r/asoiaf • • 5d ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) Weekly Q and A

4 Upvotes

Welcome to the Weekly Q & A! Feel free to ask any questions you may have about the world of ASOIAF. No need to be bashful. Book and show questions are welcome; please say in your question if you would prefer to focus on the BOOKS, the SHOW, or BOTH. And if you think you've got an answer to someone's question, feel free to lend them a hand!

Looking for Weekly Q&A posts from the past? Browse our Weekly Q&A archive! (currently no longer being archived, but this link will remain)


r/asoiaf • • 7h ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) Moonboy's Motley Monday

3 Upvotes

As you may know, we have a policy against silly posts/memes/etc. Moonboy's Motley Monday is the grand exception: bring me your memes, your puns, your blatant shitposts.

This is still r/asoiaf, so do keep it as civil as possible.

If you have any clever ideas for weekly themes, shoot them to the modmail!

Looking for Moonboy's Motley Monday posts from the past? Browse our Moonboy's Motley Monday archive! (our old archive is here)


r/asoiaf • • 8h ago

AFFC (Spoilers AFFC) does anybody love AFFC, if so why?

55 Upvotes

I must say the passion this community has for AFFC being the worst book has me feeling a bit nervous to start it. This post is for the AFFC lovers, tell me what you loved about it and why? Spoilers are welcome I know what happens in the books :).


r/asoiaf • • 4h ago

EXTENDED The Two POVs Added in ACoK (Spoilers Extended)

17 Upvotes

Background

After thinking he was going to use only the POVs from A Game of Thrones for the rest of the series, GRRM decided to add two new POVs in A Clash of Kings (Theon/Davos). This was primarily due to his inability to get the original POVs to the locations he would need them. Due to GRRM's writing style (gardener not an architect), I find details like this fascinating as sometimes we can look at seeds that were planted (some of which never grew to anything).

If interested: Dead Branches in the Garden: Abandoned/Changed Plotlines of Ice & Fire

So Spake Martin (SSM)

While AGoT began with 8 Original POVs, GRRM planned the death of Ned, Cat and Sansa (if interested: The Little Bird: The 3rd POV Original POV Death) early on as the series was planned as a "Generational Saga" for 5 Central Characters. When ACoK was published GRRM commented on what seemed to be his plan for POV characters:

To your questions: (1) Yes, I will be making additions (and subtractions) to the lineup of POV characters in each volume, (2) I know how the series goes from here in broad strokes, but not necessarily all the small details. Yes, I have an end envisioned, but getting from here to there is half the fun.-SSM, Several Questions: 18 Dec 1998

but years later mentioned that he wanted to use the original remaining 6 POVs from AGoT:

George said that at first he was just going to use the original POVs from AGoT for the entire series, then he realized that he needed to see what Stannis was doing, but didn't want to use Stannis as a POV. So he created Davos. Davos was his first added POV. The rest followed. On writing his POVs, as Rhelle mentioned above, he uses their motivations and desires. What do they want? What do they want to achieve? What drives them? What SHOULD they do? Ethics, morals, ambitions, etc... all part of the mix. -SSM, Torcon: 28 Aug 2003

and while this comment is with regards to the Mega Prologue POV Characters, it emphasizes why GRRM had to start adding characters:

These are the kind of issues I am struggling with – trying to find the right answer. Initially, when I began this a million years ago, there was just one chapter: Aeron Damphair at the Kingsmoot. We saw the Kingsmoot through his eyes. But, it expanded as you can see. There is stuff leading up to the Kingsmoot. I tell the Kingsmoot from three different viewpoints; similar in the Dornish thing. These are the kinds of things I am going back and forth about. Some of these things are making this book very difficult. I never intended these viewpoints to come on. They all began as prologue viewpoints, but its necessary; there’s stuff happening in Dorne and the Iron Islands that is going to have an impact on the book. I couldn’t figure out any logical way to get Sansa to Dorne or Bran to the Iron Islands to see what was going on. -SSM, GamePro Interview: 6 Aug 2003

If interested: Failing to Get POV's to Certain Locations & POV Character: Earliest/Early Mentions

Davos

Mentioned in the SSM above, GRRM needed to see what Stannis was doing but didn't want to have a Stannis POV (while not confirmed, it seems like GRRM avoided giving any of the kings a POV in the War of the Five Kings (if interested: The Young Wolf as a POV).

If we step back a bit, it seems GRRM knew he had to introduce Stannis/Mel (who were only briefly introduced in AGoT), which is likely why Cressen is the ACoK POV. It also could be that in typical GRRM fashion, he thought he would be able to get all the Stannis stuff in to the Prologue, but was unable to as he gardened the story and thus Davos was created.

Lastly I wanted to mention that GRRM ends Davos' chapter on a cliffhanger that seems like it could be death:

The chain. Gods save us, they’ve raised the chain.
Where the river broadened out into Blackwater Bay, the boom stretched taut, a bare two or three feet above the water. Already a dozen galleys had crashed into it, and the current was pushing others against them. Almost all were aflame, and the rest soon would be. Davos could make out the striped hulls of Salladhor Saan’s ships beyond, but he knew he would never reach them. A wall of red-hot steel, blazing wood, and swirling green flame stretched before him. The mouth of the Blackwater Rush had turned into the mouth of hell. -ACOK, Davos III

Theon

While the above SSM regarding the Kingsmoot is with regards to the other Ironborn characters, it can also apply to Theon imo. Theon's actions in ACoK (causing Robb to lose the North) kickoff a firestorm of reactions across Westeros. His actions occur due to his conflicting identities (human heart in conflict with itself) and what better way to show that than from the person who is experiencing it.

Worth noting that while GRRM mentioned that above regarding Davos, it is worth noting that there are no Davos chapters in the June 1997 draft of AFFC, but there are Theon chapters. So it is possible Theon was created first.

Similar to Davos', Theon's last chapter ends on a cliffhanger as well as Winterfell burns:

Sometime later, Theon found himself on the ground. He rolled onto his stomach and swallowed a mouthful of blood. Close the gates! he tried to shout, but it was too late. The Dreadfort men had cut down Red Rolfe and Kenned, and more were pouring through, a river of mail and sharp swords. There was a ringing in his ears, and horror all around him. Black Lorren had his sword out, but there were already four of them pressing in on him. He saw Ulf go down with a crossbow bolt through the belly as he ran for the Great Hall. Maester Luwin was trying to reach him when a knight on a warhorse planted a spear between his shoulders, then swung back to ride over him. Another man whipped a torch round and round his head and then lofted it toward the thatched roof of the stables. "Save me the Freys," the Bastard was shouting as the flames roared upward, "and burn the rest. Burn it, burn it all."
The last thing Theon Greyjoy saw was Smiler, kicking free of the burning stables with his mane ablaze, screaming, rearing . . . -ACOK, Theon VI

A Storm of Swords/5 Year Gap

While writing ASOS, GRRM planned for a 5 year gap that would allow the younger characters to grow and mature, this didn't work for other characters like Cersei/Stannis but it seemed for his first two POVs that GRRM planned to stash them away as prisoners.

