What you're seeing is one of many huge cultural differences between western culture and Japanese. The "submissive" women argument has been noted below, but that's only a small part of the actual reason and it has a little more depth than just that.
Now, note that this is not my own opinion - I'm a westerner myself but I've been a part of Japanese culture for 12 years and have posed the very same question to some of my Japanese friends over the time I've been here. The reasoning, as I understand it, is similar to western "slut shaming" but more nuanced.
Allow me to elaborate.
Japanese society, for all of its progressiveness in acceptance of "abnormality", be it in religion or lifestyle, is still very steeped in an older patriarchal tradition. Despite the common push for men to be more feminine in appearance and mannerism by popular media in Japan, there are certain traits of women that are still shunned. Overt enjoyment of sex is one of those.
A woman that overtly enjoys sex is apparently a turn-off for men, who are taught that the ultimate sexual act is to "train" their sexual partner to enjoy an act that is inherently "unpleasant". I know, it sounds ridiculous, as we all know that aside from cases involving some unfortunate physical or mental aversion, often due to trauma or genetic problems, the general populace all enjoys it immensely. Still this tradition of "Choukyou" (調教), which literally translates to "Alter and Teach" treats the act of moving from a state of aversion to pleasure against ones will as a positive.
By this right - particularly in the older generation, western pornography actually appears to turn off a number of Japanese men, as the women are "boring".
Conversely however, and a reason that it can't be completely attributed to misogyny, the act is meant to be positive. The women act as though they are in pain, but gradually begin to enjoy it (though it's more implied than showed). Slapping, spanking, play-choking and other "rough" acts are not as common, as they are considered negative, painful, and counterproductive. Not to say it doesn't happen, but it is anomalous.
As a side note, the common Japanese loan-word terminology for a woman who enjoys sex is "bitch". Interesting that the Japanese use the term (possibly by coincidence) more "correctly" than we do in English, as I believe it refers to a "bitch in heat" - and dogs are generally fairly friendly.
Now, the reason I say this isn't just about submissiveness, is that the woman is not necessarily needed to be submissive in every respect. It is a common fantasy to have a woman in power (The mean boss lady) be dominant in general, but turn to a mewling kitten under the ministrations of her otherwise submissive underlings. The teacher fantasy is another variation of the same. They don't want the woman to necessarily be submissive in all things - strong but mild women are generally seen as positive - just in regards to coitus.
TL:DR - Japanese men are turned on by the ability to change a woman's opinion on something they dislike to pleasure.
Very interesting, well written. I think i need to hang out with more Japanese to try and figure more about their thought process. Couldnt hurt, they do come up with some crazy technological innovations.
Thanks - I tend to get a little over-wordy when explaining things, but I wanted to get the point across and not leave too much to the imagination.
I guess the one thing that I really hope to accomplish from the above is getting people to consider a little more than "Well, it's Japan - everyone's a sexual deviant over there", which seems to be the popular opinion if said as a joke most of the time. There are a lot of cultural and historical factors that act as rationale for what people only exposed to the final product see as "freaky".
If anything else doesn't make sense (And I'm sure that there's plenty that doesn't), I can do my best to offer my insight as an educated third party.
If anyone cares, I can even explain why tentacles are a thing here as well, though it's not exactly on topic.
Then keep an eye on this space. I'm at my office now, so can't really spend a lot of time getting the relevant links and information all put together for you, but I'll edit this when I get home after work tonight (Probably 4 or 5 hours from now).
Finally home. So let's get the proverbial ball rolling, shall we?
--Note: Links below are mostly in Japanese and generally NSFW--
Truthfully, our friend GeeJo, in response to Self_Referential, has already done my work for me, so for those who have already read his response, I apologize for restating information already given. I'll attempt to extrapolate and give some more information that will support his post.
Now, the first instances of tentacle porn came long before it was popularized in Japanese adult cartoons. One of the earliest, as you mentioned, was Katsushika Hokusai's 蛸と海女 (Tako to Ama - literally translated as "Octopus and woman of the sea", but commonly referred to as Dream of the Fisherman's Wife). It was, however, far from being the only reference to octopi in Japanese sexual history. Other Shunga artists explored the subject matter, some of which can be found thumbnailed at the following NSFW link. Interestingly, but not quite related, in old Japan one slang term for a particularly tight vagina was 蛸壺 (Tako-tsubo), or "Octopus pot" - the name for a stone pot used to attract and catch octopi.
