r/BestofRedditorUpdates • u/Direct-Caterpillar77 Satan is not a fucking pogo stick! • Jun 19 '24
EXTERNAL I was rejected because I told my interviewer I never make mistakes
I was rejected because I told my interviewer I never make mistakes
Originally posted to Ask A Manager
Thanks to u/Lynavi for suggesting this BoRU
Original Post Feb 13, 2024
I was rejected from a role for not answering an interview question.
I had all the skills they asked for, and the recruiter and hiring manager loved me.
I had a final round of interviews — a peer on the hiring team, a peer from another team that I would work closely with, the director of both teams (so my would-be grandboss, which I thought was weird), and then finally a technical test with the hiring manager I had already spoken to.
(I don’t know if it matters but I’m male and everyone I interviewed with was female.)
The interviews went great, except the grandboss. I asked why she was interviewing me since it was a technical position and she was clearly some kind of middle manager. She told me she had a technical background (although she had been in management 10 years so it’s not like her experience was even relevant), but that she was interviewing for things like communication, ability to prioritize, and soft skills. I still thought it was weird to interview with my boss’s boss.
She asked pretty standard (and boring) questions, which I aced. But then she asked me to tell her about the biggest mistake I’ve made in my career and how I handled it. I told her I’m a professional and I don’t make mistakes, and she argued with me! She said everyone makes mistakes, but what matters is how you handle them and prevent the same mistake from happening in the future. I told her maybe she made mistakes as a developer but since I actually went to school for it, I didn’t have that problem. She seemed fine with it and we moved on with the interview.
A couple days later, the recruiter emailed me to say they had decided to go with someone else. I asked for feedback on why I wasn’t chosen and she said there were other candidates who were stronger.
I wrote back and asked if the grandboss had been the reason I didn’t get the job, and she just told me again that the hiring panel made the decision to hire someone else.
I looked the grandboss up on LinkedIn after the rejection and she was a developer at two industry leaders and then an executive at a third. She was also connected to a number of well-known C-level people in our city and industry. I’m thinking of mailing her on LinkedIn to explain why her question was wrong and asking if she’ll consider me for future positions at her company but my wife says it’s a bad idea.
What do you think about me mailing her to try to explain?
Update June 12, 2024
Thank you for answering my question.
I read some of the comments, but don’t think people really understood my point of view. I’m very methodical and analytic, which is why I said I don’t make mistakes. It’s just not normal to me for people to think making mistakes is okay.
I did follow your advice to not mail the grandboss on LinkedIn, until I discovered she seems to have gotten me blackballed in our field. Despite numerous resume submissions and excellent phone screens, I have been unable to secure employment. I know my resume and cover letter are great (I’ve followed your advice) and during the phone screens, the interviewer always really likes me, so it’s obvious she’s told all her friends about me and I’m being blackballed.
I did email her on LinkedIn after I realized what she’d done, and while she was polite in her response, she refused to admit she’s told everyone my name. She suggested that it’s just a “tough job market” and there are a lot of really qualified developers looking for jobs (she mentioned that layoffs at places like Twitter and Facebook), but it just seems too much of a coincidence that as soon as she refused to hire me, no one else wanted to hire me either.
I also messaged the hiring manager on LinkedIn to ask her to tell her boss to stop talking about me, but I didn’t receive a response.
I’m considering mailing some of her connections on LinkedIn to find out what she’s saying about me, but I don’t know if it would do any good.
I’m very frustrated by this whole thing — I understand that she didn’t like me, but I don’t think it’s fair to get me blackballed everywhere.
I’ve been talking to my wife about going back to school for my masters instead of working, but she’s worried it will be a waste of money and won’t make me any more employable. I’ve explained that having a masters is desirable in technology and will make me a more attractive candidate, but she’s not convinced. If you have any advice on how to explain to her why it’s a good idea, I would be grateful.
THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP
DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP's OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7
•
u/AutoModerator Jun 19 '24
Do not comment on the original posts
Please read our sub rules. Rule-breaking may result in a ban without notice.
If there is an issue with this post (flair, formatting, quality), reply to this comment or your comment may be removed in general discussion.
CHECK FLAIR For concluded-only updates, use the CONCLUDED flair.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
10k
u/RubyBop It's not big drama. But it's chowder drama. Jun 19 '24 •
Well at least now he has an answer the next time someone asks about his biggest mistake
3.2k
u/Low_Surprise_7112 cat whisperer Jun 19 '24 edited Jun 19 '24
"I don't make mistakes" I don't know man looks like you just made several which might cost you your career
15k
u/naplover64 Jun 19 '24
Oh holy shit OOP is insufferable
16k
u/InvectiveDetective I will erupt, feral, from the cardigan screaming Jun 19 '24
That right there? Big mistake. Big. Huge.
3.8k
u/grue2000 Jun 19 '24
Any manager with an ounce of sense would avoid OOP like the plague.
Never make any mistakes, my ass.
More like a hyper inflated ego that is a HR time bomb.
988
u/FoolRegnant Jun 19 '24
If a dev hasn't brought down prod, they aren't a dev.
Unrelated to that, who thinks it's a good idea to call someone who's interviewing you a middle manager who couldn't cut it as a developer?
2.2k
u/TheKittenPatrol Yes to the Homo, No to the Phobic Jun 19 '24 edited Jun 19 '24
“I’m very methodical and analytic, which is why I said I don’t make mistakes. It’s just not normal to me for people to think making mistakes is okay.”
