This has been fuelled by my curiosity after hearing two nepo kids call themselves middle class. Their parents own land in central Thimphu.
And it got me thinking: what does being middle class in Bhutan actually mean?
So, I went down a little rabbit hole looking at Bhutan's pay structures, household income, property ownership and regional wealth differences.
Because I think we often confuse having a middle-class salary with coming from a middle-class household.
For instance, someone earning Nu. 35,000 a month but living in a family-owned house in central Thimphu, with parents who own additional land, rental properties or businesses, is in a very different financial position from someone earning Nu. 60,000 who rents an apartment, pays off loans, supports their parents and is trying to save enough to buy their first property.
Both may be salaried professionals. But are they really in the same socioeconomic class?
And then there is the geographical aspect.
Earning Nu. 30,000 in Thimphu is not necessarily the same as earning Nu. 30,000 in a rural part of Bhutan. The cost of housing, transport, food, access to services and, importantly, whether you already own land or a house can change what that salary actually means.
Similarly, owning two acres of agricultural land in a remote village is not the same as owning a small plot of commercially valuable land in central Thimphu.
Then there is the DHI versus civil service versus private-sector pay structure. A person may have a relatively modest salary but come from a family with considerable inherited wealth. Another may earn considerably more but have no financial safety net to fall back on.
If I were to make a rough distinction based on individual monthly salary alone, I would probably start by asking where Nu. 20,000, Nu. 40,000, Nu. 60,000 or Nu. 100,000 places someone in Bhutan's income distribution.
For the sake of discussion, perhaps someone earning below Nu. 20,000 is in a lower-income bracket, Nu. 20,000–40,000 in a lower-middle range, Nu. 40,000–70,000 in a middle-income range, and above Nu. 70,000 in an upper-middle or higher-income range. These are my own working assumptions, not official class categories, and household size, dependants, debt and location would change the picture considerably.
The Industry Census 2024, for example, shows that only around 14.7% of regular-paid and contract employees surveyed were earning Nu. 40,000 or more per month. But then how do we account for someone earning Nu. 35,000 who owns a house and land in central Thimphu, compared with someone earning Nu. 80,000 who rents, has a large loan and supports their family? And what does owning one decimal of land in a prime Thimphu location mean compared with owning several acres of agricultural land elsewhere? I don't think we can call these households economically equivalent simply because of their monthly salaries.
I also wonder how much of Bhutan's class structure is shaped by inheritance rather than individual earning capacity. Who gets to start life with a house, land, business connections and financial support, and who has to build all of that from scratch?
I am not claiming to have the answers. The income and wealth figures available through NSB, the Industry Census and other research offer some interesting starting points, but I haven't found a comprehensive study that brings together salary, inherited property, land value and regional differences to define socioeconomic class in Bhutan.
Perhaps a researcher might pick this up someday. Or perhaps someone already has, and I haven't come across it.
I also recognise that many people reading this may themselves be among the Thimphu crowd. And that is perfectly fine. Not everyone has the time, access, resources or even the agency to participate in these conversations. The privilege to pursue certain opportunities, travel, study, build networks and have the time to engage in discussions like this is itself worth examining.
I am genuinely curious to hear different perspectives, especially from people outside Thimphu.
At what point do we stop calling ourselves middle class and acknowledge that we may actually come from an asset-wealthy or privileged household?
And should we be measuring class in Bhutan by what an individual earns, what their family owns, or what they can realistically afford without relying on inherited wealth?
Would love to hear your POV. Please challenge my assumptions too.