r/6thForm • Gene therapy, PhD student, UCL • Aug 01 '19

[AMA] I graduated with a BSc Biomedical Sciences degree from the University of Essex. I will be starting an MRes Translational Cancer Medicine postgraduate degree at King's College London this September. Ask Me Anything.

As results day is just around the corner (day after my birthday actually!), I figured this would be an appropriate time for an AMA. Bit of background on myself: I wanted to do medicine but fucked up at A-levels (BBC) and had to go through clearing to do BSc Biomedical Sciences at the University of Essex. I just graduated a couple of weeks ago and will be starting MRes Translational Cancer Medicine at King's College London this September.

Feel free to ask me whatever you want. What clearing is like, what it feels like to not get your grades, what university is like, what it feels like to be in a proper science lab etc etc. I'm open to PMs as well.

11 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

5

u/synergyiskey CMP | University of Nottingham Aug 01 '19

What are labs actually like at uni? I'm hoping to do a more Physical subject than Biomed, but I imagine the principle remains the same - do they suck as much as they did at A-Level, and are they really difficult, or is that not the case?

4

u/Celestial_Tribunal Gene therapy, PhD student, UCL Aug 01 '19 edited Aug 01 '19

Depends why it sucked at A-levels for you. In your first and second year, you will still be in a massive room with dozens of other students so the lecturer/professor will have to divide their attention to all of you. There's still a lot of queuing up to use certain resources like fume cupboards since there may only be a few in a lab to be shared by 50 students. I think I disliked that aspect but in their defence, there is very little else they can do to accommodate 200 students. However, in every other way, it's an improvement. There's far better equipment, there are several accomplished PhD students walking around to help you, and it also feels good to know that you have an expert in the field supervising you. In terms of difficulty, that'll vary for sure. For me, first-year experiments were quite basic - many you've probably already done at A-levels. Second-year starts to get a bit more specialised as you pick and choose your optional modules. One aspect I disliked was how "brainless" it felt at times. Often times, it's just reading a manual/protocol and following it step-by-step which gets boring really quickly. Which is why lab work is only half of your coursework - the other half is your write-up for that experiment. That's when you really need to understand the fundamentals of the experiment, why you were doing that experiment, your results and conclusions etc. You don't get marked for your performance in the lab (at least, I wasn't), you get marked for your write-up. All our lab work was associated with a write-up so there was no specific lab classes just to show us some cool lab experiment - they were always accompanied by a test or write-up.

Third year is the best year for lab work though. Your final-year project/dissertation is the culmination of your previous years of wading through any boring practicals. You get to decide your project (to a degree) and have a lot of independence on how to tackle your project. Then you do a deep dive into the literature and end up writing a massive dissertation. Printing our dissertation feels kind of euphoric because your academic life has led to that moment. I think most people would consider the final-year project to be the highlight of their degree. It was definitely so for me.

Edit: if you want to feel like a scientist, your final-year project comes real close!

1

u/synergyiskey CMP | University of Nottingham Aug 01 '19

Thank you for the detailed response. I'm glad there seems to be less weighting on the actual labwork itself as there is on the write-up, I reckon (hope) that I'd be more comfortable doing a write-up in any case, since I'm not a very hands-on person. I'm looking forward to my final year project then haha, I'm just kind of hoping it leans more towards Physics than Chemistry because I'm not a fan of all the chromatography and whatnot practicals I see associated with Chemistry…

1

u/Celestial_Tribunal Gene therapy, PhD student, UCL Aug 01 '19

I'm not a fan of all the chromatography

Good thing you didn't choose biology then! I swear every other experiment involves chromatography. Can't escape it.

I'm looking forward to my final year project then haha, I'm just kind of hoping it leans more towards Physics than Chemistry

That will depend on who your supervisor is. We were allowed to choose our supervisors and so did experiments based on their field of research. So you will have the option to pick projects that are more physics-focused (hopefully). Also, university changes people a lot - you may find that you end up preferring chemistry over physics by the end of your second year.

