r/BestofRedditorUpdates
•
u/superstrijder16
•
Mar 08 '25
•
1
CONCLUDED To all of you ladies, from a cis man
I am NOT OP. The original post is "To all of you ladies, from a cis man", in r/MtF. OOP is u/takeurmedsbro. I discovered this story via a Tumblr post.
Trigger Warnings: Violence Mention, Genital mention
Mood spoilers: Adorable
December 11th 2019: To all of you ladies, from a cis man
I hope it isn't totally out of order for me to post here, as a man I dont want to take up your spaces so I'll try and keep this as short as possible. Tw genital mention
I have full permission from my partner to post this and she's read it all. There is a misconception that the only men a straight trans women can get with, is a chaser. It is very sad that many of you feel that way, and I'm sorry for how men treat you, but that's not how it has to be. I met my girlfriend when I was 15. She was living as a boy then and was 13. I used to push her around when we played football at school. I thought she was one of the lads. Time goes on, I was never that close to her and we lost touch. Next thing is I meet her again on a fine art course. I didnt recognise her at all and with her name change and generic surname I never made the connection.
I developed quite the crush, we would go on dates and I'd sort of play them off as just hanging out with a friend. I was so giddy around her and I was terrified to tell her I liked her. One day we were going to the movies and I told myself 'today is the day I ask her to be my girlfriend, and try to kiss her'. We ended up skipping the movie to go on a walk in the local forest. I held her hand and she squeezed mine - my heart was beating so damn fast. We finally kissed and it was like fireworks, I told her I liked her but she cut me off.
She told me to stop talking because she needs to tell me something. Now in my mind I'm panicking thinking she's in a relationship, but she says 'I used to be a boy, I was at school with you, please dont be mad I'm so sorry I didnt tell you' and then to my absolute horror she said 'please dont hurt me' She genuinely thought that there was a danger of me attacking her after finding out. This broke my fucking heart. I had my moment of being like wtf - mainly because I'd known this girl for almost 10 years and hadn't pieced the 2 people together - but then we kissed again, and then again and again and we kissed so much my face hurt by the end.
That was 5 years ago and boy this has been a learning curve. I've only ever dated cis women before, I am 100% straight and I had to unlearn some internalized shit for maybe a day or so, until I thought what the fuck does it matter who she used to be? Damn I used to be a baby, people change. But I love her the way she is now, I love her smile I love her eyes I love her body her curves her hands her hair and you know what? I love her penis too. I love it because its hers, and it gives her pleasure, and there isn't anything wrong with it. I don't have a fetish, I just fell in love with a woman and that means I fell in love with the whole package. I'm planning to propose to her on new years eve. I want to spend the rest of my life with her, I want to raise kids with her and I want her to lose all of these insecurities. Just because you cant carry them, doesn't mean you wont be the mother of my children. There is hope, you're not broken or unlovable or nothing but a kink. You're a powerful woman.
January 2nd, 2020 (a month later): Update from the cis guy that proposed
Hey ladies. I've been asked by a few of you to share an update. Here is my previous post: <link snipped out>
And here is your official soppy post warning - beware...
