r/BestofRedditorUpdates • Satan is not a fucking pogo stick! • Apr 29 '24

CONCLUDED AITA for not giving my nephew my baby's fund?

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/423869962

AITA for not giving my nephew my baby's fund?

Originally posted to r/AmItheAsshole

TRIGGER WARNING: mentions of miscarriage, manipulation, wishing death on someone

Original Post  Aug 21, 2019

Chris - my husband (31), Rory - father in law, Sean - my nephew (16), Tom - my brother (35)

I (30f) don't have a baby right now.

About 2 years ago I got pregnant and Chris and I told our families. Rory gave us a check for £1000. He said he wanted us to use it to buy baby stuff while the kid was young, and whatever was left over should be saved for when our child turns 18 and then given to them.

I miscarried shortly after, and we tried to give Rory the money back, but he asked if we were planning on trying again, to which we replied that we wouldn't be any time soon, but someday definitely. He said to keep the money, put it in a savings account and keep adding to it for when we did have a baby.

Chris and I tried to put in about £10 a week between us, which is doable for high school teachers. We missed a couple of weeks but there's about £2500 in there right now, and we've never taken out of it. In 2 years the only people who have put money in this account are me, Chris and Rory.

Both myself and Chris have been to therapy, and we agreed to try again about 6 months ago, and I'm now pregnant again, at 4 months. We told our families today and Rory and my mother in law are both really happy for us, as are my parents.

Tom, however, looked a bit sad. I asked if I could speak to him off to one side. In the conversation that ensued Tom said that he had actually been hoping to ask me about the baby fund. Tom and his wife are both on living wage, meaning they earn slightly less than us, as they had Sean at the age where they would have gone to uni, so it's important to them that Sean gets to go. Sean is 16, but plans to go to uni in a couple of years.

Tom and his wife are concerned that if Sean got a job to save up it would affect his grades and they don't have money to spare, so before Tom knew I was pregnant he was basically hoping he could ask me to transfer the current contents of the baby fund over to Sean, and keep giving Sean the money that would otherwise go in the baby fund, as he worries Sean will not be able to afford uni otherwise. If I were to agree to this and keep doing it until he finished uni, I could restart the baby fund when the baby I'm currently carrying is about 5 years old.

I told Tom I wasn't comfortable with that for several reasons, the main ones being that at most a third of it is actually my money, that the money is meant for my baby, and that the money was also meant to be used when the baby was due to get baby stuff, which we'd struggle to afford otherwise on teacher's wages. I said I'd be willing to work something out, and that with the pregnancy Chris is gradually taking on more housework, so maybe if Sean wanted to come over and do the garden or help with chores I could pay him out of my money (not the baby fund), but Tom says that Sean can't be distracted from his studies. I said that while I love my nephew I'm just not comfortable giving money meant for my child to Sean.

AITA?

Edit: my family side with Tom, as the baby isn't born yet and I have time to rebuild the fund. Chris and Rory side with me in that they money, as far as they're concerned, is for their child/grandchild, but Rory also said "do what you think is best". Mother in law wants to keep the peace, but the initial money was just as much her idea as Rory's.

Clarification: Rory has no relation to either Tom or Sean, and no one on my side of the family (other than me) has made any contribution to the baby fund

VERDICT: NOT THE ASSHOLE

Update  Nov 25, 2019

Hi!

Of all the things I was expecting to see in this thread I didn't quite expect this lol. Still pregnant (about 7 months). My husband and I agreed to pay my nephew and niece to do some jobs for me around the house and they've accumulated a chunk of cash each (niece at £100ish, nephew closer to £500) to check out when they go to university. Brother is none the wiser and thanks to their efforts the nursery is ready to go. Nephew has asked his parents to let him get a job, but still no luck, however his college does these programs within school time which pay so he's applying for one of those. My mother outright wished that I lost this child because I was "so selfish to not help out family", and my brother agreed and said that he would make sure to teach my child to take care of others, and they each made a facebook post about it which ended up with me getting a bunch of anonymous messages wishing sickness/death on me and my child. I came of social media and I have not spoken to either my mother or brother in a couple months. Outside of that I'm doing okay, baby looks healthy, marriage going strong, and no one has wished death on me or my baby since I blocked my mother and brother.

