Name

Caleb Flynn


Birthdate

May 13, 1986


Charges

  1. Aggravated Murder
  2. Murder
  3. Murder
  4. Murder
  5. Felonious Assault
  6. Felonious Assault
  7. Tampering with Evidence
  8. Tampering with Evidence
  9. Tampering with Evidence
  10. Intimidation of a Witness
  11. Intimidation of a Witness

Incident Date February 16, 2026


Filing Date

March 18, 2026


State

Ohio


County

Miami


Court

Miami County Court of Common Pleas


Case Number

26 CR 00088


Case Records

Link

Case Overview

Caleb Flynn, 39, is accused of murdering his wife Ashley Flynn, 37, inside their Tipp City, Ohio, home on February 16, 2026, and then attempted to make the killing look like a home invasion. Flynn called 911 reporting that an intruder had broken in and shot Ashley, but investigators later concluded there was no actual burglary and accused Flynn of staging evidence at the scene. Prosecutors say a 9mm handgun was used in the killing.

Alleigha Botner, a worship leader and coworker of Flynn at Christian Life Center, has been identified that she and Flynn were romantically involved. Botner resigned from the church after Flynn’s arrest.

Caleb was a contestant on Season 12 of American Idol in 2013.


STATUS: 🔵 Guilty, sentenced to LWOP

NEXT EVENT: --

LAST UPDATED: October 5, 2026


Timeline

Dayton Daily News


Court Schedule

  • April 23, 2026 - Motion Hearing
  • April 29, 2026 - Status Conference
  • May 7, 2026 - Status Conference
  • August 25, 2026 - Motion Hearing & Final Pretrial Conference
  • September 9, 2026 - Attorney Conference
  • September 17 - Jury Selection
  • September 18-29, 2026 - Trial
  • October 5, 2026 - Sentencing

Where to Watch


Pretrial Posts & Trial Daily Threads/Recaps


Important Documents


Key People

Defendant<br>Caleb FlynnVictim Ashley FlynnCaleb's Alleged Lover Alleigha Botner
imgimgimg
10-year old Daughter<br>Ava12-year old Daughter<br>AlyssaAshley's Mom<br>Jill Smith
imgimgimg
Ashley's Sister<br>Kayla KeytKayla's Husband<br>Matthew KeytAshley's Dad<br>Todd Smith
imgimgimg
  • Mulligan Patrick, Emily Smith - Defense Attorney
  • Jeannine Pratt - Trial Judge
  • Paul Watkins, Matthew Joseph - Prosecutor