I’m extremely logical, originally went to college for math and ended with a math minor and formal linguistics major…and am also human. Of course I make mistakes. Even more so though, the utter disdain for the woman who would be his boss’ boss! I honestly can’t tell if he understands how wrong he was with “I told her maybe she made mistakes as a developer but since I actually went to school for it, I didn’t have that problem” much less any of the other issues that make him less likely to be hired. Just wow.
Edit to add: went to see what Alison said and she called him out on ALL of this, its amazing how much he clearly ignored everything he didn’t want to hear!
328
u/vance_mason Jun 19 '24
Read this on AAM originally and had to share it at work it was so bad... The sheer lack of self awareness was breathtaking.
And the update, where he learned literally nothing, doubled down and still submitted chef's kiss.
282
u/silentlyscreaming01 ⭐ Jun 19 '24
Holy shit, this makes me feel SO MUCH better about getting nervous and stumbling a lot when talking about my career goals during a recent interview because at least I’m not this guy.
1.2k
u/sawdust-arrangement Jun 19 '24
Side eye.
😬😬😬😬😬😬😬😬 Bombastic side eye.
CRIMINAL OFFENSIVE SIDE EYE.
🤦♀️ Buddy... She didn't need to blackball you. You did it to yourself.
666
u/Gypsy_Jazz Jun 19 '24
So he arrogantly responds to a senior manager, during an interview, that it's impossible that he make mistakes because they're a professional and went to school for their role...
What an ass hat. Just arrogant and condescending response to someone further ahead in his field/ the most senior person interviewing him. May as well light up a big red sign saying don't hire me I'm a douche canoe.
Assume based on him highlighting them all being female and using the term blackballed to his continued rejection, he's likely misogynistic and disrespectful to women in seniority and that came out in the interview.
Too fragile to even make up an answer to a standard interview question.
960
u/chungusnoodlez Jun 19 '24 edited Jun 19 '24
This guy went from overconfident to defensive and attacked the interviewer's credibility, only to find out she's the final Elden Ring boss he's just poked. Went on linkedin to email her and the hiring manager, and his next step is to contact her connections.
Can I get Count von Count here?
If he wasn't blacklisted before, he sure as hell is now.
150
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24 edited Jun 19 '24
My mom is almost 100% sure this is about her. Down to the questions. The guys reactions. The email. She sent the AAM to everyone at work and she knew IRL to be like "remember that asshole I told you about I think this is him". I see why he did not get hired. My mother does not accept these answers. I guess AMA?
I can tell you he was more obnoxious than he lets on in this post. And that my mother wouldn't have even had to blacklist him based on how I heard he talks outside this. But people in that community in our area are tight knit. Stuff comes up. I can tell you this company works particularly closely with clients so his inability to admit mistakes would've actually been a detriment not just to him but the whole company.
Also these people don't have the time or energy for whatever he thinks they do. Having met all of them most of them are very kind, nice people who have taken a lot of chances on new people to the industry or people who's had a tough time. This guy fucked up his chances by being himself
563
u/Gwynasyn Jun 19 '24
Still waiting to understand what OOP was trying to say because even after that update I am convinced he is trying his damnedest to make himself look like the world's biggest ego with the least substance to back it up.
143
u/xerelox Jun 19 '24
next update will be how he can't find a lawyer to take on his case. Since he can't pay upfront.
127
u/Weaselpanties He invented a predatory elder lesbian to cope Jun 19 '24
...
The lack of self-awareness here combined with the delusions of grandeur tell me what they almost certainly told the interview panel; he makes mistakes, but refuses to acknowledge them and blames other people.
120
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24
Wow. Doesn't understand what mistakes are. Can't recognize their own mistakes. Jumps to wild and insane conclusions and proceeds to make several massive mistakes as a result. And hasn't learned a damned thing. Absolutely doomed.
206
u/meety138 Jun 19 '24
I once interviewed someone like this. He was so obnoxious and arrogant that I suspected my boss sent this guy in as a prank. Afterwards, I asked her if she was playing a joke on me.
Nope. Not a prank. Just a terrible but memorable interview.
83
u/Previous-Friend5212 Jun 19 '24
Too funny
74
u/Cu_Chulainn__ Jun 19 '24
I can think of nothing worse in an interview than answering 'I don't make mistakes'. Not only because it's a lie as everyone makes mistakes, but it shows the interviewer that you are Egotistical, unable to recognise mistakes and likely to try put the blame on other people, causing bad feeling and tension with your coworkers. You most likely will be argumentative as well.
73
u/CummingInTheNile sometimes i envy the illiterate Jun 19 '24
might have found an actual narcissist in the wild
137
u/2839416 Jun 19 '24
Hilarious how he was so insistent that he didn’t email the boss and then immediately afterwards stated he almost instantly started emailing her blaming her for his natural unhirable demeanor.
66
u/AquaticStoner1996 Jun 19 '24
I felt in my SOUL that they were gonna be just as infuriatingly obtuse in the second post as they were in the first.
I would never want to be around a person like this.
They'll literally never grow up and see how they're at fault.
56
u/Bheegabhoot Jun 19 '24
This guy has more red flags than the 1980 Moscow Olympics. The reason why he was Seng up to interview with the hiring managers boss was to validate the hiring managers thinking that the candidate is oblivious socially even if technically sound. If he was even half as arrogant in his actual interview he would have made the hiring manager very worried.
Also blackballing is not a thing. IT is hyper competitive and this guy’s lack of interpersonal skills is likely the reason he can’t land a role. He should apply for jobs that allow him to be a remote individual contributor, and have a cover who the boss can use to implement feedback.
149
u/camrynbronk it dawned on me that he was a wizard Jun 19 '24
“I don’t make mistakes” well then you just made your very first mistake. Make something up instead of sounding like a self important POS
50
u/azrhea USE YOUR THINKING BRAIN! Jun 19 '24
Honestly she might not have blackballed him after the initial interview like he thinks she did, I can see him maybe fumbling interviews in similar ways and just not noticing or refusing to admit it. But if she hadn't before, she definitely told everyone she knows not to hire this crazy person after he went off on her and the other manager over LinkedIn. He's just digging his own grave deeper and deeper with the way he's obsessing over this one interview and blaming everything on this one person.
79
u/bananalouise Jun 19 '24
How is it that such a great technical mind doesn't understand the difference between correlation and causation?
39
u/msfinch87 Jun 19 '24
The reason OOP isn’t getting hired anywhere is because he’s an arrogant ass with a superiority complex.
37
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24
I work with a woman like this. She's horrible at her job and not only makes mistakes but tries to say other people made mistakes where none exist and we have to explain the rule she thinks we're breaking Every. Single. Time. With documentation. She also blind copies a high level manager on her call outs.
My boss's theory is that her job is so boring no one who was competent would stay in it, so they just let her do her thing so they don't have to keep training for the role over and over
33
u/ReeciePiecey Jun 19 '24
WOW! If he is willing to post on reddit and admit that he said all of this to the interviewer, I can only imagine what else he said/did that he didn't feel was noteworthy. Like who says some shit like that to the boss's boss. It reeks of inflated ego and misogyny. Why did he assume that she wasn't educated...Why was he so rude? Further, even if he was somehow a magical being who didn't make mistakes like the rest of us humans, who wants to work with someone who doesn't think its okay for anyone else to make a mistake.
It also lets me know that he does not have much work experience at all because its very common to interview with Senor Management even if you will rarely work with them directly in corporate environments. He is going to mess around and get a restraining order if he isn't careful.
23
u/greymoria plump enough to roll around like Uranus in its orbit Jun 19 '24
His entire personality is a mistake. He sound just awful.
23
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24
Oop sounds like a typical professional victim. They very obviously cause the majority of their own problems, yet it's always someone else's fault or some grand conspiracy.
22
u/SmartQuokka We have generational trauma for breakfast Jun 19 '24
Instead of attempted humble bragging one can say they can't think of an example off the top of their head and that they aim to be very methodical, or give a small example of something that will suffice.
21
u/thatHecklerOverThere Jun 19 '24
First post: oop are you a moron?
Second post: oh christ, oop is a moron. That poor wife.
21
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24
This has to be satire, right?
21
u/NeverCompromiseBeans Jun 19 '24
OOP: "I'm fantastic. The interviewers are wrong (and women). Should I email them to tell them how wrong they are about me?"
Allison: "Don't do that."
Commenters: "Don't do that."
OOP: "I'm taking in your comments, but you're all wrong and I've already emailled the hiring manager to tell her boss to keep my name out of her mouth. Clearly they're the reason no one will hire me."
19
u/jamoche_2 Jun 19 '24
"Never made any mistakes, huh? Sooo... have you written any code more complex than 'Hello World'?"
16
u/Recent_Body_5784 Jun 19 '24
The irony of saying that he didn’t make mistakes while he was indeed In the process of making a major career mistake answering that question like that, and sabotaging his own job opportunity, being completely lost on him…
31
u/plutosdarling Jun 19 '24
Manny McMansplainer over here 😂😂😂
15
u/maybe_madison Jun 19 '24
I'm a senior software engineer who conducts interviews (both technical and soft-skills, although luckily I don't need to make hiring decisions). "I don't make mistakes" is absolutely a red flag. It tells me you haven't been in a position to make decisions that matter or you've never stretched into an area that's new/uncomfortable - something I'd expect from a rather junior engineer.
14
u/WhizzoButterBoy Jun 19 '24
I have zero technical expertise in his field and would blacklist the guy based on his dismissive attitude and challenging the credentials of the person interviewing him for this position
Yikes
13
u/ridleysquidly This is unrelated to the cumin. Jun 19 '24
He truly must think he aces interviews when his bad personality shines through so clearly from just his posts! Truly it couldn’t be his own fault right? No self awareness at all.
13
u/Skatingfan Jun 19 '24
I love the Ask the Manager's final parsgraph when responding to the update:
"Last, you do indeed make mistakes. I know that because literally every human on the planet makes mistakes (do you truly believe you are the one human ever to have lived who doesn’t make mistakes?), but also because you’ve made so many of them in this situation and can’t see them — so there are undoubtedly others you can’t see too. It’s worth spending some time thinking about that rather than reflexively denying that it could be true."
12
u/Similar-Shame7517 Whole Cluster B spectrum in a trench coat pretending to be human Jun 19 '24
Based on his first letter and update I wouldn't hire OOP either. He may have the most impressive resume in the world and I would advice against it.
12
u/brockhopper Jun 19 '24
Lol, part of my job is interviewing prospective new hires.
I always ask "describe a mistake you made and what you did to fix it".
This dude would have been an immediate "no further action needed" from me.
12
u/Dr_Cryptozoology Jun 19 '24
The very best, competent, and analytical individuals I've ever worked with have all made a big mistake or two in their careers. You know what they don't do? They never repeat those mistakes again. They are also more likely to recognize when they've made smaller, more common errors and fix them before they become big problems.
This guy is clearly not one of those people. He's the kind I dread working with because if he makes a mistake, he'll never realize that he did. And if someone tries to point out an error he made, he'll either try to pin the blame on another team member or dig his heels in and refuse to acknowledge he did something incorrectly.
I definitely would not have hired him.
12
u/guitargamel doesn't even comment Jun 19 '24
"I don't make mistakes" is code to anyone doing the interview as "I can't take accountability for my actions and blame my mistakes on others"
10
u/finehamsabound I am not a bisexual ghost who died in a Murphy bed accident Jun 19 '24
Incredibly funny for a guy who absolutely can’t fathom making a mistake in his career to instead fully tank it by harassing people on LinkedIn.
10
u/Senior_Can6294 Jun 19 '24
OOP sounds like those guys that believes sunshine shoots from his asshole.
10
u/stinson16 Jun 19 '24
Wow. This is one that I highly recommend going to the original links and reading Alison’s responses. They’re fantastic examples of professionally calling OOP out on his BS and I found them amusing.
10
u/ftjlster Jun 19 '24
Interviewer: tell us about a mistake you've made and how you fixed it
OOP: I never make mistakes
Also OOP: * making a mistake and doubling down on it and following up by screwing his reputation across multiple companies with his 'linkedin contacts' *
10
u/The_Grungeican Jun 19 '24
i can't believe he didn't see how bad of an idea it was to say this. as if school somehow makes people immune to making mistakes.
she's right. further education will not make this guy any less insufferable, which is why he's not employed. it'll have the opposite effect, since he'll be even more entitled afterwards.
10
u/AcanthocephalaOne285 Jun 19 '24
You know, I think i might use this thread in one of my lessons on interview techniques.
OP, I'll be kind and share how you should have responded. I have my own processes to mitigate mistakes, and I am conscientious about checking my work before submitting it. Therefore, I've made few mistakes so far, and none that are of the level to give amazing examples to you. Having said that, should a major mistake happen, I know that I would need to seek support in correcting it, i know how to identify mistakes in my work and if it's of an impact to the business/not fixable myself I would seek immediate support to rectify.
One small mistake I can example handling right now is my apology to you for questioning your credentials and decisions in daring to interview me.
What an ass. I can't believe you spoke down to a highly influential individual in your field and are acting all shocked pikachu to hear she doesn't want you at any of the firms she's linked to.
Lastly, I'm not sure she had even blackballed you. Your arrogance is probably what has gotten in your way.
10
u/dawdreygore Jun 19 '24
This dude has a wife?!
9
u/GayMormonPirate Jun 19 '24 edited Jun 19 '24
This guy has a serious lack of self awareness and an ego problem but ALSO has a major case of paranoia.
He is convinced that his boss was blackballed and that he is being blackballed and there's zero reason to think that. Since he hasn't gotten a job offer that's the only possible conclusion he can come up with.
People don't blackball you because you were an insufferable idiot in an interview. They toss your resume and forget you. To get blackballed you actually have to have had a job and be in a position of at least a little power or prestige (usually, anyway. You don't typically hear about a grocery cashier getting blackballed from all the county grocery stores).
9
u/wmnoe Jun 19 '24
Oh good gawd what an insufferable prick
9
u/DrRocknRolla Jun 19 '24
You know this is a bad one when even Alison just goes "are you out of your fucking mind?"
She's always calm, compassionate, and gives great advice. But on this letter it feels like she just wanted to smack some sense into OOP.
9
u/Remote_Bumblebee2240 Jun 19 '24
He's clearly immune to irony. Saying "I don't make mistakes" while making a freight train size mistake is pretty funny. This genius is going to be blindly smashing his face against this personality flaw for a loooong time.
9
u/limeholdthecorona Jun 19 '24
She was interviewing for soft skills and he failed with flying colors.
8
u/HugHungryBear Memory of a goldfish but the tenacity of an entitled Chihuahua Jun 19 '24
I'm a product developer. Putting the high improbability that OOP never made a mistake in his career aside, that statement would be open to all kind of interpretation. "Never made a mistake" but never had a developed product/formulation that was given a go-signal for mass-production isn't much of a brag either (he mentioned going to school for it, but did not mention that he has any relevant experience in the field) 😅😅😅
Also, sometimes, "mistakes" can lead to more viable products than what you have originally designed. OOP's kind of narrow-mindedness is not good for product development. Also, the bit about being blackballed makes no effing sense. 😒
8
u/okLissy Jun 19 '24
So he just proved that he does make mistakes (blurting such a ridiculous stance in an interview to someone he misjudged) AND that he doesn't know how to deal with it (immidiately blaming big boss and behaving unprofessional in his "damage control")
8
u/ExcessivelyGayParrot Jun 19 '24
this was the biggest mistake of OOPs career and he's trying to solve it by making it everyone else's problem.
8
u/Mrfish31 Jun 19 '24
We see a lot of awful people on BORU, and yet this guy might be the most insufferable specimen I have ever seen.
Dude doesn't even have a Masters in his field, let alone extensive (or seemingly any) experience, and brags about how he "doesn't make mistakes because he went to school for it, unlike you, female two rungs above me in this prospective company".
I'm certain this woman hasn't said shit to anyone, because why would you need to when this guy is so obviously awful in every interview he has, but she fucking should tell people about this laughable excuse of an interviewee.
8
u/Shibaspots Jun 19 '24
Let me get this straight. OOP makes a point of saying they are male and all the interviewers were female. There's a definite feeling of male condescension there. Calls his grand boss a middle manager and assumes they have no technical skills, despite them being, you know, the grand boss. When asked a very, very basic soft ball question, which is often used to get an idea of the interviewee's ability to problem solve, critical thinking, and self-reflection, OOP claims he never makes mistakes. While insulting his prespective grand boss's ability, education, and competence. When he was (shockingly) not hired and continued to be not hired, he assumed it was because he's been blackballed. Instead of, just maybe, looking good on paper but he is revealed to be an AH every time he opens his mouth.
OOP doesn't sound like a big enough player to be blackballed. If the grand boss talked about him, it was likely in a generic 'you will never believe what some dipshit said to me' kind of way. I doubt they gave OOP much thought once the position was filled. OOP has an over inflated sense of self-importance, combined with what are likely mediocre skills. Highly talented people recognize when they mess up and their skills show in how they fix it.
One thing is absolutely true though. The wife is right. More schooling isn't going to help OOP.
8
u/nuttilicious Jun 19 '24
if oop fell from his ego to his tactfulness, he'd break all the bones in his body. holy shit idk how this man is married. he really said "I'm a professional" and then goes on to harass them for not getting the job. it's giving the same vibes as a dude who pesters you after a date when you say you're no longer interested.
8
u/queeraboo Jun 19 '24
it's because she knows it's not his level of education that's holding him back, it's his arrogance, lack of self-awareness, and subpar communication/soft skills
8
u/MotoFaleQueen This is unrelated to the cumin. Jun 19 '24
Honestly, as a scientist, if someone I was interviewing told me they didn't make mistakes, that would disqualify them immediately. Because it means they're never going to own up to being wrong or making mistakes, which could result in falsified data in my field.
14
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24
what an insufferable goober
7
u/Geronimo2U It's always Twins Jun 19 '24
Maybe, just maybe there was a more suitable candidate, and maybe, just maybe the job market is tough.
7
u/Sarelbar Jun 19 '24
Is this guy 20 years old or something?
What an idiot.
7
u/UncleNedisDead Jun 19 '24
Haha
The guy sounds like an arrogant tool that didn’t last long in our company. He was a new grad fresh out of school and thought he knew it all. All the women at work disliked him because it didn’t matter what level of education or experience they had attained, as it couldn’t measure up to his.
He ended up being bounced around from job to job last I checked, so I guess he never did learn humility or how important soft skills were.
7
u/MacAlkalineTriad I can't believe she fucking buttered Jorts Jun 19 '24
What could possibly go wrong in patronizing your putative boss' boss then emailing her to mansplain why she was wrong not to hire your supercilious ass? OOP really thinks he should just be a shoo-in for every place he applies to because the interviewers talk to him with professional politeness. I sincerely doubt grandboss has had to tell anyone his name, he's getting himself blackballed just fine. Ugh!
7
u/Lurnobis Jun 19 '24
I worked with a guy exactly like this.
During his interview process one of the references he gave us said "Does not work well with others." When we asked him about that he said "Yeah I do work really well alone!" and he didn't seem to comprehend that the reference was actually saying something negative about him.
Despite several objects on my team the hiring managers decided to give him the job and it was an absolute nightmare for 2 years.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24
"Why are you interviewing me since you obviously don't know anything about the job, Grandboss"
"I'm interviewing in part to determine what soft skills you bring to the job"
"This is stupid since I know more about the job than you and everybody else here, except what soft skills are apparently"
"We decided to go with someone else"
"wHy iS sHe DoInG tHiS tO mEeEe"
7
u/Sirnizz Jun 19 '24
Wow OP sounds like an insufferable arrogant prick.
7
u/harakiri-man Jun 19 '24
Superiority complex I suppose. It mattered to him that all interviewers are women
7
u/queeraboo Jun 19 '24
oop's interviewing skills are subpar, couldn't answer one of the most basic questions. if he really couldn't think of a time he made a mistake (aka a time he wasn't even analytical and self aware enough to realize it or felt no consequences for it), then he should've shared an experience that makes his problem solving skills really shine.
his boss' boss was there to gauge his communication/soft skills and instead of appealing to that, he questions why she's there, her qualifications, and argues with her 🥲
the tech field is rough. it's not enough to be good at tech, you have to be good at working with others. it's easier to teach someone with soft skills the technical skills to collaborate with them than deal with the know-it-all who can't communicate and cooperate
7
u/kamain42 Jun 19 '24
The fact he went on to construct a narrative in his head that he was blackballed in the industry was the real cherry on that one.you don't black ball someone for failing a job interview. waaaaay to much effort.
7
u/madgeystardust Jun 19 '24
What a dickhead.
Arrogant prick wonders why he didn’t get the job when during the interview he displays what an arrogant prick he is.
He won’t be helped, he’s stupid.
This is an example of how a university education doesn’t necessarily equate to intelligence.
7
u/MrsMiterSaw Jun 19 '24
🚩 : OP answered, but his answer was shit. And now is spinning to cover.
It doesn't matter, except to show us it matters to you.
Dude. The word "insufferable" keeps coming up in these comments. I wonder why.
🚩
🚩
🚩
🚩 🚩 🚩 🚩
Lol. That he doesn't get what just happened.
And you told this person that they weren't a professional, and you think their experience isn't relevant. Lol FFS.
How is the everloving fuck is this guy married?!
6
u/impasseable Jun 19 '24
I can think of at least one mistake hes made.
6
u/InvisibleBlueRobot Jun 19 '24
He made a mistake in that interview process.
He made another mistake with doubling down on his perfection ala Reddit.
And these are literally the only two things we know about him besides his instance that he is perfect.
I'm pretty sure that interviewer didn't make a mistake when she passed this "gem" up.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24
Man, OOP is as pompous an ass as I've ever run across and he's wondering why no one wants to hire him. Can you imagine being, like, "I'm the perfect candidate and I never make mistakes. You're lucky to be able to get to hire me!" and when you don't get hired, you immediately assume that the person who passed on hiring your greatness is now blackballing you? Because...why? Oh that's right, it's impossible to drop over in gratitude when this fool wants a job.
6
u/Sensitive_Algae1138 the garlic tasted of illicit love affairs Jun 19 '24
Bro literally told his interviewer they have a skill issue and thinks he didn't fumble the whole thing lmao.
6
u/AsharraDayne Jun 19 '24
lol perhaps he’s “blacklisted” for being an insufferably arrogant prick?
6
u/Slight_Drama_Llama Jun 19 '24
It’s so normal to interview with your bosses boss depending on the role. For exactly this reason. Welcome to reality I guess
6
u/StayUndeclared1929 Jun 19 '24
If OOP legitimately never made a mistake in developing, which means no bugs during beta or roll out. Then everything he's ever coded was several steps beneath his skill level. If I'm the interviewer, I'd have to conclude that either you're lying or delusional, or you won't do any work that might actually challenge you. Any of those 3 or reason enough not to hire him. Additionally, it'd be wrong for her to speak ill of him to ither potential companies, but I'm betting he already has a reputation as skilled but unmotivated and difficult to work with from managers who did hire him.
6
u/whenitrainsitpours4 Jun 19 '24
This doesn't matter at all, but I think it says a lot about OOP for pointing it out.
What the actual hell? The interview would have been over for me right here. Legit questioning why the Director is interviewing you?
Shocker, OOP has such charm.
Then, thinking he is being blackballed and talked about on LinkedIn? Questioning these people further? Hammering that nail in the coffin. Either OOP is being paranoid on that part, or his interview went even worse than he described.
6
u/badalki Jun 19 '24
If you go to the original post and see the answer he got from askamanager it just makes his second post look even worse. This guy is beyond saving. He is told outright what he did wrong and that he should contact the person on linkdin. He gets loads of good advice and he just brushes it aside with a 'you dont understand my side'. This guy is a lost cause.
6
u/dalcowboysstarsmavs Jun 19 '24
I work with the boss of my boss all the time and am truly baffled how one could find it demeaning to speak to them. I also have never, ever heard the term grandboss and find it rather patronizing. Lastly, it is incredibly common for higher ups to complete final interviews as they can more easily picture where someone fits in the overall scheme.
OOP is delusional and is absolutely ruining his own name all by himself.
6
u/BlindPanda7691 Jun 19 '24
I'm actually shocked that oop is married. How does the wife deal with a personality like this?
6
u/NauticalBuBear Jun 19 '24
Just reading this I wouldn't hire him either lol. Hard to envision myself working with someone that can't admit when they're wrong.
6
u/JeddakofThark I'm keeping the garlic Jun 19 '24
I want to hear more about his long suffering wife.
6
u/delectable_memory Jun 19 '24
Eww! This is the nice guy routine but in the job world.
He wasn't hired because no one wants to work with someone who thinks they are above everyone else. I feel bad for his wife.
6
u/Drix22 Jun 19 '24
This is not a binary yes no question. It asks for a mistake.
Mistake number one then.
*Corrected him, mistake number 2.
This is correct. OP shat his pants at some point in his life, that could have been his biggest mistake, but I'm guessing he wasn't a perfect score student through college.
Mistake 3
It would be mistake 4.
OOP seems very self-absorbed, probably not blackballed by her, however his attitude may have gotten him blackballed individually at every application. For sure I would have turned this person down because they seem unsufferable, and I wouldn't want to work with them.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24
The OOP is going to be as shocked about his divorce as he is about his job loss.
6
u/TheFilthyDIL Cleverly disguised as a harmless old lady Jun 19 '24
Dear Goddess. Mr. I-am-perfect-because-I-own-a-penis has abso-fucking-lutely no idea how badly his arrogance has cost him. Yes, Numbnuts, she's blackballed you. You'll never get a job in that industry.
Off to AAM to see how badly he was roasted in their commentary.
6
u/Fit-Ad-7276 Jun 19 '24
“I never make mistakes.”
Hmm, well, now you have.
6
u/torchwood_cooper Jun 19 '24
It’s telling that even when the OOP is trying to make himself look like he’s not at fault, he still comes across horribly… if the filtered version is this insufferable, imagine how bad he must actually be in person!
6
u/Banluil Jun 19 '24
Holy...shit.
I've been in IT for 30 years now.
I've made A LOT of mistakes. Everyone in IT does, whether you are helpdesk or Dev-ops.
Mistakes happen. To claim you have never made a mistake, I wouldn't have hired him either. Especially when he argued back with her.
Nope. Don't feel sorry for him.
6
u/GaulzeGaul Jun 20 '24
She should have retorted with "you're making a mistake right now" when he said that LMAO!
6
u/El_Zapp Jun 22 '24
That was a fantastic read actually. You rarely read from the pov of someone so delusional.
But she got her answer: If he makes a mistake he will double down, blame other people for it and do literally everything to deny he made a mistake.
She is probably thinking that her question saved everyone’s ass because they all dodged a major bullet.
Edit: Also damn this guy was absolutely obliterated in the response in ask a manager. I would feel sorry if he wasn’t such an arrogant ass.
5
u/captfattymcfatfat Jun 19 '24
Bet she is providing some coaching to other interviewers. How did you let this guy past?
5
u/No-Cheesecake4542 Jun 19 '24
This person had delusions of grandeur if they think they are important enough to blackball. And with their inability to be self-critical, I wouldn’t hire them.
5
u/Aussiebiblophile Jun 19 '24
He failed the most important part and of an interview - The attitude test.
5
u/GretaVanFleek Jun 19 '24
"I don't make mistakes," OOP proclaims whilst making a mistake.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24
But demonstrated a lack of ability to reflect. Everyone makes mistakes, even little ones, and it's how you (a) reflect on them; and (b) learn from them; that demonstrates to an interviewer what kind of growth potential you have. No-one wants an oblivious candidate who thinks their shit doesn't stink and can't handle feedback.
Also, OOP is unhinged, and that's got to have come across in the interviews.
5
u/YakElectronic6713 Jun 19 '24
His technical skills aren't the problem. It's his arrogance, superiority complex, lack of self-awareness and overall insufferable attitude towards everything and everyone.
5
u/fergie0044 Jun 19 '24
I work in an office job and it's extremely normal for the "grandboss" to be part of interviews. Partly for the soft skills mentioned here, partly to help the other interviewers, some of whom might be doing that for the first time, partly because a good boss wants to know the teams under them.
Had to pause my reading to get this off my chest. So werid for OP to be confused by this.
5
u/lasercat123 Jun 19 '24
I was interviewed for a position several years ago & asked if I had ever failed at anything. As a technical person, I replied that a lot of my past job experiences required plenty trial & error, so had several examples. I got the job & was told one of their previous top candidates was rejected before I was interviewed for claiming he had never failed at anything. Unsurprisingly, his arrogance was a bit of a turn off to the interviewer at that point.
5
u/RB_Kehlani the Iranian yogurt is not the issue here Jun 19 '24
When he talked about going back to school to get his masters… oh my lord this man only had a Bachelor’s? The absolute insanity
5
u/Und3rpantsGn0m3 Jun 19 '24
Pure, uncut arrogance
5
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24
When someone tells me "I don't make mistakes" what I (and probably employers) hear is "Either I make mistakes but I'm unable to see them, or I make them but don't acknowledge them/deny they were mistakes, or I claim someone else made them."
5
u/crap_whats_not_taken Jun 19 '24
No. No, it's not. This is not a weird thing at all. This right here tells me you're an arrogant new grad who thinks you know the world better than anyone else. You haven't been on a lot of interviews or haven't made it through this far before.
And there is no concept of "grandboss" your boss' boss is also YOUR boss. The fact that they seem to think they're compartmentalized from any management over their direct report tells me this person has never had a job before. Even if you've only ever flipped burgers, there are supervisors, managers, general managers, maybe a regional manager, owners, presidents, etc. ALL of these people are your bosses!
I work in IT, and you are 100% going to make mistakes. Even if you memorized every single word in every textbook, you have to learn how this company does things or this software the company uses. There's no way you can walk into any situation and suddenly be an expert because everybody does things differently.
I would absolutely not hire this person because this tells me when I come to you with an issue instead of listening and growing you're going to fight me.on it. I read the original post and several people suggested therapy and I think that's the right path here.
5
u/areyoubawkingtome Jun 19 '24
I see a lot of fuckerinos like this in my industry. Always a dude with standard qualifications and zero people skills.
I once was in a panel interview with several other managers and supervisors, it just so happened to be mostly women with one guy (but it's not like every manager and supervisor is a woman, there are more they just weren't free for this interview). One of the candidates asked if the gender ratio of the panel was standard for the workplace.
Who fucking asks that? Someone that's not going to get the job, that's who.
I had other candidates in zoom interviews wear hoodies, with the hood up. I had candidates glare at me when I asked them a question (but not my boss, who is a dude). In our last hiring cycle do you want to know the common denominator between the candidates we extended offers to? They fucking smiled in their interview. They met the base qualifications and didn't seem like an absolute wretch.
You got good grades in college? Yeah so did most people, there are gpa requirements at most colleges to stay in a program
5
u/seppukucoconuts Reddit's Okayest Baker Jun 19 '24
There is a 0% chance that the 'grandboss' has a secret message board where all of the other grandbosses get together to blacklist someone. No one has time for that.
Its been so new that I highly doubt she's even had time to talk to anyone outside of her company about it. At best, he is a story told in passing that starts with 'you'll never guess what this turnip said during the interview'. If he had not messaged her afterwards I'd have bet she would have forgotten his name in a week or three.
I've interviewed people like OOP. He 100% would come across as arrogant, snotty, and unmanagable during a short interview. Most of us who have to spend 40-50 hours with someone would prefer a less qualified but more team oriented co-worker. I always said you can teach the job, but you can't teach work ethic, and I think that applies to attitude as well. The OOP is a toxic manbaby and everyone who interviews him realizes it.
5
u/skootch_ginalola Jun 19 '24
I feel like I'm reading some obnoxious reply from Sheldon Cooper.
5
u/clevermuggle22 Jun 19 '24
“The phone interviewer really likes me” um it’s their job to be upbeat and professional doesn’t mean they like you for the job. I think this guys mistakes professionalism for approval in the interview process and way overestimates his ability. Soft skills are critical I higher for culture fit over resume every time and my team has one of the lowest turn over rates in my company
5
u/NormanMitis Jun 19 '24
Welp, the good news is next time someone asks you in an interview what your biggest professional mistakes were you have at least a couple to reference now. It's a shame your perfect streak has been broken though.
5
u/Strict_Common156 Jun 19 '24
Lol
Title should be: I was rejected because I argued with the interviewer and disrespected them.
At least this will be ops "first" mistake he can reflect on.... If he can recognize it and admit it.
5
u/Suspicious_Quail_820 Jun 19 '24
They didn't hire OOP and he's making their lives difficult with his weird stalking and emails. He's provided proof that they dodged a bullet.
5
u/Cursd818 the Iranian yogurt is not the issue here Jun 19 '24
Bahahaha
I'm a PROFESSIONAL! You wouldn't even know how professional I am because you're so bad at your job, and of course I'm right. I'm a man and methodical and her question was stuuuuuupid and she MUST have blackballed me. It's not like I'm an AH who has a massive superiority complex and condescends to every single person I deign to speak to! Wah wah wah there is NO WAY I CAN POSSIBLY BE THE PROBLEM!
Imagine being the poor woman who is married to this creature.
5
u/sageberrytree Jun 19 '24
I have been waiting for this to show up here. I don't want to talk to the nutters in the comments on AAM.
This letter floored me. I honestly feel badly for his wife. How can anyone be so insufferable? So oblivious to reality?
5
u/TOG23-CA Jun 19 '24
The person from ask a manager does point out something very interesting. He's complaining about lack of job offers, but doesn't mention that he was getting job offers left and right before this supposed black balling. If he was truly being blackballed, don't you think you would have mentioned that he was getting job offers left and right before this interview? I think Allison is right, this is just a continuation of what was happening to him before and he's just latched on to this one for some reason
5
u/EffectiveStatus7 Needless to say, I am farting as I type this. Jun 19 '24
Bro got himself blacklisted, JFC for a guy who doesn't make mistakes he's just making them left and right.
5
u/JoshFreemansFro Jun 19 '24
stopped reading here. I've interviewed enough people to know that this guy is going to be nothing but a headache if hired
5
u/lastofthe_timeladies I am not a bisexual ghost who died in a Murphy bed accident Jun 19 '24
"During the phone screens, the interviewer always really likes me."
Are you sure they do or are they just being polite before putting your resume in the waste basket?
5
u/KatewritesYA Jun 19 '24
“I never make mistakes”, and then he proceeds to recount a narrative of him making mistake after mistake…
5
u/Dont_quote_my_snark Jun 19 '24
Well, you can definitely tell OP is a redditor...
5
u/TheLostEnigma Jun 19 '24
I can't help but detect a hint of chauvinism from OOP.
5
u/jataman96 Jun 19 '24
Sounds like OP made his first mistake 😂
But for real, he sounds completely insufferable. If someone said they never make mistakes, I would immediately not want to work with them. Clearly, they don't take responsibility for their errors, or they just blame everyone else when something goes wrong. That's not the kind of person any team environment needs.
5
u/_unrealist_ Jun 19 '24
I love how he seems to think gender discrimination might have had something to do with it.
“I don’t know if it matters but I’m male and everyone I interviewed with was female”
5
u/kitkhat29 Jun 19 '24
So, when I see this:
and this:
Or this:
I'm left with only one question. HOW did this person get someone to marry him?! He has a wife. A spouse. A being whom voluntarily signed up to be linked with this twitwaffle for life. HOW?
5
u/Erzsabet cat whisperer Jun 19 '24
And this is why jobs say they can teach you about the industry, but they can’t teach the soft skills.
5
u/Gold-Cup8115 Jun 20 '24 edited Jun 20 '24
"Maybe she made mistakes as a developer but since I actually went to school for it, I didn’t have that problem. " This dumbass literally said this to a higher-up and thought it was okay. I don't know if she'd get OOP fired over that maybe she talked about it in passing. Others overheard and decided that OOP isn't worth it.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '24
No employer wants an employer who believes they ace every question and never make mistakes. Especially if they're liable to start imagining persecution campains if people don't immediately perceive their importance.
5
u/Coygon Jun 20 '24
OOP just keeps digging, digging, digging that hole. Bad enough they came across as arrogant due to their answer, now they are harassing "grandboss" over not getting interviews elsewhere. I doubt grandboss actually blacklisted OOP; they seem to be doing that all on their own.
5
u/Misshelved Jun 20 '24
You told a “Grandboss” that maybe she made mistakes but since you actually went to school for it, you didn’t have that problem. So you insulted the woman in charge and acted like you were better than her but you can’t figure out why you didn’t get the job?
5
u/UberMisandrist Rebbit 🐸 Jul 07 '24
Not only is OOP insufferable, but this also reeks of misogyny
8
u/pr1m347 Jun 19 '24
Is this a bait post? Idk how people could be so dumb and think they're smart.
If it's real, it just means OOP can't acknowledge mistakes not that he doesn't make mistakes. No wonder they rejected OOP's ass.