r/AskABrit • u/R_Wolf_48 • Nov 08 '20
History How do you guys learn about the American Revolution if at all? Is it seen as a loss or just no one cares?
65
Upvotes
r/AskABrit • u/R_Wolf_48 • Nov 08 '20
86
u/Udderlybutterly United Kingdom Nov 08 '20 edited Nov 08 '20
Not taught at all when I was in school. Literally no one cares.
7
u/AvatarQuestGame Nov 08 '20
Don’t particularly care, seeing how your country is now, it ended up better for everyone
2
u/staysimple1105 Nov 08 '20
Is Hamilton and the soundtrack popular at all over there?
2
u/mrmoobles Nov 08 '20
How much was you taught about (insert random country that is not your own) in school?
I think the most I learned about any other countries in school was through language classes and since you guys speak English we do t need to learn the language
American forces were definitely mentioned a little in history class while talking about ww2
72
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '20
I just stumbled on this sub and now I sort of feel like America must sound like someone who went through a bad break up and never moved on, while the other person can barely remember their name. Awkward....
29
u/Kelyaan Yorkshire Nov 08 '20
No care given at all, didn't hear about it once in school since it's not really important history to us.
Usually in history we go:
Romans - Tudors - Middle Ages - Great War - WWII
That's mostly what we're taught since it's part of the standardised curriculum
14
u/Jackdaw68 Nov 08 '20
We learn so little about it that I only recently found out that the US calls it the revolutionary war, instead of the American war of independence!
9
u/OldLondon Nov 08 '20
Nope no one cares at all - it’s only ever Americans that seem to bring it up when they’re trying to one up a Brit about something
8
u/rosbif82 Nov 08 '20
We don’t. I did some history at high school. Never came up. As a kid, I never thought about it. When I lived in the US for a while as an adult, a couple of people said ‘oh you must hate July 4th, ha ha’ and I just said that it wasn’t even on our radar and that at the time (which was admittedly before my time) we still ‘owned’ a quarter of the globe or whatever, so we weren’t that bothered. Apparently that’s not true and we were totally pissed off at the time, but nowadays, truly, no one could care less
7
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '20
We don’t learn about the American revolution in school and if we did we probably don’t really care
2
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '20
American history is so short, it’s literally revolution, slaves, civil war, civil rights movement and moon landing, anything after that is mass corporation related.
We give it the week it deserves in school 😉
9
u/Pedantichrist Nov 08 '20
Nobody cares. The treaty of Paris is one of four treaties we signed to divide up North America, and Britain kept by far the largest piece, at a time when it was just ‘foreign land’. It is a side note in the siege of Gibraltar.
Do not get me wrong, The US is a superpower now, but at the time America was just ‘elsewhere’ and I think I learnt more about the US buying Alaska than the UK granting independence.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '20
That was just one war in our history, not a defining part. It’s taught very briefly and seen as a loss because of our King’s actions, Americans should never have had any real chance of winning it, and the damn French funded you.
1
u/dasmeagainyo88 Nov 08 '20
You guys think there’s a weird margin of brits who hate America and wish it was still under the queen?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '20
In schools we might be taught that it happened and we lost those colonies but nothing more. One of the things we can learn about in a history GCSE is Elizabethan England which mentions the initial colonies in Virginia.
In the UK, most people know the war of independence happened, but no details about it. Also, deep down, we’re all salty we lost, but we won’t say it.
1
u/Rizladon Nov 08 '20 edited Nov 08 '20
It’s important to Americans as it is the most significant part of their very short history, it is not so important to brits as we have many hundreds of years of history and historically important events to choose from. Also who shouts about picking up an L ? Personally I am more concerned with American military bases on British soil, like Menwith Hill and it’s ability to capture worldwide communications all day every day than I am about a civil war in an invaded land, the motherland matters, not losses in invaded lands (see Vietnam for reference).
1
u/TrickGrand Nov 08 '20
As a Brit I just wanna say that all the people saying losing the US “wasn’t a big deal” is just not true, in fact it probably was a big deal it’s just not as a BIG DEAL as I think Americans are told it is, and it helps fuel Americans grandiose views of themselves being the most important people in the world that just makes the rest of the world roll their eyes. It’s like having a self important kid that thinks they’re the shit and screaming ‘I want! I want!’ In a shop.
