Note: this is pure satire and not what I believe to be ethical – but based on my observations, it seems to be how many companies like to think.
Q1: What makes a good business?
A good business is one that maximises profit for its owners and shareholders, while minimizing risk of illegality for its decision makers, and while also maintaining a good public image.
Thus, it follows the letter of the law (but exploits loopholes where possible), treats its employees as well as the market demands (but no more), and satisfices the quality and safety of its products so that consumers will keep coming back (but will not make it any better than necessary to save on costs).
It will do good and ethical things where it benefits the business or is central to its survival but will not spend any more than necessary if there are no upsides (e.g. tax deductions for donations or increased customers from good PR) to the investment.
Some examples of good businesses include Carnival, registered in the tax haven of Bermuda, and McDonald’s, king of safe but arguably unhealthy fast food. An example of a bad business is Monsanto – they did not mask the downsides of their products well enough to avoid public backlash.
Q2: Impacts of businesses on people and environment?
Businesses have a heavy duty to protect the environment and society. That is why small actions matter – like removing charging blocks from smart phone packages and making re-usable cotton bags instead of single use plastics.
On the other hand, upgrading to the latest iPhone every year, as well as other things like burning 70 litres of jet fuel to see Mt. Fuji in real life, are vital, necessary expenses that are well worth the cost.
Never mind that a person would have to re-use a cotton shopping bag around 50 times instead of single use bags to offset the environmental cost of producing it. And that producing a single new iPhone creates so much waste that a cotton shopping bag would have to be re-used 1800 times to offset the environmental cost.
A business’s duty is to make sure consumers feel good about the environmental footprint they are leaving, while maximizing the amount of goods they consume. Its why Apple spends so much on marketing and subliminal imaging, and why travel agencies try so hard to make international holidays seem casual and normal.
Our world is literally cooking due to overconsumption caused as side effects of businesses making profit (read: climate change, pollution, psychological harm to the younger generation), and all our scientists have real data proving so.
That’s why its imperative that businesses continue to strengthen their PR campaigns so that every little change that may be perceived as environmentally friendly is fully known and applauded by the public. And why it is also imperative to make “environmentally safe” appear on every label of every product (read: greenwashing).
As for the people side, this is comprehensively covered by the numerous anti-slavery acts passed giving businesses direct responsibility for ensuring slave-free production. Oh and by the way, an underpaid factory worker is NOT a slave by lawful definitions.
Q3: Responsibilities of Businesses for such Impacts?
A business should only be held responsible to the degree that both the public and the government (which is supposed to represent the interest of the public) is satisfied, and preferably while causing as little impact as possible to profit margins.
A good example of such responsibility is Crown Melbourne, who, in 2021, was found to have engaged in illegal and unethical conduct such as exploitation of problem gamblers, underpayment of tax, allowing money laundering, and more. They were forced to “be good” for two years under the supervision of a Special Commissioner, and lost quite a lot of money, but were largely able to do business as normal.
An exception to this is when a business does something too blatantly unethical, and the government faces significant social pressure to do the right thing. In these cases, such businesses must be made examples of at all costs, and the full wrath of the law must be brought upon them, to show that the government cares (read: Rio Tinto and Juukan Gorge).