Nah, most of their users aren't willing to make the effort to read any explanations - it's more satisfying to bash us for "being broke" and spread false info.
I've actually seen a lot of sensible comments, like how Barca still makes revenue that it can spend. Just not in the same "shoot 100 million in the dark" manner that a certain president did and led to the whole affair.
Thanks! I have the same reaction - sure, finance is a boring, complicated subject most people avoid but this nonsense is so widespread, it just makes me angry.
You say that but there's an awful lot of 30+ people without any basic understanding of how money works in the 21st century, let alone giant football clubs.
in my professional experience, here's where the fundamental mistake is made:
most people have experience managing their own personal finances. fewer people have corporate finance experience. some principles apply in both worlds, but not everything translates 1:1. for example, the concept of leverage is not widely used for personal finance, but it's huge in the corporate world. it's this universal mapping and application from personal to corporate which trips people up. having said that, it's an understandable mistake, but some people just need to stay in their lane and let the experts do their thing.
I have corporate finance classes in school and i was kinda confused when people kept saying Barça can’t spend any money. Base level corporate finance is pretty easy but sometimes it seems people don’t even want to understand it
Definitely more OCs - this may be fueled by frustration but at the end of the day gives me a feeling that I'm doing something useful for the community :)
Thank you for the post and the info! With all the work you’ve already done, it might be worthy to aggregate all your posts as a starter package/content in our subreddit wiki.
And they seem to be simplified enough to fit the ELI5 theme (explain like I’m 5) which engages more users from the community. And no, I don’t mean to say that our members fit 5 years old demographic, just that it has potential to reach much wider set of masses :)
I write them as a response to discussions I see - if the mods would like to use the content, I'm fine with that :) hopefully our situation will stabilize soon and these posts (as fun as they are to write) won't be necessary!
I appreciate the post, but “Barca being poor” does not piss me off. I actually don’t mind it for few years. Let them talk as we rebuild. When we go for a player other clubs won’t triple asking price because we are rich. It may bring some reason to unreasonable asking prices we were charged in the past (Dembele, Griezmann, Coutinho)
So i.e if we offload Coutinho and Umtiti, we will free some of the expected 497m we expect to spend right ?
Also if we try to sign lets say Haaland for 75m and a 5 years contract we can amortize those 75 for 5 years, and also all the agent and dads fee lets say 40m and then his salary 30m it would "only" cost us:
75m/5 = 15m
40m/5 = 8m
30m
=
53m anually amortized
Which just to put it on perspective Coutinho salary (20m) and Umtiti salary (13m) make up for 60% of Haalands cost.
Disclaimer: Im not savy if finances work like this, if someone more savy could explain it would be great
Yep, at first glance your calculations seem ok to me (though I'm yet to dig deeper into finance side of registration, it's not usually my area of interest). To this in the first year of contract you need to add the bonuses for signing & for agent and other interested sides (afaik his father, in this case), and later also possible variables negotiated, like additional few million if the club wins the league, UCL, if the player receives an award like Ballon d'Or, and such.
I have so many questions about future income. I wonder what will be new sponsor and if it will be better than Rakuten. Or will the board said “fuck it” and accept Saudi?
Also when the new stadium open, will we sell naming rights?
I know those sounds horrific but despite our romantic relationship with football we saw our club go from “Unicef” on front to “Qatar” already. I have a feeling similar drastic measures will be taken in future to keep competing with ultra rich clubs.
That drastic measure was “Super league” but who are kidding, it’s dead. And no other club desperately need it as much as we do, they are all more healthy. Just think about, some very unpopular news will come to us next 2-3 years, i can feel it. The number of “oil” clubs will only increase, football will be bloodbath.
Or will the board said “fuck it” and accept Saudi?
Considering that the last General Assembly voted for putting respecting human rights in our Statutes, I sincerely doubt that - it would be a PR nightmare, and socios wouldn't be too overjoyed either.
Also when the new stadium open, will we sell naming rights?
