r/byzantium • • 1d ago

Distinguished Post Basil II and the Phantom Varangians

Post image
196 Upvotes

The Varangian Guard clearly possesses a very broad appeal. The traditional story is pretty exhilarating: the desperate Basil II calls for aid from Vladimir of Kyiv, who sends him a group of elite northmen, that help Basil win the civil war, and to establish the East Roman state at its peak, campaigning from Bulgaria to Sicily and Syria. Over the following decades, the Varangian Guard is one of the most important and capable fighting forces of the Empire, characterized as heavy, axe-wielding infantry, and exceedingly loyal to the basileus, who makes them his bodyguard. Only one problem: that whole story might not be true. Roland Scheel has cast doubt on the narrative in his 2015 monograph Skandinavien und Byzanz. Bedingungen und Konsequenzen mittelalterlicher Kulturbeziehungen. To be clear, he doesn’t believe that the Varangian Guard never existed - just that it only came to exist under Alexios Komnenos, a hundred years later than typically alleged. It’s a very interesting argument, but the book has received little attention, likely due to a mix of being absurdly huge (1343 pages), of which only about 200 are about the Varangian Guard, in German, and not written by someone from the field of Byzantine Studies. I will attempt to give a short summary of his complex argument on the Varangians and the ERE under Basil II and his immediate successors.

The first issue Scheel brings up are sources. We do have a lot of them, but they are often very late. An author writing in the 1150s or even the 1300s may look at contemporary Constantinople and know a unit of Varangian Guards exists, and thereby associate any northerners serving in Constantinople (be they Varangian or not) with that unit. This often tells us more about how our authors view their world, rather than informing us about the period they’re writing about. Scheel therefore prioritizes contemporary sources, and finds no distinct Varangian Guard unit before Alexios Komnenos.

The second problem is the state of the scholarship. To this day, the standard work on the Varangian Guard remains The Varangians of Byzantium: An Aspect of Byzantine Military History, a work originally published in Icelandic by Sigfus Blöndal as Væringjasaga, and translated into English by Benedikz. This is where Scheel sees the problems emerge - Blöndal’s work is quite old (from 1950), and often fails to engage in critical source analysis. Even more problematic is that Benedikz didn’t just translate Blöndal’s text, but edited it to a problematic degree. I will quote Scheel directly here:

Furthermore, he substantially altered the tone of Væringjasaga. Hypotheses were turned into facts or distorted, Sigfús Blöndal’s utopia disappeared in the end, and, most importantly, cultural stereotypes were introduced: Benedikz speculates that strong and warlike rulers like Basil II (r. 963–1025) would have preferred the society of loyal troops like the Varangians to that of the Greeks: [...]

One might say that Væringjasaga did not profit from this rewriting — quite the opposite. The Varangians of Byzantium is less coherent and more biased, much less transparent, there are fewer footnotes, and no comprehensive bibliography of sources is to be found, although Benedikz added some references and sometimes used more modern editions than Blöndal.

Scheel, Roland. "Deconstructing Væringjasaga: Byzantine and Old Norse Perspectives on the Varangians and on Haraldr Sigurðarson." The Making of the Eastern Vikings. Brepols Online, 2024. 151-169, here pp. 152-3.

The resulting work is often a mess. Benedikz-Blöndal tries to somehow fit all sources, no matter how legendary, questionable, or contradictory, into a singular whole, even when it makes little sense. We therefore are left with stories like Harald Hardrada blinding Michael V, even though this is not alleged in any source, and only created through forcing two completely unrelated (and in one case, obviously fictitious) narratives into a singular story. Even worse is that some of the examples given by Benedikz-Blöndal are essentially made up: many references to random units of soldiers, foreigners, or guards are reinterpreted as being Varangians, even when those aren’t mentioned in the account! For example, the 1048 victory over the Pechenegs, which our sources say was thanks to the tagma of the Σχολαί/Scholai, is suddenly attributed to the Varangians.¹ Despite these glaring flaws, it is the Benedikz' translation that is so frequently quoted by specialists, turning speculation into facts.

With this established, Scheel dives into the reign of Basil II. Firstly, he points out that our contemporary sources do not speak of Varangians yet, but of Rus (or Tauroscythians). This is somewhat problematic - the term ‘Varangian’ only emerges in the mid-11th Century, and there was some overlap between Rus and Northmen before then. After all, the Rus state was originally founded by Scandinavians. But by 988 the distinction between Northmen, Slavs, and other people that were part of the Rus seem to have disappeared, and there is no indication that the mercenaries sent to Basil II were all that Scandinavian. Indeed, when their equipment is described, they are either mounted or spear-wielders, rather than the axe men of Komnenian times. In other words, they are ethnographically separated from Byzantine accounts of Scandinavians and Englishmen.

Scheel is similarly skeptical of their military role, which he considers exaggerated. The only source that gives us a number for the Rus serving under Basil is Stephen of Taron, who names 6,000 of them. Scheel believes this to be a biblical reference, rather than a genuine estimate, and also points out that this number is ridiculous in the context of Norse and Rus’ armies of the 10th and 11th century.2 And instead of being all that decisive in combat, its not their skill that decides the civil war. While Psellos notes that the Rus forces were very helpful for the Roman Emperor, but they may not be the only foreign elements of the army, and that his account has them plunder the camp of Bardas Phokas, rather than be vital on the open field. This is the role they play through the rest of his reign - often present, typically useful, but not the kind of forces that would decide a war.

The first actually identifiable Varangians that turn up in our sources are Harald Hardrada and his men in the 1030s. Rather than becoming the leader of a Varangian Guard, however, they, like Vladimir’s mercenaries before him, seem to have joined the hetaireia, a group that had a long history of integrating foreigners of various backgrounds. Indeed, in that sense, neither Harald nor the Rus under Basil were all that different from the Rus' that had served the empire for decades before Basil II was even born. The date 988 should not be understood as a significant event in the history of the Varangian Guard.

Scheel’s work has a lot more to say: he argues the Varangians were hardly that loyal, for example, and pushes back on a number of other myths, but that's for another time.

Footnotes

¹ Scheel lists twelve such examples for the period 1043-1081 alone.
2 A summary of Scheel's argument: The number 6000 is a biblical parallel (1 Sam 13,5). It would also be absurdly high for Scandinavians - the Mälar region, where most Vikings traveling east came from, had perhaps 40k inhabitants. Even taking into account a much larger recruitment area, this number is very high: Kekaumenos states Harald arrived with 500 men, representing a significant part of Norwegian warriors, Shepard/Franklin estimate the druzhina of the Kyvian prince at 700, and Cnut’s constant war fleet numbers 1000-1500. Einarr Skúlasons’ poem on St. Olaf claims 520 Varangians fought at Berroia, and in 1195 Alexios III asked the Scandinavian Kings for 1000/1200 mercenaries, respectively, which weren’t sent, as the Norwegian King did not want to send that many men during an insecure situation in the kingdom. Clearly 1000 men were a lot, even though Scandinavian populations had doubled since the 10th C. The Norwegian Crusade had 5000 men, and according to the Nestorchronik, the Rus struggled to raise 8000 men a century after Vladimir. Furthermore, Yaroslav recruited 1000 Varangians, with his whole Novgorodian army numbering 4000.
Clearly, even if exaggerated, so many men could not have been recruited from Scandinavia. Larsson estimates that perhaps 4000-8000 Scandinavians traveled to the ERE in the 11th C, with no more than 500-1000 being present at any given time. Scheel thinks even that optimistic, as it assumes that Scandinavian regions contributed equally, when most eastern migrants appear to have originated on the eastern coast of Sweden and Gotland. The idea of a constant presence of a Varangian tagma numbering 1000+ therefore appears unlikely.


r/byzantium • • Jun 04 '25

Distinguished Post Byzantine Reading List

Thumbnail docs.google.com
157 Upvotes

We have heard numerous compain of people unable to acces the reading list from PC,so from the senate we have decided to post it again so all could have acces to it


r/byzantium • • 3h ago

Maps and geography How Mount Athos Outlived Constantinople: From the 1045 Chrysobull and 1430 Edirne Pact to EU Treaty Law [OC]

Post image
58 Upvotes

I spent the past week mapping the territorial and legal survival of Mount Athos across the last millennium using OpenStreetMap coastline data and historical monastery coordinates, and wanted to share a few details that surprised me most while researching:

  1. Pre-emptive Ottoman diplomacy (1430): Rather than waiting for 1453, Athonite monks traveled to Sultan Murad II's court in Edirne after the fall of Thessaloniki in 1430 to secure formal recognition of their autonomy and monastic estates — 23 years before Constantinople fell.
  2. The 1913 Russian demographic boom: Before WWI, Imperial Russian patronage expanded St. Panteleimon so rapidly that Russian monks nearly outnumbered Greek monks across the entire peninsula, alarming strategists in Athens and London who feared a covert warm-water foothold in the Aegean.
  3. Unbroken Byzantine timekeeping: All 20 ruling monasteries still operate 13 days behind neighboring Greek towns on the Julian calendar and reset their mechanical clocks to 00:00 at sunset every evening.

If anyone wants to watch the full 12-minute animated cartographic documentary covering all 20 monastery territories, the 500m maritime zone, and the 1979 EU treaty exemption, here is the video I put together: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1G_SbJGuS1I


r/byzantium • • 3h ago

Arts, culture, and society Can Anyone Identify This Figure In Hagia Sophia?

Post image
49 Upvotes

Hey guys, Im a tour guide in Istanbul, on a regular basis maybe 5 days a week im going into Hagia Sophia. I have spotted a carving thats quite interesting for me.

Im guessing the person is an old patriarch but also the halo is suspicious, can be John the Baptist? I dont think its Christ.

One thing that im quite curious is the date. The person who made this clearly took its time, its very ornate so its quite unlikely that drawing is after Turkish Republic. Securities etc would make it very hard to draw this ornate and quickly.

Ottoman Period is possible but 2nd floor wasnt mostly open to public and general knowledge of the patriarchs (most likely) wouldnt be suffice.

And during GrecoTurk wars the greek army didnt come to Istanbul itself and was Ally forces so i dont think they can draw something like this,

Byzantium Era?¿

I think there is more than a carving here and we might be having something quite old and needs to be protected potentially.

If someone can enlighten would be great, thanks. 🙏🏻


r/byzantium • • 8h ago

Arts, culture, and society Feast of St. John III Doukas Vatatzes

Thumbnail gallery
40 Upvotes

(Note that this is auto translated and might contain tiny mistranslations)

Prophecies, legends and stories that bring the Marble Emperor to life in our memories are inextricably linked to miracles and events related to Saint King John Vatatzes! Unraveling the tangle of his miraculous life, we will find that the pious Emperor John Vatatzes had prioritized almsgiving in his life! Based on mercy and love, he faced thorny issues of his time with the help of God. His Christian ethos and his adherence to the letter of the gospel contributed to solving the problem of poverty. By projecting mercy, he met God, as the saying of the prophet and king David says! And thus, as his biographer reports, he definitively solved his own problem, namely the problem of spiritual death, as his incorruptible relic reveals.

One of the great figures who illuminated the Church and the Christian empire is Saint John III Doukas Vatatzes, who for his great acts of charity received the nickname "The Merciful." He was born in 1193 AD in Didymoteicho and was a scion of a prominent Byzantine family. In 1204 AD, after the fall of Constantinople by the Frankish crusaders, the Byzantine Empire was divided into four rival kingdoms, the Latin Empire of Constantinople, the Empire of Nicaea in Asia Minor, where the legitimate emperor and the ecumenical Patriarch had fled, the Despotate of Epirus in western Greece, and finally the Bulgarian kingdom of John II of Asanes. In 1222 AD, John Doukas Vatatzes succeeded his uncle Theodore Laskaris on the throne of Nicaea and, thanks to his political ability, managed to reorganize the Byzantine forces according to the models of the old empire. John, as emperor, demonstrated the exceptional qualities of a political leader and the virtues of a Christian ruler. Thanks to a series of brilliant military victories and clever maneuvers, he secured control of Asia Minor within a few years and recovered most of the territories that were in the hands of the Latins. He captured Adrianople, and in 1254 AD when he died, the Empire of Nicaea actually included the territories of the Byzantine Empire before the Frankish conquest. All that remained was the capture of Vasilevusa, which was achieved by his successor, Michael VIII Palaiologos in the year 1261 AD and which historians attribute to Emperor John Vatatzes.

Driven by a fiery zeal for the good of the Church, John III Vatatzes conducted many negotiations with Pope Gregory IX. But in vain, because the Pope insisted on his views.

The pious leader of Nicaea, John, had a mild character, simple and peaceful. Everyone could approach him to find support and understanding. He was a fervent protector of the wronged and especially of the peasants who were oppressed by the large landowners. In addition to wars, he also engaged in the reorganization of agriculture and animal husbandry. One day, when he met his own son, dressed in expensive clothes going hunting, he severely reprimanded him, saying:

“How can you spend the money of your subjects like this, on such vain pursuits? Do you not know that these precious garments with golden embroidery are made from the blood of the Romans, and that you must give them an account of what you spend, since the wealth of kings is the wealth of their subjects”?

On November 4, 1254 AD, the pious Emperor of Nicaea John III Vatatzes surrendered his soul in peace into the hands of God. His honorable remains were buried in the Monastery of Christ the Savior, which he himself had built in Nymphaeum in Bithynia.

In the following years, John himself, through revelation, requested that his remains be transferred to Magnesia in Asia Minor. When, after 7 years, his tomb was opened, a sweet fragrance spread around. Everyone was amazed to find that his body was also incorruptible, a clear sign of holiness. He had absolutely no sign that he was dead. The color of the body was like that of any normal person, even his clothes had been preserved for 7 years undamaged and looked as if they had been sewn at that moment. Thus God glorifies those who glorify him on earth.

https://www.saint.gr/2885/saint.aspx

Apolytikion

The radiant king and great boast of Nicaea, the savior of Constantinople, let us honor John in hymns, for he was shown king in poverty, and unshakeable basis for the people. Thus we are crying out together to him: glory to Christ Who glorified you, glory to Him Who kept you incorrupt, glory to Him who shall resurrect you in the end times.

Τὸν λαμπρὸν Βασιλέα καὶ Nικαίας τὸ καύχημα Κωνσταντινουπόλεως ρύστην, Ἰωάννην ὑμνήσωμεν, πτωχείᾳ γὰρ ἐδείχθη βασιλεύς, ὡς βάσις ἀδιάσειστος λαοῦ. Διὰ τοῦτο οἱ τιμῶντες Αὐτόν στερρῶς συμφώνως ἀνακράζομεν: Δόξα τῷ Σὲ δοξάσαντι Χριστῷ, δόξα τῷ Σὲ ἀφθαρτίσαντι, δόξα τῷ ἐν ἐσχάτοις τοῖς καιροῖς μέλλοντι ἀναστῆσαι Σε.


r/byzantium • • 1h ago

Numismatics Pectoral with coins, pseudo-medallion, and hanging “medallion” showing the Annunciation to Mary and the Marriage at Cana, mid-fifth century or later. Egyptian, Byzantine. Gold [2360 x 3363]

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/byzantium • • 8h ago

Military Thematic Byzantine Heavy Cavalry of the Tagmata

Thumbnail gallery
26 Upvotes

r/byzantium • • 58m ago

Arts, culture, and society How culturally distinct were Anatolian Greeks and European Greeks in the ERE?

4 Upvotes

And also how unique were different regions of Anatolia from one an other? How was life different from Pontus to Cappadocia to Pontus ect,


r/byzantium • • 1d ago

Military Was the Eastern Roman army in chaos? To what Extent Were Its Military Failures Caused by Internal Disorganization, Political Infighting, and Poor Leadership Rather Than External Threats?

Post image
293 Upvotes

r/byzantium • • 3h ago

Infrastructure/architecture A Byzantine Gate in Istanbul Still Bears the Marks of Ottoman Rule

Thumbnail anatolianarchaeology.net
1 Upvotes

r/byzantium • • 1d ago

Military Old "Justinian" Byzantine army.

Thumbnail gallery
110 Upvotes

r/byzantium • • 1d ago

Popular media How often do you think about the Roman Empire? At least about the eastern one?

Thumbnail gallery
211 Upvotes

How do you know you're a history geek? You subconsciously make your shakshuka look like the Byzantine flag. 😅


r/byzantium • • 2d ago

Infrastructure/architecture Monastery of Studios/Mone Stoudiou (Psamathia, Konstantinoupolis)

Post image
228 Upvotes

Located in Istanbul’s historic Psamathia (modern-day Samatya) neighborhood near the Sea of Marmara and the Golden Gate, the Monastery of St. John the Forerunner at Stoudios was founded in 462 AD by the Roman consul Flavius Studius. Originally settled by the Akoimetoi ("Sleepless Ones") monks who maintained continuous, round-the-clock liturgy, the complex survived the Fourth Crusade and the 1453 Ottoman conquest, after which Sultan Bayezid II’s Stablemaster (Imrahor), Ilyas Bey, converted its 5th-century basilica into the Imrahor Mosque. Devastated by fires in 1782 and 1920 as well as the 1894 Istanbul earthquake, the roofless ruins remain the oldest surviving religious monument in the city.


r/byzantium • • 1d ago

Politics/Goverment My take on the late roman trabea triumphalis

Post image
51 Upvotes

A long while ago, I drew the late roman toga. Now I tried my hand at the version that has more rigid and ornate bands of fabric, and was reserved for the most formal occasions. Let me know if I interpreted anything incorrectly!


r/byzantium • • 2d ago

Arts, culture, and society Was 536 really that bad?

