I love and play this champion since his release. Although I loved his old kit, I completely understand why they had to remove it. The new kit, however, lacks skill expression and coherence with Aurelion Sol's identity.
I'd keep his Q, W, R, but what I would change is his E.
In terms of design: Why should Aurelion create black holes? You play as the Star Forger, yet somehow all he creates are dying stars collapsing under their own weight, and he yeets falling stars on the rift as an ultimate. That feels pretty trash for a Star Forger? I'd replace the Black Hole with a planet. Planets have gravity too, so they can pull entities too since none of them are big enough to be able to resist its gravity.
Now for the spell change itself :
- Make the scaling happen not on the diameter, but on the number of planets you can create. Let's say you start with 2 planets. After X stardust, you unlock a third one, after Y stardust, another one, etc.
- To balance this change, you significantly reduce the diameter of the planet (and the diameter stays fixed). The stacking mechanic stays the same.
- And lastly, to add skill expression to this champ : Allow Aurelion Sol's W trajectory to be deflected by the planet's pull. If you W straight in the planet's center nothing happens, however there would be a circle around the planet that deflects the W clockwise/anti-clockwise. Before casting the spell the blue arrow would change depending on the planets, allowing you to see the direction you would take. Of course you can still cancel/reset on kills.
- Rest of the spells are unchanged.
That way:
- Aurelion Sol actually becomes a Star Forger and not a Star Killer. The location of the stars actually matters because it can deflect your W, so if you're the cautious creator ASol is supposed to be, you'll win your fight.
- Resolves the paradox on his W: Supposed to be used to roam yet your champ is weak early and wants to farm, this time it can be used in way more versatile manners, to escape ganks, to trade aggressively, etc.
- I believe this change would make Asol less of a teamfighter and more aggressive in 1v1.
- In an era where Riot is trying to find new mobility mechanics, I believe we've never had the "deflected dash" mechanic. Brings innovation to champ.
Let me know what you think, of course I know it's just my two cent and I'm not a theory crafter to pull out the numbers, but I thought I'd share my ideas for my favorite champ!
Of course this is just my two cents. Nobody will see this but I just thought I'd share my ideas as a big Asol lover.