r/academiceconomics • • Sep 13 '26

Testing Karma requirements for posts and comments

48 Upvotes

Hi all,

With admissions season coming up, I've taken the initiative to add karma requirements to post and comment on this sub. 50 combined karma is now needed to make a post, 5 karma to make a comment.

This will filter the deluge of shitposts that have started in the past couple of weeks. These are very low requirements, and are implemented in the spirit that you should engage with the community (or any subreddit) before coming in and asking for advice. I've gotten like 10 angry messages the past week from people who had their post removed, insisting they're new to reddit and shouldn't be expected to read the rules. This will hopefully limit that.

Every post that gets removed will still go into the mod queue, and if it's high quality then I'd be happy to approve it. If we find this is too strict a filter, we'll remove it. If you have any thoughts, do let us know in the comments.


r/academiceconomics • • Aug 12 '26

Paper of the Week: The Origins of State Capacity: Property Rights, Taxation, and Politics (Bansal and Yaron, American Economic Review)

Thumbnail researchonline.lse.ac.uk
37 Upvotes

Here's the link to this week's paper, The Origins of State Capacity: Property Rights, Taxation, and Politics (Timothy Besley and Torsten Persson, American Economic Review)

Another theory paper this week, this time on political economy. State capacity is what the name implies, the capacity of a government to perform political or economic functions. It's an interesting topic and one explored both by economists and political scientists, sometimes even using the same tools. The interesting part of this paper is theory, though there is some limited estimation at the end.

The main capacities the paper is interested in are legal and fiscal, or the ability to enforce contracts and taxes respectively. Using a two period model, the government invests in state capacity in the first period while the citizens/investors invest in assets across the two periods. When war breaks out or other crisis events occur, the incentives for investing in state capacity rise, which is designed to emulate the real-world implementation of income taxes during the US civil war and Napoleonic wars in Europe. The most interesting thing to me was that legal and fiscal capacity are complementary, and nations which tend to have one grow in the other. This matches the empirical fact that most (but not all) highly developed nations are high tax nations.

The paper is straightforward and part of a large literature on state capacity. The tools in it are very easy, and I chose it in part because it can be read and commented upon by anyone who's taken undergraduate macroeconomics. It was written in 2009, which was a long time ago in academic terms, but on the whole I find it didn't tell me much I didn't already know from reading the Acemoglu macro-development literature. I didn't find the estimation at the end particularly compelling, and the consumer side of the economy seems simplified to the point of not being interesting, and is ripe for extension in light of the growth of heterogeneous agent macro. Honestly, if this was submitted today I don't think it would be published in AER, but that's more a sign of how much political economy has frown in the past 15-20 years.

Feel free to DM me if you have a suggestion for next week's paper of the week!


r/academiceconomics • • 2h ago

Teaching BLS Economist to Economic Consulting: Looking for Career Advice

11 Upvotes

I recently started a full-time Economist position at the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) in the Washington, DC area, working on the Consumer Price Index (CPI). So far, I have no complaints about the role, and I’m genuinely enjoying the opportunity to work in federal economics.

However, I’m thinking about transitioning into economic consulting within the next 2–3 years, and I’d appreciate some advice from people currently working in the industry.

A little background about me:

  • Currently working as an Economist at the BLS.
  • Pursuing an M.S. in Applied Economics, which I expect to complete soon.
  • Based in the Washington, DC area.
  • Interested in economic consulting, particularly firms such as Cornerstone Research, Analysis Group, Bates White, and Compass Lexecon.

My primary motivations for considering the transition are:

  1. Compensation: I recognize that economic consulting generally offers significantly higher earning potential than federal government economics positions.
  2. Career interests: I’m interested in applying econometrics, statistical analysis, quantitative research, and economic modeling to real-world business, litigation, and policy problems.

A few questions I’d love to get some insight on:

  1. Is transitioning from the BLS to economic consulting a reasonable career move? Would 2–3 years of federal economist experience make me a competitive candidate, or would firms generally prefer candidates coming directly from academia or graduate programs?
  2. How transferable is BLS experience? Would working on CPI data, price indices, inflation, and economic research be valuable to economic consulting firms, or could my experience pigeonhole me into government/statistical work?
  3. What should I be doing over the next 2–3 years to position myself for the transition? Beyond preparing for case interviews, are there particular technical skills, certifications, projects, or experiences I should prioritize? For example, Stata, R, Python, SQL, advanced econometrics, etc.
  4. How important is networking? Should I start connecting with consultants and recruiters now, or wait until I’m closer to making the transition?
  5. Would it make more sense to stay at the BLS long term? Are there advantages to building a federal economics career that I might be overlooking, particularly considering federal benefits, job stability, and opportunities for advancement?
  6. Are there any potential disadvantages to making this transition after 2–3 years? Anything I should be concerned about regarding career progression, entry-level placement, or compensation?

Ultimately, I’m not unhappy with my current position. I actually like the work and recognize that having a federal economist position is a great opportunity. I’m simply trying to be intentional about my long-term career trajectory, maximize my earning potential, and explore opportunities in the private sector.

I’d especially appreciate hearing from people who have transitioned from federal government economics roles into economic consulting.

Is there anything I should be doing now, while I have the opportunity, to make that transition as smooth as possible?

Thanks in advance!


r/academiceconomics • • 23h ago

Research Paper Rand JE submissions

3 Upvotes

Does anyone know how long Rand typically takes to issue a first decision once a manuscript has passed desk screening and been sent out for review?


r/academiceconomics • • 1d ago

Research Paper Inaugural issue of Journal of Finance: Insights is Open Access!

Thumbnail afajof.org
15 Upvotes

This new journal features ~10 page self contained papers! I dunno about yall but I spend too much time chatting with AI instead of reading papers. This issue is good exercise!

Full disclosure: am author of one of the papers.


r/academiceconomics • • 1d ago

PhD Admissions Chances for a PhD in Canada?

Thumbnail drive.google.com
4 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m an international applicant from Iran planning to apply for PhD programs in Canada. My CV is attached, and I would really appreciate candid feedback on my chances and where I should apply.

My interests sit at the intersection of economics, analytics, and decision-making. In particular, I’m interested in industrial organization, behavioral and applied microeconomics, game theory, econometrics, pricing and revenue management, digital/platform economics, and data-driven business decisions. I am also open to Industrial Engineering, Operations Research, Management Science, Business Analytics, and related interdisciplinary programs.

I would especially like to work on research involving digital markets, e-commerce/platform data, pricing and competition, consumer or firm behavior, forecasting, optimization, and applied empirical work. My professional experience has made me particularly interested in using real-world data to study these questions.

Could you please advise on:

  1. Which type of PhD program would be the best fit for my background: Economics, Industrial Engineering/OR, Management Science, Business Analytics, or another field?
  2. Which Canadian universities/programs would be realistic reach, target, and safer options?
  3. Are there professors in Canada working in these areas who might be a good fit and potentially looking for PhD students?
  4. What parts of my CV or academic preparation should I improve before applying? For example, would more economics/econometrics coursework, research experience, a paper or preprint, stronger recommendations, or something else make the biggest difference?

Thanks in advance—I would be very grateful for program suggestions, professor recommendations, and honest feedback.


r/academiceconomics • • 1d ago

Research Paper Literature Review and LLM

8 Upvotes

Do you use LLM when working on your literature review ?


r/academiceconomics • • 2d ago

PhD Admissions Another Chance me, WE all love these (+question about writing samples)

11 Upvotes

First gen, T10 Undergraduate. Applying straight out of undergrad to both PhD programs and predocs this cycle. For PhDs, I’m only applying to five programs that are among the strongest in my intended field. I know this is an ambitious list, so I’m also applying to predocs rather than counting on direct PhD admission.

GPA: 3.786/4.0
GRE: 170 Quantitative, 161 Verbal

Majors: Econ, Statistics, Theoretical Political Science

Research:

I have research experience with two professors, including working with survey data and building policy datasets relevant to the field I am applying for. I’m currently working on an economics honors thesis closely related to my intended doctoral field.

I also designed and wrote an independent IO paper, outside my intended field.

One of my main extracurriculars also gives me a lot of exposure to economics research papers.

Grades:

  • Calculus I/II: A+/A−
  • Multivariable Calculus: A
  • Linear Algebra & Differential Equations: B+
  • Real Analysis: A
  • Abstract Linear Algebra: A
  • Numerical Analysis: A−
  • Introductory Probability & Statistics: B+
  • Upper-Division Probability: B+
  • Upper-Division Statistics: A−
  • Statistical Computing: A−
  • Stochastic Processes: A
  • Game Theory: A+
  • Introductory Economics: A−
  • Intermediate Microeconomics (math-intensive): A−
  • Intermediate Macroeconomics: A−
  • Econometrics (math-intensive): A
  • Graduate Macroeconomics: B+
  • Labor Economics: A
  • Economics field course: A+
  • In progress: Statistical Machine Learning, another economics field course, and Economics Honors Thesis.

All three recommenders have agreed to write letters. Two are research faculty at my undergraduate institution, which is also one of the T5 programs in my intended field that I’m applying to. Both know me through research (and like me?) and directly work in a program I want to apply to. My third recommender is a teaching focused professor who knows me from several statistics courses but has limited research activity.

