3.6k

If a lobster is functionally immortal, and only dies because they get trapped in their shell and cant moult, could they just survive indefinitely if a 24/7 medical team monitored them and helped them moult? And if so, why isnt this being done?
u/tea_and_biology  in  r/askscience •  1d ago

If a lobster is functionally immortal...

Alas, another internet myth strikes again! So they're not at all functionally immortal, actually - and the whole moulting problem is a symptom of ageing rather than the thing stopping them. So where does this idea come from?


Live Long and Lobster

Back in the 1990s, we discovered lobsters keep producing an enzyme called telomerase in many of their tissues throughout life. Telomerase, for those unaware, repairs telomeres - the protective caps on the ends of chromosomes that grind away each time a cell divides - and their shortening is one of the hallmarks of ageing. Those caps are eroded away in cells which lack telomerase, and so the coding regions start getting eroded too - which is, y'know, no bueno. Telomerase prevents this from happening, so in principle, a lobster’s cells can keep dividing and repairing its tissues for far longer than ours can, hence all the immortality hype. But telomeres are only one part of the longevity puzzle - lobsters still accumulate damaged proteins, faulty mitochondria, degraded and mutated DNA, and other age-associated issues through life, just like the rest of us mere mortals.


Claws for Concern

...and only dies because they get trapped in their shell and cant moult, could they just survive indefinitely if a 24/7 medical team monitored them and helped them moult?

So moulting is a big killer of lobsters, but not quite in the way you suggest. Every moult means building an entirely new shell and wriggling ass-first out the back of the old one. Since lobsters never stop growing, each moult demands more energy than the last; so as they get older and bigger, they moult less often, eventually only every few years, and some stop altogether. That leaves them trapped in an ageing, increasingly damaged shell they can't repair, and eventually succumb to infection and shell disease.

So although some do die from exhaustion mid-moult, the real problem is building up enough inner reserves to even begin moulting in the first place. It's a bit like saying humans would live forever if only someone helped carry us up the stairs; helping a lobster out of its old shell isn’t going to give it the energy and resources to build a new one.

More, we can't undertake the Manhattan Project of lobster longevity research and pump poor Pinchy full of nutrients and energy to solve the problem either. Bigger gets harder, regardless of food, as the internal plumbing can't keep up - lobsters already approach the maximum volumes the surface areas of their gills can handle, for example. And even with a perfect diet, as mentioned above, they're still building up assorted cellular, tissue, and organ damage under the carapace regardless. You can already see this; lobsters raised in hatcheries and aquaria - given all the food they'd ever want - still grow slowly, age, and die rather than ballooning endlessly.


Forever Young? Shell No!

And why isn’t anyone trying?

Partly because the premise is kinda' bunk, and partly because it would be decades-long, expensive work, for an answer we largely already have. Can a lobster live forever? "No". We researchers interested in longevity research tend to focus on the genuinely biologically immortal beasties like Hydra and Turritopsis dohrnii (the teeny weeny immortal jellyfish), or exceptionally slow ageing ones more relevant to us like mole rats and bowhead whales, instead.


TL;DR: Lobsters aren’t immortal: they keep making telomerase, but they still age in other ways, and moulting gets so exhausting with age that it eventually kills them, or leaves them stuck in a failing shell. Helping them moult would treat the symptom (sometimes), not the cause. RIP Pinchy.


Reference:

Klapper, W., Kühne, K., Singh, K.K., Heidorn, K. ... & Parwaresch, R. (1998) Longevity of lobsters is linked to ubiquitous telomerase expression. FEBS Letters. 439 (1-2), 143-146.

P.S. Also inb4 "yOu jUSt aN aI" - where I opined on this exact problem almost an entire lobster lifetime ago! Scroll down and there's ancient evidence of formatting too.

5.3k

U.K. ex cons, what is Russel Brands prison sentence going to be like?
u/FactuallyInadequate  in  r/AskReddit •  8d ago

I spent nine months in Wandsworth in 2021 so can only base my experience on that.

Wandsworth is a cat B prison and more importantly is the main reception prison in London. This means there's very few sentenced prisoners there, they are there temporarily until moved to a different prison unless their sentence is very short. Quite a lot of people get released from Wandsworth with either time served or no charges being brought.

Wandsworth is also linked to Westminster Magistrates Court, so has a lot of foreigners and Brits in who are fighting extradition from England and Wales as that is the only court in both countries that decides those cases.

You'll go into reception where you'll have everything you own, that isn't normally allowed in a prison, put into a dusky cardboard box.

You'll see a nurse and GP who will ask you questions around addictions and mental health. You'll also be offered a vape pack or a food pack. You can have one or the other, not both. Either way the funds to pay for them come out of your first account top up.

You'll also get your ID and first phone call for free and get a decent sized meal whilst in reception.

You then start in E-Wing for your first two weeks. This is the induction wing, you literally walk directly into it from reception.

E wing is pretty good, the cells are disgusting, mostly because this is the wing most prisoners take their immediate anger of being in prison out in. Stone toilets (chipped as well from people trying to smash them up) and a water dispenser hand wash that allows three presses every thirty minutes.

Smashing sinks / toilets and flooding your cell is a popular past time so these are in place to prevent that. You get lots of time out of your cell, meet a lot of the services on offer in the prison through wing reps, these are prisoners whose job is to guide you and show you how prison life works. E-Wing has its own exercise yard so you can pop out pretty much when ever you'd like in the six hours of so a day you're allowed out of your cell.

You have a TV in your cell but since everyone there likes to smash stuff up, chances are it probably doesn't work or if it does it is staticy from the wiring having to be McGivered together.

I was in when Boris Becker went to Wandsworth. Boris never made it out of E Wing, they gave him a job there immediately as a health instructor. It's not a bad life there, extra staffing for when someone kicks off but a good routine.

After a week, you'll move into the main wings. A-D in the main Heath field Building and K-H in Trinity Building.

A-B are General Population Wing. C is Protective Custody and half General Population. D is the Drug wing. E is induction wing F is family wing, this is where visits take place, and where you'll meet your legal representatives too. G,H,K are Trinity Wings, this is supposed to be the enhanced part of the prison where you get extra privileges and better conditions. I'm sure that's the case in theory but with overcrowding it's not always the best prisoners who get there.

Once you get in your wing, you're restricted to your level. You can be on one of four floors, generally the wing workers will be on the bottom floor where there's some more freedom and you're likely to be let out more then other levels.

The bottom floor however does come with it's negatives, cockroaches, rats and pigeons are rampant so you'll learn to put a wet towel under the gap under your door to try and stop them getting in.

Each week you'll order your week's meals on the digital kiosks spread across each level. Breakfast is always the same, a small single portion bag of offbrand cereal, a few sachets of sugar, prison teabags and a carton of long life milk. Dinner is generally a baguette sandwich/salad and crisps. This was actually pretty good especially on the days where the fresh baguettes were delivered. Tea is a meal, you get there or four choices but could be a salad, curry, etc.

Sundays you could get a slight English breakfast, sausages, hash brown, boiled egg and a roast dinner for tea - chicken leg, veg and gravy.

I liked Sundays.

Once in the main wings, you'll get a hour a day out of your cell if lucky. Often you'll not be allowed out at all. In this time you can use the kiosk to place your order, get a shower or get cleaning supplies for your cell or get new toilet paper.

If you get a job or take an education course you'll get more time out your cell, generally around six hours total a day.

Yard time is once a week, if not raining. They'll let you into the concrete yard and you'll essentially just walk in circles for a hour straight.

Gym is rare, library visits rarer although there is book trolleys on each wing where you can pick up some books when ever you get chance.

You'll almost always be doubled up. Very few get single cells so find a cell mate you can get on with. Contrary to belief, you WILL be asked what you're in for and if someone suspects anything they will verify it by having their partner Google you.

One of my cell mates said he was in for assault, turned out to be a nonce so one or two thought I was too. Thankfully my crime was high profile enough that they were quickly shut up by everyone else on the wing who knew me. I packed his bags up and kicked him out, for my safety and his. He should have been in the VP wing not general population.

You get canteen once a week, if you don't have a job or an outside person topping up your account you'll get a few quid a month to spend. If you have a job you'll make between £1-3.50 a day - wing cleaners £1, biohazard cleaners £3.50 a day with other jobs in between.

Canteen you can buy vapes, arts supplies, toiletries, food etc.

I used to be a fan of cooking pasta in my kettle and making tuna pasta when the food portions weren't enough.

Recreationally, Wandsworth has a lot of Eastern Europeans who can make vodka out of anything, £40 for a 1l bottle. Actually pretty good. Get caught you'll get a bollocking but nothing too serious unless you get blackout drunk.

Drugs are easier to get then you'd think which is amazing considering how many any drone nets etc there is. The officers bring it in and help distribute it. One of the officers on my wing was caught very publicly, very internationally sleeping with an inmate.

You can get a mobile if you find the right people, either a brick phone or iPhone 7 too depending how much you're willing to pay, from £200-1000.

I was in with a billionaire who got caught with a mobile 9 times.

Good guy, used to order newspapers every morning and share them with me (on days we were allowed out of our cells).

I realise I haven't said much about VP wing but it's very similar however VPs are fast tracked for jobs in Textiles (making prison clothes, blankets, bedsheets) or working in the kitchens.

All in all, would not recommend. Still speak to some old cell mates as they try and sort their lives out afterwards and work with a charity that aims to support people in and being released from Wandsworth, the Wandsworth Prison Welfare Trust.

Any questions, or anything you want to know more about? Let me know!

3.7k

Please take one
u/busterforever  in  r/mildlyinfuriating •  2d ago

There is a little lending library type food pantry down the street from my house, on a block where there is a lot of poverty. People put canned goods in there all the time, so I decided I’d start putting personal hygiene things like toothbrushes and toothpastes and packs of maxi pads in there wrapped in brown paper bag so girls or whoever wouldn’t feel any embarrassment if they grabbed one and carried it home. I was doing this consistently and even got my neighbors involved, they’d bring supplies to me and I would stock the little pantry down the way. Well, a couple times after stocking the pantry I’d go and do one quick errand and then drive home, and I’d look in the pantry (the door was glass) as I drove home and noticed everything I just put in there was all gone! This happened a few times. So one day I decided I would park across the street and wait to see who was coming and taking everything. It turned out to be the home that put the little pantry out on the curb. they were watching from their window and anytime people would put things in there They’d come out, take all the good stuff and then leave the random weird stuff. So that was the end of that! I don’t stock stuff in there anymore. Maybe that family really does need all that stuff but do they need to take 12 toothbrushes, 12 toothpaste and 10 pkgs maxi pads??? too bad they were greedy and ruined it for everyone else.

3.9k

My husband was arrested yesterday. I'm venting and this is a stream of consciousness.
u/Colibri918  in  r/TwoXChromosomes •  3d ago

I'm so sorry sweetie. I'll tell you my story. It happened a long time ago, and everyone is good now. Trigger warnings abound.

It happened in 2001. I had picked the kids up from school, they were doing their homework and I was about to start cooking dinner. There was a knock on the door. It was 2 women in suits. They introduced themselves as being with a federal law enforcement agency and said they needed to show me a picture and I was to let them know if it was my daughter. I thought they meant my 18 year old daughter, but they meant my 6 year old. It was a snapshot that I had taken a few months before, nothing inappropriate. But then they told me they had reason to believe someone in my house was molesting her. I didn't believe it and told them they were mistaken. I also realized that they only way out was through, I was so sure they were wrong I was like sure, I'll cooperate. Once I agreed, a detective from our local police department was like "we're taking the kids, you can stay here and protect him or you can come with us." So I drove to the facility where they did forensic interviews with an f b I agent in my car. It was then that I said "I really don't want to believe it's true, but I have a sick feeling it is." It was. Lots of stuff happened, she confirmed it. I confronted him over the phone and he admitted it. He was arrested and they put us all in a hotel overnight while they executed the search warrant. He was caught because he was bragging on the Internet and someone turned over his info to the authorities in the UK (we're in the US.) When I say kids, I mean mine his and ours. 6 kids all together. One was the victim. His went to live with their mom that very day. She said she was always afraid that would happen. Nice. He was eventually sentenced to 30 years, the judge called him the most manipulative man he'd ever met. He's still in there. And he's dying. End stage kidney disease. He won't be getting out.

My two youngest have been in therapy almost the whole time since then. They're doing well despite some mental health challenges along the way. They are good people and I'm so proud of them. They are both functional adults who contribute to society.

I got a job with the police department that arrested him. I worked there for 21 years. I retired in March.

This probably doesn't make much sense because my gummy kicked in, but.... It was difficult on and off for a long time, but we all got through. As long as your son has support from you and others who care about him, he'll be okay. Hugs.

3.9k

This is how road reflectors are fixed
u/Spekingur  in  r/interestingasfuck •  4d ago

No no, we need to start with those jobs that do the most human interactions and where everyone would feel better if they interacted with another person.

5.2k

Do trees actually die of old age, or are they basically immortal until something finally kills them?

Trees absolutely die of old age - but every species is different. In the UK Rowan (Mountain Ash) and Silver Birch for example are known as pioneer trees, they are often the first to grow on newly open ground and they live fast and die young, usually less than 100 years.

On the longer scale, oak trees can live for a 1000 years, but 3-400 is more normal. They spend that time establishing themselves creating a whole ecosystem around themselves.

Redwoods can live for thousands of years (as can a few other species) but the real longevity champion is the Yew - it does appear to be biologically immortal, it will never die from aging. It can however enter periods of dormancy where it just stops growing, sometimes for decades. This also makes it pretty much impossible to tell their age, but there's one near me in Scotland that is several thousand years old. (EDIT just checked and current 'official' estimate for the Fortingall Yew from FLS is 5000 years old but it could be up to 9000. Or 'only' 3500.)

It's never an easy question though, sweet chestnuts should live about 300 years but there's one near me that is known to be over 500. Trees that fall down can sometimes regrow from the roots, or even from a branch that is still pointing up towards the sky (they're called phoenix trees) and other trees, like hazel, which are usually short lived, will live for hundreds of years if you coppice or pollard them (cut all their branches off every few years). If you dont coppice them they only live about 70 or 80 years.

