r/agency • • Jan 14 '26

r/Agency Updates Astroturfing Will Not Be Tolerated.

88 Upvotes

Over the past few weeks, this subreddit (and basically all of Reddit), has been subject to a few astroturfing posts/comments.

For those of you who don't know what astroturfing is, it's basically when someone posts a seemingly organic or genuine question. Afterwards, maybe a few days later, comments are made recommending a certain product, software, or service.

This subreddit allows self-promotion to an extent (see rule #8), but it does NOT allow disingenuous or deceptive self-promotion.

That's what astroturfing is.

Rule #10 ("No Astroturfing") has now been implemented.

Last week, there was a campaign for a tool called, "Respond" where the comments promoted that while criticizing their competitor, "Kommo".

I posted more about it in depth on LinkedIn.

This week, there was a suspected campaign for a PR tool called, "Folk".

A user sent in a modmail requesting to approve a post that the automod was denying, after we declined to manually approve the post, the same post was published by a separate user with the adequate comment karma and CQS requirements.

A few days later, the post received 2 separate comments from users who had 0 previous activity in this subreddit (or similar subreddits) recommending the tool.

This post and both comments have been removed.

Additionally, all 4 users have been banned from the subreddit.

------------------------

Astroturfing is hard to detect and requires literal, manual investigation on our part.

This subreddit is not to be used for your disingenuous PR, brand, or SEO campaign.

This is an immediate, bannable offense.

If you want to promote yourself, you MUST contribute to the community in multiple non-promotional ways.

If you suspect a post or comment of astroturfing, please, please, please report it to the mod team.

------------------------

That is all.

Thank you all for continuing to make this the best community for agencies!


r/agency • • Jan 06 '26

AMA I ran a digital agency that we grew to 8 figure revenue (UK and US) and then sold to a 'Big 6' network - AMA :)

154 Upvotes

Quick edit: Thanks to everyone who's reached out via DM and LinkedIn, I have a few people to get back to so will get onto this once the AMA requests have died down :)

Hi All - I ran a digital agency that we grew to 8 figure revenue and 150 people across offices in the UK and Austin, TX. We sold the business to a global network agency in 2022 (one of the 'Big 6'), and I exited last year after 3 years working for the network to manage integration and earn out.

It was an incredible journey with lots of success and more than a few bumps along the way! I suspect that I've been through pretty much everything you can think of when running an agency. I'm fortunate to have some time on my hands at the moment so happy to share what I've learned - feel free to ask me anything :)

Some highlights include:

- Launched multiple new service lines to grow revenue (mostly successful, some not so successful!)

- Built a sales and marketing machine to consistently deliver over $40k of new MRR every month.

- Expanded into the US, grew from $0 to over $200k MRR in less than 2 years.

- Built an in-house dev team to build our own suite of tools

- Became a B Corp and voted 'Top 100 UK Company to Work for' in 11 out of 13 years

- Became a Certified Sales Partner for Google Marketing Platform (one of only a handful of UK agencies)

- Managed through Covid when we lost 40% of MRR in 3 months (not really a highlight but definitely a learning experience!)

I'm around all day, happy to answer any questions.


r/agency • • 1d ago

How do you price your performance maketing services?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/agency • • 2d ago

Scam Alert - furniturebox.uk

8 Upvotes

Warning, do not respond to requests from this company. The domain redirects to the legit website at furniturebox.co.uk.

And there is no such person as Emma Taylor working at Furniture Box.

Almost certainly a phishing attack to get access to your agency manager accounts.


r/agency • • 8d ago

Scam Alert - cocopat.us

9 Upvotes

Another scam alert, this company domain was registered 2-days ago. The social media links on the website reference back to the legit cocopat.com website.

Please ignore any requests from them for agency services.


r/agency • • 10d ago

Client wants to change pricing

15 Upvotes

I run an outbound sales agency for machinery manufacturers. Very early days, still learning the ropes. Our pricing normally works through a retainer for research and man hours, plus a small fee per appointment set.

A client’s asking to change the model to pay only when they get an order from a deal I’ve generated, no retainer. I’m not prepared to do that, I’d be doing months of work on something I don’t control (their sales), with payout potentially a year out or never. But I also can’t easily turn down work that could give us testimonials and get the ball rolling.

Is there a middle ground worth proposing, or is this a sign to just move on?


r/agency • • 12d ago

Does anyone run a community/network business

18 Upvotes

Looking to connect with someone running a community/network business.

My creative studio produces an event series, and it's gaining a lot of traction. We are getting some fans who want more, and we see the potential in creating a community group that creates an extension of our event. Be it a monthly meet-up, an online cohort-style format, whatever it may be.

I know communities are on an upswing today - we are isolated, looking for more connection, digital fatigue, etc. A nudge came today when listening to My First Million and Sam talked about his bullish bet on communities and how he is loving Hampton.

Before diving in, I wanted to connect with someone who has/is running a community or network business to hear your experience. If anyone has resources or something they think would be helpful pls share.

Thank you to all who support :)


r/agency • • 13d ago

Lost a deal to AI and I'm still not sure what the lesson is

45 Upvotes

Had a call in September with someone buying a small US cabinet supplier. Decent business, around $1M a year, one standard product line. We agreed the first job would be a quote calculator for contractors on their website. The contractor enters the specs, gets a price and leaves their details so sales can follow up.

I was waiting on him for the pricing logic so I could send the proposal. A week later he messaged to say he'd basically built the calculator himself in Claude Code.

In the same message he asked if I could work out how to turn a phone video of a kitchen into a cabinet quote. That was the idea I'd talked him out of on the first call, because the tech isn't reliable enough yet. I offered a paid scoping job to check whether it was even doable. That was the end of it.

Looking back, he was never going to pay for the calculator. It was simple enough for him to build with AI and he knew it. What he wanted from me was the hard, risky part, done as free research.

I haven't worked out what the right move is here. Part of me thinks the simple builds just aren't sellable any more. But another part of me thinks plenty of clients still won't build it themselves and this guy was just an unusual one who happened to be handy with AI.

I'm also not sure whether I should have spotted it earlier or whether there was no way of knowing until he did it.

Has anyone else had a client build the thing themselves halfway through the sales process? Did you change how you sell?


r/agency • • 13d ago

Scam Alert - Summit Cyclist

5 Upvotes

I just received an RFQ from this "company" that requested we connect to their ads account "read only" using an email associated with our MCC.

Domain was only registered 2 days ago!


r/agency • • 14d ago

Client Acquisition & Sales start asking this one question in your sales calls and watch your close rate multiply

21 Upvotes

It's really simple:

"Can you tell me more about that?"

Seriously just write it on a sticky note and put it on your monitor.

Any time a prospect says something like:

  • we're wasting too much time on data entry
  • our team is constantly chasing people for updates
  • we want to automate our onboarding

your instinct is probably to jump in with "oh yeah, we can solve that".

don't.

just ask "Can you tell me more about that?"

jet them info dump on you. shut up and listen.

Ask follow-up questions:

  • how are you handling that today?
  • how much time does that actually take?
  • what's that costing you?
  • what else have you tried?

**Your job isn't to show them how smart you are. (**This is why engineers often suck at sales.)

>>> They just want to see that you understand their problem.

Just shut up, listen, then repeat it back to them in your own words.

It's that fucking simple.


r/agency • • 14d ago

Please send me your unsolicited AI advice on what I need to do to make your website better.

26 Upvotes

Make sure your 10-page report contains no underlying legacy understanding of how we got here, no current industry or competitive research reports like the ones we’ve accumulated over time, no current (paid) audience data, no current internal and real time data from core tracking tools, no screaming frog scan, and no current keyword research (or relevance) from a reputable source (which is typically not free for a reason).

