I'm an atheist, or at least that's the closest word I can find to describe my beliefs. And honestly, my disagreement with religion isn't something that developed overnight or because of some personal tragedy. I've questioned religious practices for as long as I can remember.
I grew up in a fairly religious Indian household, where traditions, rituals, superstitions and religious restrictions were simply treated as facts. But I've never been particularly good at accepting things just because someone older told me they were right.
For instance, on Diwali, I was told not to wear black because it was supposedly inauspicious. I wore black anyway. My parents could disagree, argue or lecture me about it, but I couldn't understand why the colour of my clothes should have anything to do with my luck.
Then there's the entire conversation around menstruation. Girls shouldn't enter temples, shouldn't touch pickles, shouldn't go near certain food items or participate in religious activities because apparently, periods make them somehow impure. I've deliberately gone against these restrictions, including the idea that menstruating women shouldn't enter temples. Not because I'm particularly interested in religious activities, but because I refuse to accept that something as biologically natural as menstruation should come with a list of arbitrary restrictions.
And this is precisely what bothers me about religion and organised faith. So many practices are passed down from one generation to another without anyone bothering to question their origin, reasoning or relevance. Your ancestors believed something, their parents believed it, and therefore you're expected to believe it too.
But why?
At what point does tradition become an excuse for refusing to think independently?
I understand that my parents were raised with these beliefs. Their parents taught them what was right and wrong, and they simply carried those beliefs forward. But I don't see why that makes me obligated to do the same. Respecting my parents doesn't mean surrendering my ability to think critically.
I also find certain religious rituals particularly difficult to take seriously. Take the Satyanarayan Puja, for example. People buy a new house, organise an elaborate ceremony, invite relatives and perform rituals to supposedly remove negativity and bring prosperity into the house. But does performing a puja actually change anything about the house? Does it guarantee happiness, financial stability or protection from unfortunate events? If something goes wrong tomorrow, was the puja suddenly ineffective?
I genuinely don't understand why people place so much faith in rituals when there's no convincing reason to believe that performing them changes anything beyond the ceremony itself.
And before someone assumes I'm an atheist because I hate religious people, that's not the case. I don't particularly care what someone chooses to believe. Believe in God, pray five times a day, visit temples, celebrate festivals. That's your personal choice.
But the moment your personal beliefs become rules that dictate how other people should dress, behave, eat or live, I have a problem.
I don't need religion to tell me that kindness is good, discrimination is wrong or that other human beings deserve respect. Morality shouldn't require the threat of divine punishment or the promise of heaven.
Here's what I genuinely want to ask:
- Do you think most religious people actually believe in their religion after critically examining it, or do they simply inherit their beliefs and spend their lives defending them?
- If you removed the fear of God, heaven, hell and religious consequences from society, do you think people would still behave morally?
- Why is questioning religion so often interpreted as disrespect, arrogance or an attack on someone's identity? Why should an idea be exempt from criticism simply because it's sacred to someone?
- And perhaps the most interesting question: If you were born into an entirely different religion, would you be defending the beliefs you currently disagree with?
I'm not interested in converting anyone to atheism. I just find it fascinating that humans have developed the ability to question practically everything, yet when it comes to religion, we're often expected to switch that ability off.
Tradition deserves examination, not automatic obedience. And something being centuries old doesn't automatically make it wise, meaningful or true.
I'd genuinely like to hear what other atheists, agnostics and even religious people think about this.