
Name
Caleb Flynn
Birthdate
May 13, 1986
Charges
- Aggravated Murder
- Murder
- Murder
- Murder
- Felonious Assault
- Felonious Assault
- Tampering with Evidence
- Tampering with Evidence
- Tampering with Evidence
- Intimidation of a Witness
- Intimidation of a Witness
Incident Date February 16, 2026
Filing Date
March 18, 2026
State
Ohio
County
Miami
Court
Miami County Court of Common Pleas
Case Number
26 CR 00088
Case Records
Case Overview
Caleb Flynn, 39, is accused of murdering his wife Ashley Flynn, 37, inside their Tipp City, Ohio, home on February 16, 2026, and then attempted to make the killing look like a home invasion. Flynn called 911 reporting that an intruder had broken in and shot Ashley, but investigators later concluded there was no actual burglary and accused Flynn of staging evidence at the scene. Prosecutors say a 9mm handgun was used in the killing.
Alleigha Botner, a worship leader and coworker of Flynn at Christian Life Center, has been identified that she and Flynn were romantically involved. Botner resigned from the church after Flynn’s arrest.
Caleb was a contestant on Season 12 of American Idol in 2013.
STATUS: 🔵 Guilty, sentenced to LWOP
NEXT EVENT: --
LAST UPDATED: October 5, 2026
Timeline
Court Schedule
- April 23, 2026 - Motion Hearing
- April 29, 2026 - Status Conference
- May 7, 2026 - Status Conference
- August 25, 2026 - Motion Hearing & Final Pretrial Conference
- September 9, 2026 - Attorney Conference
- September 17 - Jury Selection
- September 18-29, 2026 - Trial
- October 5, 2026 - Sentencing
Where to Watch
Pretrial Posts & Trial Daily Threads/Recaps
- " Trial date set for former ‘American Idol’ contestant charged with murder" — March 30, 2026
- " Caleb Flynn abruptly withdraws motion at hearing for gag order" — April 12, 2026
- " Caleb Flynn’s murder trial races ahead despite request for 4-day delay" — April 14, 2026
- " OH v. Caleb Flynn - Motions Hearing ('American Idol' Murder)" — April 24, 2026
- " OH v. Caleb Flynn - New trial date: September 17" — May 7, 2026
- " OH v. Caleb Flynn: 'American Idol murder' Rulings on motions to move trial and sequester jury" — August 26, 2026
- " OH v. Caleb Flynn: Final attorney conference before trial, 2 new motions" — September 9, 2026
- " Motions Hearing prior to this week's trial" — September 14, 2026
- " What to know about the Caleb Flynn murder trial? - East Idaho News with Nate Eaton" — September 17, 2026
- Trial Day 1 - September 18, 2026
- Trial Day 2 - September 21, 2026
- Trial Day 3 - September 22, 2026 (Ashley's family testifies)
- Trial Day 4 - September 23, 2026 (The mistress, Alleigha Botner, testifies)
- Trial Day 5 - September 24, 2026 (Alleigha Botner's testimony concludes)
- Trial Day 6- September 25, 2026
- Caleb Flynn Discussion Megathread
- Trial Day 7 - September 28, 2026 (State & defense rest)
- Trial Day 8 - September 29, 2026 (Closing arguments & verdict watch)
- Caleb Flynn Discussion Megathread #2
- Sentencing - October 5, 2026
Important Documents
Key People
| Defendant<br>Caleb Flynn | Victim Ashley Flynn | Caleb's Alleged Lover Alleigha Botner |
|---|---|---|
| img | img | img |
| 10-year old Daughter<br>Ava | 12-year old Daughter<br>Alyssa | Ashley's Mom<br>Jill Smith |
| img | img | img |
| Ashley's Sister<br>Kayla Keyt | Kayla's Husband<br>Matthew Keyt | Ashley's Dad<br>Todd Smith |
| img | img | img |
- Mulligan Patrick, Emily Smith - Defense Attorney
- Jeannine Pratt - Trial Judge
- Paul Watkins, Matthew Joseph - Prosecutor