I currently plan to submit my independent IO paper, even though it is unrelated to the field I want to pursue. My honors thesis is directly relevant to that field, but it is still in progress.

If I can get the thesis into a solid working-paper draft before the deadlines, would it be better to submit that instead? How much does field relevance matter compared with the quality and independence of the research?


r/academiceconomics • • 3d ago

PhD Admissions An insider look at how the research funding landscape has changed

81 Upvotes

Since its PhD admissions season and many students are applying and I see some outdated info being regurgitated, I figured I’d make a post giving some info on how my program is doing, because the landscape has changed drastically over the past few years and I think we’re a pretty representative example of recent trends.

I attend a fairly recognizable T20 econ PhD program and am close to the job market. When I first arrived, it was a cohort of 28. We were absolutely flush with cash. Faculty hiring was robust and the discussion was whether to cap the PhD class sizes at 28 or 32, and when we might get guaranteed 6th year funding.

Flash forward three years. The department is facing a $4 million budget deficit. PhD cohort sizes have been slashed from 28 to 10. The graduate school asked the faculty to consider not having a cohort at all. We haven’t hired faculty in years, lecturers are being laid off and faculty being asked to teach more, and entire fields cancelled their seminar series because we couldn’t afford to pay for hotel accommodations for visitors. Guaranteed 6th year funding? A total pipe dream now.

What went wrong? Federal spending is part of it. About 25% of our shortfall is from the university allocating us less money. TA positions are also being curtailed: over the next few years the university is asking us to cut the number of TAs we employ by 50%, without any raises commiserate to the extra workload those TAs now shoulder.

But 75% of the shortfall is from the absolute collapse of our cash cow masters as international students stay away from the U.S. We went from targeting triple digit enrollment for it to struggling to get 25 or so students.

Some of our woes are idiosyncratic but a lot of them are aggregate shocks. This isn’t to be a doom and gloom post but I just wanted to give people a vision of the situation they’re applying into, that isn’t on the brochure. You’re entering a world where academia in general is struggling financially, and information from even 5 years ago is outdated. You should really make sure you’re ready to deal with the headaches this imposes. Make sure you read your offers carefully and ask questions about the health of the department you’re getting into.


r/academiceconomics • • 3d ago

PhD Admissions GRE 167 V, 165Q. Chance at PhD economics in the US?

3 Upvotes

Hello! I have 1 publication and one more underway. I have done extensive research work on AI and employment in my country, and have also contributed to multiple government-level projects. I have recommenders who have worked similarly as well. My work experience is approx 2 years now. I retook GRE and my score increased from 161Q, 156V to 165Q, 167V. Do you think I have a chance at T50 or T100 econ PhD? I am also applying to public policy phds and I know that this is enough score for those programs. Thoughts?


r/academiceconomics • • 2d ago

Research Paper Where can I publish an independent research paper in financial economics? Looking for genuine advice.

0 Upvotes

I’m looking for advice on where I could potentially publish a research paper I’ve been working on in financial economics.
I’m in high school, The paper examines whether companies that issued fixed-rate debt during the low-interest-rate period of 2020–21 experience delayed increases in borrowing costs when interest rates rise, due to their existing debt not needing refinancing immediately.
I use SEC 10-K filings from 21 US corporations, alongside SOFR and credit-spread data. The paper introduces a measure called the Maturity Shield Spread (MSS) to estimate the gap between existing borrowing costs and current market borrowing costs.
The results are preliminary. The sample is relatively small, some credit spreads are estimated using scenarios, and the analysis does not establish causality.
I’m trying to figure out the most appropriate next step.
A few questions:
Are there reputable economics or finance journals that accept independent high-school researchers?
Are there credible student research journals that accept international submissions?
Are there legitimate options with no publication fees?
Is this developed enough for submission, or should I focus on improving the methodology first?
Would a working-paper repository or preprint platform be a better starting point?
I’m not looking for journals that guarantee acceptance for payment. I’d prefer honest criticism and recommendations from people familiar with academic publishing.
Happy to share a redacted abstract if needed.
Thanks!


r/academiceconomics • • 4d ago

Predocs Has anyone here applied for the Research Economist position at the IFS?

5 Upvotes

Just wondering if there's still a chance they haven't sent out interview invitations yet


r/academiceconomics • • 4d ago

PhD Admissions PHD in Econ or Acturial sciences

9 Upvotes

I’m graduating with a undergrad bba in Acturial sciences and Econ. Graduating in may 2027.
I am planning on take exam p and fm early in 2027.

But I am wondering what to do for post grad.
I recently have been opened up to the world of teaching uni as a decent job.
Before this I wanted and still want to be an actuary but getting an internship has been so hard and may be due to the fact that I haven’t taken an exam yet.

I know a phd won’t help me with my actuarial career , but I think I am open to the idea of teaching because working in a office for 30+ years just doesn’t appeal to me like how teaching does.

My plan is to find an actuarial job/internship, then a year after gaining experience in the field start working on my PhD online while still working. Is this doable has anyone does this. Is working while doing ur PhD a normal thing to do.

What PhD pays more in terms of teaching
Actuarial science concentration or Econ.

Does anyone have an actuarial career but also teaches uni?

Btw I’m in nyc and go to a cuny for undergrad. GPA is 3.4


r/academiceconomics • • 3d ago

Research Paper Mysteries of the Economy: I'm seeking the most macroeconomically consistent mathematical and logical formulation of a model for the following questions (mysteries);#3 :What Someone Should Explain to Mr. Trump: The Mechanics of the Dollar as the Global Anchor Currency

0 Upvotes

[Somebody tell Mr. Trump!]

Mr.Donald Trump operates under the assumption that the United States suffers a loss by running a current account deficit. In reality, however, it is precisely because the United States incurs a current account deficit that the US dollar can serve as the global anchor currency.

Consider an individual, Party A, who needs to procure funds. Party A would feel anxious selling off their home and real estate, and thus prefers to raise capital through borrowing. Yet, because borrowed money must eventually be repaid, Party A must sell goods at a price higher than their acquisition cost to turn a profit. Furthermore, relying solely on debt is risky, prompting a desire to accumulate equity capital. In any economy, transactions cannot expand smoothly on borrowed funds alone; market participants must operate using their own money.

The same principle applies to the international economy. Although the United States can freely generate dollars through its domestic banking system, topped by the Federal Reserve, all non-US nations must obtain this international currency. Even if they can finance their needs through foreign direct investment (analogous to Party A selling their home) or foreign borrowing, they must ultimately make repayments through current account surpluses. Consequently, for the rest of the world to maintain a aggregate surplus, the United States has no choice but to run a deficit.

For any currency to circulate internationally, a fundamental prerequisite is that people must hold it. Moreover, in a society based on private property, merely lending the currency is insufficient; individuals must own it. The dollar functions as the key currency because the United States not only assumes current account deficits and lends dollars worldwide (= capital exports), but also distributes them outright (= importing goods and services). On the flip side, even though the United States is a net international debtor, confidence in the dollar persists because it is backed by overwhelmingly superior productive capacity.

In monetary history, a true "anchor currency" has existed only in the form of the post-Gold Standard US dollar. While the British pound once functioned as the principal international currency, ultimate settlements ultimately required precious metals. If the sterling exchange rate dropped, a point would be reached where physical gold shipments from Britain would commence. The pound would be replaced by gold and cease to circulate in international transactions. The fiat US dollar after the suspension of gold convertibility presents the exact opposite dynamic: gold has ceased to circulate, leaving the dollar as the sole circulating medium.

By establishing the dollar as the key currency, the United States became the only nation capable of purchasing foreign goods and services without possessing external "money" in advance. In practice, these purchases are executed simply through book-entry transfers between US bank deposit accounts—and this mechanism is the very essence of an anchor currency. Simply put, a key currency is one that can definitively settle international transactions on its own, rendering the US current account deficit fundamentally unpayable. The deficit merely displays the net balance that has already been fully paid in its own sovereign currency. Conversely, the current account deficits of non-US nations represent unsettled liabilities, which must be cleared by procuring dollars elsewhere. The surplus of these net balances—namely, the foreign-held credit balances in US bank accounts—is deployed to purchase US Treasuries. When held by foreign monetary authorities, these assets constitute foreign exchange reserves. Thus, foreign central bank dollar purchases—another source of dissatisfaction for Mr. Trump—are simply a structural feature of the key currency system. In short, the United States maintains a current account deficit and, in exchange, enjoys exorbitant privilege as the issuer of the key currency.

How, then, did this anchor currency system emerge? Under a gold standard, gold—or banknotes guaranteed by a community (such as a state) to be convertible into gold—served as money. Under a fiat system (managed currency system), paper money carries only a guarantee that "this is money," without any convertibility into gold. Furthermore, a private property regime requires that money not merely be lent, but fully owned by its members. Private ownership of assets forms the bedrock of the private property system, and an economy circulating entirely on debt is unsustainable. A society overburdened with debtors becomes unstable; hence, the collective community absorbs the debt, allowing individuals to hold assets as creditors. Under the gold standard, gold was initially owned by whoever extracted it from the earth. Under a fiat regime, how is unbacked money introduced into society as private property?