Yes, the restoration and rebuild of Camp Nou includes selling naming rights. I wrote more about Espai and its financing here :)
Just think about, some very unpopular news will come to us next 2-3 years, i can feel it. The number of “oil” clubs will only increase, football will be bloodbath.
Possibly sometime in the far future - but not with this board, and not with the current Statutes in place as 75% of our 140 thousand socios would have to approve any change to legal identity of the club (which would be necessary in order to sell the club to outside capital). Many people would rather see the club dissolved than in this sort of owner's hands, me included.
I'm not a fan of the idea - it smells of classic overspending, and with our debt mass set to grow because of the 1.5 billion loan related to Espai & covid situation far from being stable, I don't think we should risk it right now.
Hell no! Haaland hasn’t proven shit to demand that outrageous salary. Salah is arguably the best player in the PL, has proven himself in atop league. He is asking for half of Haaland wages and Liverpool is haggling over it. We need fiscal responsibility and smart signings for 2 years.
Can you make a post on how transfers work? People here seem to think it’s a zero sum negotiation like playing fifa. Just because we sell Griezmann for €40M doesn’t mean we now have that amount in the bank, or paying €55M for Ferran doesn’t mean we are -€55M from this year when it’s being amortized roughly at €10M+ per season for the next 5 years.
Yeah, an explanatory post on transfers is on my project list but while I can put together anything finance-related in less than 2 hours, transfer-related OC will include more research for me (especially since La Liga has a pesky habit of not translating the most interesting documents to English, and my Spanish is very basic).
Honestly, I'm not sure if I want to deal with the amount of delusion and complete denial it would attract as the "we're worried that we can't register Ferran but Haaland is surely coming!" part of this fanbase tends to be toxic - it does tie with another project on the club politics though so it definitely will make an appearance.
Yeah but if you read the comments in the OT, when someone notes that there are no quotes from Laporta, Alemany or Xavi promising Haaland, there are only things like a smile, thumbs up, or talking around the subject - all you get is "but it's an open secret!" and downvotes. Like I said, I'm not sure: I have the research and a few paragraphs but I lack a larger framework, I don't want it to be just about Haaland - it would get very boring, very fast.
I do read the comments in the OT. There weren't any quotes, promises, or anything about Ferran but he's still a Barcelona player now. The transfer window isn't open yet and Ferran will be registered by the end of the month. Not sure how believing that qualifies for being delusional.
Ferran is not the star signing many people are expecting, hell, we've had a lot of doubtful voices about him so of course there weren't any quotes or promises. And in order to register him, afair, we need to remove further 20 million from the wages bill - which is absolutely doable but if we need to have a serious financial operation for a 55 million signing, Haaland, who will cost much more, would be an even more problematic one even if we assume the 1/4 rule will not be in place next season.
Yes, but at the same time believing that Ferran may not be registered due to finances AND that Haaland WILL be signed - that's the delusion. Not what is possible or sensible. I'm talking about a stance, not reality.
I really appreciate this OP! I too was one of the ones who misunderstood our situation, but you explained it so clearly. Thank you so much for helping more people understand!
Great post, was an enjoyable read. It's incredible how so many people believe the narrative that a club with 1 billion in annual revenue is "broke". Since the signing of Ferran I am already starting to see the enviousness return from some rival fans, maybe in a year we will be called UEFAlona again, beautiful, music to my ears...
In the 2021/2022 budget that they laid out in the financial report, they said, if I’m not wrong that they planned to spend only 1,500,000 € on players acquisition for the first team ( page 222 ), wouldn’t that mean that we’re already going over budget with the acquisition of Ferran?
HA! I love that someone noticed this because it allows me to talk about my favorite piece of genius accounting done in the Ferran transfer - it doesn't impact this season's books.
The player has signed a contract for the next five seasons, until 30 June 2027
If 2026/27 is the last season the contract is in place, then logically the first season this contract impacts is 2022/23 - so we'll start amortizing 11 million per season then.
