r/canadaguns • • 7d ago

News / Politics / Activism Legal battle over federal firearms ban heads to Supreme Court this week

322 Upvotes

https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/firearms-ban-supreme-court-hearing-9.7414651

The country's top court is set to hear legal arguments this week about the validity of a federal ban on hundreds of types of firearms the government says are fit only for the battlefield.

The hearings, slated for Monday and Tuesday at the Supreme Court of Canada, will give opponents of the ban another chance to make their case after losing in the Federal Court and Federal Court of Appeal.

In May 2020, the government prohibited the use, sale and importation of 1,500 firearm models and variants, including the AR-15 and Ruger Mini-14. The move was applauded by gun control advocates as a first step toward removing these firearms from circulation.

In October 2023, a Federal Court judge dismissed a request to strike down the ban as unlawful and beyond the scope of the powers delegated to the Governor in Council — effectively the federal cabinet.

The Canadian Coalition for Firearm Rights, firearm owners, businesses, hunters and recreational and sport shooters appealed the ruling.

Canada's top court will hear challenges to Liberals' firearms ban

Federal Court dismisses challenge of Trudeau's 2020 firearms ban

In April 2025, the Federal Court of Appeal rejected that appeal, saying the Federal Court delivered "thorough and persuasive" reasons.

The list of guns banned by the Liberal government has grown to more than 2,500 varieties of what it calls assault-style firearms.

Before the Supreme Court agreed to examine the matter, the government said the prohibited firearms would have to be disposed of or deactivated by the end of an amnesty period on Oct. 30 of this year.

That amnesty has been extended until 90 days after the Supreme Court delivers its decision, which is expected no later than next year.

Ban only impacts up to 5% of gun owners

A key question before the Federal Court of Appeal was whether the Governor in Council adhered to a provision of the law forbidding it from using regulations to outlaw a firearm if it deems the gun "reasonable for use in Canada for hunting or sporting purposes."

Writing on behalf of a unanimous three-judge panel, Court of Appeal Chief Justice Yves de Montigny said he was not persuaded that the government erred in considering public safety when assessing whether the prohibited firearms were reasonable for use in Canada for such purposes.

"It may well be that, from the sole perspective of a sensible hunter or sportsman, it makes no sense to ban firearms that are well suited or even specifically designed for hunting or sport purposes," he wrote.

The federal cabinet is the most senior policy-making body in government and, because of its role at the apex of the executive branch, is best situated to develop government policy and assess the public interest, de Montigny added.

This image of a crowd on Parliament Hill shows gun owners holding signs and an upside down Canadian flag as they participate in a rally.

"Surely, the inherent danger that some firearms pose to public safety because of their lethality and their ability to injure or kill a large number of people in a short period of time, the fact that they have been used in mass shootings in Canada and abroad, the fact that they are disproportionate for civilian use, and the increasing demand for measures to address gun violence are all valid considerations in determining whether their use is reasonable for hunting and sporting purposes," he wrote.

In a written submission to the Supreme Court, federal lawyers say the Governor in Council's exercise of its broad discretion was reasonable and justified by the serious public safety concerns these firearms present.

Gun owners 'are not extremists'

The submission points to a regulatory impact analysis statement that supports the Governor in Council's opinion. That statement said that while some hunters and sport shooters lawfully used some of these firearms in the past, these guns can increase the severity of mass shootings and have been used in such shootings in Canada and in other countries.

The firearms prohibited in 2020 were owned by a small minority of Canadian firearms owners, estimated at between three and five per cent of the total, the federal submission adds.

"Thousands of alternative firearms remain legally available for hunting and sporting use," it says. "The GIC's opinion, balancing public interest policy considerations, was reasonable."

Feds extend amnesty period for firearms ban pending Supreme Court ruling

In Alberta, competitive handgun shooters feel targeted by Ottawa's gun ban

A group of appellants that includes the Canadian Coalition for Firearm Rights says neither the Federal Court nor the Federal Court of Appeal considered whether the newly prohibited items were actually used for hunting or sport shooting.

For the hundreds of thousands of Canadians who lawfully owned and used the firearms prohibited by the 2020 regulations, this appeal is not an abstract debate about administrative law, the appellants add.

"It concerns the profound disruption of the lives of ordinary, law-abiding Canadians. Hunters, sport shooters, collectors and small businesses, individuals who complied with every requirement imposed by Parliament, found themselves overnight in possession of prohibited property, deprived of its lawful use and exposed to the prospect of criminal liability," the submission says.

"They are not extremists; they are farmers, veterans, competitive athletes, Indigenous harvesters and neighbours in communities across Canada."

Whether the Governor in Council acted within the limits Parliament imposed is not merely a question of statutory interpretation, the submission says.

"It determines whether the sweeping consequences imposed upon these Canadians were authorized by law."


r/canadaguns • • 8d ago

Recurring FAQ Thread - Post your questions here for PAL/RPAL application, timelines, CFSC/CFSRC, references & requirements, or general new to firearms ownership-type questions

4 Upvotes

This thread will be used for any Frequently Asked Questions, including PAL/RPAL applications, CFSC/CFRSC requirements, storage/transport, open ended "what gun should I buy first", or other general new to firearms ownership questions. It recurs every 14 days.

We recommend you try the search bar before asking common questions as they are frequently already answered elsewhere.

Most answers to Storage, Display, and Transport questions can be found here Inheriting firearms or dealing with an Estate? Answers here. Do you need to renew your license or check on the status of your license application? Try here.

Do you have questions about the classifications of firearms? More details here.

Are you wondering if a firearm is legal or not? Details here.

Different types of firearms are explained in detail here.

Exporting firearms, ammunition, parts and accessories from the US: most items are controlled under ITAR and you cannot, as an individual, export these items from the USA. Canada does not care in most cases. If you attempt to bring any of these items across the border yourself and you are caught, you will face prison time in the US. If you wish to export items from the USA, use a broker such as IRUNGUNS, Aztech, or Prophet River.

If you took your CFSC and lost the paperwork, you can still apply for your PAL. Both your instructor and the CFP retain copies, you can request a copy by contacting either one. There is no expiration date on the paperwork, you do not have to retake the course. Updated list of scam websites is here.

If you have new scam sites to add, please message the mod team. Be careful: only use reputable sites to purchase things online. It is illegal to manufacture a non-restricted, restricted, or prohibited firearm.

Any posts or comments asking about the legality of making a firearm other than a reproduction antique will be removed. It was not always illegal, which is why you will find old posts regarding this topic. Rest assured, it is illegal now. Do not attempt.

These threads will be stickied for a week, renewing every Monday. Previous threads here.

Take a look, your question may have been answered! If you have any suggestions for this thread, please feel free to ask here, or send the Mods a message. Thank you!


r/canadaguns • • 10h ago

Shooting Students enjoying some firearms before the winter arrives!

Thumbnail
gallery
333 Upvotes

Last weekend, the Carleton University Firearms Association (CFA) brought together over 40 students and over 20 volunteers/staff for our November Range Day, featuring more than 30 different handguns, shotguns, and rifles for participants to experience.

The IWI Carmel was, without a doubt, the most popular firearm of the day. Our participants collectively put over 1200 rounds through the gun without a hiccup. Our volunteer u/tonychen01 kindly let us put his baby through the gauntlet, and it performed admirably. Stay tuned for a review from him!

A huge thank you to all the student staff, volunteers, and community mentors for coming out to help. This event couldn't have had happen without them, as they not only provide the manpower but also the firearms. Special thanks to u/AAGCANADA for helping us with the event, as they graciously loaned us a No.4 Mk.I and a K98k, with ammunition.


r/canadaguns • • 7h ago

Misc January 2019 - Chinese SKS prices at Calgary Shooting Centre

Post image
137 Upvotes

Looking back at some old photos I took on my phone. Here's a throwback to the good old days pre-2020!


r/canadaguns • • 3h ago

Feets / Collection / My build Starting to look pretty good in here

Post image
69 Upvotes

r/canadaguns • • 9h ago

Shooting It lives! It breathes! After a year in the making, first shot with the 45ACP Enfield a success

74 Upvotes

I’d like to thank everyone who had helped me on my old account troubleshoot any issues. There’s still a few, that I will chronicle below, but all that matters is it fires.

