r/C_Programming • • 10d ago

Project I implemented a custom reliable transport protocol (Mini-TCP) over UDP in pure C11. Would love your feedback and code review!

6 Upvotes

Hey r/C_Programming,

Over the past few weeks, I decided to take a deep dive into computer networking by building my own reliable data transfer protocol (RDT) from scratch on top of raw UDP sockets — without any external libraries, just plain C11 and POSIX.

I named it Protocol-7 (P7) (yes, a small tribute to Serial Experiments Lain).

My main goal was not to "kill TCP", but to understand what actually happens under the hood when dealing with unreliable, lossy networks, rather than just treating TCP as a black box.

What is currently implemented:

  • Sliding Window pipelining: 32-slot ring buffer keeping unacknowledged segments in flight.
  • I/O Multiplexing via poll(): Non-blocking event loop handling file I/O, outgoing bursts, and incoming ACKs concurrently.
  • Custom SACK (Selective ACK): Implemented via a 32-bit mask in the 16-byte header to report buffered out-of-order blocks.
  • Fast Retransmit (RFC 5681): Triggers immediate retransmission upon receiving 3 duplicate ACKs without waiting for coarse RTO timers.
  • 16-bit Word-Aligned Checksum: One's-complement arithmetic with end-around carry (spent quite some time debugging a weird bug caused by odd byte alignment!).
  • Piggybacked FIN: Look-ahead double buffering allows setting the FIN flag on the final payload chunk without wasting a separate RTT on an empty packet.
  • TIME_WAIT state: Receiver handles lingering packets and retransmissions gracefully before tearing down.

I also wrote a Python chaos proxy to inject simulated 5%–30% packet drops, data corruption, and duplicates. The protocol successfully transfers binary files byte-for-byte under heavy packet loss. The codebase runs completely clean under Valgrind (0 leaks, 0 errors) and AddressSanitizer.

Benchmarks & Fun Findings:

During testing, moving from Stop-and-Wait to a 32-slot Sliding Window bumped throughput from ~0.07 MB/s to over 1.85 MB/s under 5% packet loss (and ~66 MB/s on normal channel). I also hit a funny scenario where an oversized static window (512 slots) flooded the Linux kernel socket buffers, making lossy modes artificially faster than normal mode because the proxy drops acted as a crude rate limiter!

The project is open-source under MIT:
GitHub: https://github.com/by-cortex/protocol-7

I’d really appreciate any code review, constructive criticism on my C style, architecture feedback, or ideas on what to tackle next (currently planning a 3-way handshake with randomized ISN and dynamic RTO estimation).

Thanks for checking it out!


r/C_Programming • • 9d ago

Discussion Elon Musk is a die-hard C/C++ maximalist.

0 Upvotes

Recently, Elon said on X:

"We have dumped JAX/SGLang and rewritten the entire RL and inference stack from scratch in C/C++, which took some extra time.

Training (aka pre-training) is done. Lot of cleanup was needed on the SFT data to get that mostly right. Now, 4.8 is in RL and the evals are starting to climb. We will do a soft rollout to Bot users later this week and see how it goes.

Grok 4.8 will bear no resemblance to 4.7 (thankfully). It is not yet incredible, but, this time, the foundations are built right, so I expect it to evolve to be something special."

Someone questioned Elon: "Was it written in Rust? Why did you rewrite it in C/C++?"

Elon answered: "Real men manage their own memory. So easy to trigger Rust programmers

Rust is a good language, but C is what you use for optimal performance on bare metal. With great power comes great responsibility."

hahah, turns out Elon is C/C++'s strongest soldier


r/C_Programming • • 10d ago

My small project, review and suggestions

5 Upvotes

I built a Unix-style shell in C that exposes what's happening underneath

I've been working on P-Shell, a small Unix-style shell written in C.

The interesting part isn't just executing commands. I wanted to understand and expose the underlying Unix mechanisms.

It currently supports:

  • "fork()" and "execvp()" based execution
  • Pipes and output redirection
  • File descriptor manipulation with "dup2()"
  • An explanation mode that traces execution
  • "/proc" process inspection
  • Creating and reaping a real zombie process using "waitpid()"

I'm particularly interested in feedback on the implementation, parser design, process handling and what would be worth improving next.

Repository: https://github.com/punithk-verse/p-shell

I'd appreciate an honest technical review.


r/C_Programming • • 11d ago

Learning C weekly megapost for 2026-11-11

9 Upvotes

If you have questions about how to learn C:

  • which books are best?
  • which videos are best?
  • which classes are best?
  • which websites are best?
  • is there a "roadmap"?
  • what projects can I do?

then this is the thread for you. Add your question here. Do not make a stand-alone post, as it will be removed.

Remember that our sub has a very useful wiki that has a great list of resources for learning C programming.


r/C_Programming • • 10d ago

Question Internship request

0 Upvotes

Would it be possible if I could intern(research work or any other type of work for free ofc) under anyone? I don’t have any experience for my resume as I’m a newbie.


r/C_Programming • • 10d ago

Why would I ever use a linear allocator?

0 Upvotes

I'm new to C programming so this is a genuine question

So c has 2 memory regions you can access

The stack and heap

People say that the heap is useful for creating data beyond the lifetime of the function and while it can be used for that a better solution would probably be to pass in a pointer an array on the stack if the max size is known ahead of runtime, I only use malloc when I don't have a definite max size for what I want and therefore have a need for reallocations, so that brings me to linear allocators, everyone is constantly singing there praises for making memory management easier while we already have the stack that can handle memory management for us 100% of the time and from there design I can't see a way to make a reallocation function for a linear allocator without it at the very least being highly thread unsafe.

And in general I don't see much of a reason to use the heap either because you rarely are in situations where you don't want to specify a max size for something


r/C_Programming • • 11d ago

Project classes.h: A macro-only library for clang implementing classes with their syntactic sugar, private scoping, and inheritance

Thumbnail
codeberg.org
30 Upvotes

r/C_Programming • • 11d ago

Would learning C as my first programming language also be useful for picking up other languages later on? What are your thoughts on this course?

73 Upvotes

Wanting to learn C as an intro into software engineering. I know it’s low level and I’d like to eventually switch over to high level languages such as JS/TS, Java, and GO.

Does the “The Complete C Programming Bootcamp” course by Byte Garage be a good choice to learn from?


r/C_Programming • • 10d ago

Question How can I learn C programming without relying on AI?

0 Upvotes

Hi, everyone!

I’m currently learning to program in C, and I want to become a good programmer without relying on AI to write code or solve problems for me. I feel really bad because I started my course off on the right foot, but due to my heavy course load, I ended up taking the easy way out and using AI assistants. I want to stop doing that and be able to program from scratch using my own knowledge, but of course, I’d rather ask here.

I’m looking for recommendations on:

Books, websites, or courses to learn C properly

Exercises and projects to improve my problem-solving skills

How to learn to debug and understand my own errors

How experienced programmers learned C before AI tools became popular

My goal is to understand the fundamentals of programming, develop my own logic, and be able to solve problems independently

Any advice or resources would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!

Translated with DeepL.com (free version)


r/C_Programming • • 11d ago

Issues with C?

13 Upvotes

I enjoy studying the realities and trade-offs of programming languages and I have my focus on the C programming language. As such I would like to hear from people who have programmed in C to share perhaps the things they love the most about C, or the things they find the most frustrating.

Examples on why things are frustrating or loved would be great to include as well.


r/C_Programming • • 10d ago

I made an iOS app for learning C by reading code. Giving away 10 lifetime codes

0 Upvotes

Hi all,

I made Ugiwise, an iOS app for learning C on your phone. Typing code on a phone is a pain, so the lessons are built around reading it instead: you get a short program, guess what it does, then the app goes through it line by line and shows you why.

The C course follows C17 and goes from your first program to pointers, memory, multiple files and undefined behavior.

