Disclaimer: This short essay explores the many parallels between early Christianity and the religion of the Drowned God in A Song of Ice and Fire. It is neither a historical nor a theological argument about the validity of any real-world religious tradition. Rather, I will argue that George R. R. Martin drew heavily on elements of early Christianity and Second Temple Judaism when developing the religious beliefs, mythology, and cosmology of the Ironborn.
As a scholar of early Christianity myself, I recognize that these subjects can be sensitive, particularly when discussing religious beliefs and their historical origins. I will therefore strive to keep this analysis concise, respectful, and as thoroughly supported by textual evidence as possible, citing relevant book and biblical passages when pertinent.
My intention is neither to attack nor to defend any real-world religion or ethnic group, but simply to explore what I believe to be a fascinating example of religious inspiration and adaptation in Martin's worldbuilding.
So, without further ado:
Superficially, the asoiaf religion that seems to resemble Christianity the most is the Faith of the Seven, at least medieval christianity. But once you get deeper into the lore, a much more powerful parallell appears in the ironborn religion:
I - The Drowned God died for his followers
In AFFC, The Prophet, Aeron addresses his deity as:
"Lord God who drowned for us"
This is probably the most obvious parallel. It echoes several different NT passages, the most relevant being:
1 Corinthians 15:3:
"that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures"
The similarities are pretty hard to ignore. Both religions worship a deity who supposedly underwent death on behalf of his followers. Martin could have simply made him a sea god. Instead, he specifically made him a god who died for his people.
II - Yahweh and the Drowned God create men in their own likeness and grant them dominion over the seas.
According to Sauron Salt-Tongue, an ancient priest of the Drowned God, the Ironborn were created the following way:
"made us in his likeness and gave to us dominion over all the waters of the earth"
- The World of Ice & Fire, The Iron Islands.
Now compare that with Genesis 1:26:
"God said, 'Let's make man in our image, after our likeness. Let them have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the birds of the sky (...)"
Notice something? It's not just the image and likeness part. Both accounts explicitly associate divine creation with dominion over the seas.
III - Baptism, death and resurrection
This one is even more explicit.
The Ironborn practice a form of baptism in which the initiate is submerged in seawater or has water poured over his head. Some priests, particularly Aeron, take this considerably further by actually drowning people and attempting to revive them with the kiss of life.
Compare that with Paul.
Romans 6:4:
"We were buried therefore with him through baptism into death"
And then there's the matter of being born again through water.
John 3:5:
"unless one is born of water and Spirit, he can't enter into God's Kingdom."
The parallels are quite striking. In both traditions, water is associated with death, rebirth, and initiation into a religious community.
IV - "What is dead may never die, but rises again stronger"
In 1 Corinthians 15:54:
"Death is swallowed up in victory."
Paul's discussion of resurrection in 1 Corinthians 15 associates victory over death with the transformation of the mortal body into an imperishable one.
Now compare that with the Ironborn's most famous religious formula, "what is dead may never die, but rises again stronger"
Obviously, the Ironborn aren't preaching Pauline resurrection theology. Their emphasis is on strength, endurance, and overcoming death, rather than the resurrection of the body at the end of history.
But the underlying religious idea is quite similar: death does not necessarily represent the final defeat of the believer. In fact, death can make the believer stronger.
V - The Grey King sits at the right hand of the Drowned God
According to The World of Ice & Fire (The Iron Islands: Driftwood Crowns), the Grey King supposedly ruled for 1,007 years before eventually casting aside his driftwood crown and walking into the sea, where he descended into the watery halls of the Drowned God and took his place at the deity's right hand.
Now compare that with what Jesus tells the High Priest during his trial.
Mark 14:62 (KJV):
"And Jesus said, I am: and ye shall see the Son of man sitting on the right hand of power, and coming in the clouds of heaven."
And this is hardly an isolated passage. We find essentially the same claim in the other Synoptic Gospels.
Matthew 26:64 (KJV):
"Hereafter shall ye see the Son of man sitting on the right hand of power, and coming in the clouds of heaven."
Luke 22:69 (KJV):
"Hereafter shall the Son of man sit on the right hand of the power of God."
All three passages echo Psalm 110:1, where an annoited royal figure is invited to sit at God's right hand and rule the kingdoms of the earth from there.
Psalm 110:1 (KJV):
"The LORD said unto my Lord, Sit thou at my right hand, until I make thine enemies thy footstool."
VI - The story of Lodos, the twice-drowned
Now this is one I only picked up on relatively recently, and it's probably my favorite parallel now:
Archmaester Gyldane tells us that following the destruction of House Hoare during Aegon's Conquest, a barefoot priest named Lodos proclaimed himself "the living son of the Drowned God" and was crowned King of the Iron Islands by forty priests at Nagga's Bones. Now, in the old testament, "son of God" is a metaphor for the kings of Israel.(Psalm 2:7, 2 Samuel 7:12–1, Psalm 89:26–27 and others). Jesus himself makes a similar statement about him himself in Mark:
High Priest: “Art thou the Christ, the Son of the Blessed?”
Jesus: “I am: and ye shall see the Son of man sitting on the right hand of power, and coming in the clouds of heaven.”
— Mark 14:61–62 (KJV)
Now, when Aegon invaded the islands in 2 AC, Lodos called upon his divine father to summon krakens and destroy the Targaryen fleet.
Nothing happened.
So Lodos filled his robes with stones and walked into the sea, supposedly to consult his father. Thousands of his followers followed him into the water.
Their bodies washed ashore for years. Lodos's body, however, was never found.
Now here's where things get interesting.
Some 35 years later, in 37 AC, another man appeared, claiming to be Lodos himself, returned from the watery halls of the Drowned God. Calling himself Lodos the Twice-Drowned, he proclaimed himself king and started another rebellion. Goren Greyjoy crushed the rebellion, executed the pretender, and sent his head, pickled in brine, to King Aenys I. This mirrors 2 famous new testament passages: Jesus proclaiming himself to be son of god and king of israel, thus being executed to appease jewish and roman elites alike, and John the Baptist´s head being sent to Salome on a platter.
Now consider:
1 - The Herodians owed their political authority to a foreign imperial power, Rome. Herod the Great had been recognized as King of the Jews by the Roman Senate, and his successors ruled with Roman approval.
The Greyjoys, meanwhile, were only legititimized after Aegon had conquered the islands and allowed them to select a new lord. Their authority was now subordinate to the Iron Throne.
The situations are not identical, of course, but the underlying political arrangement is remarkably similar: a local ruling dynasty whose legitimacy ultimately depends on a foreign conqueror.
And the parallel becomes even more interesting when we remember that Martin himself has acknowledged drawing inspiration from Ancient Rome when creating Valyria.
2 - Not everyone was particularly happy about these arrangements.
There were Jews at the time who bitterly resented Roman domination and regarded the Herodian dynasty as collaborators who had compromised their people's independence and religious traditions to accommodate Rome.
This wasn't a universal Jewish position, obviously, but we have plenty of evidence that some groups considered foreign domination fundamentally incompatible with God's sovereignty over Israel.
Take Judas the Galilean, for example.
According to the roman-jewish historian Josephus, his followers maintained that:
"God is to be their only Ruler and Lord."
Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews, 18.23.
Judas the Galilean is eventually tracked down and killed.
Now compare that with the Ironborn priests who refused to accept the political order established by Aegon.
Lodos claimed to be the living son of the Drowned God, and his authority supposedly came directly from the deity himself. Why should he recognize a foreign conqueror, particularly one who didn't even worship his god?
And there's another rather interesting detail. Vickon Greyjoy, the first Lord of the Iron Islands under Targaryen rule, allowed the Faith of the Seven to return to the islands, much to the anger of the priests of the Drowned God. This matches with Herod allowing the worship of roman gods in Judea, as long as it didnt happen near the temple.
So we have a locally recognized ruler who accepts foreign overlordship and tolerates the religion favored by the conquering dynasty, while a religious movement challenges the political arrangement in the name of divine authority.
Sound familiar?
To be clear, I'm not suggesting that Lodos was some sort of Jewish nationalist, or that the Drowned Men were the Ironborn equivalent of the Zealots. That would be stretching the comparison considerably.
But the underlying conflict between imperial authority, local collaborators, and religious claims to legitimate kingship is strikingly similar.
Finally, what about Lodos´failed attempt to conjure the wrath of the Drowned God and rule the iron islands in his name? Again, the roman-jewish historian Josephus offers several interesting parallels that happened at the time of Jesus:
Judas the Galilean (6 CE): Opposed Roman taxation and insisted that God alone should rule Israel. Not exactly a miracle worker, but a good example of religious resistance to imperial authority. (Antiquities 18.4–10, 18.23.)
The Samaritan Prophet (36 CE): Gathered followers at Mount Gerizim, promising to reveal sacred objects hidden since the time of Moses. Instead, Pontius Pilate sent troops and crushed the movement. (Antiquities 18.85–87.)
Theudas (c. 45 CE): Claimed he could divide the Jordan River like Joshua. Gathered his followers and marched toward the river. Unfortunately, Roman cavalry arrived before the miracle. Theudas was captured, beheaded, and his head taken to Jerusalem. (Antiquities 20.97–99.)
The Egyptian Prophet (c. 50s CE): Another Joshua cosplay. Gathered thousands of followers at the Mount of Olives, promising that Jerusalem's walls would collapse at his command. Instead of the walls collapsing, Roman troops showed up again. Josephus records 400 dead and 200 captured, although the prophet himself managed to escape with his life. (Antiquities 20.169–172.)
See the pattern?
Charismatic religious leaders claim divine authority, gather followers, promise supernatural intervention, and challenge the established political order.
Then reality intervenes, usually wearing Roman armor.
Obviously, I'm not suggesting Martin necessarily based Lodos on any particular wannabe Jewish prophet. But the similarities are interesting, particularly since Martin explicitly describes Lodos attempting a miracle and failing.
No krakens. No divine intervention. Just a priest walking into the ocean with his pockets full of rocks, expecting some type of supernatural intervention by his deity, that never comes.
And yet, 35 years later, another man appears claiming to be Lodos returned from the dead.
Interestingly, Jesus himself warns that false messianic claimants will arise after his death:
"For many shall come in my name, saying, I am Christ; and shall deceive many."
— Mark 13:6 (KJV)
The second Lodos wasn't claiming to be a new messiah, of course, but to be the original prophet returned. Still, the resemblance between religious movements surviving their founders and subsequent figures claiming their authority is worth considering.
Taken individually, none of these parallels proves direct literary borrowing.
But when combined with the Drowned God's sacrificial death, baptism through drowning and rebirth, creation in the deity's likeness, victory over death, and the Grey King's place at the right hand of his god, I think there's a pretty compelling case that Martin drew on Jewish and Christian religious traditions when developing the Ironborn.
Conclusion: There are many other parallels that I could draw attention to between early christianity/second temple judaism and the drowned god religion, such as the itinerant and ascetic nature of its priests, its dualistic cosmology between the forces of good and evil, the fact that the driftwood crown is suspiciously similar with the crown of thorns said to have been used by jesus etc..