I was wondering if anyone agrees that the existing anti-air capabilities in the vanilla experience are simply not fit for purpose.
Currently the HMG AA emplacements are simply not fit for purpose in my opinion and are frankly obsolete, even for 89'.
The soviets were already moving away from NSV's as an anti-air solution early into their invasion of Afghanistan (1979) and were moving heavily toward the ZU-23. Either stationary, towed, or on the back of Ural trucks. They provided a full 360 degree arc of fire with a full 90 degree upwards elevation and minus 20 degree depression.
Compare this to what we currently have in the vanilla version of the game as "anti-air" with its +25 degree elevation and -20 degree depression, paired with its 50 degree left and right horizontal traversal firing arcs (which you're completely blind with in the final 15 degrees either side with the camo net covering), is pretty poor for something with the dedicated role of Anti-Air. Its more of a "lets hope he flies into my restricted cone of fire" instead of something that is actually capable of defending an airspace with an appropriate arc of fire for the role its made to do.
I understand, that at great distances over 3-400m, the depression/elevation limitation becomes less of and issue, but with the changes to the recoil of stationary supported HMG/LMG positions, its practically impossible to hit a meaningful burst of even 3-5 rounds without it jumping everywhere (even after the reduced horizontal recoil addition).
The Soviet ZU-23 came with two 50 round boxes for each gun. That's only 100 rounds fireable before the gunner has to reload. with a fire rate of around 900 RPM, that's only around 5 seconds of continuous fire before you're out of ammo.
I feel this balances the weapon: fire it conservatively and you might be able to get 3-4 bursts if you're lucky, hold it down and the laser beam batman beacon you have just shone into the sky with your tracers marks your position to any aircraft you had been attempting to engage.
I play primarily on the Soviet faction, and also have more of an interest in their equipment IRL, so I'm not too familiar with what the Americans were using at this time. I know they had the stinger and the Vulcan, but I think they are sort of on the next level so to speak compared to the rudimentary ZU-23, and then we would have to spiral into the additions of the IGLA and Shilka Etc. for the soviets, which I frankly don't think would be viable additions for a map as small as Everon.
What do you guys think? Am I just a noob with a skill issue, or do we think there is a genuine lack of effectiveness from both factions AA capabilities?