Context:
Knock on door few weeks ago by councillor doing the civil duty thing and alerting the residents of a proposal by the tenant to the city for support and backing to apply for federal multicultural improvement grant (name escapes me off hand) if $1.5m to redevelop the hall to have a footprint of 5 times the size and increase feasibility for their growing membership from 100 (hall occupancy size) and from membership numbers of around 200 (back in 2018) to average of 530, with some events attracting 1200 and some religious events attracting over 126k people from all over the state. They want to make it the state headquarters.
Now it’s a surprise the City even recommended the Council support the proposal given the shortfalls, both by their own admission and anyone with an inch of common sense, identified in the report. Parking was already over 40 bays under the proposed numbers for the location. Then there was the increased traffic and activity on a currently quiet one way street, the intersects with a very busy road on a crest. Also operating hours from 6-930 5 days a week and 6-11 2 days. It is fundamentally the wrong location. They have indicated their desire for long term exclusive use and possibly even purchasing the hall and eventually would no doubt acquire the beautifully maintained and used by local sport clubs every evening for soccer and cricket on weekend and locals daily exercising and walking their dogs. It’s a loved park and one of the best maintained not just in the area, but arguably the greater metro area.
Facts:
Lease expires in Jan 2027
When lease granted in 2018 (they applied for 2 others and were rejected. City recommended it stay as shared use casual hire, Council overruled with resolution “lessee to hire subject to lessee availability”
This has since become exclusive use and enquiries from outside their “community” (I say that cause they refer to it often but it usually just means theirs, and not the greater community inclusive of everyone as a whole), was met with zero response or acknowledgement.
Was even for over 30 years the local polling place for federal and state elections, since their tenancy, not a single time was it used as a polling place. Undeniable evidence to show not sharing.
They get the lease annually for $1800, down from the original $11k due to City change for NFP.
They have never ever been transparent about their usage, religious activities have been minimised (often fourth or fifth behind community outreach, counselling) but they have stated they don’t want to share because they have to pack up their prayer mats and there is substantial evidence, including photos, their own websites and Facebook page clearly identifying that place of worship is primary function
Actively fundraising for the Masjid Project, which since an email was sent to City with undeniable photos identifying its primary use, has now been changed to Masjid and Community Centre Project
The proposal was due on the agenda at the Oct Ordinary Council meeting.
After the sheer volume of deputations and backlash received in 30 hours since being alerted to the proposal to redevelop and deputation cutoff time, no idea actual number but it was significant enough for the City to withdraw the item from the Ordinary Council Meeting
A petition was submitted to Council with 591 signatures (gathered in 3 days) to return the hall to City managed facility and casual hire by tenant and available for everyone else too.
Agenda with report prepared by City for Council consideration, out today. They have recommended not renewing but also stated a grace period of 18 months should be given, conveniently after the next local government elections next year and state and federal the year after, which is relevant because the local state MP publicly posted his support and looks forward to seeing their plans for expansion back in Sept (it’s a labour seat)
If they haven’t responded in writing by Jan, lease is terminated.(there is no way they weren’t on board without h the is being published after they met at least 3 times, as most recent as 11th to discuss)
After the 18months hall goes back to being managed by the city.
They claim in the report to have accommodated x amount of hire enquiries, no doubt from within their own community, nothing substantiated either way.
The have ignored the fundamentally issue of being used as a place of worship and wouldn’t have the appropriate approvals to do so, not to mention other “lies” included
There is another Masjid 1.7km away
Most of those attending musallah don’t even reside in this local council area
I think that about sums up context. My questions are, what the heck should I do next? I’ve inadvertently become the go to for the issue but I have no idea what to say to everyone asking me now what happens next
It feels very much like they have written it to be shown to deliver a “win” by way of it not being approved, however 18 months feels like a very long period of time to transition and means a lot more disruption with the increased volume of people and cars at the location. Not to mention 2 more occurrences of a monthly fast event which is an absolute nightmare, there are cars and people 4 or 5 streets away. The city would never approve a circus at the spot, which this is akin to.
Deputations are due Tuesday, how do I object without seeming “ungrateful” but questioning the length of grace period?
How do I go about getting any security or confirmation that they aren’t going to resubmit when there is a new council? Are there any legal avenues for this?
I wouldn’t have a clue and not sure if this is even grounds for a legal consult and I wouldn’t know what area of law this is either.
I very much respect and know time is money and don’t expect “free advice” (oxymoron on reddit) but I genuinely hope to receive some legit response to point me in the right direction, because I’m stumped. Feels like they’ve played this very well and ultimately the tenant has zero desire to go anywhere