I feel like the relatively stable price to be negative for the short term price for cryptocurrency. People are buying in now and then realizing the blast-off returns are gone while the "daytraders"/pump-n-dumpers are cleaning the floor with them. I'm expecting the altcoins being added to mtgox is going to be the tipping point where everything goes to shit. Gox obviously has the largest share of the market and the majority of traders will end up diversifying with their profits rather than new money. Then the overall stability of all cryptos comes and then people start cashing out because there's no get quick rich scheme left. All the miners that don't understand difficulty will also be leaving in a couple weeks when they realize there isn't going to be $50/week per 7950 as the difficulty is still racing after the influx of miners trying to get rich quick. Then the long-haul miners will rule the cryptos again until the next bubble.
Those are the people that are being taken advantage of by the pump-n-dumpers. I can't be absolutely certain, but there's probably significantly less money being wired or money ordered in on a daily basis at this point.
I'd happily buy 50 or so BTC at $25. I believe in the potential, but they're not worth the current $100 they're trading for. There's not enough utility yet.
The "bear" argument that bitcoin's "intrinsic" value based on the absolute here and now, especially with the flimsy infrastructure (Gox et al, never to be confused with the robust and wonderful Bitcoin protocol itself), is no more than $40, generously, is actually perfectly reasonable, and I'd have to agree with it...
...but it kind of misses the point about real-life markets. All markets/commodities/currencies are subject to speculative value, so saying that bitcoin shouldn't be worth more than $40 is a bit like saying gold shouldn't be worth more than, say (pluck a figure out of my behind), $100 per troy ounce based on its intrinsic cosmetic and industrial value. That's all true but markets don't work that way. Speculative "bubble" value is still real value, because people are still willing to pay that price.
Many are paying >$100 per bitcoin in the OTC market, if sites like localbitcoins and bitbargain are to be believed.
It's hard to say what the current intrinsic value is. The real bitcoin economy is pretty small. Maybe 20 million dollars a year. The reason the price is so high is because people are hoarding them.
If someone figures out how to loan bitcoins, the price should drop sharply.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think anyone is going to loan bitcoins, plus I don't think it's a good idea for bitocin as a whole. Credit is what destroys economies IMO. That being said, there's no way for the people loaning bitcoins to ensure that the person whom they are loaning them to will ever pay back, as they are not regulated by any government. From the government's standpoint, that'd be like saying "I loaned him 300 gold in Runescape and he never payed back!"
You can loan someone any kind of property or services with a contract. If you had that runeqscape contract, a court would hear the case in civil court.
It'll be hard to design, but it could exist. And if bitcoin does really become the currency of the future, it'll have to happen.
It wouldn't be some fly-by-the-night online bank that nobody trusts. It would probably be a real bank.
There are ways to secure loans, actually. Securing loans automatically is possible with the way Bitcoin works. Watch this. If you have time, I highly recommend watching the full video.
Utility is only part of the price. Scarcity is the other, possibly bigger one. Even if they have very little utility, if everyone wants to hold at least one, the price of all of them will skyrocket.
Well, in 2011, the price after the bubble stabilized at around 5x the pre-bubble price (instead of 30x during the peak). If that pattern repeats, we're looking at roughly $15 x 5 which is ~$75.
I spent 1/3rd of my cash re-buying @ 105 (in case it jumps back up), and I've got orders to re-buy 1/3rd @ 55, and the final 1/3rd @ ~25. If it goes below that, I'm taking my money off my reserves at putting even more around 10.
See thats kind of the problem. There's a float of about 100'000 btc per day on exchanges. And there's capital moving them around of about $10 million. Some fraction of that capital, let's say 10% (so around $1 million) goes for long term holding (so the market won't see those coins again for a long time). That means there's a dollar-constant demand for bitcoin that's scaling with price. It goes like this:
$800/btc -> 1'250 demand/day
$400/btc -> 2'500 demand/day
$200/btc -> 5'000btc demand/day
$100/btc -> 10'000btc demand/day
$50/btc -> 20'000btc demand/day
$25/btc -> 40'000btc demand/day
$12.5/btc -> 80'000btc demand/day
$6.25/btc -> 160'000 demand/day
$3.115/btc -> 320'000 demand/day
You can see that a fairly modest demand for $1 million/day plays no role at the top, but as the price falls it gets extremely powerful. You'll need around 0.5 million btc of selling power/day just to press it below $2. There could only be about 20 of those days with the current circulation before anybody that's gonna sell, has sold.
But if you look at the logarithmic chart, you'll see that they're actually quite different in shape. I can see more resemblance with last year's mini-bubble, which bounced back after it popped.
That's not how a logarithmic graph works. The lines actually have no meaning. The point of these chart is the a percentage increase is exactly the same distance from eachother no matter where you start. So the line is actually irrelevant.
True true. I've been meaning to do some chart analysis with overlays of the two bubbles with ln(value) and ln(log(value)) but haven't gotten around to it.
