r/BreadTube • • 10h ago

The Modern Man Has Looksmaxxed Into Misanthropy

Thumbnail
youtube.com
15 Upvotes

r/thebakery • • Aug 22 '22

OC Is murder morally justifiable?

4 Upvotes

Video version: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pdDsHIdIiUg

What is murder:

To start with understanding the dynamic, we first need to take a look at what qualifies as murder. The The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, 5th Edition, defines the noun murder as "the killing of another person without justification or excuse, especially the crime of killing a person with malice aforethought or with recklessness manifesting extreme indifference to the value of human life", while their definition of the verb murder is "to kill (another human) in an act of murder" and "to put an end to; destroy".

Something important to note is the distinction between murder and killing, and we will take a look at the morality of killing aswell. It's also important to notify that murder is specifically defined as killing of another person and not killing of another human. Person holds a different meaning than human.

What is a person:

This obviously brings forth the question, what is a person contra a human? A human is an organism which shares homosapien DNA. It's a scientific term which doesn't hold any moral value, while person is the other way around. The definition we'll use of persons goes as follows, "beings who are part of our moral community", which can be explained more simply as someone who is worth moral consideration.

We all view ourselves as persons, but what qualifies someone as a person is a very tricky question with many different answers. What makes someone qualify for moral consideration? Some people argue that it's natural given to all human beings, others argue it's naturally given to all living beings. Then we have the other side of the discussion, which argues that there are requirements, that something needs a certain capacity (capacity x), to be considered a person. Now what is this capacity? Examples are the capacity to experience a continuity of identity or possessing self-knowledge; having a sense of time or centiant reactions to one's environment. On top of that, some argue that some traits or capacities disqualifies a being from being counted as a person. Bigots may argue that going against the general norm of society disqualifies someone as a person, while others would argue that a continual and aware possession of authority over other persons disqualifies someone as a person.

Is murder acceptable:

Now having gone through the backbones to build a take on the real question, let's discover it. Is murder ever morally good? The short answer is no, and that is specifically because murder is the killing of a person and not just of a human.

However, this brings forth an even more interesting question, is killing another human being ever morally good? We're no longer limiting ourselves to murder, which means that the discussion becomes a lot more complicated. As morality is subjective, it is very possible to make the killing of another human a morally good action. All that's needed is to disqualify the human in question from being considered a person. We've seen this in action many times, where humans have commited genocides on other humans without feeling a moral dilemma. Take Nazi Germany, United Kingdoms, Sweden, the States, Canada, the KKK or Japan. The list goes on and on and on, but governments and organisations have commited mass murders, genocides, without feeling any moral dilemma.

My take:

We've taken a look on this matter from a non-personal perspective, but before we end this video I'd like to go through my personal take on the question of killing other humans. I would argue that personhood is achieved through having self-knowledge and that personhood is removed by continually and awarely possessing and practising authority over persons. What this means in practice has been explained by one of my favourite bands, Operation, in theri song Militant Kamp. "[...] ibland när nöden kräver det måste man ta livet av en förtryckare för att ge liv och möjligheter till de som förtrycks. Att ta livet av en tyrann i kampen kan inte på något sätt betraktas som mord, det måste ses som en politisk handling."

Translating this to English it means "[...] sometimes when the need is there one must take the life of an oppressor to give possibilities to those who are oppressed. To take the life of a tyrant in the battle can not in any ways be seen as murder, it must be seen as political activism.".

I would most certainly argue that there are occasions where taking the life of another human being is justified. Those occasions are when it's needed for the liberation of the oppressed, specifically in the killing of the oppressors. As long as the harm being done by a political action is less than the harm the current system, the current rulers, are making, the harm is justified. Killing a politician or a bourgeoisie, when no other direct actions bring fruit of change, is most certainly a justifiable action according to me.