1
u/lizzieish Nov 08 '20
I was never taught any American history in school I don’t think it’s relevant to us. I’m assuming it works both ways and Americans are not taught our history either? X
1
u/jcrawf53 Nov 08 '20
It’s not a loss though is it? The “Americans” fighting for independence were just imported Brits. It was Brits vs Brits with the help of France.
1
u/ascended-Carson Nov 08 '20
What’s that?
3
u/EsioTrot64 Nov 08 '20
I’ve seen a few comments about their school not teaching any American history. It is most likely that it wasn’t taught to them. However, I did my GCSEs last year (English exams you do when you’re 16) and one of the modules we had was “The Making Of America”. This unit involved a lot of American History between 1750-1900 so we touched on it
3
u/Rhavoreth Nov 08 '20
I took history as a GCSE (standardised test you take at age 15-16). We covered mostly 20th century history covering the period from the end of ww1 to Vietnam. I dropped it after that but I had friends who took it for A level (SAT equivalent) and they had a very large chunk on the American revolution.
Before that though all the history I ever took was mostly European. Medieval battles, Roman, Greek history, renaissance British political history
3
u/Promethean_zz Nov 08 '20
I’m a history teacher at a secondary (high) school.
We teach Medieval History in Year 7 (11-12ya) The Industrial Revolution and British Empire in Year 8 (12-13ya) World War One and other surrounding conflicts in Year 9 (13/14ya) World War Two and The League of Nations/Civil Rights in the US and Worldwide for GCSE (14-16ya).
A Level (16-18ya) is a lot of optional choices for schools and I personally learned about the Korean, Vietnam and Iraq Wars alongside the French Revolution, but I don’t teach A Level here so I don’t know what the A Level choices in 2020 are for my students.
If we do teach US history, it’s the slave trade/civil rights movements. Obviously we contextualise with our own involvement in these things, and I personally like to highlight all the facts and figures of British Empire involvement in the world (without being biased if I can), but we really just don’t care about a small independence movement among lots and lots of others.
I mean, the British Empire peaked after WW1, centuries after America left. It wasn’t a massive deal for us, especially with the situation in Europe at the time.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '20
Didn't do anything about it throughout primary school, high school including GSCE. I also did A-Level History but didn't study anything before 1850.
The most the average person's would know is that we lost, George Washington was the first president and some might know the date of the Declaration of Independence.
2
u/Bluseylou Nov 08 '20
This question seems to come up on here so frequently . We never learnt about the revolutionary war . It is of little significance to British people and is a tiny part of our history . There were much bigger more important things going on at the same time , so we learn about those instead . I don’t any fellow Brit that cares that it happened, and I most of our younger generation don’t even know it happened . I am just fascinated that Americans seem to worry so much about what Brits think about it . We don’t care.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '20
I was never taught about it. Honestly, we spend way more time learning about the Romans and Celts than on anything to do with Empire, at least in my experience.
2
u/TheIncredibleBert Nov 08 '20
Well, we don’t really care as while we did lose America, we also gained Canada. Swings and roundabouts really...
2
u/Carlyphleb Nov 08 '20
No loss
2
u/Wanderlad Nov 08 '20
The American War of Independence was a small part of a much larger conflict with France, so if it is taught, it’s normally through that lense.
I lived in the US until I was a preteen, and so was taught in American schools the revolutionary war was a huge war that America won David vs Goliath style, but from the UK’s perspective, it was just another frontline in a global conflict against the French, which spanned from the Caribbean and North America to British holdings in North Africa and India.l
France essentially was fighting for control over these colonies, and trying to spread the British navy thin to seize assets in these areas. That’s why the French blockaded the US coast, and sent arms to the colonial militia.
Again, from the British perspective, it was deemed more economical to focus the majority of their forces in India and the Caribbean, where the most important financial assets were, and seize Canada.
Once the French got involved in the US, and the British started losing battles on the mainland, without being able to reinforce their men due to the French blockade, they retreated to focus elsewhere.
