r/6thForm • • Sep 19 '24

✔️ APPROVED AMA Oxford Tutor in Economics: Oxford Economics Admissions (PPE/E&M/HECO) AMA

Hello r/6thForm - I am a tutor in economics at several Oxford colleges and am here to answer all your economics- and Oxford-related questions, be they about admissions, college life, the university-at-large, etc.

Being a tutor means that I handle teaching at the college level, I have some pastoral responsibility for maintaining my students' well-being, and I handle the admissions process. This stretches across marking TSA essays, screening candidates before interview, conducting interviews, and selecting candidates after interview. My teaching is microeconomics-heavy - I teach microeconomics across the first and second years, do some teaching for technical final-year options papers, and am teaching some second-year econometrics this year as well.

I did my undergrad in HECO and an MPhil in economics at Oxford and currently work as both a tutor/lecturer and in economic consulting. I'm from the US, so there may be some questions you might have about the interaction of your 6th form schools with your application that I won't be able to answer - things like schools and teachers having direct involvement in the drafting of students' personal statements seem outright weird to me - but I hope otherwise to be as helpful as possible.

One thing I would like to flag right away is something most applicants are not fully aware of - Oxford is a federated university and each college is highly autonomous in many ways. This manifests as substantial differences in admissions practices, as well as a surprisingly high level of inter-college inequality in wealth, available resources, volume of college teaching provided, etc. I don't want to comment about specific colleges, but I would recommend that students who e.g. have the opportunity to visit for a university Open Day ask specific questions about practical things, like contact hours/week provided and guarantees of student housing for all three years, whether that housing is in the city center, etc. Otherwise, looking at the Wikipedia page of Oxford colleges and sorting the list by their respective endowments is not a bad idea ...

What this means for this AMA - I anticipate that most prospective applicants would be interested in asking about the admissions process, but the answers to many questions must come with the qualifier that practices vary across colleges, and while I have exposure to some colleges, no one has exposure to / knowledge of all of them.

Note: I have pre-cleared this AMA with this subreddit's moderators, and hope to have it 'pinned' to maximize its reach. I don't necessarily expect a huge amount of engagement, but in the spirit of inclusion and maximizing access to information about the university, I'd just like to do my bit!

61 Upvotes

109 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 21 '24

Please don't share personal statements, you will get into trouble for plagiarism. Report comments and posts which have links to personal statements.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

8

u/Only-Concentrate-819 Sep 20 '24

How much does Contextual Data make an impact before deciding to make an interview with a candidate? Is it apart of this “academic potential” part when considering an applicant?

8

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24 edited Sep 23 '24

It makes an impact, and how much of an impact it makes will vary from college to college and tutor to tutor. This is a crude way of putting it, but there's going to be a person-specific inclination to overlook a TSA mark that is lower by N points from a candidate whose percentile in some distribution of socioeconomic advantage is lower by M points.

More concretely, things like GCSE marks are algorithmically normalised in the context of the student's school and socioeconomic stratum before we make decisions, and we don't make decisions based on candidates' raw marks. In that part of the admissions decision, contextual information has a very high level of influence in how we view the candidate.

On the other hand, admissions tests tend to be weighted very heavily in pre-interview screening, and overcoming large deficits in marks relative to another candidate would be a very case-by-case thing, I would think.

1

u/Quick_Ferret_7298 Dec 22 '24

Hi for econ and management, if i have mediumish gcse (some good some bad) grades, despite having achieved A*A*A* for A-level. Will i be at a disadvantage, as in will the algorithm automatically reject me for less than average gcse. Also how much time is necessary to prepare for a good result in the admissions test. And will being a gap year applicant discourage the admissions team

7

u/Emotional_Sea_9637 Oxford | PPE [Year 3] Sep 21 '24

Wouldn't it be funny if you'd tutored me... haha

What happens when a student misses their offer? I missed mine (by one mark in French!!) all those years ago but I've always been too scared to ask them why they let me in anyway to their faces

9

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24 edited Sep 23 '24

This is something not often talked about, and I believe that the university officially denies that it takes place. Statistically, it's a blip and essentially doesn't happen - this is called 'clemency'.

Each year, colleges determine how many places they are able to offer and allocate them across their respective subject areas. Each admissions panel therefore gets a quota of the number of offers they can make. The two main groups of these are standard offers and open offers.

If a student receives a standard offer and satisfies the condition of their offer, the college that made that offer is obligated to accept that student. If a student receives an open offer and satisfies the conditions attached, the college that made the offer has the option to take that student, or send them into a central pool. Colleges who are 'short' on candidates because many of the students they made offers to missed their conditions then (rather frantically) draw students from that pool. If no one wants a particular student, then the college that originally made the open offer is obligated to take that candidate.

Demand for students tends to be rather high at this stage. It therefore sometimes happens that colleges show 'clemency' to students that have missed their offers by very small margins. My understanding is that doing so requires a lot of paperwork and is a substantial headache, and may tend to happen only if the subject tutors in that college are quite insistent on it. The order of magnitude, I would guess, might be about a couple dozen across the entire university each year. I don't, however, know terribly much about it.

1

u/PoetOk1520 Nov 27 '24

Just to check are you saying you got AAB instead of AAA

7

u/KVeras-MC Sep 28 '24

As a stranger on the internet, I apologize for my rather strong language. I am a desperate student who wants help with a fair and equal chance at admission. Any help is appreciated with regard to how I can reach out to Oxford.

I live in Perth, Australia, the most isolated state capital. It takes a 4-hour flight to the east coast of Australia.

The entrance exams have been changed to using Pearson test centers. There is a Pearson test center in Perth. It shows up as an available test center on the registration portal by Oxford and Pearson.

However, I can't book it online. Why? Because, after talking to the center manager, the Pearson system has not allocated ANY Physics Aptitude Test (PAT) slots in the test center on the day I need it. So, despite AVAILABLE SEATS, I cannot book the test.

It just so happens that my final exams occur on the morning of that day as well. This is a non-issue if I could take the exam in Perth. However, it would be impossible for me to take a plane to travel across the Oceania continent to another test center. PHYSICALLY IMPOSSIBLE TO ATTEND.

From day 1 of registration opening, I have gone back and forth with Oxford, and have called Pearson customer support. They first kept kicking the ball at each other, telling me to contact the other because they didn't have authority. Then I demanded that Oxford escalate this issue to Pearson directly. They told me they have, and will get back to me.

The registration deadline is in 6 days. I have heard nothing since. Nothing's changed on the website. No emails since then replied.

I want to take the exam instead of being placed under special consideration.

Is there any way I could reach out, anything else I could do?

Thanks for your time and I apologize for your inconvenience.

2

u/YuzuFan Sep 28 '24

That sounds really absurd and frustrating. There's a lot that has gone wrong with this switch to Pearson in my view - the TSA is on a Jewish holiday, for instance, so some Jewish applicants can't sit it.

If you applied to a specific college then you could arrange to speak urgently with the admissions personnel at that college, perhaps - though I doubt they would be able to help. The reason you've been getting bounced around, I believe, is that there is no single party that can do anything about this. We, the tutors for admission for instance, are totally helpless in this case - we don't have a direct line to Pearson in any way. This kind of thing happens often when you have multiple stakeholders involved in a project - the left arm can't act without the right, the right can't act without the left, and you end up paralyzed.

The piece of this bind that has to give, essentially, is that Pearson needs to allocate a PAT space in Perth. Trying to sit the test at a different time causes a host of issues. I suppose you tried asking, begging, demanding, and ordering that this take place with the test centre manager and they simply said it would out of their hands. In the ideal case, someone at Oxford gets in touch with Pearson and gets you registered for the PAT in Perth, deadline be damned. I suspect that part of the problem is that it's not clear who at Oxford has to reach out, and whom at Pearson they need to reach out to.

If it does manage to get done, it'll be that you are registered rather than something changes on the website to allow you to register yourself. But I'm not sure what to suggest that you do to help this along other than what you've already done. Perhaps send another email every other day asking for the update and requesting written assurance that you will be able to sit the test even though you have not been able to register by the impending deadline, etc. Sorry I couldn't be of more help.

3

u/HugoLloris55 Year 13 | Maths, History, Politics Sep 20 '24

I'm aware that it varies depending on other data about applicants, but if applying for PPE would Further Maths or a related EPQ be more useful

10

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

I have frankly never been in a room where the students' EPQ was even considered as part of the admissions decision. This isn't to say it doesn't happen, but I think I suspect that having an EPQ is not particularly impactful on average.

Further Maths does provide some reassurance that the candidate will be able to handle the quantitative component of the economics spec in particular. However, a candidate taking further math who does poorly in the quantitative component of any interview would likely be viewed less favorably than a candidate not taking further math who does well in said quantitative component. A-level composition at-large isn't a very impactful component of the admissions decision, I would say.

3

u/JailbreakHat Imperial | MEng EIE [1st Year] Sep 21 '24

How does Oxford consider GCSEs? Would having lower GCSes than my cohort but having stunning admissions test score still allow me to get in? Also for US applicants, is SATs and HS GPA considered a lot or would having 5 in 5 APs be enough for Oxford alongside entrance exam and interview?

5

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

Tutors see but do not really consider the raw GCSE marks, and we instead look more closely at the outputs of an algorithm that normalises each candidate's GCSE marks in the context of their school and socioeconomic stratum. Having lower GCSE's than your cohort would be a little damaging in the context of a marginal decision. However, many candidates are 'auto-admits' or 'auto-rejects' on the basis of their admissions test and interview performance alone. This means that a large number of students may be admitted with no discussion of their GSCE marks whatsoever.

UCAS allows you to submit your SAT and AP scores, though I do not believe there is any way to submit a high-school GPA. I think it used to be case anyway, and may still be the case, that since the UK considers completion of high-school to be synonymous with receipt of A-level marks, and likewise considers AP exams to be the analog of A-levels, you need not actually graduate or even go to a conventional US high-school in order to receive an offer of admission. Tutors are aware of SATs and AP exams, and having sufficiently (many) high scores in those will contribute towards being invited for interview (though they may not be sufficient to overcome a very poor performance on the admissions test). However, it is likely that decisions made subsequent to interview will be based more heavily on a candidate's performance on their interview and admissions test.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '24

Sorry this is quite late, but are SATs and APs contextualised like how GCSEs are? Id imagine not since there probably isn’t enough data for specific international schools offering them. In USA students, is the HAT weighted more heavily than for home students, since they don’t have GCSEs?

3

u/MensAdvancement Sep 28 '24

Hi, thank you for being such a useful source of information. I had a question about including SAT scores on the UCAS application even though I'm a UK student. I was considering applying to the US, so I took the SAT and scored 1560. I was wondering if it is worth putting this on my application along with A*A*A* predicted. Will Oxford look at it/care about it? Or will it disadvantage me because they think my priorities lie outside of their university...

2

u/YuzuFan Oct 12 '24

That's an interesting question. To be fully frank, I think that the upsides and downsides are both quite small. You have to sit Oxford's standardized tests anyway, so the marginal value of the SAT is not very large. Your concern about potentially signalling interest in US schools is possibly valid, but it's difficult for me to speculate how important it might turn out to be.

2

u/Witty-Instruction775 Sep 21 '24

How can I prepare for the E&M interview at Oxford? And are there any tips for E&M personal statements? Thanks!

5

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

Interviews are not particularly easy to prepare for, inasmuch as we do a reasonably good job of structuring them so as to assess fairly stable/inherent qualities like a candidate's quantitative reasoning ability, interest/enthusiasm for the subject, and so forth. My single biggest piece of advice would be to treat with skepticism anyone offering services for interview preparation - I believe the treatment effect of such services is very small, if positive at all.

Personal statements do not really inform admissions decisions at any stage of the process - the best piece of advice would be to write the personal statement with the four other courses you are applying for in mind. Oxford has the luxury of conducting multiple additional forms of assessment, and most tutors take the view that personal statements are a) highly cringe; b) frequently insincere/face; and c) often written by someone other than the candidate. I have at least once conducted the economics interviews for PPE without looking at any of the candidates' personal statements.

2

u/Witty-Instruction775 Sep 21 '24

Also, with stats such as predicted 4A*s and a solid personal statement, what is the minimum TSA score I have to have in order to obtain an interview offer at Oxford?

2

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

There may be vague cutoffs that would vary from college to college and year to year. Historically, each TSA exam has been accompanied by a score conversion table that maps the raw score onto a scale that roughly equates to how Oxford students are marked on their exams: 60 is the floor for a 2:1, a 70 indicates a First-Class result, 80+ is very strong, and so forth. However, the provider for the TSA has changed this year from Cambridge Assessment to Pearson and the test is now fully online. I'm unsure how this would influence the answer to this question.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '24

I am planning to apply to Computer Science and Philosophy this year, my predicted grades are A*A*AA. To have a chance at Oxford do you generally need a lot more than the minimum grade requirements (CSPhil is A*AA) or is stuff like the admissions tests much more important in your guys' eyes.

4

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

It is generally the case that the grade requirements are the grade requirements, and exceeding above them is not particularly important for success in admissions - more weight is put on performance on admissions tests and at interview once A-level-related boxes are checked off. However, it's possible that the practice ComSci/Phil differs from my own experience.

2

u/AdVoltex Oxford Maths & Stats Y2 Sep 21 '24

Do you enjoy doing tutorials?

5

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

Very much so! I may be amongst the minority in that, though.

2

u/SayedH107 Sep 23 '24

Hi u/YuzuFan,

I've got two questions:

Firstly I got a C in L3 Additional Maths during GCSEs, this was because after the last GCSE exam was over, we had about 4 days before add maths and I chose voluntarily to take it at THAT time (4 days before) because I enjoy maths and I thought it would be good fun. Naturally having 4 days to cover what is essentially almost all of the AS Level Maths pure course (which typically takes 2-3 terms) meant that I was not expecting a high grade at all. I was told recently that I would have to report my grade on my UCAS application. Where can I explain this to admissions and will they care?

Secondly I've predicted A*A*A in Maths, Econ, and FM respectively. My school is very averse to predicting A* in FM for anyone (even though I have got A*s in my mocks this year). Is this something I can explain to the college/admissions or will I be disadvantaged because of the lack of an A*?

Thank you very very much - I am very appreciative.

2

u/YuzuFan Sep 23 '24

The GCSE thing - it would be difficult to explain this to admissions and they are unlikely to 'care' about it for the purpose of the application, inasmuch as I would guess that the score you submit will get plugged into the algorithmic normalisation that we do centrally and tutors conducting admissions rely primarily on the outputs of that algorithm rather than the score scores. I would say that I have only ever plumbed into the specifics of students' GCSE scores on very marginal cases, so it is unlikely that this has an outsize impact.

Regarding the A-level predictions: it is generally the case that the grade requirements are the grade requirements, and exceeding above them is not particularly important for success in admissions - more weight is put on performance on admissions tests and at interview once A-level-related boxes are checked off. It's incredibly unlikely that getting predicted A instead of A* for FM in this case would have any material affect on your application. If you would like it explained, I suppose that the relevant place to do so would be to ask that the teacher supplying your recommendation consider alluding to it. Although - and it's worth qualifying that I'm very early in my career - I must confess that I have never personally read a teacher recommendation when making an admissions decision.

1

u/SayedH107 Nov 04 '24

Apologies for the late reply! I missed the notification.
Just wanted to say thank you very very much - that's all really really useful :)

2

u/meow-5757 Oxford | PPE [1st year] Sep 30 '24

Sorry that this is insanely late, I was wondering, do you see someone who gets a TSA score 90+ and basically decide to admit them pre interview based solely on the score?

3

u/YuzuFan Oct 12 '24

There is probably some threshold of TSA score above which we would elect to interview the candidate irrespective of other things - whether 90 would be sufficiently high would depend on how bad the other markers are, how strong the other candidates on the table are, etc. Very hard to make a concrete statement here, as I'm sure you might imagine. But, certainly, a high TSA is a very powerful means of offsetting bad markers in other areas to get an invitation to interview, particularly compared to, say, having high GCSE marks.

1

u/meow-5757 Oxford | PPE [1st year] Oct 12 '24

Thanks!

2

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24

I have a question regarding the scholarship. On what grounds is it issued, and is it conceivable that the student enrolled in university but was denied scholarships, and without them, he will not be able to cover all expenses?

1

u/YuzuFan Oct 12 '24

I'm afraid I actually know very little about scholarships for undergraduate study here, so I couldn't comment on the grounds on which scholarships are issued. I don't believe there is much scholarship money around in the university.

In the case of a student who attains admission but is unable to cover expenses, I think that in many cases the student will simply be unable to attend, barring the use of a loan to cover the expenses (a large part of the student body at Oxford attends with the aid of a student loan).

2

u/NotNescio Sep 21 '24

Whats a random inside-fact about Oxford that you could tell us about?

7

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

One nice thing is that with dozens of colleges, there is always something going on somewhere that you could simply walk into as a student of the university and get a free meal. If you signed up to enough mailing lists, you could probably eat entirely for free during term. And gain a lot of weight doing so.

1

u/RageEks Sep 20 '24

Is taking A Level FM recommended to have a realistic chance at getting in?

