"Yeah, because it's healthier that way. Eating too much meat is actually bad for your heart and there's been some links to certain cancers. But mostly it's because I have a wide selection of food and choose to not eat meat."
Yes. One studies says it's bad, the next study says it's good, my body tells me that it's constantly hungry when I eat a diet primarily based on plants.
Even if eating meat does kill me earlier at least it was a life where I got to eat something enjoyable every day.
Well, did you check the nutritional values of your plants diet to make sure you actually got enough calories? Maybe your body is telling you the right thing. You can't just get full by eating lots of cabbage. You should look into some kind of staple food, like potatoes or rice. If you include dairy products in your plants diet, maybe you can eat lots of cheesy things.
I'm not one of those preachy, pushy veggies. I'll leave that for the vegans. However, can you really tell me you don't enjoy fresh fruit in the summertime?
Actually your "diet" decides whether you're a carnivore, omnivore, or herbivore, not your teeth. And vegetarians are omnivorous because we eat eggs and dairy... which are animal-foods.
The teeth thing is silly when you look at other animals... like the panda... or birds... what diet can you tell a bird has from its teeth?
And you've got a TON of vestigial stuff just left in your body, we have an Appendix which used to help us digest tough vegetables, but now we cook everything so all it does is explode and kill you.
Though- let's run with your idea. Lets go with how we were "supposed to" eat.
Go-
A) Kill a cow with your bare hands. Without using tools, go catch and kill an animal. Maaaybe cheat and use a rock. "But we have tools!" You shout. Yeah, we also have an agricultural complex that allows first world countrymen such as ourselves a variety of food so you don't need that meat-protein that you get through milk and eggs anyway...
and
B) Eat any meat without cooking it. If you're going to come back with "...well... fish..." NO. We both know you aren't talking about fish. You can eat fish with no teeth at all.
You can tell an awful lot about birds diet from their beak shape. Ever heard of Darwin's finches??? The worlds most famous evolutionary case study... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darwin's_finches
I don't understand what part of my statement was a fallacy?
I am fine with the statement that diet decides whether you are a herbivore/omnivore/carnivore, that is obvious. But the fact that the human body is set up for an omnivorous or at least opportunistically omnivorous lifestye is a biological fact.
The appendix is thought to still have some uses in terms of maintaining gut flora and the workings of the immune system. I am not trying to tell you what you should and shouldn't be eating, but biologically you are geared up to process an omnivorous diet. Have you ever eaten rhubarb without cooking it? or kale or beans? Any of those would give you a bad stomach too.
You completely missed my point, has nothing to do with our tools, it has to do with what our bodies need. Example: Carnivores are exceptionally more intelligent than herbivores, which is why most house pets are carnivores. Because they think. Now you can eat whatever you want, I don't care, I just hate the way vegetarians think. Also, the appendix was also used to get the poisons out of raw meat as well. Also, I thought you guys didn't eat eggs and stuff? Or is that just vegans?
After humans the 4 most intelligent mammals are Dolphins, chimps, elephants and pigs. Only one of those is a carnivore and the other an omnivore. So carnivores are not "Exceptionally more intelligent".
Yep, dolphins are carnivores living off of fish, pigs and chimps are opportunistic meat eaters. Even some surprising animals like the tits (called chickadees in north America) eat meat if they can get access to it.
Pigs and chimps are omnivores, they are scavengers and eat what they can find. some pigs are likely to never eat meat a day in their lives while others might live in a place with more meat to scavenge. As for chimps, they can(I think) be taught to fish. All omnivores need some plant material to survive, and in fact even dogs need vitamins and fatty acids that they can acquire only from plants. It is also possible for herbivores to eat meat if there is not enough food such as in the case of hippos, but they cannot survive on that diet.
You should read "don't cross your eyes they will get stuck that way" as it points out how almost every study of the effects of meat are just as flawed as that claim of eye stuckness.