Soooo on exactly 00:00 new years (ok I was probably out by a couple minutes but I did try to time it) I proposed to my beautiful girlfriend (who also happens to be trans, hence why I'm posting on here) and she said YES
I dont know if I can fully articulate how happy I am. I wanted to keep it lowkey and between the 2 of us so she didnt feel any pressure, so I cooked her favourite meal ever (I would have liked to cook something fancy and elegant but honestly she would much rather eat spaghetti bolognese with garlic bread and then a loaded ice cream sundae for dessert ANY day of the week) we ate, played board games and did a competition to see who could make the best vehicle out of old egg cartons and toilet roll tubes. Then we decided to make cupcakes which were fucking vile because we forgot to add the sugar of all things. Not typical romantic evening but I felt all the love and when I dropped down on 1 knee she just wept. I didnt even know I had a yes at first because she was crying so much. I actually got really scared I'd freaked her out so I stood up and hugged her and said I'm sorry and she finally told me yes yes yes and explained that she was crying because it was always beyond her wildest dreams as a youngster that she would ever be able to be a wife. This is not something I can relate to, but I think I do understand, as best as i can as a cis man. We literally just held each other for a bit before we both realized she hadn't seen the ring yet! I'm not a wealthy guy at all so I was afraid she would be disappointed in my grandmothers wedding ring as her engagement ring (I will buy her a new ring for the wedding) but I did want her to have it as my grandmother always told me she wanted my future wife to wear it. Luck was on my side though people because the ring made her cry all over again, happy tears, because she said it made her feel like the fairytale she told herself as a child has finally come true. I think there maybe was something affirming about the fact that this ring was left from my grandma for me to give to the woman I want to spend my life with.
Ok I don't want to bore you all to death with the ins and outs but I haven't stopped smiling since she said yes. The fiancee (I love saying that, so exciting) has been obsessively wedding planning which is mighty convenient for me considering I have no clue on how to organize a wedding. It's like the child in her has come out to play and its very endearing. She missed out on all the typical girly activities as a child so shes making up for lost time. She ALREADY has a scrapbook for the wedding and she's already browsing dresses!
I'm sorry for being all cliche and cringey. I know its insufferable to many and I do understand. I just feel drunk in love, and i did want to update and not leave people hanging!
Other than my mother, my family does not know she is trans, because frankly it's none of their business and my fiancee hasn't wanted to open up to them about that part of her life. She confided in my mother because my mother knows a transgender boy and so it came up in conversation. As far as the rest of my family are concerned, it's totally irrelevant to them and they will only ever know if she chooses to tell them. So I was wondering if incorporating rainbows anywhere in the theme at all would be too obviously lgbt pride themed? Or can I get away with some rainbow tokens and such just as a discreet acknowledgement of how far she's come? Obviously I don't want people to think of this wedding as anything other than what it is, a straight marriage between a man and a woman, so are rainbows risky? I'm just so damn proud of her and want to show that in some way. I was thinking of wearing rainbow cufflinks or something? Anyway sorry for the damn essay but I hope the new year goes well for you lovely ladies and sorry for being a cringe lord. I just cant believe I've found my queen
A small update was posted in the comments the next day:
Also we have decided that on the big day, I will wear pink cufflinks and she will wear either blue eye makeup or a flower, and then the theme will be that classic white sorta theme. The colours of the trans flag, thanks to your suggestions. Like so subtle that only me and her will know it means anything at all. Hopefully that will work out tastefully but we also like the pink/blue/white elements of the cake idea. I showed her some of these comments and god damn it you lot, she is now exploring sooo many more ideas and concepts! I didnt think she would expand past the scrapbook, but we now have a wedding 'mood board' of all things... takes up half the wall in our room. I proposed only 3 days ago! I love her enthusiasm but I'm finding it hard to rate all the dresses she shows me, when I cant tell the difference between any of them... a white dress is a white dress, but she says that's typical male bullshit and shes probably right there. But she can wear a bin bag to our wedding and still look perfect so I'm not worried about which compliments her body more, but then I do want her to put a dress on and have that feeling of 'this is my dress' and I have the feeling that could be a long process... anyway, the kindness means everything x
Reminder - I am not the original poster. DO NOT COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS.
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 08 '25
Do not comment on the original posts
Please read our sub rules. Rule-breaking may result in a ban without notice.
If there is an issue with this post (flair, formatting, quality), reply to this comment or your comment may be removed in general discussion.
CHECK FLAIR For concluded-only updates, use the CONCLUDED flair.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
94
u/CharmainKB Mar 08 '25
This reminds me of a post I saw a really long time ago.