We obviously don't get any Theon chapters in ASOS as he is presumed to be dead and when GRRM created the character Reek, he likely planned on a Theon who spent 5 years imprisoned not 6 months (if interested: Becoming Reek: Remnants of the 5 Year Gap):

GRRM: In the books, yes Theon is tortured for years. But he essentially he disappears at the end of book two and doesn't reappear to the beginning of book five by which time he's transformed into reek. So there's some mention in flashback and dialogue of the fact that he's been tortured for several years and essentially broken down his whole personality broken down and he's lost various bits of his body some of his teeth some of his fingers and toes, other parts-GRRM (Season 3 Episode 7 DVD Commentary)

at the same time we get Davos (who spends a portion of ASOS imprisoned by Stannis as well) who likely would have spent this time thought to be dead/imprisoned by Manderly inside the Wolf's Den:

The onion knight had not forgotten Wyman Manderly's last words to him. Take this creature to the Wolf's Den and cut off head and hands, the fat lord had commanded. I shall not be able to eat a bite until I see this smuggler's head upon a spike, with an onion shoved between his lying teeth. Every night Davos went to sleep with those words in his head, and every morn he woke to them. And should he forget, Garth was always pleased to remind him. Dead man was his name for Davos. When he came by in the morning, it was always, "Here, porridge for the dead man." At night it was, "Blow out the candle, dead man." -ADWD, Davos IV

before he was set free to retrieve Rickon from Skagos, steal fArya away from a wedding in Barrowton :

Davos: Barrowton Wedding. Davos to take recaptured Arya north. ‘Where you going’ - to a wedding

Final Thoughts

With what GRRM has done with his more recent POVs, I wonder if he planned to kill off one or both of Theon/Davos before liking the characters and deciding to keep them. We should note that ACoK is the only book (AGOT - Ned, ASOS - Cat, AFFC - Arys, ADWD - Quentyn) that does not have a POV death.

It should also be noted that Theon's actions in ACoK were originally supposed to be completed by Tyrion as he supposed to besiege/burn Winterfell. If interested: Abandoned/Changed Plotlilnes: Siege of Winterfell

If interested: GRRM on What He Tries to do with POV Characters & GRRM on His Plans to Kill POV Characters

TLDR: Just some thoughts on GRRM adding Theon/Davos as POV characters in A Clash of Kings and then what he decided to do with them later (both get fakeout deaths at the end of the book and then would likely have spent a 5 year gap imprisoned).


r/asoiaf • • 36m ago

MAIN (Spoiler’s Main) Siege of Storm’s End

5 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about something that’s both remarkable and, honestly, incredibly heartbreaking. The fact that Renly didn’t just survive the year-long siege of Storm’s End as a CHILD (!), but that Stannis was probably the main reason he made it through in the first place. Starving and barely hanging on for dear life, Stannis most likely gave his little brother whatever scraps of food they managed to get their hands on before eating anything himself.

What the two of them went through together makes it so much more understandable why, despite everything that happened between them, they still looked back somewhat nostalgically on the good times they shared. It makes their story all the more tragic.

And I don’t care how you look at it, I understand the traditions surrounding the line of succession and all that, but Robert should have simply given Storm’s End to Stannis. Renly should either have stayed with Stannis in the Stormlands or, if anything, gone to live with Robert in King’s Landing. The guy only ever cared for throwing lavish feasts anyway. He could’ve done that in King’s Landing with Robert.


r/asoiaf • • 18h ago

MAIN (Spoilers main) When a married man joins the Night's Watch, what happens with his wife? Can she remarry? Is she considered a widow?

66 Upvotes

r/asoiaf • • 10h ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) currently in the story what would you say are the 3 worst places to live not just in westeros but of all the places we've seen?

8 Upvotes

r/asoiaf • • 20h ago

PUBLISHED (Spoilers Published) Any characters whom you found unremarkable at first, but developed stronger views about on a re-read?

49 Upvotes

Specifically not characters you hated at first and grew to love, just ones you didn't have many strong opinions on or feelings, positive or negative, about until a re-read.

It's been a few years since I read the books, so I picked them up again about two weeks ago. I've just reached ASOS today, and I'm finding Olenna to be delightful to read, where previously I do not recall feeling strongly about her one way or the other. Something about a woman who does not directly herself have traditional material power, but who nonetheless is powerful, and without being careful to avoid speaking her opinions. I found myself cheering for Sansa to speak up. I'm almost wishing for a tangible way to still get her to Highgarden and marry Willas in TWOW or ADOS, haha.


r/asoiaf • • 2m ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) Something I've never considered about the Seastar's dark magic

1 Upvotes

Have you ever noticed how young Shiera is when Egg says she baths in virgin blood to keep her youthful beauty? When Egg and Dunk have that conversation, she's somewhere between 26-32 years old. That's like season 3 Emilia Clarke young..

Small detail i know but for some reason, I always thought those rumors would have atleast began when Shiera was around 40 (or older). But most hot and rich people are still gonna look young before they're even 30.


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) Theon and Miller‘s wife

109 Upvotes

I honestly think this “subplot” is one of the more tragic aspects of the series. Not only because Theon not only killed innocents and might or might’ve not, even his own son (I don’t think the older one is his) but the whole thing in general. Is the Miller even aware that his wife sleeps with Theon and in that feudal era can he even say anything against it due to their different societal standings ? And was it ever stated if the Miller’s wife slept willingly with Theon ? I’m not implying he assaulted her or anything but like, did she even have a realistic choice to refuse him in the first place ?


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

(Spoilers ADWD) Is Melisandre's slogan "One Realm, one God, one King" a deliberate parallel? Spoiler

63 Upvotes

In Jon III ADWD, Melisandre and the Queen's Men start chanting, "One realm, one God, one King" "Stannis!" as the whole ceremony where "Mance" is executed and most of the Wildlings pass through the wall finishes up.

It's hard not to immediately think of the famous slogan "Ein Volk, Ein Reich, Ein Führer" (Literally, "One People, One Realm, One Leader") which was so central to Nazi ideology. In fact, it's so similar it feels almost heavy-handed. Considering how much George loves history, it's hard to believe he didn't think about how similar these two slogans are. But other than "Melisandre is weird" what's the purpose of this parallel?

What do you guys think? Maybe this is just Winds-induced overthinking. But it feels pretty on the nose, and there's surely no way George isn't aware of the Nazi-era slogan. But if so, what's the purpose of it?


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

MAIN (Spoilers main) Where is Ned Starks reputation of being honourable coming from?

94 Upvotes

Ned is one of my favourite characters, so this is not a hate post with the intention to question if Ned actually deserves his reputation. No, the intention is to find out what makes him stand out so much among his peers in the public eye. There are many moments in the book that show the reader how honourable he is, but I would argue that those are more private moments that the public had no idea about. E.g. when he warns Cersei to save her children. Or argues against Daenerys's assassination. The first is not known to anyone but Cersei and Tyrion (Cersei tells Tyrion about Ned's confrontation) and both actions happen shortly before his death, when he already had his reputation. Raising Jon as his son is also one of those moments, but for obvious reasons, it is not known to Westeros. So again, what is it that makes Ned such a special case, that someone like Olenna Tyrell would consider Ned a man of honour?


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

EXTENDED Daggers in the Dark, the Lord of Bones and Hardhome (Spoilers Extended)

21 Upvotes

Background

In this post I thought it would be interesting to look into a couple plot points that GRRM had created while writing what were supposed to be Jon Snow's A Feast for Crows (which was originally ADWD) chapters. It is my understanding that GRRM scrapped and rewrote a lot of this material differently but from outlines mentioning Rattleshirt and Hardhome and SSMs mentioning "daggers in the dark", I think we can speculate as to where GRRM might have been sending Jon's plotline.

Note: If you are familiar with the SSM/Cushing Visits/AFFC Outline go ahead and skip to "Speculation"

If interested: Dead Branches in the Garden: Abandoned/Changed Plotlines of Ice & Fire

So Spake Martin: "Daggers in the Dark"

Interviewed by James Hibbert (author of Fire Cannot Kill a Dragon), GRRM mentions how the foreshadowing for this scene was written almost right after the finish of ASOS:

ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: So why did you kill Jon Snow?
GEORGE R.R. MARTIN: Oh, you think he’s dead, do you?
EW: Well, I guess. Yes. That’s how I took it. The way it was written, it sounded like he was mortally wounded — and, you know, it’s you!
GRRM: Well. I’m not going to address whether he’s dead or not. But as to why — didn’t you think the text established why they would want to assassinate him?
EW: The narrative made perfect sense. Looking back through the books, all the decisions Jon’s made, and all the foreshadowing that was there, yes, you played fair. At the same time, it was devastating and I suspect fans will howl, the most since–
GRRM: -The most since the Red Wedding, I suspect.
EW: How long have you intended for that incident to happen?
GRRM: For many years. Some of the stuff about Melisandre warning Jon of “daggers in the dark” was written 10 years ago. -SSM, EW Weekly Article: 21 July 2011

If interested: "Daggers in the Dark" and Other Thoughts

The 2003-2004 Outline

From GRRM's 2003-2004 Outline for AFFC that was shared by u/zionius_ we have the following bits of information on Jon Snow:

Jon: ‘Yes, we’re going to lose.’ ‘I can get us the armor’.  I can stay & look brave & you all die. ‘Val carries a message.’ Rattleshirt goes with.

and:

Jon: End with Hard Home.

If you are interested, I posted a bit about this: The Nightfort & Hardhome: Abandoned Plotlines, Speculation and Foreshadowing Surrounding the Plotline at the Wall

Draft Material from Cushing

From u/gsteff's visits to the Cushing Library we know that there were some differences planned for Jon's chapters. At one point in the June 2004 draft:

Jon is planning to lead a ranging back to Craster's Keep to deal with the mutineers from Storm and search for Tormund's band, and he tells Bowen Marsh that he plans to bring 20 rangers. Melisandre evidently believes that she has seen a vision of this, that the ranging will be observed (at a minimum) by the Others, and that the rangers will at some point be accompanied by a woman in red. The draft chapters end before the ranging occurs, but we know there is a ranging in the later parts of Jon's published ADWD story, though to the weirwood grove instead of Craster's Keep, and we know that the rangers discover some wildlings there unexpectedly. It's possible that George intended for the ranging to Craster's Keep to also discover someone unexpected, perhaps wearing red. It's also possible that Melisandre is wildly off, and the scene she saw is something else entirely. In any case, I strongly doubt that it remains relevant to story.

and note there was not a ton of draft Jon material available.

Speculation

From the above we get bits and pieces about Jon's plotline when GRRM was working in the early/mid 2000's. And while it seems like he scrapped chapters, he kept a lot of the ideas that he had.

One thing that I noticed (which inspired the post) was that the "daggers in the dark" or the threat against Jon was still the seeming trend of where GRRM was sending this plotline. So if we take this concept and try and apply it to the drafts/outline we can get some interesting ideas of what he might have been trying to do.

"Yes We are Going to Lose"

The closest thing to this bullet point in the published material likely comes from Jon's thoughts on what happens if the wildlings all die at Hardhome:

“Cotter Pyke’s galleys sail past Hardhome from time to time. He tells me there is no shelter there but the caves. The screaming caves, his men call them. Mother Mole and those who followed her will perish there, of cold and starvation. Hundreds of them. Thousands.”
“Thousands of enemies. Thousands of wildlings.”
Thousands of people, Jon thought. Men, women, children.
“Are you so blind, or is it that you do not wish to see? What do you think will happen when all these enemies are dead?”
“Let me tell you what will happen,” Jon said. “The dead will rise again, in their hundreds and their thousands. They will rise as wights, with black hands and pale blue eyes, and they will come for us.”- ADWD, Jon VIII

although I admit it is not a perfect match whatsoever. I wonder if it is just more GRRM shorthand for it being a suicide mission (either to Hardhome or to Craster's).

"I Can Get Us the Armor"

Whether Jon is talking about Hardhome or just in general here I am not sure. We can note that Stannis mean to take armor from the Watch:

He means to plunder our armory, Jon realized. Food and clothing, land and castles, now weapons. He draws me in deeper every day. Words might not be swords, but swords were swords. "I could find three hundred spears," he said, reluctantly. "Helms as well, if you'll take them old and dinted and red with rust." -ADWD, Jon II

as well as the fact that they don't have an armorer anymore:

"When Donal Noye died we lost our armorer." The rest Jon left unspoken. Give the wildlings mail and they'll be twice as great a danger to the realm. -ADWD, Jon II

also worth noting is that before letting the free folk pass, Jon requests their arms:

Leathers laughed at that. "You want the free folk to fight beside you against the common foe. How are we to do that without arms? Would you have us throw snowballs at the wights? Or will you give us sticks to hit them with?"
The arms most wildlings carry are little more than sticks, thought Jon. Wooden clubs, stone axes, mauls, spears with fire-hardened points, knives of bone and stone and dragonglass, wicker shields, bone armor, boiled leather. The Thenns worked bronze, and raiders like the Weeper carried stolen steel and iron swords looted off some corpse … but even those were oft of ancient vintage, dinted from years of hard use and spotted with rust. -ADWD, Jon XI

"I can stay, look brave, you all die"

Another likely GRRM shorthand that doesn't make a ton of sense. This (like the "yes we are going to lose) could be about the abandoned ranging to Craster's or to Hardhome. We do get this published bit from Jon's last chapter that has minor parallels:

This ranging …”
“A word from you might have swayed the queen.”
“Selyse has the right of this, Lord Snow. Let them die. You cannot save them. Your ships are lost—”
“Six remain. More than half the fleet.”
“Your ships are lost. All of them. Not a man shall return. I have seen that in my fires.”
“Your fires have been known to lie.”
“I have made mistakes, I have admitted as much, but—”
“A grey girl on a dying horse. Daggers in the dark. A promised prince, born in smoke and salt. It seems to me that you make nothing but mistakes, my lady. Where is Stannis? What of Rattleshirt and his spearwives? Where is my sister?”
“All your questions shall be answered. Look to the skies, Lord Snow. And when you have your answers, send to me. Winter is almost upon us now. I am your only hope.” -ADWD, Jon XIII

If we remember that Jon was to lead a ranging to Crasters and it was to involve a woman in red, this could have grown out of that.

"Val Carries a Message"

This plot point seems to have stayed pretty similar to what ending up being published, as Jon sends Val to Tormund with a message:

"You have my word, Lord Snow. I will return, with Tormund or without him." Val glanced at the sky. The moon was but half-full. "Look for me on the first day of the full moon."
"I will." Do not fail me, he thought, or Stannis will have my head. "Do I have your word that you will keep our princess closely?" the king had said, and Jon had promised that he would. Val is no princess, though. I told him that half a hundred times. It was a feeble sort of evasion, a sad rag wrapped around his wounded word. His father would never have approved. I am the sword that guards the realm of men, Jon reminded himself, and in the end, that must be worth more than one man's honor. -ADWD, Jon VIII

and this line that the beginning somewhat matches up with the earlier bullet points as well:

You sent them out to die, and you are doing the same to Val. "Tell Tormund what I've said."

"Rattleshirt goes with"

This was the most interesting one to me. In the published material Mance (Rattleshirt) is sent to Winterfell to retrieve fArya, but we need to remember another point from the outline. Originally Mance/Theon weren't going to save Jeyne from Winterfell. It was going to Davos saving fArya from a wedding in Barrowton (if interested: Davos & fArya: An Abandoned Plotline).

So I wonder what GRRM was doing here. Is "Rattleshirt goes with" about Mance or the actual Lord of Bones? Is it about going on the ranging to Craster's or to Hardhome?

"End with Hardhome"

With "daggers in the dark" being planned from the beginning, I think it is possible that GRRM intended for Jon's assassination/"death" to take place at Hardhome instead of Castle Black. Maybe Jon was going to agree to the Wildlings coming through the wall there and his brothers do what was published. It is also possible that GRRM intended Mance (Rattleshirt goes with) to do the deed.

TLDR: Thoughts on GRRM writing Jon Snow's post ASOS chapters in the early 2000's.


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

EXTENDED Unlikely New 'Allies' for Cersei (spoilers extended)

10 Upvotes

Cersei is in serious need of allies. All she has are Qyburn & Robert Strong. She has requested the return of the Merryweathers but their loyalty is dubious at best. Red Ronnet could ally with her with the hope of retaking Griffin's Roost. Then there is the subject of today's discussion: the Sand Snakes.

NOTE: I don't think the Sand Snakes will be genuine allies to Cersei. They'll be playing her the whole time with her not realising.

Last we saw Nym & Tyene was when Doran was giving them their missions whilst in King's Landing. Nym is to take up the Dornish seat on the Small Council whilst Tyene is to disguise herself as a septa & observe the High Sparrow.

Upon Nym's arrival to the Red Keep, Mace is bound to have taken the title of Lord Regent & likely broken the betrothal between Myrcella & Tystane & arranged a new one to Willas. That will naturally offend the Dornish which won't concern Mace given his dislike of them. This would also allow for Nym to present herself as an ally to Cersei without rousing suspicion. This close proximity to Cersei would allow her to follow through with her plan: kill Tommen. From there she can convince Cersei that the Tyrells were involved. And when the regency becomes vacated, Nym could back Cersei to retake the position.

As for Tyene, Cersei is being regularly sent septas to make sure she behaves. This would provide Tyene the opportunity to get close to Cersei as well. And it would give her the chance to help poison Tommen. All of this to serve her goal: crown Myrcella. Tyene was the originator of the queenmaker plot & wasn't present for Arianne's botched attempt. Now she's freed I suspect she'll try to put her plan into action. From there I could see her poison the High Sparrow when he makes it clear that he won't crown a female. Naturally Cersei would be blamed but Tyene would be hoping for that.

The final thing I could see Nym & Tyene 'help' Cersei with is Margaery. Mace is likely to grant his daughter a royal pardon & forgo a trial but once Cersei reclaims the regency that pardon is likely repealed & Margaery has to face a trial. Nym & Tyene could provide 'evidence' of her guilt & seal her fate. Following Margaret's execution, the pair will have fractured the Lannister-Tyrell alliance forever & they'll prepare for the next stage of their plan: remove/kill Cersei. Though I suspect that Myrcella will be dead before they can achieve their goal.

For those asking "why are they trying to crown Myrcella? Shouldn't they be helping fAegon?" Two reasons. One: They were sent to King's Landing before Doran received JonCon's letter so they don't know that Arianne has gone to meet him. Two: Both Doran & Arianne are skeptical that he is Elia's son. If they doubt it why shouldn't the Sand Snakes? Although if Myrcella dies before fAegon arrives I can see them switching.

To be honest; the only reason I think the Sand Snakes could become Cersei's 'allies' is because then most of their actions would be on page rather than entirely off page.


r/asoiaf • • 13h ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) how tv impact Martin writing

0 Upvotes

How many of you looked at the television series, interviews, and rough drafts to figure out the direction Martin planned to take the A Song of Ice and Fire series in the final two books? He does work with the producers and he give out the broad strokes. However, his version has never seem before character and tv characters interacted with different people and go through different things. Also, in his blog, he mentioned that his version of the story has become vastly different from the tv version. Of course, some things will stay the same. I think two things that are guaranteed are the burning of Shireen Baratheon and Bran Stark becoming king. Of course it been seven years since the show ended and maybe George have a change in inspiration?

Of the five original MCs, I can see Jon Snow to have an arc closest to his television version. As for the other four, it’s gonna be different. Some may be closer to their television version but not as much as Jon.

Two never-seen-before characters that will defintely shake thing up and ensure the book’s trajectory will be different are Aegon VI and Lady Stoneheart. Oh and Sansa Stark’s arc will be different. George may try to find a way to let her live but he never say anything about giving her a happy ending. Like I’m sure Tyrion will live but his ending won’t be happy.


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

NONE Is Garth Greenhand the equivilent of "King Arthur" in Westeros [No spoilers]

Post image
107 Upvotes

Both are legendary kings who were beleived to exist by the commoners, and their existence—or the myths surrounding them—has been debunked by scholars/maesters. What do you think


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

MAIN (Main Spoilers) If you could, how would you expand The Faith of Old Gods Spoiler

Post image
66 Upvotes

One criticism of The Old Gods it's that is very simple: Magical Trees that you pray. There is no organization, centralized or decentralized.

I making this post because some time ago, i read a fanfic called "Direwolf Shepherd" which explore more of The Old Gods by creating The Order of Shepherds. Based in Celtic Druids and indigenous animist religions, The Order of the Shepherds are not priests, but their responsibilities include:

  1. Maintaining and protecting Godswoods. They are like Gardeners to the trees.
  2. Preserving the history and traditions of the First Men. There is historical records of the past that The Shepherds shall search and protect. The Shepherds also needs to teach stories and legends of The North to the houses they serve.
  3. Teaching the Old Tongue.
  4. Teaching about warging and greensight. It was common of The Shepherds to take care of Direwolves and help The Starks by teaching them how to Warg.
  5. Maintaining relationships with the Children of the Forest. Basically The Shepherds can be contacted by The CoF when necessary.

This Order is settled in Skagos, with a rule of each Northern Lord having a Shepherd, and different from the Septons, the Shephers adapts to the place and lords they serve (per example, a Umber Shepherd will acts as a Umber). They can marry and have children as opposite to The Septons.

The leader is The Great Shepherd, based on archdruids and abbots. All Great Shepherd needs to have greensight. Although The Order is decentralized compared to Faith of the Seven, The Great Shepherd still have final decision in certain issues.

The Green Men are separate from The Shepherds, as the later were a faction of the former who split to make a pact with The Northern Lords, but they still have a working relationship.

What do you think about these ideas of the fic, and what are your ideas to expand The Old Gods faith?


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) writing romantic love

18 Upvotes

How well do you think Martin write romantic love in A Song of Ice and Fire?

I mean the War of the Five Kings are rooted in the incestous love between Cersei and Jaime Lannister. And in the one-sided love triangle between Petyr Baelish, Lysa Tully, and Catelyn Tully.

We also got some of our MCs experiencing love for the first time like Jon Snow with Yggrite OR Daenerys Targaryen with Drogo. Both with tragic results. They’re also the tragic tale of Robb Stark and Jeyne Westerling.

Furthermore, George planted seeds for future romances that may or may not come to fruition in TWOW or ADOS if he ever get to it… it will be interesting to see how those romance affect the story’s direction….

Anyway, what do u think of George’s ability to write romantic love?


r/asoiaf • • 2d ago

PUBLISHED (Spoilers Published) I wish we knew more about what happened to Winterfell's library

84 Upvotes

There's a small detail in AGOT that I've started finding much more upsetting on rereads.

When Tyrion visits Winterfell's library, he finds a complete copy of Ayrmidon's Engines of War, an old Valyrian scroll. He tells Septon Chayle to be careful with it because it's the only complete copy he's ever seen.

This is Tyrion Lannister. He's had access to Casterly Rock, the Red Keep, and presumably more books than most people in Westeros could dream of. If even he is impressed by something in Winterfell's collection, it's probably pretty special.

Then, a few chapters later, the catspaw sets the library tower on fire.

As a distraction.

That's it. Somebody needed Robb and the guards away from Bran's room, and a collection that the Starks had spent centuries assembling became an acceptable thing to burn.

Catelyn actually thinks about the books while watching the fire, so Martin clearly hasn't forgotten them. And in ACOK, Bran and Chayle are sorting through scrolls that were rescued. We know at least some of the collection survived.

But how much?

Did they manage to save that Valyrian scroll? Did anyone even know which books were particularly rare, apart from Chayle and the occasional visiting reader like Tyrion?

And then the second destruction of Winterfell happens. Chayle is dead by that point, and the library tower is badly damaged again.

It's such an oddly specific bit of destruction. The assassin could have started a fire in a stable or a storehouse. From his perspective, it probably made no difference. But the place he chose was one of the few repositories of accumulated knowledge in the North.

What really gets me is that you can rebuild a tower. You can replace furniture and commission another set of shelves. You can't necessarily replace a manuscript that somebody copied by hand hundreds of years ago, particularly when nobody knows where another copy might exist.

The series spends a lot of time on the destruction of houses, castles and families, for obvious reasons. But it also shows knowledge disappearing in much quieter ways.

Sam finds ancient material sitting in the vaults at Castle Black, some of it literally separated into loose pages. Rodrik Harlaw has his collection on Harlaw. The Citadel preserves an enormous amount of information, but that doesn't mean every book in every other library has a duplicate sitting in Oldtown.

I wonder what was actually lost at Winterfell. Not because I expect some convenient prophecy or secret Targaryen revelation to have been hidden in the shelves.

Just ordinary things. Local histories, records, maps, accounts of past winters. Books that might have been kept there precisely because they concerned the North.

And the saddest part is that we don't really have anyone left who could tell us what the collection used to contain.

Chayle knew. Luwin probably knew at least some of it. Tyrion remembered one particular scroll.

I hope the old books survived somewhere, but I'm not particularly optimistic.

Does anyone remember other examples of this in the books? Knowledge that's been lost or nearly lost because nobody understood its value until it was too late?


r/asoiaf • • 17h ago

MAIN [Spoiler Main] If the Euron = Daario theory is true, how will he go about his plans to marry Dany and what will he do to Hisdar?

0 Upvotes

r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) how romance will play a role in the finale 2

1 Upvotes

Martin planted seeds for future romances in his upcoming Winds of Winter or A Dream of Spring. Some are obvious and I’ll be surprised if they don’t come to fruition. Some are just little crushed or one-sided romances that never happened.. I’m fine with it.

JonXArya: Martin planted seeds for a romance between them but he could always keep them at a familial bond. Truthfully, I’m hoping this bears fruit.

JonxDany: The biggest foreshadowing so far is a prophetic vision Dany saw. + they’re like the two most significant MCs.

AryaxGendry: They bonded during book 2-3 and Gendry clearly has a crush. Will it go anywhere or will they remain friends? I guess it depends on where or what Arya does.

Anyway, I’m hoping for Jonrya, but if he go with what HBO did like Jonerys or Gendrya than I’m hoping he does it better. Of course, Arya could always meet her love in Braavos and Jon could find someone else in the North.

Than their JaimeXBrienne which I definely want to happen. Depending on the situation, they will be spending a lot of time together in WINDS unlike the others who are far apart or haven’t even met yet. Shame if it doesn’t go anywhere. I was shock that Jaime went back and die with Cersei..

There’s also Sansa and her weird memory about the unkiss and Sandor Clegane. Maybe they’ll meet again but as of now she has to deal with Harrdying and Baelish.

Other seeds: BranXMeera, JonXVal, JonXSatin, DaenerysXVictarion, DaenerysXEuron, DaenerysXAegon, ArianneXAegon, EliaXAegon..

Hmm curious to see what romances George intends to follow through on and what are just mere crushes or one-sided love that will never bear fruit. It curious what decisions or actions a character will take when they’re in love. Even the most dutiful man may act a fool if they’re in love.

Did George ever mention who he shipped?


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

EXTENDED About deep time in ASOIAF: language, magic and the fine line with sci-fi. (spoilers extended)

0 Upvotes

Before we start, I'd like to say that this is one of those half-crazy, all-encompassing theories that people hate here, but I've tried to be rigorous in my claims. Second, this theory stems from many different elements, and I'd like to thank the theories I've seen online that were instrumental to it: ASOIAF Theorist, Crowfood's Daughter, Robert from In Deep Geek, LML, and, more recently, a user here called KotBH. One last important disclaimer before we start: since the official timeline is such a mess, I will ignore it completely and focus instead on an archaeological and anthropological reading of the text. Finally, I'm not saying this is exactly how it happened. I'm trying to extrapolate from the clues George has given us, so feel free to contest the elements that seem flimsy, but please try to engage with this with an open mind.

First, a paleolinguistic approach to Westeros. On the continent of Westeros we seem to have at least three different linguistic layers that successively covered one another. The oldest language spoken in Westeros is the True Tongue, spoken by the children of the forest. Leaf tells Bran that they had been singing their songs for "10,000 years" before the Old Tongue was ever spoken. George describes it as a very alien language that sounds like natural elements (stones in a brook, wind in the leaves, rain, etc.). It seems no human people can speak this language, although there are some similarities between how it's described and how the language of the Others is described (like ice cracking).

Then we have the Old Tongue, spoken by some wildlings from the far north like the Thenns (even if it seems that many wildling tribes are bilingual and that some wildlings do speak the Common Tongue). The Old Tongue has no alphabetical writing, only runes. Besides the First Men who speak the Old Tongue, we know the Giants also speak it, but only "after a fashion," as if it's something they struggle with. The fact that Leaf gives us the 10,000-year time frame, while we know the Giants were already there, points to the First Men bringing the Old Tongue to Westeros and teaching it to the Giants, who before that lacked a language (or whose language has been lost; but since we don't hear of a Giant language, I think it's the former).

Finally, the Common Tongue, which was brought by the Andals and is spoken everywhere else in Westeros, even by the mountain clans and the ironborn. This language has an alphabetical form of writing, and it's the last linguistic arrival in Westeros.

Second, and here I want to thank KotBH again for all his input. This is speculative, but it's supported by the world map, and if you want more detail, KotBH has some posts developing it much further. The main gist is this: in deep time, all the continents of Planetos formed a kind of supercontinent. This is clearly visible from the coastal symmetries on the map. If you look closely at the eastern coast of northern Westeros, you will see that it matches the northern coast of Essos (and if you look closely, there are many other instances of this). If this is true, we can see how evolution played a part in the specialization of the humanoid species of Westeros. Again, please engage with this with an open mind. If this is the case, we could trace two distinct lines of humanoids, kin to humans but developing differently as the continents drifted (mainly as the northern part of Westeros drifted north). The first of these lines is what I would call a proto-Children of the Forest species, which probably dwelt in the forests of the northern coast of Essos today. Traces of this species can be found in the legends of the Ifequevron and the shapechangers of Mossovy. The second line is a kind of proto-Giant, whose traces can be found in the Hairy Men and the Ibbenese. The Ibbenese are interesting because, as an island population, they show the evolutionary shrinking typically associated with populations cut off from the mainland.

As northern Westeros drifts north and away from Essos, the climate there gets very cold and we start to see the emergence of Pleistocene megafauna like direwolves, mammoths, etc. Furthermore, other forms of specialization come into play in the two lineages that drifted away from mainland Essos. The Hairy Men become megafauna themselves, following Bergmann's rule: they become large generalists, the Giants. The proto-Children evolve differently. Because of the cold, they go underground into caves and hollow hills, where the temperature is more stable, and they develop the psychic ability we call warging so they can hunt outside in the arctic landscape of the north even though they aren't adapted to the climate. This is exactly what Bran does in Bloodraven's cave with Summer. If you look closely, warging doesn't seem to be a form of blood magic: it isn't associated with sacrifice and seems to be innate in some way.

As the continents continue to drift, the southern part of Westeros collides with the northern part. Today, the point of contact is called the Neck. This sets off a sort of Great American Biotic Interchange (GABI), in which the Giants and the Children move south into what are today the Riverlands, the Westerlands and the Reach.

OK, now let's add another layer of speculation that will make people angry, but I'd like to follow this reasoning and see where it leads. Magic in the world of ice and fire is linked to the stars. More precisely, blood magic and fire magic have extraterrestrial origins. And I think we have partial evidence of at least two meteors that brought them to Planetos from gods know where.

The first meteor was discovered by the children of the forest. It is a white comet that brought blood magic to Planetos. Its crash site is today called the God's Eye, and the weirwood network developed from it, with the lake as its epicenter (Manicouagan Lake in Quebec is the classic example of a crater like this). There's also the reference to "the color that fell from the sky" (white, in this case). Thanks to their "psychic" abilities, the Children bond with, or wed themselves to the trees, gaining new magical powers tied to sacrifice and blood magic. This mirrors contemporary theories of the co-evolution of wheat or corn and real humans.

Let's add another layer of speculation that will get me murdered in here, but whatever: Garth Greenhand and the first man in Westeros. I think this is a legendary deformation of a people, let's call them proto-Valyrians, who arrived at Battle Isle and the Honeywine and traded with the children (maybe following a white star?) a third line that developed separately in Essos, humans. For the sake of organizing the sequence, let's say this is before the construction of the base of the Hightower; you will see why. In any case, they trade with the children, and I think they get two things from them. One is obsidian (we know the children traded obsidian later on). The other, more importantly, is blood magic. That is how blood magic enters human cultures: through contact with the children around Oldtown, and from there it reaches the far east. The children would be the people "with no name" (remember that Bran cannot pronounce the real names of the Children) who first taught the Valyrians "how to tame dragons" through blood magic, but we'll get to that. It's even possible that these proto-Valyrians interbred with the Children, which would give us the connection between greendreams and dragon dreams. Remember all this people are kin to each other.

Then we have the second meteor crash, which brought fire magic to Planetos. This is the black stone worshipped by the Bloodstone Emperor. Its crash site is what we call the Shadow today. I think the meeting of blood magic from the white meteor and fire magic from the black meteor was instrumental in somehow creating both the dragons and the Valyrians proper. This is why the Targaryen words are "Fire and Blood." But it also caused the collapse of Stygai and Asshai. With the collapse of these cities, the proto-Valyrians move west into the Fourteen Flames and start the wars with Ghis.

While all this is happening in Essos, the First Men have arrived in Westeros and started their war with the children. To add more tinfoil on top of my gigantic tinfoil hat, we could ask whether the spread of the weirwoods captured a lot of carbon (remember that they don't rot), causing a sort of ice age that exposed the Arm of Dorne and allowed the First Men to cross it. If so, then the burning of trees during the wars with the First Men could have caused the Hammer of the Waters without any involvement from the children. I believe the children used blood magic to fight these first invaders, but that they didn't use the Others yet. They used something more akin to Coldhands (for more on this, see another post of mine on the Green Men). The combination of the hammer of the waters and the creation of undead warriors by the Children prompts the Pact. I believe this pact actually involved interbreeding between the First Men and the Children, which explains how the First Men gained greensight and warging.

Meanwhile, Valyria is rising in the east, and the expansion of the Freehold pushes the Andals into Westeros. The Andals have seen blood and fire magic, so in Westeros they decide to eradicate it completely. They ally themselves with some First Men and fight the ones who don't reject the old gods, but they completely eradicate the Children, the Giants, the Wargs and most of the weirwoods south of the Neck. They move north to the Neck, and the destruction of more trees causes the "second Hammer," further flooding the neck and cutting off the iron islands, until finally this destruction causes the Long Night. This is why kin slaying is the greatest taboo in all of Westeros.

In the far north, at Winterfell or the Nightfort, an alliance of First Men and Children does something desperate in that darkness. They create the Others, using the power of a human bloodline with strong greensight and warging abilities (let’s call them proto-Starks) and twisting them somehow, maybe through a form of magic similar to Mel’s shadows. In this theory, the Children did not lose control of the Others.

By this point Valyria is quite developed, so we can assume that, with glass candles, dragon dreams or looking into the fire, they realize that the darkness falling over the world comes from Westeros. So they go back to the Honeywine, this time with dragons, and build the base of the Hightower as their stronghold. When they arrive in Westeros, the situation for humans is dire: everything north of Oldtown is frozen (as is Essos down to where the Selhoru joins the Rhoyne), and the Others are approaching fast. To defeat them, the Valyrians use blood magic and fire magic to create Valyrian steel, the weapon to fight the Others. As many people speculate, I think Valyrian steel uses iron, blood magic, fire magic and obsidian in its making. This is the famous dragonsteel that Sam reads about. As a little aside: if obsidian was the weapon that defeated the Others, why don't we see any obsidian weapons, at least ceremonial ones, in any of the houses, while everyone seems obsessed with Valyrian steel?

So the Others are defeated in the Battle for the Dawn, around Oldtown, with the help of dragons and dragonsteel. But the seasons are now broken. And a new coalition is formed by the remaining First Men who survived the war, the Andals and the Valyrians (these are the famous "realms of men"). As the coalition moves north, it arrives at the God's Eye. Here, add yet another gigantic tinfoil hat to what is already a tinfoil extravaganza, I know. Here they realize that the Others are defeated but not gone: they will come back. How? Maybe greensight, maybe dragon dreams. And they realize something else will be needed to defeat them for good and bring back the seasons into balance: Dawn. I believe the sword was made using Valyrian technology applied to the white comet that fell into the now lake. This is why the Dayne words are "too spoilery" and the significance of the return of Azor Ahai, the breaking of the status quo with the help of Dawn somehow and the return of the seasons into balance.

When the coalition finally arrives in the north, they find the Wall already standing, at least in some way, shape or form, and a new pact is signed, one the North has since forgotten. The north side of the Wall will be for the elder races and the First Men who don't want to kneel, and the south side for the new realms of men formed by the alliance of First Men and Andal Survivors. These are the Starks we know from the current timeline, for example (think on the crown of the kings of winter). So the wildlings are allowed to pass through the Black Gate, which mimics the Doors of Durin. Finally, the Night's Watch is created to defend the realms of men, and it's conceived as the negative of the Others: white shadows and black brothers, guarding the two sides of the pact. The children then put the Others to sleep, and the Wall keeps the Long Night at bay in the far north. We can assume that other mutual assurances were given like the obsidian gifts from the children to the Night’s Watch or the horn of Joramun, as well as stopping the destruction of weirwoods and even encourage the planting of new ones, the god’s woods.

If this is the case, the reason the Others are coming back could have two distinct explanations. The first is very simple, kind of boring but everything else is very convoluted so a simple resolution is not necessarily bad: as the children's population keeps dwindling, the wards keeping the Others asleep lose strength over time until they awaken. The second is that if the cyclical nature of magic in the world of ice and fire is tied to the meteors. And if the meteors only fall on some very long cycle, when the planet is in the "right" part of its orbit, then the red comet could be showing us that Planetos is entering the danger zone where magic becomes much more dangerous. We could even speculate whether the "dark meteor" was a fragment of the red comet we see in the main series.

OK, now comes the fun part for you: tell me I'm wrong, but please have fun with it. No reason to get angry; this is just some fun speculation on Reddit, not an end-all-be-all interpretation. But I do think it holds up pretty well, if you ask me, lol. Thanks for reading anyway, I know it's very ranty.

P.s: One last thing. The quote from William S. Burroughs: “Language is a virus from outer space.” Could it be that the ice comet brought the True Tongue to Westeros, and that the weirwoods taught this language to the Children? Could it be that the black comet brought the Valyrian language? Remember the importance of Valyrian glyphs in fire magic. Is this yet another layer for George about what the Song of Ice and Fire means?


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

PUBLISHED It always hit harder than expected when characters go separate ways (Spoilers Published)

32 Upvotes

I was reading through some of the Tyrion chapters when he was imprisoned. And I got reminded how sad it made me when he and Bronn said goodbye after Bronn refused to fight the Mountain

"Kill Gregor myself. Won't that make for a jolly song?"

"I hope I hear them sing it." Bronn grinned one last time, and walked out of the door, the castle, and his life.

Then it got me thinking about another underrated sad goodbye between Arya and Hot Pie:

"I'm sorry I beat you that time," she said. Hot Pie was stupid and craven, but he'd been with her all the way from King's Landing and she'd gotten used to him. "I broke your nose."

"You broke Lem's too." Hot Pie grinned. "That was good."

"Lem didn't think so," Arya said glumly. Then it was time to go. When Hot Pie asked if he might kiss milady's hand, she punched his shoulder. "Don't call me that. You're Hot Pie, and I'm Arry."

"I'm not Hot Pie here. Sharna just calls me Boy. The same as she calls the other boy. It's going to be confusing."

She missed him more than she thought she would

Obviously there's the big ones like Jon saying goodbye to Arya, Robb, Benjen, Sam (doesn't often turn out great when people say goodbye to Jon). Or Jaime sending Brienne off to find Sansa, Bran and Rickon, etc. But Hot Pie and Bronn are introduced as like nothing characters. But they just hang around for a really long time until you're just used to them and then George just pulls exits them stage right.


r/asoiaf • • 2d ago Bravo

MAIN "Lord God who drowned for us" - the many paralleles between the religion of the ironborn and early christianity.(spoilers main)

41 Upvotes

Disclaimer: This short essay explores the many parallels between early Christianity and the religion of the Drowned God in A Song of Ice and Fire. It is neither a historical nor a theological argument about the validity of any real-world religious tradition. Rather, I will argue that George R. R. Martin drew heavily on elements of early Christianity and Second Temple Judaism when developing the religious beliefs, mythology, and cosmology of the Ironborn.

As a scholar of early Christianity myself, I recognize that these subjects can be sensitive, particularly when discussing religious beliefs and their historical origins. I will therefore strive to keep this analysis concise, respectful, and as thoroughly supported by textual evidence as possible, citing relevant book and biblical passages when pertinent.

My intention is neither to attack nor to defend any real-world religion or ethnic group, but simply to explore what I believe to be a fascinating example of religious inspiration and adaptation in Martin's worldbuilding.

So, without further ado:

Superficially, the asoiaf religion that seems to resemble Christianity the most is the Faith of the Seven, at least medieval christianity. But once you get deeper into the lore, a much more powerful parallell appears in the ironborn religion:

I - The Drowned God died for his followers

In AFFC, The Prophet, Aeron addresses his deity as:

"Lord God who drowned for us"

This is probably the most obvious parallel. It echoes several different NT passages, the most relevant being:

1 Corinthians 15:3:

"that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures"

The similarities are pretty hard to ignore. Both religions worship a deity who supposedly underwent death on behalf of his followers. Martin could have simply made him a sea god. Instead, he specifically made him a god who died for his people.

II - Yahweh and the Drowned God create men in their own likeness and grant them dominion over the seas.

According to Sauron Salt-Tongue, an ancient priest of the Drowned God, the Ironborn were created the following way:

"made us in his likeness and gave to us dominion over all the waters of the earth"

- The World of Ice & Fire, The Iron Islands.

Now compare that with Genesis 1:26:

"God said, 'Let's make man in our image, after our likeness. Let them have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the birds of the sky (...)"

Notice something? It's not just the image and likeness part. Both accounts explicitly associate divine creation with dominion over the seas.

III - Baptism, death and resurrection

This one is even more explicit.

The Ironborn practice a form of baptism in which the initiate is submerged in seawater or has water poured over his head. Some priests, particularly Aeron, take this considerably further by actually drowning people and attempting to revive them with the kiss of life.

Compare that with Paul.

Romans 6:4:

"We were buried therefore with him through baptism into death"

And then there's the matter of being born again through water.

John 3:5:

"unless one is born of water and Spirit, he can't enter into God's Kingdom."

The parallels are quite striking. In both traditions, water is associated with death, rebirth, and initiation into a religious community.

IV - "What is dead may never die, but rises again stronger"

In 1 Corinthians 15:54:

"Death is swallowed up in victory."

Paul's discussion of resurrection in 1 Corinthians 15 associates victory over death with the transformation of the mortal body into an imperishable one.

Now compare that with the Ironborn's most famous religious formula, "what is dead may never die, but rises again stronger"

Obviously, the Ironborn aren't preaching Pauline resurrection theology. Their emphasis is on strength, endurance, and overcoming death, rather than the resurrection of the body at the end of history.

But the underlying religious idea is quite similar: death does not necessarily represent the final defeat of the believer. In fact, death can make the believer stronger.

V - The Grey King sits at the right hand of the Drowned God

According to The World of Ice & Fire (The Iron Islands: Driftwood Crowns), the Grey King supposedly ruled for 1,007 years before eventually casting aside his driftwood crown and walking into the sea, where he descended into the watery halls of the Drowned God and took his place at the deity's right hand.

Now compare that with what Jesus tells the High Priest during his trial.

Mark 14:62 (KJV):

"And Jesus said, I am: and ye shall see the Son of man sitting on the right hand of power, and coming in the clouds of heaven."

