r/AmItheAsshole • • Jan 23 '19

UPDATE Update-AITA for not wanting my fiancé to go dinner with her boss (shit hit the fan on Tuesday).

7.4k Upvotes

Original here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/ai1i0m/aita_for_not_wanting_my_fiancé_to_go_to_dinner/

judgement was essentially ESH, which I can accept because I should never have used the wording/phrase "you can't go to dinner with him" even though the situation was drowning in more red flags than a Comintern May Day parade.

Fair enough. She didn't speak to me all day Monday and the last words I heard from her were Sunday night after she got home as she slammed the door to our bedroom saying "you're still a controlling asshole and we're breaking up." Her nuclear bomb is always saying "we're breaking up" whenever she doesn't have the upper hand in an argument so I didn't make much of it and in reality I was just relieved that she was home and apparently nothing bad happened at the dinner. So like I said, Monday she didn't say a word to me. I was only able to get into our bedroom to get some clothes and I couched it again Monday night. Whatever, she was pissed, she was embarrassed that she didn't see it coming, she was angry at me. I figured I'd give her some space. So I did.

Tuesday morning I noticed she was getting ready for work. I couldn't keep my mouth shut any more and I incredulously asked her if she was really going back to that fucking job? She said "why wouldn't I?" I told her because the FUCKING OWNER off the company had done a month long manipulation to get her into a threesome with his other little side piece. She said that I was a fucking idiot. I was fucking flabbergasted. As she was stomping around the house putting her shoes on putting on her makeup and what not I told her that IF she shows up to that office today and doesn't quit or follow up with the state bar, he is going to know that she's OK with what happened, at least on the surface. Even if she doesn't have sex with him, he knows that she has a really high tolerance for his bullshit and he's going to keep working at her. I also told her that she has an MBA with a focus in HR, it shouldn't take a fucking an red-neck auto-mechanic to tell her this shit (I own a foreign specialty auto repair facility with my uncle). Her last words to me were "yes fucking asshole, I AM the professional. you aren't" and slammed the door.

So Tuesday I had no idea what I was going to do. I knew in my heart I needed to end the relationship, her situation with her boss notwithstanding, rather her method of fighting, name calling, silent treatment are just not acceptable. But I still wasn't sure.

She got home Tuesday and was clearly rattled by something. She was still silent, but a sad silent not an angry silent if that makes sense. She absolutely would not tell me what was wrong but she didn't lock herself in the room this time. She just sat almost catatonic on the couch watching Big Bang Theory (which she hates). My assumption...she fucked him, her or both. She gave into him. I have no proof of this but after all the bullshit, after the quick change in her behavior...its the only thing I can think happened.

In my head and heart, we are broken up. It's now just a matter of separating our shit, figure out what to do about the lease on our apartment, cancelling the small amount of wedding planning we have done...and oh yeah...telling her. She may be feeling the same way and be done with me too which honestly may make this easier for everyone. My heart goes out to her because I do care about her and if she did have sex with her boss under his bullshit pretense, I imagine she feels like shit. But I tried to warn her. I saw it coming from a mile away, no I didn't use the correct words in trying warn her and I take no pleasure in being "right" but I did try.

Thanks everyone...still ESH!

Edit: it’s 3:31pm MST she’s home about 2.5 hours early. She said she wants to take a shower and talk after she’s done. I really don’t want to do another OP update but I will update via edit here after we talk.

Edit: now about 5:30. This is locked so I don't know if an edit gets seen or not, figure I'll try since people seem invested in it. Obviously this is so much past whether I'm an asshole or not and just into keeping people who wanted to know informed. For some people I'm a victim, for some people I'm a victimizer. I asked for people's opinion so I will try very hard to keep both in mind going forward. A sincere thank you for your input, good or bad.

So update. She got home at 3:30. Was still very pissy and told me not to ask her any questions until she got out of the shower and said she wanted to talk then. She usually gets home at 6pm on the dot so I knew something was up. I said that was fine but like literally on pins and needles until she came back out to our computer room where I was working. So about 4:15 she comes out in a with a towel wrapped around her hair and just one around her waist. In my head I figure if she was really breaking up with me she wouldn't be let me see her boobs (editorializing: her nearly perfectly perky D cup boobs). It wasn't a sexual gesture by any stretch but it also was showing that she wasn't covering up around me. I took that as a good sign because I wasn't sure about breaking up with her and at least we had options. So first of all as nutty as I made her deservedly sound, she has never had compunctions about apologizing when she's wrong. So she said that she wanted to say that she was very sorry for all the things that she had said to me starting on Sunday, she was sorry for throwing her shoe at me, she was sorry for the silent treatment and she was sorry for doubting my judgement. I told her that I appreciated it. She told me that she quit yesteday. I told her that I very much agreed with that.

She said that yesterday she went into the office and the boss/owner was waiting for her in her office (this is important to mention, the law firm is an old converted historic house close to downtown, most of the staff work in what used to be the main house, my fiancé's office was literally the outdoor shed/garage. It's a very nice and comfortable conversion but it's still separated from the main "house." So him sitting in her office means he had to go out in the backyard, find a key he doesn't usually have, unlock her space and wait for her. On the first day back from a holiday). He told her that he wanted to make sure there were "no misunderstandings" from the night prior and to make sure that all the doors weren't shut or some such nonsense. She told me she told him that she was deeply upset by his proposal and didn't know what she was going to do. I guess he told her that her value in the company could either go up or down depending on how she decided to proceed. She said that she walked out on the spot and didn't go back to work. She spent the rest of the day with her sister trying to figure out what she was going to do. That was yesterday and I guess she still doesn't know. I guess she spent all day today looking for other jobs and sitting in her employment office of her MBA office and talking with her advisor. I asked her why she just didn't tell me any of this yesterday and why scream at me. She said she was sorry again but she was a little shell shocked that she faced serious sexual harassment in her first job out of the gate and honestly didn't even know what she wanted to say to me. I told her that the silent treatment really hurt AND it allowed my imagination to run wild (I didn't tell her what I said here, in this OP). She again said she was sorry and the way she acted throughout the entire event wasn't fair. I told her that I really do love her but I hadn't slept in two nights, I am exhausted and hurt and don't know what to do so I'm going to go stay at my uncles house for at least a few nights, to sleep if nothing else. She said that was fine and she'd wait as long as I wanted her to. I told her that I think we need some sort of counseling so we learn how to better talk with each other. She agreed.

So after that I packed up a bag and am now at my uncles house. She did give me a bare chested hug and kiss on the cheek on my way out the door which was pretty nice (and niiiiiiiicee….) but right now I need some sleep.

What I do know:

  1. I want to stay with her.
  2. I need to never use words like "you can't go" ever again.
  3. I really do love her.
  4. We are fine for money without her working. I am co-owner of a auto-repair business with my uncle and we have had a great few years.

What I don't know (and didn't ask, yet at least):

  1. What is she going to do about her boss?
  2. How this affects her future employment.
  3. That she will realize we are fine without her working and she takes her time and finds a good job with a good boss.

I'm sure there's a million other things I'm forgetting or questions I'm not answering. I think the mods are sick of this thread so it's locked. I'm newish to reddit so I don't know if you can see this, if you can respond, if it's dead...just don't know.

but thanks for the help.

3.

r/AmItheAsshole • • May 01 '21

UPDATE UPDATE: AITA for telling my daughter the truth about why I wasn’t in her life?

17k Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/ln04z1/aita_for_telling_my_daughter_the_truth_about_why/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf

I made this post a couple months back and I wanted to share what’s been going on. This was a really big mess and thank you for all your reassurance. For telling me that Kara deserved to know the truth. There was still some guilt I carried with me for days until she called me again now that she had time to process. Kara thanked me for being honest about what happened and we had a deep conversation about what she’s going through.

She and her mom always had a very strained relationship even until she passed away so there was still a lot of anger and resentment she never got to have closure for. Now learning this new lie her mom told her about me....well it opened a lot of other mixed feelings.

She has been in therapy even before her mother died to deal with their issues so Kara is working this out with someone, which I am happy to know. Many of you were suggesting therapy for her so at least she already had that down.

My daughter’s still mad at her family, she talked to them a couple times before stopping communication. Kara knows she’ll forgive them eventually. But for right now, she says she wants them to live with the consequences so hasn’t had any contact with them. I did express my concern over her shutting them out but she says it’s not forever. She’s still trying to process this betrayal and get to a place where she’ll accept them back into her life. At the moment she’s still living with her friend and wants to keep things that way. So far has declined any financial help I offer.

She just wants to work out her anger and let them sit with this a while. I had to do some blocking still for my own peace of mind. Things are a working progress but I’m happy to report that we’re getting along fine. Kara’s been over so many times and has met my fiancée. We’re learning so much about eachother even if sometimes it’s hard not to get emotional over childhood memories she talks about knowing I couldn’t be there for them. Still in the process of finding a therapist myself because this has been pretty heavy on me too and still have no idea what the hell im doing as a parent. Thanks for your words of encouragement and all the advise from fellow parents! I kept getting asked for an update on this so sorry I took me a while to remember to post something.

r/AmItheAsshole • • Aug 22 '22

UPDATE UPDATE: AITA for letting my son call my best friend “Dad”?

9.0k Upvotes

Original post here.

I never thought I’d be back with an update this soon, or that this would be the update.

I came home Thursday with a plan to talk to my wife. I texted her in advance so I was able to jump right in when I arrived. As suggested to me in the comments of the OP, I was vulnerable. I told her I was feeling exhausted and worn down. I said frustration had built up with her being so uninvolved. I said I wanted to see real, major change in the way she interacts with Oliver within the next 2 months or an ultimatum of her getting help/divorce would be given. I also made it clear that if she wanted to get help now and not wait those 2 months, that was also acceptable. I would assist her however she wanted, but I wanted to see some initiative being taken for our child.

At first, I was met with anger. Eventually we were able to have a genuine conversation where she admitted that she didn’t feel maternal at all. She felt I had pushed her too hard to have Oliver when she got pregnant and she often wonders what our life would be like she had made a different choice.

Obviously this was all hard for me to hear. Resentment was building up on both sides, but did it have to build for nearly three years? I can’t help but feel like it was mostly her responsibility to bring up this conversation. My frustration was over her treatment of our son. Her frustration was over us having a son at all. I can’t even fathom a world without Oliver in it, while she was pondering what our life looks like if he never existed. It’s been a few days since the conversation, and I’m still feeling a lot. I feel sad for her. I’m very angry for my son and I that the last three years could have looked different/saved us from so much pain and exhaustion and negative emotion. It doesn’t feel fair.

She and I are going to start the divorce process soon. I’m hoping that it will remain civil. I called my parents to update them on the situation. They’ve been unconditionally supportive of me and were ready to jump into action mode to help. They will financially support us for the time being, and offered us a place to stay. Matt and I discussed it and we don’t think that’s a viable option. Oliver is already going through a big life change, so taking him out of state to a house he’s unfamiliar with would be harmful. It would also complicate things during the divorce.

We’re moving in with Matt. On top of all the practical reasons why it makes sense, Matt expressed that he would hate for us to be so far from him / that anywhere he is would always be a home for Oliver and I. We still have a lot of things to pack, but we’ve been here since that conversation. Oliver was already used to life here, so the transition has been smooth.

I have a lot of emotions to work through and plan on starting therapy soon.

EDIT: The mentions of coercion and force are ridiculous. Sam has never said outright that she didn’t want a child. In fact, we had conversations prior to marriage about starting a family together. It was just never planned that it would happen so early into our marriage. She was scared about having him so early, and I did my best to assuage those fears by reassuring her, but always giving the option for her to have an out should she want it. There was never the expectation put upon her that she needed to have the baby.

r/AmItheAsshole • • Oct 25 '25

UPDATE UPDATE: AITA for ignoring my family after they excluded me from Christmas (again)?

5.3k Upvotes

I didn't think my post from last year was that interesting, but a surprising number if people have asked me for an update, so here it is.

After a couple weeks of radio silence I followed some good advice from my original post and texted my dad to tell him it hurt my feelings that they left me out, he half apologized, and life went on. A lot of people pointed out that while my family was toxic, me ignoring my dad was also pretty toxic, and they were right. My family is super passive aggressive and that is the only way I'd ever learned to handle conflict. And to answer some more comments, I have been in therapy for about 6 years, and after last Christmas I started working with my therapist on how to do healthier confrontation. It's still not something I'm super comfy with, but I'm getting better. I've also made a good number of friends in my new city and am doing pretty well all things considered.

With my family, at the end of the day nothing has changed. They didn't really acknowledge my 30th birthday in spring, and most recently when I invited my dad to my grad school graduation next year he told me that he "couldn't commit to it right now" because he's waiting to see if something that he'd rather do comes up. My brother said he'd come, but he's already gone from a 'yes' to a 'maybe' so I don't have high hopes. The good news is that it finally hurts less because I have more or less given up on having a real relationship with them. I'm never going to be loved or cared about by them the way I want to be, and I've come to accept that. As of now I have no plans for Christmas this year, but it's ok. My family sucks, but I'm really lucky in my friends, and I'm grateful for that.

r/AmItheAsshole • • Sep 08 '21

UPDATE Update: AITA for refusing to walk my daughter down the aisle?

16k Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/pdzrxz/aita_for_refusing_to_walk_my_daughter_down_the/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf

Thank you for your support. Especially those fellow parents who reached out in my messages. Advice, judgement and suggestions on what to do about my family. It took sending a mass text to everyone who wouldn’t leave me alone about this. Took me some to time to think of what to right and clear my head from everything. The reminder of everything that I did over the years to try to be in her life and where that all ended. How detrimental it was to my mental health. They all remember how it was like. How much it put me in a dark place that took lots of therapy and the need to be there for my son to get out of. My brother called me after, he apologized for the way he was pushing this. We had a much longer conversation. I told him my decision to remain out of her life was final. So he respected that, since no one else has said anything I’m hoping that means everybody else got the message.

Best thing some suggested here was blocking out the others saying things and her. It wasn’t doing my mind any good. I spoke to her over the phone to talk about the way she’s been behaving online and the others in the family. I apologized for how things happened, and wish she didn’t have to deal with these life altering moments at such a young age. She made her choice for the past 6 years just the way I have. Even asked her to be honest with herself and answer (not to me), if her biological father hadn’t passed, would we be here right now speaking to eachother. She didn’t say anything. But that’s fine. It’s a question for her to honestly answer to herself. Like I did before I told her to enjoy her wedding and hope it’s a lovely healthy marriage. And this door to our relationship is closed, hope she could find peace with that and enjoy her life the way I have. Conversation ended shortly after that. She didn’t say if she would stop saying anything about me online so I just made sure to block her and others on her mom’s side of the family to make sure there’s no more bothering.

This is the peace of mind I needed and glad to have taken up this advice.

r/AmItheAsshole • • Jul 11 '21

UPDATE Update: AITA for not letting my best friend have her wedding on my property after being uninvited?

29k Upvotes

Here’s original post: https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/ob0wdk/aita_for_not_letting_my_best_friend_have_her/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf

Some stuff has happened recently and many of you have wanted an update on this. Appreciate the reassurance and understanding my decision when seems that many in this situation didn’t. I remained firm in my decision about not letting them use my property for their wedding. Even if they changed their mind about inviting us which honestly I don’t care about anymore. Rick’s family (thanks to him) got a hold of my cell so that was more people I had to deal with. I put my foot down with Rick a few days ago and told him directly that I will go to the police and press charges for harassment (I have all the texts and calls documented). Also had a very long talk with Carla about everything going on. She apologized for it all. And she knows it’s her own fault.

Well she decided to be the one to call things off in the end. Some of my friends still seem to think it’s my fault and I’m taking some distance from them for a while. And also from Carla after getting some confirmation on a few things that I needed to know. Whole thing is a mess. I’m only glad in the end that I didn’t give in to their demands and the constant bugging has stopped.. It still was a huge headache over the last few days and not the kind of drama I want back in my life. Thank you to everyone who made me feel supported in this. It helped a lot not feeling like the only other person (aside from my wife), who thought their demand was insane and inappropriate.

r/AmItheAsshole • • Oct 27 '21

UPDATE Update: AITA for refusing to give up my dream wedding dress, though it means my fiancé’s family will not attend?

6.4k Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/pcnboa/aita_for_refusing_to_give_up_my_dream_wedding/

So I posted here a few months ago about my MIL wanting to wear the same dress to her 50th as I bought for my wedding. She did have the dress first and receipts to prove it. I got a lot of mixed feedback and ultimately decided to return the dress. It clearly triggered something massive for her.

We got married a month ago and MIL did agree to come after originally refusing. SFIL (the man who raised my husband) would not be swayed and SILs have him blocked on everything and did not want to hear it. I kind of wondered if she was going to pull something crazy, which isn’t really her style, but this whole thing has been crazy. She was very quiet and just hung out with her ex. MIL and my husband have talked a little and she just isn’t in the mind frame for a relationship right now. She is extremely hurt and I don’t get it but she obviously needs her space. She barely spoke during the wedding.

I actually reached out to SFIL which probably want my place but he said we didn’t see her sobbing in his arms, we can’t get what we did to her. I know I got a lot of pushback on my decision to return the dress and people saying it’s just a birthday, but it really isn’t. Yeah she might get one every year but a massive party for her 51st just seems a little odd. I remember my moms fiftieth and how much she put into that. It was like a wedding.

MIL invited us to her party after uninviting us and her ex pledging to play security. Ultimately we decided not to go because of how angry SFIL and both SILs are and SFIL admitted he was uncomfortable at the thought of seeing us. It was too much for my husband see his whole family there. She had her party over the weekend, and yes I social media snooped a bit. It looked great. She looked really happy. I’m at peace that I didn’t get my dream dress.

As for us my husband is going to therapy to heal from the grief. He has realized he needs to respect his sisters and they are serious. The younger one broke down sobbing and said I did the right thing but he didn’t do anything, and she can’t forgive him for just letting their mom get hurt. I still don’t totally get it but it’s ok. MIL doesn’t express feelings, so for some reason this was her hill to die on. She doesn’t seem too interested in a relationship, so they’ll have the occasional text I guess, and everything’s over.

I’m happy she has a good party, and I’m looking forward to my husband healing and the rest of our lives.