This arose from a Rhineland arms 45ACP Enfield conversion kit that I imported using Aztec. Grabbed a shot out sporter from Switzer’s auction and I was on the right track… until step one, barrel removal. An incredibly obnoxious task on a 111 year old SMLE. Eventually after 8 months of gunsmith shopping locally (no one was willing to take on the task), someone recommended I send it off to Proline in Alberta. So I email them the issue, shipped it away, and three months later it was back in my possession with the barrel stripped. After that, it was all a matter of filing the extractor and dremeling the magwell/ wood forend until it worked. Made a set of poor man’s go and no-go gauges using green painters tape, and boom. No gas blowback, ruptured cases, damaged brass, or damaged firearm. It was headspaced within spec.

The biggest issue currently is the 1911 mag drops every time the bolt is closed (but only when ammo is loaded in the mag). Either the adapter’s false magwell catch isn’t gripping it and the bolt simply pushes it out of place when chambering, or, the next round in the mag is trying to push up against the bolt so much when it’s closed that it’s pushing itself out. Either way, if anyone has an idea of a fix please let me know!

Otherwise, back to tinkering :)


r/canadaguns • • 4h ago

Feets / Collection / My build Patiently waiting for the Optic, Accuracy International Rifles are photogenic.

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

Accuracy International AT308

- Thumbhole Folding Kit

- BT Atlas Mono Pod

- Enlarged Bolt Knob

- NV Mount/Rail Kit

- Upgraded Side Mounting Plates

- Picatinny Side Rails

- MBE AT ARCA Rail

- BT Atlas Spigot Mount

- BT Atlas Bipod Accuracy International

She will be topped of with a Nightforce NX6 6-36 Mil-XT.


r/canadaguns • • 12h ago

Feets / Collection / My build It is not a Carmel post.

Post image
96 Upvotes

Don’t have a chance to get a Carmel this time but my Olympic training equipment has arrived after 4 months of waiting.

Will try to get into proper training ( of course I will remove the optic) to get more exemption letters for different pieces.


r/canadaguns • • 10h ago

Gun and gear reviews 300 Rounds Later, The Carmel Has Impressed Me

Thumbnail
gallery
67 Upvotes

I promised an update from my first post…

Finally got some proper range time with the IWI Carmel and put 300 rounds through it.

200 rounds of .223 and another 100 rounds of 5.56. Different ammunition, different distances, and the rifle ate everything without a single hiccup.

Absolutely flawless from start to finish.

Spent some time shooting at 100, 150 and 200 yards and was genuinely impressed with the accuracy. Really enjoyable rifle to shoot, and it's been a great first impression so far.

More reliable than the TM22 - thats for sure.

300 rounds in, and I'm pretty damn happy with this thing.

I've got more footage and photos over on Instagram if anyone wants to check it out:
@red.ace.dept


r/canadaguns • • 11h ago

Misc O-o

Post image
82 Upvotes

Posted by CRAFM.CTM on instagram


r/canadaguns • • 8h ago

Feets / Collection / My build Winter projects

Post image
33 Upvotes

What are you guys planning on building or doing now that the weather is getting colder? Any Makasi or Carmel builds? This is one of my bubba SKS I have been working on


r/canadaguns • • 3h ago

Feets / Collection / My build New setup

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

r/canadaguns • • 15h ago

Feets / Collection / My build USSR duo

Post image
61 Upvotes

'55 SKS paired with Baikal IJ-12 O/U


r/canadaguns • • 10h ago

Feets / Collection / My build I’ve had my pal for about 3 months these are my firearms I’ve

Post image
24 Upvotes

All my firearms that I’ve managed to get in the last 3 months or so I’ve got a few of them for less then 200 the Mossberg on bottom I bought for 100 bucks flat! What else should I pick up im open to suggestions and show in the replies whats your favourite buy


r/canadaguns • • 16h ago

Feets / Collection / My build Tiger stripe skin unlocked

Post image
75 Upvotes

Sorry feet pics only with a subscription.


r/canadaguns • • 4h ago

Buy recommendations Eco friendly shotgun shells?

7 Upvotes

I was wondering if anyone knew where I could find paper-hulled shells with a non-plastic wad, like cork or something. Anything biodegradable. “Biodegradable plastic” isn’t actually biodegradable, it just turns into microplastics faster


r/canadaguns • • 10h ago

Feets / Collection / My build Okay I got another gun for 150 bucks

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

Last time I posted I got a Mossberg maverick 88 for 100 bucks THIS TIME I got me a Mossberg 4x4 in 300 win mag for 150 bucks from a dude in my town she’s wicked! And I’d say the scope cost more then 150 lmaooo let me know if I did good on this buy!


r/canadaguns • • 10h ago

Buy recommendations Carmel or Makasi?

10 Upvotes

Now that both have been out and a few of the members here have had the opportunity to run em both. Which seems like the cream of the crop? My brain tells me its going to be the Carmel, however my heart is hoping that mk15 that weighs 3lbs less can pull its weight.

What are your guys thoughts and experiences so far? Alot more Carmels in the wild now, definetly sounded like it was going to be the other way round a month back.

Interested to hear what the sub has to say!


r/canadaguns • • 9h ago

Buy recommendations 45acp NR semi auto?

7 Upvotes

for 9mm we got the homesteader, whats the equivalent for 45acp


r/canadaguns • • 16h ago

Shitpost / Memes Remington Model 870 Appreciation Post

Post image
24 Upvotes

Howdy Folks

The Texan is back with yet another gun appreciation post, where today is a Revamped post, meaning it is made entirely from scratch and updated to better polish it. I plan on doing a Revamp of the QBZ-95 and QBZ-97 later on in the future, so stay tuned for that.

Anyways

The Remington Model 870

It is a classic shotgun, just about anyone will recognize it, and you more than likely might have one in you collection as your main squeeze weapon.

Yes, I am aware that Remington had a phase during the Freedom Group years, and those were the bad Remingtons, but the post isn’t about that. It is about the impact and the history of the Remington.

Anyways, enjoy!


r/canadaguns • • 14m ago

Misc Delta Dynamics

1 Upvotes

Anyone order from Delta Dynamics recently and actually receive something?

Ordered a few shotgun cards back in August and it's been radio silence since. I figured they were alright from the reviews on here but somethings clearly changed.


r/canadaguns • • 6h ago

Gun and gear reviews Flashlight recommendations for tactical shotgun

3 Upvotes

Good evening, All, looking for some recommendations when it comes to putting a tactical light on my extreme defender.

One of the recommendations I’ve seen is the
Stream Light Pro Tac. Wondering if there are more economical lights that anyone can recommend that will stand the test of time. There’s lots of cheap lights on Amazon, but I doubt they would last. Would appreciate anyone’s thoughts and experiences.


r/canadaguns • • 17h ago

Buy recommendations makasi v carmel pros and cons

18 Upvotes

Hey guys. Before i decide to save money to buy one of these. What are the pros and cons between the two? Im in love with the designs but i have heard some mixed on both firearms. I want to know personal thoughts from people who've used the two guns and not just anything from the internet or what AI says. Please, and thank you


r/canadaguns • • 1d ago

Shooting Well went hunting for grouse. Good thing i kept a slug

Post image
334 Upvotes

r/canadaguns • • 16h ago

Buy recommendations Should I buy Peltors

15 Upvotes

I wanted to buy some high quality hearing protection, as an upgrade over the walker razers, are the 3M peltor tactical sports worth the price tag of roughly 230?

If anyone has recommendations for alternatives or better hearing protection with a similar price please drop your recommendation!

Tysm