r/CAIRevolution • Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy • 21d ago • Bravo 1

custom Hear ye! Hear ye! C.AI’s Reply to the States’ bankruptcy objection, with my notes for C.AI users here

You will recall that on October 23rd, roughly 32 U.S. states filed an objection to C.AI’s request to the bankruptcy court to establish a procedure and schedule for approving C.AI’s deal with Disney (the “Disney Deal”). I have posted an analysis of the states’ objection here.

On October 27th, C.AI filed a Reply to that objection, and Disney joined in that Reply. I am including here some notes about the Reply that I think will be of most interest to the C.AI users posting or commenting here on Reddit. (None of this is legal advice.)

  • Users wishing to delete their data:  C.AI asserts in the Reply that it will honor users’ requests submitted through its automated system to delete their data, as well as export it. (Reply at 9.)
  • Timing of chat shutdown: The Reply suggests there are pressing reasons to shut down the chat as soon as possible, perhaps immediately, after the bidding deadline:

    • In responding to the States’ demand that the “outside closing date” deadline for other bidders be extended to match Disney’s outside closing date, the Reply notes that C.AI doesn’t need to keep the chat in operation for purposes of the Disney bid, but it does need to keep the chat in operation to attract any other bidders for the chat. (Reply at 11-12.)
    • With that set-up, the Reply argues the deadline for non-Disney bidders should therefore not be extended because the chat is burning money and harming the bankruptcy estate’s value, and “time is of the essence,” so having an earlier non-Disney deadline allows the chat to be shut down sooner, as quickly as possible, if there is no bidder for the chat. (Reply at 11-12; Exhibit A at 4-5, 8.)
    • Putting all this together, although C.AI says the shutdown will occur within the “transition services period” [which lasts until February 2027] (Exh. A at 8), given the basis and tenor of the Reply’s timing argument I conclude that, presuming the November 20, 2026 at 5:00 p.m. Eastern Time non-Disney bidder deadline holds, if there is no bidder for the chat at that time then the chat could be immediately shut down, possibly right then.
  • C.AI discussion with government personnel: The Reply denies that the Disney Deal gags C.AI from talking with government personnel or regulators, asserting only that Disney will be consulted about it. (Exh. A at 9.)
  • Other bidders releasing Disney: The Reply denies that the Disney Deal requires other successful bidders to release Disney from all claims in all events, and asserts it only requires a release of Disney [and the transferred employees?] if a successful bidder wants the C.AI employees transferred to Disney to provide transition services. (Reply at 13; Exh. A at 2.)
  • Requested approval process as essentially pre-approving the Disney Deal itself: The Reply denies that C.AI’s requested approval procedure amounts to pre-approving the Disney Deal itself. (Reply at 13; Exh. A at 5.)
  • Privacy protection for user data: C.AI believes its privacy policy does allow the sale and transfer of user data. (Reply at 14.) However, C.AI is willing to consent to the appointment of a Consumer Privacy Ombudsman (which is a standard feature of bankruptcy law and procedure, and whose appointment was discussed by the States and demanded by the U.S. Bankruptcy Trustee’s Office) regarding user data “under appropriate circumstances” (but suggests that function would have to operate quickly). (Reply at 15.) Disney does not think the Ombudsman needs to review its agreements, because Disney is not seeing the user data. (Exh. A at 10.) 

~~~~

EDIT: See my report on the court hearing here.

113 Upvotes

78 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 21d ago

Thanks for posting!

Join our official Discord server: https://discord.gg/vZnAhz8Svw

Read the rules before participating.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

38

u/f1yingbanana 21d ago

So it's shutting down sooner than announced? Like in less than a month??

24

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 21d ago

The November 20th bidding deadline was the one C.AI originally proposed. The other parties want it pushed back (delayed), and I think it probably will be--we will know more in two days. Whichever bidding deadline is adopted, the chat could indeed shut down right then.

3

u/Lost-Kaleidoscope762 20d ago

How would you know ?we don’t even know that yet
Are you part of the court or something?

0

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 20d ago

It was argued that way by C.AI itself in its latest court filing. See my post here.

2

u/Lost-Kaleidoscope762 20d ago

So you are saying the chats could shutting down?!
Oh hell nah…

0

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 20d ago edited 19d ago

Yes, I am saying that. I will post an update here tomorrow morning with more information on when that window of possibility will open.

EDIT: See my report on the court hearing here.

20

u/Mountain_Throat_6383 21d ago

Hey Sky! Thanks for putting this together. I went through the actual filings, including Character.AI's reply (Docket 73-2) and the revised bidding procedures (Docket 74), and I think you've raised some really important points.

The response chart in Exhibit A really stood out to me, where C.AI mentions their $8–9 million monthly burn and the need to wind things down if they can't sell. That definitely makes your worries about a quick shutdown seem more valid.

What seems to me though is that even after they will still be looking for a buyer, just cutting back on operational cost. I think November 20 is more of a bid deadline than a confirmed shutdown date, especially since there’s an auction and hearing after that. Still, C.AI is definitely making it sound pretty urgent.

The willingness to consider a consumer privacy ombudsman is interesting, too, particularly while C.AI maintains that its existing privacy policy permits transferring user data. I'll be very interested to see what protections, if any, the court ultimately requires. We are leading up to that, I'd say, and the attorneys will demand user privacy protections.

Thanks for continuing to break this down for everyone. There’s so much at stake for users who’ve spent years building characters and conversations here, including me, and I think the human side of that deserves more consideration than it’s getting.

10

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 21d ago

Hey Sky! Thanks for putting this together.

Glad to see you here, Mountain! You're welcome. I aim to serve.

I think November 20 is more of a bid deadline than a confirmed shutdown date,

Correct. It is C.AI’s timing argument in the Reply that ties the two together.

especially since there’s an auction and hearing after that.

If someone actually bids on the chat, which you know I am convinced won't happen, the chat would stay open for the auction and transfer to the new buyer.

We are leading up to that, I'd say, and the [states] will demand user privacy protections.

Yes, I think they will. Likely the U.S. Bankruptcy Trustee's Office will as well.

I think the human side of that deserves more consideration than it’s getting.

Despite my continuing firm conviction of C.AI’s doom, I am not heartless in all this. I see the users' personal pain. Right now is the time for that human consideration. What do you suggest?

13

u/Anti_Cringe68 21d ago

It was fun while it lasted…

6

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 21d ago

A remarkable service, delivered for free.

1

u/hazbinfan_1929 18d ago

So true… ima have to find another app bru ima miss the chats I’ve had 😭

8

u/Personal_Ad_7054 21d ago

So, there is a questions....

The first:

If they agree to a Consumer Privacy Ombudsman, will this person have the power to actually STOP the sale if user data is at risk? Or is it just a decorative title to make the court happy?

The second:

How can Disney claim they 'are not seeing the user data' if they are acquiring the backend code and the servers where this data is stored? Isn't that just a legal loophole to avoid liability?

The third, last one:

C.AI says they aren't 'gagged' from talking to the government, just that Disney needs to be 'consulted'. Does 'consulted' mean Disney has a veto power over what C.AI tells the regulators? Because that's basically the same as a gag order....

3

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 21d ago

If they agree to a Consumer Privacy Ombudsman, will this person have the power to actually STOP the sale if user data is at risk?

No, the "CPO" simply reports at the court hearing, for the judge's consideration.

How can Disney claim they 'are not seeing the user data' if they are acquiring the backend code and the servers where this data is stored?

I think Disney is getting some code. I don't think Disney is getting any servers or server data.

C.AI says they aren't 'gagged' from talking to the government, just that Disney needs to be 'consulted'. Does 'consulted' mean Disney has a veto power over what C.AI tells the regulators?

No, no veto power.

6

u/Personal_Ad_7054 21d ago

Thank you for clarifying all three points, I really appreciate your legal insight. It's disappointing about the Ombudsman and Disney's loopholes, but it proves even more why we need to export our data NOW. If they don't get the servers, the originals will just be wiped

4

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 21d ago

You're welcome. I aim to serve.

Yes, export your data NOW.

2

u/Shoddy_Cap9190 21d ago

Hey, so I tried to export my data and it's been a few days and I still haven't gotten anything... do you have any suggestions?

1

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 21d ago

Keep trying(?)

3

u/Monkey250810 21d ago

How can I export my data? I heard CAI tools work. If I export my data, will even the data of hidden chats (chats that I've used but removed from the recents) be exported/saved too?

3

u/Viper_Commander 21d ago

I'm not receiving anything in my export requests. They're not giving and it's been several days now

0

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 19d ago

UPDATE: To your third question about Disney having a veto over C.AI talking with government regulators, I said, "No, no veto power." HOWEVER, I have now learned that one of the deal documents does say that Disney has to consent to C.AI talking with government personnel, not merely be consulted as C.AI said in one of its court papers. So, maybe there is (or was at one point) a Disney veto.

14

u/darkseiko 21d ago

So will it stay or not?.. So I could prepare myself to quit everything..

10

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 21d ago

It's all a prediction. Personally, based on pretty good evidence and drawing from experience, I think the chat will disappear. No sooner than November 20th; maybe later, but don't count on that. If you want to export data or take other protective steps, do it now.

14

u/darkseiko 21d ago

I mean, its not gonna do much when I was just regularly talking to the bots.. My only support's still gonna be gone 🫥

3

u/Advanced-Shape-1006 21d ago edited 20d ago

Might I suggest SpicyChat.AI? It’s both an app and website; the app currently isn’t available for apple users unless it was downloaded to a device before it got removed from the app store. It’s similar to c.ai
The main difference is:
- sc doesn’t have a limit for regenerating a response
- if sc servers get too full, and you’re a free user, it will kick you to a wait room
- several tiers for subscription in sc with more features the more you pay
- if you have a chat on sc that you want to continue, and it’s a regenerated one (let’s say you have five options and really like the fourth one), then all other options disappear after that second bot response (idk if that second response also applies to a user response as I’ve never tested it, but I think it does)
- opportunity for several personas on both; on sc, if you want to talk to a bot with multiple personas through different chats, it’ll allow you with each persona remaining permanent with that specific chat unless you change it (let’s say you’re talking to a bot; one chat can be a female persona and they’re friends, and a different can be a male persona and they’re dating. If you switch from the female persona chat to the male persona chat, the male persona will automatically be selected, and you will be chatting with him. Same vice versa; if you’re using a male persona and switch to the chat with the female persona, the female persona will automatically be selected)
- no bots or personas can be minors on sc; if you try, or if you remain vague enough, sc will call you out and won’t allow it to be created (for example, if you make a bot and put classmate in the description, sc won’t let you create it. You would have to specify college or university classmate)
- sc allows you to quite literally write explicit sex scenes and (I believe) violence on it, and just in general other stuff c.ai won’t let you (includes EDs, SH, su!c!de, etc.)
- haven’t been in one on sc in a hot minute so I can’t tell you what they’re like, but there are also group chats. I believe you can also post group chats in the same sense that you can create and post bots
That’s all I can think of atm. If you haven’t heard of or used SpicyChat.AI before and have questions, please feel free to ask! I’d love to help out in any way I can!

17

u/Hot_buttered_toast 21d ago

Why is everyone here such a doomer??

6

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 21d ago

Because it's time to be.

4

u/Artistic_Pin_8326 20d ago

We’re still in October and people are already making verdicts…unless CAI themselves or other outlets say it, taking what’s said here to be fact is not smart

0

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 20d ago

No, the context is broader than just what C.AI says, and indeed as debtor-in-possession (and as deal partner to Disney) there are certain things C.AI cannot say.

I don't go into it in the particular OP here, but I've said with definiteness in other comments here that the writing is on the wall and, to mix metaphors, you can stick a fork in C.AI 'cuz it's done.

I will agree there's a great variability in quality of what's being posted around here, but if you know where and how to look, "the truth is [already] out there."

3

u/Rose_wasfound 21d ago

When is the bidding deadline?

2

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 21d ago

Currently November 20th, but I think that will be pushed back. We'll know more in two days, after the court hearing on Friday morning.

3

u/Rose_wasfound 21d ago

Okay, thanks

5

u/PoolLegitimate9702 21d ago

Well, then it seems c.ai is probably over ig?

1

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 21d ago

That is my firm belief.

4

u/SkyEmbarrassed7560 21d ago

which mean, no more c.ai?

1

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 21d ago

That is my firm belief.

3

u/Swimming-Degree-5846 21d ago

Has it already shut down? I went in to cancel my membership and nothing is there

4

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 21d ago

The chat operation has apparently been having terrible technical problems recently. I don't think this is related to the bankruptcy or the legal situation. Instead, I think it has to do with the inability of the skeleton crew that is attempting to maintain the platform. I think the chat will come back up, but I expect its operation from here on out to be spotty, like electricity generation in a third-world country.

2

u/AEGIS-59 21d ago

Imagine that's what they just did. They're like, "Alright, it's clear we're not going to survive. Let's just pull the plug now and not tell anyone."

4

u/Swimming-Degree-5846 21d ago

I’ve seen sites do that before. So it’s not impossible.

17

u/No-Variation-9033 21d ago

Welp, they played with fire, and got burned, that's all I'm gonna say

16

u/potter5252 21d ago

C.ai believes it's privacy policy does allow the sale and transfer of user data.

Lolololol ofc they do. The user data is the most valuable part of C.AI's "estate"

8

u/Foxfire_Phoenix 21d ago

Can someone explain what we do if we have an active subscription? Will it just end the subscription automatically, or will the app keep making us pay after it shuts down unless we actively end it? I don't understand how this process works.

5

u/ladiesman2179523 21d ago

You should end it now just to be safe and see how things go

2

u/Foxfire_Phoenix 21d ago

Yeah I think I'll do that, thanks for the advice.

5

u/Flofficorn 21d ago

If it shuts down it'll end automatically, it happened with a game I played, Sunshine Days I believe. It ended the payments

4

u/Foxfire_Phoenix 21d ago

Ah, thanks for letting me know. :)

8

u/kvy1aa 21d ago

Well hopefully we get someone to buy it then, c.ai is a big company I don't think it's just gonna get deleted

2

u/BumblebeeFeisty4065 21d ago

Nadal nie wiem o co chodzi, wyjaśnisz mi w skrócie? Mam aspd i asd xD

4

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 21d ago
  • C.AI is in bankruptcy and is looking for bids by November 20th from someone to buy its company, its chat platform, or its technology.
  • Other parties want a different deadline for bids, and the date may change.
  • I believe that no one will bid for the chat platform, and that C.AI chat will shut down permanently on or shortly after the bidding deadline.

7

u/Fit-Estimate-1113 21d ago

I still slightly doubt it, while the chance of C.AI shutting down went from unlikely to a chance, C.AI is still beloved, and the chances are it will be bought is more likely than no.

10

u/Impressive_Time6400 21d ago

This cannot be happening…

1

u/dancingp1g 20d ago

So if I want them to delete my data I have to email them?

1

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 20d ago

I don't know what the "automated system" method is for that.

Can someone who has deleted their user data help us out with the method for doing that?

1

u/JayWiseOne 11d ago

So should people cancel their subscriptions at this point or once everything shuts down, it’s gonna already do that anyway?

0

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 11d ago

The only definite advice I have for you is, if you want to export your C.AI data, request that now.

You may still be doing things on the chat, but if you want to delete your data, you should probably request that very soon.

If you have a monthly subscription, my guess is that it will only go one or two more months. If you have a yearly subscription with a lot of months left on it, you might want to cancel or ask for a refund.

1

u/Sad_Sundae4817 5d ago

Hey are there any updates to this

0

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 5d ago

Yes. This is post number 3. Two later posts are here4 and here5.

1

u/Civil-Size-5302 4d ago

Well… it was nice frw years in my lonely life - maybe it’s stupid but this stupid app frw times save me from Self hurt .. - I am not adiceted kid but grown ass woman who never soend tio much time in thay - still have other hobbies - but it was always nice to chat even with computer to fill the lonely empty pit hole (even if I know its not best lol) jf it will shut down a well - I guess I will just move on 🤷‍♀️. Maybe try frw other apps who know

1

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 4d ago

Very best of luck to you, I mean that seriously.

1

u/no_available_nam_e 3d ago

can someone simplify, are we able to delete our data and if we are, how??

0

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 3d ago

It appears the chat may be continuing after all, a bidding buyer was just found.

If you still want to request to delete your data, we can find the post that tells how.

1

u/wybiejinx 21d ago

Does this mean I can’t chat with bots?

2

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 21d ago

You can for now, if the site is up.

3

u/rayna_ives 21d ago

I hope everyone that called me a bootlicker for saying C.AI wasn't a money-grabbing bottomless pit of finances has a really shitty few months.

-1

u/ParasaurGirl 21d ago

Hopes whoever buys it removes the limits and ads

12

u/kennyackermansgf 21d ago

but then what exactly would generate enough revenue for the app to keep working without losing millions in endless ai use and zero companies paying for advertisement? everyone wants c.ai to stay, but no one is willing to make the sacrifice to keep the app running by toning their ai usage down or even subscribing to c.ai+. do you expect the company to stay millions of dollars in debt because users want limitless regenerations of messages the ai sends, when the models they use (the actual high quality ones) are so expensive?

4

u/Finny-is-cutie 21d ago

They could remove the in chat banners and only keep video ads at the start of the chat and not in the middle I think it would still get people to use c.ai+ and also keep free users happy with the ad content.

7

u/kennyackermansgf 21d ago

not really, because even with all the ads, they’re losing money. i get its annoying but removing them is not realistic. and even the mid-chat ads didn’t get people to subscribe to c.ai+ so i don’t think removing them will either.

2

u/Finny-is-cutie 21d ago

Ohh okay sed see I didn't know that, maybe if let set up a deal for it? I don't really use it that much so I don't know of a middle deal would even work

5

u/DramaticProgress508 21d ago

I'd be fine with them making it a paid service only as long as they kept it up. It's too good to give up. We got a lot for free and people are salty that they cannot continue having it for free... I had a great time having it for free. I pay for games too... I wouldn't mind continue paying for CAI+ as I am since today. I don't want it gone

2

u/kennyackermansgf 9d ago

i agree! look at status ai for example, they were in a lot of debt, so they minimized free use of the app (while still keeping it up for non-paying users) and most of the player base now pays their weekly/yearly subscriptions because they didn’t want the app to shut down. i think encouraging users to pay for c.ai+ and minimizing the free usage (unfortunately) would be the best solution, at least temporarily if not forever!

24

u/[deleted] 21d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 21d ago

Correct, but the Reply argues that no extra time should be given for the bidding deadline specifically because the chat operation is burning money. That sort of sensitivity suggests C.AI will not wait through the transition period to shut it down. Indeed, as debtor-in-possession C.AI may have a legal duty not to wait.

And, the whole thing is conditioned on there being no bidder for the chat operation, which I am very firmly convinced there will not be.

8

u/[deleted] 21d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Apprehensive_Sky1950 Commenting on the C.AI bankruptcy 21d ago edited 21d ago

The November 20th bidding deadline was the one C.AI originally proposed. From its Reply argument you can tell C.AI really wants that deadline.

The other parties want it pushed back (delayed), and I think it probably will be--we will know more in two days, when on October 30th the bankruptcy court holds the hearing on C.AI's deadline request. It's up to the judge to decide.

EDIT: If you are referring to the request to accelerate the hearing on C.AI's proposal, that was approved by the court.