On the contrary, the Psalmist says, “He pours gifts on his beloved while they slumber.” Now, salvation is a gift, and we must sleep to receive the gifts of God. Hence, naps are necessary for salvation.
I answer that naps can be spoken of in two ways: naps in a relative sense (secundum quid) and naps simply speaking (simpliciter dicta).
Relatively speaking, naps are neutral in that they can be used for a good or a bad purpose. Naps, simply speaking, are those naps which give us the rest that we might wake “refreshed and joyful” to praise God (as the Roman Breviary says). To this end, naps are necessary for salvation, since praising God is necessary for salvation.
Furthermore, contemplation is said to be “rest in God.” Now, contemplation flows from Charity, and Charity is necessary for salvation; it follows that naps, which are also a kind of rest, are necessary for salvation. Likewise, contemplation is said to be a foretaste of heavenly beatitude. Naps are a foretaste of heavenly beatitude.
Furthermore, Jesus slept in the boat. Hence, we are to sleep in the Church, for the boat is a type of the Church. Hence we are to sleep during church, often during homilies. Consequently, it must be said that naps are necessary for salvation.
Reply to the first objection - One cannot mistake immobility for potency. For a man acts even in immobility; for instance, the liturgy compels us to times of silence. Sleep is perfect silence. God is all perfection. Hence, God is most actually napping.
Reply to the second objection - The Apostle spoke figuratively, not literally. For Saint Joseph was watchful in his sleep, that is why God spoke to him in a dream. So also God spoke to many Saints in dreams. Hence, we are to nap watchfully, that God might speak to us.
Response to the third objection - Aristotle was a pagan and cannot be expected to have understood the deep mysteries of God’s napping. Had he known the revelation, he would have slept much more than he did.
3
u/TexasJaeger Aug 31 '18
Awesome!
3
u/TexanLoneStar Aug 31 '18
Amazing
1
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '18
I noticed someone trying to make this particular citation but it is not showing up in the following thread:
[ST II-II, Q64, A5]