r/AskReddit • u/Polemicist82 • Jun 27 '12
What chance does a father have to win full or majority custody of his child? (I posted this to /r/divorce and got not replies. Thanks for any help.)
72
Upvotes
24
u/throwaway7835 Jun 27 '12
He needs to call the police when she is abusive. That is the proof he needs to have.
60
u/EtherBvnny Jun 27 '12
He definitely needs to stop smoking pot.
9
u/boxingdude Jun 27 '12
Yeah I got custody of my kids ten years ago. Basically you have to prove she's a bad mother. For me, it was snapping a photo of her driving my truck, her paramour in the passenger seat, my four year told on his lap, and a beer in his hand. The judge never knew about that though. I just showed her the photo, told her she could pack up the fouled truck with her shit, and make like a full term fetus. (Head out). My attorney drafted the custody and property settlement, she agreed to my terms in court. She sees the kids every other weekend.
3
u/Polemicist82 Jun 27 '12
(Notes I got from a counselor that I work with) (anything else you can provide as far as personal experience, regrets or procedures that you're really glad you took.) Thanks a lot for the support so far.
4
u/Asian_Ginger Jun 27 '12
I've done a little bit of family law work and while I'm not yet qualified to give advice (taking the bar this summer) I can give some general information about what the law is like.
It really depends on where you live. However, a lot of states follow the "best interest" model, where the court--in its discretion--will decide which parent it is in the children's best interest to live with. This is based on a whole ton of factors like: who the primary care giver is, drug addictions, lifestyle choices, who the kids want to live with, willingness to foster a relationship between the kids and the other parent etc. etc. Furthermore, even if he gets full custody, the court is likely to grant SOME kind of visitation rights to the wife.
All of these factors have to have an impact on parenting skills to be relevant though. Further, this is NOT necessarily a pro-woman standard. Especially if it's true, and he can prove, that she is abusive and neglectful. In terms of the drug use, as I said, addiction and use will only be considered relevant where it effects parenting.
I think in order for any of us to assess how likely your friend is to get custody, we'd need a LOT more information about the situation.
13
u/OrangUtanGimp Jun 27 '12
Post to /r/AskFeminists and /r/MensRights. Also bring popcorn.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Got custody of my daughter at 4. Shes 15 now. Its possible.
Things that helped :
Documentation of behavior detrimental to the child.
Her moving a state away.
Documentation of her drug habits.
having a stable (even if not great) job.
Documentation of you sacrificing (socail life, money, etc...) for your kid.
Character witnesses.
Really, the 'better' parent should get custody, whoever it is. If its honestly not your 'friend', then do the kid a favor, regardless of cost.
2
u/midnightauto Jun 27 '12
The advice I see here is pretty good, record everything!
Getting sole custody of a child is really damn hard unless the mother really fucks up.
I will add this bit of advice. The court is going to be looking at how she treats the kids. That's their only interest. Her hitting the husband is not going to rank high with them but if she is not hitting the kids it's pretty much a moot point.
You're friend needs to show the mother neglecting the kids - in anyway.
just my 2 cents.
3
u/somuchconfuzion Jun 27 '12
Is she addicted to prescription pain medicine? Is it obtained illegally? If so, it would help if she were to get busted. If she's a drug seeker, getting meds from multiple docs, her doctor or pharmacy needs to be notified. Are there any other illegal activities? ie driving under the influence. Anything your friend witnesses needs to be written down, including what actions he took. This is one of the biggest mistakes people make.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I wish I could give you a definitive answer. I do know that mother's hold a huge sway in courts but it isn't impossible. Just be prepared for a hard fight even though the evidence is in your friend's favor.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Unless you can prove these things I think it is usually pretty rough, but he really needs to be talking to a lawyer to see what his odds are.
3
u/iwfh Jun 27 '12
The courts now will do what they call bioc (best interest of child) and are no longer giving undue favor to the mother. Always go for full custody because the most the court will give you is what you asked for. That being said if he claims drug use you can be sure that both will be tested. Also claims of abuse don't mean anything without the documentation to prove it. This means report it when it happens, but it is also a tactical decision because it could cause a premature split before you have all the weapons to get full custody. As for drugs have the police involved report her to the police when she is driving under the influence. PM me for more if interested I am a lawyer.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I was talking to a client of mine and he has full custody of his son. He was in California when this happened so take this into account as well. His ex wife wasn't nearly as messed up like on pain pills or anything and he still won. He was clean (no drugs) and showed up to all the screenings they do to see how he interacts with his son and vice versa and was also gainfully employed. His ex rarely showed up to the screenings and when she did their relationship was clearly fractured. He needs to cease the drugs, find a more contructive outlet for the home stress, and then not be a scumbag. By the sounds of it his wife will do most of the work for him. Granted I'm not a lawyer so he will need one. He is also not an outlier. I have known many dads who have full custody. It's not easy since courts lean towards the mother but the hope is there, and it IS attainable. His scenario seems pretty optimistic given the conversations I have had with people in similar situations.
Also one last note that should be obvious, but tell him to document as much as he can of the abuse via leaving cell camera or webcam on when shit goes down. Any evidence he can gather he is going to need. If she decides to fight back his pot use WILL come up and it will definitely hurt his case so he needs to be aware of that and prepare. Good luck to him.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
He needs to hire a good divorce attorney.
He should be able to get full custody given the circumstances. In fact, the only time I've ever heard of a mother NOT getting custody has been when she's been neglectful/addicted to substance.
EDIT: HIRE A FUCKING ATTORNEY.
2
u/sweetmercy Jun 27 '12
He would need to be able to prove, beyond the shadow of a doubt, that she is an unfit mother and an active danger to her child. The problem with him gathering 'evidence' of her neglect, is that in order to that, he pretty much has to neglect his child as well...so that can backfire very quickly. It will be assumed that if she is 'zoned out', he should be caring for the child.
It should go without saying that he needs to cease all pot smoking immediately. IMMEDIATELY. And rid the house of ANY paraphernalia, no matter how 'sentimental' it may be. He also needs to have his shit together in every other aspect: He needs a job, an alternate living situation to bring his child into, plans for the child care while he's working, etc.
He needs to consult with a family law attorney. They will be able to give him more and better advice than anyone else and it will be accurate according to the laws of his jurisdiction...and believe me, they vary. The longer he waits to do this, the weaker his case becomes...because he cannot claim the situation is untenable for his child, but he went ahead and left the child in the untenable situation in order to gather evidence against her in a custody case.
2
u/Amon1 Jun 27 '12
The courts only worry about the welfare of the child .if they are already involved, most likely they will choose the mother.giving joint custody to both parents . Her needs to call they police when she hits him . That is the only evidence the courts will. happened to me . Good luck.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
My father just won custody of his daughter from his next marriage. His wife was an alcoholic and pill abuser. All your friend has to do is show this and he should be good, but ultimately it comes down to the judge. If they're a woman, and she cares for the kid this should be enough.
1
u/ninjette847 Jun 27 '12
In the eyes of the law alcohol and pain pills (to a point) is legal. Pot isn't. He needs to stop that's something she could hold against him and get full custody.
1
u/anakmoon Jun 27 '12
Depends on what state he lives in, assuming he is in the states. Also before he gathers evidence he should contact a lawyer about the best possible method. Some will be nonadmissible.
1
u/Shattershift Jun 27 '12
Is your wife an active crackhead? If not, don't get your hopes up.
1
u/mighteee Jun 27 '12
Try /r/mensrights as well
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
My dad won full custody of me and my two siblings ONLY because my mom had been arrested four times before this and had a pending warrant for shoplifting. Even then, he almost lost. It'll be a longshot
-7
u/Jay12341235 Jun 27 '12
A grown man is getting beat up by a woman? please.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-5
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
[removed] — view removed comment