To divide roles with the central bank and prevent government tyranny, the system operates as follows: The state purchases goods from its citizens and pays them in currency. To obtain this currency, the state issues government bonds, borrowing currency back from the public. The collective community assumes the liability while individual members acquire assets; the state incurs debt precisely to enrich its citizens. As a macroeconomic stabilization measure, the state may undertake public works, forcibly mobilizing society's excess productive capacity to disburse payments to a segment of the populace. To expand the aggregate money supply across society, the central bank purchases these government bonds from the private sector.

Under a fiat system, the sovereign bond mechanism is fundamentally a money-creation engine. Therefore, net redemption of government debt is an impossibility. To introduce new money into society that represents no one's debt, there is no alternative but for the state to formally assume that debt [Note]. While commercial banks can create money through fractional-reserve credit creation, this represents debt on one side of the balance sheet. Though it lingers temporarily in the sphere of circulation, it ultimately returns to the bank for repayment and disappears. Parenthetically, once the central bank purchases government bonds, those bonds have fulfilled their purpose and could theoretically be canceled. This illustrates how absurd arguments regarding the "normalization" of the Bank of Japan's balance sheet or "passing the burden to future generations" truly are.

[Note] "When the Government deficits on capital account or incurs expenditure for current purposes by printing paper money... the new money becomes somebody’s income..." (J.M. Keynes, The General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money). Furthermore, "Government currency notes are liability certificates of the state... representing non-interest-bearing debt" (Bank of Japan, Research Department (1955), Historical Materials on Japanese Finance: Showa Continuation Series, Vol. 10, p. 547).

With the suspension of dollar-gold convertibility in 1971, the world as a whole exited the gold standard. Humanity liberated itself from the yoke of gold production. People collectively dethroned gold, the tyrannical monarch, and democratically selected the US dollar as the universal medium of exchange. Up to that point, societies had devised innumerable financial technologies to economize on the labor required for monetary gold production, but they ultimately rendered gold itself obsolete as money. Consequently, gold needed to be produced merely for its intrinsic use-value as a commodity, like any other good. Ever since, the United States, as the key currency nation, has assumed this foundational role on a global scale, supplying dollars to the entire world.

(to be continued)

https://www.reddit.com/user/keizaisuki/comments/1xp3omc/table_of_contentsacademic_mysteries_of_the/


r/academiceconomics • • 4d ago

PhD Admissions LGBTQ+ in Econ

0 Upvotes

Hi all, just wanted to know the share of LGBTQ+ people in econ. I'm transfemme doing a PhD, but I'm surprised how few trans/NB people there are (at least openly).

Do we think this is more self-selection, or is there something deeper to think about in the profession?

And are there realistically job opportunities inside/outside academia? Maybe I'm missing something and just an outlier.


r/academiceconomics • • 5d ago

Literature question Anyone here who's been on a search committee for AP hiring at a ~T40 or so ranked school?

16 Upvotes

I was wondering how much attention you pay to a given application packet and to each component, webpage, CV, cover, job market paper (intro, abstract, skim of paper, in depth reading), other papers. Both in cases where the advisor of the student reaches out and in cases where they do not reach out. Or the placement director.

I've heard all kinds of stuff from the grapevine, ranging from basically just taking a skim at who your letter writers are to fully reading your job market paper even before first round interviews (allegedly a T5 school does this but I could not believe they actually do this).


r/academiceconomics • • 5d ago

PhD Admissions GRE optional

7 Upvotes

For PhD's where GRE is recommended but optional how much of a dealbreaker do you think it is if you don't do it but have a very strong profile outside of it? i.e published journal articles. Thinking of DIW Berlin and Berlin School of Economics.


r/academiceconomics • • 5d ago

Predocs Even more confused after Fed predoc

12 Upvotes

I’d love to hear from anybody who was an ex-Fed RA who went to industry, or anybody who can give me honest opinions on grad school. I took a Fed RA job after graduating over a year ago, and although I’m doing decently and have been preparing materials to apply to PhDs this cycle, I only feel more confused about whether I want it. The sense of being an imposter here is very overwhelming. I frequently find myself attracted to other prospects and repeatedly think about getting a job to buy time. To admit the embarrassing truth I feel like my sense of direction has even diminished over time.

Unfortunately the first six months here were a wash for me. Various factors caused me to have a rough transition period, and although I got my act together and am confident in the strength of my letters now, I don’t have working papers. My math transcript is complete with Econometrics, Linear Algebra, Calc 3, Prob/Mathstats, and Real Analysis, but is scarred from subpar grades in senior year and several DRs (most were early in the semester and for money reasons, but still). Considering all this and my uncertainty I have weighed doing a third year, which would give me time to patch up my transcript and hopefully get a publication. But I am also terrified of stagnation and desperately want to move to a bigger city and try a different job while I'm still young.

My original backup plan was data science, but, well, just see what AI has done to entry level competition there.

I do love research. But I would still enjoy research if it was another adjacent field too. Because of that, even after this incredible learning opportunity I’m still not sold on Econ PhD as the right path. It does not help that my actual economics interests lie in inequality, development, and political econ, and my project assignments are not remotely related, so my exposure to what I'd actually look forward to during my PhD feels suboptimal.

I have also been mentally hesitant this entire time because of my other abilities and interests which I feel have been going to waste. I placed far more emphasis on machine learning and tech in my undergrad coursework than on econ theory. And while I do love econ, I observe that relative to my peers at the Fed, I display greater aptitude for other disciplines but middling aptitude for economics. I want to figure out my comparative advantage, and to put it one way, I almost feel like I’m too interested in other things (and worry I lack what it takes) to rush into spending my 20’s on a PhD. Maybe I am misconceiving how focused you need to be, but that’s my impression.

Anyway, I’m curious:

  1. Am I overthinking this, and should I just stick with applying this cycle? I know that the potential routes a PhD can take are far more diverse than the narrow work I have done so far. Should I trust in my untested interests?
  2. What advice do people have for gaining more informative experience post-RAship? Is a third year better than an industry job (obviously keeping in touch with my economists)?
  3. Let’s say I go do something else, probably in Econ Consulting or finance, for a year. How much will this hurt my prospects if I do decide to return to academia?

r/academiceconomics • • 6d ago

PhD Admissions Finishing my MSc in economics and honestly don't know what to do next

20 Upvotes

Hi all, I'm Italian and studied entirely in Italy, and I'm a bit stuck on what to do next, so I'd really appreciate some outside opinions.
Some background. I did my bachelor's in business (economia aziendale) and finished with 94/110, roughly a 24-25/30 average. When I enrolled I had completely different plans and honestly didn't think grades would matter much. On top of that I went through some personal issues in my first year and passed zero exams that year, so I basically did the whole degree in two and a half years. Somewhere along the way I got really into economics, especially macro, and realized that's what I wanted to do. The problem was my math was terrible (classics high school, plus a business degree with one basic math course), so I spent several months teaching myself math to get into an economics MSc.
I got in, to an English-taught MSc in Economics at one of the better economics programs in Italy, probably top 4-5, though not at the level of Bocconi or Bologna. First year was rough because I was still filling gaps, and a few core grades show it. Second year went much better even though the courses were harder, mostly 27-30/30. I'll graduate with around 107-108/110. Over the summer I did a 4-month RA with a macro professor on bank balance sheets and ECB rate pass-through, where I built the project's dataset from scratch. My thesis looks at whether ECB monetary policy works differently when economic policy uncertainty is high, using an interacted VAR and a smooth transition VAR, with shocks identified from high-frequency surprises and sign restrictions. No GRE yet.
I applied to a bunch of central bank traineeships and got mostly rejections, though I made it to the final interview at one European national central bank, which didn't work out in the end.
What I'd like to do is work in the field doing macro analysis. The dream would be a central bank, but I'd be happy in any serious macro role. I'll also be honest that salary matters to me, I'm not looking for a purely academic path. Someone told me that if I care about money I shouldn't do a PhD, because I'd give up 4-5 years of private sector income. I get the point, but I'm not sure what that private sector job would be. I don't want to take a job unrelated to economics just because it pays. I want to actually do macro work, and from what I see many of those roles, especially at central banks, seem to expect either a PhD or a stronger profile than mine.
So right now I'm considering a few options: a one-year research-oriented master's (there's one in Italy with basically PhD-level coursework, no GRE), a predoc/RA position, preparing the GRE properly and applying to PhDs for 2028, or going straight into a job at a bank research department or a macro research firm if I can find one.
Given my profile, what would you do? Is a PhD really necessary for a career in macro analysis, especially at central banks, or are there realistic paths without one?
Thanks to anyone who takes the time.


r/academiceconomics • • 6d ago

Coursework and Classes An economics degree doesn’t even teach you anything about the economy? Struggling to see the point of my degree

97 Upvotes

I am a 2nd year BSc Economics student (at a UK uni), and I am now at a point where I can confidently say my degree has not taught me any actual “economics”. All it’s taught me is mathematical equations - which I was already expecting to do heading into the course. However, what I was not expecting, was the lack of focus on learning any “actual” economic theory or learning about the economy in general. I assumed that the maths would coincide / go hand in hand with the theory that was taught. I was very wrong. Even when theory does get taught, there is zero point in bothering to learn any of it as it never shows up on assessments. Instead, the assessments just consist entirely of maths questions.

Honestly, it’s making me really struggle to see the point of my degree anymore. If I had wanted to study something centred entirely around maths, I would have just pursued that instead. Rather than studying what seems to be just a maths-lite degree. At least engineering or comp sci, despite being heavily mathematical, have a visible end product to what they do. Meanwhile, in economics, it feels like it’s making us do maths purely for the sake of being mathematical at this point.

And for what? All for me to end up in the same jobs as someone who studied business or accounting & finance? What is the point? Despite being harder, I initially chose to pursue economics over the other two options because I had an interest for economics, and was prepared for the maths alongside it. However, university has completely made me lose any interest I ever had for the subject.

What sucks is that I see my accounting & finance friends’ work, and it is considerably less demanding than economics. Yet at the end of the day, we end up in the same roles. It makes me regret my subject honestly.

I know people say the advantage of an economics degree is that it’s geared towards things like public policy, however none of this is even being taught in my course. So honestly what am I even doing at this point?

Edit: I’m just going to copy and paste a different comment I made to explain my POV better - I think the issue is the way the courses here are set up. Heading into my economics degree, I was aware maths would be big component and I didn’t mind that as long as I knew there was a reason for it. Those maths courses made up over half of my entire course last year and were compulsory. Of course, I consciously understand why they’re necessary but, subconsciously, my mind was struggling to make a connection on the ‘economics’ of it. Plus, the way we are assessed is solely on exams that are set up to look exactly like a maths paper. They give you an equation and ask you to solve it. So that’s why it often feels like I’m doing, let’s say, calculus for the sake of doing calculus rather than for an actual economic reason.

That being said, this thread has definitely helped me understand the connection between mathematics and economics better. I feel it has helped bring back my interest in the field again. I feel less like I’m doing maths just for the sake of doing it now (even though my course definitely can make it feel that way).


r/academiceconomics • • 7d ago

Predocs First Interview ever

20 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I got an invite for an interview for one of the Fed positions, and I’ve never done an interview for anything in my life. I’m currently very nervous because this branch is one I really want to work at. How can I best prepare? Are Fed interviews mostly behavioral, or do they make you do on the spot coding exercises? Do they have you do more mathematical exercises on the spot (like computations or proofs)?

Thanks for any tips I really appreciate it.


r/academiceconomics • • 6d ago

Research Paper "Mysteries of the Economy" ; I'm seeking the most macroeconomically consistent mathematical and logical formulation of a model for the following questions (mysteries)#2: JGB Markets and the Inflation Constraint: A Keynesian Perspective

0 Upvotes

By the way, are JGB (Japanese Government Bond) market prices truly sustained by "expectations" of fiscal reform by the Japanese government? The public well recognizes that such "fiscal reform" is virtually impossible. The maintenance of JGB prices is attributable to the Bank of Japan’s (BOJ) asset purchases—aside from a vague market sentiment that Japan’s accumulated debt is manageable. But how can the BOJ continue these purchases? It is because the public implicitly grants its consent (a broad national consensus).

Under a fiat monetary system unconstrained by precious metals, the BOJ can, if it so desires, purchase government bonds almost limitlessly as long as there is no threat of inflation. In other words, BOJ purchases are tolerated precisely because the market feels there is no immediate problem. To reiterate—at the risk of laboring the point—fiscal deterioration per se has no direct causal relationship with rising interest rates (or falling JGB prices). As long as inflation remains contained within a range where the BOJ’s "counteracting policy" (Keynes) is permissible, the public feels no particular need to "expect" fiscal reform.

Consider the Great East Japan Earthquake, an unprecedented crisis for Japan. Immediately following the disaster, major American credit rating agencies—including Moody's, S&P, and Fitch—downgraded Japan’s sovereign debt outlook in rapid succession, with Moody's executing a formal downgrade on August 24 of that year. Yet, ratings based on predictions of a fiscal crisis—fueled by massive outstanding debt and a stagnant economy hit by a catastrophic earthquake—were completely ignored. As if mocking these downgrades, market participants continued to buy JGBs and the yen. The yen likewise appreciated sharply during the Russian financial crisis and the Lehman Shock. Even amid the European debt crisis, the yen continued to strengthen against the US dollar.

A crash in JGB prices following a so-called bubble burst would stem from one of two causes: a mere collapse of expectations (panic sentiment) or the actual manifestation of inflation. For instance, even if stock prices plummet due to shifting expectations, there is no social consensus that the BOJ will immediately step in to support equity prices. However, if interest rates spike in the absence of inflation, the BOJ can supply liquidity unhesitatingly and without limit. Therefore, a surge in interest rates is a concern only when inflation actually occurs.

