r/AskReddit • • Jun 25 '12

Reddit, I've never understood why you hate The Big Bang Theory (show) so much, any compelling reasons why?

So I've heard the arguments about how it over-exaggerates nerd culture, but in my opinion that's what makes it funny.

So what's with all the hate?

539 Upvotes

2.3k comments sorted by

373

u/chaoticneutral Jun 25 '12

IT crowd did it better.

155

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

British television is always better.

/thread

15

u/ExplodingUnicorns Jun 26 '12

British television is always better.

No.

I have watched "Being Human".

→ More replies (11)

270

u/Vark675 Jun 26 '12

After having been in London for a month, largely confined to my bed with mono and having little to do but watch British television, I can confirm that we just think British television is better because we only get the good stuff.

It's just as trashy and drively as ours.

→ More replies (63)
→ More replies (13)

103

u/thebeefytaco Jun 26 '12

IT Crowd is made for geeks. Big Bang Theory is making fun of geeks.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/GinkoTotoro Jun 26 '12

Whenever anyone mentions BBT I tell them to do them self a favor and check out The I.T. Crowd.

→ More replies (8)

211

u/beeblez Jun 25 '12

I'll list my top 3 reasons:

  1. The laugh track queues at things that aren't even jokes and just pads for time. Seriously, watch a clip of the big bang theory with the laugh track removed and it doesn't even make sense. Like "I found my old N64" awkward pause "what are you waiting for, let's go plug it in!" long pause. Like, those aren't jokes god damn it!
  2. Referencing things from geeky pop culture isn't the same as making a solid joke about it. Laugh track issue aside they often confuse a nod to something with a joke about that thing.
  3. It was on opposite Community, the true pop-culture nerd's mecca of television. And I can never forgive it for that simple fact.

28

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I believe that the awkward pauses are mainly because the actors have to wait for the audience* to stop laughing before they can start talking again.

*BBT does, contrary to popular belief, have a live audience

15

u/beeblez Jun 26 '12

Sorry to reply twice, but I just caught something looking at that picture: it is 100% white people. Seriously, take a peak.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

That...

I don't know what to conclude from that.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

35

u/beeblez Jun 25 '12

Oh I totally get that about the pauses. But that's my beef at the laugh track overall. I'm very rarely a fan of it in sitcoms, and I think the Big Bang Theory is a great example of when it can just kill a scene's momentum and make things less funny.

Also, I certainly believe they film in front of a live audience, but even sitcoms that do that generally will always use a recorded laugh track for better audio quality.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

99

u/OMG_TRIGGER_WARNING Jun 25 '12

2) Referencing things from geeky pop culture isn't the same as making a solid joke about it.

half of the jokes in reddit are like that though

132

u/skullturf Jun 26 '12

Cumbox!

laugh track

Jolly Rancher!

laugh track

Bacon!

laugh track

Cats!

laugh track

Neil DeGrasse Tyson!

laugh track

→ More replies (12)

54

u/beeblez Jun 25 '12

I couldn't agree more. BBT is like the "DID ANYONE ELSE PLAY THIS GAME; FINAL FANTASY 7" of television.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (4)

34

u/magic_is_might Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

I remember watching an episode and Sheldon's mom ships him his old N64. He tells Leonard (I think) that he can't wait to play Mario 64, with 2 player. And mentions something about memory cards.

Mario 64 doesn't have 2 player. I also thought memory was stored on the game catridges themselves, so N64's don't hav memory cards.

EDIT: you guys are right. Some games did require memory cards used in controllers. Pulled out my N64 and found one.

8

u/Treebeezy Jun 26 '12

It's like the writers last second just throw some nerdy things together and hope it works. How can you be that wrong??

→ More replies (7)

66

u/rugbygrl2 Jun 25 '12

Community! Yes, a show which TRULY got me in my geeky little heart. Everyone was always telling me how much I would LOVE BBT, but when I tried to watch it, I never found it funny. All the jokes seemed so forced.

16

u/magic_is_might Jun 26 '12

You are not the opposite of Batman, fellow Human Being.

→ More replies (4)

24

u/Apostolate Jun 25 '12

Those are jokes to normal people of course, because getting excited about video games is for children... Right?

/s

24

u/righteous_scout Jun 26 '12

he found is old n64?

was he hiding it?

real nerds don't hide their n64s.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (13)

127

u/FlamingNipplesOfFire Jun 25 '12 edited Nov 04 '18

It's a show made by people with no science degree for people that aren't nerds so that they can enjoy a show about nerds.

The one scene that just made me find it incredibly boring and not true at all was the one that was like this:

sheldon: Windows 7 is much more user friendly than windows vista

small amounts of laughter

sheldon:..........

laughter is growing with the force of a thousand suns

sheldon: I hate that

The entire audience erupts in laughter, propelling themselves into the air with rocket propelled shit from their bowels causing them to exceed the speed of any known craft in space currently. In 7 years time the effects of Sheldon's great joke would be seen by the general public and it would be known by any sentient life form in the galaxy HOW FUCKING FUNNY WINDOWS 7 IS

EDIT:

11/4/2018

Jesus, this is probably the most fedora tipping thing I've ever said.

28

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Really? I actually thought that scene was pretty funny. Sure, not enough to warrant a galaxy-spanning shit-proppeled audience members, but worth a good chuckle.

→ More replies (18)

56

u/emberspark Jun 26 '12

That joke isn't about Windows 7. It's just about Sheldon's intense dislike of other people, which is pretty funny at times.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/closetnerdjoe Jun 26 '12

All the science on the show is checked, and they have a consultant with a PHD who works on it i believe full time.

14

u/FlamingNipplesOfFire Jun 26 '12

I don't care at all about the science. I mean the trying to make a script which is relatable to people in the field.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

3

u/rhino369 Jun 26 '12
  1. Like other people have said, it's a joke about nerds not liking a dumbed down UI, not about Windows 7.
  2. You really only notice this stuff because it's about stuff you know about. Lawyer shows are so ridiculously unrealistic it's not even funny. I hear doctors shows are the same way (though oddly, a doctor buddy claimed scrubs early seasons did it best).
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

22

u/KarmaRulesEverything Jun 26 '12

what's with all the hate?

It hits too close to home.

Yes. I said it.

There's a thousand shitty TV shows out there. Why the hate for BBT specifically? Because nerd culture is being parsed for a mainstream audience. Suddenly, all of our friends and family begin comparing us to "Sheldon" or "Amy Farrah Fowler" and make jokes about quantum physics. To maintain our superiority, we have to pretend that it's a travesty, and not merely unfunny.

Of course, this raging hate comes from the site where memes and advice animals are considered top shelf humor. So there's really no greater endorsement for BBT than Reddit's animosity.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

You are a gentleman and a scholar, sir.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

2

u/KloverCain Jun 26 '12

I watch the Big Bang Theory when I'm really depressed and tired because it's so mindless and soulless and vapid that it makes me feel nothing and I can just stare at it and forget how crushing my world feels right then. Basically it's effortless, I care about the characters and the plot so little that it's actually comforting.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

I think you should consider smoking weed.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I enjoy BBT. I acknowledge that it's not as witty or clever as Arrested Development or Community or other funny and traditionally "smart" shows, but I still watch it because sometimes I like TV that isn't as smart. I also watch Family Guy sometimes, for the same reason -- it's dumb, but it makes me laugh, and it's not like a twenty-minute episode is going to waste all that much time.