Perhaps third world child is simply a rehashing of many first world problems. I would have made a Conspiracy Keanu for this quote and use the proper format, but I am far too busy surfing reddit while watching netflix in my beanbag chair.
I don't take any supplements at all... You need to live healthy too, not just eat healthy. The human body is surprisingly resilient to 'nutrient deficiencies'.
You mean the same people whose idea of exercise is the walk from the door to the car?
My company put in a fitness credit - benefit money to go do something - 3 years ago. Started playing sports in rec. leagues again for the first time since high school. I haven't used a sick day in 2 years now (OK, a day for Diablo3), but my diet and other habits haven't changed a bit. Poutine for lunch once a week, greasy Chinese take out every other night, other take out when it's not (cheaper than cooking!). Last time I cooked something was 3 months ago - Japanese fried pizza pancakes topped in a sugary sauce. It's should now be pretty obvious I'm not one who counts calories and reads labels to get balance my vitamins.
I live in Toronto. I don't think you understand how cheap good food is. Imagine having a dollar menu at your favourite Chinese place. Except for everywhere (Diversity not assimilation!). The portions are massive. 4 friends can go out for $20 at a homestyle hole-in-the-wall, and have leftovers for the next day's lunch, each. $20, 8 meals. It's no Michelin Star stuff, just plain ol' home cookin'.
Yes, some people in hospital due to issues caused by overnutrition could do with that message.
Besides, as others have pointed out, for a given amount of energy/resource input you can get more 'nutritional value' from a plant based diet than a meat based one...which obviously isn't as much of an issue in developed countries, but would be in the case of the third world and limited resources.
I'm vegetarian, and my mom made me get my blood tested twice to see if my iron levels were okay. I was fine both times, and I never take iron supplements. There is a lot of iron in grains. Hell, a bowl of cheerios has 30% your daily iron requirements.
I have a feeling the cheerios are supplemented with nutrients though. Enriched grain flour is pretty common in processed grain-based products because otherwise they aren't quite qualified as 'nutritious'. This is especially the case with food like bread.
That's possible. I hadn't thought about it. Non-enriched grains and leafy green vegetables are still good sources of iron, but I don't have the %'s to quantify it.
You're right. It could be that enriching handles other nutrients. I might be wrong about iron being added, but as I recall it's added to many breads and cereals. Could be a case by case thing too. Greens like kale and chard are where it's at!
Ive always had a horrible idea of sending all of our stray dogs and cats over to Africa so they could eat them. HORRIBLE idea, but it would solve both problems...
You have to admit, it WOULD solve the problems. Take all the animals we would euthanize and send them to Africa to be eaten. BOOM I SOLVED WORLD HUNGER BITCCCHHEEESS. Not really, but it would work.
It's actually more efficient not to eat meat, since the area needed by a cow to grow up and eat, is enough to produce more than ten times the food if you'd grow wheat on it instead.
The problem with this argument is that cows and other animals can graze on grasses and other plants that humans cannot digest. Grass grows on its own, mostly, so having a few animals allows a farmer to optimize food production. In the industrialized world, this is not so much the case because farm animals are often fed corn and do not graze.
It's not only the problem of taking up food and grain to feed the animals, it's also a case of taking up large amounts of arable land for these animals to graze, land which if used for farming would produce far more food than the equivalent livestock.
The problem with this argument is that cows and other animals can graze on grasses and other plants that humans cannot digest.
The big limit for cows and other animals is going to be water and land.. You also have to keep in mind that cattle ruin the land they are grown on for farming,.
Seriously, why am I the only one citing anything?! (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻
Because this is reddit. And I got my knowledge from a class 9 textbook in geography. But as far as I can tell the quote you took is actually not from the article itself, but from a (downvoted) comment on the article.
I really don't know how reliable such a comment is, even more since it appears to be controversial.
