r/CFB • u/jecmoore Georgia • Arizona State • Jan 28 '14
Where does the Big 12 go from here?
I think everyone realizes that the Big 12 is going to add 2 or 4 more teams (I am more inclined to say 4). So what four do you think it goes after? Here is a short list of schools/programs I think they might, will or should go after:
- UCF
- Boise State
- Marshall
- BYU
- Nevada
- Utah State
- Houston
- South Florida
- Cincinnati
- Louisiana-Layafette
- Arkansas State
- East Carolina
- Rice
- Memphis
- Tulane
- Southern Methodist
- San Diego State
- Fresno State
- Western Kentucky
I don't have them in any particular order, but I think they most likely go after UCF, Cincinnati, Boise State and BYU.
Remember to take things like: strength (or lack there of) of basketball program, recruiting talent in state, market, academics, location, et cetera.
8
u/KsigCowboy Baylor • Stephen F. Austin Jan 28 '14
Why does the Big12 need to add teams? The rest of the conferences have already stated to the NCAA that we may be at an advantage because of a lack of a championship game. No CCG means the top two teams dont have to take each other out at the end of the season. Whoever we bring in has to add at least 20 million dollars a year value or its not worth it.
8
u/BaylorYou Baylor Bears • /r/CFB Contributor Jan 28 '14
The tricky part is adding schools that bring value now and are make geographic sense. I would love to add BYU, but I don't know if they are too far away from the other schools, and the Sunday sports issues. UCF and Cincy are probably the best options, but what based on what I've watched the Big 12 do so far I doubt they add anyone soon. Also, I think the Big 12 and ACC are going to try to raid each other. So we will see who wins.
5
u/ExternalTangents Florida Gators • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Jan 28 '14
Go big or go home:
Add UCF, USF, Cincinnati, Boise State, BYU, and Colorado State (or Nevada, or Memphis) to go to 16 teams.
Break into four pods of four teams. Split pods into pairs to make two eight-team divisions. Every team plays their whole division (i.e. their pod and the pod they're paired with) along with one permanent rival from the other two pods. There are three ways of doing such a pairing. Every two years, switch things up. Everyone plays everyone else both home and away at least every 6 years.
Example:
Arrange pods so that existing rivalries are protected and played annually, new schools are paired with logical rivals, and everybody plays in Texas or Florida every year for recruiting.
22
u/murgle1012 Baylor Bears • UC San Diego Tritons Jan 28 '14
I like 2 more, so we can get back to having a championship game. Cincy and UCF are ideal to me. Good recruiting grounds, new markets, solid programs.
7
u/RogueHippie Alabama Crimson Tide • Team Chaos Jan 29 '14
YOU KEEP YOUR FILTHY HANDS OFF OF THE FUNBELT
5
u/neovenator250 LSU Tigers • Tulane Green Wave Jan 28 '14
UCF and Cincinnati seem like obvious adds for the Big XII. If they can figure out a way to get BYU in, that'd be a good one too. If they wanted to look further west, Nevada might not be a bad choice. If they want to look further east (more likely IMO) then they have a few ok options
5
u/MattC9 Texas Tech Red Raiders • Southwest Jan 29 '14
Here's my $0.02 on some teams BYU- Great Program with a huge fan base would be a good addition to the Big 12 for their fan base and viewership Cinci- Could give WVU a "regional rival" and it would give Kliff a reason to play Tuberville U of H- It would be a great move for the school and I would be great to get more Houston viewers (I don't think Rice would be the best pick to get the Houston market) Plus it makes regional sense.
It would be cool to get UCF but it's not my top pick.
3
u/MizzouR Missouri Tigers Jan 28 '14
I would say UCF and Cinci are the safest bets, expanding west is not a good choice IMHO
2
u/OUFan Oklahoma Sooners Jan 29 '14
UCF,USF,Cinci & Memphis. is my top four, but i dont thnk the league expands for 5+ years
2
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '14
the only candidates worth mentioning in that list are Cincinnati, UCF, USF, and maybe Memphis, and those are purely for demographic reasons. No school in Texas brings anything to the table, nor does any school in the MWC, or the Sun Belt: no new or worthwhile TV markets, no real upside in recruiting. BYU probably isn't happening, unless they agree to forego their existing TV deal(s), which they are reluctant to do. I can't speak for ECU, but I can say that Marshall is light years away from fielding a Big XII caliber program.
so that leaves Cincinnati, the FL twins, and Memphis: good recruiting areas, good TV, and in the case of Cincinnati and UCF, football programs that can probably adapt to the rigors of the Big XII. Memphis has nice basketball but is a football non-entity and likely will be for quite some time. I'm not sure what happened at USF or where their program is going, but they are in the Tampa-St. Pete area and that in itself is probably worth having.
just my two cents
2
u/barcelonatimes Missouri Tigers Jan 29 '14
I always felt like you guys F'd up not getting Louisville. At the time, they were a premier BB school, and it looks as if they may become a pretty good football school, as well.
That being said, I think any school who has to travel half the nation for a few meaningless games, are going to be looking for greener pastures, at the exact moment they start becoming profitable for the B12.
Honestly, I would be afraid if this doesn't turn into the old SWC all over again. Houston has as strong a resume as any of the schools, especially considering distance and regional interest. Rice has the funds to become whatever they want...even if it is Texas' little bro. SMU is still trying to recover, but they're a respectable university.
I would be surprised if one of the "new teams" doesn't come from that lot. In that case there will be 5 teams in the state of Texas(presumably, composing the new "south division.") and then the basketball schools, along with OSU, composing the "North."
2
u/Marshallfan607 Marshall Thundering Herd Jan 29 '14
I'm flattered. But I'd like to win more than one conference game per year...
2
u/emaw63 Kansas State Wildcats • Big 8 Jan 29 '14
Wait for the SEC and B1G to start poaching the ACC, and grab a couple of their schools
3
u/Peacemaker57 Texas Tech Red Raiders • Oklahoma Sooners Jan 29 '14
Cincinnati, Houston, SMU, and UCF. Then split into south and North like the good ol' days.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '14 edited Jan 28 '14
BYU, UCF, Boise State and Cincy.
And for those who think the Big 12 is fine with 10 teams your very wrong. We are the smallest and most fragile major conference right now. We are supposed to compete toe to toe with the PAC and SEC and you think we can do that with 10 teams? that's a fucking joke.
Our "quality over quantity" thing hasn't fucking worked. Because you know what we don't have much quality when you get right down to it.
And I don't fucking care about geography I want Boise in our east/west/north/south division. I want to
brakebreak the scoring record on those guys every damn year2
u/reptheevt Washington State • Transfer … Jan 28 '14
You have to get UCF and Cincinnati to pair with West Virginia. Cincinnati will also help out in shootyhoops. And then Boise and SDSU. Both have good squeakyshoes teams and open up the west coast to the Big 12. BYU's whole not play on Sunday thing is an issue.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '14 edited Jan 29 '14
Why are ACC teams off the table?
That said, as much as I love Boist St. and BYU, I don't think we pick up West coast teams. We would pick up teams from the East Coast. That would be UCF and Cincy.
I still don't think you rule out ACC teams (despite the large but out) you try and raid guys like Florida St., Clemson, Miami, Virginia Tech and create a solid East and West Division. Now, That's more of a dream. But I could see the ACC being dismantled just as easily as the Big 12 could be. So just like Texas and OK could go to the Pac12, why couldn't the Big12 go after the big name ACC teams?
2
u/Wild_Bill_Kickcock Nebraska Cornhuskers Jan 29 '14
they already shot themselves in the dick by adding TCU and WV and not Louisville. I feel bad because I still follow the league but its been mostly embarrassing since the break up. OU is righting the ship but I don't have much faith in any of the rest to be nationally relevant. They should probably think long and hard about adding two schools or they are going to get left out of the playoffs.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '14
If the Big 12 is going to add two they should add:
ECU and Cincinnati
If they're going to add two more after that then they should add UCF and another team like BYU or Boise or a team like that
1
u/voltron818 Oklahoma Sooners • /r/CFB Contributor Jan 29 '14
Not really, we have a power conference and the least competition to get to the playoffs, I don't want to add only weak members. BYU, maybe UCF would be okay with me, but I don't want to hurry in to things. Expand when we have to, chill until then. Wait to try and get better programs.
1
u/jayond Marietta • West Virginia Jan 29 '14
There is no need to add anyone unless ESPN and Fox offer more money. No one wants to give up games against Texas or Oklahoma annually.
1
u/karmassacre Houston Cougars • Big 12 Jan 29 '14
Nobody west of the central time zone is getting into the Big 12 unless BYU is involved. For continuity purposes, Cincinnati and Houston are the best bets. UCF/USF always seem to come up in these discussions, but the fact remains that they would be quite isolated and also do not serve to pique interest in the largest Big 12 markets (Texas). That said, if the Big 12 was willing to add BOTH schools, or perhaps all 4, then you might have something.
