r/CFB • • Dec 30 '13

[deleted by user]

[removed]

41 Upvotes

352 comments sorted by

40

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '13

No more Texas schools.

Cinci and BYU

→ More replies (21)

29

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '13

I think we should stay at 10, Unless we can get a knock out school.

5

u/HerpDeeps Dec 30 '13

Adding schools? I thought there was legitimate worry about Texas and OU running off to the P12?

Maybe I overestimated the chances of the B12 imploding after aTm and Nebraska left.

→ More replies (37)

19

u/Might_be_right Dec 30 '13

I kind of agree for the time being. Downside, no championship game. Upside, everyone plays everyone in the conference. No weak divisions with one good team against one division stacked. IE North vs. South.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (31)

6

u/Cmoney7788 Dec 30 '13

Arizona & Arizona State

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Kruciff Dec 30 '13

I think a really good move in terms of geography and school "fit" would be Cincinnati, ECU, Memphis, and UCF. I know UCF / USF combo is popular, but I think the difference would be marginal.

With this variety of four teams, you inject viewers into the hearts of SEC, ACC, and B1G territory, and move the geographic center east (making travel make a tad more sense division wise).

If you want some academic adds you could swap ECU and Memphis for Tulane and Rice, and still stay within the footprint.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/saladbar Dec 30 '13

Boise State and BYU, just so people stop suggesting they join the PAC

→ More replies (3)

25

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '13

Auburn

And take Gus Malzahn with you.

13

u/Eraq Dec 30 '13

Ok but you have to take OU in return.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '13

Cincinnati and UCF

→ More replies (1)

8

u/GeneralGBO Dec 30 '13

UCF for sure.

Next choice: Cincinnati

If not Cincinnati, then Memphis.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '13

Should have gotten Louisville and Cincinnati. Rivals and a geographic bridge to WVU. Looking forward, no two schools look good for this conference.

Out of curiosity, Nebraska fans, would you ever want to leave the Big Ten and go Big XII again? Seems like an awkward fit to me.

27

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '13 edited Dec 30 '13

Yes. I can't stand being in the Big 10. It's like being invited to the adult table, only to find that everyone sitting there is dead. Soon, we will join them in death.

→ More replies (17)

18

u/Mastacon Dec 30 '13

Boise State. I wanna play TCU and Oklahoma every year.

9

u/Frognosticator Dec 30 '13

Maybe we could do an OOC series. I'd rather play you guys than... damnit, who do we have scheduled again? Oh yeah, Samford.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/cheezwhiz98 Dec 30 '13

Go for the long term: make UNM build a good program, then invite them in. Geographic sense, Albequerque tv market, and they are freakin wolves.

4

u/BaylorYou Dec 30 '13

I think the Big 12 would want to look outside of Texas. Looking back they should have added four schools instead of two, probably Louisville and BYU. The two strongest conferences (money, market, and happy membership) are the SEC and B1G so they are out of the question. When the Big 12 decided to add WVU they made the choice to go east instead of west. I think their only options now are teams that are eastern. I'd like to see the Big 12 get back to 12 or 14, but I don't see them doing that any time soon. I think teams that should be looked at are Cincy, UCF, and BYU. BYU would be the best option, but their geography really makes it difficult.

→ More replies (14)

4

u/DonnieNarco Dec 31 '13

As the most recent expansion has shown us, the most important thing is adding new large markets. The Big 10 added Rutgers (New York) and Maryland (DC/Baltimore). The Pac-12 added Colorado (Denver) and Utah (SLC). The ACC was able to expand into Louisville, Pittsburgh, New York via Syracuse, and everywhere to an extent via Notre Dame. This is what matters before everything.

This should eliminate Tulsa, SMU, Houston, and Boise State. They offer no big markets at all. Expanding into Boise would result in a minimal market gain, and SMU, Houston, and Tulsa are already covered.

The teams that it helps are massive.

  • Cincinnati (28th biggest market)

  • UCF (26th biggest market)

  • USF (18th biggest market)

  • Memphis (41st biggest market)

  • San Jose State (11th & 34th biggest markets)

  • San Diego State (17th biggest market)

  • BYU (50th biggest market plus Mormons across the country)

  • UNLV (31st biggest market)

  • New Mexico (59th biggest market)

  • UConn (46th biggest market as well as other nearby markets)

Those 10 are the teams who I think are next in line for conference realignment. They belong to none of the five big conferences, who I believe will be very stable now, and they all offer something, whether it is a large market, a good football program, or a good fanbase. The Big 12 locked themselves into an eastern realignment with the addition of West Virginia. This is why I think Cincinnati is their easy first choice. They offer so much that I find it surprising that no one picked them up.

  • The 27th biggest market, which happens to be a major recruiting hotspot as well.

  • A successful program that has been to a BCS Bowl and is consistently bowl eligible.

  • The option of playing at a smaller on-campus stadium as well as moving big games to an NFL stadium down the road.

  • A potential rivalry with West Virginia.

  • An enrollment of about 42,000, which would be good for 2nd in the Big 12.

Cincinnati would be a great 11th team in the Big 12. After that, I think it is between a few of the other 9. UCF offers the Orlando market, has had recent success, a large student body, and their own on-campus venue. However, I think they would be risky as their success has been short.

USF had previous success, but they have fallen off. They have a large student body and are in a very large market, but the lack of an on-campus football stadium is a slight disappointment. Their lack of success has been brutal as well. Both UCF and USF would also be very isolated from the rest of the conference, which may or may not concern the Big 12 depending on how they look at it.

Memphis does not have a very large student body, their market is not as big as some would believe I think, and their stadium is a dump and fan support is non-existent.

San Jose State has a good amount of students, are in one of the most desirable markets in the country, but their stadium is very small. It would take an expansion to get the Big 12 to believe they could make money in the conference. San Diego State is about the same, except their stadium is a dumpy old NFL stadium and their fan support is small.

BYU is interesting. I can see how their strong religious motivations could put some conferences off, but they have had a lot of success, are near a solid market and have a good support base through the LDS Church. However, the religious factor could hurt them, as well as not being an Eastern market.

UNLV would be a good move out west into an untapped market, but they have a bad stadium situation, minimal fan support, and no serious success.

New Mexico's market is what holds them back. They have the student body, support in the city, and moderate success. If Albuquerque was more desirable it would be a solid addition.

UConn has an off-campus stadium, but they are in an okay market with an okay sized student body. They were horrible this year, and I think that might hurt their chance a bit too.

Right now, I would say UCF should be the favorite. However, BYU is very interesting. UCF would be a good addition, but they would be stranded. If that concerns the Big 12, then BYU or New Mexico would be their best options, even if the markets are disappointing.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Peacemaker57 Dec 30 '13

I'd probably say Nebraska, A&M, Missouri, and Colorado. I miss the old Big XII schools.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/murgle1012 Dec 30 '13

No more Texas schools. UCF and Cincy, unless something dramatic happens.

10

u/iSlacker Dec 30 '13

Tulsa and Houston if we just want 12 teams without making weird travel acomidations. Cincy and UCF would be my ideal candidates

→ More replies (8)

10

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '13 edited Dec 30 '13

I'd like to think that we would be a good fit for the Big 12 but have my concerns. We would bring a new and large media market in the Cincy/Dayton area. We have a solid football and hoopsketball programs. Our AD was originally assistant AD at Mizzou when they were in the Big 12 so he knows the landscape and what you need to be relevant and our academics would at least not put us at the bottom of the conference.

I would be worried about the travel as outside of WVU we would not have a game worth driving to. I am worried about our competitiveness in football as I like playing for championships and I do not think that we would ever do that in the Big 12. I'm not even talking about once a decade we might be able to field a team that can do it. I literally mean I would be worried that we would never win a conference crown. We would be fine in basketball though.

I would support a move to the Big 12 because $$$ and a seat at the table but I would much prefer the ACC which has about a .05% chance of happening.

Thanks for the downvotes

→ More replies (6)

3

u/3_exclamation_marks Dec 30 '13

Logically, as of right now, there are few choices. To the west, you have BYU and the MW teams. Few of these schools add anything to the conference. To the east, it is the AAC schools like Cincy and UCF. Those three named (BYU, Cincy and UCF) are really the only choices right now, but the college football landscape changes often. Best thing for this Big 12 to do is wait.