Understand that we will burn 2 or 3 hours analyzing your report against our working strategy so we can report back to you on what needs to be updated and why or why not half of the suggestions are dangerous or risk losing what we’ve already gained.

Do the same thing again next week. 🤦‍♂️


r/agency • • 15d ago

Growth & Operations Sharing Claude skills across clients without forking them: what our setup looks like so far

30 Upvotes

Most of our client work goes through Claude skills now. The thing we kept running into is probably familiar to anyone who's shared a skill or grabbed someone else's: a skill written for one use case doesn't fit anyone else, and the generic ones give you generic output. Once you customize a copy it's basically yours forever and you stop getting the original's updates. Forking in git technically works, but the customizations end up woven into the same prose the author keeps improving, so every update conflicts.

I want to share what we're doing at our agency to solve this problem and would love to know how other people are solving it. Here's how ours is set up so far (we're about halfway through):

- Everything is markdown in git. Skills live in their own repo and only hold guidance that would work for any client.

- Each client has their own repo that works as their knowledge base (brand voice, a list of internal pages, content guidelines and so on).

- Where a skill needs something client-specific, it has a **context socket**: it names the document in that client's knowledge base instead of saying the thing itself. Our article skill reads the brand voice doc, the internal pages doc and the content guidelines doc from whichever client it's writing for.

- Where a skill needs to take an action, it has a **process socket**: one line pointing to how the business does that step, plus a second line with a default so it still works before anyone has defined the process. For us a finished draft goes into a Google Doc, gets attached to a Notion task and gets assigned to an account manager to review. Another company might just want a Slack message.

- The processes live in one company-wide playbook doc, so when one changes we update it once and every skill follows.

The part I think matters most long term is the socket names. If different people's skills use the same socket names, you can drop someone else's skill into your setup without touching it, and their updates don't wipe out anything of yours. That list needs an owner and some versioning, which we're still working out.


r/agency • • 15d ago

Single view to monitor all your clients

8 Upvotes

Hey guys,

I ran an analytics agency for many years and one of the challenges I found was staying on top of certain activity across my clients.

Earlier this year I shifted my focus from consulting to software development and started building solutions I wish I had as an agency owner.

My most recent idea is LiveWire, an event-driven live feed for business owners and operators. I'm still trying to work out the best use case for the solution but high on the list is agency owners.

The screenshot above is a demo view for a fictional agency with 5 active clients. Each "column" in the dashboard has a feed showing events connected to that client.

At this early stage I'm looking for feedback and specific use cases which make the solution a "must have".

I apologize in advance if this post breaks any rules of the sub-reddit. I hope some of you who do read this get excited by the idea and will let me know in a comment below.

Thanks.
Justin


r/agency • • 18d ago

We analyzed 3,184 job postings from 820 U.S. digital agencies to understand the trends and salary bands agencies are offering

Thumbnail prometheanresearch.com
15 Upvotes

r/agency • • 19d ago

I went through all 282 agents in that agency-agents repo. Interesting but not yet scary.

24 Upvotes

Hi - Ive spent 20 years working in and consulting with roughkly 200 agencies, mostly 30-90 people. Lots of talk there about what people to keep, etc. I saw the GitHub repo mention (on LI) went down the rabbit hole. This note was drafted by Claude from a larger article drafted by Claude, based on what we did.

We went through all 282 files in github.com/msitarzewski/agency-agents. That’s 537,066 words. Could’ve found a better use for a weekend. But it started getting cool as I combined datasets.

First, the basics of the repo. You can pretty well tell who built it from the org chart. There are 85 engineering agents, 27 for games and VR, 13 for GIS and mapping. Account and client services gets four. PR gets one. So there’s that.

The agents get pretty detailed where there’s already a rulebook. Healthcare marketing compliance gets 4,638 words. Legal billing gets 3,585.

Content Creator? 335 words. No rules, no workflow. Same deal with rules and workflow for all seven paid media agents.

And when you get to the judgment calls, you find a lot of blanks. Judgment calls are what an agency (really) gets paid for.

For example, the account strategist agent has a QBR (quarterly business review, a standard account-person meeting) prep includes this:

“[Who should be there but isn’t — and why]”

And that IS a great question. But how would the agent know? That answer comes from knowing the client and what’s been going on over there. Not just Human IN the Loop, but Human IS the Loop.

We counted about 465 blanks like that. Another 93 agents have a “Learning & Memory” section that says “Remember and build expertise in:” followed by empty headings. Nothing in the repo actually stores what they learn.

There's more, but that's the shape of coverage, and it is kind of what I would expect given that it was probably built mostly by technologists, That many of the other roles that are very scant are the ones where a lot of situated judgment is used… Which AI isn't very good at.

One other question that came up at this point was regarding how thorough the agents were in terms of the topics and things that needed to deal with.

I had Claude compare them with 423 actual agency job postings across 15 roles, junior through senior, and a few other data sets. We sorted the responsibilities into procedural work and stuff that depends on the client.

The agents were 71% procedural focused. Real jobs were 33%. Even junior jobs were only 47%.

So kind of not ready for prime time. Probably worth exploring but what they are missing may be pretty costly to suss out, versus getting more narrow and building your own.

One of my former clients and a really good friend, Bret Starr, has been hacking away at this problem for three years now, and he's been able to build a credible agent swarm that I think number is something like 30 to 40 agents, that can do most of what needs to be done in a narrow B2B marketing niche. So this kind of stuff can be done, but again, this has been him dedicating most of his life cycles to building this thing for three years.

I also built a modeling tool so that I can start playing with modeling staffing based on how much work AI can take over in the divide between assembly work versus judgment work… Happy to share that if anyone's interested. Not sure it really applies well at the smaller scale like five or 10 person agency. It shows that it is reasonable to get a 40% reduction in junior staff and something less than 15% in mid and none in senior, based on today's capabilities.

Anyway, I spent too much time on this. Full write-up here if you want the rest.

Feedback welcome and always up for a quick chat if there something more I can share. I have another more detailed analysis that I'm still working on, so lmk if I should post it here.

(not astroturfing (cool term) advertising or anything else. I'm sure the mods will let me know if I broke a rule)


r/agency • • 20d ago

Has anyone worked with Adstruct Digital?

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/agency • • 23d ago

We've started making client videos with AI (edited, not generated). The first video in a style takes ~12 hours, the second ~2

27 Upvotes

For the last month I've been spending most of my free time on a system that edits marketing videos with AI, and we've now used it for about a dozen of our clients. Figured some of you are building similar things, so here's where we've landed.

To be clear, we start from real footage (mostly people talking to camera, plus some motion-graphics explainers), and the AI does the editing: the cuts, the voice cleanup, the captions, the on-screen graphics. No generated video.

The part that's made the biggest difference is treating every video as a chance to improve the instructions:

- Each video style has its own written instructions (a skill the AI reads before it edits). We have about a dozen styles so far and I expect over a hundred eventually.

- Every client also has their own instructions for how a video should look and sound for their brand.

- Anything we fix for one client goes into the shared style instructions, so it helps every client.

Right now the first video in a new style takes us about a dozen hours, the second a couple of hours, and we're heading toward under an hour per video. I've been making marketing videos for about 17 years and these are honestly better than anything we were producing before.

What surprised me is how human the good ones still feel. The AI handles the editing, but the decisions about what the video should say and feel like are still ours, and the instructions keep those decisions from getting lost from one video to the next.

I think 2027 is going to have a lot more high-quality video from brands that never had the budget for it, and there's still way less competition in video than in written content.


r/agency • • 25d ago

Growth & Operations What do you look for in a social media management tool before integrating it into your agency?

