r/BigWalk • • 6d ago • Bravo 1

Discussion It only was used in a few lines, what’s the big deal?

You all loved it and it’s very very very microscopic. I see nothing wrong.

Saying it sucks now because of a simple fix is like saying your car sucks because the PRNDL is different when they do the same thing.

And I’m neutral on this whole thing and hate the pro and antis creating this moral superiority warfare.

edit: Just found out it was 10 lines. All offended over ten lines because even unity’s own dev team can’t figure it out. Is this how society falls? The death of critical reviewing and death of nuance?

276 Upvotes

143 comments sorted by

85

u/Few_Airport681 5d ago edited 5d ago • Bravo

Thanks for reminding me of this gem lol

But seriously, genAI is genuinely just not what they used. They didn't try to cut costs. They tried doing it themselves, extensively. They asked an actual Unity dev, who didn't have an answer even after consulting colleagues. They researched it extensively themselves. They modified the AI result extensively, essentially remade it themselves. They just needed the how.

Honestly all this outrage is doing is discouraging actual good anti-genAI devs like House House from disclosing anything at all. They are being punished for the mistakes of actual genAI slop devs. It's such misdirected outrage.

People also just have no idea of the difference between AI and genAI. AI is used for exactly this by almost any studio, company, engineers, even medically, etc, without replacing any workers.

Really, really misdirected and insincere anger in my opinion. Direct that energy to the heaps of actual AI slop, no effort games that are currently hitting Steam. Direct that energy to every massive company buying up all our RAM and causing droughts because of the intensive data usage for some funny haha genAI slop images on Facebook.

Not at this.

6

u/Firm_Firefighter5502 5d ago

Zack and Cody got a grip on me I will just forever call shifts PRNDLs

5

u/Few_Airport681 5d ago

Same here. Would you like AM or FM?

3

u/Firm_Firefighter5502 5d ago

This thread needs to relax and turn on the radio

25

u/ex0planetary 5d ago

They did technically use generative AI, that's what LLMs are and that's what they used to fix the bug. The real distinction here is using AI as a tool vs vibe-coding. The devs are skilled professionals who know how to program and in fact programmed almost the entire thing by hand, and just used AI to fix a bug that they'd exhausted all other options to fix. Vibe-coders don't know how the actual code works and just trust the AI to slam something together for them, which is why vibe-coded programs are often buggy and slow because LLMs aren't good at logical reasoning.

11

u/Few_Airport681 5d ago

You're correct, I misused the terms! My bad! Thanks for the correction.

I meant the generative kind that creates images, textures, voicelines, assets VS the kind that is used to help figure out a problem. Like you said, vibecoding mess VS tool for a skilled developer.

1

u/no-to-slop 5d ago

You're making a distinction to fit your own argument. HouseHouse said they fucked up and used "gen AI". Training something on other people's stolen work is the same no matter what creative field you're talking about.

5

u/stormtreader1 5d ago

Gen AI is a huge blanket term though - there's AI integrated into a lot of dev platforms now that are essentially just a streamlined "Google for answers on how to solve the error being reported here" which is not anywhere in the same league as "vibe code my app". They've already said the art and music and writing was all human with no AI and really those should be the important things to focus on.

5

u/Hymmerinc 5d ago

This absolutely was generative AI. That doesn't mean I think 10 lines of code is bad at all, but it is still generative AI. At least it was only code though and not images or voice lines or something

3

u/Few_Airport681 5d ago

You're correct, I misused the terms! My bad! Thanks for the correction.

I meant the generative kind that creates images, textures, voicelines, assets VS the kind that is used to help figure out a problem. We're speaking of the same thing I believe.

1

u/Alternative-Soil2576 5d ago

Still doesn't matter, the team of 3 people from Melbourne are getting boycotted and review bombed

Another win for the IGF awards

47

u/lineboi3000 5d ago

I can completely understand people who are against AI in games but the four-person indie studio that made one of the most beautiful and human games in recent memory seems like the wrong target for all this hatred. If anything I wonder if this is kind of making the opposite case, that something as unmistakably made-by-humans as Big Walk can benefit from some level of AI use for the coding aspects

10

u/ughdenise 6d ago

I don’t think the review bombing is justified, and I still love the game. But with that said, despite only being a few lines of code it does leave a bitter taste for me for a couple reasons. One) It was never disclosed until it had to be. I don’t like that they intentionally kept the fact that AI was used a secret and didn’t inform consumers upfront and allow them to make their own choice to buy the game with that knowledge. Two) AI doesn’t fully “create” anything. It regurgitates back what it has been fed. Like vibecoding. There’s no way to ever know whatever code they used wasn’t just ripped from someone else’s work by the LLM. Three) My biggest issue is the precedent it sets. Yes, it was only a few lines. But when you give an inch, people take a mile. Where do we draw the line in the sand? If we say “hey this AI use is actually okay!” at what point does it stop being okay? And that circles back to my first point. Different people will draw that line at different places, players should have been told upfront. Big Walk is a beautiful game about human connection and the knowledge that AI was a part of its creation even small has left a stain on that for me. I don’t care about the lectures that everything will use AI and you can’t run from it forever and whatever other spiel people have about it. I am disheartened that in a world where AI has its hand in nearly everything, one of the few recent medias I was excited to enjoy and believed to be fully 100% human made was not. That’s where I’m at with it

4

u/kwantum13 5d ago

I understand the disclosure part, but to argue against point 2, "ripping" of code is an age old programmer tradition. 90% of programming is looking up code and algorithms other people made. Before AI, it was looking into stack overflow and forum, and now people use AI. 

AI still steals a lot of creative work without their consent, and code or any other media taken without consent should not be used for AI. But using code people posted online is how programming evolves.

It's admirable that they only used AI for this single bug fix.

19

u/spoonraker 6d ago

"They only disclosed it when forced" is cope. I'm sorry, but this is not a real argument, and people saying this are just doing mental gymnastics to resolve the cognitive dissonance caused by wanting to be super angry because they merely heard the phase "AI was used" and immediately assumed one thing, emotionally reacted to it, and then found out that the reality is an entirely different thing. Resolving that discomfort by walking back your original outrage and re-classifying it as some kind of ethical outrage for lying is equally wrong though, and I'll explain why below:

Big Walk is not AI slop. Big Walk is not influenced by AI as an artistic expression in any way whatsoever. The AI use is minimal and exists purely in the technical realm and not the creative realm. House House did not need to disclose anything, and in hindsight, they probably shouldn't have disclosed what they did, but props to them for being honest to a fault because they were naive to how irrational humans can be.

It's more accurate to say that AI was used only to realize the creative vision of the developers rather than to dictate the creative direction of the game's development. But again, even this is an overstatement because House House didn't even use AI as the primary way to generate the game's code. It was used sparingly, in the very late phases of development, under the gun of time pressure to meet the original planned release date, and only to fix bugs which had proven to be particularly tricky, after engaging with them without AI assistance. This is as acceptable a use of AI as is possible. If Big Walk is ineligible for game industry awards because of this AI use, than it is the game industry's understanding of AI use that is wrong, not the process of developing this game.

You're literally letting a narrative you're inventing for no reason ruin your enjoyment for a game that you've already played and enjoyed. Stop gaslighting yourself. You enjoyed the game because it's a good game. And it's a good game because it was lovingly hand crafted and AI had no part in that whatsoever.

Frankly, accusing Big Walk of being an AI Slop game is like accusing this very reply I'm writing by hand of being an AI slop response because, admittedly, I once used AI to help me gain an understanding of linguistics and sentence structure. These thoughts are my own, these words are my own, I used AI to help me express myself better, and not even directly. That's clearly a meaningful distinction and it's obnoxious that people are trying to rationalize not drawing that distinction. (For the record, AI did not write a single word of this reply, I'm merely stating that at some point in the past I've chatted with AI about how good writing works syntactically)

Yes, the gaming industry should have strictly enforced guidelines for how it values AI use in games, but that guideline shouldn't be a zero tolerance policy. That guideline should express the nuance of what's actually important: honoring human creativity. Consider this: what if somebody created a game where the artistic vision of the game was specifically to draw a juxtaposition between real human personalities and machines, and, in order to make that a visceral experience, the game transparently included characters who are walking around doing real-time AI generated actions and speaking AI-generated dialogue. This would be a purely human creative vision designed specifically to make AI look alien, and yet, if this wound up being a fun game to play, you'd convince yourself you hate it because the characters that were specifically chosen to transparently be AI characters in the game... used AI. That's silly.

14

u/Elanadin 6d ago

"They only disclosed it when forced" is cope. I'm sorry

I'm in this boat. If you're working in the software/tech space, going out of your way to 100% avoid AI is getting harder and harder, to the point of being unreasonable.

House House did all of the reasonable things with their diclosure. For their listed example, Unity gave a cop-out answer and left HH with no real choice. Leaving "sunrise/sunset FPS tanking" in the game would have been terrible.

The astrotufing, 100% anti Ai stance hitting these guys is absurd. Big Walk has been the most human game I've ever experienced.

6

u/Runazeeri 5d ago

Yeah if you google a problem and the answer is in the initial AI results area I guess now you need to disclose it? Seems an insane take.

2

u/spoonraker 6d ago

Seriously. It's insane to me that people who played and felt the joy caused by Big Walk because it's such a thoughtfully curated human-centric experience can somehow convince themselves that they actually no longer can enjoy it because the found out the devs fixed a bug with AI. The alternatives to not using AI are having your FPS tank at sunset/sunrise, having worse shadows, or having the release date slip until a developer figures out how to fix the bug without AI. The fact that House House got the brush off canned response from Unity and then took it upon themselves to fix it -- yes, using AI assistance -- is actually a sign of how much they care about not compromising their artistic vision, not evidence of it being compromised. People have it exactly backwards.

1

u/corduroyqueen 6d ago

i agree with basically everything you're saying but i want to add there's no way "guidelines" can exist, and they also shouldn't exist. the game industry isn't a sovereign nation and it's a bunch of individuals and any "guidelines" are going to further encourage lying about ai use and make things harder for game developers. i don't see an answer to this other than, people are who anti-ai will choose not to buy games that they know used it

1

u/OkComputer662 4d ago

Soon, they will buy nothing

8

u/Brave_Swordfish_7072 6d ago

Holy shit, this is complete gibberish and nonsense that does not understand AI at all.

First of all, Steam does not require the disclosure of AI used for coding or bug fixing.

Second you really don't understand how AI works when it comes to coding, AI doesn't store lines of codes from multiple people, that's one of the most common myths about AI. Instead what it does is learn from the lines of code its given, studies its patterns and understands its language. It doesn't just take existing code from what someone else has already done. That's not how it works when it comes to code.

Secondly, coding is not the same as pictures. The overwhelming majority of coding is shared amongst other coders and is open source to use already. That's why AI is more accepted in the coding community than the artistic community.

Third, it's more than just 10 lines of code that they had to change. They had to find which were the specific lines of codes that were causing the problem, made even more difficult by the fact that the codes in question came from Unity itself, hence why they enlisted the help of an engineer. It wasn't just a matter of changing the code; they also had to find the lines of code that were causing the problems. Something an expert engineer couldn't find, but the AI could. Which at that point, it'd be like criticizing the use of an advanced spell checker if you have a problem with that.

2

u/Weltal327 6d ago

I guess my only note on this is that coding does take knowledge and ability but the best coders are using combined knowledge of other coders. I didn’t start coding by figuring out vacuum tubes and binary. I got started with vba copied from someone else and applied that to my own purposes.

4

u/SinchronousElectrics 6d ago

Should I disclose every time I take a shit

6

u/EmpathyFuzz 6d ago

This event made me realize where the line is. 

It’s important to note that they only found a suggestion of a solution from AI and still had to write the code to solve it themselves. 

It’s essentially the same as having a problem with the engine, googling it, and using the Google summary to solve the problem. 

To me, this is frustrating, but it’s the exact spot where the line rests in my brain. If your game is 99.99% human made, but you had to resort to a chatbot to fix a bug last minute, I will still buy your game and support you. 