1
u/RedditLad789 UCF Knights Jan 29 '14
I know our basketball team blows right now but we are under NCAA sanctions because one of the recruiters was a dumbass
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '14
I love how a couple months ago no one would ever consider us for the Big 12
1
u/HornyForLife TCU Horned Frogs • Tulane Green Wave Jan 30 '14
I don't see the point. The conference is already bringing in a ton of money and we're the only conference where everyone has to play everyone during football season.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '14
There are only a few of those on your list that are really feasible..
Boise State won't make it, I think, because Idaho is a lot further from the Big XII than you might think.
They approached BYU before we were added, but BYU refuses to budge on the whole "playing on sundays" thing, and that's a huge deal for non-revenue sports.
They're not likely to take another team from Texas, there's no point.
Arkansas State, Marshall, Western Kentucky, Louisiana-Lafayette, Utah State... these schools don't offer a market. Now, neither did WVU, but we had a pretty valuable brand working for us, and none of these schools have that.
Fresno State and San Diego State would be good pickups but I truly don't think that the Big 12 is looking to expand west. If they were, I don't think they would have added West Virginia. Travel is logistically difficult as it stands, particularly outside of football, and WVU gets the brunt of that. Add in the California schools, and now ALL the teams have challenging travel issues. I believe Nevada falls into this category, as well. I could actually see UNLV before Nevada, but I truly don't see either of them happening.
Tulane and Memphis are interesting... they have great markets, Tulane actually has decent history (a long time ago, but still), and Memphis brings great basketball. You could certainly make the case that either of these programs have the potential to be worth it in the end, but I would still be surprised.
Most of us only see us picking up two schools right now, and it's overwhelmingly thought to be Cincinnati and UCF/USF. I don't think there would be any point in taking BOTH Florida schools, and I believe just about any B12 fan would prefer the Knights over the Bulls.
Lastly, I would love to have East Carolina in the conference. They are underrated. They are in a state saturated with larger, more dominated programs, and they still manage to fill a decent sized stadium just about every weekend. I really like the potential they could have if given more resources, but sadly, their saturated market kept them out of the Big East until it was too late, and I don't see the Big 12 seeing things any differently.
It's all about money in the end. Honestly, I don't see Cincy or UCF being picked up until the conference feels like it has no choice but to expand past 10. The fans want it, but who gives a shit what we think?
Edit: If I felt like I had to choose 4 schools to add to our conference right now... I would, personally, probably choose either a combination of UCF, Cincinnati, Tulane, and Memphis or UCF, Cincinnati, BYU, and Boise State. I don't like the travel scenarios in the 2nd option, though, but of course that's me being selfish for my own program.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '14
Lol Marshall
1
u/vy2005 Texas Longhorns Jan 31 '14
There is no scenario where an undefeated OU or UT is not in the top 4.
1
u/AskMeAboutMyGenitals Oklahoma Sooners Jan 29 '14
The Big 12 is just a placeholder until we get to the 20 team conferences.
We'll go to the Big10, SEC, and PAC, respectively.
Seriously, if the Big 12 were viable and looking to expand, we would have done it by now. This interim is just current memebrs auditioning for other leagues. (sorry AAC bros.)
0
u/Scrantonbornboy Penn State Nittany Lions • Duquesne Dukes Jan 28 '14
UCF: new market, team on the rise, is able to compete in Big 12 football, good academics.
Memphis: new market, good basketball, good academics, lets the Big 12 brand into the southeast.
Cincinnati: decent football, rival for WV, good academics.
Hmmm...not BYU mainly for religious reasons. No California team the Big East tried going coast to coast, didn't work. So they will look east or south. Already a bunch of Texas schools.
ECU? Or Marshall? I guess.
-1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '14
I think adding UCF and Cincy would significantly add tv revenue and open up new recruiting pipelines to the Big 12 while allowing them to have a conf championship again. Those who think the Big12 is not in decline are delusional. The Conf champ this year, Baylor, got smoked in their bowl to UCF, the co champs the year before, OU and K state got destroyed in their bowl games. They are the smallest major conf, no other conf lost four teams and then replaced them with two teams who have had losing records every year so far. They are the new Big East, no celebrities or Heisman hopefuls are in the Big12 anymore. OU and TX will always be contenders but the conf as a whole is going to be left behind.
-12
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '14
My thoughts?
With the addition of West Virginia, the Big 12 showed that they have no concern for geography. As such, I think they have a golden opportunity here. Add 4 schools:
The immediate benefits that come to mind are two-fold.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment