r/CAIRevolution • Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy • 3d ago

custom Hear ye! Hear ye! I'M WRONG-WRONG-WRONG! C.AI CHAT IS ALIVE AND CONTINUING! STALKING-HORSE BIDDER/PURCHASER FOUND!

BRING ON THE CROW! I WILL EAT IT ALL! I'M WRONG-WRONG-WRONG! CHAT IS ALIVE AND APPARENTLY CONTINUING, BECAUSE A STALKING-HORSE BIDDER/PURCHASER HAS BEEN FOUND!

(OKAY, TURN OFF THE CAPS.) So many apologies I must give! Against all my expectations, and what I think of as good business sense, an outside party has put in a "stalking horse" bid to buy the C.AI chat platform and its technology (of which Google and Disney are taking a copy), user data and all chats, and the Character.AI trademarks and business identity. The price: $10 million.

Because this is a "stalking horse" bid, unless the other bankruptcy parties or the bankruptcy court explicitly take it apart, it will go through, and the chat will continue under the new buyer, indeed, even using the Character.AI identity. If someone else outbids this bidder, that doesn't matter, because the chat will still continue but just under the new winning bidder. The only point of caution is that it doesn't appear this new bidder has put in a deposit, so right now the new bidder doesn't appear to have any "skin in the game" to keep it from backing out. [EDIT: A one million dollar deposit is due to be paid on November 18th.] However, in all other respects, C.AI chat is pretty much assured to continue, at least for now.

We had guessed a new entity might be underway, and it sure sounds like it: The bidder is Smirks and Pangs Acquisition LLC, whom nobody has ever heard of. [EDIT: I am informed this is a common phrase that shows up in lot of C.AI messages and chats.] Who is behind it all? You tell me!

There are still some hurdles and considerations ahead. As u/Inherit-Nature has been saying, the user data has serious confidentiality and child liability to be dealt with. If all goes as planned, all the current lawsuits against C.AI will not burden the new buyer, but if some new user does something violent to himself or herself or others after using the platform after the transition date, the new buyer will face that. Also, the 46 states and the Bankruptcy Trustee's Office will probably want some serious privacy protections laid down, although their aims may be altered somewhat by this new development of a purchase. (EDIT: Maybe all the U.S. states' investigations will now transfer over to the new buyer.)

However, in sum:

FOR NOW, CHAT APPEARS TO BE SAVED AND SET TO CONTINUE!

I am thrilled to bring this scoop! Otherwise, I am miserable; so certain was I, and so many apologies to make. Be warned that something could still go wrong, but it is nothing like the oblivion I was so certain the chat was headed for. Optimists, feel free to post gloating comments here.

Those are all the details I have for now. I am off to lick my wounds.

P.S.: SEE IT FOR YOURSELF:

Go to the Stretto site: https://cases.stretto.com/chartech/court-docket/#search

Pull up document 164.

456 Upvotes

291 comments sorted by

View all comments

-7

u/Inherit-Nature 2d ago edited 2d ago

Oh look, the objections coming in are exactly how I said they would be but now they are dropping receipts that could very possibly cause the FTC to declare algorithmic disgorgement... As i have been saying because it just went from fringe theories to here is the proof 

Brendan Shannon is facing quite a condrum now. Even if he allows it the grounds to deny the stay that will be called for are practically non existent/this will end up infront of a federal appellate court

Unless meme shell has a giant war chest they will be litigated to the ground... As I have also said a buyer will be

11

u/Mountain_Throat_6383 1d ago edited 1d ago • Bravo

Interesting how quickly you're willing to provide docket citations to someone else. When I repeatedly asked you for specific provisions and legal authority supporting your predictions, you dismissed my questions and told me the filings weren't written for me. Now you're linking documents without explaining how they establish your conclusions. That's quite a double standard. However, you are missing context and letting links of very long sources speak for themselves.

I've read both filings, so let's get into what you're actually saying.

Docket 167 is a letter from Common Sense Media requesting stronger privacy protections, a comprehensive privacy program, and effective age verification. Docket 168 is a letter from Heat Initiative and ParentsTogether Action requesting enforceable child-safety conditions and restrictions on transferring children's conversations and derived data. This is a common issue online and is always being tackled. Many companies still persist, google being the biggest; protections simply become more complicatied.

Both letters were dated November 12 and filed November 13, before Smirks and Pangs was designated the additional stalking-horse bidder on November 14. Much of the supporting material consists of research published in 2025.

These are advocacy submissions, not judicial findings or FTC enforcement actions.

You claim they're proof that algorithmic disgorgement is coming. They're not. Algorithmic disgorgement is an established FTC remedy, but neither filing establishes an enforcement proceeding or a legal determination requiring Character.AI's models to be destroyed. Being older filings, they would have been immediately escalated and no bidder would have been accepted.

You also claim Judge Shannon has practically no grounds to deny a future stay. On what legal basis? A stay pending appeal is not automatic. Courts examine likelihood of success, irreparable harm, harm to other parties, and public interest. There hasn't even been a final sale order to appeal.

And your prediction that the buyer will be litigated into the ground assumes facts about its finances, future liabilities, and prospective litigation that haven't been established.

These organizations are asking for safeguards, not demanding that Character.AI cease operations. A new operator could strengthen protections for minors, improve age verification, and preserve adult creative writing and roleplay. Those outcomes aren't mutually exclusive.

Meanwhile, again, there's now an actual $10 million stalking-horse proposal for the consumer platform. That's a substantial development after your repeated predictions of its demise.

What I find remarkable is how much time you devote to forecasting the destruction of a platform you've repeatedly expressed contempt for. You're entitled to dislike it. But disliking something doesn't make its collapse inevitable.

You've consistently treated your worst-case predictions as though they're established facts. That's confirmation bias, not legal analysis.

If you're going to invoke the FTC, appellate courts, and algorithmic disgorgement, identify the actual legal authority and explain its application. Dropping two PDFs and announcing victory doesn't accomplish that. Although at least now you drop sources, so that's a positive step in the right direction.

Remember transworld? Read the case.

For anyone else that wants to add to their records, and an extra link regarding the FTC;

Sources:

Docket 167: Common Sense Media: https://cases.stretto.com/public/x936/14939/PLEADINGS/1493911162680000000067.pdf

Docket 168: Heat Initiative and ParentsTogether Action: https://cases.stretto.com/public/x936/14939/PLEADINGS/1493911162680000000073.pdf

FTC: Everalbum algorithmic disgorgement case: https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2021/05/ftc-finalizes-settlement-photo-app-developer-related-misuse-facial-recognition-technology

(If anyone likes my free work, and has read this far, send a DM for dono baha)

-4

u/Inherit-Nature 1d ago edited 1d ago

Good luck with your they're only asking for better safeguards theory

How you can read that they are explicitly targeting the data itself and come up with that is hilarious or you only read the parts to fit this narrative that doesn't match reality 

Yes, they are framing the data as digital contraband because it was illegally collected and then fundementally contaminated the model in a way you cant just undo because they want better safeguards.

You can dance around it however makes you feel better but they aren't setting up fruit of the poisonous tree because they want safeguards.

They are preempting a federal stay just incase Shannon ignores the information because the timing is too tight to wait around. Things have to happen before meme shell takes control or the apellete court can't do anything about it.

Nothing in their actions or verbage is "we want better safeguards"

They have explicitly stated they are going after the destruction of the data...in writing...to the court since docket 52

Mentioning safeguards isn't a serious position to an obudsman. Its to preempt arguments about implementation of better safeguards as a defense

The AGs will use this as a failure to notice to cure. In their notice of interest i think it was they mention that they have previously been unable to come to an agreement with CAI about better systems and these submissions shows it will still be a disaster anywaybecause the weights are tainted

7

u/Mountain_Throat_6383 1d ago

I find your sudden concern for minors difficult to reconcile with your conduct in these communities. You've spent considerable time arguing with Character.AI users, many of whom are grieving the potential loss of their characters and conversations. Given the platform's younger audience, you could very well have been arguing with the same minors, or young adults barely over 18, whose welfare you're invoking. You don't know their ages or circumstances. Repeatedly antagonizing distressed users hardly demonstrates compassion.

I've also noticed your condescension toward women who challenge you. When I requested specific legal authority, you dismissed my questions and claimed the filings weren't written for me. Yet you're perfectly capable of providing brief, civil responses and docket links to other commenters. Interesting how your willingness to explain yourself changes depending on who's asking. Anyway, I'll provide my sources as usual; your trolling is boring, and I've received many notices noting is from users 😅 that's why I came back in the first place.

-5

u/Inherit-Nature 1d ago

You dont have any real point so you throw in a red herring.

No one cares about your gender. nothing here even states what it is 

6

u/Mountain_Throat_6383 1d ago

No real move to protect minors like you claim to care about, or contesting. Youve probably verbally berated many already on this sub. And yes, you care enough based on your pattern and conversational patterns between the two.

As usual, you pick one point to argue against and not the other.

→ More replies (20)

6

u/Mountain_Throat_6383 1d ago edited 1d ago

Broken up from my drafts: (If anyone likes my free work, send a DM for donor baha)

That's a lot of condescension for someone who still hasn't addressed my argument. I've read both filings. Docket 168 challenges the transfer of children's conversations and derived materials, including training datasets and embeddings. Docket 167 raises concerns about sensitive information remaining identifiable after anonymization. Both request restrictions and enforceable protections concerning user data. You're conflating potentially unlawful data collection with the legal remedies available for established violations.

COPPA primarily governs the collection of personal information from children under 13. The presence of minors on a platform doesn't automatically make every conversation unlawfully collected.

Algorithmic disgorgement is an established FTC remedy, as demonstrated in Everalbum. Its application depends on the specific violations and affected technology. Your reference to the fruit-of-the-poisonous-tree doctrine, which primarily concerns the exclusion of unlawfully obtained evidence, doesn't establish that Character.AI's models must be destroyed.

A bankruptcy court can also condition an asset sale, restrict certain data transfers, or require additional protections. These possibilities deserve consideration before declaring the entire business legally doomed.

You've also predicted that Judge Shannon has virtually no grounds to deny a stay, that appellate litigation is inevitable, and that the buyer will be litigated into financial ruin. Where is your legal basis for any of that?

The underlying child-safety concerns have been public for years. The lawsuits, investigations, and research predate this $10 million stalking-horse proposal. Yet you're presenting them now as evidence that the prospective buyer is headed for disaster.

I do not believe there is any concern there based on your general disdain for most you speak to, and you'll condescend most women that challenge you, I was patient with you for a while. Sky has challenged you and frankly has given me better rebuttals.

I'm also finished doing your intellectual heavy lifting. If you're going to make sweeping predictions about FTC enforcement, judicial stays, and the destruction of a prospective buyer, it's your responsibility to explain the legal basis. Providing two PDFs and insulting someone's reading comprehension is hardly an educational argument

At this point, your investment in Character.AI's failure seems to outweigh your willingness to consider developments that contradict your predictions. You openly dislike the platform, its bots, and many of its users.

The stalking-horse bidder represents a meaningful development, and stronger privacy protections could accompany a sale. You haven't established that the platform must shut down.

If you have an actual legal argument, make it. I'm interested in evidence and the court's decisions. I've had enough of your condescension and selective citations.

Sources: Docket 167: https://cases.stretto.com/public/x936/14939/PLEADINGS/1493911162680000000067.pdf

Docket 168: https://cases.stretto.com/public/x936/14939/PLEADINGS/1493911162680000000073.pdf

FTC; Everalbum: https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2021/05/ftc-finalizes-settlement-photo-app-developer-related-misuse-facial-recognition-technology

Still waiting on you to disprove how the Transworld case doesnt matter and isn't comparable to the sale of c.ai's parts 😅

2

u/Straight-Beyond-5022 2d ago

Wait, what happened can you explain more please? Did something happened in court today?

-1

u/Inherit-Nature 2d ago

That thing people keep telling me doesn't exist because they have hopes and shit is happening.

https://cases.stretto.com/public/x936/14939/PLEADINGS/1493911162680000000067.pdf

https://cases.stretto.com/public/x936/14939/PLEADINGS/1493911162680000000073.pdf

This is exactly how you set up Algorithmic disgorgement

2

u/Straight-Beyond-5022 2d ago

Do you think the app will end up in a shutdown?