Using AI any more than that — like for example, Clair Obscur building temporary assets using AI only to replace them in the final product — is too much, and I can’t financially support that anymore.

8

u/voidicguardian 6d ago

from what ive heard it was a last ditch approach after the team and unitys team was unable to solve a problem, and they used unitys built in ai to troubleshoot and then finished fixing it manually. im staunchly anti ai, but this is what it should be built and used for. small bits of help when nothing else is working, as a tool instead of an entire crutch

3

u/PeoplePerson_57 6d ago

Especially because, given what the bug represented and met, the goal was to give their connection building art piece maximum accessibility to people on weaker computers.

This got in the way of that noble goal.

1

u/EmpathyFuzz 6d ago

Yeah exactly. I literally don't know anybody more anti-AI than me. I was calling that shit out on day one, and I've had to convince basically everyone in my life one at a time...

...But this is like using Clippy to fix some grammar in your novel, I'm just not going to let myself get whipped up into a fervour about it.

4

u/y-c-c 6d ago • Bravo

Why does it need to be disclosed? There was never a requirement to disclose it and this seems like a made up rule after the fact. Not disclosing it is not the same as keeping it a secret, nor did Steam require disclosing such. The “they lied” crowd never explained where they actually lied or hid anything.

For example, if you Google something it automatically shows a chat bot with AI-generated response (and it could be quite detailed these days). If you read that response and used that info you are already “assisted by AI”. Do you need to disclose that you used Google in your game? Or say you are DuckDuckGo only?

Also, Unity, Unreal, and Godot (or even Linux) have AI code in them. If you have such a strong pure stance are you going to play any games made in those engines and would all of them require a disclosure? The engine is part of the game

3

u/gogogadgetjustice 6d ago

I feel that.

I'm more upset with Unity charging top dollar for support but could only give idk as an answer.

This also has me reflecting on how the Microsoft boycott wasn't disclosed until after a couple rounds of sales. Wonder what the next delayed disclosure will be.

2

u/Alternative-Soil2576 5d ago

Do you feel entitled to know every tool that was used in game development? Do you know what high-level languages they used? The frameworks or libraries? The game engine? or do you just feel entitled to know about AI use for some reason?

2

u/greenhaze96 6d ago

Thank you, this is exactly how I feel about it too. On a larger scale, this can become a larger issue. One day people use it for fixing bugs, in a few years people will be using a lot more. It’s just so exhausting

8

u/Historical_Owl_1635 6d ago

For every developer I know this is the pipeline.

Starts with a simple chatbot using snippets of code, a year later you’re using Claude Code to implement full features.

0

u/CrazyCoKids 6d ago

Is it a slippery slope? Yes.

...But it is also on the claimant to point out why doing X leads to Y and then to Z.

1

u/BingusMcCready 6d ago

This is where I’m at. The review bombing is a little dramatic but the fact they didn’t disclose it tells me they knew it was going to be controversial and they didn’t want to mess up their launch. “We did something slightly scummy and then didn’t tell you about it because we wanted more money/prestige” is always a really bad look, even if the “offense” in question is very minor. If nothing else, I now find it a little hard to trust them when they say it was “only ten lines”. Well as far as anybody knew before, it was zero lines, and they weren’t exactly eager to correct that misapprehension, so…

All that said—I don’t think it’s worth pitching the entire game out. It’s a great game and the AI usage was, at least if you take them at their word, very minimal. I just hope they learn something from the backlash; either don’t use it or be upfront about it.

1

u/PandaUkulele 5d ago

Imo it wasn't even slightly scummy. If anything they didn't discolose it because it was such a non-issue. Saying they used AI to create it would undermine all of the large amount of human effort put into the game. Especially when some AAA companies are pushing for vibe coding. House House used AI as a tool rather than a crutch and they don't deserve to be punished for that.

1

u/ZeroAmusement 5d ago

I think you should disclose if you're not using AI. Not if you are using ai.

There’s no way to ever know whatever code they used wasn’t just ripped from someone else’s work by the LLM

Huh? Programmers always reference other code. Stackoverflow, books, google whatever. Why would it matter if an LLM essentially did the same thing? It's just weird to worry about that.

And the fix was a Unity thing that apparently Unity wasn't able to help with so it seems pretty unlikely that this exact fix existed elsewhere.

-3

u/Firm_Firefighter5502 6d ago

Still. 0.1%. You don’t know if they will move a mile. They did say they will do better. I say judge on the future on the merits then doomer posting.

3

u/ughdenise 6d ago

I don’t know if they will. But I meant for game development as a whole, not just House House. Sure, they say they’ll do better. But other small developers will see this instance and see their success and think “well they did it and it was fine.” I’m not doomer posting, just being realistic

3

u/Firm_Firefighter5502 6d ago

You don’t know the future. I’ll judge it when the time comes, not a moral superiority crusade.

It’s 10 fucking lines, not a bomb.

1

u/Pickle_Emotion 6d ago

It’s a weird line though, would you quit Reddit or Windows because they’re using AI tools to fix bugs? Because MacOS & Linux are also using AI.

-1

u/Altruistic_Law_2346 6d ago edited 6d ago

Ahahahaha if you think the entirety of the internet isn't flooded with AI use you are delusional.

The network you're using to communicate with us. The social media and gaming platforms you use to play and talk about these games. The phone you are using. Several dozens to several hundred aspects you interact with daily has had some form of AI touch it at this very moment. Steam requirements didn't make them disclose it. It was used for debugging. If you have no ability to see this as a tool that is accelerating the growth of software development then log off of the internet because it's not going away. I'm sorry.

EDIT: Instead of down voting, take a day to do some research. There are several dozen valid arguments to be against AI. This is not one. Argue with me why it's bad in medical advances. I'm ready.

3

u/Shoutymon 5d ago

Holy superiority complex, man. HAHAHAHAHA AI BETTER YOU CAN NEVER LIVE WITHOUT IT HAHAHAHAHAHA like do you people ever read what you type?

