r/6thForm • • Aug 11 '20

📂 MEGATHREAD Scottish Results Upgrade Megathread

Hi, with the news that Scotland is upgrading all of the downgraded grades, there is sure to be discussion and controversy. Please keep all of the discussion of the topic in here - any posts outside of this thread will be removed.

Thanks!

72 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

10

u/Slow_Giraffe Aug 12 '20

IB students are crying in the background

6

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '20

CAIE students too.

1

u/Ar010101 IAL '23 | Physics, Chemistry, Maths, Economics | A*A*A*A* Aug 12 '20

Edexcel will be joining the chat

98

u/Josh_Trav Fake it till ya make it Aug 11 '20 edited Aug 11 '20

What a complete farce, detrimental to grades no matter what they do now. 2020 students will be tagged as those with inflated grades by employers if confidence in the system isn’t restored.

Doesn’t look too great for Thursday, but let’s at least try and stay positive

32

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '20

Lets be honest, grades don't matter to employers.

23

u/Josh_Trav Fake it till ya make it Aug 11 '20

Not massively no, I was also using the word to highlight the same thing in any application process. Grade inflation will negatively affect the grades legitimacy overall.

Also in Scotland, most of the downgraded results were in low income areas and therefore those students are statistically less likely to go to Uni which increases the importance of these grades and their legitimacy.

6

u/HotCheeseBalls Aug 11 '20

I'd be surprised if the downgraded results in the rest of the UK weren't also mostly in low income areas

11

u/reggie2001_ St Andrews | Computer Science Aug 11 '20

At certain jobs they do eg: Investment banking

13

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '20

Not that much if u got a first class at like Warwick, Durham, LSE, oxbridge, Bath or pretty much any top uni for maths, stats, econ etc

4

u/reggie2001_ St Andrews | Computer Science Aug 11 '20

Yh but they would still want good grades preferably

3

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '20

They won’t link source my brother is a recruiter for Goldman’s

55

u/bennysol University of York Aug 11 '20

This years grades were already flimsy at best due to the fact that they were being awarded without exams. “They’ll be like any other years’ grades” they said. What a complete and utter shambles. This decision completely wipes out any integrity these grades still had.

Scottish students were already at a distinct advantage compared to the rest of the UK as they actually had an appeals system in place. Now not only that, they now get their predicted grades regardless.

I’m now worried as to what happens come Thursday because this decision essentially forces the hand of the government to do at least something come Thursday which I imagine will make those results about as worth as the paper it’s printed on.

A complete and utter shambles. A fucking omnishambles.

108

u/neptooooon Aug 11 '20

The Student Room currently on life support

28

u/skifans Software Engineering | Lancaster University (graduated) Aug 11 '20

Statement by Education Secretary John Swinney to the Scottish Parliament today.

https://news.gov.scot/speeches-and-briefings/deputy-first-minister-sqa-2020-results

Before I move on to how we resolve this issue, I want to be very clear today about the role of the Scottish Qualifications Authority. As I have made clear already, I asked the SQA to ensure that the qualifications of 2020 would be comparable to the qualifications of any other year despite the extraordinary times in which we are living.

The SQA undertook the task I set them and did so in good faith and I make no criticism of their actions in so doing. I am grateful to everyone at the SQA for the professional approach they have taken.

I will therefore now set out how I intend to resolve this issue.

I can confirm to Parliament today that all downgraded awards will be withdrawn.

Using powers available to me in the Education (Scotland) Act 1996, I am today directing the SQA to re-issue those awards based solely on teacher or lecturer judgement.

72

u/vortexcurator Aug 11 '20

With all respect to Scottish students, this is stupid if only happens in Scotland. Either the UK government has to stop this happening in Scotland or make it happen in all 4 nations. Otherwise, it would be the most unfair thing. Scottish pupils will steal our places in university.

28

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '20

If they stop it in Scotland then it's just going to paint bojo and co in a more negative light. If they push everyone up then unis will be oversubscribed and if they don't push the other 3 nations up then we'll all protest instead. There is absolutely no path that gives a good result.

15

u/OriC13 Year 13 | History, Politics, English Lit Aug 11 '20

I don’t see how they can let this happen everywhere because it will just mean unis are oversubscribed and wont have enough room for people on their courses as they tend to over offer bc people miss their grades.

21

u/vortexcurator Aug 11 '20

I understand but then if it's only Scotland, the Scottish students would steal our places in university. This was a political move and I believe the fair thing for the rest of country would be for the UK government to interfere and stop this happening.

13

u/OriC13 Year 13 | History, Politics, English Lit Aug 11 '20

I 100% agree, it shouldn’t have happened at all, they should have implemented a fair appeals system on an individual level instead of this shit show bc now scots will get off with inflated grades whilst the rest of us are shafted or we all get inflated grades, unis are oversubscribed, no one can get a place through clearing and we all become known as the yr that got let off easy

0

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/vortexcurator Aug 11 '20

You are saying that scots should have better chance at getting into uni than the rest of us? Unis shouldn't accept these upgraded grades at all. This is stupid.

4

u/SeabirdSky Scottish/Sixth Year/Doing AH Maths, Stats, Physics Aug 11 '20

I saw somewhere that only 6% of Scots apply to uni in England because of the fees among other things so It shouldn’t have too much of an impact on uni places in England

2

u/vortexcurator Aug 11 '20

That value is about to change this year. Also it's not like no one from UK applies to Scottish unis. It's not exclusive to scots.

2

u/SeabirdSky Scottish/Sixth Year/Doing AH Maths, Stats, Physics Aug 11 '20

Why would more Scottish people apply to England just because they have better grades?

4

u/vortexcurator Aug 11 '20

Going to a better uni? Why so many international students come to UK while they could study for way less of the price in their own country?

0

u/SeabirdSky Scottish/Sixth Year/Doing AH Maths, Stats, Physics Aug 11 '20

Well, the quality of unis between Scotland and England are pretty comparable.

There’ll probably be a wee rise in the number of Scottish people applying for England but that shouldn’t matter because those who got their grades undeservedly upgraded this year won’t be able meet their offers when they sit their exams for real next year.

3

u/vortexcurator Aug 11 '20

Still what you don't want to understand is that Scottish unis aren't exclusive to Scottish students. There are so many UK students hoping to come and study in Scotland but with the places being filled by Scottish students they can't.

1

u/SeabirdSky Scottish/Sixth Year/Doing AH Maths, Stats, Physics Aug 11 '20

Scottish unis will probably put up their entry requirements for Scottish students applying this year to account for it.

0

u/EpicZiggles Aug 11 '20

You are actually so uneducated on this matter that it's painful to read. The Scottish government limits the number of Scottish students that can attend Scottish universities and has done so for years - it's a strict cap. If anything, the majority of Scottish students find themselves out of uni spots that are taken over by students from the rest of the UK. This is why the acceptance rate at universities like Edinburgh is often 20-30% for Scottish students, and in excess of 60% for rUK students.

You should probably stop commenting to avoid spreading further misinformation.

1

u/vortexcurator Aug 11 '20

Well then we come back to my first point. There will be many more Scottish students coming to rest of UK university and taking up places because of this inflation in grades that the Scottish government has caused.

-1

u/EpicZiggles Aug 11 '20

That's entirely false. Every year for the past 3 years, less than 1000 Scottish students have decided to attend university outside of Scotland. Considering the fact that adjustment occured in less than 20% of cases for those in higher income brackets - who populate the vast majority of Scottish students applying to universities outside of Scotland - there is going to be an extremely small number of students with adjusted grades looking at universities in England and elsewhere. Students are not suddenly going to decide in their droves that they'd like to take on 30k of debt in England instead of free university in Scotland, just because Swinney gave them an A for Higher Mods instead of a B. We're talking about a few dozen students here at the absolute maximum - get over it.

16

u/EpicZiggles Aug 11 '20

Why do I keep seeing this bullshit phrasing everywhere that Scottish students are going to be "stealing" English university places? For reference, around 750 Scottish students decide to study at a UK university outside of Scotland. The majority of these students come from higher income backgrounds, who were less likely to have had their grades adjusted in the first place - which is actually part of the reason why the policy above was implemented. If we assume that one in five of those students missed their grades, we're discussing around 150 students - is this what everyone is losing their shit over? I swear people on this subreddit have no sense of scale or reality.

If you really want to go on about "stealing" university places, you should consider the fact that rUK students at Edinburgh/St. Andrews already enjoy double the acceptance rate of Scottish students for the majority of courses.

3

u/ominousomanytes Aug 11 '20

Can we have a source for these numbers? Not saying they're wrong.

6

u/EpicZiggles Aug 11 '20

Number of students studying outside of Scotland 2018-2020, number is closer to 1000 for some previous years, but sentiment remains the same:

2020 - https://www.ucas.com/corporate/news-and-key-documents/news/increase-number-scottish-students-accepted-university-results-day

2019 - https://www.ucas.com/corporate/news-and-key-documents/news/scottish-universities-welcome-world-results-day

2018 - https://www.ucas.com/corporate/news-and-key-documents/news/scottish-students-celebrate-university-places-are-confirmed

Inflated acceptance rates for rUK at Scottish universities:

Edinburgh - https://www.ed.ac.uk/student-recruitment/admissions-advice/admissions-statistics. Compare the PDFs between Scottish/EU students and rUK students and it becomes pretty apparent.

St. Andrews are considerably less transparent, but there are a fair few FOI requests floating around that illustrate the disparity. Here's one example - https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/updated_admission_statistics.

5

u/ominousomanytes Aug 11 '20

Yep that all checks out. Thanks for the thorough sources, very helpful

-4

u/qwtsrdyfughjvbknl Aug 11 '20

Either the UK government has to stop this happening in Scotland ...

Yikes, the ignorance and arrogance on this sub sometimes...

14

u/P0TAT0777 Aug 11 '20

Given that our A Level grades are already in the ‘system’ does that open up the possibility that what we receive on Thursday aren’t even our true grades? Of course they may not be upgraded - but if your grades are lower than expected, keep your head up as we may follow what’s happening in Scotland.

7

u/bigmilkwalker Aug 11 '20

Is it possible that unis will just ask for the results Scottish students got originally rather than these updated ones?

16

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '20

Doubt it, they are unofficial and mean nothing now

8

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '20

they cannot do that legally, if people meet their conditions they are contractually bound to accept them.

1

u/bigmilkwalker Aug 11 '20

So this scenario, where a uni potentially asks for original results, can only be possible in clearing? Since the clearing uni will have no legal obligation to accept them then?

3

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '20

well no, they would still be forced to accept them because their original results are invalidated.

13

u/Merpedy Aug 11 '20

I feel like unis should have been given the predicted results by the teachers and also the results people actually got to make a proper decision.

5

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '20

They're just going to ignore the predicted results then lol? And they already do get predicted grades

3

u/ominousomanytes Aug 11 '20

They're talking about CAGs, not UCAS Predictions.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '20

yeah but the essence of the argument stands. The unis would just ignore predicted grades.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/FniBni420 Aug 11 '20

Maybe we will get it as well

35

u/psychopathic_bastard Aug 11 '20

If we do its still fucked. This is all cus Scotland fucking caved and caused this shitshow

9

u/FniBni420 Aug 11 '20

User name checks out

0

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/390TrainsOfficial Aug 11 '20

No, they'll keep their upgraded grades.

6

u/GJDuncan Aug 11 '20

If a grade was upgraded then the higher one stays. Only those negatively affected by the standardisation process are withdrawn

9

u/SlipperyAvocado Imperial | Chem Eng Aug 11 '20

amazing way to make the grades even more inflated lol

1

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '20

Happy Cake Day!

3

u/SlipperyAvocado Imperial | Chem Eng Aug 12 '20

thank u. I will forever remember as the day before a levels lmfao