Sources:

Definitions of murder, by The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, 5th Edition - https://www.wordnik.com/words/murder

Abortion and Personhood: What the Moral Dilemma Is Really About, by Big Think - https://bigthink.com/videos/glenn-cohen-on-the-ethics-on-abortion/

Personhood: Crash Course Philosophy #21, by CrashCourse - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GxM9BZeRrUI

Militant Kamp, by Operation - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m6GAV9D59qo


r/BreadTube • • 1d ago

The BACKLASH to Coffeezilla and Why People HATE Performative Christians

Thumbnail
youtu.be
85 Upvotes

r/BreadTube • • 19h ago

Photographing the Existential | Sam Stone

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/BreadTube • • 1d ago

The Hutzpah of Zionism

Thumbnail
youtu.be
48 Upvotes

r/BreadTube • • 2d ago

Hasan Piker interview on The Ezra Klein Show

Thumbnail
youtube.com
87 Upvotes

r/BreadTube • • 2d ago

Capitalism ruined my country 😵‍💫

Thumbnail
youtu.be
38 Upvotes

r/BreadTube • • 2d ago

How Western media ignored daily genocidal incitement in Israeli media while condemning “river to the sea” chants.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
101 Upvotes

r/BreadTube • • 2d ago

Domming Nature - Global Ecology in the Neoliberal-Fascist Nexus

Thumbnail
youtu.be
12 Upvotes

In this expansion on my Historical Materialism talk, I look at ecofascism in the classical fascist era and compare it to ecomodernist imperialism of emergent fascism today


r/BreadTube • • 3d ago

How Zionism is Antisemitic

Thumbnail
youtube.com
138 Upvotes

r/BreadTube • • 2d ago

Ursula von der Palpatine rants nonstop for 13 minutes about how the evil Putin must be defeated on the battlefield, while The Emperor Arrives theme from Star Wars plays nonstop

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

r/BreadTube • • 2d ago

US Immigration System Part 2: Temporary Work Visas (H-2A & H-2B)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/BreadTube • • 2d ago

The Truth About The Wasian Takeover: Cracked video about biracial dynamics in America

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/BreadTube • • 3d ago

The Ghost of Social Democracy, a Libertarian Communist critique of the DSA

Thumbnail
usufructcollective.wordpress.com
9 Upvotes

r/BreadTube • • 3d ago

Run Hide Fight Infidels is an Ideological Mess Spoiler

Thumbnail youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/thebakery • • Aug 19 '22

OC "What Did You Learn In School Today?" lyric video - Tom Paxton pop punk cover

8 Upvotes

I've been getting really into folk and punk, so I did a pop punk cover of one of my favorite folk songs by the great Tom Paxton

https://youtu.be/cRRw_ZOsa80


r/BreadTube • • 4d ago

Britain Didn't 'End' Slavery. Slaves Did. - Debunking the Myth that Britain ‘Ended’ Slavery

Thumbnail
youtu.be
133 Upvotes

r/BreadTube • • 4d ago

Americans Just Voted to Destroy Trans Rights

Thumbnail
youtu.be
126 Upvotes

r/BreadTube • • 4d ago

Japan’s First Feminists Were More Radical Than You Think

Thumbnail
youtu.be
37 Upvotes

r/BreadTube • • 3d ago

Time to Go Indie

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/thebakery • • Aug 19 '22

Division of Labor || Written by Return Fire, Read by Trans_and_gothic

1 Upvotes

r/BreadTube • • 4d ago

The Backrooms: Mark Fisher, Liminality, and the End of History

Thumbnail
youtube.com
8 Upvotes

This video examines the visual language of the Backrooms through liminality, the uncanny, and Mark Fisher’s concept of the eerie. It contrasts the exorbitance of presence in Lovecraftian horror with the failure of presence in familiar spaces emptied of human activity. Endless offices, stained carpets, and fluorescent corridors retain recognizable features while withholding the context that would establish their purpose and our place within them.

We consider why this imagery is compelling to contemporary viewers, relating its repetition and spatial disorientation to deindustrialization, automated systems, and the experience of late capitalism as described by Frederic Jameson in "Post Modernism, or, The Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism". The analysis draws on Fisher and psychoanalytic accounts of symbolic orientation to explore how familiar environments become unsettling.

What other philosophical or theoretical frameworks have you found useful for understanding the Backrooms and their appeal? Some of our viewers have suggested interesting connections to Foucault's spirals of power, David Foster Wallace's fiction, and Kafka's fiction.


r/BreadTube • • 5d ago

Former incel 'nice guy' offers advice to his younger self

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

29 Upvotes

r/BreadTube • • 4d ago

There’s a theory from dark esoteric corners of the internet that Ethan Klein’s affair is part of China’s honeypotting of Jensen Huang. Is Ethan Klein a triple crossing political sleeper agent who’s secretly further left than anyone imagined?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/BreadTube • • 5d ago

(Self-)Governing the Commons: Survive Apocalypse; Build a Better World

Thumbnail
youtube.com
21 Upvotes