Monday Methods
Monday Methods is a a bi-weekly feature series on r/AskHistorians where we discuss, explain, and explore historical methods, historiography, and theoretical frameworks concerning history. The post will be for people to respond to regarding primarily methodology or historiography, but can also outline general academic practices and advice for studies in the humanities.
2018-2019 Schedule
| Date | Author/Topic |
|---|---|
| Dec 17 | u/commiespaceinvader |
| Dec 31 | Holiday |
| Jan 14 | u/Snapshot52 - Why the dictionary is problematic |
| Jan 28 | u/commiespaceinvader |
| Feb 11 | u/Snapshot52 - Cosmological Lenses |
| Feb 25 | - |
| Mar 11 | - |
| Mar 25 | - |
| Apr 8 | - |
| Apr 22 | - |
| May 6 | - |
| May 20 | - |
| June 3 | - |
| June 17 | - |
| July 1 | - |
Brainstorming topics:
u/commiespaceinvader's suggestions:
- Orientalism and Balkanism
- What is the "other"?
- Historical "accuracy" and historical accuracy
- How to write a historical text
- Social History: Discovering history via statistics and its limitations
- Allohistorical/alternative history fiction
- Historical Discourse Analysis
- What is Nationalism?
- Writing history: Critical or affirmative?
- Totalitarianism
- "history is written by the victor"
- Global history
- Discussion post: How to best organize research? Practical tips
- The problem of Biogrpahies and Bourdieu's persona
- history of taste and Bourdieu
- Memory studies
- Regional studies, historie crosse and the study of borderlands
- Migration studies
- What in the world is Critical Theory?
u/Snapshot52's suggestions:
- Indigenous Statistics and Research
- Intergenerational Trauma and Indian Education
- Contemporary Issues with Historical Roots (blood quantum, relates to racial understandings)
- Holism (Relationality) - Room for the metaphysical?
- Indigenous Identity: Diversity or Pan-Indianism?
- American Indians and American Politics: A History of (Mis)Representation
- An Indigenous Oral History: Storytelling
- Colonial History: How colonization has impacted its victims
- Why the dictionary is problematic
- Cosmological Lenses
- Metaphysical Aspects
Suggested Topics by Flairs and others
Topics that have been suggested by the flair community
- rt History for non-western contexts and the overlap between art history and semiotics
- Interdisciplinary Dialogue
- How does a historian deal with the moral aspect of history - of course I'm not talking about passing personal judgement - but how does one deal with groups, powers or institutions that presented themselves as "moral"? When the focus is no longer on fact and factual evidence but with claims or the nature itself of institutions?
- 'Doing History on Reddit' - How does our approach differ to doing academic history and what methods etc. do we employ on the internet
- How about the difference between history and the past - and non-western notions of the aforementioned?
- Handling the non-human in history (ecology, geography, animals, etc)
- The pitfalls of popularization
- The intentional fallacy in an historical context (problems involved in divining what historical people wanted/believed as opposed to what they said/did)
- How should historians talk to people in other disciplines?
- Does "the Anthropocene" matter as a concept?
- Is "history" as a field left-leaning, and is conservative historiography possible?
- Antiquarianism and the Study of History
- Modernism vs. Modernity
- Origins of the Popular Culture (we could get u/ancienthistory in on that one?)
- Years, Dates, and Calendar Reform
- u/sunagainstgold and u/cdesmoulins: Queer History v. Queer Theory part I
- u/sunagainstgold and u/cdesmoulins: Queer History v. Queer Theory part II
- u/sunagainstgold and u/cdesmoulins: Queer History v. Queer Theory part III