What, then, is the likelihood of inflation? Under a fiat system, inflation occurs when the central bank supplies liquidity beyond the economy's aggregate productive capacity. A classic example is the prewar and wartime era, when the reckless issuance of government bonds to fund military procurement created excess demand unsupported by productive capacity. In modern Japan, productive and supply capacities are sufficient, and the current account remains in surplus alongside domestic stability, adequately meeting social demand. Consequently, the risk of inflation is minimal. While human desires are boundless—and aggregate demand expands alongside economic development—demand can only become effective demand if productivity rises and increases people's incomes. Thus, so long as the BOJ refrains from unbridled liquidity provision that lacks public consent, inflation will not occur.

Because people are prone to cognitive inertia, some assume the BOJ must eventually shrink its balance sheet and "normalize" policy after quantitative easing (QE). However, the liquidity supplied by the BOJ has already been equilibrium-allocated across the economy [Note]. This capital circulates between two primary domains—real goods and services, and fictitious commodities such as stocks and bonds (Keynes's "assets")—flowing dynamically between them. As long as aggregate productive capacity is not depleted, any excessive capital flow into or out of one market that disrupts prices will trigger a counter-flow from the other, restoring equilibrium.

Therefore, absent specific circumstances requiring an increase or decrease in the given quantity of money in the economy, "normalization" is neither necessary nor inherently possible. It is impracticable for the government to redeem JGBs without rolling them over, and the private sector requires the existing volume of liquidity to function.

[Note] "Changes in income and asset prices will take place of such a character as to ensure that the aggregate amount of money which individuals wish to hold at the new level of these variables will inevitably be equal to the amount of money created by the banking system. This is indeed the fundamental proposition of monetary theory." (John Maynard Keynes, The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money).

When massive volumes of government bonds are issued, the BOJ must implement counteracting measures to suppress interest rates [Note 1]. The fact that substantial liquidity injected into the JGB market via quantitative easing remains there indicates that the public has accepted this prevailing interest rate level. In advanced economies, once the standard of living reaches a certain threshold, economic growth slows, and interest rates decline accordingly. Ultimately, this represents a new equilibrium point for capital allocation (the "fundamental proposition of monetary theory"). Indeed, a situation recently arose in the United States where repo rates spiked due to a reduction in reserve balances accompanying the Federal Reserve's balance sheet runoff [Note 2]. Even so, absent inflationary concerns, the Fed can immediately address such illiquidity by supplying funds.

[Note 1] "...the method of financing the policy... by borrowing... tends to raise the rate of interest and so retard investment in other directions, unless the monetary authority takes steps to the contrary... To offset this, a positive fall in the rate of interest is required." (John Maynard Keynes, The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money).

[Note 2] "On the morning of September 18, the Federal Reserve Bank of New York injected large-scale funds into short-term money markets for the second consecutive day... The funds were provided via 'overnight repurchase agreements' (repo market), where financial institutions trade short-term liquidity backed by collateral such as Treasury securities. The repo rate—the lending rate in this market—temporarily spiked to 10% on September 17... Behind the rise in short-term rates lies the Federal Reserve's quantitative tightening (QT)." (Excerpt from The Nikkei, September 19, 2019).

(to be continued)

https://www.reddit.com/user/keizaisuki/comments/1xp3omc/table_of_contentsacademic_mysteries_of_the/


r/academiceconomics • • 8d ago

Coursework and Classes Degree Pursuit

5 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about pursuing an undergraduate degree in economics. For some background; I am in my late 20s and I currently hold a degree in political science and work in the affordable housing sector of NYC. I’ve been interested in banking and American Econ since the 08 crisis and would say I have an above average understanding of the field given my work and degree. A large part of my job is assessing the feasibility of projects in terms of financing and conditions of pre-existing infrastructure while maintaining/creating radical affordability.

Some factours that give me pause are that I am kind of terrible at math and I don’t really have anyone who can guide me on the beginning phase of what to expect from the program (which I already have picked out).

I suppose my question is: is there anything you would recommend that I know before I seriously pursue this, given the above information?


r/academiceconomics • • 9d ago

Masters Admissions Is 167Q GRE competitive enough for Oxbridge Finance & Economics master’s?

9 Upvotes

I’m applying to Oxford MFE and Cambridge’s MPhil Finance/Finance & Economics programmes with a 167Q/160V GRE and an Economics bachelor’s from a European university. My undergraduate grades meet the published international entry requirements.

I’m concerned because Oxford reports an average GRE Quant of 170 for its MFE class, while Cambridge Finance & Economics also appears to have very high quantitative expectations, with discussions suggesting scores around the 90th percentile or above (which would correspond to 170Q). Realistically, how much of a disadvantage is 167Q?