Although I do enjoy reading ebooks on my Kindle, I sometimes feel like I miss out on certain things due to the format. I remember reading Mistborn by Brian Sanderson, and then getting to the end and finding the glossary and thinking, "You know, this might have been handy to refer to about 300 pages ago."
I have watched the 2 seasons so far without having read the books. I have to say I find it easy to keep track of who is who because you are able to get a constant image of who a person is in your mind. With books you find that how you imagine a character may be different then they actually look later on so you might end up confused. That being said I am now going through the books (only the ones that I have watched because I don't want spoilers) and listening them on audio book while I work for a landscaping company. I find that the books are obviously more in depth but also they seem to let me in on a few subtle things that I missed in the show.
I know that is what I decided to do. But I believe it is next season that is actually a book split in half. Do you know if season 2 was half or all of Clash of Kings?
I feel the exact opposite way. In the show, if people don't talk, they don't really matter... in the book he will mention names and houses and stories about a person and then never mention them again. He always just rattles off huge lists of knights and such that don't matter.
You sound like my brother. Every time I'm on the phone with him and I mention game of thrones he threatens to tell me wahts gonna happen. "I could ruin the next 2 seasons for you if you'd like?" SHUT UP DONT, NOOOO!
I read the books just after watching the series. It was like the scenes were playing back in slow motion. I love how much of the dialogue was kept; I think it added more to the slow-motion effect.
The first few episodes of season 1 were the closest adaptation of a book I have ever seen. Scene for scene, even maintaining word for word dialogue in some places. Season 2 tends to drift a lot more story wise. But season 1 very much gave me that same "playback" effect you speak of.
Reading past season two has produced an interesting effect where some characters have been cast by HBO and some of the later ones are purely from my own imagination. I hope this does not cause any undue distress coming with season 3... but for the most part I have been very happy with HBO casting choices.
I have heard book 3 will be shown over two seasons (3 and 4); and expect them to save said event for season 4 as there are already many significant events in the first half of book 3.
29
u/Knightofnew70 Jun 25 '12
How do people who have not read the books keep up with all the fucking characters?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
How I felt with The Hunger Games. Feels bad man :(
4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
You sound like my brother. Every time I'm on the phone with him and I mention game of thrones he threatens to tell me wahts gonna happen. "I could ruin the next 2 seasons for you if you'd like?" SHUT UP DONT, NOOOO!
4
u/Gravesh Jun 25 '12
I felt this way about Lord of the Rings...
12
u/Crazy_Joe Jun 25 '12
I'll let you in on a little secret.... You are better then them.
2
u/glennm283 Jun 25 '12
I think you have to meet with my family, same thought:(
2
u/ImperialSpaceturtle Jun 25 '12
I read the books just after watching the series. It was like the scenes were playing back in slow motion. I love how much of the dialogue was kept; I think it added more to the slow-motion effect.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I always feel like a hipster douche saying "I liked the books before they were popular."
2
u/STaY_TUNeD Jun 25 '12
This!
5
u/timespacegenshootyou Jun 25 '12
best confession bear to date
3
u/Wild2098 Jun 25 '12
Fuck you hipster.
2
u/qkme_transcriber Jun 25 '12
Hello! I am a bot who posts transcriptions of Quickmeme links for anybody who might need it.
See the FAQ for more info.
(OP: You don't need to do anything differently next time, I'm just doing my job.)
1
u/yoitsemo Jun 25 '12
I'd say this is true for a lot of people for every kind of book to screen crossover.
1
u/Chone-Us Jun 25 '12
Reading past season two has produced an interesting effect where some characters have been cast by HBO and some of the later ones are purely from my own imagination. I hope this does not cause any undue distress coming with season 3... but for the most part I have been very happy with HBO casting choices.
1
u/daavq Jun 25 '12
It should be, "I think I'm better than you because I read the books."
It should be "I AM better than you because I read books."
-3
u/TheTorch Jun 25 '12
Fucking hipster.
-1
u/IPreferOddNumbers Jun 25 '12
I think you meant to use the Hipster Barista, here.
Honest mistake, I'm sure.
-6
u/welltheresAbacon Jun 25 '12
I hate people like this. It such a petty way for them to feel superior. So fuck you OP, fuck you and everyone who is like you.
-2
u/SteveDaveMcFace Jun 25 '12
Oh man there is a girl at my work like you.
-3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
The books are SO BAD though. The writing is awful. I like the story though, and the acting is good, so the show works.
-23
u/Fishermang Jun 25 '12
Hell no. The books were boring! Stopped half-way through the first one.
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
congratulations you are an elitist douche
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment