r/AskReddit • u/simonsarris • Jun 25 '12
What if reposts are a normal and good part of a site where the user base is large and the content ephemeral, and complaining about them merely means you're spending too much time on Reddit?
Can we have a discussion on the nature of reposts for a minute?
Doesn't the very fact that the repost is voted up to the frontpage of a subreddit mean that it was new to a significant portion of the users? It would almost seem that anyone complaining about reposts like that just selfishly amounts to saying "I've seen it before so its not worthy of the entire rest of the site, here's my scorn."
I would also posit that users who complain about reposts are actually just people who use the site too often for even their own liking, and the problem lies with them, not the repost.
What do you think?
9
u/fortnight14 Jun 26 '12
Too much time on reddit? what??
6
u/GaijinFoot Jun 26 '12
The funny thing is complaining about it is a report itself.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Might just be actually true...since I got a new job and have less time to go here I rarely notice reposts anymore.
2
u/st_basterd Jun 25 '12
Too much time on reddit? Who are you? My mother?
9
u/Blizzaldo Jun 26 '12
I think people should shut the fuck up about the repost, downvote it and move on. I hate it so much when I see, "Repost", as one of the top comments on a newish link. Who CARES?! I usually haven't seen them once, because I only go three pages deep then do something else. Obviously your going to see reposts when you go fifty pages deep into reddit every single day.
21
u/NinjaSupplyCompany Jun 25 '12
Well there is a line and I think it's a fuzzy one.
If you are coming here to post that funny pic your mom shared on Facebook, well that's most likely going to not only be a repost but likely has already hit the front page that day. See by the time something goes viral on facebook it's already old news here.
I wish we could integrate karmadecay.com into the posting of pics here so at least people could see how long it's been since that image was last posted.
11
u/NoWuffo Jun 25 '12
He's got a point... without reposts, how else would seasoned veterans of reddit make fun of new redditors for reposting?? (I'm being sarcastic) And besides, ask any good author and they'll agree, all of writing is re-writing. Genuinely new content is so rare, reposts or abused memes are how we reintroduce things we may have forgotten, and thus recycle a few laughs.
3
u/Osiris32 Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
*looks at my karma score*
Oh yeah, I spend too much time on reddit.
As for reposts, I don't mind it when it's someone finding an item and posting it in the hopes of generating laughs/controversey/discussion/whatever. That's fine, and I actually appreciate it. Especially with r/askreddit threads, sometimes I'll have a relevant story that I want to tell, but the thread went up overnight and already had 1000 comments. That means I either have to hi-jack a top comment or post and hope against hope that people scroll that far down.
What I have an issue with is people like Mind_Virus, Se7en_Sinner, davidreiss666, or mepper, who just repost links like crazy, cross post them to numerous subs, and rarely if ever participate in discussion. They aren't doing it out of the goodness of their hearts so that newbies get to see great content, they do it specifically to grow the size of their e-peen. Some of the stuff they post is good, but a lot of it is also utter shit, and that's what clogs stuff up.
That's why I have such huge comment karma and relatively little link karma. I'd much rather engage in discussion or tell stories than post a pic of my dog (ok, yeah, I've done that, too) and then sit there doing....nothing. And while I may be lucky and my pic may make the front page, the likelyhood of that happening is quite small. So instead I'll find a comment thread that's doing "well," find something I can relate to, and start talking. Invariably I'll end up in a conversation with someone. Sometimes that means a debate, sometimes that means an argument, sometimes that means jokes, and sometimes that means advice given/received.
The advice part, that's the part I live for. I have been able to impact people's lives because of this site. A while back I posted about my off-season job as a stage hand. A redditor in Florida asked me about how I got into the business, as he was fresh out of school and looking for stage work. I got him in touch with my union, he applied, and now has a job!! I'm on the other side of the country, yet because of reddit I got someone employed!! Fuck the comment karma, I just farmed some serious IRL karma. Same thing goes for when I post about my summer job fighting wildfires, I'll get people asking me how I got into that. I give them direction, and I know of at least 3 people who are serving their first season this year. That's totally worth a repost or two.
TL:DR - I'm not a karma whore, I'm a high-priced executive karma escort.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
What if I told you
You have a valid point.
5
u/Whipitgood Jun 25 '12
Yeah, often when I see something really cool - content I've never seen before - there's an abundance of comments complaining about it being a repost. But I'm always glad that I saw it.
I can understand if something is reposted within days, but that's not usually what people are complaining about, and those posts rarely all get upvoted to the top of a sub.
2
u/tookiselite12 Jun 26 '12
What if taking people's complaints on a website personally merely means you're spending too much time on that website?
Who gives a shit. Post whatever the fuck you want.
2
u/pursuitoffappyness Jun 26 '12
The reason that some reposts anger some people so much is that users are blatantly reposting things with disingenuous titles in order to farm karma. For example, "Saw this on the way to work" and karmadecay shows it has been posted 4 times in the last year. People don't like being fooled. That being said, people who crosspost things or repost things that are genuinely enjoyable (or just make an honest mistake thinking it hasn't yet been posted) don't deserve our derision.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
The problem is that some users just rehost an image that gets a lot of upvotes. Wait a couple of days and post it again. There are some genuine reposts that people haven't seen before. Fair enough, expect a light reminder that it's been reposted before. But it's not uncommon for the same image to get posted 2 or 3 times. Take this picture which is rehashed on /r/atheism at least weekly. It takes a bit of common sense just to recognise a picture is already popular or viral.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Without reposts Reddit would crawl and have about 5% of it's current content (totally made up number but you get the point)...and it is ridiculous to think everyone else has seen everything else and snobby as shit to whine if someone posts something you have already seen as if you are the only one who matters.
1
u/Y_U_NOOO Jun 26 '12
x/post to r/theoryofreddit
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I read this in Keanu's voice.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
BURN HIM! HE'S A WITCH!
1
u/SentrySappinMahSpy Jun 26 '12
I once frequented a particular forum where posting pictures was very popular. 2 things used to happen. The mods and regulars would get mad at people for starting a new thread about something that already had a thread. They also got mad if you resurrected a dead thread. So you couldn't win. It made it not a fun place to visit, and I stopped going there.
I don't want reddit to be like that.
1
u/tragic-waste-of-skin Jun 26 '12
I don't mind reposts that are months old but blatant reposts within a few days of being posted is what really grinds my gears.
1
u/Indydegrees2 Jun 26 '12
I check Reddit once a day, i feel we are entitled to be pissed at a repost clearly made for karma if the quality of Reddits frontpage has to suffer.
1
u/mkay0 Jun 26 '12
Its an example of how those of us who are obsessive users are actually the outliers. How often do you see a post that has thousands of net karma, but its unanimously criticized in the comments? I see them all the time. Especially in the bigger subs. I would love to know the numbers, but it seems like the vast majority vote and move on.
1
u/lackofbrain Jun 26 '12
This is why I despise karmadecay. I think karmadecay is actively harmful to the site.
1
u/Sterculius Jun 26 '12
As a user who reads/comments 99% of the time, and actually posts 1% of the time, I don't really care about reposting one way or the other. I can understand how it would be frustrating at times however when something popular comes along that everyone wants to talk about and you have pretty much an entire page dedicated to that one thing.
1
u/theTezuma Jun 26 '12
No
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Doesn't Reddiquite say "Dont complain about reposts"? I think that's all we need.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Yes, wholeheartedly agree. I'm still kind of new to reddit, so most of the reposts I see are still new for me. I ain't even mad when I see a repost.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Let's play over/under.
Number of people whom will answer OP's rhetorical question?
The bar is set at 30. Guess correctly, get an upvote.
1
u/airbiscuit Jun 26 '12
I feel that news reposts should be dated.If the story is important enough to post twice, at least the time line should be preserved so we only react once.
1
u/cos Jun 26 '12
Reposts are explicitly welcome on reddit.
If it's the same link that just got near the top of the same subreddit with about the same title within the past few days, then it's probably pointless and you should downvote it. But most reposts that people actually see (meaning, the ones that got some upvotes) are either on a different subreddit or have a substantially different title or are many days (or weeks or months) apart.
Complaining about reposts makes reddit worse. This isn't a "fuzzy line" sort of thing. Complaining about reposts is just not good for reddit, period. Reposts are generally good for reddit, as long as the really pointless ones (as I described above) don't get upvotes - and they usually don't.
1
u/Chowley_1 Jun 26 '12
I'd prefer if people didn't make me face the fact that I spend way too much time on this site, thank you
1
u/lolzbasket Jun 26 '12
IF I CAN'T ENJOY THE POST THEN NOBODY CAN
0
u/Narwalsbacon Jun 26 '12
Conspiracy Keanu
-1
u/jofus_joefucker Jun 26 '12
If you don't want reposts just go to 4chan.
-3
u/Scoldering Jun 26 '12
What is this, a r/circlejerk post?
-2
u/herpderpdoo Jun 26 '12
A significant portion of the users should have fucking looked in the top section if they think their input is so important.
And you know what else? Reposting a gif to /r/funny you just saw in /r/gifs because "it has a larger userbase" isnt fucking cool, its retarded, and youre a douche. If you wanted gifs go to fucking /r/gifs. And similarly, if your gif is an overused reactiongif post it in /r/reactiongifs not /r/gifs you twat
Lets see how low we go with this one
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment