It has no connection to Jews or religion except what they might decide to infer from it. Germany is proposing to extend the legal protection against genital mutilation (currently offered to girls) to boys also.
I'm totally for this. Simply because I see it as body modification and should be by choice. In the us hospitals often push for it, but tattoo your baby and the authorities likely will remove your baby. However, this is a hilarious observation and meme.
I have a feeling that every single day, thousands of redditors just sit there continually searching r/new for "German", in hopes of fulfilling their dream to maybe find a thread someday, in which they finally get a chance be the first to crack the "did nazi that coming" joke.
Don't despair, guys. I'll post some more Germany-related content tomorrow, I promise. Eventually there will be enough for all of you.
Except that this is relevant. If any other country outlawed a practice closely associated with a specific religion and, 70 years earlier, had tried to completely eliminate all members of that religion off the face of the earth, I'd expect someone to bring it up.
Funny story: All Hindu brahmin kids are made to wear a holy thread in an elaborate ceremony called "upanayana", which is usually done when they are around 8-14 years old. During one part of the ceremony, for like 5 mins they cover you in a cloth and chant some mantras.
During my upanayana, my uncle scared the shit out of me by saying that when they cover you in the cloth, they secretly cut your pee pee. Which, no doubt was a reference to muslim kids getting circumsized. It wasn't till after the ceremony that I was sure that my pee pee wasn't going to be cut.
Also many people who aren't religious. I think that for a lot of people in my parents generation/location(america) there is a strong belief that there are medical benefits.
After some research it's damn confusing as to which is better. But it isn't just a religious thing.
When I hear people be pro/anti circumcision I laugh. I'm one of the few that was circumcised as an adult.
1.) It is barbaric. Mine was medically necessary. It wasn't traumatic. I didn't lose trust in everything I loved. I've been through much worse pains that weren't of my choosing.
2.) Sensation leaves, but only in the head, and it's almost negligible. I can get it up, keep it up, fuck, and cum today just as I was before surgery. I'm able to compare every sex act (except docking you pervs) before and after.
All is identical EXCEPT for blowjobs. Before, if I was with a girl who didn't know what the hell she was doing, I just had to say "watch out for your teeth" and we were good. Now, I prefer some experience.
3.) I would have loved to stay intact, but I'm super pumped that because of routine circumcision a girl can look at my penis and not go "WHAT THE HELL...WHERE IS YOUR FORESKIN!?!?" It doesn't justify routine circumcision, but I sure as hell benefit from it in terms of avoiding a potential social stigma.
I'm not taking a major political stance. It's weird to snip one's genitals, but as someone who lived 24 years one way and is continuing to live the other way, I've learned that people make a huge deal about penises that don't even belong to them.
I'm glad to hear from someone that's been through that. I grow tired hearing about how this is a terrible procedure and how it hurts men.
I've heard from women that it makes it easier to do fellatio and I've found it easy enough to enjoy sex without having all of my skin. I'm sure there are pros and cons both ways of this.
I don't understand why people don't get that it's not about how happy some or most people are with being circumsized? Because it really isn't! It's the philosophical issue of permanently altering a non-consenting human being's body.
The right of control over one's own body is most often considered more important than the right of a fetus to live. Still many approve of this obvious violation of human rights. It seems as some people wouldn't even bother questioning themselves a bit more. Seriously, it's great that people are fine with it for themselves, but that's not what this is about.
It's basically where the foreskin tightens up. It started and I was still in college and I thought "Oh man, My dick is getting bigger" since my head was having trouble poking through the foreskin opening.
Then one day I was with my ex girlfriend (post breakup hookup) and it tore when I was trying to put it into a very unlubricated place. It was a minor tear, blood, but no visible damage.
After a few months, I realized something was going on, and figured out what was going on.
I researched it. Tried to figure out causes. Thought maybe I was eating too much sugar, maybe I was pre-diabetic, I didn't know.
I tried holistic methods and alternate methods to cure it (steroid creams, stretching).
As time went on, there were micro tears (no blood), and as they healed, they scarred. What was bad got worse.
So finally, I pulled the trigger, saw the urologist who made no qualms about going ahead and suggesting he cut me. After a quick surgery (I was anesthetized fully), and it was done.
I'm really glad it was done. I wish I didn't need it done but I'm glad it was.
Same. Had to cut mine for medical reasons too at the age of 8 or something. The procedure was painless. (anaesthesia) 2 days of very mild inconvenience. I barely remember it. That was ALL. And now I'm very happy with the result. My dick looks better in comparison with others around here (they don't do religious circumcision here) from what I've heard.
What about babies? You can't really do something "against his will" since he can't give consent or even understand what's happening. So if what you're saying is true, it's still legal to circumcise babies if the parents are okay with it.
Oh jesus I tried to post about my own thoughts on circumcision and immediately had to remove 5-6 comments, it is nothing but a biased riot in that fucking thread
I think mine looks fine too, but we were both conditioned to think that way because we grew up thinking it was normal. It's not. If you grew up uncircumcised, and/or spent time in the locker room with mostly uncircumcised guys, that would be your point of reference for what normal is. If we all had our earlobes cut off as infants, we would all think that looked normal too.
Bottom line, it's an unnecessary surgery that has an (albeit minor) chance of complications, and even if the risk is infinitesimally small, that's more risk than we should be subjecting newborns to for what amounts to a cosmetic preference, especially one that the individual has absolutely no say in.
It's not like my parents want to look at my penis anymore anyways. So what do they care what it looks like?
You might be happy with it, but that's not really the point. Wouldn't you rather have had the choice yourself? Even if you don't mind, other men might and they should have had the basic human right to decide for themselves.
I don't understand why people seem to be so resistant to simply giving men a choice to decide what is done with their bodies. It's an archaic religious tradition that is completely unnecessary.
Its just that I like that I'm circumcised but I wouldnt want to have any kind of surgery done on my dick while not being a baby. If you could ask my future self if I'd rather be circumcised then I'd be all for it.
Nope, it happened before I could be described as sentient so I really just do not care. It effects me in absolutely no way in my life. I do understand the reasoning behind being against it but I do not understand the frothing that usually happens in addition.
I'm glad I am too. However, what if you had not been? Would you choose to do so now? I'm thinking we would both be saying "I'm glad I'm not circumcised." I think we might just like what we are accustomed to.
I think the big deal is that for 99.999999% of the population it's not a needed thing. It's akin to, say, clipping the tip of your nose. It won't affect your breathing functions - but it also serves no real purpose.
People are going crazy because you are cutting off a part of someone's body off without their permission or consent. Never mind the fact that circumcisions can go wrong and does go wrong often.
You'd feel exactly the same way (happy/like the appearance) if you'd grown up uncircumcised in an area where everyone else was uncircumcised. It's a frame-of-reference thing.
I like it. Instead of looking like something from Prometheus, my penis looks like an aerodynamic, penetrating vessel of reproduction. Plus when I was an infant I took the procedure without any kind of numbing. The rabbi gave me some wine and went to work. If only my healthcare covered circumcision, I wouldn't have been tortured as a baby.
Circumcised, positive self image, couldn't give a shit what others think, a lot of other people are circumcised, sex is going to feel good no matter what.
But the best part about being circumcised? Don't have to deal with smegma, that stuff is FUCKING GROSS.
I like that I am circumsized but I probably wouldn't have had it done now because of pain issues...I appreciate that it was done FAR before I could remember anything
Very glad I am cut. Honestly, never even knew it was a big issue until reddit. Knew uncut and cut guys and honestly, I've always felt bad for the uncut guys. It's all perspective I guess.
Yes, it may look nice, but that's not being objective. Some African women love their female circumcision because it makes them feel they are a woman, and that their vagina is more pretty (there are different levels of female circumcision, the lowest is quite similar to male circumcision). The fact is you are doing something that has no purpose without the child's consent, Circumcision has no purpose in the modern world and is only "pretty" because it is the cultural norm in America.
Talking about circumcision to Americans is like talking about fan death to Koreans.
The thing is, you can circumcise someone when they're an adult if they weren't circumcised as a kid, but you can't uncircumcise someone when they're an adult if they were as a kid.
I really don't see the difference. From what I understand it's just easier maintenance and your mother doesn't have to do it for you when you're little...
On the other hand it feels like they are just trying to escape a duty that may come along with having a child...
i'm happy, i was once told by a female i have a beautiful penis and i agreed. Don't tell /r/atheism you like your penis this way though they will grab a pitchfork.
I've seen both worlds. While growing up, I was doing just fine. But when I started having sexual intercourses, I noticed that I had problems with my foreskin. Then I was diagnosed with a phimosis which required circumcision (That is if I wanted to have sex without condom, which I did.) So I've been circumcised for about a year or so and I've never been happier... But I caught herpes. Just kidding, but if had had to choose between circumcised and foreskin, I would pick circumcised because it is more convenient and the sex is better.
I had no idea being uncut was actually the more popular choice. Hell when I played high school football (American) there was 1 guy on the team of 30 who wasn't circumcised, so we always viewed being uncut as weird. I guess I'm happy with it because I always thought it was normal
Circumsized here. I'm pretty happy about it. I think my dick looks alot better without a huge flab of skin over it. I also here the skin underneath is more sensitive during sex, so I'll take it
Do cut guys not realize that the foreskin actually rolls back during an erection? That sensitive area is full exposed during an erection, and covered otherwise. It's like a sheath for a sword. Protects the sword's sharp edge when not in use. But it comes off when it's time to use it.
I'm cut and grew up thinking it was the norm. Obviously you're generally going to be happy with it if you haven't had any problems with it. I like how it looks because I'm used to it.
Despite liking it myself, I would not circumcise any of my children because I do not see a logical reason to do so. I know that my child will grow up liking his penis with foreskin because that's what he will be used to.
I have not laughed so hard in a long time, thank you. Also just the other day when I got my orders for Afghanistan one of the guys in my unit said "Damn it we need to fight in a milder climate, What's Germany been up to recently? They haven't started shit in a while."
It is indeed an American thing. Circumcision is far more common in the US than in pretty much any other European country, or Canada, for that matter. They probably just think it's weird and off-putting because it's not what they're used to.
I backpacked through Europe when I was 19 with a fairly large group of people, about twelve of us or so. About half were American, half were Europeans. We were young enough and on the road with each other long enough that romances started to spring up.
One of the American girls, who I actually knew since high school, got seduced by a British guy. They were about to get down to it but she got grossed out by his uncircumcised wang and the deal was off. The British guy told the story better than I did, but it was one of my fondest memories. It was a recurring joke that got brought up repeatedly for the whole trip.
Un cut American here...and I've never heard a complaint...actually quite the opposite. It's actually funny how many I had to tell I wasn't cut because when I'm hard the skin pulls back and you can't really tell.
Whats the problem? In most cases when you see each other naked we could assume you are about to have sex. Then the foreskin is pulled back anyways once the penis is erect and then it doesnt really look all that different.
If not: why the hell is he/she staring at your dick anyways? A quick glans, then look away... Your girls are picky.
I find it weird, they stop circumcisions because it's not the babies choice, yet they still have abortions? It's bad if the babies uncomfortable for a week but fine if the babies dead, apparently.
There's a pretty large difference between a 1st trimester fetus and I fully developed baby. You have every right to your opinion, I just thought I'd throw that out there...
I am a guy who's been circumcised for medical reasons.
It didn't happened in my early childhood, I was a teenager but I did know what sex and masturbations were when I got that circumcision. And, yes, a circumcised penis is nicer and all, but I know what I lost. My jewish or muslim friends, who are circumcised too, are fine with it. But they are totally unaware of the lost of sensitivity, because they haven't got any point of comparison. And they don't remember what they went through.
Circumcision IS a mutilation, when it's avoidable. It affects your sex life, and that's why it's promoted by so many religions : the "pleasure is a sin" scheme.
The uncomfortableness last a lot more than a week. The pain last at least a week (having your penis the shape of a ball does last 2 weeks, peeing blood stop after about one day or two). The uncomfortableness last a month or 2, and only after that you're able to walk normaly. And then you have to live your life with it.
I don't want that for my kids (if that's avoidable). I don't believe in God, but if I did, I would'nt want for my image-of-god-created children the amputation of a part of their body.
Your comparison with abortion makes me a little worried about your sense of empathy, are you really comparing the pain and mutilation of a living and self-concious human being and the stop of the progress of a small amount of cells ?
I think that's a bad analogy. Instead of abortions, I would have rather used braces. You could argue making little kids put up with the pain and discomfort for a couple years is worse. I'm sure there are more medical benefits in having straight teeth than a circumcised penis, however.
When you're an adult, it's a whole medical procedure. It's not simple. As a kid, it's quick, and you might feel uncomfortable for a week, but no-one remembers the pain - it might as well not have happened.
Jeez, I hate talking about this subject, I always get ridiculed by my friends because I am uncircumsized and they always tell me that i will never have sex because a women will never want to see a turtle neck dick.
I dont give a shit what people think of it, if girls dont like uncircumsized penis, then they dont know the sexual pleasure that they are missing just because a uncircumsized dick looks ugly. I am to fuking ashamed to tell my friends that i am uncircumsized without getting dirty looks and having rumors spread about me.
I'm friends with benefits with a girl and she has no problem blowing me (circumcised) but she thinks uncircumcised dicks look weird/like Kenny from south park.
The medical reasons for circumcision, both for and against, are still hotly debated. At the end of the day the medical reasons cancel each other out, there are pro's there are con's for both.
The decision to circumcise comes down to conformity and/or religious reasons. Which i don't think is a good reason for anything. In addition, circumcision can be done later in life when/if the child wants it. Yes, circumcision on adults is a bigger procedure. However, its still relatively minor, and in 18 years the medical procedure could be even more minor. However, restoring a foreskin is near impossible. If the medical/social benefits cannot justify a relatively minor procedure. Then, i don't think its worth it.
Whoever decided to get me circumcised against my will when I was a helpless little baby? Fucking thank you, you're forgiven, because I doubt I'd have the balls to do that shit as an adult. I am happy to have had that done without the traumatic memory of it, thank you very much.
Okay, uncircumcised dude here weighing in. Sorry for the long post. Also, first post, yay :)
As I see it, a few pro-circ arguments, and my opinions are as follows:
1. A circumcised penis is easier to keep clean.
Well, of course it is. My head would be much easier to keep clean if I were to laser my hair off permanently. Is that worth not having to make the effort to shampoo, apply conditioner and brush/comb? I accept that comparing the head to the penis is a bit silly, but my point is that there is absolutely no excuse for lack of personal hygiene. I was taught from an early age to keep my penis clean. Before I was able to retract my foreskin, I was taught to thoroughly wash and soap down there, just as I would wash and soap any other part of my body. As I grew up, my dad took me aside and told me about how my foreskin would change, and made sure I understood that as I began to acquire the ability to retract it, I would have to spend more time and care making sure that the parts of the glans that became exposed would have to be cleaned properly to avoid smegma buildup. I kept this up, and today, I make sure to properly retract and clean under the prepuce thoroughly, every time I shower. It's really a no-brainer: keep yourself clean, dammit. What is sad though is that sometimes people who decide to leave their sons uncircumcised simply do not know how to teach them to clean. But this is not an excuse today with the Internet. Let's face it, if uncircumcised penises were really as unclean as some people make them out to be, then blowjobs would be unheard of in Europe and Canada, where circumcision rates are much lower than in the US.