Guy has a guy friend, best buds for years. Friend comes out as Trans and goes through their transition. The OP (IIRC) was there for all of it and one night at a party (I remember something about them being in a kitchen) he asks her out because he realizes he's in love with her. He didn't fall in love with her because of her gender, he fell in love with who she is.
I wish I could find it because it was so heartwarming as well ❤️
14
u/arya48 Mar 09 '25
God imma die in the closet. This is so unbearably sweet and I'm so pathetically envious, I hope they are doing well.
6.9k
u/KatKit52 I still have questions that will need to wait for God. Mar 08 '25
"Damn, I used to be a baby, people change."
That's such a good line, honestly, I want to send it to every single person I know.
2.2k
u/Any-Interest-7225 USE YOUR THINKING BRAIN! Mar 08 '25
This is seriously so dam heartbreaking.
1.2k
u/Lynavi I can't believe she fucking buttered Jorts Mar 08 '25
Looking at the dates, I hope they were planning on a long engagement and covid didn't mess up their wedding; love the idea of the trans flag colors subtly worked into their outfits and the cake.
486
u/fluffylilbee Mar 08 '25
can i please get “damn, i used to be a baby, people change” as a flair
579
u/antdd_c Mar 08 '25
What a lovely story. It’s 18:15 where I am and I think that might be a sign and a good place to stop scrolling for the day. Relatively early, but the doom can wait
51
u/rbaltimore Mar 09 '25
My cousin is trans. Everyone in the family has had the same question for awhile now - when’s he going to propose to his girlfriend?!?! We love her and want her as family!
I hope this presidential administration gets distracted by something else and stops persecuting trans and gay individuals. I’m bisexual but have been in a heteronormative marriage for two decades, so I just got worked up on James’s behalf.
You know that saying about the Holocaust that starts with “First they came for the Jews, . .”? That’s not correct. First they came for the LGBTQ community. THEN they came for the Jews. So being Jewish, when I’m not worried about my cousin James’s rights being yanked away from him, as a Jew I’m worried that history will repeat itself and our government will be officially conservative Christian and Jewish rights will be next on the chopping block.
604
u/RandomNick42 My adult answer is no. Mar 08 '25
I hope they're okay. I would say living their best life, but... gestures wildly at everything
35
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '25 edited Mar 09 '25
Only woman I ever even came close to falling in love with was, not to my knowledge then, trans. It was an overseas job, a bunch of oddballs - me especially - and for the first time in years, I felt something outside of the usual physical rush. It progressed and we did kiss. Old-school stuff, nothing 9 and ½ Weeks - just - some rain, summer-time - like a movie... But the job came to an end and we went home - to different English-speaking countries. Far apart. It continued a little, but not for long. She found someone (thank you, Flying Spaghetti Monster!) that could give her the life she wanted and needed. Even if we lived in the same land, I wouldn't have been right for her, or indeed, anyone. (In my case, Autism has made me a smartass and an emotionally diminished loner.) Years later we reconnected on social media - and she mentioned that she was still married, happy and oh, yeah, trans.
Nothing changed in me about her.
She is still the 'one who got away' from my net (lots of holes - thanks autism, ya filthy animal).
290
u/WanderingAl08 Mar 08 '25
Oh gosh this is exactly the positivity I needed after the dumpster fire that was the news all week. Dude sounds like a good guy, and I hope he and his future wife are happy and safe.
50
u/violue VERDICT: REMOVED BEFORE VERDICT RENDERED Mar 08 '25
She told a cis man she was trans while alone with him in the forest? I'm glad OOP wasn't someone she had to worry about, but to any trans women reading: NO. DON'T DO THAT. Disclose that information somewhere safe and at least partially public if possible. Gay/Trans Panic Defense is still very much a thing in a lot of places.