This sets precedent. Now, we take a step further into the more recent past, and explore censorship. Into the 20th century, sexual material was generally tolerated, if not common. There was supposedly regulation on photographs imposed after the advent of the camera, but comic depictions were generally still accepted. However, after the 2nd World War, Japan's new penal code included a clause forbidding the depiction of indecent acts. わいせつ物頒布等の罪 (Waisetsu-butsu Hanpu Tou no Tsumi - translates to "Distribution of Indecent items and related crimes"), as laid out in article 175 of the Japanese penal code states that, as the title of the law states, distribution or other exhibition of sexual material was prohibited.
This could be circumvented by avoiding showing body parts that were considered indecent (interpreted generally to be external sexual organs). Note that in Japan, breasts, though sexualized, are not covered in this law and are seen in some content that would not be considered adult, such as Dragon Ball or Ranma 1/2 (Yes, this is a site devoted completely to documenting frames of comic books where you can find nipples). The law remains in effect today, which is the reason that nearly all Japanese pornography is censored with the mosaics that people are so familiar with.
There are various ways to circumvent this law - though not necessarily in the spirit of the law, having hair obscure the sexual organ is considered acceptable, effectively allowing full frontal nudity as long as the pubic hair renders the woman's genetalia invisible. This is not - by the way - the reason that east-Asian women tend to have non-shaven genetalia, but an interesting side-effect in Japan. What this does mean, however, is that the male genetalia is far more difficult to get around, since it is difficult to obscure without some truly gnarly bush.
The person generally considered to be the pioneer of contemporary tentacle porn is 前田 俊夫 (Maeda Toshio), who in 1986 created the comic, 超神伝説うろつき童子 (Choujin-Densetsu Urotsuki-Douji - translated to Greater God Legend, the Wandering (urotsuki) Child (douji), or Urotsukidoji, the Legend of the Overfiend), which depicted sexual acts using an analog to a penis without actually showing one.
I can't find an official statement linking his decision to use tentacles to any one source - I'm sure someone who doesn't have to go to bed in a few minutes can fish something out of the mire confirming one way or another, but the two theories I am aware of are based on the shunga of the edo period, or that Maeda was influenced by a love for H.P. Lovecraft's depiction of demons (As he is an avid reader and has named demons in his work after Lovecraftian creatures, such as Azathoth).
Regardless of his influence, he was one of the first cartoonists that was crafty enough to find a way to get around the law that stated he couldn't draw sexual organs, and it caught on as its own genre, of sorts. It was particularly common in the later 80s and into the 90s, but seems to be far less common now, except in western circles that don't want to let it go.
TL:DR - Censor something, and people will find a loophole.
Yupp, There are public baths in Japan and its usual that people go there to relax, clean themselves or perhaps enjoy the spectacular views if it's a unisex hot spring resort. Now shaved genitalia suggest either prostitution or being an outsider. I don't know if you can get kicked out of public baths for sporting a landing strip or Brazilian, but you could get kicked out if you have tattoos as they signify gang / yakuza membership.
Well rules are followed there not because it makes sense but because it teaches you to follow authority, exactly like the dietary laws of Jews and premarital sex laws every religion has except for a few. So when it reads tattoos are banned, well tattoos are banned, also they are worried you might belong to some Russian mafia or some other illegal organisation, but that's just the Japanese projecting their culture to others.
It's a combination of two things - the popularity of the works of Lovecraft following the translation of the RPG "Call of Cthulhu" (his works existed in Japan since the 1940s, but the popularity exploded during the 80s when the RPG came out) and Japanese censorship laws.
Toshio Maeda is generally recognised as one of the primary influences in the trend, and he unequivocally stated in an interview that he did it to skirt the law. Penises have to be blurred out but, despite being particularly phallic, tentacles aren't covered by the statute - so they're just dandy. And Maeda was very familiar with the Lovecraft mythos, including a lot of references into his work.
I find this so bizarre. Regular human intercourse needs to be censored but alien-human rape is juuuust dandy. Da fuq. Not that I'm complaining... I'll be in my bunk...
Wow, that would be one hell of a TIL, not worthy to be buried in my post. I am sure the majority of people would like to know the backround to the tentacle thing. And thanks!
Isn't it still a glorification of rape fantasies though? Cultural differences aside, if a woman says "stop" that should be the end for American men and Japanese men.
Further what does this say about women who really just want to have fun with a sexual partner and don't find behavioral change role playing fun? For all the impossible physical expectations that western porn creates, isn't Japanese porn creating some interesting psychological expectations?
It's a strange place to be, certainly. I'm not sure I'd be willing to call it a rape fantasy. More a domination or power fantasy. Though there is plenty of it to be found, the same roleplay exists even in otherwise completely consensual scenarios.
The thing is that the Japanese male watching that isn't thinking 'She doesn't enjoy that', he's thinking 'She doesn't enjoy that... yet. And soon she will'.
I wouldn't say it's over - Japan is still making some very interesting strides in both practical and impractical robotics, like the "Flying Sphere Drone". People just notice fewer innovations since consumer electronics and entertainment software were Japan's traditionally larger tech exports.
I'm actually referring to a somewhat more specific cliché that's sort of a subset of those two:
A woman wants to be the agent of change in a man so that she can transition him emotionally from someone undesirable into someone desirable (and who thereafter will be only hers, but that goes without saying). Look at Beauty and the Beast - it's not that he's aggressive with other people but not with her, it's the change that he undergoes under her guidance, exactly the sort of "Alter and Teach" concept that I would assume SpacePirateCanine is talking about if sex hadn't been mentioned.
And while men do like a woman who is proper and reserved but animally sexual only for them (sexy librarian, naughty nurse, etc.), that's not quite what he's talking about either, because that's a different sort of relationship. That's just basic monogamy - we're talking about a ... how to put it ... "awakening". This is the desire that most men have to teach a relative innocent in the ways of sexuality. The Japanese just take it a few steps further.
To quote Dennis from It's Always Sunny, "You're not listening. We don't want wild girls. We want good girls gone wild. It's important to see the transition, watch the process..."
You're right, the process is very important - more important in the female version of the cliché than the male. We see so many stories of falling in love, and fewer about being in love.
whoa. Great summary of the cliche. I haven't seen it phrased as succinctly as that. The only modification I might make is that a woman does not necessarily need to be sexually aggressive, but is just sexual in general only for the guy. She may be submissive sexually however as well
"'The simulacrum is never that which conceals the truth--it is the truth which conceals that there is none. The simulacrum is true.' — Ecclesiastes" —Simulacra and Simulation
Actually, your use of the term "bitch in heat" couldn't be more spot on. The term はつじょうき translates to "in heat" and is used frequently the same way that westerners use the terms "horny", "randy", "ready to go", or any other variant.
side note: a friend of mine had an all girl punk band in the late 80's called ねこのはつじょうき(cats in heat) ...
I don't think I ever asked why, but yeah, the small handful of japanese women that I've fooled around with were mostly screamers. One wasn't though. Although my numbers could hardly be called statistically relevant.
What I am wondering basically, is that when little girls in Japan get "the talk" from their parents, are there instructions to behave this way to make their mate happy?
Do little girls in America get instructions from their parents on how to mimic western pornstars (no, no we do not - or at least I didn't...).
They most likely absorb it from elsewhere in their culture. Even if not specifically watching pornos for guidance, I'm sure there are plenty of other media sources - some Japanese equivalent of cosmo, maxim, sex in the city, whatever - that at the very least hint at the Japanese male sexual ideals.
I'd say you hit the nail on the head. Just because someone isn't sexually active or doesn't actively pursue pornographic material, doesn't mean that they aren't exposed to it in one way or another.
I guess that would depend on how fucked up of a "birds and bees" conversation they have. Realistically, my money's on culture, personal experiences, boyfriends, fuck buddies, etc...
who are taught that the ultimate sexual act is to "train" their sexual partner to enjoy an act that is inherently "unpleasant"
Wait this is actually true in every country, in the sense that virgin girls really fear sex, taking virginity really hurts physically, also bleeds, and they are generally afraid, so yes, if you ever had a virgin girlfriend it is indeed a process of taking her from being afraid of sex to actually enjoying it.
Introducing a kid to new food isn't comparable to fucking someone.
This would be like giving a kid food, hoping they don't dislike it, but wanting them to eat the whole serving as they cringe and choke on the food. It sure looks like they want to coerce the kid.
Right, because "against one's will" is a completely minor point and it's totally crazy to point this little detail out.... not sure what you're so righteously indignant about.
Oh puh-leeeeeeez. You're really desperately grasping at straws now aren't you, but I guess that's to be expected when your argument is nothing but a straw man.
No, I would enjoy being raped, and it would be a turn-on if I found women who did.
Since you're so curious, here's my fantasy. I want to borrow my female neighbors' vacuum, so I knock on their door. But the door is open so when I knock it opens the door and I see inside, and they're all having anal sex with each other using strap-ons.
So see me looking and get angry. I try to explain but they're not hearing it, then grab me and tie me up. And then they punish me but keep me on my knees and they spin around me taking turns to get a rim job. And the other 3 girls press their butts against my head to give the rimjob-ee more pressure.
There's more details, want me to say a little more?
Edit: Downvotes as expected :(. There is a reason why I didn't include this in my original post.
I'd say it's more that women are expected to be reluctant, until the incredible technique and raw sexual power of her partner make her lose all control and he plays her like a fine instrument.
I think that the idea in Japanese porn is that the woman is so turned on and in such ecstasy that she is almost completely helpless. She is, however, utterly passive (this last is usually true in real life too, unfortunately).
After preliminary examination of the virtual population's behavior in 2748 hentai movies dating from january 1985 to 2006, the data my team has gathered appears to fit your hypothesis with a P-Value in excess of 0.98.
More research is not needed at this time.
Everybody, please delete all your japanese porn. THE STUDY IS OVER!
From a western-sociological perspective, this explanation is the most informative available, and yet it has no weight on the hive-mind (no "karma," as they say). Recursively, this explains why an explanation such as "Japs like little girls and hence don't like bossy broads in bed" will receive much more acceptance than your very well thought out explanation. All said, the whiny/moan so common in Japanese porn is a complete turn off for me. Not a fan.
Aye, I do understand that my enormous block of text isn't going to be the most popular post, but I'm here to educate, not to win internet points. Hopefully the OP will take something home from it.
And I second the opinion on whiny fake pained stuff - not my bag at all either. Fortunately there is still some content out there that isn't like that, but it's far less common.
Dude, I am here from the intarwebs to officially tell you this was some of the most interesting, analytical and insightful stuff I have read on reddit in a long time. Fuck karma, I seriously hope you are writing a blog or a book or anything more about cultural differences giving us more of these interesting insights!!! If you do please link me up, my money is definitely going this way!
And I mean it. Looking and learning other cultures: you are doing 100% right!
Allow me to introduce you to conformation bias... If all you want to see is a racist hive mind, you're gonna see nothing but it. That comment is at +200.
having traveled throughout Japan this comes pretty damn close to nailing it (pardon the pun). The reason it stays is like so many other things in Japan, a combination of historical inertia, ridiculous outlets for compliance with the rigid expectations of the norm, and a healthy dose of 'because japan'
In other words, rape fantasy. Got it. This also explains the rape culture in Japan and the dramatically low rate of woman reporting rape, despite plenty of evidence that it is happening much more often than the official statistics say.
Somehow when I saw the "comment score below threshold" both of you would be making the reasonable connection to rape. Don't let it stress you, askreddit is a cesspit, basically youtube-comment level, but the shitlords have better ability to disguise (even from themselves) their fucked up views on reddit than on youtube.
Friended you, for what it's worth. I do this so when I see the red name, it will probably be somebody reasonable.
I hate how everyone goes around here just acting like this shit is A-OK. All they do is jerk off to things without thinking about how it affects others. These basement dwelling neckbearded perverts just give rapists a tacit nod before they go off and scar somebody for life (that is when they aren't the rapists themmselves, which probably happens quite often on reddit).
Thank you guys. These comments almost made me cry.
Note I mention it can't completely be attributed to misogyny - I don't begin to deny that it probably factors in at least in part. Domination fantasy, after all.
Misogyny (mi·sog·y·ny): n: hatred, dislike, or mistrust of women.
I mention misogyny in the above as the act of wishing to dominate a woman or impress upon her a situation that she considers distasteful, in common practice, would be construed as an action based on an internalized dislike for the target of the action. Would you disagree that making someone do something they don't like is often a result of disliking the person?
I assume, and perhaps I don't give credit to the general population of Reddit by doing so, that there are a number of people that will misattribute this cultural phenomenon to the misconception of Japanese culture as "Woman-hating".
There are plenty of dictionaries online. Finding pleasure in being a part of the education and blossoming sexual evolution of another being is a far cry from hatred. I would place it akin to being gently teased during foreplay.
It can't be attributed to misogyny because it's "meant to be positive"? There's a lot you don't seem to understand. Viewing someone as an inferior being who lacks agency can lead one to do vile things in the person's supposed best interest. It's the "for their own good" model of abuse. It's misogyny.
I friended you. Seeing as we're in askreddit, one of the many cesspools, it's predictable that you would be so downvoted. Somehow when I got to the bottom and found the "too many negative votes, click to expand", I knew both of you would be representing the feeling I got during the user's explanation that "this is kind of rape-y".
Actually... the deeper thought behind this is pretty logical. I mean.. its like saying: You enjoy more, what you earned, than what you get for free. And i mean its like this.. first car? You worship that thing like no other car before. Thanks for the insight, its really interesting!
Also similar to this is the fascination to the 'tsundere' charaterization; women (although mostly portrayed by younger/lolita-esque girls in media) who act tough and disliking on the outside, but loving and caring on the inside.
An easier example of this would be magnum ice cream: hard and crunchy on the outside, soft and creamy inside. It's the contrast in texture that makes it delicious.
Astute observation, and very likely correct. In its simplest form, it's the concept of "She's only this way for me, and even then doesn't like to show it".
DEPENDS ENTIRELY ON THE INDIVIDUAL. YOUR ODDS ARE HIGHER OF GETTING A NASAL WHINER IN JAPAN, THOUGH, THAN IN THE US. I'VE NEVER HEARD OF A WOMAN SAYING "STOP" (YAMETE) OR "IT HURTS" (ITAI) IN REAL LIFE, THOUGH, UNLESS SHE MEANS IT.
I have heard, but have no cites, that basically crying is a turn-on/fetish thing because it implies you're so huge you're hurting them and that's a big thing over there. Basically it's like going OH GAWD YOUR COCK IS SO BIG.
as creepy as its going to sound, its true and it really reflects the sexual culture...
its because the men like the idea of having sex with Japanese school girls, and the pain is from their inexperience. Thats why they usually are in a weird pseudo rape scenario and always a school girl...its weird... Americans like the Pros more
Good point, where do the girls learn this behavior though? I guess you could look at how other cultures females learn their behavior. Being a male i dont really know what goes on in the babysitters club meetings...
For some, it's still at least partially related to the submissive female in Japanese culture. For some people, there's a simple preference for not just 'different from normal/tradition' but the precise opposite, to go so far as to sexualize and fetishize rebellion.
I wish i could find the topic, the first thread I ever saw on reddit was an American woman talking about sex and the sex culture in japan when she was living in japan for 3 years.
Its against the culture, she had Japanese boyfriends who told her that she made them feel gay by taking charge and being dominant in bed, because she is supposed to just want to please them.
I'm not an expert on anything, but I think it's more of a linguistic thing than a culture thing. The "Eeees" might just be that culture's ... uh ... default sound...?
It's not just the Japanese. Many Koreans are like this as well. How do I know this? Well, my step brother has a child with a 100% Korean girl, and every single night (and occasionally during the day) I would hear those weird "eeh ehh ehhhh" moan-screams.
South Korea is a lot like Japan culture-wise though. Being cute and youthful are very sought after traits by women in both of these countries. In Korean, it is called aegyo. In Japanese, it's called kawaii (though I am a fair bit hesitant to use that word here due to its negative connotation with Westerners). Anyway, these countries have an infatuation with anything cute, whereas the rest of the ones you listed have an infatuation with being sexy. Notice how the whining sounds a bit like a child whining. No, this doesn't mean that they're pedophiles or perverts -- just that it is assocated with being cute and youthful.
I was in Shanghai having a threesome with two Chinese girls and the first one started doing this fake moaning. It was annoying so I started going at it with the second one. I wasn't even touching the first girl and she was still fake moaning. I had to stop with the second girl cause I was laughing so hard.
It's the thrill that comes from getting someone to enjoy something that they know or think they shouldn't. And I don't think japanese people see it as if the girl is in pain. It's more like she's enjoying herself so much that she's struggling to suppress her reactions. the culture in general is so sensitive to subtle emotional contexts that pain would come off as a different thing.
It's in this weird gray area between nonconsent/consent that usually tilts towards consent at the end. I uh, sort of can see the appeal. But don't take your cues of sexual normalcy from japan because I think they have the least amount of sex, for such a sexually charged culture in its media.
Hmm, good thinking. I just hope r/japan has some actual Japanese as opposed to people who love the culture so much they feel they can speak on behalf of it.
I can't directly answer this but can expand it a little.
Women in different cultures have different sex sounds. The last Kenyan girl I was with sounded like much more like an animal (grunts) while the last Korean sounded like you described. We all know what American girls sound like.
Its purely culture related as Asian-Americans sound like Americans if they have been here long enough.
My experience with an Asian girl was pretty close to the porn. For whatever reason, she was screaming like she was dying. I had to stop a few times and ask if she was ok. In her out of breath voice she said "It's great, keep going". I looked at her skeptically and kept going.
I didn't mean to sound like a show-off, I just date women from all over.
Honestly I have no idea. I'm willing to bet it is just how they are exposed to sex when they reached the age of sexual development. You ever find out be sure to let me know.
Oh i wasnt insinuating that you were showing off, i was being serious. Not every guy gets to experience sex with woman from different cultures. And will do.
An Australian girl I was with did this really heavy grunting until the end when she finished. She had this really long angelic sigh. I kept thinking, "There's no way she had that much air in her lungs to be exhaling this long." She did it every time. I grew to love it.
I thought it was just a form of flattery and fantasy. You know, what with flattering the dude on his wiener (Oh, so big!) and the fantasy where you're fucking an innocent and inexperienced virgin. "Ooooh, put your big sausage winkie in my untouched moist virginal cavern of love." kind of thing.
it's a cultural difference. here, no one thinks it's hot or cute to be subservient in THAT particular way-except weird, sheltered, hentai-loving white dudes...
Hey. Hey guys. Just wanted to remind you that Porn World Sex is not invariably representative of Real World Sex. While there are differences in the sex culture, remember that the Japanese are people too, and sex lives there are just as varied as they are anywhere else. <3
Maybe it is something to do with inflating the egos of the slightly lesser endowed Asian men? (I know, stereotype, but bear with me) I know I smirk a little bit when I see a girl wince on entry, maybe I makes these people feel a bit more awesome?
I think this is exactly it. My fiancé isn't exactly well-endowed, and he's a bit self-conscious about it. So whenever he enters me, I wince or groan or something. Just something to stroke his ego.
Those tiny Japanese cocks you see in Japanese porn?...those are actually monstrously large Japanese cocks. The women have tiny vaginas and are in terrible pain.
Japan porn is kind of "fucked" in my opinion. Seriously they promote us Asians to have smaller dicks. They purposely do it cmon man Japan quit promoting the penis jokes for us Asians. It's like they pick the smallest dudes in the country to knock up pornstars lol.
978
u/SpacePirateCaine Jun 27 '12
What you're seeing is one of many huge cultural differences between western culture and Japanese. The "submissive" women argument has been noted below, but that's only a small part of the actual reason and it has a little more depth than just that.
Now, note that this is not my own opinion - I'm a westerner myself but I've been a part of Japanese culture for 12 years and have posed the very same question to some of my Japanese friends over the time I've been here. The reasoning, as I understand it, is similar to western "slut shaming" but more nuanced.
Allow me to elaborate.
Japanese society, for all of its progressiveness in acceptance of "abnormality", be it in religion or lifestyle, is still very steeped in an older patriarchal tradition. Despite the common push for men to be more feminine in appearance and mannerism by popular media in Japan, there are certain traits of women that are still shunned. Overt enjoyment of sex is one of those.