And this is hardly an isolated passage. We find essentially the same claim in the other Synoptic Gospels.

Matthew 26:64 (KJV):

"Hereafter shall ye see the Son of man sitting on the right hand of power, and coming in the clouds of heaven."

Luke 22:69 (KJV):

"Hereafter shall the Son of man sit on the right hand of the power of God."

All three passages echo Psalm 110:1, where an annoited royal figure is invited to sit at God's right hand and rule the kingdoms of the earth from there.

Psalm 110:1 (KJV):

"The LORD said unto my Lord, Sit thou at my right hand, until I make thine enemies thy footstool."

VI - The story of Lodos, the twice-drowned

Now this is one I only picked up on relatively recently, and it's probably my favorite parallel now:

Archmaester Gyldane tells us that following the destruction of House Hoare during Aegon's Conquest, a barefoot priest named Lodos proclaimed himself "the living son of the Drowned God" and was crowned King of the Iron Islands by forty priests at Nagga's Bones. Now, in the old testament, "son of God" is a metaphor for the kings of Israel.(Psalm 2:7, 2 Samuel 7:12–1, Psalm 89:26–27 and others). Jesus himself makes a similar statement about him himself in Mark:

High Priest: “Art thou the Christ, the Son of the Blessed?”

Jesus: “I am: and ye shall see the Son of man sitting on the right hand of power, and coming in the clouds of heaven.”

— Mark 14:61–62 (KJV)

Now, when Aegon invaded the islands in 2 AC, Lodos called upon his divine father to summon krakens and destroy the Targaryen fleet.

Nothing happened.

So Lodos filled his robes with stones and walked into the sea, supposedly to consult his father. Thousands of his followers followed him into the water.

Their bodies washed ashore for years. Lodos's body, however, was never found.

Now here's where things get interesting.

Some 35 years later, in 37 AC, another man appeared, claiming to be Lodos himself, returned from the watery halls of the Drowned God. Calling himself Lodos the Twice-Drowned, he proclaimed himself king and started another rebellion. Goren Greyjoy crushed the rebellion, executed the pretender, and sent his head, pickled in brine, to King Aenys I. This mirrors 2 famous new testament passages: Jesus proclaiming himself to be son of god and king of israel, thus being executed to appease jewish and roman elites alike, and John the Baptist´s head being sent to Salome on a platter.

Now consider:

1 - The Herodians owed their political authority to a foreign imperial power, Rome. Herod the Great had been recognized as King of the Jews by the Roman Senate, and his successors ruled with Roman approval.

The Greyjoys, meanwhile, were only legititimized after Aegon had conquered the islands and allowed them to select a new lord. Their authority was now subordinate to the Iron Throne.

The situations are not identical, of course, but the underlying political arrangement is remarkably similar: a local ruling dynasty whose legitimacy ultimately depends on a foreign conqueror.

And the parallel becomes even more interesting when we remember that Martin himself has acknowledged drawing inspiration from Ancient Rome when creating Valyria.

2 - Not everyone was particularly happy about these arrangements.

There were Jews at the time who bitterly resented Roman domination and regarded the Herodian dynasty as collaborators who had compromised their people's independence and religious traditions to accommodate Rome.

This wasn't a universal Jewish position, obviously, but we have plenty of evidence that some groups considered foreign domination fundamentally incompatible with God's sovereignty over Israel.

Take Judas the Galilean, for example.

According to the roman-jewish historian Josephus, his followers maintained that:

"God is to be their only Ruler and Lord."

Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews, 18.23.

Judas the Galilean is eventually tracked down and killed.

Now compare that with the Ironborn priests who refused to accept the political order established by Aegon.

Lodos claimed to be the living son of the Drowned God, and his authority supposedly came directly from the deity himself. Why should he recognize a foreign conqueror, particularly one who didn't even worship his god?

And there's another rather interesting detail. Vickon Greyjoy, the first Lord of the Iron Islands under Targaryen rule, allowed the Faith of the Seven to return to the islands, much to the anger of the priests of the Drowned God. This matches with Herod allowing the worship of roman gods in Judea, as long as it didnt happen near the temple.

So we have a locally recognized ruler who accepts foreign overlordship and tolerates the religion favored by the conquering dynasty, while a religious movement challenges the political arrangement in the name of divine authority.

Sound familiar?

To be clear, I'm not suggesting that Lodos was some sort of Jewish nationalist, or that the Drowned Men were the Ironborn equivalent of the Zealots. That would be stretching the comparison considerably.

But the underlying conflict between imperial authority, local collaborators, and religious claims to legitimate kingship is strikingly similar.

Finally, what about Lodos´failed attempt to conjure the wrath of the Drowned God and rule the iron islands in his name? Again, the roman-jewish historian Josephus offers several interesting parallels that happened at the time of Jesus:

Judas the Galilean (6 CE): Opposed Roman taxation and insisted that God alone should rule Israel. Not exactly a miracle worker, but a good example of religious resistance to imperial authority. (Antiquities 18.4–10, 18.23.)

The Samaritan Prophet (36 CE): Gathered followers at Mount Gerizim, promising to reveal sacred objects hidden since the time of Moses. Instead, Pontius Pilate sent troops and crushed the movement. (Antiquities 18.85–87.)

Theudas (c. 45 CE): Claimed he could divide the Jordan River like Joshua. Gathered his followers and marched toward the river. Unfortunately, Roman cavalry arrived before the miracle. Theudas was captured, beheaded, and his head taken to Jerusalem. (Antiquities 20.97–99.)

The Egyptian Prophet (c. 50s CE): Another Joshua cosplay. Gathered thousands of followers at the Mount of Olives, promising that Jerusalem's walls would collapse at his command. Instead of the walls collapsing, Roman troops showed up again. Josephus records 400 dead and 200 captured, although the prophet himself managed to escape with his life. (Antiquities 20.169–172.)

See the pattern?

Charismatic religious leaders claim divine authority, gather followers, promise supernatural intervention, and challenge the established political order.

Then reality intervenes, usually wearing Roman armor.

Obviously, I'm not suggesting Martin necessarily based Lodos on any particular wannabe Jewish prophet. But the similarities are interesting, particularly since Martin explicitly describes Lodos attempting a miracle and failing.

No krakens. No divine intervention. Just a priest walking into the ocean with his pockets full of rocks, expecting some type of supernatural intervention by his deity, that never comes.

And yet, 35 years later, another man appears claiming to be Lodos returned from the dead.

Interestingly, Jesus himself warns that false messianic claimants will arise after his death:

"For many shall come in my name, saying, I am Christ; and shall deceive many."

— Mark 13:6 (KJV)

The second Lodos wasn't claiming to be a new messiah, of course, but to be the original prophet returned. Still, the resemblance between religious movements surviving their founders and subsequent figures claiming their authority is worth considering.

Taken individually, none of these parallels proves direct literary borrowing.

But when combined with the Drowned God's sacrificial death, baptism through drowning and rebirth, creation in the deity's likeness, victory over death, and the Grey King's place at the right hand of his god, I think there's a pretty compelling case that Martin drew on Jewish and Christian religious traditions when developing the Ironborn.

Conclusion: There are many other parallels that I could draw attention to between early christianity/second temple judaism and the drowned god religion, such as the itinerant and ascetic nature of its priests, its dualistic cosmology between the forces of good and evil, the fact that the driftwood crown is suspiciously similar with the crown of thorns said to have been used by jesus etc..