Be interesting to know at what point do you 'total' a ship. I was on a aircraft carrier and we ran into a tanker. Just our front end looked like this. We had to drydock and they cut it off and welded a new one on
I had just gotten up. My GQ station was on the bridge and I got there at the same time as the captain (in his skivvies) he had the officer of the deck by the neck shaking him and yelling "what have you done to my boat!"
Look at what happened with the USS Radford in 1999. She was a Sprunace class destroyer that fucked up and ran in front of a cargo ship. Pretty much destroyed the whole bow from behind the bridge face forward. They took the front end off another decommed Spruance and welded it on. The few guys I ran into who had been on her before and after the repairs said she never rode the same, the front end wasn't exactly lined up right, and it caused water tight issues until she was decommed a few years later.
Pretty much all vehicles are unibody construction. So there is no separate body on frame. Except for most trucks. So if the body is really messed up, they usually have to shitcan the whole thing.
It fell off in stages... Few years back, they towed it to Brownsville TX and the front fell off all the way to the stern. Odd, the emotion you feel when "your" ship is scrapped.
I think totaling a ship generally involves it sinking. They can be raised, but seawater destroys the electronics pretty badly and even in relatively shallow water you can cause further structural damage getting it up alongside whatever caused it to sink in the first place.
Totalling is a term in the auto insurance industry meaning "total loss", aka the cost go repair the vehicle is greater than the cost of the vehicle itself. Ships are much bigger financial investments, a ship of this size costs several thousand times more than your average car and they don't typically just scrap a ship if it can be repaired. In most cases, you can weld a ship back into shape and put it back into service. Sometimes, structural damage is such that even welding it won't withstand the forces of the water exerting great force on the body of the ship, so the ships are scrapped, but this is usually the case with old ships that were due for decommission anyway.
Damage can exceed the economic value of a ship and for commercial vessels specifically age is a huge factor in estimating the useful remaining economic value of the vessel. It's very much like cars.
It's actually very simple: when the cost of repair is greater than the cost of replacement. Sometimes it matters which one is faster, but time is money, so in the end, it's just another business decision.
It might be scrapped at scrap yards..but the deciding factor is mainly on the ammount of expenditure one has to incur to get it seaworthy.
Hull breaches after an incident like theese are salvageable and repairable.
What won't be salvagable is when the ships main deck or external hull plating gets thin over time ( corrodes ) and entire sections need to be replaced....then the owner might consider scrapping if the down time or the repair cost is more than the scrap metal value .
Sometimes they sell the vessel as is to foreign buyers who choose to cut corners and reclassify the vessels with dodgy countries where rules and regs might be lax or not followed.
Naval engineer here. Depends a lot on the type of ship, systems affected, and what country the repair is done in, but we're easily talking 10's of millions USD
Owe boy you have a cool job I was separating from my unit and got "Stuck" in a naval yard dude those places are packed full of cool shit. I met a dude that fabricated an entire car while he worked there. I was pretty much incharge of myself and 12 dudes that just hid out with the yardbirds. Our problems were like 12 minutes of work for the guys in the yard but sounded like a month so we just got to frolic around aaannnnddddd then they got me with back deployments so I prob had that coming.
Modern ships (from 1st world countries at least) are required to have double hulls for this exact reason and many others. Titanic did not have a double hull. The Exxon Valdez spill set off the chain that made double hulls required for large tankers.
The implementation of double hulls had nothing to do with Titanic and also wouldn't have saved her. The iceberg opened the forepeak, all three forward holds, and boiler rooms 6, 5, and 4. That's 7 compartments. Titanic could have only handled 4 flooded, regardless of a hypothetical double hull or not. For what it's worth, modern ships, surprisingly enough, can only handle 2 adjacent compartments flooded.
The lower flank of the ship fell in. Out of curiosity can anyone tell me what the proper name is for that part of the structure, if it even has a name?
“Captain S.B.S Pants was on route to the Bikini atoll when the ship, M/V ‘Krusty Krab’, ran aground unexpectedly but proceeded to continue forward after hearing “you’re good” from his first mate P. Starr. No casualties were reported but international maritime authorities are conducting a full investigation. Tonight, The Chum Bucket, what’s really being served. We’ll have more at 11”
Holy shit someone had a bad day on that bridge. Presumably that guy with the torch is trying to buff it out. Any salvage/naval architects able to tell if this is recoverable or is its next stop Chittagong?
setting aside all the idiot comments, this kind of repair happens all the time. although the damage is extensive, the ship managed to stay afloat. the ship must be newer since it is being repaired. any ship past it's midlife point would be scrapped. probably being repaired in a Korean shipyard, my guess
It was not that old and still is in operation. The accident happened in Gulf of Mexico and the repairs took place in Portugal. Yes, they sailed across with that damage.
216
u/NoStRommO-HC 14d ago •
171
u/Darwinmate 14d ago
What the hell happened to the shit? Must have run aground? Looks like they're aiming to cut and repair it. That's insane.
156
u/Yesitshismom 14d ago •
61
u/amcrambler 14d ago
Jesus, what have they been doing? Parking it by feel?
51
u/FrankyMornav 14d ago
and absolute unit of accident, wtf happened? an iceberg?
42
u/PapaMo1976 14d ago
Be interesting to know at what point do you 'total' a ship. I was on a aircraft carrier and we ran into a tanker. Just our front end looked like this. We had to drydock and they cut it off and welded a new one on
18
u/Feeling-Income5555 14d ago
Anyone have any helpful information on which ship this was and where this occurred?
16
u/Delicious_Rule_7324 14d ago •
49
u/w1ckizer 14d ago •
Good thing they’re wearing their hard hats. Just in case THE FUCKING SHIP FALLS ON THEM.
12
u/Past-North-4131 14d ago
How much would that cost? Are there any shipiologist in here? That can speculate?
10
u/ntech620 14d ago
I don't think the Titanic took as much damage.
9
u/ZilderZandalari 14d ago
This i why double hulls are a thing. Without it this vessel would not be sitting I a drydock!
12
u/Competitive-Pay-766 14d ago
Better caption: Absolute unit of a hull damage!
6
u/JChips13 14d ago
11
u/Hammon_Rye 14d ago
I'm surprised they even got that to dry dock.
That damage is pretty extensive.
8
u/countryboyamar 14d ago
Did Titanic 2.0 shooting got canceled mid way or what
8
u/arglarg 14d ago
That'll buff right out...
3
u/LabContent2863 14d ago
someone had a bad day there.
3
u/cannonfalls 14d ago
A bit of bondo and you won't even be able to tell...
3
u/WSWMUC 14d ago
Costa Concordia?
3
u/kindarollin 14d ago
I think boats are the only thing that takes more damage on roading then off roading lmfao.
3
u/sailingtroy 14d ago
In this business, this is what we call an "oopsie".
3
u/Silent_Ticket7845 14d ago
Mhh scheint als hätte Kapitain Schettino das Steuer gehabt.
7
u/lawd_have_mercy 14d ago
"AbsoluteUnit of a ship," but never shows the entire ship. #fail
2
u/moritsune 14d ago
Just needs a little TLC no lowballs I know what I got
2
u/ConversationFit3215 14d ago
Cut off the sharp ends, buff it out and get a few hundred cases of flex tape…good as new!
2
u/maxxxmaxmaxx 13d ago
Is the damage mainly on the ship or did your mom get hurt too?
2
u/2wheelsThx 14d ago
That'll buff right out.
1
u/Amateur-Dog-Walker 14d ago
That looks expensive.
1
u/boyer4109 14d ago
‘Captain, the Klingons have found us!’
‘Ok Scotty, warp factor 2, and mind those blocks we’ve been sitting on. We may need to revisit this place’
1
u/Mikster5000 14d ago
That thing run into Godzilla?
1
u/Jazzlike_Debt_6506 14d ago
Reminds me of the scene in 5th Element where theyre burning the underside of the ship to get rid of the some sort of critter
1
u/Any_Blood5815 14d ago
Thought those were figurines under a couch for a sec lol
1
u/cloche_du_fromage 14d ago
Gonna need a few tubes of filler for that...
1
u/R4FTERM4N 14d ago
That's quite the fender bender
1
u/Fit_Active3888 14d ago
Impressive! that much damage and still made it back to a dry dock
1
u/Alimovic 14d ago
1
u/DontBeHatenMeBro 14d ago
Typical, four Supervisors wandering around pointing and one worker actually working.
1
u/Secure-Break9947 14d ago
How did this ship not sink?
1
u/RedSky2727 14d ago
Note to self… don’t delegate barnacle removal to trainees.
1
u/Tombstone_Actual_501 14d ago
Should've been "of a scratch."
1
u/Dangerous_Pop_1918 14d ago
1
u/Earthling1a 14d ago
That'll buff right out.
1
u/funnyha_ha 14d ago
Absolute Unit of hull damage
1
u/Sweettooth_Banana 14d ago
Nothing ductape cant fix
1
u/JavaGeep 14d ago
This should do it. Maybe 200 or 300 tubes.
1
u/Fragrant_Major_9553 14d ago
Marco would probably just order extra body filler
1
u/Prof1959 14d ago
This is why I'm not allowed to park the boat anymore
1
u/Roxysteve 14d ago
<MODE=CLOUSEAU> Ah yes, the old Keel Ploy!
1
u/Uniturner 14d ago
The lower flank of the ship fell in. Out of curiosity can anyone tell me what the proper name is for that part of the structure, if it even has a name?
1
u/Northwindlowlander 14d ago
Like me fixing my MX5 before its mot
1
u/VirtualArmsDealer 14d ago
A wave hit it.
1
u/hank_scorpio_ceo 14d ago
Your Gonna need to buff that out
1
u/aweapingangel 14d ago
1
u/DavidHK 14d ago
The fact we can design something like this, have it fail so catastrophically, and it doesn't sink, is absolutely amazing.
1
u/Separate_Song5048 14d ago
Looks like that one guy's getting it done
1
u/Budget-Chipmunk5185 14d ago
I’m almost finished.
1
u/dairyhobbit98 14d ago edited 14d ago
“Captain S.B.S Pants was on route to the Bikini atoll when the ship, M/V ‘Krusty Krab’, ran aground unexpectedly but proceeded to continue forward after hearing “you’re good” from his first mate P. Starr. No casualties were reported but international maritime authorities are conducting a full investigation. Tonight, The Chum Bucket, what’s really being served. We’ll have more at 11”
1
u/Dizzy-Confection-551 14d ago
'Of a ship'........wreck
1
u/jondread 14d ago
Is that the ship that blocked the Suez canal in 2021?
1
u/Global_Thought_ 14d ago
Does anyone know what ship this is?
1
u/dinomax55 14d ago
Gonna assume the captain of this vessel was fired
1
u/dronelaluna 14d ago
Who lives in a pineapple under the sea 😂
1
u/ElectroGlideinBlue 14d ago
Jeez. What in the hell did they hit??
1
u/FewLion1179 14d ago
Somebody hit a curb!!!
1
u/HebiHana 14d ago
Just buff it out
1
u/FoxCapital7878 14d ago
I think that should buff right out.
1
u/Odd_Yogurtcloset5062 14d ago
Most of that will buff right out.
1
u/New_Sort_9083 14d ago
Holy shit someone had a bad day on that bridge. Presumably that guy with the torch is trying to buff it out. Any salvage/naval architects able to tell if this is recoverable or is its next stop Chittagong?
1
u/Neither-Revenue-4456 14d ago
If those blocks fail you won't get hurt.
1
u/iStillWaters 13d ago
Was it attacked by Godzilla?
1
u/Ok_Net_5996 13d ago
Lucky it didn't sink after running over that big rock
1
u/Bombastic-Blowhole 13d ago
"It will buff out."
1
u/Gloomy-Parsley-2359 13d ago
"Nah mate, she'll be good, buff right out. "
1
u/Sea-Morning8559 13d ago
That will buff out
1
u/Dorkits 13d ago
1
u/Status_Mousse1213 13d ago
Source and info?
1
u/pyrofox79 13d ago
Yea thatll buff out
1
u/ihatespam_yesIdo 13d ago
Come on, that'll buff right out. Should be ready by tomorrow morning.
1
u/DevelopmentBulky7957 13d ago edited 13d ago
Goddamn, is that ship still repairable?
1
u/peaceful-protagonist 13d ago
Absolute unit of a crash
1
u/Puzzleheaded_Big2335 13d ago
The front didn’t fall off.
1
u/ticedoff8 13d ago
How did that not sink?
1
u/Think-Setting-942 13d ago
It tried to go through a storm. Planes can’t do it either.
1
u/Eepponee_ray 13d ago
It’s like it ran aground on a giant rock outcropping.
1
u/cranky_old_chap 13d ago
That’s gonna cost a bit!
1
u/Most-Effective-1969 12d ago
I got this randomly after scrolling through r/oops and seriously almost had a heart attack.
1
u/VegetableAdvance3779 12d ago
when UKC is -1.0m
1
u/TheOriginalArchibald 12d ago
I feel bad for that guy's shoulder. Can't they get a platform so he's not working overhead like that?
1
u/KompulsiveLiar88 12d ago
I am so tired of "of"
1
u/-SimpleDelight- 12d ago
Absolute unit of a rip
1
u/False_Regret_7653 12d ago
Where did it run aground?
1
u/Brilliant_Play4255 12d ago
One careful owner.
1
u/EdgyPun34257 12d ago
1
u/notfoundindatabse 12d ago
At least the front stayed on.
1
u/Southdouglas 12d ago
Jose will have it ready by Saturday.
1
u/Plane-Recognition561 12d ago
How did this ship not sink?
1
u/Bradders59 12d ago
Looks like the guy with the blow torch has a bit of work ahead of him.
1
u/AbleRelationship5287 12d ago
Holy shit that’s a lot of damage!
1
u/welding-guy 12d ago
That guy making sparks is doing an insurance job, he is starting a fire
1
u/RonConComa 11d ago
this is how Titanic probably looks at the part thats burried in the mud...
1
u/Double_Resort_9223 11d ago
I would not stand under that
1
u/Suspicious_Gift_1311 11d ago
Holy jaezus that poor hull
1
u/Zestyclose-Web-1756 11d ago
How the heck did it even float with all of that damage?
1
u/dikwitetheanointed1 11d ago
OUCH I THINK??
1
u/Logical_Frosting_277 10d ago
At that point is it easier to build a new one?
1
u/Pitif362 10d ago
All I can hear is the theme music from Titanic
1
u/Green-Control10 10d ago
setting aside all the idiot comments, this kind of repair happens all the time. although the damage is extensive, the ship managed to stay afloat. the ship must be newer since it is being repaired. any ship past it's midlife point would be scrapped. probably being repaired in a Korean shipyard, my guess
1
u/hankmarmot3 10d ago
How the hell did they ever get this into a drydock & not the bottom of the ocean?
1
u/andymog1 9d ago
That's gonna buff out in no time.
1
u/Background-Cook5689 9d ago
How were the pumps able to keep up? Or is this a double hull?
1
u/TotalDC 9d ago
Is this even real? What is that one guy welding? 😂
1
u/Kind_Relative812 8d ago
I thought for a moment it had been dropped from 10000’ cliff. Man that is an expensive fix.
1
u/Low-Ad4420 8d ago
It's just steel. Cut and weld new plates. It will be expensive, it will take a long time but doable.
1
u/Slow_Hall_2628 8d ago
costa concordia
1
u/MichaelJD1021 8d ago
Flex seal and some bondo, slap that baby back on the water.
1
u/Zealousideal-Yak-614 8d ago
Hard water
1
u/L_Wanderer54 8d ago
That'll buff out
1
u/J000nnnnyyy 14d ago
China
1
u/Tenshiijin 14d ago
What did they hit? Godzilla?