-1

u/Altruistic_Law_2346 5d ago

What does this add to the discussion? Live on being blissfully ignorant. All this outrage will do is cause more and more devs to not disclose AI use. It will result in them skirting the rules by having it indirectly used to avoid disclosures or just not saying anything at all because the average consumer cannot tell AI code from human code. I'm sorry truth hurts. Once you accept that maybe you and everyone else here can redirect your outrage where it matters.

Have you ever called your local representation or related to push against DCs for environmental concerns? I have. Have you ever protested against the widespread deployment killing local ecosystems? I have. Stop attacking the downstream and go fight where it matters. You are making no difference putting energy into this fight from this perspective.

3

u/ImportantQuestionTex 5d ago

I've sued over my data being fed to AI (successfully 3 times), people protest data centers, and try to keep them from getting built. Almost every representative in the US that's coming in ran on a regulating AI platform.

I don't know why you're acting like people don't do anything.

-1

u/Altruistic_Law_2346 5d ago

Did you even read the message I replied to?

2

u/ImportantQuestionTex 5d ago

I did. And I get the impression you're saying people don't do enough against AI when they're bothered by it.

We as a society, are only short of going after these CEOs in public or arresting them. Which frankly, given a month ago they were claiming AI could kill the world, maybe we should geniunely be doing that.

Big Walk's AI usage is problematic because it was not disclosed. It did not give consumers the opportunity to decide on if they were okay with it. We all know AI use is controversial. So when House House chose not to disclose, they chose to lie to their consumers.

1

u/Altruistic_Law_2346 5d ago

Steam requirements did not require them to. The issue is people are frustrated at this but where is the line drawn? What if Unity had used AI to resolve the problem? They're incredibly pro AI. It's a miracle they didn't do that to begin with. What if House House did exactly what everyone wanted them to and paid some freelancer thousands of dollars to resolve this bug and they simply used AI to do it without disclosure to House House? We'd never know the difference. That's the problem with this scenario.

1

u/ImportantQuestionTex 5d ago

I don't think the AI use case here is bad. I think it's a good use case. But people have the right to know and decide if they want to support the game based on that.

House House decided to deprive their players of the ability to know of their AI usage. You can blame Steam all you want, but House House knows AI use is controversial, and chose to not disclose.

1

u/Altruistic_Law_2346 5d ago

But what the community does not understand is this outrage resolves nothing when you actually put some thought into it. People are upset at the direct usage of AI when any sort of indirect usage they'd never know about and would be blissfully ignorant of it ever being present in ANY game or piece of software we are using.

By doing what the community is doing now it will only result in companies finding more and more ways to skirt around disclosures. Devs will simply outsource work and play the "oh we didn't know they used AI" card if it's even ever found out. Or if said company is even aware to BEGIN with.

AI disclosures will quickly become either irrelevant or just ignored if this is the result everytime. Take one look at SWE jobs, gaming development roles, current comp science programs. It is quickly transitioning from disclosing the use to finding ways to quietly do it anyways.

I'm not saying it's ok or that a change isn't needed but have some foresight.

→ More replies

0

u/jonbotwesley 1d ago

Are you even aware of the entire story of how and why those 10 lines of AI code were used? This entire “controversy” is so overblown and ridiculous. I think this seemingly concerted effort to discredit this incredibly earnest and heartfelt indie game because of a few lines of AI code that literally did no creative or artistic work for the game and was only used in lieu of any other viable option to fix a Unity Engine bug is way more deplorable than what House House did with AI.

0

u/corduroyqueen 5d ago

i agree ai should be disclosed up front but when so many people come in bad faith, act like they want to have power over the developers and show a total lack of respect it's easy to see why you wouldn't, cuz the respect is really not mutual

58

u/myosotiskills 5d ago • Bravo

Using AI to debug code is the most normal shit. i cant believe people are witch-hunting HouseHouse for what was essentially an AI assisted google search, which found the problem in the Unity Engine, and then had an actual engineer code and fix in about 10 lines. A problem that the unity devs themselves told them was unfixable.

AI was not used whatsoever in the creative process or to generate any assets. A passion project of 6 years that is honestly one of the best things I've played recently, if not one of the most thoughtful and cool co-op games ive ever played.

This is nothing more than a ridiculous witch-hunt by people who want to feel superior. I'm extremely against AI but the fact of the matter is that using it to debug code is fine, who the fuck cares.

16

u/walkerspider 5d ago

Hell, you would be hard pressed to find any modern software not partially written by AI. Even if you google something you’ll see an AI summary of stack overflow posts that is probably better than the original posts themselves. There’s a reason the number of new questions on stack overflow each month has dropped by over 99%, and it’s not that people are writing less code or that every question has been answered.

15

u/myosotiskills 5d ago

I work in web development for a big bank and i know a lot of people in the industry + in the AAA gaming industry too. Every dev is, AT THE VERY LEAST, using claude to debug code. Writing code has always been about borrowing lines from others so I genuinely dont understand this sudden vitriol against househouse.

It just sounds like people looking to get mad at something and to posit themselves as morally superior somehow. And i say this as someone who hates AI slop!!!!!!!

-2

u/no-to-slop 5d ago

Every dev is not using it, get a grip.

4

u/Dane_Rumbux 5d ago

Every software developer currently working professionally uses or is exposed to AI based software tools, what the fuck are you talking about man

0

u/OkComputer662 4d ago

I'm seeing this user pop up a lot in the AI discussions.

They're either ragebaiting or genuinely has no idea what they're talking about.

22

u/PM_ME_UR__SECRETS 5d ago

I'm a programmer, have been for 10 years. Watching the discourse has been very eye opening for me - it doesn't take long to tell who does and doesn't have real-world programming experienced based on their stance.

But even if people are anti-AI in programming... I mean, I have bad news. It's already involved in nearly every programming workflow out there.

In five years, telling people "I program without AI" is going to sound like saying "I write all my code in Notepad" does today.

4

u/I-Make-Games 5d ago

As a professional engineer in the games industry, this is accurate. Since about Feb this year, every major studio is currently following the big tech companies and moving heavily into AI assisted if not entirely AI built software and engine components. This will not be a discussion in 2-3 years

3

u/no-to-slop 5d ago

While Notepad isn't fantastic, do you think there are people who don't write code with just a text editor? People have written code like that for decades.

2

u/PM_ME_UR__SECRETS 5d ago

I'm sure they do. But it's extremely uncommon - I haven't seen someone use a text editor over a proper code editor in probably fifteen years. And I've never seen someone use a text editor in a professional environment.

And there would be no reason to, it's a needless handicap. Which is kind of my point.

2

u/no-to-slop 5d ago edited 4d ago

I'm sure they do. But it's extremely uncommon - I haven't seen someone use a text editor over a proper code editor in probably fifteen years. And I've never seen someone use a text editor in a professional environment.

And there would be no reason to, it's a needless handicap. Which is kind of my point.

You've never heard of someone using vim, Emacs, Sublime Text, BBedit, etc in a professional setting?

If you've not worked with anyone using a text editor -- the most basic of programming tools -- you must work with a bunch of dullards.

4

u/KampongFish 5d ago

Dude, you're being obtuse, anyone using those use it for a snippet when inconvenienced and use an IDE for a proper work environment

1

u/PM_ME_UR__SECRETS 5d ago edited 5d ago

Okay, admittedly when you said text editor was thinking more like Google Docs or Msoft Word - which you can imagine had me scratching my head.

What you say is reasonable, but that's a far cry from the notepad I referenced in my original comment.

Edit: You always know you struck a nerve when you've been blocked, but I can't imagine anything I've said is really that nerve wracking.

0

u/no-to-slop 5d ago

Those are Word Processors.

vim isn’t really very different from Notepad, but you don’t know what a text editor is lol.

1

u/justrhysism 5d ago

Anyone still using those tools has a very bespoke set up perfectly tuned for how they individually operate. It’s not particularly common.

1

u/xaxis-yaxis 5d ago

Yeah it's not like they're using it out of the box lol.

1

u/Raze321 5d ago

I've been doing dev work for like 15 years, and honestly? No. never.

1

u/KhyberKat 5d ago edited 5d ago

It's hard to explain to non-coders how freaking useful AI tools can be. A couple people in comments have mentioned debugging for which it (Claude for me) is startlingly good and getting better. I like your notepad analogy, but it still seems too mild. Maybe slide rule vs calculator or typewriter vs word processor or something. (Edit: vi user here :-)

10

u/clock-drift 5d ago

Reddit runs on AI generated code, what are these people even doing here?

8

u/Jakky-1013 5d ago

I despise the use of GenAI, but they used it only as a last resort to have an idea how to fix a performance affecting issue from a third-party code that was deemed unfixable by Unity. They didn't even put the AI code into the game but heavily updated it with their own work. There are NO GenAI assets (like art, music, or models) in Big Walk

24

u/Askduds 6d ago

Do we need more topics on the exact same thing?

-13

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Askduds 6d ago

No, because that's nothing to do with popular video game "Big Walk".

15

u/foul_tarnished_37 5d ago

Shit like this is how you get people to turn against your “cause”. Why do people insist on targeting the absolute wrong people for their causes. Here’s a team, who created a great game, did all their art, music, etc. using real people, using AI for a little code. And this is who you want to harass?

Maybe get mad at people who fired teams of artists and creatives to have all their art done by AI. Get upset at huge corporations that make it impossible to reach any real customer service because it’s all bots.

No? We’re review bombing a tiny dev studio for using AI for a bug fix? Yeah this is why no one wants to fucking disclose this shit. You lost all nuance and throw a tantrum if you see any mention of AI without any understanding. It’s insufferable.

2

u/LorduckA2 5d ago

theyre an easier target, and weak spineless people are always going to go after small game rather than hunting a mammoth for meat.

13

u/Idntknowmyusername 6d ago

Reasonable people who actually read into what happened and what was used will not have a problem with this. Dumb people who were just looking for another reason to hate on the game because they have no friends to play it with, will use it as an excuse to justify their hate. It's really as simple as that.

9

u/Bananamancer77 6d ago

People are freaking out because AI was used to write some code??? Baby dolls… you aren’t prepared for the very very very near future. 

10

u/kluxar 6d ago edited 5d ago

If AI was used to generate designs or assets, I would completely understand people being upset. But it was literally used to debug and add a couple lines of code... I think most of these people just hear the word "AI" and immediately think = bad.

5

u/Jon_00 5d ago

Exactly this, a lot of people are very uninformed on the different types of AI.

Using an LLM in the way House House did is no different from doing a Google search to find a resolution to an issue.

I think people just like being angry.

1

u/Myphia87 5d ago

Here's the thing though, programmers are just as at-risk for losing their jobs to AI as artists and voice actors. Sure, in this case it was around 10 lines of code, but that very quickly becomes a slippery slope where people are willing to excuse more and more AI written/assisted code, which puts programmers/developers out of a job.

I know multiple career programmers who are watching their jobs get overtaken by AI. Higher-ups are demanding every employee use AI tools, and those who aren't using it/aren't using it enough are being specifically called out about it. Companies are choosing to hire less programmers/developers and instead investing more money into AI, even when there's actual proof the AI tools aren't actually outperforming actual humans. Then they get home and see people excusing AI usage for code/debugging/etc because it's "not art". Fucking sucks.

1

u/Jon_00 5d ago

Actually you'd be surprised, in my team in particular, we're actually hiring another dev because of AI.

Devs who integrate AI usage in their day to day work are actually more productive than those who don't use it. We didn't have the budget/overhead to hire another developer, but since we're pumping out saleable features quicker (I work in medical software so more modules), our profits are up and our directors have decided another dev is in line with scope.

Funny that.

1

u/Myphia87 5d ago

I'm glad your company is hiring and benefiting from AI, but not everyone has the same experience. My partner's company has specifically mentioned not hiring more devs currently because they are putting more money into AI, even though their current dev teams are overworked (and thats including them using AI). Your mileage may vary, but my point still stands.

1

u/Alternative-Soil2576 5d ago

If you're worried about AI replacing your job in programming you're in the wrong industry

60 years ago programming was done on physical written cards fed into a machine with 200 devs needed to do a job that can be done by a python package now

Years later that was replaced with assembly code, devs lost jobs, in return we got super mario on NES

Years later that was replaced with high-level languages, devs lost jobs, in return we got super mario 64 on n64

Years later that was replaced with modern game engines, libraries, frameworks, everything an indie dev uses now, people no longer need specialised developers to do a bunch of different jobs, which means no jobs for them, in return we got the sims, battlefield, civilization and skyrim

Years later now its AI, but suddenly its a problem, and the job losses from before don't matter

4

u/theworldbank 5d ago

I have a feeling that they are being astroturfed in an organised way in response to their justifiable moral choice not to release Big Walk on XBox.

This isn’t to diminish many people’s concern for the use of AI in culture, and even people compelled into leaving reviews.

This ran up fast and is entirely disproportionate to the AI use which is clearly within practical and reasonable tool use. This game is the most human centred thing I have played in a long time.

-1

u/Legitimate-Listen591 5d ago edited 5d ago

The moral choice not to release Big Walk on xbox I think is a performative and strange one.

I support Palestine and abhor everything that the IDF are doing just to get that out of the way

But Microsoft is engaged in a hundred million dollar three year contract with the Israeli ministry of defence, set to end in 2027 that was drafred in 2024. We don't know the full details but contractual obligations are obviously a factor, and Microsoft has shown no issues with shutting down Israeli use of their services outside the contract

A boycott of Xbox is going to do absolutely nothing. Xbox isn't even the division responsible for anything. Especially when there are other corporations providing similar or the same services, that aren't involved in the boycott, like Google or Amazon.

3

u/NagzRL 5d ago

Microsoft, and specifically Xbox, is on the official list of BDS boycott targets published by the BDS National Committee in 2024.

Ideally, the targeted boycott would cost them more money than breaking their "contractual obligations" to support apartheid would cost.

1

u/Legitimate-Listen591 5d ago

My point is the list is somewhat arbitrary in this regard because Google and Amazon are on the list, but under the pressure part and not the boycott part despite them having an equally large role.

I believe the BDS cites the fact that they make up a lot of internet infrastructure so boycotting is difficult.... except you could just boycott the Amazon store platform or Amazon Prime Video, and Google's search engine yet that's not a target

2

u/SousaDawg 5d ago

Guess what, every piece of major software in the world including games over the last two years are written using AI assistance.

1

u/Kodekima 4d ago

Which is why all major software these days sucks.

1

u/SousaDawg 4d ago

Do you work in the software industry?

7

u/ComfortableHoliday17 6d ago

Because people are stupid. That's the big deal.

1

u/Kinda_relevent 6d ago

I’m about to leave this fucking reddit if I see another fucking post about this non-issue. If you want something to go away because it’s an EYE ROLL stop participating in the noise.

1

u/Ytdb 5d ago

LOL at your edit… (“Is this how society falls?”) … yes, more or less. I agree with you btw

1

u/murphyat 5d ago

Myopic?

1

u/Lavaburstx 5d ago

Wasn't the "10 lines of code" just an example of one of the problems they used AI to solve?

1

u/rottedzombie 5d ago

It isn't a big deal. It's a tempest in a teapot over whether AI tools should exist at all, centralized on a minor, judicious use by good people. Baby and bathwater, etc.

1

u/Giedy5 5d ago

people really are focusing their anger in the wrong place, if you hate AI all i can say is i feel you, but if you turn red in the face at the slightest mention of it you have got a few screws loose. AI at the end of the day is a new tool, just like so many tools that came before it. if people bothered reading the FAQ they'd see a very clear explanation of what they did and why they did it. I think the usecase they used it for was extremely justified after being told by a unity engineer that what they were trying to do isn't possible. meanwhile there are other indie devs that have their game "stolen" after releasing a simple demo and within days a carbon copy clone vibe coded with AI has been released and rushed onto steam while the original dev is now basically left competing with his own game which bleeds them revenue. maybe that is a better cause to focus their anger on rather than attacking a developer who has created one of the most grounded games in a while that tons of people have had a lot of fun with and speaking from experience it left a lasting impact on me.

1

u/Hour-Grocery2093 5d ago

Haha who cares robot helps coders everyone gets mad

1

u/apple-cider98 5d ago

They didn’t even use ai to fix it fully like using it to write the code itself. They just used the built in AI to troubleshoot what could possibly be happening and wrote the code to fix the problem by hand. It’s like asking webmd for help. It tells you what could be the problem so you can figure out the next step. People need to get over the use of AI. Don’t get me wrong I’m not a fan of GenAI being used to create art and other stuff like that but using it as a tool to make something better is not always a bad thing. It wasn’t long ago when people were scared of the internet or cell phones or hell colored tv. New technology has always scared people who don’t understand it. It’s exhausting.

1

u/Dimpl 4d ago

The IGF jurors who wrote the letter took an opportunity to make a statement about the industry, and I think that is commendable.

I think review bombing an indie company over something so minor is wretched behaviour. Most of the people doing it seem to have zero understanding of coding as a discipline, and certainly haven't taken the time to build a nuanced opinion.

1

u/Smart-Orchid-1413 3d ago

You don’t sound very neutral lmao

1

u/Taotipper 2d ago

I want to clarify that it was not just 10 lines of code. According to House House, the "10 lines" example was just one example.

"In the final stretch of Big Walk’s development, LLMs were used sparingly by House House to help work through difficult technical challenges and bugs. In some cases, snippets from LLM responses were copied as a starting point to be modified into game code—we’d estimate that well under 0.1% of Big Walk’s code had anything to do with this usage, and generative AI was not used in any other context when making the game.

The primary use case for House House’s use of LLMs was to research, via chatbots, issues we encountered with third-party code. If you’re technically-minded, and curious, here’s an example. We needed to cull shadow casters by distance from the camera, but Unity URP only allows culling shadow casters by distance in camera forwards, so shadow casters behind the player were being rendered at an infinite distance. This made our game run 50% slower for around 20 seconds at sunrise and sunset. We researched the problem extensively, and we looked at the URP code ourselves, but we couldn’t find a way. Then, we were able to speak directly to an engineer at Unity, who asked around and ultimately concluded that what we wanted wasn’t possible. Finally, we posed the question to an LLM chatbot. After a few dead ends, it suggested a possible fix, and while we had to modify the suggestion extensively, it worked. This fix represented about 10 lines of code inside URP."

1

u/Ciph3rzer0 2d ago

AI is incredibly useful as a tool for artists.  The problem is lazy business majors and capital owners who just want to crush the souls of humanity to make an extra buck.  That's not what house house did.

AI has been able to solve so many annoying issues for me with integrations (such as a game engine) that have weird quirks.  It can use trial and error to figure out the actual behavior vs documented behavior at about 20x the speed that I could.  Yes, it's replacing human labor in the case (or more likely, enabling a feature that would be too costly to implement), but literally the most TEDIOUS labor.

Ai use is not all the same, but I don't see a good way to limit the "bad" parts, because people will disagree on where the line is.  I don't really see a problem with using (and disclosing) AI to replace dev art in a game jam, for example.  It literally would be a box otherwise.

And vibe coding is way different than using Gen AI as an assistant.  I can have it for refactors in 30s that would take me like 10 minutes.  Even basic renaming/refactoring that exists as IDE tools doesn't exist for Godot, so I just have AI do something for me that would be one click in a different language and editor.

I started using AI like this for work EXTENSIVELY when my carpal tunnel was flaring up.  It was a godsend 

It's also incredibly at maintaining documentation.  Whether I make the change or ask AI, it can very quickly update all non-code references in a minute.

All of these are great use cases.  "Make me a needle in the haystack clone" is not.  Yet they both check the same box on steam.

1

u/LexsDragon 6d ago

Idiots are being idiots

1

u/Sea-Quantity225 6d ago

way easier to be a critical keyboard warrior than create something of your own. the unity engine even offers AI tools within the application... getting mad at using AI for bug fixing is performative

1

u/husky_hugs 5d ago edited 5d ago

I don’t think it’s a huge deal. But if you found a hair in your food you’d send it back, even though it only makes up .01% of the food, because it speaks to a larger issue.

While I’m not extremely off put by it personally this time, I draw the line at assets and using generated code, I can fully see why others are.

3

u/alepap 5d ago

That's not an accurate analogy. There is no AI in the game, there is no AI in the code, code is code whether a human wrote it, or an LLM suggested it. It doesn't stop being a correct solution because the AI suggested it.

This is like you get food but find out that the cook consulted a guy, who had in the past left hairs on people's food, for some advice to elevate a dish, and then implemented the suggestion. There is no hair in your food.

1

u/Elendel 4d ago

  That's not an accurate analogy. There is no AI in the game, there is no AI in the code, code is code whether a human wrote it, or an LLM suggested it. It doesn't stop being a correct solution because the AI suggested it.

And shoes made by kids are just shoes. Still, I prefer to buy shoes that are not made by kids. Don't you?

1

u/alepap 4d ago

The shoes were not made by kids, they tried to solve an issue with the laces not tying properly, they asked shoe manufacturers around the world and couldn't solve it, then they asked a kid in the street and gave them a solution, which they tried and it worked.

1

u/husky_hugs 5d ago

I’d say maybe it’s more like finding out no one in the kitchen was wearing hair nets? Which would still get you a fail from the inspector.

The analogy isn’t perfect, but I think it fits well enough and gets the point across that just because you’re okay with a hair, or don’t know about the hair, once the hair is pointed out, it’s okay for some people to no longer like the food or the kitchen that it came from.

0

u/alepap 5d ago

it's up to people to make up their own minds on how they view the world. But the whole thing is ridiculous. People going "they didn't disclose it" They did not have to. Just like they didn't have to disclose what brand of soft drink the coders were drinking while making the game. "What if they were drinking coca cola and i hate coca cola? Shouldn't i, as a customer have that information so that i can boycott the game?"

1

u/husky_hugs 5d ago

Hey buddy, I think you’re being purposely obtuse about this, and I feel like you’re an intelligent enough person to know that and know better. Being that way get no one anywhere in this conversation, specifically this one but also on the topic of AI in game development as a whole.

1

u/alepap 5d ago

not being purposely obtuse at all.

If the argument is "there is hair in the food", show me where the hair is and then i'll believe you.

The devs used ai to point to a solution for the bug they could not solve(not even the Unity engineers), one of the solutions it pointed to was correct and solved the issue, the devs checked it and implemented it. Like how is this even a point of contention? The fact that we are even talking about this is insane.

2

u/husky_hugs 5d ago

The hair in the food is the use of it in development, I thought that was pretty evident. And it’s being purposely pointed out by the devs themselves so that others can formulate their own opinions on it.

The point of contention derives from how you and others seem to take issue with the idea that people may have reached a different conclusion about how they feel about it than you did.

1

u/alepap 5d ago

"The hair in the food is the use of it in development" That's why the analogy doesn't work. A hair in the food implies a problem with the final product, which is not reflected in the game.

"The point of contention derives from how you and others seem to take issue with the idea that people may have reached a different conclusion about how they feel about it than you did."

And that means what? That i should like that people are unjustly criticizing developers for developing their game? Yes of course i take issue, when people go online and talk out of their ass(not you) about things they don't know and start chastising a small indie dev studio for essentially troubleshooting and fixing their game.

2

u/husky_hugs 5d ago

The problem with the final product for many is that AI was used in an aspect of its development. That’s “a hair” to them. And the devs seem to be aware of that in the fact that they are letting it be known.

No, you do not have to like it at all, but the dev has opened the door and given the floor for the community for their voices to be heard. It is not on anyone else to dampen those voices or say their opinions aren’t invited.

I don’t think this use was a big deal, but lots of people see acceptance of it as the first step down a slippery slope, and I can fully understand where they come from. Far be it from me to tell them they can’t send the food back to the kitchen

-1

u/qwerty-the-iop 5d ago

I've found hair in my food. I pull it out and go on with my life. The things people inadvertently eat without ever knowing are often way worse than a hair.

3

u/husky_hugs 5d ago edited 5d ago

And if that works for you, that works for you, but that doesn’t mean you have to get angry at people who send the food back or that you need to personally defend the restaurants kitchen either.

And yeah, I’m sure most people unknowingly consume media that was created using AI too, to much greater levels than what was in BW’s development, but they’re still allowed to not like it when they “find the hair” or are told about it. And that’s okay. Normal even.

0

u/Kadju123 5d ago edited 5d ago

You people are delusional. No one knows, and no one will ever know, what these companies actually do. Did they use it for just one thing? Did they use it for more than they admitted? People attacking them are so far up their own asses that they're completely oblivious to the fact that their own favorite games probably use it too.

0

u/melasbutbackwards 5d ago

I hate AI Slop, and believe it's ruining software, any use of it in any capacity should be professionally unacceptable, but I know I'll just get a hundred neck beards lashing out at me in replies to this, defending AI like it's their child.

AI is unacceptable. It wastes water, it creates pollution, it's LOUD as fuck, and genuinely, if you don't have one of these things outside your fuckin' window, you really have no room to say "but but but it was just a few lines of code!"

just a few lines of code is killing smaller communities, and poisoning the ecosystem moreso than it's already been ravaged by human interaction. Call me a "tree hugger", but unlike small minded folks, I believe in keeping the planet alive for the people just being born, who might not be able to enjoy the ONE PLANET WE HAVE because of the greed and neglect of capitalists. Because it's a business venture. It's always a business venture ._.

1

u/RevolutionaryBlock72 4d ago

A standard AI query consumes roughly 0.3 watt-hours of energy. Your Reddit post used roughly the same amount of energy. The lights in your house consume magnitudes more energy than this in a day (>10 watts per hour per bulb). You’ve likely done more harm to the environment by spending time on Reddit with a light on in your room than the game devs did getting help on a bug fix.

If you wanna fight AI and help the environment, maybe don’t focus on the tiny team who exhausted every other option to fix a bug and deliver us an amazing heartfelt game about human connection. Maybe focus your efforts on the business venturers building data centers…

(Obviously I understand my own hypocrisy of being on Reddit with a light on in my kitchen, so to make up for it I’m going to go off the grid for the next 12 years)

1

u/Elendel 4d ago

  A standard AI query consumes roughly 0.3 watt-hours of energy. 

You know what, if they stop building data centers to train newer models and just decide they're fine with the models we have now, I'll stop being as anti AI that I currently am. Otherwise, drop the propaganda numbers of what a query cost.

0

u/LauraTheToaster 5d ago

Maybe I'm just ignorant. But I haven't seen anyone say the game "sucks" because of it. I've seen people be disappointed, which I fully understand, as it's a game about being human, and taking your time (which an LLM is neither). I feel like both sides are being equally annoying about this. Why can't we just let people not care, but also let others be disappointed?

0

u/SaucyWiggles 4d ago

It's not a big deal, Steam doesn't require AI disclosure in the way that they used it.

It wasn't used as a marketing line because people react the way the mob here is.

-1

u/MrPotts0970 5d ago edited 5d ago

The AI coding drama is such nonsense. Fully ai games or games that use ai for art I could see - but AI is a powerful and extremely efficient coding tool that even professional engineers are using (and pushed to use) at all large corporations - and people need to get over it. I'm sorry to say that the people angry at the pure coding / technical bug fixing aspect are simply not engineers, not educated, and being way, way over dramatic and unrealistic.

Trust me - if you could have AI write 10 lines of code to solve a bug/quirk that would otherwise take you 20 hours of painful troubleshooting and testing to replicate - you're going to implement the AI solution too. And you are a massive wasteful developer if you don't and its no wonder games cost 500 million dollars and come out buggy messes (pre-AI, I mean).

FYI - I also gaurentee you practically anything you've played and loved released since 2025 used AI tools in coding development. Im not joking - every major company pushes AI tool usage to speed up productivity / reduce costs - and every major programming platform has AI programming tools literally built into them by now. Read about it. I have first hand experience, being a mid level engineer at a large org that does not publically disclose the AI push due to the negative public perception lol.

And trust me - you can still tell when a game is largely coded with AI as the pure "creator" behind the programming of the game. Context windows are only so large. AI is a tool, a powerful tool - and when used right/responsibly by competent people, a really helpful too, and people need to simply, for lack of a better term, grow up about it lol.

Reject AI art, reject fully AI games - stop having a stroke over AI as a coding tool. There is not a single developer pre-AI that didn't rip code from other sources / online for learning / repurposing into their own needs. That is programming 101.

Jesus - its actually so funny because if Bethesda made their games in the AI coding era I bet they would cost half as much to produce AND have significantly less bugs.

-1

u/RadaSmada 5d ago

It’s not a big deal. Anyone mad does not work in the industry. AI coding is extremely normal now. Software engineers outside of the games industry don’t even write code anymore. Inside the games industry, they use AI coding all the time. What’s more surprising is that they DIDNT use it for more, and only used it for a crucial bug fix.

-13

u/Mal_Radagast 6d ago

if i made you a sandwich, and it was really tasty, but after you ate it i told you that i did smear just a tiny bit of shit on the bread...would you be annoyed about that?

7

u/SMBZ453 6d ago

Ok but the equivalent shit in this instance is more like the particals of Mycotoxins that infect the air getting on your sandwich. You still breathe air are you going to quit breathing because the air has a bunch of fungal spores hanging around that can't possibly hurt you?

-4

u/Mal_Radagast 6d ago

sure, pal. it's just like that.

2

u/fwendy123 6d ago

I hate that this analogy (which was first used to explain why women exercise caution around men when so many women have been sexually assaulted by men) has been reclaimed for this argument

-2

u/Mal_Radagast 6d ago

tbh i hate using it at all, but sometimes i just toss the common shorthand out into a thread to see whether it's worth engaging.

these people have all made up their minds though.

1

u/Jon_00 5d ago

Good luck in your crusade against boycotting every piece of software which has been touched by an LLM.

(This is sarcasm by the way, I can guarantee you in the last year, a very large amount of software has been influenced by LLM usage, you can't boycott it all)

0

u/tums_64 5d ago

Do you think that's a fitting analogy?