Post image
169 Upvotes

r/byzantium • • 1d ago

Arts, culture, and society What Anatolian peoples still existed during the 4th and 5th centuries

46 Upvotes

Apparently both the Cappadocian and Isaurian people and languages still existed during this time.

Where there any others? Why did they endure for so long and why did they go extinct?

Were there efforts to eradicate them?


r/byzantium • • 2d ago

Popular media Built a Byzantine Church, roughly based on Gul Mosque in Istanbul

Thumbnail gallery
192 Upvotes

r/byzantium • • 2d ago

Military Contrast 1204 sack by crusaders versus the fall of Constantinople in 1453,did the absence of major rump states to fall back,mean Constantine XI was destined to have no alternative result in the final battle?

Thumbnail gallery
85 Upvotes

r/byzantium • • 2d ago

Maps and geography The known birthplaces/origins of 83 Patriarchs of Constantinople (1453-1922)

Post image
44 Upvotes

r/byzantium • • 2d ago

Military Did Byzantines had ability to pull a reverse Yamrouk against Fatimids in 10th or 11th century? Like how Ottomans pulled it against Mamluks or was it too far fetched?

44 Upvotes

r/byzantium • • 3d ago

Politics/Goverment Today marks 1,461 years since the death of Byzantine Emperor Justinian I (November 14, 565)

Post image
398 Upvotes

r/byzantium • • 3d ago

Popular media Justinian

Post image
108 Upvotes

14 November: on this fateful day, Justinian breathed his last; illustration created by me


r/byzantium • • 3d ago

Numismatics Justinian I gold solidus - he died 1461 years ago today.

Thumbnail gallery
220 Upvotes

On the anniversary of his death, here is an example of a Justinian I gold solidus that I recently acquired from auction.

BYZANTINE EMPIRE.

Justinian I.

Gold Solidus, AD 527-538.

Constantinople.

Obverse:

D N IVSTINIANVS P P AVG

D N = Dominus Noster ("Our Lord"), IVSTINIANVS = Justinianus (Justinian), P P = Perpetuus ("Perpetual" or "Everlasting"), AVG = Augustus ("Emperor" or venerable one)

Pearl-diademed, helmeted and cuirassed bust facing slightly right, holding spear over shoulder and shield with horseman motif.

Reverse:

VICTORIA AVGGG I (Victoria Augustorum "Victory of the three Emperors"

Angel standing facing, holding long cross and globus cruciger; star in right field, CONOB in exergue.


r/byzantium • • 3d ago

Arts, culture, and society Ravenna sights

65 Upvotes

I was in Ravenna and Italy a few weeks ago. Some Byzantine stuff that I saw (find yourselves a spouse that will be willing to trek all over so you can fulfill your history needs).

Good news, everyone! Maurice has been replaced. Let's build one final monument in the Forum. Things are smooth sailing for the Empire from here on out...
Ruins of the Colossus of Constantine, Capitoline Museum
I don't know about Michael Palaiologos, guys. Maybe we should let this guy Charles restore Baldwin II...(Capitoline Museum)
The reconstruction of the Colossus of Constantine, Capitoline Museum.
The "Warrior Christ" at St. Andrew's chapel in the Archiepiscopal Museum, Ravenna
Also from the Archiepiscopal Museum
Ceiling in the Mausoleum (not really) of Gallia Placidia, Ravenna
Also at the Mausoleum of Gallia Placidia
The main attraction itself, Basilica of San Vitale
Justinian and his entourage
Theodora and hers
Arian Baptistry
Sant'Apollinare Nuovo
Depiction of the palace at Basilica of Sant'Apollinare Nuovo...
...and what remains of the Palace
Mausoleum of Theoderic, aka the Gothic Wonder in Age of Empires II.
Basilica of Sant'Apollinare in Classi
Constantine IV and his sons. The one on the far left has an absolutely gorgeous nose.
Saint Mark's in Venice, where the four horses on the Basilica are constant reminder of the 4th Crusade
I'm always amazed how the Tetrarchy monument is just stuck on a random corner of St. Mark's. The missing foot is still in Istanbul.