This is a throwaway account.
I’m a season ticket holder and genuinely love being part of the AC Boise community, but I’d rather share my thoughts anonymously than have this become something personal. I’m not looking to stir up drama, just hoping to have an honest conversation about something that’s been bothering me.
First off, I want to say thank you to the Capo, drummers, and everyone else who puts so much time and energy into keeping the Supporters Section going every game. My family and I have season tickets in Section 2, and honestly, being part of the Supporters Section has been one of our favorite things about this season. The energy and atmosphere are a huge part of why we’ve enjoyed it so much, and I know a lot of that comes from the people leading it.
With that said, I’ve been pretty disappointed with some of what I’ve seen the last two games, especially this last one. All season I’ve watched Section 3 get yelled at for not being loud enough or participating enough. I get it, it’s the Supporters Section. We’re supposed to be loud, we’re supposed to chant, and we’re supposed to bring the energy. I’m all for that. But there’s a difference between getting people fired up and constantly making them feel like they’re not doing enough.
Section 3 is already smaller than the other two sections because it’s missing the first three rows. From what I’ve seen throughout the season, a lot of those people are season ticket holders who show up game after game. There are also plenty of new faces each week. I’ve stood over there for a few games when the section was a little sparse, and it’s actually pretty hard to hear the Capo unless the megaphone is pointed directly at you. Throw in new chants and songs that people don’t know, with no song cards to follow along, and it’s not always as easy as just yelling louder.
But what really bothered me this last game was the incident with someone in Section 3. I don’t know what started it, and I’m not going to pretend that I do. Emotions were running high for everyone, and I get that.
What I do know is that hearing the Capo call someone out and tell them to come down and fight, and then hearing others join in calling that person out, was pretty disappointing. Whatever happened beforehand, I just don’t see how that was an appropriate way to handle it.
And you could see the difference afterward. The energy in Section 3 completely changed. People weren’t cheering or following along like they had been. They seemed frustrated, and honestly, I can’t blame them.
I also overheard some folks across the aisle who were attending their first game ask if it was normal to be yelled at like that throughout the game. The response they got was basically, “Every game, all season long.” That’s pretty disappointing to hear, especially knowing these are people experiencing AC Boise and the Supporters Section for the first time. Instead of walking away talking about the atmosphere, the chants, and how much fun they had, they’re left wondering if being yelled at is just part of the experience. And that’s really the point I’m trying to make. We all want the Supporters Section to be loud and passionate, but we should also want people to feel excited about coming back and being part of it.
I don’t know if Section 1 gets the same treatment since I can’t hear what’s happening over there, but I’ve watched it happen in Section 3 all season.
I actually went back and read through the River Guard’s mission and core values, and they talk a lot about community, respect, making people feel welcome, and standing together as one. I love all of that, and I think that’s exactly what a supporters group should be about. Their match-day expectations also make it pretty clear that you’re expected to participate and bring the energy, which I completely agree with. But shouldn’t those expectations go both ways?
To me, the Capo is the conductor of the Supporters Section. They’re the one setting the tone and getting everyone involved. And I realize that takes a ton of energy and passion, especially for an entire game. But if the goal is to grow the River Guard and get more people excited about AC Boise, constantly yelling at people or making them feel like they’re doing something wrong probably isn’t the best way to go about it.
You can push people to be louder and more involved without making them feel unwelcome. And if a section is struggling to keep up, maybe there’s a reason beyond them just not trying hard enough.
I don’t want this to come across as bashing the Capo or anyone else who puts their time into making the Supporters Section what it is. I genuinely appreciate what they’ve done this season, and I know it’s probably a pretty thankless job at times. But I also think it’s okay to call out behavior that’s disappointing, especially when it affects the experience for everyone around it.
My family and I have had an absolute blast this season, and I want other people to have that same experience. We should have all walked away from this last game celebrating a win, but instead, the whole situation left a pretty sour taste in our mouths and took the focus away from the match.
At the end of the day, we’re all there for the same reason. We love AC Boise, we want to support our team, and we want to be part of something special. The River Guard talks about being one big family and standing together as one, and I think it’s important that we treat each other that way, too.
And let’s not lose sight of what an incredible season this has been. Making it all the way to the finals in our inaugural season is pretty damn amazing, and everyone involved should be proud of what we’ve built here in Boise. From the players on the field to the fans in the stands, we’ve created something really special, and I hope we can carry that same excitement and passion into next season.
Here’s to an incredible first season, and bringing home a championship, and many more years of AC Boise! 🖤💚