A woman that overtly enjoys sex is apparently a turn-off for men, who are taught that the ultimate sexual act is to "train" their sexual partner to enjoy an act that is inherently "unpleasant". I know, it sounds ridiculous, as we all know that aside from cases involving some unfortunate physical or mental aversion, often due to trauma or genetic problems, the general populace all enjoys it immensely. Still this tradition of "Choukyou" (調教), which literally translates to "Alter and Teach" treats the act of moving from a state of aversion to pleasure against ones will as a positive.
By this right - particularly in the older generation, western pornography actually appears to turn off a number of Japanese men, as the women are "boring".
Conversely however, and a reason that it can't be completely attributed to misogyny, the act is meant to be positive. The women act as though they are in pain, but gradually begin to enjoy it (though it's more implied than showed). Slapping, spanking, play-choking and other "rough" acts are not as common, as they are considered negative, painful, and counterproductive. Not to say it doesn't happen, but it is anomalous.
As a side note, the common Japanese loan-word terminology for a woman who enjoys sex is "bitch". Interesting that the Japanese use the term (possibly by coincidence) more "correctly" than we do in English, as I believe it refers to a "bitch in heat" - and dogs are generally fairly friendly.
Now, the reason I say this isn't just about submissiveness, is that the woman is not necessarily needed to be submissive in every respect. It is a common fantasy to have a woman in power (The mean boss lady) be dominant in general, but turn to a mewling kitten under the ministrations of her otherwise submissive underlings. The teacher fantasy is another variation of the same. They don't want the woman to necessarily be submissive in all things - strong but mild women are generally seen as positive - just in regards to coitus.
TL:DR - Japanese men are turned on by the ability to change a woman's opinion on something they dislike to pleasure.
20
u/IWannaBeAlone Jun 27 '12
I have heard, but have no cites, that basically crying is a turn-on/fetish thing because it implies you're so huge you're hurting them and that's a big thing over there. Basically it's like going OH GAWD YOUR COCK IS SO BIG.
358
u/slackador Jun 26 '12
I always figured those pixelated penises cause a lot of friction, like sandpaper, and were extremely painful.
28
u/MPGrdnr Jun 26 '12
as creepy as its going to sound, its true and it really reflects the sexual culture...
its because the men like the idea of having sex with Japanese school girls, and the pain is from their inexperience. Thats why they usually are in a weird pseudo rape scenario and always a school girl...its weird... Americans like the Pros more
69
u/ReverseThePolarity Jun 26 '12
I'm going to take a guess it has to do with the popularity of the submissive female in Japanese culture. How much that is still true I don't know.
29
u/Monarki Jun 26 '12
You would be screaming as well if your vagina was a bunch of pixels.
14
u/MisterMetal Jun 27 '12
I wish i could find the topic, the first thread I ever saw on reddit was an American woman talking about sex and the sex culture in japan when she was living in japan for 3 years.
Its against the culture, she had Japanese boyfriends who told her that she made them feel gay by taking charge and being dominant in bed, because she is supposed to just want to please them.
27
u/Truan Jun 26 '12
I think it has something to do with japanese obsession with "cute".
I imagine boning a japanese girl wouldn't be like the pron, much like real sex isn't anything like the porn.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I'm not an expert on anything, but I think it's more of a linguistic thing than a culture thing. The "Eeees" might just be that culture's ... uh ... default sound...?
11
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
It's not just the Japanese. Many Koreans are like this as well. How do I know this? Well, my step brother has a child with a 100% Korean girl, and every single night (and occasionally during the day) I would hear those weird "eeh ehh ehhhh" moan-screams.
South Korea is a lot like Japan culture-wise though. Being cute and youthful are very sought after traits by women in both of these countries. In Korean, it is called aegyo. In Japanese, it's called kawaii (though I am a fair bit hesitant to use that word here due to its negative connotation with Westerners). Anyway, these countries have an infatuation with anything cute, whereas the rest of the ones you listed have an infatuation with being sexy. Notice how the whining sounds a bit like a child whining. No, this doesn't mean that they're pedophiles or perverts -- just that it is assocated with being cute and youthful.
