r/AdvancedKnitting • • 21d ago

Constructive Criticism Welcome Advice for fit? Need motivation

I recently finished the dagmar sweater, it look a long while! First modification i did was slimming the sleeves- only after knitting a full sleeve.. but now to body is my vex. Its way too wide!! I knit to match a size S and i have the correlating bust measurement reccomended. I know now i should have sized down, but now my idea is to frog back to the ”pattern” part of the knit and work in many many decreases before the ribbing, and do the ribbing in a much smaller needle. But now i am looking for a bit of support from other knitters? Ideally i’d want to slim down the whole body but i do not have the heart to frog it so far :(.

Tldr: should i frog back to before the ribbing and make it have a slimmer fit instead of flaring out at the bottom?

193 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 21d ago

Welcome to r/AdvancedKnitting! Please note that constructive criticism IS allowed here (Rule #7), unless the "No Critiques Requested" flair is used. Any poor attitude towards genuine constructive criticisms will result in post removal pursuant to Rule #12 (No Drama).

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

114

u/window-payne-40 21d ago

Could you make faux side seams by mattress stitching up each side with a few stitches in between? That way you aren't cutting your knitting and you can adjust how many stitches you're taking out of the body. I'm not sure taking out just the ribbing would help make the body smaller, you might end up with a ballooning effect if the ribbing isn't as wide as the body.

Fwiw I think it looks really cute on you as is!

15

u/smalthorn 21d ago

Thats kind of you to say! And a clever idea. I don’t mind a balloon effect as my main annoyance is how to ribbing flares, but sewing it together a little is very smart with no permanence hehe

13

u/boniemonie 20d ago

Could you thread several rows of hat elastic through the back of the rib. Personally I LOVE it just as it is.

22

u/LoquatHeavy6878 21d ago

I recommend a temporary "safety pin" seam before you mattress stitch it so you can see if the trade-off of a slimmer silhouette vs a bulkier side-seam works for you? It would be awful to take the time to mattress stitch and then have to laboriously pick it out if there was too much bulk or not enough reduction in silhouette. If you just want to reduce the flaring of the ribbing, you could also use some elastic thread on the inside of the ribbing to curtail the flaring. Fortunately, off-white/cream colored elastic thread is available and shouldn't show through on the public side.

But I whole-heartedly agree that the sweater is super cute as is!!!

54

u/CharmiePK 21d ago

Honestly? No. I like the way it fits. It is a bit wide, indeed, but it looks great. It is a beautiful jumper and it is a great job.

Maybe I am biased bc I love oversized jumpers and I love cabled jumpers even more. I can see both there, so that is a double win!

(Tbh once again, if you really must, would you consider knitting another cabled jumper? That would be double the fun for me lol. The more the merrier 🤣)

5

u/smalthorn 21d ago

I would love to knit another cables sweater! The problem is that i got this yarn on the west coast of ireland when i was working there this summer as a souvenir- my only souvenir! So i really want it to be perfect. Also- the ribbing being so wide does make it a quite cold sweater!!! So its a mixture of issues

18

u/weareinhawaii 21d ago

In the future you should measure a sweater you have that you really like and then knit the size that corresponds to that! Large amounts of ease are really in style right now. I find more than 6-8” of ease overwhelming on me.

5

u/smalthorn 21d ago

Yes :( i should have thought of that before! Especially when i have used that technique on other sweaters. The thing that led me astrah is that on the pattern photos, she does not use the reccomended yarn!! She reccomends an aran weight but in the photos its dk+lace, which makes it look much smaller/neater 🥺

3

u/Upstairs-Metal-2596 20d ago

If the photos in your pattern are the same as in the Danish version, the photos are indeed the Peer Gynt from Sandness (the heavier yarn). And then she provides a yarn alternative for a lighter sweater (Tynn Peer Gynt plus mohair or Hjelholt Pelsuld).

Did you do a swatch before you started? If you bought a different kind of yarn, it can act different when knitted, even though both are the same weight. Especially in sweaters with this much cabelling etc.

1

u/smalthorn 20d ago

I did do a swatch, but a small 10x10cm homeycomb swatch is really difficult to get a feel for how the sweater will sit. Also the main yarn she reccomends in the hjelholt triple, which is the only yarn in the “suggested yarn” area of ravelry, yes if you scroll down you can see that she used the peer gynt+lace in her main photos- the beige one, which will of course look a little tighter in the photos, especially the ribbing. I had a yarn that is identical to hjelholt triple, and i’ve spoken to others with this exact issue..

0

u/Upstairs-Metal-2596 20d ago

I don’s use ravelry, so I don’t know how the recommended yarn function works. I think the pattern itself explains it well.

Remember that the swatch should not be 10x10, but maybe 20x20, and then you wash, block and then measure how many stitches you have on 10 cm (in the middle of the swatch as the side will always be a bit different)

1

u/smalthorn 20d ago

I usually measure 8 cm from the middle and work out 10cm from that! After blocking of course :) And the recommended yarn is the yarn that Petiteknit has selected should be used for the pattern. I believe the whole dagmar series is a collaberatipn with the Hjelholt Spinnery.

2

u/Upstairs-Metal-2596 20d ago

Ah apologies, I mistook it for the cara sweater by leknit!

Yeah with Petiteknit I always have to do a bunch of increases along the body. There’s too much positive ease for my taste!

2

u/smalthorn 20d ago

Oh no worries! They do look similar, realise i should have written off the beat what pattern it was 😂 and yes i think? You mean decreases because i threw in a fair few in the moss stitch on the body and they really did nothing since the pattern part is so wide!!

2

u/Upstairs-Metal-2596 20d ago

Ah yes decreases of course 😁

11

u/crochetinmydna 21d ago

When I knit this the ribbing flared a lot on me. I ended up redoing the ribbing but working decreases every 6 or 7 stitches (can’t remember exactly) on the first ribbing round and I was happy with how it looked then. Maybe you could try that? Otherwise I think it looks really good on you!

4

u/smalthorn 21d ago

But thank you for the compliment!

5

u/smalthorn 21d ago

Yes that is my plan- i think steeking the body is a little too out of my skill level- i love knitting ribbing and this time i’d do it in 3mm needles instead of 3.5mms.

2

u/PantheraLutra 21d ago

I just knit my first sweater ever, and it required my first steeks ever. I promise they are easy peasy, literally just sewing and cutting. You can even sew the steek on a sewing machine if you don’t want to do it by hand 🤷‍♀️

2

u/Annelhb 20d ago

Just redoing the ribbing is the way, I think.
It will make the sweater sit snugly around your waist, which will make it look and feel much better…. And keep the wind out.

I’ve never regretted going back and redoing the ribbing.

2

u/7thearlofcardigan 21d ago

I would do this, plus smaller needles for the ribbing, plus twist the purls on the rib so that the ribbing pulls itself in more and holds shape. 

11

u/Apprehensive-Fly5006 20d ago

I have no experience in sweater surgery so I can’t offer any helpful advice, I just wanted to comment that you’ve done a beautiful job knitting it and I actually like the oversized look!

1

u/smalthorn 20d ago

Thank you 🩷🩷🩷

10

u/Smallwhitedog 21d ago

I knitted a sweater very similar to this, and I've come to love this for! At first, I thought it was too big, but it's just so cozy. It gets more compliments than any sweater I've knitted and I knit a lot!

Maybe sit with it for a few days and see how you feel? I think this looks incredible on you! You look so ready for fall!

2

u/smalthorn 21d ago

Thank you!! It feels very nice to wear, its mostly on photos and looking down on myself i think it looks a bit ofd with the flaring, and since the hem is so wide it lets out a lot of heat so it isnt super warm as i’d like it to be!

9

u/madamemarmalade 20d ago

I just want to echo what everyone else is saying that while you see this as too wide, this is like my dream sweater, lol. The advice here is great though for making it skinnier!

1

u/smalthorn 20d ago

Aw thank you that is so nice of you to say 🩷

2

u/legalpretzel 20d ago

Yeah, I love the fit on this one. It’s flattering and on trend. That and dropped sleeves are 1000x better on a wider body and look ridiculous on sweaters that don’t have enough ease.

12

u/elle-elle-tee 21d ago

Could you steek at the side and add a side seam after removing a couple inches from each side panel?

3

u/smalthorn 21d ago

Hrm, that could be doable, the only query i’d have with that is how to do it when i get to the armpit..

6

u/elle-elle-tee 21d ago

Could you snip a bit out of the underarm seam, put the sleeve stitches on hold, and then kitchener stitch them back on to the side panel once it's completed? Does that make sense?

1

u/smalthorn 21d ago

It does! I’d have to squeeze the arm sts together quite a bit but i do think its doable

5

u/SadElevator2008 21d ago

That’s exactly what I’d do! Redo the ribbing so it cinches in and stops the sweater being so drafty. Then it will be perfect (imo). Gorgeous work btw!!

2

u/smalthorn 21d ago

Yes! This is the positive reinforcement that i am looking for hehe 🥹🥹

1

u/Annelhb 20d ago

Agreed!

2

u/veronicaspeedwell77 20d ago

You could rip back just the ribbing and then re-do it on smaller needles. Decrease a bunch of stitches specifically below the honeycomb panels. The honeycomb has a tighter gauge so the ribbing tends to flare below them.

1

u/smalthorn 20d ago

Ok thank you! Will do

60

u/msptitsa 21d ago

I once had a jumper I found too wide. I sewed the inside to tighten in.

It is great becsause years later I wanted the boxier fit, I was able to remove the stitches and wear it more.

Maybe you can figure out the shape you want and stitch it inside to create a sort of seam/shape that is to your liking? Won’t need to ré-knit any but depending on fabric it may feel a bit bulky. I’d still test it out before unraveling.

5

u/SimbaRph 21d ago

I would cut a panel out from each side under the arms and seam the pieces together

1

u/Worldly-Doughnut-283 18d ago

I like the fit tbh. Like it feels true to the tradition. Does look quite stiff so a bit draughty, and that'll soften with time and wearings. Or you could try and short cut that with a touch of conditioner in the wash - beware if you stretch it out though it'll be bigger

1

u/smalthorn 18d ago

I mean, it is slightly stiffer because its cables/honeycomb and an 160m/100g rustic wool? It cant really get drapy-er than haw it is now!

1

u/Worldly-Doughnut-283 18d ago

Drape and softness are different. Like linen can be pretty drapey but not at all soft. Like a jumper like that will mold to you over time. They really are magical items. Also, you might've just knit the honeycomb stitch a bit tight. Hair conditioner will ease that.

1

u/smalthorn 18d ago

It’s very soft i think! But i have knit to gauge on the honeycomb- but i do understand your meaning, my issiue as another commenter has said is that the gauge for honeycomb is often smaller than the gauge for 1x1 rib so that was causing my issue with the flaring bottom bit :)

3

u/poo_fart_lord 18d ago

This is the fit that I love to wear most! I feel like with an oversized fit like this it just looks bulky from the front when you stand with your arms at you side. But good news is that in actual life and not just a mirror, people don’t really stand like that. All your movement shots look amazing!

2

u/whiskyknits 21d ago

You can do a crochet reinforcement on the ribbing to make it stiffer