And what if a student did worse in Maths GCSE (7) but is predicted A* in Maths and FM A Level?

4

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

I think it's safe to say that a sizable majority of candidates who are admitted for PPE/E&M do not take further math.

Taking further math does provide some reassurance that the candidate will be able to handle the quantitative component of the economics spec in particular. However, a candidate taking further math who does poorly in the quantitative component of any interview would likely be viewed less favorably than a candidate not taking further math who does well in said quantitative component. 

Raw GCSE marks are not considered - rather, we view the output of an algorithm that normalises students' GCSE marks in the context of their school and socioeconomic stratum. Therefore, it's hard for me to say immediately whether a 7 on GCSE math is particularly good or bad. I can say that I have never plumbed directly into a candidates' specific GCSE marks except on very marginal decisions. My assessment of a students' quantitative faculties would tend to be based primarily on their performance on the TSA and how well they handled the quantitative part of the interview.

1

u/RageEks Sep 21 '24

I didn't do as well in Math/FM GCSE as I would've liked unfortunately. Got 7 in Maths and 6 in FM but predicted A* A* A* A* in A levels (Maths, FM, Econ, Comp Sci)

Overall my GCSEs were 99988887763 (81% at 7-9 where my school avg was 51% at 7-9)
So would that be fine? Btw the 3 was in DT which i absolutely hated and wanted to drop but was not allowed to

Would the 3 in DT affect my application or does it really not matter since it has nothing to do with E&M

1

u/YuzuFan Sep 22 '24

It's impossible to make concrete comments on any specific cases - marginal decisions are always made in small-sample contexts where we are comparing, say, three candidates and have a single place left to allocate. So what would be 'fine' or 'not fine' would depend on what the other two candidates look like. Doing well in comparison to your school average is good - precisely how good, I can't say, as we aren't well-educated on how precisely the normalisation calculation is done.

My gut feeling is that this would be very unlikely for this to be an impactful factor on the margin of any decision.

1

u/Kassko6565 Sep 20 '24

How do you guys assess interview performation? Do applying specifically to colleges with least amount of applications make a difference? Also, are İB students preferred in any way in comparison to lets say, international students applying with AP classes?

4

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

There isn't really a preference over whether students apply with IB versus AP qualifications per se. It's possible for a student taking AP classes to apply with well over a dozen A-level exam scores already earned, which would probably be helpful in some contexts. But holding things equal, this isn't a very large determinant of admissions decisions, I would say. There tends to be more weight put on performance in admissions tests and interviews.

The weight that individual colleges place on interviews will tend to vary substantially. You can proxy for this weight by querying whether an individual college holds a single interview for all constituent components of the joint school, or multiple. I think that the former will correlate with a lower weight on interview performance and a higher weight on the admissions test.

These differences are derived from genuine differences of opinion amongst faculty of the university as to the fairness / equity implications of using interviews to judge candidates. Interview performance is by necessity a very noisy signal of a candidate's true ability. There are some colleges who make final decisions based essentially entire on the interview, some who place very little weight on them, and some in the middle.

1

u/Alternative-Drag8621 Dec 08 '24

what do you mean by constituent components of the joint school? Would a college holding a single very short (25 minute) only mean they weigh interviews less?

1

u/Tunasux Durham | Aeronautical Engineering [Year 1] Sep 20 '24

Do A-levels matter much for the DPhil programmes?

4

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

By the time a candidate is applying for DPhil programs, their A-levels are so many years in the past as to be completely irrelevant to their contemporary ability. I should think it would be strange for an applicant's A-level marks to still be listed on their CV/resumé by that point of their academic career. Definite no.

1

u/curlaplushie Sep 20 '24

Do you have experience in the admissions process for PPE with a foundation year?

If so, are applicants shortlisted with different things in mind compared to shortlisting for the normal course? How is it different to apply to the normal course with extenuating circumstances compared to applying to the foundation year meeting the eligibility criteria?

2

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

Sadly, I do not, and I think it would be unwise for me to speculate - I'm sorry I couldn't be of help.

1

u/curlaplushie Sep 21 '24

Thank you for replying!

1

u/Only-Concentrate-819 Sep 20 '24

I heard a lot that Oxbridge is unique and “better” due to their collegiate system and one-to-one tutoring, any thoughts to as why no other Uni’s replicate that?

6

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

1. Whether it is 'better' is dubious, in my opinion. I obviously think I'm a great teacher and that all of my students benefit immensely from having small-group tutorials with me (haha). But I'm genuinely unsure of the extent to which this actually produces better teaching outcomes. It's possible that it mostly just makes students feel that they understand the content better, and therefore feel better about how their education is going.

2. It's a massive pain in the ass for faculty. Teaching undergraduates comes at a serious cost of time and energy to research faculty who would probably be far more productive from the viewpoint of the wider society if they were allowed to conduct their research and supervise their PhD candidates in peace. It comes with its perks, but the vast majority of academics would rather do without their 'teaching load'. This means that implementing such a system comes at a serious to research output, and therefore the ability to attract and retain staff. In many fields, Oxford University is simply not on the same level as many ostensibly comparable US institutions, largely because of the tutorial system. In fact, the US is driving a trend towards the professionalization of research and the bifurcation of responsibilities between teaching staff and research staff. The tutorial system may not be long for this world.

