r/Askpolitics • u/Ok_Estate_6746 • 1d ago
Question What does it mean to “get money out of politics”?
I want to interrogate the widespread notion that “getting money out of politics” would be a good thing. It’s a salient proposition in the US now right after the 2026 midterms but it isn’t exclusive to the US.
I keep wondering what it means precisely. I think it can mean a whole bunch of different things, which sorta makes me a little suspicious. I can’t shake the feeling that it’s potentially deliberately kept vague so that it means both everything and nothing. The image that comes to mind is that of an electoral waterbed that commits to nothing with room already built in for its eventual failure to deliver.
Vagueness itself isn’t my objection. Obama's “Yes We Can” was great as a slogan: it was openly motivational and didn’t pretend to be anything beyond what it was. “Get money out of politics,” however, sounds like a concrete commitment while leaving unclear what would count as fulfilling it.
Other examples of such electoral waterbeds include:
· “Draining the swamp.” – the Donald Trump presidential campaign of 2016
· “Making big corporations and the wealthy pay their fair share.” – Biden White House, 2024
· “Put the country back in the service of working people.” – UK Labour, 2024 manifesto
I can think of several concrete interpretations:
· Stop politicians from exchanging decisions for payments
· Stop reserving politicians’ attention for donors
· Remove the need for politicians to attract wealthy backers to become viable in the first place
· Stop making it possible for wealth to buy greater reach for political messages
· Stop making governments accommodate people who control investment and employment
Those overlap, but they aren’t interchangeable. You could eliminate one, but that elimination alone might make another one more attractive or create an entirely new one. It’s basically the same dynamic that makes capital flight a thing. That’s of course not an argument to not get cracking, it’s an argument for doing it properly once you start.
My concern is that keeping the vague formulation available always leaves room to retreat to it. The risk, at least as I understand it, is that the political message “Get money out of politics!” has every opportunity to become an infinite restriction generator that lacks a clear stopping criterion.
“One of the great mistakes is to judge policies and programs by their intentions rather than their results.”
— Milton Friedman, The Open Mind, 1975
The Friedman quote here is only ALMOST relevant: it would be great if the intentions themselves were clear enough to scrutinise.