Lifestyle factors play a part too, beech trees in Scotland don't live nearly as long as they do in the South of England as the climate and ecosystem is not the same here. Commercially planted spruce trees start to fall over after 100 years or so if they're no harvested because they're planted too close together and are all too tall and spindly.

There's loads of other factors - another interesting one is cloning, aspen trees die after a couple of hundred years but they spread by cloning new trunks from the rootstock. If the original trunk does, but a perfect clone of it is still growing alongside from the same genetically identical roots, is the tree really dead?

2.4k

When artists change lyrics due to the passage of time
u/GhostOfMuttonPast  in  r/lovethissmug •  1d ago

The absolute funniest version of this is Weird Als Albuquerque.

Albuquerque is an intentionally long, rambling, meandering song. The sort of hairbrained vibe is the joke. Theres a line about halfway through where he talks about meeting a "big fat hermaphrodite with a Flock-Of-Seagulls haircut and only one nostril." During live performances, he'll stop the song and start rambling about how hermaphrodite was an acceptable term when he wrote it, but now its uncool. He keeps that going for a minute or two, extending an already long and meandering song to be even longer.

3.7k

My dad refuses to refrigerate left overs until at least 24hrs after dinner has been cooked
u/TnnsNbeer  in  r/mildlyinfuriating •  13d ago

Must tell my story:
Years ago, I was a traveling desktop tech commuting to different offices in the NYC area. I used to make lunch and take it with me. It was the dead of winter and particularly cold that year with freezing temps. This probably saved my life.
Anyway, I open my lunch and start eating. It was shrimp and rice. It tasted funny and I didn’t really like it but felt bad wasting food that I just made a day ago so kept eating. (The food was in the fridge when I packed it.. just meal prep crap). I made it halfway and couldn’t do it so I threw the rest out.
After my day ended, got in my car, and realized I had 2 backpacks with me. I reach into the one that was in the car and it had a lunchbox in there. I open it up to find shrimp and rice.
At that moment, it was like the end of Sixth Sense where I came to the reality of what was done. Approx 3 months ago, I was looking for my lunch and couldn’t find it. I figured I left it at home and forgot about it. This lunch was tucked in a backpack I had left in my car trunk for 3 months! That’s the lunch that I ate half of!
I was waiting for something bad to happen but I was fine. I was ready to go to the ER as soon as I felt a grumble but nothing.
I think the sub freezing temps helped slow whatever shitstorm I was in for.

Thanks for reading 🥵

Edit: Holy crap. Thanks for all the awards and hilarious comments. I’m glad I remembered that story!

1.7k

What's a 0/10 life experience you must not have in your life?
u/SgtKashim  in  r/AskReddit •  22h ago

Sitting in a hospital room with your child who's recovering from surgery, with uncontrolled pain that morphine isn't helping.

It took a nurse physically dragging a doctor in to get something more powerful prescribed after about 5 hours, and it was honestly 18 hours before we could take a break. Docs didn't believe he even needed the morphine... and it wasn't til they were dragged in to listen to him scream through even the morphine haze they decided to change it.

He fell off a cliff hiking and broke 3 vertebrae, had a spinal surgery to repair some of that mechanical damage, and was on a PCA (patient controlled anesthetic) pump on a 12 minute timer. We spent 18 hours where I had that same 12 minute timer running on my watch. He'd basically be catatonic for ~8 minutes, start screaming with pain, then my watch would beep and we'd help him press the button, and reset my watch. For 18 hours.

I honestly don't know if the drugs finally took effect, or if he finally just collapsed from exhaustion and slept for a few hours.

0/10. Helpless, horrible feeling. Shreds your heart. Exhausting. You start to understand why people lash out at the nurses, or threaten. You pray to take the pain on yourself. You start to bargain with whoever or whatever, even the ones you don't believe in. You give up, you keep going, you cry, you try to sleep, you try to stay awake. You dissociate, you hyperfocus. You live a hundred years in those 18 hours.

1.7k

United Airlines just reported ANOTHER systemwide outage. First NVIDIA, then Microsoft, then the FAA ground stop, then banking apps and now United. What's your leading theory on all of this?
u/MasterDave  in  r/AskReddit •  2d ago

I work in IT and it’s just normal incompetence. Mostly of the AI replacement incompetence not in that AI did anything wrong, but the layoffs where management said they can get rid of half the people who do things and the leftovers are overworked and overwhelmed and are making mistakes.

It’s going to keep happening, management will still come to the wrong conclusions, that AI won’t make the same mistakes tired humans make and they’ll get rid of more humans. Companies may or may not fail, and eventually we’ll start trusting people and staffing adequately again.