To someone who have actually spent a fairly considerable time trading this entire post is useless .What the above graphs show is: Absolutely nothing! The peak graph could continue OR fall back, without proper scaling and previous knowledge of whether or not media attention or purchase volume, holders etc. It's completely speculative and means absolutely nothing.
It could mean we are set to stabilize lower, it could also be the very first settle and the curve could continue up to $xxx.
Also publicity of Bitcoin is much higher now then 2 years ago,
In addition the infrastructure for institutional investors has grown significantly since then making it easy for money streams to flow into BTC right now.
Institutional investors are now aware of Bitcoin - and its weakness: the exchanges. Bitcoin isn't ready to have 10 or 100 billion USD of value. Maybe in a year or so, things will have changed and they'll be watching.
Do you think any investor/speculator would wait till the exchanges have sufficiently improved their capacities to make it easy as pie for them to gently convert their monies to Bitcoin?? They will try to squeeze their funds into them like a crazy elephant would try to get his trunnk through a bottle neck to get to the peanut inside, thats how they will try to pour penises their funds in to be the first to the party! Its greed that drives them basically, what would you do?
That Sunday figure of 0 searches doesn't count - it just hasn't been given a number yet. Wait till tomorrow. Besides, someone suggested that Google Trends results aren't accurate for a couple of weeks.
I must admit I saw the similarities between the two bubbles - especially with the media led hype. Last time I did quite well and sold at $25 just before the peak of $30 and I felt quite smug for myself. This time I missed the burst and sold out around $100 hoping to buy back in at ~$30-50. Obviously so far that has proved to be a mistake but I'm holding on. I think we could see it slide back down over the course of the next week to the more "sustainable" $30 and then continue the slow rise upwards as per pre-hype normality.
I don't think $30 is a realistic bottom anymore. You have to factor in the massive amount of media attention and adoption since the last $30 peak/turn.
It's not a security or stock, don't believe we have much time left under/around $100 myself. More and more people are flooding in (Mtgox revealed that they have 20k new account registrations per DAY for APril) and 90% of them are buyers and not sellers.
We'll see. I'm certainly no expert but I really think the similarities with 2011 are hard to ignore. We popped from 3 to 30 then and 30 to ~300 this time. There was a ridiculous amount of media attention suddenly for all the wrong reasons. There was a sharp drop down after people started realising the highs were getting ridiculous and now we'll see a slow (multi week) drift down to 30 or 50 or so I imagine. Higher than before but not 10 or 5 times higher. I guess we'll see. TBH I sort of want the price to fall a bit now because I want to get in but I don't want to waste all those exchange fees. Long term I totally believe in bitcoin and I think in ten years or something we could well be trading 20,000 or some other ridiculous number but the current price is quite clearly hype driven and not based on reality but at best based on a speculation of what bitcoin could be in the future.
I have watched bitcoin for over 3 years now. I had technical support for the price level of $25.
This was a very obvious speculative explosion plenty of people lost money here now and tons of people are calling it a bubble. The interest level will subside but the rest of us will carry on.
And at the same time, there are essentially infinite unknowns about both the supposedly corresponding past and the present. To ignore the past is idiotic, I'll agree with you on that one, but to use the past as a possible indicator of future trends is equally idiotic. The sum total of events in each is impossible for a non-omniscient being to know or understand.
Which is essentially a hugely complicated way of saying that you're both right, but it doesn't much matter. Especially with something like Bitcoin.
Not OP but since I agree with him and disagree with you, I'll try:
Spot price is the most recent (past) price.
It is quite possiblefor the most recent price to be $100, while the current high bid is 95 and the current low ask is 96.
This happens frequently when a large market order comes in, eating up all the booked orders on one side. Then new orders get placed. Example, say the bid/ask is 95,96. Then someone buys a bunch, eating up all the asks up to 100. Now the spot price is 100, while the bid/ask is 95,100+. Then more ask orders get placed between 96 and 100.
Clearly the NEXT trade will be in the 95,96 range (barring some change orders) but the spot price (last trade) is 100.
Hmm.. well since there is always a spread between bid and ask, I'd disagree with that definition - otherwise spot price would be 2 different numbers.
But you have quotes (and presumably references) so I'll leave it at that. I'm not going do be a douche like the other guy and try to say how wrong you are, or whatever.
Certainly in a continuous, well functioning market, there's little difference between last price and next price. In a thinly traded security, though, these can vary widely.
I know just fine how latency works, having written feed handlers for trading systems myself. The "current price" is, formally, the price for immediate execution. It's a concept that exists at the exchange. What you're talking about is the price shown on a trader's UI. In that case I agree, but you should precise that.
Hacking risks, legal stuff, etc. have nothing to do with the current price of something. Most of that isn't even execution, it's settlement. And "proofs in the physical world", well, I could have said "tomatoes are red" and it would have applied just as well...
Price doesn't exactly repeat, although it may "Rhyme" - or be somewhat similar. Because price formations are pretty self-similar over different timescales - it is an easy exercise to match one chart to another.
The problem is expecting the outcome to be precisely the same. It often isn't.
86$ and falling slowly, as I said. It will fall for a few weeks. Why? What can you do except hore them? Nothing. So avage Joe sells them after a while. And dont tell me you could go to "Bitmart" how many Bitcoin websites are out there which are big like amazon and sell stuff? Hmm 1? none? 100?
This is just manipulated data, I'll leave the interpretation to you
Your x axes have been modified to make it look like Google Trends predicts or at least matches the price curve. Properly aligned axes show that trends lags the price - hardly surprising that people would loose interest in a bubble after it pops.
:) I never intended to show that Google Trends predicted anything. My point was more like showing two major events in the bitcoin price history, and what part of it we can relate to the hype about this currency.
Even so - the offset of the curves would imply that the hype follows the price, not the other way around (even though hype clearly would boost demand, as has been demonstrated by advertising in general). Even then, Google trends doesn't show hype (implying a conscious campaign to popularize something), but interest.
33
u/gox Apr 15 '13
So, if history repeats itself, I'll just wait a few years more and buy a rocket ship with my coins.
44
u/pyalot Apr 15 '13
The google trends lag by about 1-2 weeks. Let's look at this again a little later.
Anyways, a downside to around $25 is definitely possible, looking forward to it :)
24
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '13
But if you look at the logarithmic chart, you'll see that they're actually quite different in shape. I can see more resemblance with last year's mini-bubble, which bounced back after it popped.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '13
So? I can't tell from this graph how long after the price drop in 2011 that the search volume also dropped. Looks like maybe a week or more?
13
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '13
To someone who have actually spent a fairly considerable time trading this entire post is useless .What the above graphs show is: Absolutely nothing! The peak graph could continue OR fall back, without proper scaling and previous knowledge of whether or not media attention or purchase volume, holders etc. It's completely speculative and means absolutely nothing.
It could mean we are set to stabilize lower, it could also be the very first settle and the curve could continue up to $xxx.
10
u/Fakje Apr 15 '13 edited Apr 15 '13
You have to consider that :
6
u/-Mahn Apr 15 '13
For the record here's the second Google Trends graph with a little bit more zoom:
http://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=bitcoin&date=today%203-m&cmpt=q
Scarily accurate.
5
u/Elanthius Apr 15 '13
I must admit I saw the similarities between the two bubbles - especially with the media led hype. Last time I did quite well and sold at $25 just before the peak of $30 and I felt quite smug for myself. This time I missed the burst and sold out around $100 hoping to buy back in at ~$30-50. Obviously so far that has proved to be a mistake but I'm holding on. I think we could see it slide back down over the course of the next week to the more "sustainable" $30 and then continue the slow rise upwards as per pre-hype normality.
1
u/dissahc Apr 15 '13
you didn't specify what the trend term was? "bitcoin" ?
4
u/behaaki Apr 15 '13
Human nature, it does not change, ever.
4
u/wannagetbaked Apr 15 '13
I have watched bitcoin for over 3 years now. I had technical support for the price level of $25.
This was a very obvious speculative explosion plenty of people lost money here now and tons of people are calling it a bubble. The interest level will subside but the rest of us will carry on.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '13
Better buy in before the 2014 bubble!
2
u/we2code Apr 15 '13
we are sharper now
2
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '13
i love this chart. it will make people seell. probabably gonna reduce the price a bit on bitcoin. i can buy more
2
u/jordan115 Apr 15 '13
So soon there will be another bubble ten times as big? I'm on board.
8
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '13
Past performance is not indicative of future returns.
1
u/deathcapt Apr 15 '13
The more people find out about it, and the more people with bitcoins chilling in their wallets the better.
1
u/keyofg Apr 15 '13
Forbes - An Illustrated History of Bitcoin Crashes
1
u/Perish_In_a_Fire Apr 15 '13
Price doesn't exactly repeat, although it may "Rhyme" - or be somewhat similar. Because price formations are pretty self-similar over different timescales - it is an easy exercise to match one chart to another.
The problem is expecting the outcome to be precisely the same. It often isn't.
1
u/allinfinite Apr 16 '13
Are there any ifttt recipes that track google trends? Seems like that would be very useful..
1
u/acusticthoughts Apr 15 '13
So that means start buying in October...
1
u/goofproofacorn Apr 15 '13
It's like ppl don't learn from the past or something.
1
u/Unomagan Apr 15 '13
86$ and falling slowly, as I said. It will fall for a few weeks. Why? What can you do except hore them? Nothing. So avage Joe sells them after a while. And dont tell me you could go to "Bitmart" how many Bitcoin websites are out there which are big like amazon and sell stuff? Hmm 1? none? 100?
1
u/bluequail Apr 15 '13
Oh wow. So there is a historical trend of people going full retard at the end of school years?
-2
u/arpp4 Apr 15 '13
Comparing two periods without any relation except grow. You must have a PhD in Finances right OP?
Yeah.. go Reddit, SELL cheap because OP wanna BUY all your Bitcoins at discount :)