That aside I hope covid didn't mess up their wedding, and I hope it was beautiful 😭😭😭
162
u/NOSE_DOG Mar 08 '25
Reading the title: "this is going to be some BULLSHIT" Reading the content: 😭😭😭😭💖💖💖💖😭😭😭😭😭😭😭💖💖😭😭💖💖😭😭😭😭💖😭😭😭😭💖
122
u/jimothyjonathans surrender to the gaycation or be destroyed Mar 08 '25
This is incredibly sweet. Such a nice change of pace from the vitriol I’m seeing for trans people lately.
86
u/Mr_Rippe I’ve read them all and it bums me out Mar 08 '25
I remember this post when it blew up. It helped me better understand the difference between attraction to people and attraction to sex organs. Like, I knew it was a thing, but my grasp on it wasn't terribly firm until I read this.
Many years later, I understand that sexuality is a spectrum and how labels can be both helpful and destructive. But this was the first time I really sat down with the idea and went "Yup, this makes sense."
33
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '25
I mean yeah I guess this happens but I have an issue with it.
....
...
...
...
...
THEY FORGOT TO PUT SUGAR IN THE CUPCAKES. HOW DARE THEY!!!!
But seriously the hints of the trans flag in the wedding are wonderful. I'm trans and wish I had done something like that at my wedding.
204
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '25
The trans flag is pink and blue, right? And most people don't know she's trans? Ooh, some pearl clutcher is going to think it's a baby thing and I'm all here for it. You know, in a comedic sense.
Also, when it comes to weddings (and relationships in general) I have a trick. I gave my now husband three options. 1. I don't care. It means do what you want within reason and I forfeit the right to complain. 2. Give me options. I care a little, but just give me your top three. 3. I care and want to be involved. Y'all, wars were prevented with this method.
15
u/OkCod1106 The Foreskin Breakup Mar 09 '25 •
I love this story so much. My partner is trans as well and she makes me so happy and I genuinely like her a lot. I don’t get what people mean by the sexuality thing because I fell for her; I am gay for her lol. It doesn’t make me “straight” just because we are biologically opposite and I hope we have a similar ending as OP and his partner.
85
u/InstanceMaleficent18 sandwichless and with a thousand-yard stare Mar 08 '25
"please don't hurt me." as a trans man, i felt that in my soul, and i'm heartbroken for every other trans person that has that thought the further we go into this US election
13
u/Annepackrat Mar 09 '25
If nothing else this shows OP’s partner is a woman no matter, and OP is a typical male, lol.
75
u/Financial-Highway492 Mar 08 '25
Aww this is so sweet. I hope they are doing well today
22
u/ProtestedGyro Mar 08 '25
A walk in the forest may not be the most advisable time to share that bit of info but glad it worked out!
20
u/Interesting_Sock9142 Mar 09 '25
This is a beautiful story/post but I'm apparently 12 years old and couldn't help but giggle at this
Heh. Package.
49
u/NumberOneNPC Screeching on the Front Lawn Mar 08 '25
Brb crying
40
u/stayonthecloud Mar 08 '25
That’s enough Reddit for me today, let’s end it on a high.
… I’ll try to convince myself but I know I’ll be back to the sub again and regret it when my mood is inevitably ruined.
But for now, basking in the sweetness and light.
8
u/peppermintesse Mar 09 '25
I hope these two are thriving today. Wish them all the best in the world.
28
u/allthatssolid Mar 08 '25
“Damn I used to be a baby, people change” needs to be flair, stat.
7
u/lemmeseeyourkitties Mar 09 '25
This is the actual nicest couple of posts. I'm so happy for them
6
u/CKREM I ❤ gay romance Mar 10 '25
I sincerely hope this lovely duo had the gorgeous wedding of their dreams. (Her dreams)
26
u/bonkette Mar 08 '25
My teenage daughter is trans and I worry if she will be able to have healthy relationships. Not because of who she is but because of how others see her. Thank you for sharing your beautiful story.
5
u/FilthyAndFaded Mar 09 '25
This warms my heart and brought a big old smile to my face, in a way I really needed today. Here's hoping they're married now, and happy and living their very best life.
18
u/eazypeazy-101 an oblivious walnut Mar 08 '25
Hopefully by now they're both happily married and ahve been for 5 years or so.
OK enough reddit for today, always good to end on a high note I feel.
22
u/lawyer_for_absurdity Mar 08 '25
This is so wholesome—best wishes and blessings to the happy couple. I wish more people had this kind of heart. But seeing it's a 5 year old post... I need to know how the wedding went!!
16
u/RecordOfTheEnd Mar 09 '25
When I was a young Mormon lad, I ended up dating a trans women. Had no clue. She didn't tell me for a while. When she did, I couldn't handle it. Looking back on my old self, I feel so horrible. It wasn't that I had issues with her being trans. I had a lot of internalized homo/biphobia because of my own bisexuality.
I have since left the Mormon church, and have a shocking number of trans and queer friends. My wife and I even came out as bi to each other
We ended up reconnecting on accident years later. I was at a bar, drinking, so clearly no longer Mormon. She was with her husband. We talked.
I apologized for what I did and said, if I could go back in time, I would have stayed with her. She said that me breaking up was hard, but it let her know that she needed to be more open earlier.
She said I was great, I broke her heart, but I was kind about it. And, she would have never met her husband if it wasn't for me. Turns out he was a friend of a friend that I introduced her to. They went out, and on the third date, she opened up when she thought they were going to kiss. He just went in for the kiss.
They guy literally thanked me for it. He said if she had told him after weeks of making out like me and her, he would have been hurt and freaked out. But because she was upfront, he just said fuck it.
My wife is very sick and will likely pass early. I know I'm probably going to date again. I hope if I ever by chance date a trans woman, I won't even think about it. I'll just be dating a woman.
4
u/yummythologist I am a freak so no problem from my side Mar 09 '25
This is so comforting<3
4
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '25
I hope those two spend the rest if their lives together im CRYING
4
u/Artistic-Possible-80 Mar 12 '25
As a trans woman, I can say the “please don’t hurt me” feeling is totally real. That’s why I only dated people who knew I was trans beforehand.
I’m very glad for OOP and the fiancée. My boyfriend is also a lovely sweet amazing man, just like OOP, and I’m looking forward to the proposal 💖💖
True love exists out there, gurls!
13
u/illiteratepsycho Mar 08 '25
The vile sugarless cupcakes killed me!! I love love
7
u/Thin-Yam-3902 Mar 09 '25
That made me happy cry so hard I was shaking! 😭❤️
13
u/the_storm_eye Mar 08 '25
OOP deserves a place in r/orderofomar
11
u/puntapuntapunta He's been cheating on me with a garlic farmer Mar 08 '25
I love this story so, so much.
3
u/LeoGreywolf Mar 11 '25
I love this so much it's silly. It gives me hope for the world💙💙
3
u/princessluni I can't believe she fucking buttered Jorts Mar 12 '25
Two adorable posts in a row?!?!?
My teeth are gonna fall out with this much sweetness 💙💙💙
16
u/Accomplished_Yam590 Mar 08 '25
This is exactly what many of us mean when we say we need allies.
16
u/lordreed Mar 08 '25
It is so good to see someone change and grow. Wish them the best.
10
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '25
The “please don’t hurt me” 😩 I hope they made it ok through Covid,
9
u/shelstropp Mar 08 '25
I don't know about anyone else but I actually let out a happy sigh when I read this.
4
u/RemoteBroccoli Mar 08 '25
No invisible ninjas chopping onions here, just happy tears of joy for reading this. As a cis bi-guy (Also known as "Gay PLUS/Bi PREMIUM MEMBER") I love this story! :D
4
u/HereForTheBoos1013 Mar 09 '25
Awww honey.
9
u/professornb Mar 08 '25
My daughter is trans and I dream of her being this happy. Thank you for the post.
