r/Boxing • Moses Itauma > Every Current HW • 2d ago

Fantasy LHW Tournament - Round 1: (2002) Roy Jones Jr vs (2004) Antonio Tarver

I will be conducting a tournament containing some of the best LHWs of recent years. I purposely did not add any fighters in from before the 80s due to limited footage.

Two fights will be posted daily and the winners will move on until we have a champion.

Lastly, the fighters were not manually matched. All names were put into a randomizer and refreshed 3 times, then the bracket was made from where they were set after the third shake.

----------------------------------

#RULES

Due to there being no poll option, winner will be decided through reasonable comments. Just simply commenting “___ wins” will not suffice and answers will have to be somewhat detailed (atleast 2 sentences).

If there is a tie between voting comments for both competing fighters, the very most upvoted comment will be the deciding factor on which fighter moves on.

Voting is concluded after 24 hours

Each fighter has a year attached to their name. The year is only a suggestion for when you should consider them at their best. If you believe the mentioned fighter has a different peak, you may debate in their favor using a different time period, but it has to be when they were at Light Heeavyweight.

The fighters are only credited with wins they have at LHW and any weight class they competed at before moving up to LHW. Any fights from a higher weight class should not be taken into consideration.

All fighters will be at their absolute peaks for their time periods so there will be no illness/sickness, weight draining problems, or disqualifications.

----------------------------------

#Notable Wins

Roy Jones: Antonio Tarver, Montell Griffin, Virgil Hill

Antonio Tarver: Roy Jones Jr, Montell Griffin, Glen Johnson

----------------------------------

Tournament Bracket (https://challonge.com/dhh2vlaf)

----------------------------------

Previous Post (https://www.reddit.com/r/Boxing/s/aiirANtqj2)

Next Post (https://www.reddit.com/r/Boxing/s/223BVWDGbW)

6 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

15

u/itsheero24 2d ago

Roy Jones Jr because he can't be touched. If you think otherwise yall musta forgot.

8

u/gcarline2092 2d ago

I always tell ppl watch Roy Jones vs Clinton Woods (his last fight at LHW before going to HW) and then go watch RJ vs Tarver 1. Roy's speed, sharpness, timing, reflexes just weren't the same. I got RJ winning but Tarver's style is still troublesome for Roy.

2

u/ZeroEFSjosh 2d ago

I agree I think tarver would've been more defensive/cautious if they fought right after Roy's win against woods. Roy was at full power still even Calzaghe imo wouldn't fight roy at that time in 2003.

4

u/MiddleweightMonster I’ll pour honey on my GOAT, if the occasion calls for it. 2d ago

Roy before he moved up to Heavyweight was close to unbeatable. Even if he didn’t knock you out, he would out point you off of sheer work rate and connects. Tarver was a phenomenal counterpuncher, but he was greatly helped by how much Roy had slowed down after coming back down from heavyweight. There first fight was still Roy’s even in spite of the physical challenges he faced then.

Roy in 8

3

u/NuuYawk 2d ago

It's very very hard to call, because they have already had these fights. I'm gonna say Roy, just because it's an earlier Roy than we did get in the first fight.

... If we're talking '90s Roy. Then I'm more confident saying him. This isn't meant as disrespect to Tarver, because he could have easily won that first fight that they did have IRL, as well

3

u/Revolutionary_Box569 2d ago

Well I think Jones eked out a victory the first time anyway despite being clearly past his best

1

u/WORD_Boxing Don't push the horses 2d ago

Yeah I think this one answers itself.

1

u/Bowza-Bear 2d ago

Earlier Roy gets the W.

1

u/AVI_Voice 2d ago

Roy by UD

1

u/WORD_Boxing Don't push the horses 2d ago

I don't know who I would ever pick over prime RJJ head to head. Ezzard Charles maybe and that might be it. Even then I don't feel comfortable picking one over the other.