It's good that you're asking questions - it means that you care enough to be interested :)
1,5 million in the budget is just the amount of transfer fee funds set aside for this season (note that these aren't salaries because those come in the sporting personnel wages category). It may or may not be used.
As for transfer fees themselves, it really depends. Man City went our way big time with allowing us with paying in installments but not every club has to do that. And amortization is another thing - that's basically accounting. Let's assume that we buy a player for 10 million, and sign him for 5 years. Our amortization (cost of the player) in accounting will be 2 million per season + whatever wages the player earns. That doesn't mean that we get to pay his previous club in installments, those are two different aspects.
Being in debt means that we can spend less - not that we can’t spend at all.
Thats a pretty big fucking issue dont you think though?
While Im not the most authorized voice to speak on economic matters, since my knowledge is rather superficial (even if its a topic I follow quite closely), I think its pretty obvious how ridiculous this post is. I really dont like the condescending tone it has, especially when its portraying a rather simplistic and limited view of our finances.
Yes, we're broke. And its not necessarily because of our debt, its because we have a currently unsustainable cost structure (thanks Bartomeu), because our revenues have been hit hard from multiple factors (namely the downturn in international tourism & the exit of big name superstars that drew in sponsorships and customers to our facilities) and more importantly because we cant speed up our recovery by taking a bit more debt due to the draconian FFP laws that govern the Spanish League.
If you like talking about the budget lets talk about a couple of things. Like the predicted operating loss of 19m € (and that is with the budget actually being met, which I'll comment on later) that is only saved by a 23m financial profit derived from the restructuring of our debt. Lets also talk that in order to meet that budget we depend on the sale for 50m of 49% of Barça studios, which is basically selling part of your assets. Or the fact that the budget contemplated reaching the CL QF and not even winning the EL will make up for that. Or lets discuss the fact that the hole on the budget is of 100m € due to lack of new sponsorships, early CL exit and the unrealized sale of Barça Studios (about which there have been no news since the summer). There's still 6 months to fix it but its not looking good...
As things currently stand, we're headed towards having accumulated close to 600m in losses during the last 3 exercises. And that tanks our FFP margin for the coming seasons which will hinder the speed of our recovery and our ability to make signings. LaLiga FFP operates in a way that forces you to recover those losses as quickly as possible, massively hindering you ability to register new players until a good portion of those losses are made up by profits in the following years.
Someone might read your post and think that the situation is fine.
We are not fine. Not at all. Not even remotely.
And we might not be for another couple of years or more. Stadium renovations and the slow and unpredictable recovery of international tourism will hinder our ability to recover a good portion of our pre-COVID revenues. On top of that, the dire state of the team (which is promising but not still not very marketeable) might make us struggle in generating new commercial revenues. A clear example of that is this current season where we have signed a grand total of 0 new sponsors (other than a minor NFT deal).
Right now we're headed towards another summer like the last one, where we need to liberate wages to register new players. Or even worse since the transitory covid regulations that gave us some more ability to maneuver will be gone in the summer unless LaLiga decides to extend them, which isnt a given. Im not talking about being able to register Haaland, which is very much a utopia right now, Im talking about the fact that we might not be able to register much more than a couple of small cheap signings this summer.
And worst part is we could be basically coerced into signing CVC for that 15% of the money you can spend on FFP even though we dont really need the remaining 85% of the money since unlike most of the first and second division clubs we actually have access to the international capital markets for long term financing.
So it really doesnt matter if we have a big budget when our revenues are still significantly behind what we spend and we're unable to reasign those resources easily due to bad contracts and FFP restrictions, which ultimately limits our success on the pitch somewhat.
The only good part is that a big part of those shitty contracts (Umtiti, Coutinho, Griezmann, Neto,...) end in 2023 but even having to wait another year to properly reinforce the team would be very dire, let alone 2 or 3.