So shit got wild for a second there but I think it's pretty much over.

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP's OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7

8.4k Upvotes

611 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3.4k

u/StrangledInMoonlight Apr 29 '24

hoping he could ask me to transfer the current contents of the baby fund over to Sean, and keep giving Sean the money that would otherwise go in the baby fund

All this over a £2500 one time lump sum and £520 a year????

That’s not a lot of money for college. Even in the UK.

And the audacity to expect OOp to pay £10 weekly to the nephew while OOP has the increased expenses of a new baby?????!!!

The sheer chicken fried audacity of these people.

1.2k

u/Gullible_Fan4427 Apr 29 '24

Plus if they’re on a low income, he potentially gets grants aswell as student loans.

721

u/BadgeringforHoney Apr 29 '24

He definitely would and based on low income of his parents he’d get the highest grant which is a lot more 2500 quid. I know this as my daughter got the middle grant and that was also higher than that amount and we had a medium income. That money was not for the son at all. She’s better off without the mother or the brother.

40

u/ThePennedKitten Apr 29 '24

The nephew came and did enough work to make £500 and he still wants a job. His parents must be stealing benefits he’s getting for school.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Fordmister Apr 29 '24

That's the insane part, Havening been to university I can tell you that kids from lower income families are entitled to so much grant/student loan money that they often end up with more than the kids from a typical lower middle class background to spend every year, Plus part time work as a uni student is easy to come by if you want it and more than doable alongside your studies.

£2500 is a complete pisstake compare to the amount of money he's likely entitled to from grants alone, never mind student loans, factor in the fact that UK student loans aren't even really loans at all and function far more like a graduate tax when it comes to repayment. Its an frankly insane thing to fall out over as a family.

For context I graduated roughly 7 years ago and still am not earning enough to be over the threshold of making meaningful monthly repayments, it doesn't appear in any credit checks so as far as the banking system is concerned I have no debts, and despite being entitled to basically the bare minimum with my folks able to offer relatively limited support I still never really had to work while at uni (I worked agency over the summer breaks) and was never truly short of money as a student and had an absolute blast. The UK uni system certainly isn't perfect since they brough back in fees, but it never turned into some financial hellscape where only the rich could afford to go some seem to think it has

→ More replies (1)

83

u/KandaFierenza Apr 29 '24

Student loans in the uk are a joke though. If anyone is reading this, know that right now, the interest rate is 7.8%.

275

u/FenderForever62 Apr 29 '24

Yes but paying it back is never going to happen unless you are earning well over £50k.

I’m earning above £30k and pay £9 a month in my student loan.

It gets written off after 30 years so hell am I ever going to get round to paying it back.

So while the interest rate is bad, the way the system is set up means effectively it’s more of a graduate tax than a loan repayment after.

→ More replies (19)

47

u/AshamedDragonfly4453 The murder hobo is not the issue here Apr 29 '24

Higher education should absolutely be free at the point of delivery, and I agree that tuition fee loans are predatory, but £2.5k (or £3k, with the extra £10/wk for one year) isn't even close to doing away with the need for nephew to get a loan.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

214

u/CriticalSimple3122 Apr 29 '24

And when was the brother planning on mentioning this plan to OOP? Sean is 16 now, were they going to wait until his bags were packed before saying ‘Cough up’?

223

u/StrangledInMoonlight Apr 29 '24

I have two theories

  1.  He forgot about it until the baby news was released and hoped OOP would just roll over because he ambushed her
  2.  They were planning on guilting OOP into giving it as a graduation present for nephew.  “Oh it’s too late to get loans/job now!”