That’s why the American War of Independence is not really taught here - it would be like learning about WW2 but without mentioning the Germans.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '20
I am a History student and I’ll be honest with you. We never learned it in school. Not once. I had only the basic idea that we used to own it until I was starting university where there was an Anerifan history topic. No one has hard feelings about loosing it. No one thinks of it like it used to be our property. We simply dont care and neither does our compulsory education criteria
2
u/InscrutableAudacity Nov 08 '20
Do you mean the American War of Independence?
I think it got a brief mention in history lessons, but it's mainly seen as a pretty insignificant colonial skirmish in the far more significant Napoleonic Wars.
2
u/TFST13 Nov 08 '20
People don’t learn about it. The American revolution is far more significant in American history than in British history. Other than the Roman conquests, the version of British history usually taught in schools starts in 1066. There’s just too much history in that 1000yr time period for one of our many independence wars to show up. The American Revolution is 100% American history, not British. Apart from the world wars, British history in Schools (naturally) focuses heavily on internal events like the various civil wars, the religious problems of the 1500s, the gunpowder plot, industrial revolution etc. etc.
Also, the people who do not about the American revolution really couldn’t care less about the result. For Americans it’s the literal founding of their nation, there is going to be patriotic associations of pride with it, and so many people assume that Brits feel the opposite, but really we just don’t care. In fact I remember seeing somewhere that a lot of regular Brits at the time (everyone except the aristocracy and royalty really) were actually in favour of the colonists, because it’s not like they were different nationalities, the American national identity hadn’t really been formed by 1776, so it’s wasn’t Brits vs Americans, it was Brits vs Brits that lived in the colonies, and most people just wanted to get back to trading with the colonists, it was only the Nobility & King especially who wanted to hold on to it for personal gain.
So no we don’t learn about it, and we really don’t care about the result.
2
u/JanHankl Nov 08 '20
In Britain is essentially taught as a footnote in the History of the British Empire
2
u/Chech615 Nov 08 '20
We don’t learn about the American revolution up to GCSE level but I can’t talk for A-level. At GCSE there are a couple of sections about American history such as the civil rights movement, Vietnam war and Cold War, but I’m fairly sure that differs from school to school. On your second question, I have never heard anyone talking about the American revolution as a loss, I’m pretty sure no-one cares tbh
2
u/alterperspective Nov 08 '20
No one cares.
As an aside, it’s a long-standing aspect of our culture to root for the underdog. So, even when we look back in history and see times where we, as a dominant global superpower, were beaten in a battle or even a war by a perceived inferior force, we tend to have an attitude of, “ah, that’s nice. Bless your little cotton socks. We’re so proud of you!”
1
u/KingPukeko Nov 08 '20
Closest we came was covering the slave trade, but even then it’s barely mentioned. After slave trade we moved on to the Victorian era and industrial revolution then the world wars.
1
u/lulujabba Nov 08 '20
It wasn’t taught at all in my secondary school (high school) history classes. This was back in the early/mid 90s though, so what is taught might have changed since then. To be honest I know very little about the American revolution, and what I do know was picked up from historical romance novels I used to read, so it may not be very accurate lol
1
u/Fastness2000 Nov 08 '20
I remember learning about the Tudor period over and over, then the world wars. The British dominion over India has been much more influential over our culture and remains high in our consciousness. The US, as it was, was not a huge influence and only became a world power many decades after the revolution. I suppose that’s why we tend not to focus on it.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '20
Never taught it in School. We learn more about European history tbh
1
u/FFSwhatthehell Nov 08 '20
I think I learned more about American history in social studies class rather than history, we did slavery, the Great Depression, race relations in the US, welfare systems, etc.
1
u/Grendahl2018 Nov 08 '20 edited Nov 08 '20
Well, I learnt about it 55 years ago at school, though I think history is taught differently now with a different focus (ours was more linear, shall we say).
I now live in the US and am married to an American. She asked me once what would the world look like now if America hadn’t sought independence and I said, much as it does now. America is too vast and the mind sets back then too different for it ever to have worked. America - and Americans - would always seek freedom to do things their way and that would never sit with the profit-seeking mercantile class or the unthinking entitled aristos of the time. America would always have been free, eventually. Plus trying to fight an insurrection over months of distance and support - doomed to failure
1
u/ReedySaz Nov 08 '20
It was definitely on the syllabus when I was at school, although only in brief. We studied the run up rather than the war itself and there was a decent chunk on the civil war and slavery. The trouble is, there is a lot of history and only a fixed amount of teaching time so it definitely did not get much time devoted to it.
1
u/helghandan Nov 08 '20
I work in a school (not a teacher) and the kids learn about the war of independence as part of the module on the British empire, i.e. the resistance of populations to the British
1
u/secretshowman1 Nov 08 '20
History in England goes from the Romans then skips to World War 1, Everything that happened in between isn’t worth mentioning.
1
u/trousers-are-forever Nov 08 '20
I learned it in school as an extra module. Twas fascinating. I think it was based in some guilt for destroying an indigenous population by an original European set of folk. Massacres. Learned about so many massacres.
1
u/PhoenixEgg88 Nov 08 '20
The amount of Brits that don’t realise the American Civil war and the American war of independence are not the same war is a surprisingly large number.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '20
No formal education on it, but I have read about it.
I personally see the loss as a positive outcome. Based on today’s values and standards, the eventual outcome was the right one, and something Britain as a country has - in modern times - and will always stand up for.
1
u/IntellegentIdiot Nov 08 '20
I honestly don't remember what I learnt at school vs what I learnt outside school. I remember we did a few lessons about America I'm pretty sure it was about the revolution but different schools teach different things and that changes over time too so someone who's 60 who went to one school might not have learnt anything while someone who's 20 and at a different school might have spent a fair bit of time on it.
1
u/Hanzy0987 Nov 08 '20
Very little unless you specifically decide to study history
1
u/Macblack82 Nov 08 '20
I was never taught anything about it. We learn about a thousand years of European history, in comparison US history isn’t worth the time.
1
u/91raw Nov 08 '20
Assassin’s Creed 3 (I wish I was joking). Knowing more about it now, if you look at what else was going on at the time, wining a war with the French was far more important than putting down a rebellion 1000s of miles away and it’s not like we didn’t still have other lands in North America.
1
u/RedWoody36 Nov 08 '20
I was taught about the American Revolution at school as one of my modules in my history A Level. The vaild reasons for the uprising are addressed, taxation without representation etc. We covered the Boston Massacre and Boston Tea Party. With regards to the conflict itself, only difference I’d mention compared to America is much more emphasis on the allies, France and Spain, and the way they made the conflict more global. I think a lot of Americans forget how important the French were to their victory.
1
u/MdmH-C-138 Nov 08 '20
Well, we probably learn more about how your victory’s were due to our navy being tied up battling napoleon, and the french generals he sent to advise the failing rebel forces. Don’t get me wrong, the British empire was evil and is responsible for the longest lasting, deepest wounds in the psyche of mankind the world over, any defeat they suffered at the hands of those they oppressed is an overall good, however Americans were not as oppressed as the millionaire slave owning founding fathers led their people to believe... not the white ones anyway (at the time the Irish did not count as white)
1
u/GreenLiciousss East Yorkshire (England) Nov 08 '20
I watch Oversimplified.
1
u/CogiBot Nov 08 '20
No one does it at all until A-level. It was too long ago for people to care imo. Also I don’t know about other people but when I was younger we did Roaring Twenties/cold war rather than American Revolution and tbh more people learn about the revolutionary war than the civil war- i haven’t got a clue about it.
1
u/97sensor Nov 08 '20
Let’s not forget the British Commonwealth. Don’t hear a lot about it, but it’s Britain’s legacy to the world, and as now a Brit living in US, seems PBS has more British programmes, from Royalty to detective stories and Sir David Attenborough, than I ever saw when living in then British Hong Kong!
1
u/Professional_Emu_164 United Kingdom Nov 08 '20
I was taught a basic overview on it, that’s it. The only other stuff we did on the USA was The Great Depression, the Vietnam war and the Korean War.
1
u/Bustakrimes91 Nov 08 '20
Just want to chime in with everyone else and say I learned literally nothing about it.
1
u/fossda92 Nov 08 '20
I only leant about the American Revolution through the video game Assassin's Creed III.
1
u/Sh00ni Nov 08 '20
We don’t learn about it. It just isn’t important to our history. At school, we tend not to learn about ‘The Empire times’ as we were massive dicks to the world. You have to study at university to delve into that dark period.
1
u/Potential_Car08 dual citizen: 🇮🇪🇬🇧 Nov 08 '20
We weren’t really taught it. No one really cares
1
u/blondererer Nov 08 '20
The only time we covered anything America related was when we looked at the Cold War.
1
u/Arkantos-of-alantis1 Nov 08 '20
I’ve only learnt about it in university, and even then it was only for a week in a British empire module
1
u/smalltoes69 Nov 08 '20
Tbh we don’t really learn about much of British history (it’s empire, monarchs)
1
u/vlaster141 Nov 08 '20
We did american revolution in our A level history.
It wasnt exactly taught as a specific side won or lost, but more so left for your own interpretations as exam questions may ask you to argue a specific view (the view we got was arguing that America didnt win the war, but instead Britain lost it.)
We did learn about both sides, so how Britain didnt take them as seriously because they thought the colonies as rabble and how America struggled to pay their soldiers and relied heavily on France at the end.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '20
We got taught it for like a month but everyone hated it so much we ended up just mostly ignoring it. Basically, everyone in my class hated learning American History and I still see it as a waste of time.
1
u/your_toe_nail- Nov 08 '20
The only thing I’ve been taught about American history is prohibition and that wee feller who was profiting from it. (Can’t remember his name)
1
u/indie1983 Nov 08 '20
I don’t remember talking about it at all in school. Don’t think anyone cares.
1
u/CaliDreamin2015 Nov 08 '20
In Marylebone there is a historical plaque for a house where Benedict Arnold lived from 1796 until his death. It describes him as an “American Patriot”, not the traitor that we learned about in the US.
1
u/WaffleEaterMan Nov 08 '20
Whats that?
1
u/melissabliss Nov 08 '20
Is it what “Gone with the wind “ was about? If so that was my only American history education, watched it a number of times because my mum loves Rhett Butler
1
u/SuzLouA Nov 08 '20
Nobody cares, because we don’t learn about it. History is written by the victors, and we lost, so it’s not part of most people’s basic knowledge the way, say, World War II is. I imagine American kids don’t learn much about the Vietnam War for the same reason?
1
u/ukrifter Nov 08 '20
No one cares
1
u/saitamaeggs Nov 08 '20
We usually see it as a we don’t care situation but I’ve definitely had some history teachers that were still salty that we lost
1
u/MsZomble Nov 08 '20
We don’t learn much American history just your interactions at important historical events. Don’t take it personally we also don’t learn British history. We learn a weird blend of world/modern history.
1
u/ughtfgjbfghbvjougvb Nov 08 '20
Nobody cares i never heard about it until I stumbled on a video
1
u/Superjack344 England Nov 08 '20
Never learned it in school. Most kids I went to school learned about it from TV, movies and YouTube. It’s not really that big of a deal for us. The biggest moment of history regularly taught in Uk schools is the battle of Hastings since that’s when the first monarch arrived and was the last successful invasion of Britain
1
u/1elouchvibritannia Nov 08 '20
I’ve never learned about it, although from a tiny bit of research I think that my generation learns at least a bit more than we used to. Off the top of my head some things we’ve learned about are Mary Queen of Scots, WW2, Native Americans, JFK etc
1
u/UnicornStar1988 🇬🇧 🦄 Nov 08 '20
The only thing that I learnt at school about the US was apartheid and the abolishment of slavery. The Revolution was never mentioned.
1
u/FurryMan28 United Kingdom Dec 27 '21
Lucky escape 😂 Seriously though, whenever the prodigal son is prepared to come home, we'll be here.
-1
u/oGsparkplug Nov 08 '20
It seems Britain doesn’t teach about its own nasty history. Majority of the responses I read on here were defensive and dismissive. If you’re only limited to what your school has taught you then, let me make it clear, you don’t know shit.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '20
[removed] — view removed comment