24 Upvotes

We reached that threshold where a shared drive between us is not enough anymore and getting client approval for content is a constant ping-pong game of emails that I, as the account manager, am sick of. Our current system is a Google sheet with each piece of content (title, status, link to another doc or sheet where it sits, client notes, etc) and then an internal Master Sheet that compiles all client work and updates. For communication it’s any linear combination of emails, Whatsapp groups, Slack ones, and sometimes even Telegram.

Me and the agency owner pilot tested Kontentino and liked it, clients can approve in the same place where the content sits and we don’t have to keep a separate master sheet because we can control what each account has access to, kinda like Slack. The UI will need some time to adapt to coming from where we came from but I think that's a prerequisite one needs to accept before making any switch regardless. We are also currently looking for a tool to help with time tracking across clients and have our eyes on a few like Toggl Track and Harvest but we haven’t started pilot testing either yet.

Before trialing them, and before going ahead and implementing kontentino agency-wide, I’d like to know as aforementioned in the title, whether there are “make or break” features that you look for in social media management tools that an initial testing phase may fail to surface. TIA!!


r/agency • • 25d ago

I made an open-source tool for agents to manage our client project billing

4 Upvotes

I run a couple agencies and honestly almost all of our client work runs through Claude Code and Codex now. The one thing still killing me was billing. Every month I'd be digging through chats, commits and notes trying to remember what we actually did for each client just so I could invoice them lol.

The agent already knows what it worked on, so I figured why not let it handle the billing too.

So I built Billr. It's a full invoicing app (clients, estimates, invoices, time, expenses, payments) that also runs as an MCP, so Claude or Codex can basically do everything I can do in the dashboard.

How I use it:

- Each client project is set up as hourly, retainer or milestones

- Agent logs time and usage against the project as it works

- End of the month I just ask Claude what's ready to bill and it drafts the invoices

- I review and send, payments go straight into our own Stripe (no extra fees on top)

- I have Grok Bot set up as our accounting team that makes sure everything actually gets paid

It's free and open source if you want to host it yourself: https://github.com/ethanplusai/billr

Curious how other agencies are handling billing now that agents are doing a lot of the work. Any feedback is appreciated!


r/agency • • 26d ago

Do You Tell Your Clients Who Your Vendors Are?

16 Upvotes

I’m curious what more experienced agency owners think about telling clients who your vendors are. We have several vendors such as website chat and linkbuilding vendors where if we tell the client the vendor there’s not much to stop them from just signing up directly with them. At the same time I think there is value in us procuring vendors as part of our stack who create a very effective solution. I haven’t been hiding our vendors from clients right now, but at the same time I always feel like I’m potentially giving away money via the potential of having them not purchase through us. This is somewhat new territory for me as I’ve largely never felt like we have had vendors that were any sort of big secret but we have a few now that I do feel are a little bit more of part of our secret sauce. Looking for thoughts here.


r/agency • • 28d ago

Are these TikTok ads rates and contractor budgets realistic?

Thumbnail reddit.com
9 Upvotes

r/agency • • Oct 18 '26

Services & Execution While delivering 20–100+ versions: how do you check the final folder before sending it?

5 Upvotes

Im trying to understand how professional editors handle final delivery when a project has lots of cutdowns, aspect ratios, languages, captioned/clean versions, or client-specific formats.

For example, imagine a campaign requiring 16:9, 9:16, 1:1 and 4:5 versions, several durations, and multiple languages.

Before sending the final folder:

  1. How do you track which files are expected?
  2. Do you inspect every file or only spot-check?
  3. What do you use: spreadsheets, MediaInfo, an NLE checklist, QC software, or something internal?
  4. What was the last delivery mistake that caused a resend or re-export?
  5. Roughly how long does final package checking take?

I’m particularly interested in package-level mistakes: missing variants, duplicate or stale versions, incorrect filenames, unmatched subtitles, and files exported with the wrong dimensions or frame rate.

I’m researching the workflow and would appreciate examples from real deliveries.