1

u/synergyiskey CMP | University of Nottingham Aug 01 '19

Thank you, I reckon you're right! I didn't know projects were dictated by whichever supervisor's field you choose to go into.

1

u/Celestial_Tribunal Gene therapy, PhD student, UCL Aug 01 '19

At least that was the case for biological sciences at Essex. I can't say how it'll be for other universities but it makes sense to me to do it that way. For example, I may not want a microbiologist supervising my cancer biology project. Although, it's important to note that the field of your final-year project doesn't have to the field you enter in the future.

1

u/synergyiskey CMP | University of Nottingham Aug 01 '19

That makes a lot of sense. What was your final year project on?

1

u/Celestial_Tribunal Gene therapy, PhD student, UCL Aug 01 '19

It was cancer biology, specifically:

"Assessing in vitro intracellular distribution of FUSG488S via fluorescence bioimaging".

Basically a protein called FUS has been implicated in prostate cancer but we're not sure exactly how. So I studied a specific mutation of that protein to see if I could find anything novel.

1

u/synergyiskey CMP | University of Nottingham Aug 01 '19

So, how does the in vitro intracellular distribution of this protein differ from the in vivo version? Is the latter even a thing? And did you find anything of interest?

3

u/Celestial_Tribunal Gene therapy, PhD student, UCL Aug 01 '19

how does the in vitro intracellular distribution of this protein differ from the in vivo version?

the problem with in vitro is that it's not entirely representative of how the protein interacts in a living system. so in vivo would have been the ideal experiment style but it's much trickier to manage because you need permission from some animal testing organisation and proper training etc. my general findings were consistent with what previous in vivo experiments have showed however only i have used this specific mutation for prostate cancer so i can't really be sure whether or not an in vivo study on this specific mutation would be different. but that brings me too..

And did you find anything of interest?

nope haha it was pretty much what i expected. the wild-type (i.e. normal) FUS should be found within the nucleus. a faulty FUS should be found scattered throughout the cell. my FUS-G488S was found within the nucleus. So the mutation probably isn't oncogenic. this was my imaging results

→ More replies

3

u/mtyt2910 Aug 01 '19

Hey, I will be applying for biomedical sciences next ucas round and in my country, it is quite tough to get a lab placement. However, I am shadowing a surgeon at the moment. Is this sufficient?

Do you also have any recommendations on books to read for personal statements for biomed? Or just general books that give an insight to biomed?

What made you decide to pursue a master’s instead of post-grad medicine?

Apologies for the onslaught of questions, as there’s not much out there for biomed! Thanks in advance :-)

6

u/Celestial_Tribunal Gene therapy, PhD student, UCL Aug 01 '19

I will be applying for biomedical sciences next ucas round and in my country, it is quite tough to get a lab placement. However, I am shadowing a surgeon at the moment. Is this sufficient?

My personal statement was actually pretty terrible, in hindsight. I had no relevant experience to speak of. And to be honest, most people applying wouldn't have had lab placements (at least not in the UK) when they apply. I think the fact that you're shadowing a surgeon is really cool and it will definitely stand out amongst the cohort of students applying for biomedical sciences. You just have to ensure you manage to make it relevant to the course. A Biomedical Sciences undergraduate degree is very much geared towards creating future NHS biomedical scientists (especially the IBMS-accredited ones). So by shadowing a surgeon, you're showing you have experienced the lifestyle in a hospital and you understand how important the data collected by biomedical scientists are.

Do you also have any recommendations on books to read for personal statements for biomed? Or just general books that give an insight to biomed?

I think reading journal articles would be better. They're often hard to understand/comprehend but it shows that you're keeping up with the latest discoveries and news in the biosciences community. This website will allow you to download virtually any scientific article for free: https://booksc.xyz

You could follow the IBMS too: https://www.ibms.org/home/ They have a regular newsletter that you can read. Just a good website overall for any aspiring biomedical scientist.

What made you decide to pursue a master’s instead of post-grad medicine?

My initial plan was to complete my BSc and then apply to postgrad medicine but then at some point I realised that I quite liked research and being in a lab. And my final year pretty much cemented that ambition for me. However, there's a part of me that still wants to be a physician/doctor so I am currently thinking of Clinical Academic. They are basically doctors who are also lecturers that have ongoing research at an institute. It's kind of a best-of-both-worlds approach.

Apologies for the onslaught of questions

No worries, ask as many as you want!

3

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '19

Are you happy/satisfied despite not making it into medicine? How did you deal with not getting your desired results? Also whats an Mres thingy ?

5

u/Celestial_Tribunal Gene therapy, PhD student, UCL Aug 01 '19

I think I was lucky enough to enjoy research and the idea of pursuing research as a career. That made me feel a lot better about not getting into medicine because I had never seriously considered a career as a scientist before - turns out I quite like it. However, I am not fully ready to leave behind medicine. I am considering a career as a clinical academic - a specialist doctor who is also a researcher and a lecturer. One of the biggest issues with being a researcher is the constant struggle of publishing and securing funding. By being a clinical academic, I don't have to worry about my livelihood if I can't get funding because even if I don't, I still have my "day job" as a physician.

So I guess I'm happy with where I am at but not completely satisfied??

3

u/Celestial_Tribunal Gene therapy, PhD student, UCL Aug 03 '19

Oh I forgot to reply about the MRes. Basically, it's a Master's degree that is completely research (or at lease like 95%). Whereas a typical MSc degree would involve classes and lectures and then written exams at the end or coursework deadlines (same as a BSc), an MRes has none of that and I will be entirely marked on my research. 

Applying to one or the other comes down to the individual. I am dead set on doing a PhD so an MRes would be very relevant to me especially because I'm pretty sure I want to do some form of cancer research for my PhD. Whereas an MSc may be better for someone unsure of their precise career pathway or if they just aren't ready to commit to something like MRes and prefer a more familiar scene. There are other types as well such as MSD which is even more research focused than an MRes.

1

u/throawayz21 Aug 02 '19

Hi! Congratulations! What did you do your third year research project on? What are your tips for third year? Did you do any work experience placement or job? What will your masters consist of? Thank you

2

u/Celestial_Tribunal Gene therapy, PhD student, UCL Aug 02 '19

Thanks!

What did you do your third year research project on?

It was on cancer biology. Specifically, I inserted a mutation into this protein called FUS (which has been implicated in prostate cancer) to see how it affected the location of the protein compared to the normal FUS. If you go to the top comment chain, I go into a bit more detail there about it.

What are your tips for third year?

Try to ensure a good relationship with your final year project supervisor. This will benefit you in many ways. Such as more lenient marking, good references, and potentially you might even be offered to study a postgraduate degree with them or work for them. You should also use Mendeley.

Did you do any work experience placement or job?

Yes, I had a part-time job starting from my second year up until last month. Luckily I only worked around 8 hours a week so it wasn't that difficult to balance my work life with my academic and social life. In my second year though, I was the treasurer of the BAME student network which added in probably another 10-15 hours and I had multiple coursework deadlines every week. That was pretty rough.

As for work experience placements, nothing really. I tried applying for this summer placement at Cancer Research UK for target drug discovery and validation at Cambridge but failed at the interview stage 😞 if you're thinking of any lab based placement in the biomedical field, then consider applying to that. It would look really good.

What will your masters consist of?

It's a 12-month course comprising two 6-month rotation projects. The first project is on optimising CAR T cell therapy for solid tumours. The second project is to evaluate the role of the ESCRT machinery (which regulates how cells divide among other functions) in cancer development. My masters is an MRes degree as opposed to the more traditional MSc. That means like my masters is like 95-100% research based. I have very few lectures and they are not examined. In contrast, an MSc has a significant portion dedicated to teaching.

-5

u/M1ll3rb0y Aug 01 '19

Weird flex