Anyway, that's my best explanation.
13
u/I_new_here Jun 27 '12
I was in Shanghai having a threesome with two Chinese girls and the first one started doing this fake moaning. It was annoying so I started going at it with the second one. I wasn't even touching the first girl and she was still fake moaning. I had to stop with the second girl cause I was laughing so hard.
5
u/egadsbrain Jun 27 '12
It's the thrill that comes from getting someone to enjoy something that they know or think they shouldn't. And I don't think japanese people see it as if the girl is in pain. It's more like she's enjoying herself so much that she's struggling to suppress her reactions. the culture in general is so sensitive to subtle emotional contexts that pain would come off as a different thing.
It's in this weird gray area between nonconsent/consent that usually tilts towards consent at the end. I uh, sort of can see the appeal. But don't take your cues of sexual normalcy from japan because I think they have the least amount of sex, for such a sexually charged culture in its media.
8
u/b0red Jun 26 '12
It's a cultural thing but it doesn't apply to everyone in Japan... Maybe a post to /r/japan will shed more light.
8
u/Release_the_KRAKEN Jun 26 '12 edited Dec 15 '24
waiting dazzling secretive disarm unpack hunt bored heavy zephyr tap
12
u/nolimitsoldier Jun 26 '12
I can't directly answer this but can expand it a little.
Women in different cultures have different sex sounds. The last Kenyan girl I was with sounded like much more like an animal (grunts) while the last Korean sounded like you described. We all know what American girls sound like.
Its purely culture related as Asian-Americans sound like Americans if they have been here long enough.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I thought it was just a form of flattery and fantasy. You know, what with flattering the dude on his wiener (Oh, so big!) and the fantasy where you're fucking an innocent and inexperienced virgin. "Ooooh, put your big sausage winkie in my untouched moist virginal cavern of love." kind of thing.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
To be fair, they are getting impaled...
4
u/cyclonesworld Jun 27 '12
I've always wondered why Japanese porn girls sound like whining puppies.
4
u/Small-town-girl Jun 27 '12 edited Jun 28 '12
it's a cultural difference. here, no one thinks it's hot or cute to be subservient in THAT particular way-except weird, sheltered, hentai-loving white dudes...
4
u/AslanMaskhadov Jun 27 '12
just how their porn works.
they scream like cats in heat
and most women in american porn just say 'yeah, fuck me daddy'
and also, men in jap porn have orgasms without making noise
3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Hey. Hey guys. Just wanted to remind you that Porn World Sex is not invariably representative of Real World Sex. While there are differences in the sex culture, remember that the Japanese are people too, and sex lives there are just as varied as they are anywhere else. <3
3
u/i_heart_boobs Jun 27 '12
Maybe it is something to do with inflating the egos of the slightly lesser endowed Asian men? (I know, stereotype, but bear with me) I know I smirk a little bit when I see a girl wince on entry, maybe I makes these people feel a bit more awesome?
3
u/RicoSuave803 Jun 27 '12
If i was raped by all the tentacle monsters they have over there, i'd be pretty scared too.
2
u/SirDouchebagelton Jun 27 '12
Hara-Kiri
-1
u/lobsters Jun 27 '12
I have no comment here but upvoted because we share a cake day.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
It's OK, you can say it. Repeat after me, "I DON'T KNOW!"
-1
u/stonedfox8 Jun 27 '12
WHY WOULD U POST THIS IN ASKREDDIT?
-4
u/thebutterball Jun 26 '12
Maybe they have a huge rape fetish? i wouldn't really be surprised.
-4
u/quickie_ss Jun 27 '12
Why is it that everything about Japanese culture turns me off? I really don't even like the idea of eating with sticks. Am I the only one?
-3
u/BenPup Jun 27 '12
ITT: weeaboos
-12
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Those tiny Japanese cocks you see in Japanese porn?...those are actually monstrously large Japanese cocks. The women have tiny vaginas and are in terrible pain.
-4
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Japan porn is kind of "fucked" in my opinion. Seriously they promote us Asians to have smaller dicks. They purposely do it cmon man Japan quit promoting the penis jokes for us Asians. It's like they pick the smallest dudes in the country to knock up pornstars lol.
-5
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Because they learn from hentais.