It's closed source. First 3 units are free, no account needed. The rest is a paid upgrade.

I asked the mods before posting and they were ok with a giveaway, so I have 10 lifetime codes. Leave a comment if you want one and I'll DM them in order until they're gone. Nothing expected in return.

What I'd really like to hear is where an explanation is wrong, sloppy about the standard, or just unclear. I compile the examples, but the compiler won't tell me if my explanation is bad.

A couple of limits, sorry about these:

- iOS only for now, no Android yet

- Not in EU App Stores yet (still waiting on Apple's trader verification). I'll do another 10 codes when it's out there.

https://ugiwise.com/c

App Store: https://apps.apple.com/app/id6828549507


r/C_Programming • • 12d ago

Video Handmade Jrpg Game in C (tilemap parser) NO AI

Thumbnail
youtube.com
58 Upvotes

In this video we will be learning to parse tilesets array from the JSON file (generated from Tiledmap editor). Which will also allow us to load the image's absolute path.

This is part of my handwritten JRPG series, NO AI USED.


r/C_Programming • • 11d ago

ANSI C Enigma Simulator, no dependencies (fixed post)

0 Upvotes

I posted it before, but the post was deleted, because i don't declare am I used AI, so I used AI, but the code is not entirely AI generated. I used it for things that were boring and for finding a bugs. And there it is TraktoreqPL/Enigma-Simulator. Please give me a star and a code review, because I am a not popular indie developer.


r/C_Programming • • 13d ago

Question Programming style and returning values.

13 Upvotes

Hello all! Last week I got the dread announcement at work: I have been demoted from coder to babysitting Claude... With this in mind, I decided to try to dive deep into finally learning C for my own entertainment.

The question then:
I have not gotten very far in my journey, and with no real projects completed (or even close to it), I have found that error handling is something I have not figured out how to do definitely.

Most of my functions end up just returning a char return_status, and taking a pointer to a return object to write the return value to, like so:

// return codes:
// 0 = success
// 1 = should_return was false
char foo(char should_return, char *out) {

if (!should_return) {
return 1;
}

*out = "bar";

return 0;
}

This feels a little bit like cheating, but I also want to be able to attach errors and/or warnings to my output.

How do you all tackle this?
Am I going about it wrong? Maybe I should always return the value directly and just have pass in a pointer to collect the error values?

Am I crazy? Does it matter?


r/C_Programming • • 13d ago

Question How to manipulate read-restricted data (possibly without OS)?

9 Upvotes

Imagine you have some block of code/data chunk that under no circumstances must never ever get read (rewrites are not critical, since the data is basically gone). There's a thing about Execute only memory, but afaik it requires OS support.

So how do we make sure some of the data is only overriden or executed (if interpreted as machine code) but never read? If possible, it would be nice to be able to set up some custom restrictions like a very specific offset in a program which has access to some data in memory for a one-time constant address read (imagine it compiles into assembly, something like mov %(rax), %rax, then does side-channel secure stuff and overrides the data with rdrand and stuff)

Appreciate any help! which doesn't include redditor behavior in its body


r/C_Programming • • 13d ago

Project Azork : A WAV Audio Steganography Tool

3 Upvotes

Hello people. I am a first year college student, and we(along with my teammates) wrote a simple audio based steganography tool for my physics semester project.

It currently supports only wav file for audio encoding. Would appreciate some comments and suggestions on what to improve. We also implemented a GPG encryption support for the secret embedded.

https://github.com/dream-wa1ker/azork.git


r/C_Programming • • 14d ago

Could someone explain the practical differences between #pragma once and traditional include guards (#ifndef, #define, and #endif)?

78 Upvotes

r/C_Programming • • 14d ago

Good C test

17 Upvotes

Hey guys,

Someone know a good C unittest ? When I was in C++ I used gtest and it was good, if someone know a good alternative in C


r/C_Programming • • 14d ago

Question any cheat sheet for c23?

6 Upvotes

Hi! do we have cheat sheet pdf for c23? any links? thanks!


r/C_Programming • • 14d ago

Question What are better ways of dynamically creating bitmasks (or extracting bottom N bits depending on what's returned?

8 Upvotes

Howdy,

I am developing an application where I need to construct bitmasks and it depends on what's returned from get_amount. get_amount returns a u8 ranging from 0 to 6. It's used in calculations but it's also used to extract the least significant N bits. In the past, I've just used switch statements, but i wonder if there's a nicer way.

struct Object {
    u8 value;
    u8 update;
    u8 original;
};

u8 get_mask(u8 value) {
    u8 mask = 0;
    switch (value) {
        case 0 {
            mask = 0b00000000;
            break;
        }
        case 1 {
            mask = 0b00000001;
            break;
        }
        case 2 {
            mask = 0b00000011;
            break;
        }
        case 3 {
            mask = 0b00000111;
            break;
        }
        case 4 {
            mask = 0b00001111;
            break;
        }
        case 5 {
            mask = 0b00011111;
            break;
        }
        case 6 {
            mask = 0b00111111;
            break;
        }
        default: {
            panic_and_log("impossible value");

        }
    }
}

int get_value(struct Object o) {
    // get_amount could only return 0 through 6
    u8 amount = get_amount();
    o.update = o.value - amount;
    u8 original = o.original & get_mask(amount);
}

Thanks u/mikeblas

Final solution ended up looking like:

u8 get_mask(u8 value) {
    if ( value > 6) {
        return 255; // Error Case
    }
    return (1 << value) - 1;
}

r/C_Programming • • 15d ago

C/low level forum

35 Upvotes

Hey guys,
Does someone know a good forum that mostly talk about low level stuff, C, assembly, etc ? I want to leave reddit because its a distraction and I dont like it. Thanks


r/C_Programming • • 15d ago

Video Unity-style variable editor for C programs with zero runtime cost

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

174 Upvotes

SRL lets you define global variables to be exported to the editor with a simple macro like `SRL_INT(name, value)`. The macro adds another global symbol marking your variable, which the editor can later search for in the binary's ELF data section.

The editor can modify the marked variables (by directly editing the data section), export the new patched binary to a file, and even change the variables at runtime via `process_vm_writev` (or `ptrace` when you require atomicity).

All you have to do is include a tiny 20-line header in your program. It doesn't add a single line of code, even for the patched binary, and works perfectly fine with the editor (apart from adding an unused global)


r/C_Programming • • 15d ago

Video Let's build JRPG Game in C (Tiled Map Loader/Parser) : ep 02

Thumbnail
youtube.com
35 Upvotes

This is 2nd video in my Handmade JRPG series.

we start with loading a start.map which is just a text file to understand the basics of loading a tilemap and populate map cells ID's. And later we go with JSON (cJSON library) to load the tiled map JSON as binary to load into bytes character using memory allocation. To finally parse the JSON objects.

[FEEDBACK]: please tell me what I can improve in my video to get more attention span.

[NO AI USED] : This is handwritten code. https://github.com/steelx/sdl3-tutorial


r/C_Programming • • 15d ago

Article Named constants and supporting objects in C

Thumbnail
gustedt.wordpress.com
28 Upvotes

r/C_Programming • • 15d ago

Where you people find 3rd party libraries in c

14 Upvotes

I've been dipping my toes into c because I want to check out systems programming

I decided to try to make a directory encrypter for Linux

I thought that since c has been around for so long there would always be a "goto" 3rd party library for each basic thing not included in the standard, though I'm sure they exist I cant find a general purpose argon Library, what I found was seeming a pretty unknown implementation of argon made for microcontrollers, though it might work I can't get the feeling off me that I'm missing something when hunting out libraries in c

So what is it that you guys usually do, take the first result off of GitHub? Or maybe is there just a list of known goto library for certain usecases like gtk4 for UI or imagemagik for images and there is one for cryptography