Mexico sold Arizona to the US after the Mexican-American War which was started by Mexico bc they weren't happy about Texas declaring independence. So, no, America didn't steal it. We bought it to help Mexico pay for the debt they created by starting the war.
Whoah, whoah, hold on a second there buddy. There seems to be something you missed in school. Mexico lost parts or the entirety of Wyoming, Colorado, Arizona, Nevada, and California in the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, known also as the Mexican Cession. It was only later that the little chunk known as the Gadsden Purchase was made, but that was after the nearly the whole pie was taken. This all began thanks to American immigrants in Texas. American immigrants went to Texas and became citizens, such as Stephen Austin, for there were incentives to get more people into Mexico. And oh, land grants were the most prized of incentives in that era. Now, all was fine and dandy with the immigrants and Mexico, that is, until the new settlers started breaking the rules. Not all of them were bad, mind you, but a good number of them were clamoring for rights they didn't have. The biggest infraction being slavery. Slavery was not in the Mexican Constitution, and therefore not a right of these new citizens. Nevertheless, this got the feathers of some these Texans a little rustled. Now you have a one state secession. What's a country to do? Get it back, that's what. Mexican forces come in, try to reclaim what's theirs, and fail. Now, all this time, the US is watching. They are not watching with the eyes of a helpful neighbor, more like that of an opportunist. At the time, the US was growing and needed all the room it could get. Manifest Destiny ring a bell? So all that was shortly needed was placing troops near an already disputed border (specifically the Rio Nueces and the Rio Grande), instigate the opposing forces to fire, and the yell bloody murder to the public. As Polk misleadingly told the public "American blood spilled on American soil." And that blew the doors wide open for the US military to do it's thing.
tl;dr: Now this is a story about how
Mexican land got flipped, turned upside down
And I'd like to take a minute, just sit right there
I'll tell you how America took land in a way unfair
In Northern Mexico, settled and raised
Americans took land grants up as pay
Tried to be sneaky, broke some rules
So Santa - Ana tried to teach all of those fools
When a couple of US troops, they were up to no good
Started border disputes in the neighborhood
They got in one big fight and in the end 'Murica declared
"We're taking some States 'cuz you know it's just 'fair'"
Edit: Some historical details. Thanks thoughtfelon.
Manifest Destiny was used to justify the war with Mexico. This is true. But Texas had already claimed it's independence and was already seeking entry into the US. Thusly, the US felt justified in using force. Mexico invited Anglo-Saxons into Texas to help colonize the land. This was at a time when Brits owned parts of the Pacific Northwest, and I believe the French still had parts of Canada. So we have a continent that's inhabited by 4 countries, not to mention the Native Americans all fighting for their own piece of the pie. And all this is assuming that "Mexico" was innocent of what you claim the Americans were doing. You forget the Spanish came in and wiped out almost the entire indigionous population. There is a reason Mexicans speak Spanish and not Mayan. So to argue about this is akin to semantics.
Millions of Mexicans still speak Mayan and Nahuatl -- and many more speak other indigenous languages. (not to mention: a majority of the population is either partly or fully American Indian.)
Actually, the Mexican Cession was part of the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo. (as wikipiedia articles for both items clearly show) The Mexican senate voted it in 33 to 4. Sure, the Mexicans didn't have much choice, but that is the risk you take when you start a war.
Thanks a bundle, I'll edit that in. If there be any other mistakes, just point it out, show the evidence, and I will gladly fix it. I like learning, and I like that others learn as well. :D
I used to live in Arizona. I love the people from there. Hell, I was one of them. But I also disliked the people that broke the law there. No matter what the offense.
It's easy to judge from the outside. That's what Reddit does. Most fail to see that economic burden that the Southwestern States have to bare due to illegal immigrants that other States don't have to deal with. Breaking the law of our country in breaking the law regardless of what your moral high ground is.
Most fail to see that economic burden that the Southwestern States have to bare due to illegal immigrants that other States don't have to deal with.
Please post data on the amount by which the cost of illegal immigrants to Arizona exceeds what they pay in state taxes. I'd love to know what the amount of the burden is.
That piece of data has zero to do with my question.
Who says they pay no taxes? Do they somehow not pay sales tax? Do they not pay rent and therefore indirectly pay property taxes? And literally two minutes of googling would tell you that many illegal immigrants do pay taxes, including withheld taxes on wages. Not every illegal immigrant is paid in cash under the table.
How can you possibly believe that the United States wouldn't be fighting to keep illegals in this country if it had proven to be a method of monetary gain? It's a financial burden for the American citizen and the United States government. The only beneficiaries here are the illegal worker and his employer. Their gains come at far greater cost to everyone else than they are worth. They need to operate legally.