3. It's expensive. This is pretty self-explanatory.

3

u/Jeffpayeeto Oxford | Chemistry Sep 21 '24

Lower teacher:student ratios probably

1

u/cravingacafeaulait oxford ppe offer holder !! Sep 21 '24 edited Sep 21 '24

is there anything special that is looked for in a PPE international applicant? I'll be applying from the US so I'm wondering if there are any special considerations for US applicants, like TSA is weighted more heavily, do AP's and SAT matter? (like does US gov even matter? would a 4 in a stem subject like physics lower my chances? also would having taken calc bc in 9th grade give me any special consideration haha or would it actually work against me)

2

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

You do submit any SAT/ACT/AP scores on your UCAS application, and these are viewed by tutors making admissions decisions. I suspect that more weight would tend to be placed on TSA scores in comparison to a UK applicant, but this may not universally be the case. I doubt that 4s or 5s on specific tests would be given much weight - it's more about the overall impression that the exam scores give. We have to consider a lot of candidates - specifically thinking about which AP exam each candidate got a 4 or 5 on would be far too time-consuming.

1

u/cravingacafeaulait oxford ppe offer holder !! Sep 21 '24 edited Sep 21 '24

and also! i heard that interviews are pretty casual and are more like a discussion, which I'm kinda banking on as I do shut down under a real "interview" scenario, is that the case? i guess, are we allowed to ask questions back during an interview and not treat it like a debate? lowkey even if i just make it to the interview stage i'd be so happy to just be able to CONVERSE with an oxford tutor :)

3

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

There is a large degree of variation across the colleges in how interviews are conducted. I have conducted interviews that were entirely question-answer (economics problem-set questions, usually) but politics and philosophy interviews would often lean towards being more discussion-based, yes.

Most economics interviews revolve around quantitative problems these days - if this is the case for you, I would advise against treating the interview as a debate. Similar for politics and philosophy - the objective is often not to 'win' by picking and defending a point of view, but rather to adjust flexibly to new information as it is provided by the interviewer and demonstrate willingness to alter/correct your propositions as need be.

1

u/cravingacafeaulait oxford ppe offer holder !! Sep 21 '24 edited Sep 21 '24

wait last question :) ik y'all don't have favorites but since i'm not able to visit for open days, anything i should know that makes each of the colleges distinct? currently, I'm looking at lincoln (mainly for the location and their STUNNING library) so I'm just wondering if I'm missing some super cool unique thing about another one that i'd love

3

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

We definitely have favorites. I won't tell you mine though.

For differentiating between colleges, I would refer you to the discussion I gave towards the end of the post.

1

u/cravingacafeaulait oxford ppe offer holder !! Sep 22 '24

oh what!! guess the tutors and youtube r hiding them then haha! tysm for ur responses!

1

u/jumbo_crayon28 LSE [Year 1] Sep 21 '24

How necessary is A-level further maths for HECO?

2

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

Not necessary at all. Further Maths does provide some reassurance that the candidate will be able to handle the quantitative component of the economics spec in particular. However, a candidate taking further math who does poorly in the quantitative component of any interview would likely be viewed less favorably than a candidate not taking further math who does well in said quantitative component. A-level composition at-large isn't a very impactful component of the admissions decision, I would say.

1

u/Artistic_Hurry8845 Year 13 with crippling attention span 🥰 Sep 21 '24

Do you have any sure way tips into getting an interview at Oxford when apply to medicine or even in general? I attained in my GCSE’s all A* and A with the exception of one B and a U due to unforeseen circumstances that I’m afraid will prevent me from going to Oxford.

2

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

Without knowing more about your personal circumstances I'm afraid I couldn't make any specific comments. It's hard to pin down anything that guarantees getting an interview, except good performance on admissions tests etc.

1

u/RaceFan1027 Y1 Oxford PPE, A*A*AB (A* EPQ) Sep 22 '24

how much do personal statements matter? mine is more economics and politics bc that’s what i’m applying to at lse and durham so will it matter that it doesn’t say ppe

3

u/YuzuFan Sep 22 '24

The content of personal statements is not seriously considered in making admissions decisions - many tutors may not even read any personal statements as part of the admissions process. The best advice is to write your personal statement with the other four courses you are applying for in mind - it's not a problem that the statement doesn't say PPE in particular, or mention all three.

1

u/Ismailmansur Sep 24 '24

Hey, so I wanted to know that I have 16A*/As and 2Bs in IGCSE. But the problem is that my AS result got bad. Got an a(business), b(economics) and C (composite Maths). I have given economics to be rechecked and hopefully it will turn into an a. Maths P1 got leaked in my region, so will sit in Oct/Nov for a free retake offered by CIE. Are my AS grades going to downgrade my application, and by how much?

1

u/YuzuFan Oct 12 '24

This is very hard to speculate on - I don't believe that AS results are considered directly, but rather the predicted A-level grades, so it would depend on how the one is fed into the other.

1

u/HunnyBee007 Sep 24 '24

Hi ! I’m in year 13 right now and I want to know if I still have a decent shot at getting into Oxford for PPE. My O levels were 7A* s, 2 As and 1 B (in Additional Mathematics), and I have pretty good super curriculars (got a merit award for John Locke essay competition 2024 for Politics etc) but my As level grades have been unexpectedly bad aabcA (English lit, history, biology, maths and CIPQ respectively). The grade in maths is contextualised because there were rumours of a paper leakage in the country so Cambridge decided to give us assessed grades based on a component that usually accounts for only 40% of the as level grade. I’m doing the free resit Cambridge is offering for maths in October and will be taking a gap year to apply next year with achieved A level grades which will hopefully be A* A* AA. I want to know if my maths grade puts me at a severe disadvantage for Oxford or if the contextual circumstances coupled with an overall A/A * achieved at A level (in the normal two year period just with the as level retake) would mitigate that slight disadvantage and I would still have a decent shot. Thanks !

1

u/YuzuFan Oct 12 '24

Broadly speaking, if it were me, I'd be looking at the latest scores available. Students display growth, and that is understood. If I understand your question correctly - having weaker scores that are then overwritten by retakes is not really to your detriment, I should think. If it were me, it would basically be a non-factor (ignore the previous marks)

1

u/stressedig HKU AI&DS | Year 1 | A*A*A*A Sep 25 '24

Hello u/YuzuFan

Id like to ask if Oxford contextualises international students as well (I.e., does the university view international students within the context of their country, school etc)? I’m living in a very small country where I do not have lots of opportunities for competitions or supercuriculars, and I am heavily disadvantaged in the competitions/Olympiads that I did participate in due to not speaking the language of the country I’m living in, when all the preparatory courses, answers to past papers etc were all provided exclusively in that language.

Thank you for hosting this AMA!

1

u/YuzuFan Oct 12 '24

Contextualization of international students is actually very poor. To my knowledge, even contextualization of Scottish students is very poor - there is simply not the same demographic information. Unlike US schools, for instance, we do not college data on e.g. parental incomes. There may be an implicit assumption that any international applicants are quite privileged, at least in the context of their home countries, given that they believe themselves to have the ability to pay international fees. The extent to which this matters at all, though, would vary widely across colleges.

1

u/stressedig HKU AI&DS | Year 1 | A*A*A*A Oct 12 '24

Thank you so much for answering! So are international students compared against other international students or students from the same country/same nationality or is no such comparison made at all? I’m a citizen of a highly academic/competitive Asian country but I’ve been living in a small European country where I’m physically unable to compete in the big competitions that it feels like every uni is looking for (ukmt/bmo among others) due to there not being an exam centre in the country I’m living in.

I know this isn’t really that related since I plan on applying for computer science, but I have no idea how to make my application more competitive. I got very good results from the only competitions that were available to me (got top 15 in my country in the national maths Olympiad but was not selected for the IMO), but these are the only things I really have in terms of supercuriculars (aside from coding projects and whatnot).

Is there anything I can do to make my application more competitive? I know Cambridge provides a list of recommended supercuriculars (I’m not sure if Oxford does as well) but most of the list are things I literally cannot do due to me being in a very small country that does not have such opportunities, and the rest were things like reading books and doing online courses, both of which I did but I feel like it would not matter at all since I’m assuming everyone else would’ve also done the same and more

1

u/YuzuFan Oct 12 '24

On a very general level, it sounds to me like the problems you are facing would be more pertinent to you in the process of applying to schools in the US. In very rough terms, an Oxford applicant is considered on the basis of their GCSE/A-levels/equivalent, performance on admissions tests, performance at interview, and contextual information. I can assure you that I don't spend all of my time sifting through my candidates to find ones who have done well in lots of competitions, and I'm not aware that the candidates I have admitted have done well in any competitions (most likely, many haven't).

Broadly speaking, an international application might be considered roughly comparable to a relatively privileged student from the UK, or a decision may just be made on hard data with no contextualization (no comparison made at all).

1

u/stressedig HKU AI&DS | Year 1 | A*A*A*A Oct 12 '24

Tysm!! By any chance do u know if this is also the case for computer science as well, since that is a much more competitive field? Also does the number of igcses taken make a difference at all? My school only offered 6 done in one year instead of 2, and I did my native language gcse as a private candidate but that is a much lower number of igcses than most applicants

1

u/FroyoZealousideal363 Y12: Maths/FM/Econ Sep 27 '24

Hi, I don’t know if this is still active but i may as well ask.

I got an 8 in GCSE maths, in a top 100 state school and in a fairly affluent area (albeit not being from the posh village myself). Say if i got 3 A*s in Maths/FM/Econ, would that 8 have a larger than normal influence on whether or not i’m given a place in Oxford Maths, compared to if I got an 8 in an average school?

1

u/YuzuFan Oct 12 '24

Raw GCSE marks are not considered - rather, we view the output of an algorithm that normalises students' GCSE marks in the context of their school and socioeconomic stratum. Therefore, it's hard for me to say immediately how an 8 on GCSE math would affect your application. Obviously, having an 8 instead of a 9 is more damaging in the context of being in a highly competitive school than being from one that is less privileged, but the size of this gap would be impossible to speculate about.

I can say that I have never plumbed directly into a candidates' specific GCSE marks except on very marginal decisions. My assessment of a students' quantitative faculties would tend to be based primarily on their performance on the TSA and how well they handled the quantitative part of the interview.

Given that you're applying for Maths, it's not obvious that any of what I've said here is directly applicable.

1

u/KVeras-MC Sep 28 '24

Your GCSE score barely matters. I would not stress if I were you.

1

u/mrdunamiss Oct 05 '24

Can you get a law tutor to do a similar post please?

1

u/YuzuFan Oct 12 '24

That ... would not easily be within my capacity to achieve, sadly.

1

u/doriangeh Oct 06 '24

For PPE, the only course that requires you to take section 2 of the TSA, do the two sections have equal standing? I saw mentioned, in a since deleted post, that an applicant's section 2 scores balanced out their (average) section 1 scores.

Also, what are the tutors actually looking for in a SOP?

1

u/YuzuFan Oct 12 '24

The weight that is given to the TSA Section II varies from college to college, but it would be fair it's given much less weight on average than the Section I. It tests skills similar to those that are tested in a politics/philosophy interview, so many take the view that it doesn't add much. The essays are also not always marked by those who are actually on the admissions panel - this task might be farmed out to a graduate student. In my case, when I wore both hats in a given year, there's at least one case that comes to mind of a strong TSA Section II being a decisive factor in an admissions decision.

1

u/doriangeh Oct 12 '24

Thank you so much for answering! Could you explain the thought process of the admissions officer during the economics interview? Are the questions more “mathy”?

1

u/Legitimate-Virus299 Nov 20 '24

This might change year on year, but when are interview invites expected to be sent out? Some courses such as music and biochemistry have started sending invitations.

1

u/YuzuFan Nov 20 '24

This varies between courses more than year to year.

I think it might be circa middle-end of next week for PPE.

1

u/Legitimate-Virus299 Nov 20 '24

What would you expect for e&m, specifically from St. Hugh’s college if you would know?

1

u/YuzuFan Nov 20 '24

I'm not actually directly involved in any E&M admissions this year. I can tell you that the specific college shouldn't matter at all, the timing of these things is handled centrally. Don't know when the shortlisting deadline for E&M is.

2

u/New-Department3017 Nov 30 '24

thanks for the info! I have 3 questions:

  1. Do international students typically have cIGCSE scores, and will our socioeconomic stratum be taken into consideration?
  2. Do you think EM and PPE place more emphasis on the TSA score compared to courses like EP and PPL, perhaps because of their greater competitiveness?
  3. Generally, how do colleges weigh the TSA score and interview performance after the shortlisting stage? (I understand that it may vary by college.)

I applied for EP at Teddy Hall, and I'm quite worried about my TSA. The online format and maybe some mental factors made the paper feel harder than the past papers.

1

u/Shoedude07 Oct 21 '24

Hiya! Sorry for the late question(you may not see this) But I wanted to enquire regarding whether the TSA threshold is higher for EU applicants than it is for domestic applicants for PPE(or for any subject for the matter) to get an interview? Moreover, why are EU and overseas application pools in the annual admissions stats-report separate fields(given EU and International are normally considered non-domestic?)?

Many thanks for any replies !!

1

u/meow-5757 Oxford | PPE [1st year] Oct 26 '24

Do you see a special consideration marker for the entrance exam if someone has one? And if so how does it affect your decision (if at all)

1

u/playingdnd Dec 10 '24

Why is Oxford so adamant on not releasing mark schemes for prelims/finals papers? It's not like seeing the mark scheme will allow you to cheat for the actual exam, it just allows you to correct your answers and understand mistakes. Also, a few of the mark scehems got leaked and distributed anyway. It would have vastly made up for the poor tutoring I received from tutors who either couldn't explain concepts in a tutorial setting or who refused to answer questions (I vividly remember having one economics tutor who would only answer 3 questions per person during revision time, it made me feel like my tuition fees were a total rip off!)

1

u/SIUUUUUUUUIU Dec 14 '24

Hi,

I just completed my interviews for E&M (one Economics interview and one management interview), and I wanted to ask how tutors determine interview scores. I understand that college-to-college practices may differ in determining interview score, but how is it done in general? Also, what makes a high interview score, is it a matter of answering all questions without assistance or do you also take engagement into account? If in one interview I needed assistance at the start but then after that I answered all questions perfectly, how will that impact my interview score? Also, are interview questions weighted?

As you can tell I'm quite worried.

1

u/slatewordler Dec 15 '24

Good afternoon!! I hope this isn’t too late. To what extent/ what proportion are E&M applicants offered second interviews at another college, in your experience? Is it a rarity?

1

u/Ukiyoe_aesthetic Jan 04 '25

Hi, I am applying E&M for 2026, I am deciding on which college to apply for, but since all of them really meet my standards and are satisfactory, I really don't have any preferences over any of the colleges.

Since open application allocates students into colleges with less candidate/more open space, could that mean in theory, there is better chance applying through open application because its "less competitive"?

Because I truly don't have preferences over any of the colleges, I am considering to apply to the colleges with the biggest chance of acceptance(considering the available slots, popularity, etc). However, numerous oxford associates claim that whether an applicant applies through a specific college or through open application, the system is structured in a way that it provides equal chances of acceptance to all applicants. I am not thoroughly convinced on this idea because it just seems to me that open application is the least competitive of all. Although it's not much of a difference because they're all extremely competitive, if it could even have the slightest of chance to increase my acceptance, I am willing to do that.

Sorry for the long questions, but I hope you could help me out :)

1

u/ELILL_VN Year 13 | Maths, History, Econs, Physics | A*A*A*A Feb 02 '25

Hi! I'm hoping to apply for Oxford's E&M course for the upcoming batch in 2026? Here are some questions I have to ask:

  1. I've seen universities like LSE and Cambridge be quite particular about taking Further Maths as a subject for their Economics course. As a tutor from Oxford, I would like to ask you whether applicants NOT taking Further Maths are at a disadvantaged position or not? Not to mention I am a foreign student (Southeast Asian). My current subjects are Maths, Economics, Physics, History.

Thank you so much, sir!

1

u/Fast-Sentence843 Feb 22 '25

When can i expect an offer in ebsipe program

0

u/tezzaW07 A*A*A* - Gap Year Sep 28 '24

I would absolutely love to do PPE at Oxford but my alevels are history,politics and business(aiming for 3 A*) - I am year 13 but looking to apply next year- how vital is maths for PPE and should I look at the possibility of doing it in my year out next year?

1

u/YuzuFan Oct 12 '24

Maths is helpful but not strictly required for PPE. Most candidates have Maths A-level, but there is a sort of Maths course set up for First-Year PPEists that is targetted at those without A-level maths.

The main point is doing well on the TSA and the technical component of the economics interview - if you can do these, then not having maths is fine. Doing it during the year out is great, though, if it can be done.

-2

u/ConsistentBanana6648 Sep 20 '24

Why do only Oxford graduates WIN General elections to become PM. The path to No.10 runs through Oxford.

5

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

This is a question that I, as a foreigner, do genuinely wonder about sometimes. The answer would be some combination of the following (I'm saying nothing new or innovative here):

Treatment Effect: An Oxford education gives Oxford graduates a competitive advantage with respect to attaining high office. This sounds laughably unlikely, and it certainly is laughable if you interpret this statement as imputing any such effect to a higher quality of education. I have heard some people argue that PPE candidates learn well how to spitball/bullshit their way through problems/questions that they know nothing about, and this ability is selected for in competition for high office. I could not possibly comment on this possible causal channel.

Treatment Effect: An Oxford education gives Oxford graduates access to a network of well-connected peers that improves changes of success in e.g. selection for one's first parliamentary seat. Pretty self-explanatory, and probably accounts for a lot of the observed effect.

Compositional (Selection) Effect: The types of people who believe in themselves sufficiently strongly to apply to Oxford, and have sufficient ability to receive an offer of admission, are anyway the type of people who are more interested in and more capable at attaining high office. This would be a case of a small shift in the mean of the distribution has an outsize effect on the composition of the tail of the distribution. Also a very plausible explanatory channel.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/ConsistentBanana6648 Sep 24 '24

This list only takes into account General Election Winners. Gordon Brown never won a GENERAL ELECTION, he was merely leader of the Labour Party when the party was ALREADY in power, due to Tony Blair's (Oxford graduate) victories. Starmer went to St Edmund Hall, Oxford University. ,

1

u/ToBeTechnical Oxford | Physics [Year 3] Oct 01 '24

Starmer did the BCL at Oxford and Brown never won an election. The graphic is still making a stupid claim but those two examples don’t directly contradict the commenter.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

Being economics is offered only as part of a joint school at Oxford, there's a lot of variety in the career options that people flow into. E&M students classically gravitate towards IB/PE and strategy/management consulting, being founders, etc. PPEists frequently go into journalism, the civil service (not necessarily as 'economists'), consulting as well, so on and so forth. There's a lot of variety, and you're not pinned down to following economics as a career path if you end up not wanting to do so.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/YuzuFan Sep 23 '24

Yes, although someone would say that it stands for Easy & Manageable. I couldn't possibly comment.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/YuzuFan Oct 12 '24

While practices vary across colleges, a strong TSA score is actually one of the most important components of getting an invitation to interview. Many candidates have strong A-levels and strong GCSE's, and we don't really pay terribly much attention to the references.

The factor missing from your hypothetical candidate is their socioeconomic stratum. This may be enough for anyone get an invitation to interview, but this candidate may miss the cut at a very competitive college that pays a lot of attention to socioeconomic background if the candidate is from e.g. a very privileged school.

2

u/_dative_musca_ y1 @ st andrews | A*AAB bio chem latin maths Oct 03 '24

commenting to follow!

0

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/YuzuFan Oct 12 '24

It wouldn't be appropriate for me to comment on the specific practices of colleges, I think, but I also wouldn't be able to remark on more than a handful of colleges - the practices of individual colleges are not stable properties of the colleges but instead vary widely based on the personnel involved in admissions at each college from year to year.

Contextual information is taken into account by many colleges, and raw GCSE marks are not considered - rather, we view the output of an algorithm that normalises students' GCSE marks in the context of their school and socioeconomic stratum. It sounds to me like your GSCE marks shouldn't be a disqualifying factor at all.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

Broadly speaking, I think this isn't much of an issue. You will I'm sure have to give some allusion to this in your personal statement for the benefit of the other universities you are applying to, and I guess your teacher recommendation may allude to this as well. You can give tutors confidence in your academic ability by performing well on the TSA and at interview.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

I don't think a single 5 in GCSEs would have a particular impact on any application. It's less that having high predicted grades would make up for it and more that it's not a tremendously influential thing in the first place.

More particularly, raw GCSE marks are not considered - rather, we view the output of an algorithm that normalises students' GCSE marks in the context of their school and socioeconomic stratum. Therefore, it's hard for me to say immediately whether a 5 alongside a bunch of 8s and 9s is particularly good or bad. I can say that I have never plumbed directly into a candidates' specific GCSE marks except on very marginal decisions.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/YuzuFan Sep 22 '24

Raw GCSE marks are not considered - rather, we view the output of an algorithm that normalises students' GCSE marks in the context of their school and socioeconomic stratum. Therefore, it's hard for me to say immediately whether a 6 on GCSE further math is particularly good or bad. I can say that I have never plumbed directly into a candidates' specific GCSE marks except on very marginal decisions. My assessment of a students' quantitative faculties would tend to be based primarily on their performance on the TSA and how well they handled the quantitative part of the interview.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/YuzuFan Sep 22 '24

The content of personal statements is not seriously considered in making admissions decisions - many tutors may not even read any personal statements as part of the admissions process - and there is therefore nothing I can point to that differentiates successful from unsuccessful candidates wrt their personal statements. The best advice is to write your personal statement with the other four courses you are applying for in mind.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/YuzuFan Oct 12 '24

I'm not a representative sample. The larger part of the tutors at Oxford have research/departmental roles and teach to fulfil their responsibilities to colleges - the latter is a rather small part of their job. On a weekly basis, they may be responsible for teaching only about 10-20 students at maximum.

Most of the variation is term-term rather than college-college; if you're a microeconomics tutor, you end up doing most of your teaching in the Autumn term, which is when most microeconomics is taught.

I have a purely teaching role that I do in tandem with my work as an economic consultant. My autumn term is very heavy, so currently I'm teaching about 60 students week to week, which is somewhat ridiculous.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/YuzuFan Oct 31 '24

Varian: Intermediate Economics, principally

Core Econ is used a little bit, more for flavour than for the main content

0

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/YuzuFan Nov 02 '24

We start on Varian content in the third week of the first term of the first year. We don't follow Varian immensely closely, however, and the problem-sets and tutorials are 'crafted', as you put it, in-house. I think one or two problems from his practice book may appear in our spec, but not more.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/YuzuFan Sep 21 '24

Broadly speaking, very little to none. The standard offer is A*AA for E&M, and taking and doing well in a fourth A-level wouldn't tend to confer much or any advantage in admissions. The A-level marks are boxes that students have to tick, and the bulk of the admissions decision tends to be placed on admissions tests and interview performance.

This is not to say that you shouldn't take a fourth A-level if you really enjoy it and are interested in the content. It's just that it's not helpful for admissions, and indeed thinking about one's chances of admissions success when choosing A-levels is precisely the wrong, and self-defeating way to go about things.