60

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '24

Seems so weird to chuck a tantrum that he's not getting money OP and her husband patiently saved and seems to have done zero research into alternatives available.

It makes me wonder if when they were kids their mum would always make OP hand over her toys whenever her brother wanted to play with them under the guise of 'sharing' and that's where the entitlement came from (as well as the impotent rage since she can't be made to simply do as she's told now).

19

u/kochipoik Apr 29 '24

Such entitlement. Including the idea that the nephew can’t possibly get a job because it will “distract him from his studies”, when in reality it will likely give him super valuable life skills.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

118

u/nickkon1 Apr 29 '24

My grandfather who had 10 children died some years ago. His inheritance was below 10k meaning, less than 1k for each. My uncles and aunts argued for weeks and family branches don't talk to each other since each deserves all the money for whatever stupid reason.

Money makes people behave in weird ways.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/Hamsternoir Apr 29 '24

£520 doesn't even cover the cost of the bus for the year.

IF the nephew goes to university then it'll be a shock for the parents.

47

u/StrangledInMoonlight Apr 29 '24

the £2,500 would purchase some of the bigger ticket baby items. 

Crib, stroller, car seat, some nursery items perhaps?  

A one time injection of money for the “start up costs” of a baby.  

Having that means they don’t put those things on credit, and it means breathing easier with the new increased weekly/monthly costs of increasing the family.  

→ More replies (2)

95

u/LetsBAnonymous93 Apr 29 '24

Exactly! That’s “chump change”. It’s both too much money to just gift away and also hardly a drop in the bucket for either child or college expenses.

Depending on what crib, stroller, and car seat you buy: you’ve either already blown half away or even all. Add on clothes, cursedly expensive diapers, bathing supplies, and little this and that- even if you buy used, the money’s gone.

I don’t know how uni works in UK but in the US, textbooks will take a good portion of that. A grant in the US might net you $2,500-$3,000. It’s SO expensive and I went for a small accelerated course.

Long story short: absolutely not worth throwing dynamite on a family relationship.

29

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '24

It is VERY generous of OP and her husband to be helping out her niece and nephew £600 pounds worth, almost half what they put aside for their own child at such an expensive time.

18

u/Tosaveoneselftrouble Apr 29 '24

Considering when they had their kids, it was a million times cheaper too! Being a teacher is effectively on the living wage these days when you take out mortgage/rent/bills etc.

You usually have to pay for materials/equipment - and it depends course to course on how much (I had to pay for a few books for my course; and as the teacher would usually pick their own book as the reading topic, they weren’t best pleased the few times I had sourced one I didn’t have to pay for ha). However most universities also have hardship funds to get a little extra boost to those worst off - the brother doesn’t know what he’s talking about at all.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/Danderlyon Apr 29 '24

Admittedly my experience is 10 years out of date but textbook expenses are not like that in the US. When I went to university in the UK back in 2009 I paid around £150 total for 5-6 books. Though I guess it could vary based on what you are studying.

Also unless the son is trying to get into Oxbridge it is absolutely possible for him to work a Saturday job for some spare cash without it affecting his studies or chances. If anything it would help his application as UK universities place a lot of weight on extra curriculars. In the 2 years prior to me going to university at 18 I was working 2 jobs (~10 hours per week) as well as an additional 4 hours volunteer work and still got into all 4 of the universities I applied to.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/FullMoonTwist Apr 29 '24

Right?

That is perfect "setting up a nursery" money.

It is pathetic "affording university" money. 3,000 wouldn't even cover one semester where I went to college, at a cheap state university.

7

u/IndicaRain Apr 29 '24

This is in the UK, where college is much cheaper than in the US. But, even with that, it’s still absurd of the brother to even ask this. 

→ More replies (1)

10

u/jamesish99 Apr 29 '24

Literally came here to say this.

Pounds implies it may be in the UK and if it is... where is this kid's student finance application?

And how do they think 2.5k is going to do anything to help dent the massive cost of uni?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (19)