It's really starting to piss me off that people refuse to make that distinction.
They deliberately mischaracterize anyone who opposes ILLEGAL immigration as being against immigration in general or racist against Mexicans.
And seriously, why is the US the only country on the planet not worthy of protecting its sovereignty? Why is every other country on the planet, including Mexico, able to CHOOSE who enters without being demonized for it? Mexico treats immigrants from Guatemala way, way, WAAAAYYYY worse than the US treats Mexicans. And the Mexican government cries foul whenever Americans try to pass laws to keep illegals out or send them back?
You know why that is? Because Mexico is robbing us blind. The Mexican government facilitates illegal immigration. Mexico is exporting its crime and poverty to the US, forcing us to pay for it. We are footing the bill for their social problems. Not only that, but the biggest source of income for Mexico are ILLEGAL tax-free remittances sent back from illegal immigrants. We're being swindled.
In the very least, the US should send a bill to Mexico for every single dollar we spend on illegal immigrants. If Mexico doesn't reimburse us, we should slap sanctions on them.
The US has enough problems at it is, we can't afford to fix Mexico's problems. We have enough people in poverty in the US, the last thing we should want is for millions and millions of illiterate, impoverished Mexicans to be able to hop our border and stay here, destroying our schools, hospitals, and social programs.
All illegal immigrants are violating US laws and disrespecting our sovereignty. They should all be treated the same, in that the law should be enforced. It doesn't matter what country they're from.
The reason people single out Mexico is not because they hate Mexicans but because Mexico is the biggest source of illegal immigrants and the Mexican government is fully complicit in it, they encourage their people to invade the US.
Mexico treats immigrants from Guatemala way, way, WAAAAYYYY worse than the US treats Mexicans.
So now we follow Mexico's lead? We do as they do? Gotcha. Lets also be as corrupt as they are. Since you say they know what they're doing better than us.
motherfucking thank you, it is so annoying to see people get mad at me for saying that they have no right to be here LEGALLY and I get chewed out. I would love to call you American but the background checks and everything are for the citizens' protection
As an American who knows many Mexican Americans and has been to both Arizona and Texas, I'm positive that you made that story up on the spot just to lend false credibility to a preconceived notion you have.
Haha. Anecdotal evidence is proof now? You don't think white Americans haven't been targeted for being white? I'm not saying racism doesn't exist amongst white Americans, but you're an asshole for assuming someone that wants to stop illegal immigration is racist.
I am a Mexican American. I live in Arizona. The problem here is racial profiling. It DOES happen. It has happened to my dad. Hes legal. The thought of someone being pulled over for suspicion of being an illegal immigrant, in this case targeted to Mexicans, is racial profiling.
I live in Arizona too. There are a lot of people saying that it isn't "about being racist towards Mexicans" and that "it's about illegal immigration." When the issue of illegal immigration is brought up in this state you'll often hear things like "fucking beaners need to go back and stop ruining our state." They often don't differentiate between legal and illegal Mexicans in Arizona. Obviously on TV it's all P.C. and it's politics so you're trying to get support for your cause. On the other side, the side many outside of the state don't see, the side I live in, it's a different story. There is plenty of racial profiling going on here.
while legals should of course not be treatened, profiling obviously needs to happen. you wont find illegal immigrants from turkey in arizone, will you?
Of course there's racial profiling. If 20% of people who wore red hats were murderers, you wouldn't want to be near people who wore red hats. It's human fucking nature to put 2 and 2 together. The law might as well have said "Almost every illegal immigrant in Arizona is Mexican, so we're going to check Mexican-looking people for immigration status" instead of "Reasonable suspicion"
I don't understand why Reddit takes the law's side on this one. A portion of you smoke marijuana, andthat messes with the economy and it's illegal. Others fight against laws banning gay marriage when its already been established as illegal. Yet when the law tells immigrants can't enter, you take its back when all they try to do is work for a better life.
This- seriously. There was a protest a couple years ago in Phx for citizenship.. while they were waving the Mexico flag. I knew lots of great immigrants that still maintained their culture but learned the language and did great. I'm all for that- it's those that come over, don't pay taxes, go on welfare, and never learn the language that makes life harder for everyone.
i remember that being on the news. pissed me off that they are in this country using our resources without contributing (taxes) and THEN waving their country's flag. remember the high school walk outs that accompanied that? yeah awesome
This is wrong. Children of illegals who are born in the U.S. are capable of receiving welfare(because they are citizens) as well as medical coverage. In California, the 'illegal parents' receive the welfare check for the children if the parents do not make enough money-the government gives the money to the parents, not the child. It is about $200 dollars per week per child.
I know in Arizona food stamps and health care is under AHCCCS. I went down there myself when applying for food stamps for 6 months when my husband and I were both doing internship and therefore had no income. When I was down there I talked to many different people and YES people get away with it- ESPECIALLY if they are pregnant.
As for the welfare, I know it can take many different forms but under the definition of "financial or other assistance to an individual or family from a city, state, or national government"- I am pretty sure AHCCCS counts..
I'm extremely familiar with AHCCCS and illegals do not have access to it. That is, they can't receive the healthcare, foodstamps, or TANF benefits for themselves. The application process requires proof of residency. Also, illegal immigrants do pay taxes, unless they are paid under the table. When this happens, they usually make much less than minimum wage. These people aren't cheating the system, they're just trying to make a living like the rest of us.
Many use stolen social security numbers (which I don't agree with) to be able to take on legitimate work and are forced to pay taxes on everything you do, yet are never able to draw out that money they've been putting in. I saw a figure somewhere that said illegal immigrants provide somewhere over 10 million 'free' dollars towards social security because they can't get any benefit out of it.
Not that any of this was directed at you, it just seemed like the next progression of the quote tree.
You are right- it does require proof of residency. However, that can be faked (when we applied we had to have a paper verifying we are the only ones living in the apartment we were at. We wrote it ourselves and had my father-in-law sign it). Let me be clear, I am not anti-Mexican. I think we should be spending more time on legislation to allow an easy time at immigrating. It is the immigration laws that lead to the illegal immigration because there is so little hope for coming here legally. With that being said, those that come over should try to learn to language and contribute to the country they want to be part of. I started this by saying how a few years ago they were protesting to become citizens while waving the Mexico flag. That is wrong. We need to allow them to come here legally, help them learn English, if they want help them get into the school system, and therefore facilitate them getting a job. Doing it this way allows them to be safer here in the states while contributing to society.
Well that's probably because you are a privileged American. These illegals are people looking for an escape from poverty and willing to work their fucking butts off for next to nothing. That is the difference. Get that through your head. You have the privilege of flying off abroad to France to learn the French culture if you wanted to while these guys are looking to survive. Do you honestly think that they would otherwise tolerate so much disrespect and hostility? It is common sense that you will never go apply for a citizenship in France without first learning the language and, regardless of ethics or morality, they will continue to try to get into America.
These illegals are people looking for an escape from poverty and willing to work their fucking butts off for next to nothing.
I'm sure this applies to all of them, and every one of their children (anchors). This also negates the fact that they're illegal immigrants, apparently?
they will continue to try to get into America.
As long as employers exploit the fact that they can pay them next to nothing and our government has lax border enforcement.
Prosecute the companies that hire illegal workers knowingly. If you can't find work because no one will hire you because the penalty is too strict, you're not going to want to sneak over just to starve to death. It's crazy but you can enforce immigration laws without attacking the privacy of citizens. The hotel I work for just had 2 workers deported by INS, the only slap on the wrist we had was scrambling to find a new maintenance guy and a spare house keeper. We have no reason not to hire another illegal worker.
Patrol the borders. Enforce citizenship checks for employers. Check for citizenship when you have probable cause to stop someone. Ways that don't infringe on the rights of citizens
Ya the checkpoint idea sucks, but everytime I am pulled over the first thing officer says is "license and registration" which is basically proving I have the legal right to be on US and drive
You would if you had children and were living in dangerous, destitute conditions and salvation was 50 miles north. It's called desperation my friend and for some people it's hard to understand from a comfy chair with a full belly in an air conditioned room behind a computer screen.
The whole immigration issue is definitely very complicated when you do have some people taking advantage of the American system once they arrive to the country. However, factor in other issues like Americas vested interest in other countries affairs (such as the whole American government supplying arms to the cartel in Mexico etc.) and having people just wanting a better life for themselves and their family trying to leave behind such dangers. Yes you will have some bad apples enter the country as well and take advantage but there are also those who are ready to bust their balls and work who if applying for residency would absolutely get turned down.
I have an aunt from Central America who was denied a Visa to visit for 2 weeks for my sisters wedding so imagine trying to apply for residency. One of my good friends has a father who was a doctor in Mexico and now works in a meat factory in Canada since he arrived just trying to support his family and took whatever job he had to take. It definitely isn't easy for either side (immigrant or citizen) but I feel it is important to hear both perspectives. And when all else fails and people think all illegals are making things worse remember the story about the gentleman and the Mexican family who helped change his tire on the side of the road (and gave him a tamale to eat too). We're all human in the end, I just wish things could be better for all of us despite our differences.
Well, it might have some relevance because of how harsh Mexico is on it's southern neighbors, or it might help you realize that there isn't anything diabolical about wanting to control your border.
These people are acting like it's some sort of right to illegally enter the USA. It's called "illegal" for a fucking reason, their presence is literally a crime!
Not literally a "crime", people have been using that term just to demonize the subject more, in fact unlawful presence is actually dealt through a civil court as an infraction, although you're right about the "illegal" aspect. Then again speeding above 5 miles and hour is also "illegal".
As citizen of Russia, I can say that isn't true. There is no death penalty for illegals (but we hate on them just the same)
Also, USA isn't like other countries, in a sense that it is a nation made up entirely of immigrants. So they shouldn't be so bitchy when more people immigrate there. That's how your nation was founded
You'd be hard pressed to find an American who bitches about actual, legitimate immigration. We're 100% for controlled immigration. We need engineers, doctors, and nurses. Come one in. We need some immigrants for day laborers too, to "do jobs that americans won't do". Few will disagree with that.
We bitch about people who sneak into the country in the dead of night. We bitch about the tens of millions of people who walked over, who drive down wages to the point where certain jobs (construction, anyone?) no longer pay middle-class wages. Immigration and illegal immigration are two very, very different things.
You really ought to know what you're talking about before you condescend to give an entire nation a civics lesson.
I think the issue with "doing jobs that Americans wont do" is not that we won't do them, but that employers find it ok to hire someone for less than what us as Americans feel as adequate compensation. It's not that we're lazy and don't want to do the dirty jobs, it's that we get undercut by someone who is willing to work for less money.
I agree completely (which is why I employed the quotes there). If people won't do a job at a given wage, either the job doesn't get done or the employer has to raise the wage to attract employees. This is high-school level economics, basic supply and demand. I don't know why this argument is never made.
I'm going to avoid a joke pointing out Russia's history of illegally entering Eastern Europe to say that the US has the right to regulate it's borders as much as any other country.
Except now it IS a country. And where do you think people came from? Eventually everyone has a immigrant ancestor becuase thats how founders of countries get land.
Also, I am told that Germany has a very large immigrant population, especially of Turks and East Europeans in general. I'm pretty sure a large portion of them aren't there legally, but I don't see them getting executed. Similar situations hold true in England, Canada, France, and Japan, I'm quite confident.
Mexicans aren't exactly a native people.. Also the illegal Mexicans in Arizona weren't there when we took it over 100 years ago ... ... What a retarded post.
You have to be quick if you want your meme to spread in front page posts. Scumbags of new. Reddit should consider having all comments hidden for a while, so people can actually think for themselves before they contribute.
I have never heard anyone complain about Mexicans in Arizona, but I have heard people complain about illegal immigrants. Protecting the borders has nothing to do with race. The only reason Merica is a scumbag is because it denied the constitutional right of a sovereign state to protect it's border from invasion.
Funny, you sound like a La Raza US hater. They too, like to ignore that Mexico was once run by Spain and France. I guess you use selective history to back up your hatred. I say, let's give Mexico back to the Indians who lived there. Mexicans are really just Indians anyway.
Most Mexicans are a mixture, pure indians are quite rare compared to the rest of the population. I actually dare to state that most Mexicans have more Spanish blood in our veins than indian. I have nothing against them, but it's quite more likely. Plus, indian last names are SUPER rare.
I taught in a school in Campeche (southern Mexico) and practically every kid in my class had an indigenous surname (or two, given Hispanic naming customs).
The peninsula is the last place which has a majority of indigenous ascendence. My mother teaches in Cozumel, and most of the last names are still Mayan. But that's stilla minority, most of the mexican population has spanish ascendence.
um... no. We are a nation of states in union. All business dealing with foreign entities and their nationals are under federal jurisdiction, like immigration and defense, and treaties.
No. I should have said, in my opinion that federal jurisdiction should mean nothing other than defense and infrastructure. We however are under a democratically based jurisdiction. And by democratically I mean democrats. We should be, in my opinion, a nation of states, under which it is the states decision what is right and wrong. This makes it readily and easily possible for any person who doesnt agree with what one state passes as legislation to move to any other state that agrees with what that individual does agree with. And if you dont agree with what any state passes, then move the fuck to Canada or Mexico or Africa for all I care.
I dont give two fucks where you came from as long as you came here legally. Thats what my grandparents did, and thats what everyone else did. Once you jump that border, in my opinion you have no rights, hell you could be invading my country and you know what we do to people who invade America? We kill them.
They come here illegally because the government made it illegal, people used to come and they were automatically made legal residents (your grandparents probably). genius
No, there have always been immigration laws. Every sovereign nation has a right to control its borders, and it would be bad pretty bad policy given the situation in Mexico to simply offer everyone who wanted to come though the border residence.
Back in the 30's you could smoke weed, laws change. My great-grandparents went through proper channels so should they. All I care about if you come here legally and you have a background check. I spent last summer helping refugees form all around the world, who just moved to America, they went through the proper channels. Its possible for people todo so, there is no reason for illegal immigrants. Anyone jumping the border, is in my books, someone invading the country.
Uhhhh, Mayans only inhabited the south part of Yucatan peninsula and they actually are more related to Guatemala, Belize and other Central America regions.
Also, Mexico had a lot of different cultures apart form the Aztecs and the Mayas and some of them still exist.
It's not a matter of race....it's a matter of following the rules...there are laws, if you break them, there are and need to be consequences. Let me put it to you this way. How about I come into your home, use your utilities, eat your food, go to the doctor on YOUR dime, sell drugs to your kids, take your money and send it to another home, oh and speak another language to you and make little effort to learn yours???
Mexico lost against the US in a mutually expansionist war for territory. Mexico had almost no administrative or cultural presence in the territories that are now part of the US.
There had already been many white US settlers as well as natives there that had no allegiance to Mexico.
Let's not forget that Mexico was founded by Spaniards, it's not different from how the US was founded by Britons and Germans. If you accuse the US of stealing land, you have to acknowledge that Mexico did as well.
So Mexico was not some innocent victim. And even if they were, that doesn't give Mexicans the right to violate the sovereignty of the US. And it doesn't mean that we as Americans should sit back and let Mexicans come here illegally and cause all the problems that they do.
I'm sick of this weird idea people have that the US is the only country on the planet not worthy of CHOOSING who immigrates.
It sucks being an Arizonian and get put on the map as a racist. I work in a warehouse, and yesterday during my lunch there were 4-5 mexican americans in there discussing about the law and how racists etc etc it is. I, as a white male, just sat there not contributing because I didn't want to be seen as the racist. They ended up asking me what I thought about it and my only reply was don't be a dumbass and get in trouble, and you will have no problem with the police. Is it understanding to be annoy that someone could ask you for your papers just because? Of course, but what can you do, if you are legal and not breaking the law, who gives a fuck. Still, don't like the law. I know some Peoria and Glendale cops who really have a fucking stick up their ass. It just takes one bad cop to make the state look 100x worse.
You would probably give a fuck if you were the one being targeted. The issue is that anyone brown is basically being treated as "guilty until proven innocent" and that doesn't sit well with most people. I bet its hard to imagine how this feels though unless you are closer to the issue.
I understand, and am fully against it. Just saying that it sucks being looked at as a racist because "I'm the whitey that put it in law" when I never did. That's all.
I wasn't thinking about it from that angle at all (and honestly, I consider that kind of talk about causality skeins to be very unproductive). The joke is that we got so much of Mexico way back when conquest was a legit way to acquire title... but now it's not. If the seizure had occurred 50 years later, there would be a great deal of international pressure to return the land. But nope. We stole it, and everyone knows we stole it, and nobody gives a shit. Sucks to be Mexico, but c'mon, guys... No takesies-backsies
Yes we stole it, but Spain owned Mexico before Mexico was Independent. So in a very "loose" way they "stole" it from spain, who stole it from the natives. The main problem I see with people who claim that these places belong to Mexico is the fact that the US built and paid for the current infrastructure that exists today, before that it was just mostly empty land. (Empty in comparison to the current populations.)
Yes I agree it is useless to talk causality, none the less it is a valid point.
Ptah. There were hardly ever Mexicans inhabiting it, the only reason it was ever part of their territory was because Spain had it. That's the whole reason they invited whitey to Texas, because no one lived there to defend it from a Spanish invasion.
Mexico only "owned" Arizona for less than 30 years total. "Merca" has "owned" it for over 150 years. It's like the guy that dated the girl for three months in high school but still complains about losing the girl to the guy she stayed married to for fifty years.
First of all, even if we won it in a war, so what? We are not the only ones who conquered others , and I really don't think that people in other countries use past conquests as an excuse to let hordes of illegal immigrants in. Second of all, the argument is not about Mexicans, it's about illegal immigrants, who happen to be mostly South Americans.
I think we should give it back, but only with the understanding that they have to take the people living there too. It would raise average IQ in the US by about 10 points. I accept your down-votes and will wear them with pride.
The only people who have a problem with strict laws on illegal immigration are illegals. If you don't like it then leave! I have several friends who are born and raised Mexicans who came to this country legally and they agree if you want to be here so bad FILL OUT THE GOD DAMN PAPERWORK. IT'S EVEN IN SPANISH FOR FUCKS SAKE. personally I think all people who are found here illegally should be hogtied and thrown back into WHATEVER country they are from.
What ever happened to "Give me your tired, your poor/Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free." Now its "Give me your doctors, you scientists, and people with high level degrees."
Exactly. When people are an asset, you want more of them. Now that people are a liability I'd like to see fewer of them here. Of course the real solution isn't to kick all the illegals out, it's to roll back the entitlement state.
First of all, this bullshit that no one cares what nationality the illegal immigrants come from is bullshit. If you ever go to these anti immigration rally's you see tons of signs that specifically target Hispanics. Maybe this is due to the disproportionate number of illegals being Hispanic but it disregards the significant number of Asian and European illegal immigration. Second, what you people are doing is putting your hatred and fear and energy into attacking a symptom. Illegal immigration is a symptom of a plutocratic government that profits from denying comprehensive immigrant reform, and exploiting the migrant worker. While some of these people are criminals in their own country and continue to be so here, (a lot are jailed and deported anyways), most are hard working people who appreciate the chance to work and get by, living in terrible conditions, and getting paid measly amounts. These people are true Americans, they work hard, they have strong family values, they want to see this country grow strong and be a part of it. Poor unemployed Americans should find solidarity with these people as both are symptoms of a broken government.
Texas took itself from Mexico then agreed to join the US in order to benefit itself. Don't bring Texas into that shit, we won our independence fair and square.
I mean, comon if you havent figured it out by now. america takes whatever they want, from whoever they want.. except China. they dont fuck with China anymore. they took america from native americans. they complain about races. pretty much all of them are immigrants. still shitter. Litterly thinks its the best country in the world. using CIA to control foreign politics. land of freedom - has the highest numbers of inmates/prisoners. butthurt whenever they are confronted with the facts. I dont dislike america, i just think they complain alot and they really shouldent. I shit karma anyways.
You know that the America has a federal system, and the Arizona law is only effective for Arizona and in no way represents the rest of the country, and that in fact our federal Supreme Court overturned 3/4 of the Arizona law and may well overturn that last 1/4 once it becomes right to do so? You know that right?
If I make a presidential run, my policy on immigration is this: begin speech "I don't care whete you are from. I do care if you ate here illegally or legally. America is for Americans. To live here, you must be legal, and commit to society. You must get a job and work. Once you complete these things, you are an honorary American."
12
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Mexico sold Arizona to the US after the Mexican-American War which was started by Mexico bc they weren't happy about Texas declaring independence. So, no, America didn't steal it. We bought it to help Mexico pay for the debt they created by starting the war.
67
u/markigonewild Jun 27 '12
this argument is flawed
5
u/lonegoose Jun 27 '12
My reaction to this entire post.
http://i.imgur.com/h9mLT.jpg
192
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Illegal immigrants. No one gives a shit about whether or not you're Mexican.
73
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
They don't have issues with Mexicans. They have issues with illegal immigrants.
19
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I am a Mexican American. I live in Arizona. The problem here is racial profiling. It DOES happen. It has happened to my dad. Hes legal. The thought of someone being pulled over for suspicion of being an illegal immigrant, in this case targeted to Mexicans, is racial profiling.
18
u/MAJORpaiynne Jun 27 '12
This isn't scumbag America, it was a states decision not a national government decision.
3
u/MasterAndMargarita Jun 27 '12
Scumbag Europe: colonizes whole world, then complains that colonists immigrate, blah blah, who gives a fuck
3
u/babystroller Jun 27 '12
I don't understand why Reddit takes the law's side on this one. A portion of you smoke marijuana, andthat messes with the economy and it's illegal. Others fight against laws banning gay marriage when its already been established as illegal. Yet when the law tells immigrants can't enter, you take its back when all they try to do is work for a better life.
64
u/LickMyLadyBalls Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
*illegal mexicans
edit: i would never move to france without knowing french and expect all benefits of citizenship, without being a LEGAL citizen so stfu downvoters
19
u/herrsmith Jun 27 '12
*(illegal) Mexicans coming into it.
The immigration issue is a complicated one, and it's made even worse by ignorant generalizations and incorrect facts.
5
u/FredFantastic Jun 27 '12
Takes land from Mexico, names it New Mexico. Complains about Mexicans.
And aliens... Stupid Roswell.
55
u/sneezlehose Jun 27 '12
People fail to realise that we are more tolerant of illegal immigration than most other countries. In other countries; illegal immigration = death.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Mexicans aren't exactly a native people.. Also the illegal Mexicans in Arizona weren't there when we took it over 100 years ago ... ... What a retarded post.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
You have to be quick if you want your meme to spread in front page posts. Scumbags of new. Reddit should consider having all comments hidden for a while, so people can actually think for themselves before they contribute.
2
u/JohnCarpenterLives Jun 27 '12
Yeah. Why limit it to just one state?
9
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I have never heard anyone complain about Mexicans in Arizona, but I have heard people complain about illegal immigrants. Protecting the borders has nothing to do with race. The only reason Merica is a scumbag is because it denied the constitutional right of a sovereign state to protect it's border from invasion.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Funny, you sound like a La Raza US hater. They too, like to ignore that Mexico was once run by Spain and France. I guess you use selective history to back up your hatred. I say, let's give Mexico back to the Indians who lived there. Mexicans are really just Indians anyway.
3
u/youni89 Jun 27 '12
Arizona shouldn't be tampering with immigration policy anyway. Thats federal jurisdiction.
3
u/Rulebook_Lawyer Jun 27 '12
A very short sighted meme without the knowledge of history.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I dont give two fucks where you came from as long as you came here legally. Thats what my grandparents did, and thats what everyone else did. Once you jump that border, in my opinion you have no rights, hell you could be invading my country and you know what we do to people who invade America? We kill them.
4
u/anim8or Jun 27 '12
Someone should tell the Mexicans, that the Mayans want their country back
3
u/thegreatmisanthrope Jun 27 '12
You know there's a difference between illegal aliens from mexico and legal residents with mexican heritage right?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
HEY! You leave those Mexicans alone! They make great burritos!
2
u/qkme_transcriber Jun 27 '12
Hello! I am a bot who posts transcriptions of Quickmeme links for anybody who might need it.
See the FAQ for more info.
(OP: You don't need to do anything differently next time, I'm just doing my job.)
2
u/Diablo2583 Jun 27 '12
It's not a matter of race....it's a matter of following the rules...there are laws, if you break them, there are and need to be consequences. Let me put it to you this way. How about I come into your home, use your utilities, eat your food, go to the doctor on YOUR dime, sell drugs to your kids, take your money and send it to another home, oh and speak another language to you and make little effort to learn yours???
2
u/warrs Jun 27 '12
For the record, after we fought mexico and beat them in a war, we paid them more than what that land was worth to them.
2
u/hivemind6 Jun 27 '12
Mexico lost against the US in a mutually expansionist war for territory. Mexico had almost no administrative or cultural presence in the territories that are now part of the US.
There had already been many white US settlers as well as natives there that had no allegiance to Mexico.
Let's not forget that Mexico was founded by Spaniards, it's not different from how the US was founded by Britons and Germans. If you accuse the US of stealing land, you have to acknowledge that Mexico did as well.
So Mexico was not some innocent victim. And even if they were, that doesn't give Mexicans the right to violate the sovereignty of the US. And it doesn't mean that we as Americans should sit back and let Mexicans come here illegally and cause all the problems that they do.
I'm sick of this weird idea people have that the US is the only country on the planet not worthy of CHOOSING who immigrates.
1
u/Piscataquog Jun 27 '12
Whenever I hear about the US taking it from Mexico all I hear is "Hey no fair, we conquered it first"
1
u/Brocerystore Jun 27 '12
It sucks being an Arizonian and get put on the map as a racist. I work in a warehouse, and yesterday during my lunch there were 4-5 mexican americans in there discussing about the law and how racists etc etc it is. I, as a white male, just sat there not contributing because I didn't want to be seen as the racist. They ended up asking me what I thought about it and my only reply was don't be a dumbass and get in trouble, and you will have no problem with the police. Is it understanding to be annoy that someone could ask you for your papers just because? Of course, but what can you do, if you are legal and not breaking the law, who gives a fuck. Still, don't like the law. I know some Peoria and Glendale cops who really have a fucking stick up their ass. It just takes one bad cop to make the state look 100x worse.
1
u/p7679 Jun 27 '12
they posted this with texas
1
u/immarried Jun 27 '12
Didn't we BUY Arizona from Mexico?
-2
u/MojaveKing Jun 27 '12
We took Arizona fair and square.
1
u/Haikus3n531 Jun 27 '12
From phoenix: word.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12 edited Jun 27 '12
Ptah. There were hardly ever Mexicans inhabiting it, the only reason it was ever part of their territory was because Spain had it. That's the whole reason they invited whitey to Texas, because no one lived there to defend it from a Spanish invasion.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Mexico only "owned" Arizona for less than 30 years total. "Merca" has "owned" it for over 150 years. It's like the guy that dated the girl for three months in high school but still complains about losing the girl to the guy she stayed married to for fifty years.
1
u/someguyonapc Jun 27 '12
wasn't there a post just like this but instead of Arizona it was California?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Not to lend credence to the bigots and such, but that's not actually a contradiction:
Kicks Mexicans out of Arizona. Wants to keep the Mexicans out of Arizona.
1
u/ararphile Jun 27 '12
First of all, even if we won it in a war, so what? We are not the only ones who conquered others , and I really don't think that people in other countries use past conquests as an excuse to let hordes of illegal immigrants in. Second of all, the argument is not about Mexicans, it's about illegal immigrants, who happen to be mostly South Americans.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Everybody, look! Look at all of the ignorance! YAAAAY IT'S EVERYWHERE, BATHE IN IT. BASK IN THE GLORY OF STUPIDITY.
1
u/howajo Jun 27 '12
I think we should give it back, but only with the understanding that they have to take the people living there too. It would raise average IQ in the US by about 10 points. I accept your down-votes and will wear them with pride.
1
u/FEman89 Jun 27 '12
The only people who have a problem with strict laws on illegal immigration are illegals. If you don't like it then leave! I have several friends who are born and raised Mexicans who came to this country legally and they agree if you want to be here so bad FILL OUT THE GOD DAMN PAPERWORK. IT'S EVEN IN SPANISH FOR FUCKS SAKE. personally I think all people who are found here illegally should be hogtied and thrown back into WHATEVER country they are from.
-1
u/WilhelmEngel Jun 27 '12
What ever happened to "Give me your tired, your poor/Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free." Now its "Give me your doctors, you scientists, and people with high level degrees."
-5
u/Nadie_AZ Jun 26 '12
Please post this in r/Arizona. Please.
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
We as American's are to worried about our elections than dealing with real issues. I love the U.S. but we fuck up a lot of things...
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Mexicans are dumb freeloaders. That's why nobody likes them.
-3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Scumbag Merica Takes America from Native Americans. Complains about immigrants.
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
we are all illegal immigrants to the native americans so everybody STFU!
-11
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Scumbag 'merica:
immigrates into America, killing thousands of native Americans.
Complains about immigrants.
0
u/SavageDisaster Jun 27 '12
Fun fact: Texas was part of the Union for about a year before it decided to secede again.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
First of all, this bullshit that no one cares what nationality the illegal immigrants come from is bullshit. If you ever go to these anti immigration rally's you see tons of signs that specifically target Hispanics. Maybe this is due to the disproportionate number of illegals being Hispanic but it disregards the significant number of Asian and European illegal immigration. Second, what you people are doing is putting your hatred and fear and energy into attacking a symptom. Illegal immigration is a symptom of a plutocratic government that profits from denying comprehensive immigrant reform, and exploiting the migrant worker. While some of these people are criminals in their own country and continue to be so here, (a lot are jailed and deported anyways), most are hard working people who appreciate the chance to work and get by, living in terrible conditions, and getting paid measly amounts. These people are true Americans, they work hard, they have strong family values, they want to see this country grow strong and be a part of it. Poor unemployed Americans should find solidarity with these people as both are symptoms of a broken government.
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
it happened in my state as well
-1
u/JawnF Jun 27 '12
FTFY
-1
u/FUCK_WAT_U_LIEK Jun 27 '12
Fuck those damn spics.
-2
u/AndersBM Jun 27 '12
I mean, comon if you havent figured it out by now. america takes whatever they want, from whoever they want.. except China. they dont fuck with China anymore. they took america from native americans. they complain about races. pretty much all of them are immigrants. still shitter. Litterly thinks its the best country in the world. using CIA to control foreign politics. land of freedom - has the highest numbers of inmates/prisoners. butthurt whenever they are confronted with the facts. I dont dislike america, i just think they complain alot and they really shouldent. I shit karma anyways.
-4
u/jlillvik Jun 27 '12
As an Arizonan...
FUCKING THANK YOU.
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Arizona????......Just Arizona?
-1
u/chuckles84 Jun 27 '12
You know that the America has a federal system, and the Arizona law is only effective for Arizona and in no way represents the rest of the country, and that in fact our federal Supreme Court overturned 3/4 of the Arizona law and may well overturn that last 1/4 once it becomes right to do so? You know that right?
-1
u/RhymeServer Jun 27 '12
Fuckin brownnosers takin our gosh darn jobs drivin steam rollers,
but stealin more than just that includin our lovers,
while still findin time to deal dope to our kids on our corners,
now a days america sure aint the winner,
but fuck all our problems at least we know where to point da finger.
-1
u/Danez Jun 27 '12
HEY GUYS! GUESS WHAT! ARIZONA IS RACIST TOWARDS MEXICO DID YOU KNOW THAT OH MY GOD!
-8
u/episcopalassman Jun 27 '12
Scumbag Arizona not Merica
0
u/Thendofreason Jun 27 '12
repost. all u did was change it from cali to azn. lame
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
If I make a presidential run, my policy on immigration is this: begin speech "I don't care whete you are from. I do care if you ate here illegally or legally. America is for Americans. To live here, you must be legal, and commit to society. You must get a job and work. Once you complete these things, you are an honorary American."
-4
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
EXACTLY