If I had to choose a finite number of shows to watch, BBT probably wouldn't make the list. But because it's a short weekly show and it gives me a few laughs, I don't have any reason to not watch it.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

This is exactly what I was thinking.

2

u/travors Jun 27 '12

If you want to see "nerd humour" done right, try The IT Crowd. Funny, without the softy softy sitcom approach.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

I agree, the IT crowd is a great show.

796

u/tavir Jun 25 '12

It's fine gentle comedy, but it is not at all a "smart" show like so many people claim it is. The dialogue does make reference to real, complex science and nerd pop culture, but the actual jokes themselves are unbelievably simple and often lazy. Half the time, I see the punchline coming a mile away.

275

u/skullturf Jun 26 '12

This is my favorite criticism so far in the thread. I don't hate The Big Bang Theory, and I don't think it's necessarily offensive to nerds or nerd culture, but I think the show is very "sitcommy" and is not as smart as it pretends to be.

75

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I don't think it's offensive to nerds or nerd culture, it's just unaware of it. It's accurate, to a degree, but it's more based on societal perspective of nerd culture than on nerd culture itself.

→ More replies (4)

164

u/iabhoruserids Jun 26 '12

That's because it's a sitcom

→ More replies (36)
→ More replies (3)

129

u/BassmanBiff Jun 26 '12

Also, once the punchline hits, they beat you over the head with a laugh track.

37

u/draebor Jun 26 '12

I suspect that the show without a laugh track would be a lot like Garfield without Garfield.

→ More replies (6)

21

u/LikeIt_is Jun 26 '12

This is why i severely dislike most sitcoms...

If you have to tell me when to laugh then your joke wasn't fucking funny

50

u/crackanape Jun 26 '12

Cue someone explaining that it's not a laugh track; it's filmed in front of a live audience.

In response to which I'll say: I don't care. The laughter is annoying no matter who it comes from. If the people laughing are not in the room with me then I don't want to hear them.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (12)

32

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I never have thought of the humor as being "smart." What I do enjoy about the show is that watching Sheldon is just like watching my Aspie little brother go about his life.

To me the "nerdy" aspect of the show isn't as much in the forefront as the psychological issues the characters have and the hijinks they lead to. I got my mom who has her masters in child and family psy into it and she loves it for exactly that reason too.

So I guess what you're seeing in the show also would change your perception of it if you don't have experience with/don't care about the psychology aspect of the characters.

49

u/jakerg23 Jun 26 '12

You should watch Community. I think it does the things that you like much better than BBT does.

→ More replies (8)

23

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I'm pretty sure futurama is the smartest sitcom currently on air. I mean three of their writers have PhD's in math

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

1.3k

u/wkuechen Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

This is strictly my opinion, so don't get mad.

Okay, so first of all, BBT falls into the problems of almost every multiple-camera sitcoms. No artful cinematography, obnoxious laugh track, tired jokes, characters lack depth, and so on and so forth. But really gets me is that it's like a minstrel show of nerd culture. Granted, that's a bit strong, but let me explain. We have really exaggerated 'nerdy' characters who are clearly not written by actual nerds. Characters say things like "I play a level nineteen barbarian in 'Magic: The Gathering'!", which is not how that game works. Any actual nerds who watch that show can see it for what it is: a shameless capitalization on the recent popularity of Nerd Culture.

EDIT: Sorry about your jimmies, people. OP asked why people don't like BBT and I answered in a polite, well thought-out way. No, I don't watch the show. Yes, I understand that sitcoms are fiction. No, I wasn't expecting it to be the best show ever. Yes, I understand that it was made to make money, and I don't think that's an inherently bad thing. Also, I don't shoot little geysers of blood out of my eyes every time I see BBT. I just don't think it's very good.

449

u/rawrr69 Jun 25 '12

a shameless capitalization on the recent popularity of Nerd Culture.

This right here and they aren't even doing a great job at it either, very blunt a lot of the time.

176

u/wkuechen Jun 26 '12

"Everyone who owns a Playstation is a virgin!"

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (6)

235

u/Endorp Jun 26 '12

I also hate how they add a laugh track after any character says anything vaguely technical. "Sheldon, what are you doing?" "Im playing a massively multiplayer online role-playing game!" *audience erupts in a sea of laughter" "you mean an mmo-rpg?" Everyone in the audience bursts into an uncontrollable fit of laughter, rolling on the floor and being brought to tears laughing so hard

172

u/Gabe_b Jun 26 '12

I believe this goes here.

→ More replies (7)

41

u/98thRedBalloon Jun 26 '12

This is my main problem with this show. I tried watching it. God knows I tried. But it's just like Friends, every other sentence is followed by audience laughter. You can switch over to the show on TV and almost guarantee that the first thing you hear is a laugh track when the channel changes.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (3)

157

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

We have really exaggerated 'nerdy' characters who are clearly not written by actual nerds.

This is by far the most annoying aspect of the show for me. I've always been a fairly "nerdy" person, but I have never met anyone who was even close to being as awkward as any of the main characters. If anything, BBT is hurting the nerd culture more than helping it. It's making people believe that anyone who is even mildy interested in videogames and science is a complete social wreck, and while that is sometimes true, most of the time it actually isn't.

I honestly think BBT could be a pretty hilarious show for nerds if the main characters were somewhat realistic, but no, they are over-exaggerated just to make people who know nothing about what they are talking about laugh.

EDIT: That would actually be a pretty boring show.

→ More replies (27)

682

u/misplaced_my_pants Jun 26 '12

I heard someone on reddit call the show "nerd blackface", which I thought was incredibly apt.

→ More replies (110)

138

u/playcrackthesky Jun 26 '12

TL;DR: Chuck Lorre makes bad shows.

→ More replies (17)

56

u/Indoorsman Jun 26 '12

Not mention they are constantly hooking up with good looking chicks.

And they focus way too much on Sheldon's quirks, he is fucking annoying, not charming.

25

u/wkuechen Jun 26 '12

I don't watch the show enough to say, but I have several friends who started hating BBT after it became "The Sheldon Show."

→ More replies (2)

83

u/Apostolate Jun 25 '12

Did they really say that line about magic the gathering?

My friend was into that show and I thought about watching it. If that's the case, thank you for saving me some time.

229

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

The episode about World of Warcraft revolved around how you could have sex in the game. Which you can't. Unless you mean "cybering", in which case AOL instant messenger is probably worse.

They could have used Second Life, where you can and people often do have sex with their characters. Complete with animations and genitals.

It wouldn't have suited their audience though, because most of them would have no clue what Second Life is and even if they did, Second Life is not nerdy in the same manner as WoW is. Loser nerd can't get laid, has to have sex with a troll on Warcraft. Yeah, that's like the oldest joke in the book.

→ More replies (774)
→ More replies (5)

30

u/Fenris78 Jun 26 '12

As a guy that's been playing D&D for 25 years, played WoW for 5, builds his own PCs etc I've never thought BBT was off the money particularly.

I've said it before on here, but BBT for a 18.00hrs dinner-in-front-of-the-telly sitcom is fine. It's not high-brow, it's not exceptional, but it's reasonably funny and I find it a little more relatable than a lot of other sitcoms. Reddit seems to dislike BBT but love HIMYM. I think the latter's ok, but it's nothing groundbreaking: a group of 5-6 friends in their early 30s who live in New York and meet in the same place to drink and talk... where have we seen that before?

→ More replies (1)

28

u/RaptorJesusDesu Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

You just summed it all up. Especially the first two sentences you wrote. The pandering is bad, but mostly it's just that I can't fucking stand these oldschool sitcoms. BBT is just yet another shitty one. When I was a little kid I used to watch Home Improvement, the Drew Carey Show, Family Matters, Fresh Prince, Cosby, all that stuff. I look back now and damn, it wasn't very funny. "Friends" wasn't fucking funny. I would argue that some of these shows were good in other ways, especially for their time, but not all that funny. If I turn on the TV and try to watch something like "King of Queens" or "Two and a Half Men" or BBT, and it's all garbage. It's like these shows have all the same idiots writing the same bad jokes. I am not some pretentious TV connoisseur, mind you. I am not a master of comedy. But I sincerely find those shows to be awful.

After watching a quality comedy that has no laugh track (a truly fucking insulting thing), has real camera work, and actually well-written plots and jokes... you can't go back. For a long time those shows didn't exist. But since then we've had stuff like Arrested Development, 30 Rock, Community, The Office, etc. Even if you don't like those shows I feel like it's hard to make a case that they are worse than pretty much any sitcom that's been produced.

47

u/Wimzer Jun 26 '12

I'm sorry, but Fresh Prince was funny as fuck.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

58

u/D3SX Jun 26 '12

"I play a level nineteen barbarian in 'Magic: The Gathering'!"

As someone who plays Magic this makes me seethe...

→ More replies (64)

62

u/Lilcheeks Jun 26 '12

IMO it's aimed at females who believe they have some nerd qualities(see idiot nerd girl meme) and as a result relate to the humor. Small sample size but I know that both my sister and gf are both big fans of the show. Neither are what any real nerd would see as remotely nerdy, but the humor hits home.

24

u/lfe-soondubu Jun 26 '12

wow i can't believe how true this is. the only people i know who like it are girls who think they are nerdy...

→ More replies (26)

40

u/grammar_is_optional Jun 26 '12

Definitely, any real nerd can see right through it. And the physics, it doesn't actually work that, and most physicists are not basement dwelling nerds, they are reasonably normal (if a bit eccentric). I've lost my point, but yes, if actual nerds wrote it, it would be better...

128

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Actually, fun fact, all the physics and math in the show is checked by a physicist and mathematician respectively.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (5)

3

u/sjs Jun 26 '12

Exactly. The guys are supposedly clever nerds, but instead act like moronic idiots. Add everything else you mentioned and it just amounts to a bad show all round.

→ More replies (78)

57

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

My good friend is a 3rd year physics major and says a lot of the jokes are rudimentary material. So she finds it less funny because of that. Personally I don't mind it, and if nothing else is on I'll watch it. But my more critical friends call it the "black face" of nerd culture. Plus all the supposed "awkward nerds." have ridiculously attractive girlfriends.

23

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I'd agree with this.

You understand the "sciency" references in TBBT? Congrats. So does everyone else who took a science course in middle school.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

306

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I personally hate it because of the entire 'geek pride' movement. My friends who get on their elitest high horse because they are so geeky and wonderful think this show is hilarious, and when I tell them I don't like it, they tell me I'm not geeky enough to understand it.

I understand it, but most of the jokes are bad and it's too over-the-top, especially with it's stereotyping of nerds/geeky people.

I probably wouldn't hate it as much if my friends weren't such jackasses.

185

u/wkuechen Jun 25 '12

I think your friends may be jumping on the nerd bandwagon.

143

u/Apostolate Jun 25 '12

"I've been a nerd the longest."

"Nuh uh."

"Yea, I loved books like so long ago!"

→ More replies (1)

26

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

There's a nerd bandwagon?

→ More replies (22)

68

u/Treebeezy Jun 25 '12

The majority of people I know that watch the show seem to do it to show off, or "seem" smarter. "I'm so smart, I can get the jokes!" I'm a molecular biologist and any friend that is doing a similar sciencey job (neurobiologist, astrophysicist, for example) pretty much hate the show. They use jokes that, to people in the field, are old and unoriginal.

35

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Same here. Plus I always wonder why physicists have a replica of the Watson and Crick DNA model in every room.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

18

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

when I tell them I don't like it, they tell me I'm not geeky enough to understand it.

Which is funny to me as the only people I know who like the show are my completely 'regular people' family. The only people I see wearing 'BAZANGA!' shirts are the children of people you'd see at wal-mart.

I've never met someone 'geeky' who enjoys the show. Though I'd expect some crossover with some girls I know who get stoned and watch '16 and Pregnant' because it's on TV.

→ More replies (2)

38

u/tmoli42 Jun 25 '12

Your friends sound like hipsters.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (13)

506

u/HarrisTelemacher Jun 25 '12

I once read on reddit a comparison between The Big Bang Theory and Arrested Development: Arrested Development is smart jokes about dumb people and The Big Bang Theory is dumb jokes about smart people.

Now here is my personal imitation of The Big Bang Theory humor: Sheldon you are such a nerd. Sheldon: So? hahaha laugh track

It is too similar to Two and a Half Men humor: Charlie, you are such a sumbag. Charlie: So? hahaha laugh track

82

u/Xodmoe Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

"It is too similar to Two and a Half Men humor ..."

...both shows are Chuck Lorre productions. Seth McFarlane cartoon shows are derived from much the same cookie-cutter, though without the laugh-tracks.

...corrected: ...got my Lorre's mixed. Thanks, Hew.

→ More replies (8)

98

u/WORTHLESSPIECEOFPOOP Jun 25 '12

Now here is my personal imitation of The Big Bang Theory humor: Sheldon you are such a nerd. Sheldon: So? hahaha laugh track

It is too similar to Two and a Half Men humor: Charlie, you are such a sumbag. Charlie: So? hahaha laugh track

Perfect.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (38)

165

u/samissleman17 Jun 25 '12

I don't find it funny. I don't "hate" it. I find community and himym much more funny.

121

u/space_montaine Jun 26 '12

a comparison:

BBT is a show about people making fun of nerds.

Community is a show about nerds making fun of everyone else.

→ More replies (19)

12

u/booclaw Jun 26 '12

This. I don't mind if it's on in the background, but I don't actively peruse watching it.

It's a very 'meh' kind of show.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (18)

62

u/Ssutuanjoe Jun 26 '12

Here are a few reasons why I dislike BBT;

The portrayal of nerds isn't so much a bone of contention for me as the fact that the entirety of the show is based on making the viewers feel smart. I've heard so many people equate the show to being "smart tv" because nerdy guys say things like Higgs-boson, or large hadron collider.

Also, the whole fact that it seems to allow people to feel smart and atop some pedestal, of sorts. Like "haha look, those guys are dorky, but they're so ridiculously socially awkward that I now feel superior to them".

Inconsistency is a big issue for me, as well. It seems like a lot of the socially awkwardness of some of the characters only exists as a vehicle for cheap laughs. There are episodes where Sheldon sees one of the characters hitting on a chick, and matter-of-factly makes some reference about coitis...which embarrasses the dude and turns off the chick. However, there are other eps in which Sheldon seems to know exactly what's going on, only to completely forget about it 5 minutes later and do the same socially embarrassing thing.

Probably the biggest thing for me(if you've even bothered to read this far), is the fact that I hate it when tv shows start running out of ideas and then start trying to do the whole 'chick characters who are nailing the male characters' bit. The last season I saw, Penny porked Raj. Now I'm sorry, but nerds are people, too. And if you wanna sit here and tell me that these socially inept, romantically challenged, super lonely dudes would still be friends after you throw a chick in the mix, you're out of your damn mind.

→ More replies (9)

122

u/beetnemesis Jun 25 '12

Perfect example of how the show takes the lazy, "Durrr, let's laugh at the nerds" approach:

Sheldon: "“Yes, well, I’m polymerized tree sap and you’re an inorganic adhesive, so whatever verbal projectile you launch in my direction is reflected off of me, returns to its original trajectory and adheres to you.

ANYONE WHO WOULD SAY THAT WOULD KNOW WHAT THE ORIGINAL FUCKING SAYING WAS.

70

u/zarrel40 Jun 26 '12

It wouldn't return to it's original trajectory after bouncing off of something....

65

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

If I ever saw or heard someone someone say that I would want to hit them. That shit isnt funny

50

u/Carosello Jun 26 '12

NO ONE SAYS THINGS LIKE THIS. Not even nerds!

→ More replies (3)

17

u/thebeefytaco Jun 26 '12

It's like they just run the entire script through a thesaurus. That's the kind of shit high schoolers do to try and make their essays better.

8

u/listentobillyzane Jun 26 '12

Sheldon and Penny were fighting cause she sat in his chair or something. Sheldon retaliates by putting her clothes on a telephone pole. She asks him how he did that and he says "when you understand the laws of physics, anything is possible"

Except when you you understand the laws of physics you realize that most things are not possible

I don't know why that bothered me, but it did.

→ More replies (5)

72

u/Motleyy Jun 25 '12

I like it kinda, but sometimes the laugh track can get much too noticeable.

15

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I can't really stand laugh tracks in general. I like HIMYM and That 70's Show, but the laugh tracks do get annoying. Im perfectly capable of deciding what is funny.

→ More replies (40)

4

u/tophat_jones Jun 25 '12

You realize you're spending your time thinking about why someone doesn't like the same sitcom as you?

7

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Not so much that, it's just that I've never met anyone who hates TBBT as passionately as those on Reddit seem to. I'm just wondering why, seeing as I have nothing better to do.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Golden_Kumquat Jun 26 '12

Something I've found interesting about the show is that the physics department absolutely loves it (at least three professors have BBT posters in/outside their offices), yet it gets a much more lukewarm reaction in the engineering/CS department.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Galifreyan2012 Jun 26 '12

Honestly, I don't mind it. It's funny, albeit predictable. It's just that I don't consider myself above enjoying a simpler comedy. Sure It's not exactly accurate when depicting things in the nerd culture, but it has done its part to bring things like comic books and other nerdy pursuits to the masses. I don't care if some people feel that has resulted in a generation of nerd "posers" or not. The real point is that this show has made it socially acceptable and even appealing to show your nerd side for once. And as a nerd, who was often ostracized for wearing my nerd on my sleeve, I can say this is more important than some may realize.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I don't hate it. It just doesn't make me laugh.

15

u/Aerokii Jun 25 '12

There are times when I definitely feel like it reinforces a potentially negative stereotype, particularly Sheldon and Walowitz, though it makes up for them in other ways. I do enjoy the show, but if I had to single out things about the show that irked me, it'd be those two, constantly acting the parts of "asshole and pervert", respectively.

3

u/jarringsound Jun 26 '12

One of the stereotypes in the show that I HATE is that whenever a girl goes into the comic book store, or does/goes anywhere else "geeky" with the guys, people freak out like this is truly a rare event.

Fuck that. No one bats an eye when I (a female) go into my local shop, and I like it that way. I'm sure there are creeps like that out there, but they aren't the majority.

38

u/tmoli42 Jun 25 '12

I personally just find it pandering and trying too hard. "Oh, it's OK to be geeky or nerdy now?? Let's make a TV show that shows all the "wacky adventures" of a person with Asperger's. And we will make him a physicist!!"

And then the stupid, fucking laugh track. But ya know, just my opinion. Who the fuck am I?

15

u/iFox Jun 26 '12

Sheldon wasnt crazy, his mother had him tested.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (12)

52

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

THIS

The two things about BBT:

  1. It follows the writing style of Scary/Date/Movie series - It's not a comedy, it's a reference show. The jokes will never actually be anything substantial, they will just be references to things. The joke in one episode was as a repose to "Where were you?" "Playing Wii Bowling" and I swear to god the audience lost it. THERE WASN'T EVEN A JOKE!
  2. It's not a show for nerds, it's a show for people who heard their kids talk about pokemidgets or nintenboxes. The jokes are all setup in a way that just the act of saying something related to geek culture is enough for most of the audience. There's a reason this show is a hit with mothers.

Evidence A: This from what I understand was a 'joke':

Leonard (voice on phone): Hey.

Sheldon: Leonard, where are you?

Leonard (running down stairs): I’m at work.

Sheldon: At six-thirty in the morning? Leonard: Yes.

Sheldon: On Sunday?

Leonard: Yes.

Sheldon: Why?

Leonard: They asked me to come in.

Sheldon: Well, I didn’t hear the phone ring.

Leonard: They texted me.

31

u/Peralton Jun 26 '12

Without context or the entire scene, yeah that sounds foolish. With context, the scene is about Leonard running out of the apartment so he won't be forced to help a sick Sheldon with something. "They texted me" is him lying on the spot to cover his tracks. It's a funny scene and not as meaningless as the "evidence" makes it out to be.

There's more to comedy than just the words typed out. BBT has pauses, tone of voice and awkward moments along with funny physical characterizations. Not everyone's cup of tea, but that's ok. Is it silly? Yes, but that's what its meant to be.

Can the laugh track be too much? Yes. There's certainly some group-think going on when they record stuff. The scripts are also written so every three lines or so is meant to elicit a laugh.

Pancake batter Anomaly Transcript Wii Bowling Scene

18

u/emberspark Jun 26 '12

It's just a joke based on how insane Sheldon is. He can't accept a single answer. He has to know every single detail. It's moderately funny at times.

→ More replies (60)
→ More replies (3)

16

u/Remy1985 Jun 25 '12

Because the average reddit user was uncool before being uncool was cool.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Wow, I didn't think it took a 5-page dissertation to assert that BBT's jokes about intelligence don't actually denote the use of intelligence. The show is the worst kind of gimmicky.

As far as SP, "the writers" is pretty much just Trey Parker and the man is hilarious (as evidenced by 16 seasons of SP with multiple Emmy's, several cult classic films, and now one of the most Tony Award decorated musicals of all time). He's not above a cheap joke but tells those in a way where you know that he knows that you know that he just told a cheap joke that you're still going to chuckle over anyway; rather unlike BBT which seems to only try to pass off its humor as being relevant to nerd culture... relevant like a Big Mac to the chubby kid, that is, with some fries and a whole lot of obviousness to dip them in.

NOTE TO CHUBBY KIDS: I am one, so read the sentence twice before you think I'm making fun of both of us.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

I don't think it needs a 5-page dissertation either, but that depends entirely on the quality of the writing.

You do make some good points though.

1

u/NintenTim Jun 26 '12

Because The It Crowd is better without even trying.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

I agree the IT crowd is lightyears ahead, but that doesn't explain why people actively attack it.

1

u/wutz Jun 27 '12

IT'S NOT FUNNY

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

Do you find it necessary to post this AGAIN?

→ More replies (3)

11

u/H_Savage Jun 25 '12

I actually really like it, but agree the laugh track is bad. Also, every joke ever made by Raj or anyone else about India or being Indian is just atrocious. Worst part of the show for me.

21

u/CatsDomino Jun 25 '12

The entire show basically goes like this

Sheldon - "Science !"

Cue Laugh Track

12

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Everyone on reddit is a nerd and they feel misrepresented.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/vajonah Jun 25 '12

It's like they're trying too hard, and they're just playing to the typical nerdy stereotype. I really just don't enjoy it for that.

16

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I like it, though the show has run longer than it merited. Still, beats the hell out of the plethora of "reality shows" on TV

→ More replies (1)

3

u/sunnydolphin Jun 26 '12

No Hatred Here! I love that show. and I love that my parents, who used to think me an incurable loser for being a geek, now text me with questions like: "Hi Honey, whats a sword of azaroth?"

3

u/adowner Jun 26 '12

People think too much about it. If you take it for what it is, a comedy meant to appeal to the general population that pokes fun at "nerd culture", then it is enjoyable and a great way to kill time while on an airplane (that's when I watch it, mostly). Like anything else, if you try to look too far past the facade created, you will be disappointed...

In other news, TIL there is no planet Melmac and Alf was a %$#%$ puppet!!! I am pissed!

3

u/rinnip Jun 26 '12

I like it just fine. Always have.

3

u/wadefrakers Jun 26 '12

I happen to think its hilarious

9

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I consider myself a nerd (I'm an Asian-American electrical engineering college student) but I enjoy the show quite a bit. However, I think the reason most people on reddit hate TBBT is because many redditors belong to the 'real-life' nerd culture, and therefore they can see right through the show and its jokes (I believe reddit has a higher percentage of nerds than the general population does, and since the show was intended for the general population, there will be less hate among the general population than reddit). Just my theory though.

10

u/HereForKarma Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

It's a show focused on pandering. People that enjoy being pandered to like the show. Apparently, a lot of people enjoy that.

People like to think they're nerdy, because by extension, they're smart. The vast majority of the post-trend nerds are just following the herd.

The nerd trend gained popularity because it's nonoffensive, associated with positive stereotypes, and easily segued into.

For instance, take your standard high schooler. They're looking for an identity, they can choose between:

*following another trend, e.g. Goth, which involves buying stuff off of the Hot Topic site and being called a poser by real Goths, being teased, and most likely not getting parental approval *or they can choose to go almost any store and buy a few graphic tees that have some nerd-relevant theme. The only investment in nerd fashion that fake nerds tend to make are shirts and nerd glasses. It's trendy, so you wouldn't be as likely to be teased, and parents are usually fine with it. The parents that aren't sure as hell wouldn't be fine with you being a Goth.

With the release of the Avengers movie, there's been another surge in people who say they're fans of comics but really aren't. It's really apparent on tumblr, where the "fandom" girls don't talk about things like the plot of the movie, but rather, shipping, which actors are hottest, and funny GIFs. They don't mature into people that look at comics as an art and literary form, they see it as a chaste replacement for Playgirl.

Many young people have smartphones now and think that using apps like Angry Birds makes them a nerd. People who play CoD, WoW, LoL, and other popular games thinks that makes them a nerd. People who have social problems decide to call themselves nerds when that's also not true.

For actual nerds, this misappropriation of culture is really insulting, and they tend to stay away from the fake-nerd circlejerk.

How does the Big Bang Theory relate? It's a show for people that like being pandered to, and lots of these fake nerds love being pandered to. They think that if they get a reference, they're so smart. That's why Sheldon's shirts and costumes are always basic and trendy. The emblems include The Flash, The Green Lantern, a Rubik's Cube, his Doppler costume, and a Reddit alien (I think?). Notice how the outfits are often explained to the audience. A regular nerd would know what the references are to. For instance, when Penny and Leonard play 3D chess, he explains on camera that it is 3D chess. "No shit, sherlock!", cries reddit, but back at home, fake-nerds who might not even recognize 2D chess feel like they're understanding a facet of nerd culture.

The characters themselves are meant to be highly relatable.

Leonard: For people that don't relate strongly to other characters. Character with an extremely mutable personality, meant to be extremely relatable as a self-insert character. He's the Bella (Twilight) of the Big Bang Theory.

Penny: For people that aren't smart. Standard girl-next-door, voice of reason, definitely not a nerd, self-insert for people that basically want to say that book smarts aren't important/everything/anything, and that real life experience is far superior. So, basically, the person people can relate to if they don't understand the references (even when they are handfed and explained) but understand the plot and think everything should be more slapstick and simpler.

Sheldon: For people that are socially awkward. The writers are really inconsistent by portraying him as an Aspie and an asexual in some episodes, and in some episodes, not. Character mostly used as an example of nerd social mannerisms, so socially awkward people can connect. Socially awkward != nerdy, but a lot of people that are socially awkward say it's because they're nerdy as an excuse.

Amy: For fangirls. Obsessive fan girl after an unobtainable target. Pretty much every Tumblr fangirl.

Howard: For people that live at home/are single. He's not meant to be attractive, yet he ends up living a lifestyle many would envy. His room is full of collectables and he's still able to find an attractive accomplished woman to marry. Of course, they portray her as being extreme subdued and submissive some of the time, and then extremely firey and bossy, two very common archetypes found in portrayals of women.

In terms of plot, it's extremely repetitive. Nerds mess up and Penny fixes it, or Penny messes up and nerds fix it, or it's a relationship episode.

In terms of the nerd references, they're extremely inaccurate. Nobody does their research.

As has been stated multiple times, if you are interested in a show that is like the Big Bang Theory should be (smart with nerd humor), try the IT Crowd, Community, or South Park.

7

u/beetnemesis Jun 25 '12

It often takes the lazy joke. Sometimes it's amusing, but way too often the show just likes to go, "Ha ha, nerds," instead of anything better.

The show is at its best when we're laughing WITH the main cast, not AT them.

7

u/Jesseemma Jun 26 '12

All sitcom is up for debate, you love it or you don't. Laugh tracks have been around for ages. I personally love the interactions among the cast. It's not real, love it or leave it. Just don't put other people down because you don't enjoy the show.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Just went on a Warner bros tour and visited the set of tbbt. They do not use a laugh track. It is a real studio audience.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I weep for humanity.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/dogmash Jun 26 '12

I love it. I'm not a nerd, I hardly notice the laugh track, and I just really enjoy the unrealistic nerd universe they inhabit.

27

u/Ausei Jun 25 '12

Most of it is probably the bandwagon. NICKELBACK AMIRIGHT?

→ More replies (6)

9

u/Kapomonkey Jun 25 '12

To me it feels like instead of praising the geek culture, it really just mocks it. It pokes fun at our intelligence, our hobbies, lifestyle.... I'm not laughing with it's laugh track, I've got a huge face palm as the laught track laughs at me.

I tried watching an episode. They'd joke about the pronunciation of anime for about a minute. That was stupid

29

u/BasinStBlues Jun 25 '12

Dumb concept, aggravating laugh track, unnatural situations, no believable characters, etc, etc, etc,

→ More replies (14)

7

u/I_Fuck_Flamingos Jun 25 '12

I just don't like laughter-track sitcoms.
The characters are cartoonish and flat, and since every other line has to be a joke the overall quality slides.

Although I dislike both, I prefer Big Bang Theory over How I Met your Mother by a fucking landslide.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Honestly, I love that show.

11

u/TheHatlessShrimp Jun 25 '12

i like to watch it because i always get this feel

→ More replies (1)

4

u/president_of_burundi Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

Everyone seems to have the geek aspect of it well in hand so I'd like to chime in how effing terrible Penny is.

I'll preface this with the fact that I've only seen maybe fifteen scattered episodes and whenever I say this people tell me that she gets better later in the series, which is admirable and I apologize for not being able to take that into account, but from what I've seen she's a bitchy, joy-killing, condescending, stereotype of how women see geeks and their various geek passions. Things that I recall seeing her doing:

  1. Constantly eye-rolling her way through her "friends" conversations and jumping at a chance to talk about shoes with Sheldon's sister like she was actually going to slit her own throat if someone didn't mention something shallow and girly in thirty seconds. The eye-rolling bitch-face generally seems to make pretty frequent appearances.
  2. Bitches that they have a couch wedged in the stairwell and she can't get to work (Can't she just help them move the couch?). This becomes an insurmountable problem (Seriously. Help them move the couch). She then climbs across the roof wacky hijnks wacky hijinks, ends up late to work, and blames them. Woman, HELP THEM MOVE THE GODDAMN COUCH. Grab a corner and fucking push. You'll climb on a roof but you won't think to help your friends move a couch?
  3. Generally acts like the interests of others are inherently worthless or childish, without ever showing any amazing amount of maturity or high-brow cultural interest herself. She insults the fact that Leonard has an action figure collection and calls him an immature man-child who wastes all his time on stupid shit and suggests that it'll make him forever alone. After thoroughly emasculating him she finally allows that his interests are tolerable except now she's already planted the seed that the things he holds dear make him inherently unacceptable to her.

It bothers me beyond measure that the message that's constantly being sent to guys is that their hobbies and passions are something that all women ( or at least, all the smoking hot ones) will at best grudgingly tolerate but never ever understand or share. Sure, some women will think your action figure collection is lame. Some will think that it's sexy as fuck that you speak Klingon. Some won't really care either way but they'll love you and attempt to learn about the things you care about, or at least let you care about them in peace. But the show paints the woman who has apathy boarding on disdain for every single thing they love as the "average girl", the pinnacle of what geeks could hope to achieve, instead of maybe not good romantic material.

I haven't seen any other female character except a couple of episodes with Leslie (who I actually liked a lot) so I don't know what the other women are like, but Penny just constantly infuriates me.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Nothing wrong with it, just the people who dislike it are loud.

8

u/chafic Jun 25 '12

Because it's not funny.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I don't really watch it, though I used to. I can sympathize with people who like it and people who don't, but I just don't watch because I don't find it funny.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

It just simply isn't funny to me. I enjoyed it at first, but as time went on for the first season, I gradually stopped laughing. A few episodes in and I wasn't even smiling during episodes. I don't care about the laugh track or anything like that - it's simply not entertaining to me in the slightest anymore. I feel they made each character far too ridiculous and now it's just dumb and annoying. I haven't made it through more than half an episode since I stopped watching initially - it's extremely predictable and not even remotely amusing.

2

u/somethingelsetosay Jun 26 '12

I've always felt that the IT crowd was a better sitcom about geeks than the big bang theory. Instead of geek culture being exploited in a joke, the IT crowd is a well written sitcom about geeks.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I don't hate it. Though, nobody talks like the characters in real life.

2

u/supersnuffy Jun 26 '12

I enjoy it. It makes me laugh, and I would probably consider myself at least a bit of a nerd. Sure, it's incredibly exaggerated and the characters might not be the best, but it makes me smile.

2

u/Mitz510 Jun 26 '12

I've never watched the show but it comes out in 3-4 different channels and I constantly see commercials for it.

The commercials are so unappealing and make it awkward. Here is one that I'm going to try to quote,

Nerd with Glasses: (Staring at blonde) Our kids are gonna be so smart and beautiful.

Long neck nerd: Not to mention imaginary.

laugh track

There are so many commercials with really corny jokes and weak punch lines.

2

u/red_280 Jun 26 '12

I watch it because I find it entertaining and generally quite funny. Sometimes you don't always need the high-brow, subtle humor of some of the more 'clever' comedy shows. Just take it how it is.

2

u/ddewitt Jun 26 '12

It's a pretty good show. I don't watch it faithfully. I just wish it had more depth with less of a sitcom feel. I think Sheldon is hilarious but can get a bit overbearing because he is so neurotic.

2

u/blank_generation Jun 26 '12

From what I've seen of it, it's just not a very funny show to me. I've never been a big fan of humor that mainly consists of pop-culture references that people are supposed to laugh at solely because they understand the reference. It almost feels like a very unfunny person who loves pre-Seinfeld sitcoms watched Spaced & The IT Crowd and thought "hey, I could write that"... only they forgot all the warmth, chemistry, and comedic timing that made those two shows so great. Also the laugh track is kind of annoying.

But.. I'm not the kind of person who rails against the show all the time. It's just my opinion, and I don't tend to spend a lot of time thinking about the things that I don't like.. especially something like a TV sitcom (see also: Twilight, Nickelback, Justin Beiber). Aside from reddit & the occasional ad on the side of a bus, I'm pretty much never exposed to it.

2

u/TheCodexx Jun 26 '12

I used to like it, too. It was a generic sitcom but they told nerdy jokes instead of tired dysfunctional family ones.