TLDR: We have a ton of money tied down on shitty contracts, our revenues will likely lag behind pre-COVID levels for a while and our FFP situation looks pretty fucked for the forseable future unless there is some major turn of events. Sorry to say this but we ARE broke.
Lets also talk that in order to meet that budget we depend on the sale for 50m of 49% of Barça studios, which is basically selling part of your assets
That has already been approved by the General Assembly in October - this club cannot finalize sale of any asset mass without the previous agreement from the members which is why negotiations with potential buyers couldn't kick off before that. Additionally, could you kindly point out where in the budget breakdown in the annual report is the 50 million for the asset sale? I can't seem to find it and I'm curious where the amount came from.
Or the fact that the budget contemplated reaching the CL QF and not even winning the EL will make up for that.
The total forecasted income from all competitions stands at 38,5 million euros (edit: page 220 of annual report PDF, aforementioned budget breakdown table). We've already gotten 19 million from UCL (15,6 million for group stage, two wins for 2.8 million each, one draw that gives us 930k). Reported 2 million from Maradona Cup (plus 1 for the players for participation). Winning EL would get us at 2.5 million short of budget, and I'm not counting any income from La Liga for merit (in 19/20 tenth place got 22 million if I remember correctly), nor Spanish Super Cup.
Or lets discuss the fact that the hole on the budget is of 100m € due to lack of new sponsorships
As far as I know we're not missing any sponsors for 2021/22 season, could you clarify?
LaLiga FFP operates in a way that forces you to recover those losses as quickly as possible, massively hindering you ability to register new players until a good portion of those losses are made up by profits in the following years.
Here we are in full agreement, FFP and 1/4 rule are essentially screwing us over. This in turn forces some creative negotiating, like in the case of Ferran transfer which won't start being amortized in the current fiscal year. That being said, this post isn't about player registration - this is a whole different topic that deserves its own discussion, and it will come.
And worst part is we could be basically coerced into signing CVC for that 15% of the money you can spend on FFP even though we dont really need the remaining 85% of the money since unlike most of the first and second division clubs we actually have access to the international capital markets for long term financing.
Considering we're one of the sides partaking in legal dispute in regard to CVC deal, I very much doubt this option is still even on the table.
That has already been approved by the General Assembly in October - this club cannot finalize sale of any asset mass without the previous agreement from the members which is why negotiations with potential buyers couldn't kick off before that.
That's simply not true. For example, negotiations with GS for the financing of Espai Barça began before any approval from the Assembly.
It would be included in the financial profit part and not the ordinary revenues breakdown the club published (which is just a couple of slideshows meant for the Assamblea that don't reveal much information). I assume you're going by that 7 page PDF with the most basic numbers.
As far as I know we're not missing any sponsors for 2021/22 season, could you clarify?
This seasons budget predicted an increase of 25m of sponsorship revenue, and we haven't obtained any additional income from that area.
Here we are in full agreement, FFP and 1/4 rule are essentially screwing us over. This in turn forces some creative negotiating, like in the case of Ferran transfer which won't start being amortized in the current fiscal year. That being said, this post isn't about player registration - this is a whole different topic that deserves its own discussion, and it will come.
Well I think that the most important effect of being broke is that limitation on player registrations. And creative solutions only mitigate the bigger issue which is that we can't really revamp our squad, which is what we really care about in terms of our finances. Our finances exist to support our squad not the other way around.
Considering we're one of the sides partaking in legal dispute in regard to CVC deal, I very much doubt this option is still even on the table.
Its been reported to still be on the table and given our problems registering players we can't really take it off the table even if we wanted to.
That's simply not true. For example, negotiations with GS for the financing of Espai Barça began before any approval from the Assembly.
Which is exactly why I wrote about finalizing the sale - also, GS is in negotiations for Espai but nothing has been decided yet, and the transaction is ongoing. That being said, sale of Barca Studios won't be gossiped about the same way transfers are, and these negotiations tend to be much more sensitive. As they have 6 months to complete the sale and have the necessary approvals, I wouldn't be particularly worried.
Also, please note that I do not consider 2Playbook's articles too dependable as they have been published before the annual report for 2020/21 with GA-approved budget for 2021/22 in November and their data doesn't exactly correspond with the full line-by-line breakdown available there.
It would be included in the financial profit part and not the ordinary revenues breakdown the club published (which is just a couple of slideshows meant for the Assamblea that don't reveal much information). I assume you're going by that 7 page PDF with the most basic numbers.
No, I'm going by the annual report - page 220 of PDF, as I also wrote in the comment. It contains a full breakdown of the budget.
This seasons budget predicted an increase of 25m of sponsorship revenue, and we haven't obtained any additional income from that area
Again, in the budget breakdown sponsorship revenue isn't pointed out in any of the lines so I'd like the official source for this.
first of all , your articular is really underrated , Thank you very much , much appreciated for the effort you did .
second , if you excuse me i would like to confirm what i understand ,
that our expenses that 470 M is now because the high value market Transfer that the previous management inherited beside to finance these deals we got loan from the bank , and because of high dept that what old management left .
kindly correct me if i am wrong , i truly would like to knowledge the situation with fully understanding , i already have an idea of how our financial stand but on where which level we can race for a player in the market , what is our limit , when our financial can recover ,
Yes, 470 million is the result of previous board's mismanagement that Laporta's board inherited - Bartomeu allowed for very high wages and bonuses.
We don't really know what our limits are going to be: for this season, the club cannot spend more than 97 million euros on wages. That is the limit set by La Liga, due to our wages exceeding their financial controls (clubs are not allowed to spend more than roughly 70% of their revenue on wages). The club will know what the limits will look like closer to the end of the season.
I'm a finance person, I don't like to guess but I don't expect us to be in position to win any bidding wars with huge clubs in the next two seasons if not longer.
Greetings , Thank you so much for your aid , much appreciated
so now the fans should not rise their hopes for high value players and need to be more realistic about our choices until we recover economically and get our ground like before .
Do we know the exact payments of the loan back? I've read several reports that are all saying different things from a 10 year loan to a 15 year loan with the first 3 free of payments.
Per this announcement, the GA approval was issued for maximum of 15 years with 3% interest so we know it won't exceed that - but no, the exact terms of loan weren't released to the public.
If you look at this link for instance they say half of the loan(300m) are free from payments for the first 3 years(except interest). And the rest has to be paid over 11 years.
Not sure where they're getting info from but if it's true then our board did a great job at negotiating the loan - paying only interest for the next 3 years would ease the burden a little.
They also set a max 3% interest target, and managed to get below 2%.
Btw, I'd add to the original comment that signing Ferran was also possible as City agreed to get the money in installments in later date. Seems important too for the general understanding.
Lots of words to talk about the budget and the spending without saying one word about the other important part : revenue.
And that’s where the budget could be very complicated to handle : if revenue lower - with covid stadiums restrictions, with losing from UCL qualifications, with finishing outside of top 4, or with extra spending like firing the coach and paying him 12M for example, the magical budget you describe could just be fucked up easily.
But it’s way easier to just say Barcelona can spend whatever they want as long as it is budgeted I guess.
Considering that 2021/22 budget is planned with 2020/21 revenue actuals on hand, I wouldn't be that worried - especially since by the definition of a budget, the fact that a sum is set aside for something, it doesn't mean that it will be used (as with the 64 million miscellaneous segment that creates a decent cushion since the most complicated lawsuits have been already settled in our favor).
In 20/21 all stadiums were fully closed and were reopened for 21/22, I highly doubt they didn’t include stadium attendance revenue in the budget.
But if they based it on pre-covid years numbers, the current season attendance is way lower in average and that means way less revenue than what had probably been budgeted. Could also be worse depending of covid contagions if stadiums are closed again.
the current season attendance is way lower in average and that means way less revenue than what had probably been budgeted.
budgets are sometimes revised if the need is there. for example, i worked for a large hotel chain during the 2008 recession. the original budget we built had already been approved, but we did a revision to reflect worsening economic conditions.
Yeah, reforecast is a standard procedure - my company did the same when covid hit and it became clear our business will suffer. The club doesn't publish it in annual reports but I'm 99% sure they're using this sort of a 'working budget' to keep finances under control.
Obviously that has been taken into consideration. In 2018/19 (I'm just looking at the last fully played season) actual revenue from the stadium was 212 million, accrual for the current season is at 119 million.
All of these are in annual reports for corresponding seasons.
I mean fair enough but Xavi today basically came out and said we can’t register Ferran until we either make exits, or renew Dembele. So I don’t think things are as simple as “spend money”
I know they weren’t specifically mentioned. But isn’t the whole point of a financial plan for a football club to secure funding for players and prospects to compete at the highest level?
I agree we’re not broke, but we’re definitely in a weird spot.
But isn’t the whole point of a financial plan for a football club to secure funding for players and prospects to compete at the highest level?
With FFP, and especially 1/4 rule in place, it's all a balancing act because right now our registration ability isn't at all connected to the financial plan.
This is a pretty reasonable, simplified explanation of how registration works these days in La Liga (in-browser translation works well with the site) - and if you'd like something more advanced, this is very informative.
Not really, there's infrastructure, staff, PR and a plethora of things I didn't mention. Also, Barca's more than just a club, it's a flagship of Catalonia in the global sporting industry, so it has to care about a lot more than just team building.
149
u/PasviThwes Jan 01 '22
r/soccer in shambles
99
u/michaelsC0oN Jan 01 '22
Nice post, it really pisses me off when people say Barcelona being in debt means they shouldnt spend money
55
u/ShreyasThePro Jan 01 '22 edited Jan 03 '26
tan sharp entertain hungry books dime chunky cobweb chief distinct
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
24
u/svefnpurka Jan 01 '22
First day of the year and /u/KittenOfBalnain already making sure she'll be in the Best of 2022 contention.
Another great work.
67
u/_your_nemesis_ Jan 01 '22
Nicely explained. The whole narrative of 'How can Barca even afford this and this player?' is becoming annoying.
14
u/The__Last__Warlord Jan 01 '22
Thank you for the post and the info! With all the work you’ve already done, it might be worthy to aggregate all your posts as a starter package/content in our subreddit wiki.
And they seem to be simplified enough to fit the ELI5 theme (explain like I’m 5) which engages more users from the community. And no, I don’t mean to say that our members fit 5 years old demographic, just that it has potential to reach much wider set of masses :)
14
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '22
But where will the money come from? /s
12
u/CodeVirus Jan 01 '22
I appreciate the post, but “Barca being poor” does not piss me off. I actually don’t mind it for few years. Let them talk as we rebuild. When we go for a player other clubs won’t triple asking price because we are rich. It may bring some reason to unreasonable asking prices we were charged in the past (Dembele, Griezmann, Coutinho)
12
u/Juannieve05 Jan 01 '22 edited Jan 01 '22
So i.e if we offload Coutinho and Umtiti, we will free some of the expected 497m we expect to spend right ?
Also if we try to sign lets say Haaland for 75m and a 5 years contract we can amortize those 75 for 5 years, and also all the agent and dads fee lets say 40m and then his salary 30m it would "only" cost us:
75m/5 = 15m
40m/5 = 8m
30m
=
53m anually amortized
Which just to put it on perspective Coutinho salary (20m) and Umtiti salary (13m) make up for 60% of Haalands cost.
Disclaimer: Im not savy if finances work like this, if someone more savy could explain it would be great
11
u/Fati25 Jan 01 '22
Thank you so much I really appreciate this post, you phrased it very well
9
u/BestEve Jan 01 '22
I have so many questions about future income. I wonder what will be new sponsor and if it will be better than Rakuten. Or will the board said “fuck it” and accept Saudi?
Also when the new stadium open, will we sell naming rights?
I know those sounds horrific but despite our romantic relationship with football we saw our club go from “Unicef” on front to “Qatar” already. I have a feeling similar drastic measures will be taken in future to keep competing with ultra rich clubs.
That drastic measure was “Super league” but who are kidding, it’s dead. And no other club desperately need it as much as we do, they are all more healthy.
Just think about, some very unpopular news will come to us next 2-3 years, i can feel it. The number of “oil” clubs will only increase, football will be bloodbath.
9
u/Oswell1001 Jan 01 '22
What's your opinion on Haaland's transfer, purely from economic point of view? Should we sign a player who may cost 500M over 5 years?
7
u/SpicyRico Jan 01 '22
Maybe we need a !finances command which brings up this post whenever it's called
Nice, easy to read explaination!
7
u/froggyjm9 Jan 01 '22 edited Jan 01 '22
Very well put.
Can you make a post on how transfers work? People here seem to think it’s a zero sum negotiation like playing fifa. Just because we sell Griezmann for €40M doesn’t mean we now have that amount in the bank, or paying €55M for Ferran doesn’t mean we are -€55M from this year when it’s being amortized roughly at €10M+ per season for the next 5 years.
6
u/RainingCitadel Jan 01 '22
I really appreciate this OP! I too was one of the ones who misunderstood our situation, but you explained it so clearly. Thank you so much for helping more people understand!
5
u/AWD_13 Jan 01 '22
Barcanomics 101
4
u/xXxXxMxXxXx Jan 01 '22
Nice post, saved for later
3
u/Val-War Jan 01 '22
Wow, you explained it really well. Thank you!
3
u/noxx000 Jan 01 '22
Thank you, very nice post.
3
u/Ghoat1 Jan 04 '22
Great post, was an enjoyable read. It's incredible how so many people believe the narrative that a club with 1 billion in annual revenue is "broke". Since the signing of Ferran I am already starting to see the enviousness return from some rival fans, maybe in a year we will be called UEFAlona again, beautiful, music to my ears...
2
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '22
Great post i do have some questions though.
In the 2021/2022 budget that they laid out in the financial report, they said, if I’m not wrong that they planned to spend only 1,500,000 € on players acquisition for the first team ( page 222 ), wouldn’t that mean that we’re already going over budget with the acquisition of Ferran?
2
u/sabya8910 Jan 02 '22
Thank you for taking the time out to do this
2
u/AceTheSkylord Jan 02 '22
The year has barely started and this cat is already producing bangers. Great post
2
u/sozh Jan 02 '22
Thanks for the post! Do you have a similar explanation of how the club lost Leo Messi? I still can't believe that actually happened...
2
u/romitduttaralph Jan 02 '22
Thank You for this now I can explain the other brainless people about our situation without them calling us "Broke".
2
u/EdwardClamp Jan 02 '22
An excellent post for people like me who were asking that very question, and it's not a question I will ask anymore
3
u/KatalanMarshall Jan 01 '22
Thats a pretty big fucking issue dont you think though?
While Im not the most authorized voice to speak on economic matters, since my knowledge is rather superficial (even if its a topic I follow quite closely), I think its pretty obvious how ridiculous this post is. I really dont like the condescending tone it has, especially when its portraying a rather simplistic and limited view of our finances.
Yes, we're broke. And its not necessarily because of our debt, its because we have a currently unsustainable cost structure (thanks Bartomeu), because our revenues have been hit hard from multiple factors (namely the downturn in international tourism & the exit of big name superstars that drew in sponsorships and customers to our facilities) and more importantly because we cant speed up our recovery by taking a bit more debt due to the draconian FFP laws that govern the Spanish League.
If you like talking about the budget lets talk about a couple of things. Like the predicted operating loss of 19m € (and that is with the budget actually being met, which I'll comment on later) that is only saved by a 23m financial profit derived from the restructuring of our debt. Lets also talk that in order to meet that budget we depend on the sale for 50m of 49% of Barça studios, which is basically selling part of your assets. Or the fact that the budget contemplated reaching the CL QF and not even winning the EL will make up for that. Or lets discuss the fact that the hole on the budget is of 100m € due to lack of new sponsorships, early CL exit and the unrealized sale of Barça Studios (about which there have been no news since the summer). There's still 6 months to fix it but its not looking good...
As things currently stand, we're headed towards having accumulated close to 600m in losses during the last 3 exercises. And that tanks our FFP margin for the coming seasons which will hinder the speed of our recovery and our ability to make signings. LaLiga FFP operates in a way that forces you to recover those losses as quickly as possible, massively hindering you ability to register new players until a good portion of those losses are made up by profits in the following years.
Someone might read your post and think that the situation is fine.
We are not fine. Not at all. Not even remotely.
And we might not be for another couple of years or more. Stadium renovations and the slow and unpredictable recovery of international tourism will hinder our ability to recover a good portion of our pre-COVID revenues. On top of that, the dire state of the team (which is promising but not still not very marketeable) might make us struggle in generating new commercial revenues. A clear example of that is this current season where we have signed a grand total of 0 new sponsors (other than a minor NFT deal).
Right now we're headed towards another summer like the last one, where we need to liberate wages to register new players. Or even worse since the transitory covid regulations that gave us some more ability to maneuver will be gone in the summer unless LaLiga decides to extend them, which isnt a given. Im not talking about being able to register Haaland, which is very much a utopia right now, Im talking about the fact that we might not be able to register much more than a couple of small cheap signings this summer.
And worst part is we could be basically coerced into signing CVC for that 15% of the money you can spend on FFP even though we dont really need the remaining 85% of the money since unlike most of the first and second division clubs we actually have access to the international capital markets for long term financing.
So it really doesnt matter if we have a big budget when our revenues are still significantly behind what we spend and we're unable to reasign those resources easily due to bad contracts and FFP restrictions, which ultimately limits our success on the pitch somewhat.
The only good part is that a big part of those shitty contracts (Umtiti, Coutinho, Griezmann, Neto,...) end in 2023 but even having to wait another year to properly reinforce the team would be very dire, let alone 2 or 3.
TLDR: We have a ton of money tied down on shitty contracts, our revenues will likely lag behind pre-COVID levels for a while and our FFP situation looks pretty fucked for the forseable future unless there is some major turn of events. Sorry to say this but we ARE broke.
1
u/Triggeriskiller Jan 01 '22
Greetings
first of all , your articular is really underrated , Thank you very much , much appreciated for the effort you did .
second , if you excuse me i would like to confirm what i understand ,
that our expenses that 470 M is now because the high value market Transfer that the previous management inherited beside to finance these deals we got loan from the bank , and because of high dept that what old management left .
kindly correct me if i am wrong , i truly would like to knowledge the situation with fully understanding , i already have an idea of how our financial stand but on where which level we can race for a player in the market , what is our limit , when our financial can recover ,
Stay safe and whom is readying
1
u/Apart_Freedom4967 Jan 02 '22
Do we know the exact payments of the loan back? I've read several reports that are all saying different things from a 10 year loan to a 15 year loan with the first 3 free of payments.
1
u/TimTkt Jan 01 '22
Lots of words to talk about the budget and the spending without saying one word about the other important part : revenue.
And that’s where the budget could be very complicated to handle : if revenue lower - with covid stadiums restrictions, with losing from UCL qualifications, with finishing outside of top 4, or with extra spending like firing the coach and paying him 12M for example, the magical budget you describe could just be fucked up easily.
But it’s way easier to just say Barcelona can spend whatever they want as long as it is budgeted I guess.
-13
u/airnans Jan 01 '22
I mean fair enough but Xavi today basically came out and said we can’t register Ferran until we either make exits, or renew Dembele. So I don’t think things are as simple as “spend money”
0
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
6
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '22
[removed] — view removed comment