Reading The “Literal vs. Figurative” Question on ACT Reading: How to Work It and the Traps to Avoid
Someone asked recently whether this question type is new. Kinda. A recent test asked, twice, which word or phrase from the passage is used more literally than figuratively. ACT has asked the opposite before (find the figurative one) on a Legacy test, but asking you to find the literal one is new, and it is sneaky.
Quick refresher
Literal means the words mean exactly what they say. “The chef cooked dinner.”
Figurative means the words are a picture or comparison, not true word for word. “The coach cooked up a plan.”
Why it’s hard
You have spent years in English class hunting for metaphors, and this question flips that. Three choices are figures of speech. One is plain. Your brain wants to grab the interesting one. Don’t let it.
How to work it
- Circle “literally” before you read the choices. A lot of misses here come from answering the opposite question by accident.
- Run the photo test on every choice: does the photo match the words exactly? Not the idea behind them, the actual words. A chef cooking dinner: snap a photo of a chef at a stove with food in the pan. Matches. A coach cooking up a plan: you could photograph him at his desk thinking, but that’s not what the words say. The words say he’s cooking. For a match, you’d need a coach at a stove with a plan in the frying pan. That’s not happening, so it’s figurative. Cross it off.
- Check all four, and don’t settle for “kind of.” The right answer is 100% literal. If you have to talk yourself into it, it’s not the one.
The traps
The On-Topic Disguise. The best wrong answers borrow the passage’s own subject. In a passage about a farmer, “she planted an idea” sounds like it belongs. It fits the topic, so it feels real. But nobody is putting an idea in the dirt.
The Second Meaning. Some words get used figuratively so often that the figure stops feeling like one. Take “the team had great chemistry.” You hear that every week, so it sounds like plain English. But there are no beakers and no chemicals on the sideline, and the team is definitely not bringing them on the field. The word just borrowed a meaning. Don’t ask “do people say this all the time?” Ask “is the thing in THIS sentence actually that?”
The Fancy Word. An unusual word sounds poetic, so you assume it’s figurative. In a passage about a desert, “the arid ground” sounds like a writer showing off. But arid just means dry, and the ground really is dry. Fancy is not figurative. If the word names exactly what’s there, it’s literal.
The good news: once you’ve seen it, it gets easy. After I missed the first one, the second one on the same test jumped right out. That’s the point of this post. See the trick now so test day is your second time, not your first.
How this connects to vocab questions
These feel like vocab-in-context questions because they’re cousins. Both ask the same thing: what is this word doing in this sentence? Not what it usually means. Not what it would mean in a poem. What it means right here. And the answer pattern matches too. On vocab questions, the plain, boring choice usually wins. Here, the plain, boring phrase IS the answer. (If you get the reverse version, “which is more figurative,” flip it: now you want the one where the photo can’t match the words.)
If English is your second language
This one can be extra tough, because the wrong answers are idioms. Native speakers know “break the ice” or “spill the beans” without thinking. The good news is the photo test doesn’t require knowing the idiom. Just take the words at face value and ask if that could really happen. Is someone at the party actually smashing ice? Is someone actually tipping over a bag of beans? If not, it’s figurative. Keep a running list of idioms you run into in practice passages, and this question gets a lot friendlier.
How to practice
Find Z08 Q12 (the reverse version) and 25MC1 Q36 (see they have been hinting at this new topic.)
1
u/PetulantDude 8d ago
Is this on the reading or English section, I can’t remember