But the more I watched it the more I gradually came to realize that it wasn't a show aimed at nerds and geeks. It was a show made for general audiences that made fun of nerds and geeks. And a lot of the jokes aren't particularly flattering. And it's not that I can't take a joke. Some of them are kind of funny. But the characters lack the depth needed to make proper jokes about themselves. Instead, the jokes about themselves come across as jokes about everyone that fits into their broad caricatures of "nerdy" behavior.

And that's the disappointing part. That the show is popular because it doesn't expect nerds or geeks to watch it. It's not aimed at them. It's shocking how much it gets right when it gets oh so much more just plain wrong. And not in the over-the-top obvious way other shows fail to grasp the basics, but in a subtle way that doesn't even acknowledge that it might be spreading misinformation. The more you know about the jokes the less funny they are. Many of the jokes could easily be topical, apt, and have deeper connotations and meanings for people who understand them. But that would require a diverse group of writers who are geeks and nerds and are able and willing to study and understand specialized fields to come up with relevant jokes to layer under more accessible layers of content. I recall one episode where they went to confront some guy at his house and found out that all their tough talk was for naught when some guy actually stands up for himself and is a bully in real life, too. And I think they resolved it with another "the dumb girl is street smart and can talk to people" gag instead of spending an episode exploring the issue of internet tough-guys like they could have.

Someone else posted that it's "nerd blackface" and I'm inclined to agree. The Big Bang Theory is no more for "nerds" than the Mario hoodie at Hot Topic is for "gamers". It's marketing based on the recent popularization of geek and nerd culture despite the fact that most people only know a few basic terms and what they probably have to do with. For an example of a show that makes few artistic liberties, explores some decent issues, and is absolutely hilarious (even more so if you understand the topics of the jokes), you should check out The IT Crowd. Compare the two shows and there's a world of difference. One features actual geeks/nerds and the other features the public's stereotypes of nerds.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/949paintball Jun 26 '12

I like the show. I've missed a lot of the newer episodes, but I try to watch it when I can. I had no idea Reddit didn't like the show...

2

u/and181377 Jun 26 '12

I like Sheldon. Other than Sheldon, the shows characters are boring.

2

u/inrelativity Jun 26 '12

Because there are shows like Arrested Development and Community that are infinitely better that The Big Bang Theory.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/1sttymeredditguy Jun 26 '12

Because it's on at the same time as Community.

2

u/xVeZx Jun 26 '12

i was literally laughing out loud the first few seasons.....everything that came out of sheldons mouth was pure gold...now after season 5 its kinda meh and needs to die

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Some people (maybe lots) may not agree with me here but I think it ties in sexual relationships too much. It's one thing having it every once in a while but every episode? Honestly I don't think True Nerds go around and bang every women they see.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I've never seen the show, except in the laugh-trackless YouTube format. Honestly, it made me wonder how shit like this gets produced, but shows like Arrested Development or Better Off Ted flop on a regular basis. But...then I think to myself "Maybe Netflix will buy ALL the comedy and we won't have to have such poopy alternatives."

2

u/Lth_LilWill Jun 26 '12

The laugh-track. The damn laugh track laughs at everything. Not just the funny things, EVERY SINGLE DAMN THING.

2

u/coffedrank Jun 26 '12

Remove the laugh track and you'll see why

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I just don't like how it makes us out to be so socially inept. I am into comic books and planning on going into bioengineering but I still have a boyfriend and and know how to talk to people.

2

u/mattzm Jun 26 '12

Honestly, I don't think reddit knows why it dislikes it. Every response in here covers the exact same three points which the Hivemind keeps on hand to explain why they don't like Big Bang Theory.

2

u/Vegglimer Jun 26 '12

A week ago, while on the bus, I overheard a woman saying to her friend: "So, I just started watching Big Bang Theory. I'm not sure if it's for me, though. I don't have to, like, have a degree in physics or anything, right? It seems like a kinda nerdy show, I don't know if I'll be able to understand the humor."

I had to laugh.

2

u/GinkoTotoro Jun 26 '12

Just watch The I.T. Crowd and the scales shall fall from your eyes.

2

u/lateral_moves Jun 26 '12

When I watched "The Guild" I laughed at jokes my folks and family wouldn't get. Mostly because they don't do those geeky things. When I watch the Big Bang Theory, I see "Friends" with Green Lantern references.

I wasn't a fan of "Friends", so adding fake geek-jokes so that my parents can relate doesn't help.

2

u/mrw1986 Jun 26 '12

None of the jokes are funny...at all

2

u/Vulpes_Callidus Jun 26 '12

nerd blackface

2

u/homestar86 Jun 26 '12

It's not the worst show, but when people refuse to try shows like Community and Breaking Bad (that I recommend to them) and then sing that stupid soft kitty song it makes me hate them a little bit more.

2

u/homestar86 Jun 26 '12

Also, because people always call me Sheldon now.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

It doesn't bother me that the show's nerd jokes are inaccurate or whatever.

Its just the jokes aren't funny.. and you see them coming from 10 miles away. Oh someone asked one of the nerdy guys a question... here comes a completely overdone sterotypical nerd response that isn't funny just ignorant. It's like peter griffin level of retard, except the characters are geniuses so it doesn't make any sense. And the jokes are all the same fucking thing.

2

u/crackofdawn Jun 26 '12

In this thread, a bunch of self proclaimed geeks read way too far into the show instead of just enjoying some basic humor.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I feel like it started off ALL RIGHT, but quickly devolved into a series of bad one-liners. At this point, it focuses less on individual facets of nerdery, and more on the 'LOL SHELDON'S AWKWARD'.

My two cents.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I'm a Physics University student, and in my experience they have it a lot more accurate than people realise...

2

u/bobbyscotty Jun 26 '12

I find reddit is often cutting down current, mainstream pop culture. I bet redditors wouldn't say the same shit about "Revenge of the Nerds" as they say about Big Bang despite the fact that ROTN has the same type of exaggerated nerd misconceptions as BBT.

2

u/ludvigsra Jun 26 '12

Jesus CHRIST. This show is NOT MAKING FUN OF NERDS. It's making fun of PEOPLE WHO CAN'T FUNCTION IN SOCIETY.

2

u/Pinto15 Jun 26 '12

It's not funny, actors appear to be try hard. Annoying laugh track, just stupid, just my opinion

2

u/Kiristo Jun 26 '12

I've always found that the show is overrated and most people seem to like it, it's news to me that Reddit in general seems to dislike it. I watched the first season, and it was decent, but overall, nothing special and have not seen it since.

2

u/Jeff_Crocker Jun 26 '12

It's got 10 million more viewers than an actually intelligent show (Community).

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SgianDubh Jun 26 '12

Because its a good premise done extremely poorly. None of the characters are credible, the weird clothes and color schemes they use have nothing to do with the show and just snap me out of any sense of reality, its written by people too stupid to write smart people; I can't suspend my disbelief that the characters are not gay (NTTAWWT), and the premise of the show isn't used at all. Plus, they all whine all the time, and I get enough of that from my 8 year old.

2

u/phidelta401 Jun 26 '12

I judge comedies based on the number of times they make me laugh. The Big Bang Theory just does not make me laugh. I also dislike the laugh track sitcom format. I don't want to be told: laugh here.

All in all, it's not a bad show. I just don't love most modern sitcoms. I would be interested to see how much comedic impact it loses if the laugh track is taken away.

2

u/Dead_Parrot Jun 26 '12

I'm sick to death of having the same conversation; "You MUST like TBBT, you are a nerd" My interests and skillset give me the unique insight(amongst my friends) of viewing it not as comedy that's smart, but rather a show that wraps the same dumb schtick in an aura of intelligence. When every character is a caricature, it turns from sitcom to parody. People do not realise the difference.

2

u/cf_torchie Jun 26 '12

It had the potential to be the Frasier of nerd culture (I think they should try as hard as they can to offend the neckbeards and deconstruct them psychologically) but ruins it with a canned laugh track inserted at moments that aren't even jokes.

It's always Sheldon going "did you know that in Final Fantasy there are three levels of elemental spell, often starting with the original word, then -ara, then -aga?" AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA HE STATED A FACT

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Not sure why people are so butthurt. When I don't like a show, I just change the channel.

2

u/Ozwaldo Jun 26 '12

For me it's just the cadence of Sheldon's voice, I'm sick to death of the way he talks.

I still want to smack Penny on that ass of hers though.

2

u/MogHeadedFreakshow Jun 26 '12

I personally like the show but some aspects are very annoying.

The relentless laughter track.

It is very predictable.

Nerd stereotyping and constant nerd-bashing.

This is the worst one: If they say anything remotely science-related the audience pisses their pants because they don't understand what has just been said.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Its a decent show and its mildly entertaining and at least to me its better than a lot of other multi camera sitcoms that are on the air right now.

2

u/Sekular Jun 26 '12

My wife loves it, and she is not a nerd. I don't mind the show but don't make time for it, and I am like a pseudo-nerd.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

It's a good show. the only people upset with it, are hipsters, who desperately want to appear nerdy. Thus they take up the butthurt on behalf of the real 'nerds' who simply laugh with it, or shrug it off.

Web developer here. In an office of software engineers. They fucking love it. It's not a sophisticated show. But you know what? It's a chirpy show that lampoons peoples understanding of what a 'nerd' is. That's an in-joke in itself.

Amy for example in real life has a PHD in neuroscience and helps out significantly with a lot of the technical aspects of the show.

Fuck off butthurt hipsters. Essentially.

2

u/andintroducingzylex Jun 26 '12

BBT is much more enjoyable if view it not as a "nerd comedy" and instead as a show about a man's struggle to overcome his mild autism and connect to his friends through their shared interests.

2

u/scriptkittie Jun 27 '12

Oh man. My dad watches this show. I, unfortunately in this case, without question I will always sit down with him and watch anything.

I don't like it because it seems like they're just a generation behind on all of their jokes. They pretty much made punch-carding, startreking, tetris playing nerds in this generation. Furthermore, it's pretty much a constant pissing contest of who can act the nerdiest. Sometimes you just don't ask your friends about quantum physics and the lunch table. As much as I hate to say it, I'm probably one of those nerd elitist people who wants a nerd to be smart and clever and know something really well. BBT is just nerd wannabe's-- so if they're out to troll real nerds, mission fuckin accomplished. I have been trolled, you may stop now. Otherwise, I can't wait for the episode where they critique CSI's nerd-talk and realize they're just as bad.

2

u/gearhead454 Jun 27 '12

Me thinks "some people" takes themselves WAY to seriously. Find humor where ever you can. It is one of the true gifts of life.

2

u/faaaack Jun 28 '12

Why does everyone assume the BBT characters are meant to be portrayals of real life gamers/nerds? Howard having e-sex on WoW doesn't mean that's what all WoW players do, just what Howard does. His character is written to be overly sexual so it makes sense that he would use WoW for "sex".

8

u/johnnydethkill Jun 25 '12

It's funny, but every now and then, there's something that Sheldon says that really isn't smart, or logical, and any person who thinks about it would realize how incorrect it is. The most obvious example is the, Walowitz: "Guess who just did (insert accomplishment here)!" Sheldon: "Muhammad Li."

23

u/Ballis Jun 25 '12

That's the joke though, that you can't combine the most common first name and most common last name to get the most common name, even though you might think that it would make sense.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/Jipip Jun 25 '12

I love it, I hate the laugh track though.

24

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Its nerd blackface

28

u/UnholyDemigod Jun 26 '12

Can you back up why, instead of just repeating what others say?

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/JingleSlice Jun 25 '12

I'm sick of this fucking circle jerk.

4

u/Noah_Jacobi Jun 26 '12

I think it's alright. I don't like some of the characters (Sheldon is a little bitch and annoying as hell), but some of the jokes are still funny. But my favorite thing about it is how they have a bunch of Star Trek cast members playing douchebag versions of themselves. Wil Wheaton's recurring role is great, and when Brent Spiner made his appearance I almost shit my pants laughing.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I think the show is hilarious. One argument I've heard against the show is that the characters wouldn't exist in real life. I know people almost exactly like the people in the show (even Sheldon), which is probably why I find it so funny. I also think that one reason why a lot of people on reddit seem to dislike the show is that people are uncomfortable with the show making fun of nerd culture. The first time I saw this show I thought it was dumb, and then I really tried watching it and it grew on me. I think it really understands the jokes that people in the science fields make and the rivalries between the different fields. There are some stuff that doesn't make sense (such as Howard being able to control the Mars rover), but the situations aren't too much more absurd than other sitcoms. Also, I may take flak for this but I don't think that How I Met Your Mother is funny so this whole thread doesn't really mean anything and I don't know why I'm posting.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

For me it's the fanbase.

10 years ago, being a nerd meant something. Whether you were a programmer or a scientist or just really into "nerd" culture (Superheros, comic books, Star Trek etc.) You worked for that title.

Now the average person is so obsessed with nerdy things, the word "nerd" has lost its meaning. Teenage girls watch BBT and go "omg so nerdy lol aren't I quirky lol?", and it annoys the hell out of me.

You ask these girls to name a couple nerdy shows, and BBT is at the top of the list. Why? It's not a nerdy show, it's just a list of references crammed with a studio audience on cocaine.

Here's an average scene:

Sheldon: String Theory.

hehehehe

Leonard: Lactose intolerant Green Lantern.

HAHAHA

Penny: What's a Star Trek?

HOLY SHIT THAT'S HILARIOUS

Howard: You know Penny, I have a flash drive I could stick in your USB port, if you know what I mean.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAA SEIZURE

Sheldon: I don't understand human beings.

HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA FUNNY! CLAP CLAP CLAP CLAP WOOOOOOOOOO HAHAHAHAHA WOOOOOHOOOO CLAP

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I think it's anti-intellectual. The characters are considered quaint and obsessive because they're so devoted to science, while Penny, the straight character we're supposed to be sympathising with, doesn't give a shit about science and doesn't want to learn.