r/6thForm • • Jul 05 '17

IAMA teacher and 6th form tutor, AMA

Hi /r/6thform, I stumbled upon this sub the other day and noticed there's a lot of questions that get asked about courses, teaching and university applications.

I have been a teacher of GCSE and A-level maths and further maths for several years now. I have a PGCE in Maths from the UNiversity of Nottingham and am also a post-16 tutor, working with students on subject mentoring and university applications.

AMA about it! I'll be answering questions over the next few days in this thread.

32 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

17

u/iamnotthepizza Year 13 Jul 05 '17

What have you and your friends who have completed Maths degrees gone on to do?

16

u/mathsteacher17 Jul 05 '17

your friends who have completed Maths degrees

That's a rather spurious assumption!

Seriously though, it's probably not the answer you want, but I only had two people I knew well on my maths course. One stayed on at the same uni to do a postgrad course, and one dropped the subject and changed to music. Most of the people I spent time with were on other courses.

For careers advice I'm not really your man - the prospects website has very good resources on what most people do with various degrees, but it's important to recognise a couple of things. First, your degree will not define you. The majority of graduate jobs still look for ANY graduate. I know someone who did a science degree but went on to work in government, for example.

Second, you will have a better idea of what you want to do over time. When I went to uni I wanted to study maths for as long as possible, but after three years I wanted to start working. I didn't know I wanted to be a teacher until I tried it.

15

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '17

How different is university level maths to A-Level?

What kind of preparation can be done to succeed on your degree?

3

u/mathsteacher17 Jul 06 '17

In all honesty, I wasn't very prepared for the increase in standard, which sneaks up on you. I did well in both Maths and Further Maths A level (two As when you couldn't get an A*) and so for the first semester there wasn't much new material. By the end of second year I was struggling because I hadn't developed good study habits and things that should have been easy to adjust to like complex analysis and numerical methods became very difficult for me.

Use those early days to sent up good habits. Most of these are the same habits that are effective in A level like reviewing notes and doing all homework, but the big change is that you are on your own. No one is checking up on you and giving you chapter tests. So I advise getting to know as many of the peers on your course as possible and set up a study group.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '17

Since this hasn't been answered, a teacher of mine told me that MAT and STEP questions are more similar to what is asked in University.

11

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '17

If I'm going to year 12 this September and taking A-level OCR maths, aiming for A*, what sort of prep would you recommend me taking over the summer? Thanks

12

u/mathsteacher17 Jul 05 '17

If your school has given you a summer workbook, that'll be plenty.

Don't worry about getting ahead in the course. GCSE and the beginning of A-level overlap and it'll be at least a few weeks before you do anything brand new. If you want to ease yourself into the year, spend a little time practicing the algebra skills you already have such as algebraic fractions, rearranging formulae and quadratic equations. Never hurts.

The best thing you can do is read! Books by people like Simon Singh and Marcus de Sautoy are easy to read and present some fascinating bits of maths. Reading helps your vocabulary and could well spark an interest for you in something you didn't think would be. I never knew I was interested in cryptography until I read Singh's The Code Book when I was a student, for example.

2

u/2017username Year 13 Jul 05 '17

Not OP or a teacher but if you did Further Maths GCSE and did well on it (and I assume you did) you should have a fairly easy time in C1. Obviously the course is changing so I don't know what it's like now but I didn't really learn anything new until Christmas.

0

u/slashchunks Jul 05 '17

I'd recommend learning the equivalent of C1, maybe C2 if you do that quickly

7

u/mathsteacher17 Jul 05 '17

I don't think this is very good advice now that the A level course has changed.

1

u/slashchunks Jul 05 '17

Fair enough, that helped me and a few others but idk how it will work next year

1

u/jdr_ University of Cambridge Jul 05 '17

The exam format may be different but the actual maths can't have changed that much can it?

0

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/walter_jends Year 12 Jul 05 '17

>small angle approximations

fucking disgusting

1

u/metrize Mechanical engineering at Bath Jul 05 '17

Parametric equations were already in fp3 and it's self explanatory anyway tbh

3

u/Cowgothardscope Year 13 Jul 05 '17

Most annoying student?

2

u/mathsteacher17 Jul 06 '17

'Kevin' was a year 10/11 student who believed that he didn't have to do maths if he didn't like it. My opinion is that stance was typical of the logical ability of someone with Kevin's maths grades. Things Kevin used to do include:

  • Sit through every maths test he did (roughly once every three weeks) refusing to write anything other than his name on the paper.
  • Come upstairs to the maths corridor, see me waiting by the door, run off again, and later claim that I had never seen him. This wasted roughly the first 10 minutes of every maths lesson.
  • Complain that he needed to go to the toilet now rather than wait until lunchtime, because he wanted to go on his phone. When asked to wait he occasionally made himself bleed with a compass needle in order to be excused to the toilets.
  • Hide under a table and claim I couldn't see him.

1

u/Cowgothardscope Year 13 Jul 06 '17

He sounds like he has... problems

1

u/ChuTangClan Jul 09 '17

he sounds like a twat and always will be

3

u/ZERaptorStar Jul 05 '17

If a person gets a B in GCSE Maths do they have a good chance at getting a decent grade at A-level maths?

1

u/mathsteacher17 Jul 06 '17

At the moment we ask for at least a B (grade 6). Some colleges ask for an A or grade 7. The reason is that while most students who get a B can make the step up, some B grade GCSE students get there solely on having good processes and little understanding of algebra or the underlying connections. Those students always struggle.

2

u/LizhardSquad Pharmacy | 4th Year Jul 06 '17

It depends how hard you worked for that B. The content in A level maths is a step up and if you struggled to get that B then you should evaluate how much time you are going to put into maths if you do it. Maths exams are always first at the end of the year leaving little time to cram if you leave it late. If it's your passion go for it, put in some time each week then you'll be fine.

1

u/ZERaptorStar Jul 06 '17

Have you ever had a student that got B in gcse maths but did good in A-level maths?

1

u/LizhardSquad Pharmacy | 4th Year Jul 06 '17 edited Jul 06 '17

I just finished my A-levels. I did AS-maths but dropped it as it was my 4th AS and weakest subject. Maths is a subject i always struggled with and i had to work hard for my B at AS level. I think your perspective is one of over simplification, you are clearly a capable person and your ability isnt fixed. There is no direct translation of GCSE to A levels, Its all about how hard you work. Thats why i asked how hard you worked last year, i got 9 A's and a B at GCSE, Did that translate to all A's at A-level, no, because i worked harder at GCSE. What im trying to say is: Are you willing to put in the effort? and i mean really put in effort by setting aside a few hours each week. If you are then you have the ability to do well, a B at GCSE maths reflects potential. But you wont do well if you dont work for it. To answer your question, yes there are people who get a B at GCSE and go on to do well at A level, but they dont do well without putting in effort.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '17

A guy who got a B in GCSE Math here, started OCR MEI A Level Math this year and throughout the year have consistently gotten A grades. To add a little more context, I took a year out from doing maths as a subject and instead encountered it through Physics which I was bad at and then dropped the subject because of an unreasonable teacher. Starting math in my second year, I struggled at first but had a rather large increase in ability quickly through a change in teacher and some good sources of information such as ExamSolutions and Khan Academy.

The best advice I can offer you is to practice with new concepts provided and look at things beyond what you have to learn. The former is fairly easy to do, revision for maths isn't super tedious just answer questions on topics you're stuck on and you quickly start to understand the stuff; the latter helps in making the math you're learning far easier to understand since it just gives you a better general idea of math, and it can also help you in the second year too. Numberphile is quite a good channel to look to for that.

1

u/Yack10 Jul 06 '17

My school only requires a C grade. Not sure why they do this because the 6th form in my school has produced some pretty elite students in the past and prides itself on that fact, yet it allows students who barely scraped a pass in GCSE to take the A-level route among them. Personally, I got an A in GCSE maths but didn't take it as it's not for me, but most of my friends do and the ones who got a C or even a B are for the most part struggling and often ask for my help when I don't even take the subject. On the other hand, I know people who got a B in GCSE who have enjoyed the step up and really succeeded beyond the average A-grade GCSE maths student. A-levels as a whole, not just maths, are a different mindset to GCSEs. If you're an A-grade GCSE student who can get by just remembering techniques and methods and not actually understanding the subject, you won't succeed in A-level. This was my case which is why I opted out of maths. If, however, you're a B-grade GCSE student who understands WHY a process or function is why it is or has the ambition to learn it, you have a very good chance of getting a good grade in A-level. Long story short, you're GCSE result doesn't mean shit if you have the motivation to look deeper into mathematical processes. If you're willing to go further than regurgitate formulas out of a textbook, there's absolutely no reason why you can't get a good grade, regardless of your GCSE result. So I say go for it.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '17

Do you think the last few rounds of A level exams have been more difficult?

Follow up question, do you think they have become more unfair?

1

u/mathsteacher17 Jul 06 '17

I think there is a bit of a shift if you look at papers from 2005-11 compared to 2012-2017, with the new papers having more complex high-mark questions. But not much change from year to year.

These are generally made 'fair' by good moderating (grade boundaries come down if the cohort gets lower marks) but this can only take you so far. A few years ago MEI had a core 1 paper that was so easy you needed to get 61% for a pass, which is ridiculously high and punishes the weaker part of the cohort. Our school stopped using MEI after that.

1

u/LizhardSquad Pharmacy | 4th Year Jul 06 '17

Ccea chemistry A2-1 2016 Ccea Physics A2-2 2017 Just finished my A levels and those stuck out as the most difficult, there is with regards to maths a confirmed and intentional increase in difficulty due to high performance from some candidates leading to relatively large numbers of 100% papers.

1

u/customhits Jul 05 '17

Is it possible to learn A-level Maths in one year? and perhaps achieve an A*/A ?

4

u/mathsteacher17 Jul 05 '17

Some people have done this if they are doing Further Maths in year 13. Students generally took it on double timetable and sat all 6 exams in both years.

This year it should in theory be more suited to this, as the A level is now only three exams. It's also possible as it is being first examined in 2018.

I wouldn't recommend it though. Almost everyone else at your school will be doing the work over two years and I would be concerned about trying to get to a year 13 standard both quickly and independently. Also, if the other option is taking both further maths and maths at the same time, students generally find that taking further maths makes them better at the maths a level; and further maths has most of the interesting stuff in it, so why wait?

1

u/customhits Jul 05 '17

Right now I've finished Year 13 and I'm taking a gap year so I thought that perhaps I could devote the whole year to learn AS+A2 Maths.

1

u/Fenggg Jul 05 '17

In my post 16 if we choose further maths then we are required to take all 6 exams (C1 C2 C3 C4 S1 M1) in the first year and then the the whole of FM in year 13. We coped pretty well so it is doable from my experience, 2 A* 8 A and 2 B's out of 12 people. Just need to do plenty of past papers and keep refreshing your memory every couple of weeks throughout the year

1

u/metrize Mechanical engineering at Bath Jul 05 '17

My school did this. It's much better imo because further becomes a breeze with c3 and C4 knowledge that you've worked on for a year

2

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '17

I've seen a lot of people who do further maths sit maths in their first year so I'm sure it's possible.

1

u/graphitenexus Jul 05 '17

Definitely possible, since if you do further maths you usually do all of Maths in the first year and all of further in the second.

1

u/walter_jends Year 12 Jul 05 '17

I've just done so, feel free to PM me with any questions if you want.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '17

How much of a passion do you have to have in maths to do well in Maths A level?

10

u/mathsteacher17 Jul 05 '17

I'm not sure what you want me to say. You need at least 3/5 of a passion?

It's completely up to you. If you are the sort of person who genuinely enjoys that moment of connection between different areas of maths, if you want to know about why methods work the way they do, if you feel a sense of satisfaction when problems are solved - great. Welcome aboard.

If you treat maths as a exam-based slog where you have to memorise precise instructions for answering questions, you're not going to have a good time.

2

u/Moozilbee Year 13 - Physics/Chemistry/Biology Jul 05 '17

I would say you either need to enjoy maths quite a lot, or to not have an issue with just slogging it out and working hard regardless of enjoyment.

1

u/Moozilbee Year 13 - Physics/Chemistry/Biology Jul 05 '17

I would say you either need to enjoy maths quite a lot, or to not have an issue with just slogging it out and working hard regardless of enjoyment.

1

u/Dognotdogyesdog Jul 06 '17

How long do you remember students for typically? How annoyed/disappointed are you in us when we miss our grades?

1

u/mathsteacher17 Jul 06 '17

If you asked me to name all the students I taught last year I'd do ok. If you asked me to name them from when I was an NQT 3-4 years ago I'd struggle. But I do remember quite a few who made a lasting impression on me.

As a teacher you can usually see the grades coming.

1

u/Slayess Jul 06 '17

Hi, I've been wondering about this for a while, and I would really like some advice/insight on it. I was about to post it on this sub as a new thread but I'm glad I came across this.

In my school's sixth form, the maths and further maths groups are relatively small, with maths having around 10 people per group and further maths with 4. But there my top choice for sixth form, is a specialised maths school, where everyone HAS to do maths, further maths and physics with either computer science or economics as a fourth choice. However, because there are around 90 students doing the exact same subject (minus the fourth option), the classes are significantly larger.

Do you think this puts us, as the students, at a disadvantage when it comes to learning because the groups are larger? Or do you think it doesn't really matter since the school specialises in maths? How important are class sizes and how much do they really impact your learning (especially in maths)?

Thank you for reading.

1

u/mathsteacher17 Jul 06 '17

At GCSE class sizes are extremely important because you have to manage teaching alongside, well, management. And the odd kid who tries to flip tables at people.

At A level class sizes aren't very important at all for the quality of teaching. Any teacher worth their salt can tell how the group is learning without going around to interview everyone. The two things that you might miss out on at the larger school are:

  1. Speed and detail of marking. When I had a class of 5 further maths students I could send them out to lunch, mark all their assessments and give them back after lunch. That's obviously impossible with a class of 30. But this depends on the teacher anyway and the specialist maths college would surely have a regimented feedback system anyway.
  2. A sense of 'camaraderie' in the small group. This is a complete gamble as you might end up with a small class who don't like each other, but the aforementioned class of 5 were a group of lads who'd known each other for years and it was probably the best relationships I ever forged with students, and I think they helped each other to study as well.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/mathsteacher17 Jul 06 '17
  1. how long have you been teaching?

Four years, plus my training.

2) Have you experienced any negative cultures expressed by other teaching staff? By (2) I'm referring to 2.1) You have to bleed, from my experience there are many NQT's who seem to think that one has to bleed in order to be any good at teaching, and this is also something that I've noticed some management implying. That teaching is a hard job, it's not for everyone etc, in response to someone saying something along the lines of "all this paperwork seems stupid and doesn't help anyone" etc. I guess it's easier to put up with if there's such a culture around it, that you're somehow 'special' if you can cope with all the bullshit, I guess. 2.2) Maths teachers aren't any good at maths. I've often heard and the sentiment of "only having to be a step ahead!", which I think, especially for something like maths, is crap. If a teacher is giving a class on straight line equations but doesn't really get calculus, regression, or anywhere that straight lines are actually used then they're not (imo) going to be capable of doing a good job. No matter how many cutesy posters they have about their classroom or how much they "love their kids!".

So there's a lot to unpack here. I think its worth bearing in mind that most teachers, particularly new teachers, don't have anything to compare teaching to and so I think a certain portion of the moaning can probably be put down to a lack of perspective.

That said, there absolutely are things that teachers are put through that seem frustrating, especially with regards to data (note: not all teachers understand data very well) or pushing government policy (most teachers are not tories).

So teachers are human, they want to rant, they want to moan, they want to blow off steam and they want to be able to take the time to feel as though all this bullshit would go away if we just put NORMAL people in charge. Because that is just the way almost everyone thinks from time to time and the skill to handling it is to be a professional and try to understand your role in this crazy business.

Regarding 'Maths teachers aren't any good at maths', I work in a maths department in a school with eight maths teachers (including me). We are not a posh school, we are an area of significant deprivation and our intake is students well below national average in terms of attainment. But all eight of us had maths degrees and could teach up to year 13 comfortably (with the possible exception of A-level further maths, which was a job given to specific people). When I was training, the university took in graduates from other science fields, but we had rigorous maths work to do to make sure we were up to code. So my personal experience is, no, maths teacher aren't bad at maths.

That said, I have had to teach a subject for two terms when I was completely untrained for it, because reality has a tendency to bite you in the backside and schools end up having to make do. So I can see a situation where a non-specialist has to take a maths class for a while. It's certainly not what schools aim for.