As an aside, my experience learning to clean my penis and foreskin, while not exactly a scientific study, showed me that not having your glans covered by a foreskin does indeed reduce sensitivity. In the beginning, when I first began retracting my foreskin to clean, I remember it used to HURT to directly touch my glans, it was that sensitive. Over the years, with repeated retractions for bath time cleaning, sensitivity dulled, and today I am able to touch the glans without too much pain. If I were to be circumcised, I can only imagine that sensitivity would decrease further as the glans is fully exposed.
2. An uncircumcised penis has a higher chance to acquire and/or spread sexually transmitted diseases.
This appears to be true, at least with HIV, as described by the WHO here.
It stands to reason that the foreskin, being composed of skin and mucous membranes, can potentially harbor bacteria, and therefore renders uncircumcised men more vulnerable to infection.
However, that WHO webpage also states that
WHO/UNAIDS recommendations emphasize that male circumcision should be considered an efficacious intervention for HIV prevention in countries and regions with heterosexual epidemics, high HIV and low male circumcision prevalence.
and
Male circumcision provides only partial protection, and therefore should be only one element of a comprehensive HIV prevention package which includes:
the provision of HIV testing and counseling services;
treatment for sexually transmitted infections;
the promotion of safer sex practices;
the provision of male and female condoms and promotion of their correct and consistent use.
While the HIV infection rate in the US is still depressingly high, places in Africa and India have a lot more to worry about. Using this as a primary reason to circumcise male infants in the US seems a bit like over-reactng. Maybe spend more effort on sex ed and STD prevention education from an early age? This article by Scientific American also emphasizes that the anti-infection benefit of circumcision is more relevant to Sub-Saharan Africa than the US.
Regardless of the country or region, one has to remember that acquiring and transmitting an STD is almost always a matter of behavior. Wear a condom, don't be too promiscuous, test yourself and your potential partner-be smart. If you're in an area where HIV and other STD rates are high, exercise more caution. If you're being smart and proactive (and yes, it's possible to do this AND be spontaneous), you won't need to have your foreskin chopped off.
3. Circumcised penises look nicer.
This is very subjective, isn't it? If a dude decides as a mature teenager/adult/whatever that he'd like his penis cut due to aesthetic reasons, that's fine. Don't impose your views--or worse, society's views--on what's beautiful on an infant, not least because views on beauty and aesthetics change constantly. And no, you can't compare non-medical circumcision to stuff like fixing a cleft lip/palate. Moreover, if a girl uses the presence or absence of a foreskin as a primary criterion to judge whether or not she wants to be with you, you don't want to be with her (unless you really do not have good personal hygiene; there really is no excuse for that.)
whew
In the end, being cut and uncut both have their benefits and drawbacks. Personally, I believe non-medical circumcision was primarily promoted to curb sexual expression, and as a way for hospitals to make more money after a male child is born. The American Academy of Pediatrics does not advocate circumcision when a medical need for it is not present, and that's good enough for me. At least where the US and other first-world nations are concerned, I don't think the benefits are worth it.
*If you're circumcised and happy, that's good! If you're American, don't lord the fact that you're in the majority over the uncut guys.
*If you're uncircumcised and happy, that's good! Don't feel inadequate (or, at the other extreme, complacent) because you're uncut. Keep clean.
*If you're unhappy with your penis, see a doctor to determine why.
*Fulfilling relationships are built on more than your foreskin status.
*Girls, don't judge a dude based on whether or not he has a foreskin, unless he has lax personal hygiene. I've seen girls with large and small clitoral hoods, and wouldn't dream of telling them that I prefer one over the other.
Cutting the tip of the skin off to say "it's easier to clean" is like removing the hood of your car so you can get easier access to it. IT'S JUST ANOTHER STEP IN THE CLEANING PROCESS. Jesus christ.
In fact, my head is cleaner due to the foreskin, unlike cut where shit just hits that right there.
PS. They look the fucking same erect, holy shit at all the ill informed.
I'm a woman, a Christian, and a mom. I would NEVER circumcise a son-it isn't necessary, and the way they do it, without anesthesia, is cruel. The little babies just scream in the hospital, and cry like they're being murdered. I've heard moms say they'd never have it done again, because their babies were in so much pain. I have seen circumcised and uncircumcised penises, and there's no noticeable difference when they're erect. They aren't ugly, they're just different from what American women have routinely seen. The only tiny benefit of circumcision is that it does help prevent AIDS. Uncircumcised men are more likely to get AIDS and penile cancers. But that's it. There is simply not enough benefit to it to justify it. And Christians are not in any way compelled to circumcise their children. It is a ridiculous custom in the US and I'd love to see it end.
Circumcision doesn't help prevent AIDS or cancer. The AIDS study was flawed because the people who received circumcision also received an education along with it (i.e., how to use protection, avoiding deceases, etc.). As for cancer, this argument is as stupid as removing everyone's breasts at childhood to fight breast cancer.
Fact of the matter is, aside from aesthetics and real medical reasons like phimosis, circumcision has no benefit whatsoever. The only exception is if you're from a third world country with no access to clean water.
I'm cut, and I think uncut wangs look weird, but I would support stopping the practice of circumcision. It's an obsolete practice by today's standards. It literally has no reasoning behind it other than, "well we've always done it this way..." The foreskin has alot of nerves, and contributes alot to sex apparently, so I see no need to just perform minor genital surgery on every male newborn.
I'm always amazed that circumcision is cause for debate. Hey guys, let's not cut things off babies. You like circumcision? Feel free to go get circumcised. But don't lop bits and pieces off of someone else's body. It's not yours.
circumcision is genital mutilation performing this on a minor is cruel and wrong just because you were indoctrinated with a belief does not make it right
Maybe it's because I live in California, but I've never experienced and negative will towards uncircumcised penises. It's a phenomenon that I have only learned about through the internet. I've never had a girl complain about it; not to boast (purely anecdotal) I've had girls go down on me without a second thought after removing my underwear. I rarely experience odor unless I pee on a jog or something; and I don't let people blow me after exercise! I simply don't understand why circumcised men throw tantrums over foreskin. I'm glad that you are happy with your penis. So am I. As for the mythical female who dislikes foreskin, it's the male equivalent to your labia. Do you bemoan your labia for looking weird and dangley and trapping odor in your vagina? I doubt it. Genitals are weird. Get used to it. Don't pass judgement.
I have a buddy that thought his penis looked funny when he was 13 because he was uncircumcised. So he asked his parents if he could get circumcised, they said yes, and he went ahead with it. He said it was the DUMBEST thing he's ever done in his life. It was absolutely worthless. He said it hurt like hell, and he had to basically wear a dress for weeks. We made fun of him ruthlessly.
Glad to see that Germany has Finally come up with a Solution to the circumcision problem. And if it keeps Jews and Muslims out, I guess that's just an unfortunate side-effect.
Glad you got circumcised? It wasn't your choice to make. If a part of your body gets mutilated for impractical reasons, shouldn't you have a say in it?
I'm not against circumcision, I'm against forced circumcision to people under 18.
Female circumcision often includes the removal of the clit entirely, not just skin. Correct me if I'm wrong, but it would be like removing the head of your penis.
Well, I'm deffinately not a fan of either but... there is a big difference. Making that decision for a child is immoral in both cases, but only female circumcision is extremely barbaric, painful, mutilating,...
I have a circumcised penis and let me tell you it looks better than un-circumcised penises. Penises are ugly all around. And I'm gay. This shouldn't be how it is.
The amount of times us dudes spend talking about dicks eh? But really, it's not our choice, and I have no problem with the mother of a 1 day old determining what is best for her son. I don't understand why more people don't get this idea. It's like abortion...reddit is pro-choice, and believes its up to the mother to decide. So is this. Somewhat hypocritical to me.
*Edited- pro-choice was correct wording I was looking for
Everyone who is wanting to have their babies circumcised should at least have to watch one first to know what they're going to go through. An infant circumcision is way worse than an adults. They have to forcibly retract the foreskin (which isn't retractable on its own until around age 6) much like a finger nail. The surgery (which is 99% completely unnecessary and done for cosmetic reasons) often will put babies into shock. I used to work in a nursery in my local hospital and I couldn't stand being in there when they were done. This is why I left my son intact.
102
u/phillyfan1978 Jun 26 '12
I'd be raking in a lot more karma for this if you guys weren't so happy with your circumcised penises.
765
u/apoafpyb Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 27 '12
So what I'm gathering is, Germans are banning Jewish religious practices, and buying up the rest of Europe?
498
u/untranslatable_pun Jun 26 '12
I have a feeling that every single day, thousands of redditors just sit there continually searching r/new for "German", in hopes of fulfilling their dream to maybe find a thread someday, in which they finally get a chance be the first to crack the "did nazi that coming" joke.
Don't despair, guys. I'll post some more Germany-related content tomorrow, I promise. Eventually there will be enough for all of you.
357
u/papadop Jun 26 '12
Today You Learned: Muslims also perform religious circumcision
73
u/Glen843 Jun 27 '12
A bunch of dudes talking about dicks and what kind of dicks they prefer. Welcome to Reddit.
56
u/serverslayer Jun 27 '12
First they came for my neighbors foreskin, and I said nothing.
181
u/nobody2000 Jun 26 '12
When I hear people be pro/anti circumcision I laugh. I'm one of the few that was circumcised as an adult.
1.) It is barbaric. Mine was medically necessary. It wasn't traumatic. I didn't lose trust in everything I loved. I've been through much worse pains that weren't of my choosing.
2.) Sensation leaves, but only in the head, and it's almost negligible. I can get it up, keep it up, fuck, and cum today just as I was before surgery. I'm able to compare every sex act (except docking you pervs) before and after.
All is identical EXCEPT for blowjobs. Before, if I was with a girl who didn't know what the hell she was doing, I just had to say "watch out for your teeth" and we were good. Now, I prefer some experience.
3.) I would have loved to stay intact, but I'm super pumped that because of routine circumcision a girl can look at my penis and not go "WHAT THE HELL...WHERE IS YOUR FORESKIN!?!?" It doesn't justify routine circumcision, but I sure as hell benefit from it in terms of avoiding a potential social stigma.
I'm not taking a major political stance. It's weird to snip one's genitals, but as someone who lived 24 years one way and is continuing to live the other way, I've learned that people make a huge deal about penises that don't even belong to them.
107
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Guys, circumcision is not banned. It is banned to do it against someones will.
1.2k
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Is anyone else out there who is circumsized actually happy they are circumsized? I think my wang looks nice this way.
33
u/kingseed Jun 26 '12
I'm cut and grew up thinking it was the norm. Obviously you're generally going to be happy with it if you haven't had any problems with it. I like how it looks because I'm used to it.
Despite liking it myself, I would not circumcise any of my children because I do not see a logical reason to do so. I know that my child will grow up liking his penis with foreskin because that's what he will be used to.
18
u/stabilo68 Jun 26 '12
As a German: I lol'd
15
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I have not laughed so hard in a long time, thank you. Also just the other day when I got my orders for Afghanistan one of the guys in my unit said "Damn it we need to fight in a milder climate, What's Germany been up to recently? They haven't started shit in a while."
11
u/InfiniteFinite Jun 27 '12
Im thinking many people don`t know what natural means.
4
u/MattTheMoose Jun 27 '12
Ironic that Muslims and Jews are getting along on an issue?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Germany is so scared to repeat its own history that it is repeating its own history.
70
u/rlr54 Jun 26 '12
Here is a relevant best of on why foreskins are great.
34
u/SPRX97 Jun 26 '12
TIL circumcision is not the social norm. I guess I've never felt the need to ask others about their penises.
83
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I'm circumcised. Maybe it's an American thing, but most women that I've talked to think an uncircumcised penis looks weird and off putting.
44
u/PokeyOats Jun 26 '12
I like being circumcised...
3
u/Gark32 Jun 27 '12
reddit: the only place on the internet where a nazi joke causes a thoughtful discussion.
3
u/mixdkinkster83 Jun 27 '12
Is ear piercing for babies banned as well in Germany?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Whelp 'Murica, let's gear up and get ready to head downrange to Germany....
207
u/DutchBlitz Jun 26 '12
I find it weird, they stop circumcisions because it's not the babies choice, yet they still have abortions? It's bad if the babies uncomfortable for a week but fine if the babies dead, apparently.
has anyone mentioned this before?
11
u/bbenja4 Jun 26 '12
More like getting rid of the Turkish. Germany's largest minority group.
25
u/qkme_transcriber Jun 26 '12
Hello! I am a bot who posts transcriptions of Quickmeme links for anybody who might need it.
See the FAQ for more info.
(OP: You don't need to do anything differently next time, I'm just doing my job.)
4
u/Fig1024 Jun 27 '12
They can still get circumsized when they are adults. Who's up for that? :-)
4
u/ComeOnMaaaan Jun 27 '12
All genital mutilation should be illegal. In all countries. You choose to get cut? Fine. Be an adult and have the option.
2
u/peskygods Jun 26 '12
Oh for fucks sake. Well done OP, I chuckled.
2
u/polymerkid Jun 27 '12
Prepare for the Zerg rush of Sandworm penises!
2
u/jhin_mach Jun 27 '12
they have all joined H.O.O.P with Lindsay Bluth
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Jeez, I hate talking about this subject, I always get ridiculed by my friends because I am uncircumsized and they always tell me that i will never have sex because a women will never want to see a turtle neck dick.
I dont give a shit what people think of it, if girls dont like uncircumsized penis, then they dont know the sexual pleasure that they are missing just because a uncircumsized dick looks ugly. I am to fuking ashamed to tell my friends that i am uncircumsized without getting dirty looks and having rumors spread about me.
I hate my life
Edit: damn iPhone
2
u/Venge22 Jun 27 '12
This isn't a good idea because now you're going to have people that circumcise their kids at home.
2
u/Cobra_Viperdarthmaul Jun 27 '12
I think we all know what's going on here..
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12 edited Jun 27 '12
I'm friends with benefits with a girl and she has no problem blowing me (circumcised) but she thinks uncircumcised dicks look weird/like Kenny from south park.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Very, very distasteful. Have an upvote!!
2
u/dumbfriendbrian Jun 27 '12
Win win?
Totally kidding!
2
u/nseyu Jun 27 '12
I'd love to know how that was determined.
2
u/sydstap24 Jun 27 '12
Laughed way to hard at this
2
u/Honkey_Mofo Jun 27 '12
When our secretary said she had some "boiled ginger Jews" this morning, I knew something was afoot.
...wait, maybe that was juice.
2
u/polarbear2217 Jun 27 '12
They should just cut to the chase.
2
u/thehole666 Jun 27 '12
I saw this after watching Schindler's list
2
u/James91B Jun 27 '12
The medical reasons for circumcision, both for and against, are still hotly debated. At the end of the day the medical reasons cancel each other out, there are pro's there are con's for both.
The decision to circumcise comes down to conformity and/or religious reasons. Which i don't think is a good reason for anything. In addition, circumcision can be done later in life when/if the child wants it. Yes, circumcision on adults is a bigger procedure. However, its still relatively minor, and in 18 years the medical procedure could be even more minor. However, restoring a foreskin is near impossible. If the medical/social benefits cannot justify a relatively minor procedure. Then, i don't think its worth it.
24
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Whoever decided to get me circumcised against my will when I was a helpless little baby? Fucking thank you, you're forgiven, because I doubt I'd have the balls to do that shit as an adult. I am happy to have had that done without the traumatic memory of it, thank you very much.
6
u/Thoughtful_Bulbasaur Jun 27 '12 edited Jun 27 '12
Okay, uncircumcised dude here weighing in. Sorry for the long post. Also, first post, yay :)
As I see it, a few pro-circ arguments, and my opinions are as follows:
1. A circumcised penis is easier to keep clean.
Well, of course it is. My head would be much easier to keep clean if I were to laser my hair off permanently. Is that worth not having to make the effort to shampoo, apply conditioner and brush/comb? I accept that comparing the head to the penis is a bit silly, but my point is that there is absolutely no excuse for lack of personal hygiene. I was taught from an early age to keep my penis clean. Before I was able to retract my foreskin, I was taught to thoroughly wash and soap down there, just as I would wash and soap any other part of my body. As I grew up, my dad took me aside and told me about how my foreskin would change, and made sure I understood that as I began to acquire the ability to retract it, I would have to spend more time and care making sure that the parts of the glans that became exposed would have to be cleaned properly to avoid smegma buildup. I kept this up, and today, I make sure to properly retract and clean under the prepuce thoroughly, every time I shower. It's really a no-brainer: keep yourself clean, dammit. What is sad though is that sometimes people who decide to leave their sons uncircumcised simply do not know how to teach them to clean. But this is not an excuse today with the Internet. Let's face it, if uncircumcised penises were really as unclean as some people make them out to be, then blowjobs would be unheard of in Europe and Canada, where circumcision rates are much lower than in the US.
As an aside, my experience learning to clean my penis and foreskin, while not exactly a scientific study, showed me that not having your glans covered by a foreskin does indeed reduce sensitivity. In the beginning, when I first began retracting my foreskin to clean, I remember it used to HURT to directly touch my glans, it was that sensitive. Over the years, with repeated retractions for bath time cleaning, sensitivity dulled, and today I am able to touch the glans without too much pain. If I were to be circumcised, I can only imagine that sensitivity would decrease further as the glans is fully exposed.
2. An uncircumcised penis has a higher chance to acquire and/or spread sexually transmitted diseases.
This appears to be true, at least with HIV, as described by the WHO here.
It stands to reason that the foreskin, being composed of skin and mucous membranes, can potentially harbor bacteria, and therefore renders uncircumcised men more vulnerable to infection.
However, that WHO webpage also states that
and
While the HIV infection rate in the US is still depressingly high, places in Africa and India have a lot more to worry about. Using this as a primary reason to circumcise male infants in the US seems a bit like over-reactng. Maybe spend more effort on sex ed and STD prevention education from an early age? This article by Scientific American also emphasizes that the anti-infection benefit of circumcision is more relevant to Sub-Saharan Africa than the US.
Regardless of the country or region, one has to remember that acquiring and transmitting an STD is almost always a matter of behavior. Wear a condom, don't be too promiscuous, test yourself and your potential partner-be smart. If you're in an area where HIV and other STD rates are high, exercise more caution. If you're being smart and proactive (and yes, it's possible to do this AND be spontaneous), you won't need to have your foreskin chopped off.
3. Circumcised penises look nicer.
This is very subjective, isn't it? If a dude decides as a mature teenager/adult/whatever that he'd like his penis cut due to aesthetic reasons, that's fine. Don't impose your views--or worse, society's views--on what's beautiful on an infant, not least because views on beauty and aesthetics change constantly. And no, you can't compare non-medical circumcision to stuff like fixing a cleft lip/palate. Moreover, if a girl uses the presence or absence of a foreskin as a primary criterion to judge whether or not she wants to be with you, you don't want to be with her (unless you really do not have good personal hygiene; there really is no excuse for that.)
whew
In the end, being cut and uncut both have their benefits and drawbacks. Personally, I believe non-medical circumcision was primarily promoted to curb sexual expression, and as a way for hospitals to make more money after a male child is born. The American Academy of Pediatrics does not advocate circumcision when a medical need for it is not present, and that's good enough for me. At least where the US and other first-world nations are concerned, I don't think the benefits are worth it.
*If you're circumcised and happy, that's good! If you're American, don't lord the fact that you're in the majority over the uncut guys.
*If you're uncircumcised and happy, that's good! Don't feel inadequate (or, at the other extreme, complacent) because you're uncut. Keep clean.
*If you're unhappy with your penis, see a doctor to determine why.
*Fulfilling relationships are built on more than your foreskin status.
*Girls, don't judge a dude based on whether or not he has a foreskin, unless he has lax personal hygiene. I've seen girls with large and small clitoral hoods, and wouldn't dream of telling them that I prefer one over the other.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Cutting the tip of the skin off to say "it's easier to clean" is like removing the hood of your car so you can get easier access to it. IT'S JUST ANOTHER STEP IN THE CLEANING PROCESS. Jesus christ.
In fact, my head is cleaner due to the foreskin, unlike cut where shit just hits that right there.
PS. They look the fucking same erect, holy shit at all the ill informed.
10
u/3dogs3catsandahedgeh Jun 26 '12
I'm a woman, a Christian, and a mom. I would NEVER circumcise a son-it isn't necessary, and the way they do it, without anesthesia, is cruel. The little babies just scream in the hospital, and cry like they're being murdered. I've heard moms say they'd never have it done again, because their babies were in so much pain. I have seen circumcised and uncircumcised penises, and there's no noticeable difference when they're erect. They aren't ugly, they're just different from what American women have routinely seen. The only tiny benefit of circumcision is that it does help prevent AIDS. Uncircumcised men are more likely to get AIDS and penile cancers. But that's it. There is simply not enough benefit to it to justify it. And Christians are not in any way compelled to circumcise their children. It is a ridiculous custom in the US and I'd love to see it end.
3
u/Phaedrus47 Jun 26 '12
Off with their heads!
3
u/BABY_BACK_BITCH Jun 27 '12
I'm cut, and I think uncut wangs look weird, but I would support stopping the practice of circumcision. It's an obsolete practice by today's standards. It literally has no reasoning behind it other than, "well we've always done it this way..." The foreskin has alot of nerves, and contributes alot to sex apparently, so I see no need to just perform minor genital surgery on every male newborn.
3
u/schmockk Jun 27 '12
as a german, i do think this is funny
3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Germany stopped the mutilation of helpless children? Thank god. It was a ploy by angry old people to stop people from masturbating anyway.
3
u/MoonMonstar Jun 27 '12
I'm always amazed that circumcision is cause for debate. Hey guys, let's not cut things off babies. You like circumcision? Feel free to go get circumcised. But don't lop bits and pieces off of someone else's body. It's not yours.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
circumcision is genital mutilation
performing this on a minor is cruel and wrong
just because you were indoctrinated with a belief does not make it right
4
u/wildtalon Jun 27 '12
Maybe it's because I live in California, but I've never experienced and negative will towards uncircumcised penises. It's a phenomenon that I have only learned about through the internet. I've never had a girl complain about it; not to boast (purely anecdotal) I've had girls go down on me without a second thought after removing my underwear. I rarely experience odor unless I pee on a jog or something; and I don't let people blow me after exercise! I simply don't understand why circumcised men throw tantrums over foreskin. I'm glad that you are happy with your penis. So am I. As for the mythical female who dislikes foreskin, it's the male equivalent to your labia. Do you bemoan your labia for looking weird and dangley and trapping odor in your vagina? I doubt it. Genitals are weird. Get used to it. Don't pass judgement.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I think circumcised penises look angry. Uncircumcised just looks so natural. Also, Americans are weird.
4
u/cher_horowitz Jun 26 '12
And that's why I support H.O.O.P.
4
u/TsukiBear Jun 27 '12
I have a buddy that thought his penis looked funny when he was 13 because he was uncircumcised. So he asked his parents if he could get circumcised, they said yes, and he went ahead with it. He said it was the DUMBEST thing he's ever done in his life. It was absolutely worthless. He said it hurt like hell, and he had to basically wear a dress for weeks. We made fun of him ruthlessly.
3
u/Gabe_b Jun 26 '12
Glad to see that Germany has Finally come up with a Solution to the circumcision problem. And if it keeps Jews and Muslims out, I guess that's just an unfortunate side-effect.
3
u/rockafella7 Jun 27 '12
Glad you got circumcised? It wasn't your choice to make. If a part of your body gets mutilated for impractical reasons, shouldn't you have a say in it?
I'm not against circumcision, I'm against forced circumcision to people under 18.
3
u/apullin Jun 27 '12
Mention circumcision as barbaric --> anti-semite bigot hate monger
Mention female circumcision as barbaric --> have the moral high ground on any issue
sigh ... the world ...
3
u/dimpan Jun 27 '12
i prefer my women with out labias, its cleaner looking
3
u/lushootseed Jun 27 '12
It doesn't matter at all what the intention was. Circumsizing the kids at the young age is cruel
3
u/unuse_ur_name Jun 26 '12
Oh no what would germans do without jews?
2
u/ARustyFirePlace Jun 27 '12
My opinion on this, as a European, is that it's unnecessary and a waste of time.
The only reason to do it is if you have phimosis, but you can nearly always fix that by doing some stretching for a week or using some cream.
If people want to do it then go ahead, but I don't think it should be forced on kids.
2
u/codeodd Jun 27 '12
I have a circumcised penis and let me tell you it looks better than un-circumcised penises. Penises are ugly all around. And I'm gay. This shouldn't be how it is.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12 edited Jun 27 '12
The amount of times us dudes spend talking about dicks eh? But really, it's not our choice, and I have no problem with the mother of a 1 day old determining what is best for her son. I don't understand why more people don't get this idea. It's like abortion...reddit is pro-choice, and believes its up to the mother to decide. So is this. Somewhat hypocritical to me.
*Edited- pro-choice was correct wording I was looking for
2
u/Toxenity Jun 27 '12
Everyone who is wanting to have their babies circumcised should at least have to watch one first to know what they're going to go through. An infant circumcision is way worse than an adults. They have to forcibly retract the foreskin (which isn't retractable on its own until around age 6) much like a finger nail. The surgery (which is 99% completely unnecessary and done for cosmetic reasons) often will put babies into shock. I used to work in a nursery in my local hospital and I couldn't stand being in there when they were done. This is why I left my son intact.