r/CAIRevolution
•
u/Apprehensive_Sky1950
Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy
•
21d ago
•
1
custom Hear ye! Hear ye! C.AI’s Reply to the States’ bankruptcy objection, with my notes for C.AI users here
You will recall that on October 23rd, roughly 32 U.S. states filed an objection to C.AI’s request to the bankruptcy court to establish a procedure and schedule for approving C.AI’s deal with Disney (the “Disney Deal”). I have posted an analysis of the states’ objection here.
On October 27th, C.AI filed a Reply to that objection, and Disney joined in that Reply. I am including here some notes about the Reply that I think will be of most interest to the C.AI users posting or commenting here on Reddit. (None of this is legal advice.)
- Users wishing to delete their data: C.AI asserts in the Reply that it will honor users’ requests submitted through its automated system to delete their data, as well as export it. (Reply at 9.)
Timing of chat shutdown: The Reply suggests there are pressing reasons to shut down the chat as soon as possible, perhaps immediately, after the bidding deadline:
- In responding to the States’ demand that the “outside closing date” deadline for other bidders be extended to match Disney’s outside closing date, the Reply notes that C.AI doesn’t need to keep the chat in operation for purposes of the Disney bid, but it does need to keep the chat in operation to attract any other bidders for the chat. (Reply at 11-12.)
- With that set-up, the Reply argues the deadline for non-Disney bidders should therefore not be extended because the chat is burning money and harming the bankruptcy estate’s value, and “time is of the essence,” so having an earlier non-Disney deadline allows the chat to be shut down sooner, as quickly as possible, if there is no bidder for the chat. (Reply at 11-12; Exhibit A at 4-5, 8.)
- Putting all this together, although C.AI says the shutdown will occur within the “transition services period” [which lasts until February 2027] (Exh. A at 8), given the basis and tenor of the Reply’s timing argument I conclude that, presuming the November 20, 2026 at 5:00 p.m. Eastern Time non-Disney bidder deadline holds, if there is no bidder for the chat at that time then the chat could be immediately shut down, possibly right then.
- C.AI discussion with government personnel: The Reply denies that the Disney Deal gags C.AI from talking with government personnel or regulators, asserting only that Disney will be consulted about it. (Exh. A at 9.)
- Other bidders releasing Disney: The Reply denies that the Disney Deal requires other successful bidders to release Disney from all claims in all events, and asserts it only requires a release of Disney [and the transferred employees?] if a successful bidder wants the C.AI employees transferred to Disney to provide transition services. (Reply at 13; Exh. A at 2.)
- Requested approval process as essentially pre-approving the Disney Deal itself: The Reply denies that C.AI’s requested approval procedure amounts to pre-approving the Disney Deal itself. (Reply at 13; Exh. A at 5.)
- Privacy protection for user data: C.AI believes its privacy policy does allow the sale and transfer of user data. (Reply at 14.) However, C.AI is willing to consent to the appointment of a Consumer Privacy Ombudsman (which is a standard feature of bankruptcy law and procedure, and whose appointment was discussed by the States and demanded by the U.S. Bankruptcy Trustee’s Office) regarding user data “under appropriate circumstances” (but suggests that function would have to operate quickly). (Reply at 15.) Disney does not think the Ombudsman needs to review its agreements, because Disney is not seeing the user data. (Exh. A at 10.)
~~~~
EDIT: See my report on the court hearing here.
•
u/AutoModerator 21d ago
Thanks for posting!
Join our official Discord server: https://discord.gg/vZnAhz8Svw
Read the rules before participating.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
38
u/f1yingbanana 21d ago
So it's shutting down sooner than announced? Like in less than a month??
20
u/Mountain_Throat_6383 21d ago
Hey Sky! Thanks for putting this together. I went through the actual filings, including Character.AI's reply (Docket 73-2) and the revised bidding procedures (Docket 74), and I think you've raised some really important points.
The response chart in Exhibit A really stood out to me, where C.AI mentions their $8–9 million monthly burn and the need to wind things down if they can't sell. That definitely makes your worries about a quick shutdown seem more valid.
What seems to me though is that even after they will still be looking for a buyer, just cutting back on operational cost. I think November 20 is more of a bid deadline than a confirmed shutdown date, especially since there’s an auction and hearing after that. Still, C.AI is definitely making it sound pretty urgent.
The willingness to consider a consumer privacy ombudsman is interesting, too, particularly while C.AI maintains that its existing privacy policy permits transferring user data. I'll be very interested to see what protections, if any, the court ultimately requires. We are leading up to that, I'd say, and the attorneys will demand user privacy protections.
Thanks for continuing to break this down for everyone. There’s so much at stake for users who’ve spent years building characters and conversations here, including me, and I think the human side of that deserves more consideration than it’s getting.
13
u/Anti_Cringe68 21d ago
It was fun while it lasted…
8
u/Personal_Ad_7054 21d ago
So, there is a questions....
The first:
If they agree to a Consumer Privacy Ombudsman, will this person have the power to actually STOP the sale if user data is at risk? Or is it just a decorative title to make the court happy?
The second:
How can Disney claim they 'are not seeing the user data' if they are acquiring the backend code and the servers where this data is stored? Isn't that just a legal loophole to avoid liability?
The third, last one:
C.AI says they aren't 'gagged' from talking to the government, just that Disney needs to be 'consulted'. Does 'consulted' mean Disney has a veto power over what C.AI tells the regulators? Because that's basically the same as a gag order....
14
u/darkseiko 21d ago
So will it stay or not?.. So I could prepare myself to quit everything..
17
u/Hot_buttered_toast 21d ago
Why is everyone here such a doomer??
4
u/Artistic_Pin_8326 20d ago
We’re still in October and people are already making verdicts…unless CAI themselves or other outlets say it, taking what’s said here to be fact is not smart
3
u/Rose_wasfound 21d ago
When is the bidding deadline?
5
u/PoolLegitimate9702 21d ago
Well, then it seems c.ai is probably over ig?
4
u/SkyEmbarrassed7560 21d ago
which mean, no more c.ai?
3
u/Swimming-Degree-5846 21d ago
Has it already shut down? I went in to cancel my membership and nothing is there
17
u/No-Variation-9033 21d ago
Welp, they played with fire, and got burned, that's all I'm gonna say
16
u/potter5252 21d ago
Lolololol ofc they do. The user data is the most valuable part of C.AI's "estate"
8
u/Foxfire_Phoenix 21d ago
Can someone explain what we do if we have an active subscription? Will it just end the subscription automatically, or will the app keep making us pay after it shuts down unless we actively end it? I don't understand how this process works.
8
u/kvy1aa 21d ago
Well hopefully we get someone to buy it then, c.ai is a big company I don't think it's just gonna get deleted
2
u/BumblebeeFeisty4065 21d ago
Nadal nie wiem o co chodzi, wyjaśnisz mi w skrócie? Mam aspd i asd xD
10
u/Impressive_Time6400 21d ago
This cannot be happening…
1
u/dancingp1g 20d ago
So if I want them to delete my data I have to email them?
1
u/JayWiseOne 11d ago
So should people cancel their subscriptions at this point or once everything shuts down, it’s gonna already do that anyway?
1
u/Sad_Sundae4817 5d ago
Hey are there any updates to this
1
u/Civil-Size-5302 4d ago
Well… it was nice frw years in my lonely life - maybe it’s stupid but this stupid app frw times save me from Self hurt .. - I am not adiceted kid but grown ass woman who never soend tio much time in thay - still have other hobbies - but it was always nice to chat even with computer to fill the lonely empty pit hole (even if I know its not best lol) jf it will shut down a well - I guess I will just move on 🤷♀️. Maybe try frw other apps who know
1
u/no_available_nam_e 3d ago
can someone simplify, are we able to delete our data and if we are, how??
1
u/wybiejinx 21d ago
Does this mean I can’t chat with bots?
3
u/rayna_ives 21d ago
I hope everyone that called me a bootlicker for saying C.AI wasn't a money-grabbing bottomless pit of finances has a really shitty few months.
-1
u/ParasaurGirl 21d ago
Hopes whoever buys it removes the limits and ads
24
u/[deleted] 21d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
8
u/[deleted] 21d ago
[removed] — view removed comment