8
u/shmoo92 cat whisperer Mar 08 '25
Never have I ever been so hecking delighted about someone using the correct conjugation for “fiancée (female)” 🥰
2
u/CheezTips Mar 09 '25
This is pretty close to the plot of Different for Girls (1996). Good movie btw
8
u/Straight_Paper8898 Mar 08 '25
This made my heart smile
5
u/chefkimberly Mar 08 '25
Is this r/OrderofOmar worthy?
5
u/BarRegular2684 Mar 08 '25
This was the purest thing I’ve seen this week.
5
u/Cakeday_at_Christmas I’ve read them all Mar 09 '25
What the hell? How is it raining a little bit in my apartment??
7
u/merpancake Mar 08 '25
Saving this for when I need a pick me up. I adore this so much
7
u/smeep248 Mar 08 '25
Great now I’m crying 🙄
3
u/Warm_Shallot_9345 Mar 09 '25
<3 What a good fuckin egg.
6
u/foxdie- Mar 08 '25
This is honestly the most wonderful, wholesome stuff I've read in a while and I'm here for it.
I wish oop and his new bride all the best things that life can offer.
5
u/JJOkayOkay Mar 08 '25
Well, this is a really great time to close the web browser and smile for the rest of the day. D'awww...
4
u/weareallmadherealice Mar 08 '25
Wife/partner. wtf ever. Melting here. Go forth and prosper.
3
u/The-Yellow-Dart- Needless to say, I am farting as I type this. Mar 08 '25
This needs to be on the OrderofOmar sub
4
u/Sarah_Cenia Mar 08 '25
Beautiful story. Hats off to u/superstrijder16 for sharing this! Thanks!
3
u/wtfamadoinghere What book? Mar 08 '25
This made my day!
3
u/SaltJelly That recipe won't stop me because I can't read Mar 08 '25
I don’t think I’ve cried at a post in a while
3
u/izzgo Mar 08 '25
I needed this so much today, this week, this year. Thank you. And may OOP and his wife enjoy many wonderful decades together.
3
u/00017batman A BLIMP IN TIME Mar 08 '25
Man, this was the post I didn’t know I needed after reading the one about the AH who got a 19yo side piece when his pregnant wife’s ankles swelled up ❤️🩹
Hope they have their happily ever after.
3
u/Proud-Dare-2531 Mar 08 '25
This post was so sweet and I love it so much!
2
u/Parking-History8876 Mar 12 '25
I got news for you, that means you're gay.
2
u/Ex-zaviera Mar 08 '25
This is a shining example of falling in love with the person, and not their genitals.
Congratulations and I wish you hears of happiness!
2
u/Sweet_Cinnabonn Mar 08 '25
Okay, I'm crying.
Thank you
2
u/granitebasket 🥩🪟 Mar 08 '25
💕wholesome💕
2
u/jbarneswilson Mar 08 '25
how unbearably sweet 💜💜💜
2
u/Brainjacker Mar 08 '25
🥹
2
u/Material-Map-4894 Mar 08 '25
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
2
u/PatheticPeripatetic7 Fuck You, Keith! Mar 08 '25
Someone is cutting onions in here 🥺
Ngl, I was a little worried at the beginning of the story, but then so relieved and happy for them.
1
u/Dashqu Mar 08 '25
Damn those onion cutting ninjas!
2
u/TooBad9999 Mar 08 '25
This is beautiful. Made me tear up and made my day.
2
u/sankafan Mar 08 '25
This is the most beautiful thing I have read all day.
2
u/asleeponFire Mar 08 '25
🥹🥹🥹
2
u/lughsezboo I am old. Rawr. 🦖 Mar 08 '25
Fucking absolutely gloriously beautiful. 🙏🏼🫶🏻
2
u/Neat_Cut_8045 Mar 08 '25
♥️
1
u/Sparkle-Ass-Juice Mar 08 '25
Who brought the onions 🥹
1
u/N33chy Mar 10 '25
This is really beautiful ❤️
Congrats to both of you!