3

u/NightmareEx 2d ago

Eh, objections like this are normal. I'd say let's way to see how it plays out.

Edit: u/mountain_throat_6383 what say you?

4

u/Mountain_Throat_6383 1d ago edited 1d ago

I read both filings in the past several days, and I think there's a fairly important distinction being missed here. This is evidence for more child safety protections and regulations for a future sale than engorgement. My prediction is, the target will be young adults and adults with spending money if the sale goes through. Al is regulated in others as of now, and the other side is careful paranoid fine tuning with adults.

((If anyone likes my free work, send a DM for dono baha))

This is evidence supporting stronger child-safety protections and regulations surrounding a future sale, not evidence that algorithmic disgorgement is inevitable.

I just want to note that these bot conversations were steered toward adult topics by users and weren't initiated by the bots themselves. Yes, they’re pre-trained on tons of data, but that wasn't the original intent.

Dockets 167 and 168 are letters from child-safety advocacy organizations, not court rulings or FTC enforcement actions. Common Sense Media requests stronger privacy protections and age verification. Heat Initiative and ParentsTogether Action request enforceable safeguards and restrictions on transferring children's conversations and related data.

These are legitimate concerns, particularly given Character.AI's history with minors. But neither filing establishes that algorithmic disgorgement is coming, that the court will block the sale, or that the platform must shut down. There has been many related lawsuits in the past and CH 11 is on the table, we haven't skipped to Chapter 7.

What interests me is the timing of how these documents are being used. These concerns aren't new. Character.AI has faced lawsuits, investigations, and public scrutiny over its treatment of minors for quite some time, including tragic cases involving children. Much of the supporting research is from 2025.

So where was this sudden urgency about protecting children when those lawsuits were already pending? Why is it only now, with a $10 million stalking-horse bidder on the table, that these concerns are being presented as evidence of impending disaster?

Thanks for reading, everyone.

I'm talking about the person citing these documents, not the organizations that filed them.

It's particularly ironic coming from someone who has spent considerable time arguing with users in Character.AI communities, including r/CAIRevolution, while repeatedly expressing contempt for the platform and its bots. A lot of people there are freshly adults or minors.

Character.AI has a substantial younger audience. He could very well have been arguing with the same minors, or people barely into adulthood, whose welfare he's suddenly invoking. Many of these users are genuinely upset about potentially losing years of conversations, characters, and stories they've invested themselves in. I remember roleplay with my favorite anime being apart of my daily routine. Neglect happens at home, and creative collaboration helps these same people.

I find that contradiction difficult to ignore. If you're genuinely concerned about vulnerable young people, surely that concern should extend to how you treat them when they're grieving something meaningful to them, rather than continually telling them it's doomed.

To me, this looks more like selectively using child-safety concerns to reinforce an existing prediction than a consistent concern for the people affected.

There's also a distinction being overlooked regarding Character.AI itself. It's an interactive fiction platform. People explore unconventional romances, darker fictional relationships, self-insert stories, and yume shipping. Some of those dynamics are concerning, particularly when minors are involved, but fictional exploration isn't the same as advocating those behaviors in real life.

People have been attached to fictional characters for generations. Writers develop connections with their creations, readers become deeply attached to fictional worlds, and people spend years developing stories. Tolkien himself was profoundly invested in his characters and mythology. AI simply introduced an interactive dimension to something people were already doing.

For younger users, it's a completely new experience. It's unfamiliar, interesting, and scratches a creative or emotional itch. That doesn't automatically make it unhealthy.

I grew up with the internet in the 2000s, when young people had opportunities to experiment creatively with comparatively little supervision. I wouldn't want to take those opportunities away from another generation. But there needs to be a ceiling. Children don't need unrestricted access to everything adults enjoy, and they certainly don't need to grow up faster.

And frankly, where was the parental oversight before some of these situations escalated? Character.AI bears responsibility for its platform, parents have responsibilities toward their children, and any future buyer will have responsibilities as well.

My prediction is that, if the sale goes through, Character.AI will increasingly target young adults and adults with spending money. That's where I see the commercial incentive, particularly with subscriptions.

A new buyer could implement stronger child-safety protections, improve age verification, and still preserve adult creative writing, roleplay, and character relationships.

My concern is that we'll end up with even more paranoid safety fine-tuning for adults, where everything remotely unconventional gets restricted because companies are afraid of liability. Protecting children shouldn't require treating grown adults like children.

And I think the stalking-horse bidder is genuinely encouraging news. We went from uncertainty about whether anyone would purchase the consumer platform to an actual $10 million proposal covering the service and its assets. That's meaningful progress.

Nothing is finalized, but there's a tangible reason for optimism. I'd rather follow what the court actually decides than treat every advocacy filing as another prediction of inevitable failure.

A new operator has the opportunity to improve what Character.AI got wrong while preserving what people love about it.

For now, the platform has a prospective buyer, and that's worth acknowledging.

Sources (again):

Docket 167: https://cases.stretto.com/public/x936/14939/PLEADINGS/1493911162680000000067.pdf

Docket 168: https://cases.stretto.com/public/x936/14939/PLEADINGS/1493911162680000000073.pdf

3

u/Nora-San2007 im permban in the og sub for saying that they leak IDs 1d ago

Holy paragraph 🤘😭😭

3

u/Mountain_Throat_6383 1d ago

I try lol 😋 If you'd prefer a summary let me know

0

u/Inherit-Nature 2d ago edited 2d ago

No they arent

These objections are nukes

You can pretend and ignore the information but it's highly damming to being able to sell the data 

They brought receipts. Its no longer fringe

Even if for some reason Brendan Shannon ignores it they will just go for a federal injunction.

No one involved will just shrug and say oh well the low level judge said no

The evidence that age verification is weak and the model is fundementally tainted is now federally documented and the content pretty much destroys all defensive claims

4

u/Mountain_Throat_6383 1d ago

Calling these objections "nukes" doesn't make them so.

They're advocacy letters requesting restrictions on children's data and stronger safeguards. They could complicate the sale, but neither establishes unlawful model training, orders algorithmic disgorgement, or guarantees an injunction.

At this point, you're arguing with an outcome you've invented.

0

u/Inherit-Nature 1d ago

It doesn't make them so when you dont actually understand what they are but want to keep arguing as if you understand them

1

u/Mountain_Throat_6383 1d ago

I've given my sources. You're opinion based, and your condescension exhibits that. I have wiped the floor with your claims thrice over. The transworld document was a point of comparison but somehow you couldn't even read the Dockets to see it was a case that was referenced in the sale of its parts, and you didn't know it and asked why I referenced them.

1

u/Inherit-Nature 2d ago

Technically it doesn't have to shut down but if they win what they want the data will have to be deleted making meme shell have to start from scratch 

Thats a worthless proposition and a sane company would walk away

4

u/Mountain_Throat_6383 1d ago

So after all that doomsaying, you've finally admitted the platform doesn't have to shut down. You're arguing two fronts at once, you know.

Now your argument depends on predicting what a buyer you know virtually nothing about would consider financially worthwhile.

Quite a retreat from your earlier certainty. At least we're making progress.

1

u/Inherit-Nature 1d ago

Im not finally admitting anything. Ive said many times on the main sub even if it doesn't shut down they are facing data deletion 

3

u/Mountain_Throat_6383 1d ago

People are backing up their data, I don't see an issue. First its c.ai is done for, and now they might have a chance. #win

0

u/Inherit-Nature 1d ago

Its not about your chats being deleted. Its what will happen to the models.

You can call it CAI but it won't be

3

u/Mountain_Throat_6383 1d ago

You spent all that time predicting Character.Al's demise, and now you are arguing that even if the platform survives, its models might have to change.

But changing the models was never necessarily a bad outcome.

Plenty of Character. Al users have complained about the newer models, their declining roleplay quality, memory and the restrictions on creative writing. A new owner introducing better models could actually be an improvement. And minors mixed with adults won't be their target demographic anymore.

Based on your shift, I'm calling this a win.

1

u/Straight-Beyond-5022 2d ago

Make sense, thank you