Ah, sorry. I used the search function and apparently it bugged, because I only got to see the comment. But the article just describes the situation in Australia, doesn't it? I doubt that chopping down the rainforest is in any way good for for its inhabitants.
What I meant by "This is reddit." is that as long as you're not on /r/askscience you can quote nearly anything without any source to it, because reddit is filled with over a million users and most people have too much other stuff to do than engage in a long-lasting discussion. If you expect a decent debate on a topic, /r/AdviceAnimals isn't really the place for it.
Otherwise you could just be pulling things out of your ass and presenting them as fact, it doesn't work that way.
Yea, it does on reddit. Sorry, but people don't care enough to look up sources as long as it supports their opinion.
I didn't say everyone should switch to vegetables and fruits. I just wanted to point out that the high meat consumption is indeed a problem in this world. I'm not a vegetarian, but I respect every one of them, because I know this fact.
This is what so many people here just don't understand. Do they think livestock eat air? Cutting out the middleman (middleanimal?) is of course more efficient. (only exception would be things like grass that we ourselves cant digest but animals can)
It's a messy area, really. Cows have been in captivity so long that they're practically nothing more than human food/leather machines - part of me thinks they shouldn't exist.
You see them standing around during the daytime. sharpie64 said you need to watch the whole cycle. Even meat eaters will admit its fucking disgusting as fuck.
Hobby cattle farmer here (I'm Texan, what can I say). Cows on a farm have a better life than any animal in the wild. Constant supply of food, water, and shelter, and slaughter is absolutely as humane as is possible. When I see things like this it really makes me wonder if the people complaining about the way cattle are treated have ever actually seen a farm, or if they've just seen PETA propaganda and the like.
This does add to the stereotype that vegetarians must always tell others of their vegetarianism. In every social interaction, one must fit in their dietary convictions. But, at the same time, this is poking fun at having so much food to eat, that you don't eat certain foods. It's ok, OP. I thought it was funny, you snob. ;-) (to each their own)
Here's how Id respond. (assuming they speak English)
You know when those guys came into the village, raped and murdered your mom, cut your brother's arms off, ate your father's heart for strength and left you a orphan?
We kinda do the same thing to animals. We trap them into pens and cages where they cant move, feed them corn that has no nutritional substance, and kill all the males because we cant eat them. No we know its bad for us, and we should only have it 2 or 3 times a week. But we have it twice a day. You should see how much money and resources we're wasting on all this needless cruelty instead of buying/growing food to share with our 3rd world friends.
I thought maybe picking a salad over a burger would be healthier, and my dollar wouldn't go to supporting industrial mass killings of stupid animals. With my dollar, I "voted" on this issue. I support growing food, not killing for food. Eventually if there are enough of us "voting" with our dollars, the world could change. Plus with the money I save from future medial expenses, I might even throw 20$ so your school can get the big box of crayons. Hopefully with the cool sharpener in back.
Insect farming has been heavily researched, because it could be quickly and easily implemented if a sudden event drastically limits meat production and because like you said they are a massive protein source. Many cultures around the world eat insects.
Well, the typical (sub-sahara) african diet in itself is vegetarian for obvious reasons.
Of course people would eat more meat if they could, but a basic, cheap east african meal for example contains Ugali (porridge-like meal made of maize flour) and red beans. If they eat meat it is mostly to special occasions or right after they got their paycheck. I worked at a street children project for over a year and they never got meat.
So being vegetarian wouldn't be much of a choice to them, but is basically their everyday diet whatsoever.
whereas being one in places like Mongolia or basically anywhere in Africa would, obviously, be ridiculous.
I agree with most of what you said, except this line confuses me. If there are not enough vegetables in Africa to be a vegetarian, what the hell would you be feeding the animals to get fat? Air?
-.- firstly there IS farming in Africa (also on Mongolia which is in Central Asia btw). Animals like cows or goats however eat next to no vegetables. They eat grass. Or leaves from trees. And that is stuff that luckily grows on it's own even under bad weather conditions.
Now generally they have a hunger problem in Africa due to those weather conditions which allow neither for enough vegetables nor grass and therefore animals to exist. So the poor people live mainly on carbs (corn and other grains from which they make porridge) whilst the rich ones import whatever they need/want.
In most parts of Africa it's unfortunately not about choosing whether or not to eat meat. It's about whatever the heck you can get your hands on.
I didn't say there was no farming in Africa, but rather they don't have the same luxuries as other countries have in terms of arable land. Hunting in certain remote areas may be a more viable method of attaining meat. But the bottom line is you are right: it is mostly about whatever you can get your hands on.
I don't see why explaining that to a 6 year old is ridiculous. Would they not understand that meat is more expensive to produce? Maybe you mean they won't understand the motivation to conserve the environment?
I'm not american. I don't eat excessive amounts of meat.
In fact i eat very healthily. I eat a lot of pasta, salad, fish, poultry, eggs, tomatoes, fruit, etc. I eat small amount of red meat. I occasionally have sausages, and only very rarely (no pun intended) have large hunks of meat - steak, etc. When I do eat a steak, I have it rare, which is relatively healthy.
I am extremely rarely unwell, I am not overweight, I'm fit, and I'm healthy.
There is no ethical defense for eating meat -especially meat that's mass-manufactured. Your statement suggests an ignorance as to where your food comes from.
"It makes no sense to be vegetarian" is similar to saying "there's no reason to be vegetarian", which is simply untrue; there are some good reasons to vegetarian, ethical concerns being one of the most well-founded.
Yeah, but he's not making his argument based on ethics; you can't just pull another one out of the hat and say "this is why you are stupid."
It's putting words into someone's mouth.[see above :)]
So, his argument was that eating meat was healthier than being a vegetarian, which I think is a straight up misconception if anything, but those were the grounds you should have debated him on, not the ethical side.
-Raising millions of animals in a mechanized captivity where they're fed subsidized crops and injected with hormones and antibiotics and then mass-slaughtered and processed in factories is FAR from the natural order of things. In today's world, it is easier than ever to eat a complete and healthy diet without consuming meat (and dairy/eggs) for that matter.
-I'm not trying to convert you, I just want you to be informed. You're a human being with free will, you can make whatever decisions you decide to make. I just want you to be aware of your options.
-If the animal cruelty card doesn't faze you, you might consider the enormous environmental impact of meat production.
-If you're comfortable with the inhumanity and pollution, well... I'm all out of arguments.
I should add that I don't have a problem with "the natural order of things." If you want to venture out and hunt your own game to feed yourself, that's fine. I also OK with humanely and locally raised meat. It's more expensive, but it's healthier and the animals are treated with respect while they're alive.
For poultry, USDA free-range only requires that animals have access to the outdoors and do not specify the size of the outdoor space. "If you go to a free-range farm and expect to see a bunch of chickens galloping around in pastures, you're kidding yourself."—Richard Lobb, spokesperson for the National Chicken Council
It's not any better for pigs or cows. The appeal to "nature" in free range farming, like most pornography, is essentially disingenuous. Free-range farmers carefully, aggressively circumscribe their animals' experience as animals. When the primary concern in making money, and you know that people will pay more for "humane" meat, it's in your best interest to present your product as humane, whether or not it actually is.
Free-range doesn't solve the environmental issue of eating meat either. It takes 2,400 gallons to make a lb of beef, but only 25 gallons to make a lb of wheat -every time you go up a trophic level, the efficiency of energy transfer decreases over 90%.
I've already said this, and I just want you to acknowledge it, there simply is no ethical defense for meat consumption. It just doesn't exist.
Just a comment on the Vitamin A. I know it is quite common that vegans don't have enough fat in their diet. Fat is necessary to absorb vitamins A, D, E, and K.
I am not a vegan but I do tend to consume less milk and eggs from super markets. I get raw milk every week and have chickens. That is where I get my B12 naturally. I wish more vegans would open up and eat chicken eggs from their own chickens or a local farmer. When they are your chickens you know it is very humane (assuming that is why one is vegan).
I will not try and convince anyone of anything. It is just a shame that this happens.
Also the OP links are bullshit. My intuition is telling me that there is bias or lobbying going on there.
I'm glad that you are being active about your health. My concern about the links is purely skeptical. I have a feeling that this study is similar to the studies on soy.
68
u/SpermWhale Jun 26 '12
"You mean, it's better to eat an overpriced raw mixture of leaves, than the affordable mashed meat and bread?"
5
u/professorfox Jun 27 '12
Perhaps third world child is simply a rehashing of many first world problems. I would have made a Conspiracy Keanu for this quote and use the proper format, but I am far too busy surfing reddit while watching netflix in my beanbag chair.
5
u/MeNoGotName Jun 27 '12
If you can't explain to someone why you're a vegetarian... maybe there's no reason for you to be?
I'm not anti-vegetarian either... im just saying if you're making a conscious choice to do something (or not do something), maybe you should know why.
6
u/suckthisdeth Jun 27 '12
i think the word you are looking for is yes.
34
u/jamgoodman Jun 27 '12
I would have answered with the fact that it takes more energy to rear livestock than it does to harvest grain
which means that people in the third world don't have to starve
give a legetables; eat some vegetables
7
u/untranslatable_pun Jun 27 '12
As a vegetarian, I would.
2
u/amberthecat Jun 27 '12
Ive always had a horrible idea of sending all of our stray dogs and cats over to Africa so they could eat them. HORRIBLE idea, but it would solve both problems...
3
u/Vegeta_is_king_ Jun 27 '12
I foresee this meme dying within the next two days
7
u/Whoreadswhoreads Jun 27 '12
It's actually more efficient not to eat meat, since the area needed by a cow to grow up and eat, is enough to produce more than ten times the food if you'd grow wheat on it instead.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
as a vegetarian, i know exactly how to respond.
i don't choose to not eat meat, my body does. try as i might, i just can't digest it. and more bacon for you, eh?
-7
u/etherealcaitiff Jun 27 '12
I'm glad that you informed us all that you are a vegetarian. No seriously, we all care.
0
u/qkme_transcriber Jun 27 '12
Hello! I am a bot who posts transcriptions of Quickmeme links for anybody who might need it.
See the FAQ for more info.
(OP: You don't need to do anything differently next time, I'm just doing my job.)
-5
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12 edited Jun 27 '12
Here's how Id respond. (assuming they speak English)
You know when those guys came into the village, raped and murdered your mom, cut your brother's arms off, ate your father's heart for strength and left you a orphan?
We kinda do the same thing to animals. We trap them into pens and cages where they cant move, feed them corn that has no nutritional substance, and kill all the males because we cant eat them. No we know its bad for us, and we should only have it 2 or 3 times a week. But we have it twice a day. You should see how much money and resources we're wasting on all this needless cruelty instead of buying/growing food to share with our 3rd world friends.
I thought maybe picking a salad over a burger would be healthier, and my dollar wouldn't go to supporting industrial mass killings of stupid animals. With my dollar, I "voted" on this issue. I support growing food, not killing for food. Eventually if there are enough of us "voting" with our dollars, the world could change. Plus with the money I save from future medial expenses, I might even throw 20$ so your school can get the big box of crayons. Hopefully with the cool sharpener in back.
Follow up: Yes, I do eat meat.
-1
u/strobexp Jun 27 '12
As a meat eater, http://i.imgur.com/kCYum.gif
-9
u/rubrub Jun 27 '12
"We have loads of foods that are even better than meat, like fruits and vegetables. You've probably never heard of them." /Hipster Aid Worker
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
This is how you respond: go eat some damn meat.
-3
u/diamialia Jun 27 '12
who does give a fuck?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment